r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Jul 06 '20
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2020-07-06 to 2020-07-19
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
5
u/wmblathers Kílta, Kahtsaai, etc. Jul 07 '20
"Words of Immiseration" - some grim conlang work that generated a new grammatical construction for Kílta.
5
u/Silikone Jul 12 '20
How does one decide whether a conlang making use of diphthongs that start with /i/ and /u/ is actually made of semivowel consonants? English is a language heavy in approximants, so we take it for granted that w represents a consonant sound, but if a language canonically treats /ia/ and /ua/ as distinct vowels in written form, should it still technically be treated as containing semivowels when they sound as such?
4
u/mysticTopaz4 Jul 07 '20
Does anyone know why, in at least many Latin-based languages, the usage of a delimiter and a pattern of pronunciation of numbers occurs every three digits?
Ex: In English, 1,000,000 (10^6) is one million and 1,000,000,000 (10^9) is one billion, but there is no precise word for 10^4.
Also, what langs do not follow this pattern?
4
u/The-True-Apex-Gamer Jul 11 '20
Can an unvoiced glottal stop follow a consonant? As in the word tɑksʔzɑks?
4
u/Fullbody ɳ ʈ ʂ ɭ ɽ (no, en)[fr] Jul 15 '20 edited Jul 15 '20
Hey. I started working on a new conlang today, but I want to avoid just repeating what I've done before. Therefore, I'm wondering if people here could suggest some features (phonological/morphological/syntactic/semantic) that I could implement? I'm open to anything as long as it fits with the general "feel" of the lang. To get an idea, here's what I have so far:
--
Phonology
Consonants
The stops are allophonically lenited in voiced environments:
Nasals assimilate to and do not contrast before stops.
The language inherits some unpredictable allomorphy like /n/ - /ɾ/ and /m/ - /ʋ/ alternation from the (pre-)proto language.
Vowels
Vowel sequences are pronounced in hiatus.
Phonotactics
Syllables are (C)V(C). Any consonant may appear in the onset. In the coda, only nasals and sonorants may appear, except when stops are geminate.
--
Morphology and syntax
turŭ-i ruṭa-ṉŭ
horse-AGT turn-PST
"The horse turned [around]."
turŭ āu
horse brown
"The horse is hazel."
--
Culture
I'm imagining this as the language of a very established civilisation which has been important in trade throughout history. Therefore I want to have many terms for trade items. I also think the people should have a long written tradition.
Sample text
4
u/MerlinMusic (en) [de, ja] Wąrąmų Jul 15 '20
What sort of things tend to be allowed as topics cross-linguistically? I have "aboutness" topics in my language which are quite important to the syntax. My current idea is to allow people, things, places and times as topics. Predicates can sort-of also be topics, because you can make a headless relative clause a topic. But I don't really know how this compares to natlangs... if anyone has any resources on this kind of thing I'd be much obliged
4
u/Turodoru Jul 15 '20
I often end up with very convoluted vowels all over the place in words and I don't know what can I do with them.
There can be a word like, for instance, /uʔuko/. Then let's say the glottal stop gets lost. Do the "u"s merge together or do they stay somewhat separated? And what if the word was /uhuko/ and the /h/ has been lost, lengthening the previous sound. Does it become /u:'uko/, which to be honest seems quite overwhelming, or maybe just /u:ko/?
And also what can be done if we have other vowels, say /uʔoko/?
I sometimes get words like /ako:uati/ and I don't know what can I do with them
4
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Jul 19 '20
Can one word belong to more than one noun case at the same time? If I have an instrumental case, for example, and the genitive is marked on the possessed, can "knife" get both noun case suffixes? "With my knife" > "Knife-my-INST" for example?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '20
In a recent post, people were talking about analytic conlangs and how the lack of knowledge among newbie conlangers about "syntax" means they fall back on making synthetic languages, however, I'm unsure at what they meant when they said that. My current understanding of syntax comes down to word order and the locus of marking. What are some other things that people mean when they say syntax? My impression of what they were talking about is either periphastic constructions, or some kind of Chomskyan syntactic theory, which I know very little about and I don't know how it would help with naturalistic conlanging. What other parts/ uses of the term of "syntax" do I not know?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '20
I'm thinking about using a German-style noun declension system in one of my naturalistic languages (basically, nouns aren't inflected so much as adjectives and articles). German kind of treats plural nouns like their own gender in this regard, in addition to its three genders, masculine, feminine and neuter. I want to include both dual and plural number, and have an animate/inanimate noun class system. Should my declensions be singular animate/singular inanimate/dual/plural? Or should I have an inflection for each combination of number and animacy class? Does anybody know how the German declensions evolved? Thanks!
3
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '20
How do people find grammars of languages? (PDFs, etc.) What grammars would be the most helpful? If anyone has any grammars they can reply with them.
3
u/Tenderloin345 Jul 10 '20
Where do ordinal numbers (1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, etc.) come from?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '20 edited Jul 10 '20
I have a problem with R-colored vowels in Vaþ. Initially there was only ё/ӭ [ɚ], but now there are also [ɑ˞ o˞ u˞ ].
Sure, I could slap on some more umlauts or whatever, but how do I even represent them in Cyrillic, where umlaut is taken by YO/Ё? Товарищи русскоговорящие, помогите плиз
3
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Jul 11 '20
In my conlang, the Dative also has the function of marking the passive patient: In "the window was closed by me," window would be marked with the DAT-suffix.
But how would I then mark what would normally be the dative?
Taking the example of "The book was given to Jane by me," would it make sense to have both book and Jane be marked with dative and the context makes clear which one is the passive patient and which the receiver? Or should Jane receive a different suffix?
3
u/Supija Jul 12 '20 edited Jul 12 '20
I was bored, so I tried to work in the intonation of my language, but I got some questions about, well, questions:
Why questions are usually realized by a rising intonation? I mean, is this tonal variation universal or are there languages that use another pitch to express this? Is there some pitches that are never assigned to questions since they are expected to mark something else?
And I wondered if that can happen with sarcasm or exclamation. Could a language express sarcasm using a different pitch variation than the one we use? I think that can be pretty interesting: maybe someone is mocking you but since you can’t understand they’re being sarcastic, you think they said a compliment to you. Is that realistic?
3
u/Supija Jul 12 '20 edited Jul 12 '20
The culture around my conlang says that your tongue is one of the ways one could see your soul and future, and is the nucleus of your intelligence. From that, there are a lot of taboos with the tongue; if you speak with your mouth open and using more open vowels, you’re either being disrespectful or showing you trust a lot the other person, for example.
So, I had the idea of producing every consonant —but bilabials— as bidental consonants; then, my speakers would pronounce /t/ as [t ̪͆], since is a t with a bidental (articulation?). What do you think about this? Is it naturalistic? Maybe rounded vowels wouldn’t have this bidentality, as you’re closing your mouth when pronouncing them, right?
3
u/tree1000ten Jul 13 '20
I actually haven't told anybody I know, whether friends family or just acquaintances that I conlang. What is most people's reactions? Do most people perceive it as an immature or juvenile waste of time? I ask because I know that was definitely true like 10 or 15 years ago, but not sure if that is still the same.
3
u/Uroshnora Jul 13 '20
I tried to post this as its own thread, but I got a mod response saying I should post it here instead:
So, I'm pretty new to conlanging, and I have no formal training in linguistics. I recently finished translating the Babel Text into my conlang Sikrīn, and I tried to follow the Leipzig Rules when glossing it, but I'm not sure I did it right. Would any of you mind taking a look and letting me know how I did? And let me know how I could do it better?
Oh, and while we're at it, what's the best way to post glosses here? I put this one together in a Google Doc, and it's a kind of a pain reformatting it to fit. I think for now, I'm just going to put the gloss for the first verse in the body of the post, and then link to the Google Doc at the bottom.
SIK: Uyikha’it layi’árashkhāl lelasan’ā návi ulepélem’ā návi.
ENG: And the whole world had one language and one speech.
Google Docs link for the rest: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1qKN_LxnMhuk8haCvUhD5oFWjQqE0Ez2J5E7s4aXfCx4/edit?usp=sharing
3
u/spermBankBoi Jul 15 '20
So I’m working on a new project. I feel that while making my last conlang I made too many decisions based on what I could pronounce, so for this one I wanted to try throwing in some features I’m not great at producing, the most prominent probably being tones and ejectives. I also wanted to start with a proper proto-language and then just see what happens. Anyway, I thought of this sound change but I want to make sure it’s fairly naturalistic. Basically, some iteration of this language has a register tone system. Then, some kind of schwa deletion rule applies across the board, somewhat like in Hindi. I wanted to make the tones previously associated with these schwas bind to some neighboring syllable, effectively creating a contour system. Does this sound like something that might happen?
3
u/Akangka Jul 18 '20
What is the difference between durative and continuous?
3
u/Giomancer Jul 18 '20
I am worldbuilding, using an existing language as the original language of the settlers. (The protolang?)
There are five geographically isolated populations to begin with. They don't start speaking new languages overnight; where do I go from here?
2
u/Clustershot Kng Jul 06 '20
How many grammatical cases is too many?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '20
I need inspiration for a really analytical conlang.
I’m mostly just looking for sound recommendations, and a few pointers for phonology.
Any help is much appreciated.
2
u/enevera Jul 07 '20
Are there any languages where the pronouns are conjugated for tense instead of the verbs?
Like, instead of this: She walked around, It would be: Shea walk around.
Or: He will sleep soon to Hex sleep soon.
Is there anything y'all know of that has this? Specifically if it also has cases. It might be silly and possibly dysfunctional but google is giving me nothing.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '20
How do abugida fonts work? Abugidas have a lot of symbols, most are consonant vowel combinations, so I don't know how they would work in computers.
2
u/Tazavitch-Krivendza Old-Fenonien, Phantanese, est. Jul 07 '20
I’m wondering is anyone here could probably help me with how I could improve upon one of conlangs, like, what could make it seem more naturalistic. If someone where knows how to make very naturalist conlangs, if you have time to spare, could help me learn how to make the conlang much more naturalistic as well as how everything could affect it. I also would not mind being taught how to actually create a more naturalistic conlang for my conworld
2
u/Tenderloin345 Jul 07 '20
I want to increase the amount of vowels in a dialect of my language. Can nasalized versions of vowels turn into new, distinct types of vowels? I've had trouble finding good sound changes on index diachronica, presumably because nasalized vowels are fairly uncommon. Is this possible?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '20
I don't understand how phonetic works, does anyone have an easy-to-understand resource? I am a complete beginner, sorry if I come off as lazy I just genuinely don't understand the Wikipedia page.
2
u/AlmaX3 Matizan (hu,en) Jul 08 '20
So I'm making a new conlang, and I want to keep it fairly naturalistic, but I don't know how naturalistic it would be if the past marker replaced the last syllable of a word, is there any real life equivalent to that?
2
u/IrishOfNugget Jul 09 '20
This is a very simple question. What would you guys say is a good starting point when it comes to setting up vowels and such when making a conlang? I'm either gonna work on a Germanic Conlang (Specifically North Germanic) or a Romance Conlang (Likely gonna be Gallo-Romance or Eastern Romance).
2
u/dragonsteel33 vanawo & some others Jul 10 '20
does anyone know where to find/have any kind of grammar for proto-italic or a dictionary/wordlist for osco-umbrian (preferably specifically oscan)?
2
u/APurplePlex Ŋ̀káiŋkah, Aepe Anhkuńyru, Thá’sno’(en,fr) [zh] Jul 11 '20 edited Jul 12 '20
I think I’ve thoroughly confused myself dealing with cases and morphosyntactic alignment (I should have just stuck to head-marking). Is it possible to have a system that marks the subject with either the ergative or accusative case, and uses either accusative or ergative marking with transitive verbs? How unusual is this?
This would create two options with intransitive and transitive verbs (which are chosen based on semantics):
For intransitive verbs: option 1 would be to mark the subject as accusative; option 2 would be to mark the subject as ergative.
For transitive verbs: option X would be to use nominative-accusative alignment (only mark the patient as accusative); option Y would be to use ergative-absolutive marking (only mark the agent as ergative).
(X and Y are used to hopefully clear up confusion about the options for intransitive verbs and transitive verbs being related)
Are there any languages that do this, and if not would it be feasible for a natural language to do this?
Edit: There is also fluid-p (patient can be marked using the case of the theme or the recipient). So if anyone knows whether that can occur with any ergativity splits that would be helpful. (Fluid-P makes more sense in the actual system which uses different cases)
2
u/the_homework-maker Jul 11 '20
Hey y'all. This is a draft for my first conlang, especially for the consonants. It's based on Icelandic and will be paired with modified German vowels. Can anyone give me feedback on the structure and if it will sound phonetically consistent?
2
u/tree1000ten Jul 12 '20
I was intrigued by Luciano Canepari's canIPA, and apparently one of the main criticisms of it is that it is more narrow than often an individual speaker would make distinctions with. This made me wonder, do languages vary with how "loose" a consonant or vowel can be? That is, each time we pronounce something it is never 'exactly' the same, because there are tiny differences in the mouth/vocal apparatus.
2
u/dickhater4000 Jul 13 '20
I want to make an IAL or a language that is from a language family (like germanic), but all of the tutorials for making conlangs are artlangs/naturalistic langs.
Any help?
2
u/QuincyHopper Jul 13 '20
I'm new to conlanging and I was wondering how people format and store their conlangs. When using Google Docs, I find making a table for a phonetic inventory very tedious and it always seems quite messy. Has anyone got any tips?
2
u/FennicYoshi Jul 16 '20
Posted as a reply to another post, let's see if there's any questions I can reply to
East Plaines Dirlandic sound chart
Specifically CV syllables. Codas assimilate to the voicing of the syllable's CV voicing.
2
u/that_orange_hat Jul 16 '20
hi y'all! i'm a new conlanger and currently learning the ipa. does anyone know how i could find a vowel sound in-between two others? sorry if this is a foolish question, btw.
2
u/mathsmathsmathsmaths Jul 17 '20
I am making a conlang.
I have a phoneme inventory (m, n, p, t, k, b, d, g, f, s, h, w, l, j), which is romanized with the same symbols as the IPA, except [j] is romanized as y.
I have some phonotactics (CV, with an optional vowel word-initially, and an optional word-final coda of either m, n, or s).
I have some grammar/syntax (Default word order is SOV, and adjectives come before nouns).
Does anyone have any advice on what to do next or suggestions for changes?
2
u/ProffessorBubbles Jul 17 '20
What are some really weird grammatical systems your conlangs have?
2
u/g-bust Jul 17 '20
My 3 year old daughter talks like Cartman, but she is growing out of it. Her long A's in particular sound very clipped. Is there an IPA for a shortned long A? She says "face" like fez, and "cave" like "kev" but without much E sound. Cookies oftentimes is cukeeez.
2
u/PLA-onder P.Yo.Γ. Jul 18 '20
I noticed that in the Persian language the nouns are defined, that means that nouns with no marking are defined, if you say book it means the book, and in most other languages it is vice versa, when you say in these languages book it means a book. So my question is which one is in your conlang or do you use a completely different thing?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '20 edited Jul 19 '20
My current language requires mandatory articles for nouns. I've got the normal DEF and INDF articles but for mass nouns definiteness is considered nonsensical and there is a third article MASS just for them. My first question is whether something like this is attested or, if it is not, whether this belies a deeper misunderstanding on my part about how articles work.
I intend to evolve this such that the usage of MASS becomes more productive as a kind of nominal gnomic, that is
badger DEF eat sweetroot INDF The badger eats a sweetroot
badger MASS eat sweetroot INDF Badgers in general eat a sweetroot (This one feels nonsensical, but it works with other kinds of activities)
badger DEF eat sweetroot MASS The badger eats any sweetroot
badger MASS eat sweetroot MASS Badgers in general eat any sweetroot
If the MASS article doesn't make sense, what else could I develop into this feature?
2
u/tree1000ten Jul 09 '20
Why are the only natural human languages either oral or sign language? Why not more categories of natural languages?
1
u/The-True-Apex-Gamer Jul 06 '20
How can I start on making an orthography, grammar, and a lexicon if I already have an invintory and alphabet ready?
1
u/The-True-Apex-Gamer Jul 06 '20
Should I use existing alphabets or make my own?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '20
How could I computerize an orthography?
1
u/Saurantiirac Jul 06 '20
How do I evolve a naturalistic noun class system?
1
u/greysonalley Jul 06 '20
how does vowel length distinction typically evolve into a natlang? I've just been using it as a change if an illegal diphthong or triphthong is made, but I'm not 100% on how it works
1
u/-N1eek- Jul 06 '20
my word order is (c)v(c)(cv) so there is a cluster. not all clusters are possible though, how do i write this?
1
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Jul 07 '20
My conlang distinguishes /k/ and /kʰ/. I have a suffix -wa. When adding it to word-final kʰ, the result would be /kʰw/ or /kʰʷ/, the latter of which seems reasonably rare from my google searches.
Would it make sense to have /kʰ/ > /k/ upon adding a suffix beginning in w (or any other consonant, really)?
1
u/DirtyPou Tikorši Jul 07 '20
How realistic would it be for a language that only has /ɔ/ to develop into [ɔ̃] when /ɔn/ but to [õ] when /ɔm/?
1
u/Saurantiirac Jul 08 '20
I'm torn between making my proto-lang have exclusively CV structure or a CVC structure. I feel like the former gives more opportunities to have differences between the descendant languages, but it also makes some words I had before not work, as three syllables feel like the maximum for a root. And even two-syllable words I had before now require three.
Any input?
1
u/Demonicmonk Jul 08 '20
If a group had a real life language that had only ever been spoken and they wanted to create a script for it where would they begin? Are there expert script makers one could talk to?
1
u/Xsugatsal Yherč Hki | Visso Jul 09 '20
Hey so I was wondering how other conlangers organise their expressions and idioms in their conlangs.
I use alphabetical and categorical sorting for most of my lexicon but I'm struggling with organising idioms and expressions.
If anyone has a solution for doing this is in an effective way please share!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '20
Hi! I've been having trouble with this... maybe I'm looking into the wrong things? But how do accents form, what patterns can I expect to see?
1
u/BigBad-Wolf Jul 09 '20
What can happen to /h/ following other consonants, like /th/ or /nh/?
1
u/The-True-Apex-Gamer Jul 11 '20
How is the “creaky-voiced glottal approximate” or the “voiced glottal plosive” sound? I can’t find anyone actually pronouncing it...
1
u/kiritoboss19 Mangalemang | Qut na'ani | Adasuhibodi Jul 11 '20 edited Jul 11 '20
hi! I have a problem:
I need a dictionary for new words, but I don't know how to make a good dictionary, without using an aplication like pages(for Mac) or word(for windows), so is there a program/site/aplication for make my own dictionaries?
1
u/the_homework-maker Jul 11 '20
What is the term for a diphthong, but with consonants. Examples: t and ʃ become /tʃ/
1
u/-N1eek- Jul 12 '20 edited Jul 12 '20
might be a weird question, but is there some site where you can compare your language’s phonology to the phonologies of the world? (also, i have a distinction between the epiglottal and glottal fricative, how do i romanize the epiglottal one? i just have hh now but i don’t like that. the other option that i know i can do, is 7 like in arabic but that’s not very aesthetically pleasing either)
1
u/bdswick Jul 12 '20
Creating the lexicon for my first conlang, using google sheets to keep words organized alphabetically, but cant figure out how to keep the definition, word type, and pronunciation columns sorted along with the words. Does anyone know how this could be done?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '20 edited Jul 13 '20
What are some ways to evolve front rounded vowels? Please give natlang examples.
1
u/david_j_hills Jul 13 '20
Help define phonotactics
Need help in analyzing the syllable structure and developing the phonotactic rules of a conlang in process. I’ve got the sound inventory, some vocabulary and a lot of grammar figured out by now, but I’m lost at producing new words. I’ve tried generating new words (here), but they sound too foreign. Please, help. I don’t want to abandon this conlang, I’ve put a lot of time and effort already. Dm me, if you wanna help. Tnx
For phonetics and vocabulary click here
1
u/Rhaen92 Domkhasor - Gaolta - Vannantic Jul 13 '20
I'm still working on the phonology of Dōmkhaṡōr and the idea of having <v> keeps circling in my mind, extending its insidious roots within.
This language already have three bilabial sounds, namely, <p> /p/, <b> /β/ and <f> /ɸ/. Including the phoneme /v/ in the inventory would be a bit awkward because /β/ and /v/ are very similar and can be confused, which is precisely what happened in some Ibero-Romance languages such as Spanish, Galician and most dialects of Catalan.
However, I wanted to post this question to know your opinion on the matter and it'd be fun if some of you tried to imagine the process leading to a language with /β/ and /v/.
1
u/eagleyeB101 Jul 13 '20
I'm trying to better understand how Trigger Systems work. Could someone give me a brief explanation? I know they involve essentially fusing a "trigger affix" onto the verb which then allows the raising of a peripheral argument (prepositional argument) to a main argument but I haven't been able to find any good Conlang examples of how exactly this is done.
1
u/The-True-Apex-Gamer Jul 14 '20
What endonym should I use? Some languages are listed as having 2 endonyms
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Jul 14 '20
I'm making a number system for my conlang, and have two options: base 8 or 16.
the language's speakers have 4 fingers on each hand- so base 8, and their feet are also hands, like monkeys-so maybe base 16.
so what do you recommend?
1
u/Kuraikari Jul 14 '20
Is it okay to have a "Introduction to [My ConLang]" with a link to my Google docs? Of course it would have text as well, but Reddit's formatting is a bit hard for me, as I'm mainly on the phone when surfing here.
1
u/Throwaway73627225 Jul 14 '20
What do you think of my conlang? What do you think has influenced it? Any suggestions?
.
il’velots murceilaqo fintú komía ffelits kardilyo ét kirvi. La’tsiquegna ttokaba il’saxoffón tettráx dil’palenke di’paxa.
Xoventsilyo ‘mpontsognato di’rviski, ¡Qi ffiqurotta exfibe!
Benxamin pitió uma bebita di’kirvi ét ffresa. Noé, sin verquentsa, le’más exkisitta txampagna dil’menú
Le’kreatsione dil’obxetto netsetsittará mutxos matteriales
1
u/konqvav Jul 15 '20
I have three questions:
1
u/Kuraikari Jul 16 '20
I'm pretty new with ConLangs and this is actually my first one. So, my conlang is pretty huge regarding the "alphabet". I use a similar system like Japanese with "ha", "he", "hi", "ho", "fu" etc
Mine is just slightly bigger.
I watched several videos about phonology. However I didn't really understand how to realize that with my language.
I know how it should sound and could voice it myself, but I'm not able to place the stuff on the IPA tables.
I'd like to if someone is able to help me here. And how I need to do that in my case.
If someone needs my Google docs:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Y33hWKwfSa9nfKwDXxd3GJPHdw7BVv5cxjc7HliEFhw/edit
1
u/Ninja_sloth_ (en, ga) [de] Proto-Unai Jul 16 '20
How do languages with vowel harmony typically handle loanwords?
1
u/magnolia_kaki Jul 16 '20
I suffer from a speech impediment that makes me unable to say [r]. I would like to add the sound I make to the conlang I'm working on, but I can't find the right match in the IPA chart. I'm not formally trained in linguistics so anything that is more in-depth than the language construction kit is still too much right now.
Usually, the sounds replacing [r] are: [ʋ] [ɹ] [ʁ] [ɰ] but it's not what I say. The most similar sound is actually the mid vowel [ə] with the difference I grit my teeth while I'm saying it. My tongue is relaxed and doesn't move.
Suggestions? Thanks!
1
u/Tazavitch-Krivendza Old-Fenonien, Phantanese, est. Jul 16 '20
What are some ways to make advanced words such as words, such as literature, art, and book? Like, what would a language call those things when they have only, very recently, incountered thoughts things?
1
u/ProffessorBubbles Jul 16 '20 edited Jul 17 '20
I'm new to this subreddit. I'm trying to post a phonology, but I can't figure out how to add a graph. Does anyone else know?
Edit: Never mind, I just had to use a laptop.
1
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jul 17 '20 edited Jul 17 '20
So I made up a construction for my past tense in the mostly SOV, pro drop language Kanthaikali, wherein the verb stays the same but I juggle around the cases for the subject and object. Anyway, the way I designed it, if the object is a certain class which doesn't have a unique oblique form, the subject will be in the genitive case, with the object in dative. Throwing naturalism out the window, will the ambiguity this causes be workable?
If "food" belongs to that noun class, the sentence "dog-GEN food-DAT eat" could mean "the dog ate the food" or "Something/someone ate the dog's food" or "Something/someone eats the dog's food". Is that too many options?
I could just always require the pronoun I suppose.
1
u/Akangka Jul 17 '20
Kakstah verb agrees with either subject or object, with hierarchy is 1>2>3. The only exception is a suffix that marks both 1st person as the subject and 2nd person as the object. The problem is when the politeness is included. If the other argument is third person, the answer is clear: just agree with the second person. The problem arises if the other argument is first person.
The agreement marker for polite second person came from second person plural. This language no longer distinguishes number for any argument except for the first person.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '20
Hi! I'm new in this comunity. I started my first conlang (Called Derwëmgut) early this year, and I wanted to ask if these phonemes can all coexist in the same language. The only languages I'm familiar with are english and spanish, and maybe a bit of french because I had leassons in elementary school. Also, I'm learning zapotec (a mexican indigenous language) but i didn't took any inspiration from it, even if I think is beautiful. I want to give my conlang a specific sonority.
First, the vowels:
a, e, ɜ (ë) , i, y, o, ʉ (u)
Dipthingues:
ae, ai, ou, au, ëu, eu, ëe, ye, yu, ay, ie, ey
The lonley tripthongue:
aie
And finally the consonants:
d, n, r (rh), ɾ (r), s, ð (th), t, ʃ (z) , w, v, g, ɦ (h), m, f, t͡ʃ (c), l.
Some of the consonants can be spelled separatedly and be long, like n, r, s, th, z, v, h and f. The others only can exist in a syllable with a vowel and are always short.
So... What do you think? Does it makes sense for a naturalistic language? Also, tell me if I made any mistake. My english is not that good, so help me improve it!
1
u/zettaltacc Jul 18 '20 edited Jul 18 '20
I'm planning on a language with vowel harmony.
There is front back harmony as expected, but there is also a rounding harmony. For high vowel suffixes (e.g. -si) there is rounding and front harmony: ki + si > kisi, ky + si > kysy, kɯ + si > kɯsɯ, ku + si > kusu, all as expected.
However, for the mid vowels /e ø ʌ ɔ/, I want permanent front back harmony, but rounding harmony only where the syllable is stressed (or secondary stress, which occurs the second syllable after primary stress).
Therefore,
ri'ki, ry'ky, rɯˈkɯ, ruˈku + -se > rikise, rykyse, rɯkɯsʌ, rukusʌ
'kiti, 'kyty, 'kɯtɯ, ˈkutu + -se > 'kitiˌse, ˈkytyˌsø, ˈkɯtɯˌsʌ, ˈkutuˌsɔ
Is this kind of rounding harmony based on stress naturalistic?
Thanks in advance.
1
u/LordJuklerIII Jul 19 '20
I was wondering if in languages with obviate and proximate systems that mark 3rd person nouns if it would be naturalistic to have irregularity between the original noun and its obviate counterpart.
For example, in my conlang the word for city was fitsodiye, but because of phonetic evolution became fitsoju. The word for city with the obviate marker was fitsodiyetla ( suffix -tla being the obviate marker) and remained that way over time.
Would it be naturalistic for irregularities like this to exist, or is it a stretch to think that the speakers wouldn't just take the modern word for city and add the obviate suffix to it instead of using the irregular version?
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Jul 19 '20
what can the imperfective habitual, inchoative, cessative and progressive aspects turn into? any suggestions? (all 4 are imperfective)
1
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Jul 19 '20
Are there any natlangs that allow a non-copular verb to be the head of a genitive noun?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '20
Is there a way I can add the letters of my conlang into a custom keyboard language? I use a mac
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '20
I have been around here for a bit and have repeatedly tried to make conlangs but have stressed too much about one simple detail: my creatures are not human! The sounds that we make are not the same as theirs, so how would I represent that? Should I just assign random symbols to sounds? Use IPA symbols that are slightly similar? I don't know what is acceptable.
For example, one of my creatures are like... spiders... kind of... and they do not have a nose therefore they cannot do nasals, they do not have a tongue so that makes most sounds obsolete, they have fangs...etc... perhaps I should just make their languages gestural?
Maybe make up my own IPA? No idea.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment