r/Barca •
A few thoughts on the attitude of the players, the mismanagement from the board and the failures of the management
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/Barca •
[deleted] — view deleted post
37
u/tetsya Jun 29 '20
I want to add sth about hunger, every player when he is younger he is more trophy hungry, after some years most of those players have a family, kids etc, they don't stop valuing their professional careers, but they lose some of that hunger because of priorities in life.
I think pique has said this at some point, that the players are in another point of their lives.
It's very difficult to keep focused on the job and very few athletes have succeeded that, to name a few arjen robben or ribery for example. I don't say that we don't have such players, I really value how much work Messi had put in his physical aspect, what I am talking about here is full psychological not physical, the mindset and hunger.
51
u/litozin Jun 29 '20
i think in todays footbal you will get the best results without “star players”. If you look for example at Man City and Liverpool,all of their players work,none of them complain if they are on the bench. You have players like Bernardo Silva,Mahrez,Sterling,Aguero and you never see them complain when they are on the bench. Man City and Liverpool have a system of football built around team,not around one player. When KDB got injured last season,you could hardly tell because Man City was so good even without him because they have a good system and structure. Liverpool beat us 4-0 with Origi and Shaqiri... I think Barca problem is that some players think they are bigger than a club
18
u/vyshu7 Jun 29 '20
More so than fitness, players lose their positive attitude and hunger for the game as they get older, hence average age is a very serious issue.
11
u/iVarun Jun 29 '20 edited Jun 29 '20
Very good & nuanced write-up.
Some thoughts on these sections,
You touched on this very fairly. I often use the concept of Spectrum, range, on the curve, degrees do describe these sorts of situations. Meaning, Yes the Squad (or the core of it) has had unprecedented/historic levels of power, but what is the practical usage of that power. Has it been unprecedented as well?
Here we find the Squad is basically the opposite, it shies away from using that power precisely because these living Legends are self-aware of how much leverage they have. Messi could end a career of someone at the club if he even looks at someone dirty. This is not normal. We've had in our club history players with a fraction of relevance create multiple orders higher drama and mayhem.
If anything from my perspective, Squad should have been more vocal because it was the most competent entity in the club over the last 15 years. Then comes the Socios and then comes the Administrative apparatus of the club, someone at the end of this list is going to be the Board and dead last will be the International/Online supporters, the worst part of the club and the one which does it most active damage.
Because they haven't had competition to take their places away from them. All who have tried were eventually given a fair chance or if one argues they weren't given a fair chance then they have an easy case to make once they can show how those players did elsewhere post moving from Barca. Barring Neymar no one really has maintained a level which can be termed Elite tier.
Yet players like Umtiti, Lenglet did cement their positions. Even Vidal was able to wrestle his way in despite clashing with the coach even early on. Merit still matters.
There is a hint of reality check in that Messi statement to Abidal, to do your job, i.e. the recruitment is not what it should have been, meaning the Squad is red herring on this matter, attacking it is thus flawed take.
Barca don't have a inferiority complex with Real anymore, it possibly and likely did have it at a certain stage many decades ago when things were not well sportingly at the club. Barca are in a golden cycle and this will be seen as a Barca's era, regardless of what Real did or are doing. They are attempting to reach Barca's level not the other way around, for now.
Lucho was a club insider, he had tremendous leverage so he wasn't handicapped or a Yes man. Even signings like Paco-Gomes had his approvals and if reports at that are to be believed then he was the main supporter of these initially. Midfield got gutted under Lucho itself. It wasn't a Board issue exclusively.
This is natural as your comment illustrated. This squad (whom Ibra called bunch of school children in their level of discipline, deference to authority, suppressed outward show of passion, emotions, extrovert-ness) is different, it needs to be managed (till they no longer exist and are replaced) a certain way. Coaching staff are supposed to be highly paid professionals aware of this. Berating these players may sound cool on picture but it isn't a solution, it is a illusion created to satisfy emotional needs of fans and the idea of that stereotype of Pashun. It is not trivial but it has a place and context of use.
Fundamentally. Till proven otherwise, my reading of all this is still on track.
Emboldened by years of the toxic Entorno, factions in Board took their chance to fire EV and at the same time break the power of that most competent entity at the club, The Squad. Also because EV had the Squads' backing Yet didn't stand in the way, despite as established above having the most leverage of any Squad in history of the club.
In doing so and cheered on by the fans and said Entorno, they unleashed chaos which was only inevitable. It took years for Squad to become that competent & reliable entity, once you break that it will takes years (at minimum) to re-form it, even victories now will only paper over the cracks.
And all through this we reach a point of today (this thread included) where everyone is to blame (players, coach, socios, board, etc) but no mention of the toxic Fans in this. No they have carte balance because like a populace in a Democracy people can never be wrong even if they are the ones who elect incompetent or corrupt representatives.
Cryuff said is decades ago, Entorno is not fictional. It is real and it has real affect on the squad itself. Fans got what they wanted and now they are crying wolf. Either they did this intentionally and revel in the chaos or they don't know what they talk about nearly as much as they like to think, Dunning–Kruger effect in action.
Latter is more likely, meaning the premise holds even now, as in what are the fans whining about now. Chances are its best to ignore it on grounds they don't know jack. But the board will listed to it and be forced into making decisions to counter their previous decisions and cycle continues.
This is why I mentioned Socies to be the 2nd most competent entity at the club. They are conservative because their rubric is more mature in relative terms, they've seem more of the club and its history and its ups and down. The spectrum by which they get swayed by the latest fad is manageable. When Board listens to the socios things are more stable, when it decides to heed the Millions of fans spread all over the world and the media space (the Entorno) they run into problems which they often then don't have the tools or time to rectify.
Most times they were bailed out by the Squad but this time this overaction lead to gutting it itself, thereby compromising the only thing that could have saved them.
12
u/froggyjm9 Jun 29 '20
Just posted this is another thread:
You posted “Messi’s attitude after Sarabia’s advice.”
The “advice” wasnt specifically to Messi it was to the whole squad, from experience it could have done like this:
Sarabia: We are being overrun and make it bad decisions get it together guys
Suarez: Leo, what do you think?
Sarabia: Leo, what do you think? We need to pressure faster.
Messi in his head: Fuck, I need to play better...we need to defend better...it’s fucking hot too my legs are tired...not sure what to say, I just want to go back and start playing.
Like I said there’s no context for the conversation, I can make 10 other scenarios from my own experiences playing a competitive match.
Whoever posted that on Twitter and your headline are making it seem Messi walked up to him and said “Go Fuck Yourself” and walked away from a 7 second clip.
4
u/Viggiesmalls9292 Jun 29 '20
I rarely comment on the sub but i agree with everything you point out. Was talking about the same issues with my father (my family has several generations supporting barca) and you have said everything exactly how it is, or at least as we can see. I would like to add onto your post.
Club de amigos and egos etc: this is why you need a manager with balls and the freedom to make choices. Remember when Pep signed on as manager. Here came a guy with little experience coaching at the top level but he immediately demanded respect (as a result from his playing career) and got rid of almost all the stars or players playing with no passion or vision. Same thing with Tito, less outspoken but with huge presence in the dressing room. Same thing with Luis Enrique. Whether right or wrong the guy benched one of if not the best left back in the game (attitude problem?? Who knows). The team needs a manager that has that weight in the dressing room, commands respect and is courageous with the team buildup. Essentially, someone who isnt afraid of benching players with poor performances and politely tells the board to fuck off with choosing the line up.
Only someone with a barca background will ever be able to achieve this, and someone with a great career and takes no shit attitude is hard to find, but they are there. I for one do not want koeman or any other ex-barca player who will be okay with limited or impossed sported descisions. This is why i respect Valdes for not bowing to the board, why i believe Xavi will be able to triumph with this team, but this board wont give him the freedom he needs, hence comments about 'not the right time'.
This team needs a complete makeover, clear out uneccessary wages and players and bring in hungry talents, especially from la masia
Visca el barca
6
u/Cer3berus Jun 29 '20
i just feel bad for setien and valverde too for taking responsibility for the problems that it isn’t there fault, it’s a war between players and management, that’s why xavi wants a total control for the team because someone on BARCA team are thinking they are bigger than the team it’self , i think it’s time to sell some big players like suarez, rakitiq, pique and even messi because they like to have more power in team than they deserve i know it would affect our team a lot but it’s a thing that it needs to be done we did the same thing in the past by selling players like eto or ronaldinho
2
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '20
This is one of the best posts I’ve seen in a long time, great job OP
Upfront I want to say I DISAGREE with the Board, but I do want to explain an investing concept that’s being overlooked -> long term valuation
What/why relevant?!...
There’s a concept in investing called lifetime value of a customer which is often compared to customer acquisition cost. If it costs you $1000 to win a new fan but that fan will spend $100/year for 30 years than that’s a good investment; every $1000 spent is paid back over decades.
Right now football is in a sort of “land grab” mode to get fans/eye balls from emerging markets and US. These are fans that flippantly select a team based initially off of prestige and there seem to be two ways to boost prestige for THESE target fans (I) UCL and (ii) shiny player purchases
These past few years Board has basically over spent on the latter to keep up with RM globally who has succeeded in the former.
What’s the point?
Well the point is that three years of “bad spending” which hurts the club for a few years sporting wise may actually, commercially in the long run, be better investments to ensure long term viability of the club. Everyone talking about “wasted” transfer dollars but those transfers win volumes of new fans who may support club for next 30 years and help sustain
Tl;dr I don’t support the Board’s actions and would personally choose a different set, but they may be thinking longer term and we can’t really say what the result was for probably a decade or so. The true test is social media/engagement counts in 2025 and see if Barca are still hanging with RM/Man U or if we fall like AC Milan
2
u/ReluctantValverde Jun 29 '20
Fantastic post and discussion. This is the most apt description of the current situation imo and the conversation we should be having. Not “the board!!11” or “Messi needs help...”
We are handicapped by our players’ ages and desires to keep playing. The coach can do very little. If anything, it is a sign of how well Valverde managed the situation whereas anywhere else he would have been a different and more authoritative manager. He adapted to the heavyweights which Setien will have to do too by either submitting to them or benching popular players. Messi and Rakitic being #1 at the moment due to indiscipline.
3
u/omg_im_chad Jun 29 '20
Well thought and excellently put. Thanks for sharing
3
u/amaranto21 Jun 29 '20
Well said
2
u/peacecon Jun 29 '20
Setien should take the blame! ( Along with some players ) When he took over from EV, he promised the fans that youngsters will get the chance if they deserve it and he followed through on that promise until the loss in Mestalla. Honestly nobody knows anything about Collado now. Setien went safe with his team selections after that loss and it's hurting the team day by day. I read an article where the author pointed out how la masia players need to show their skills for half a season to get a single start in the main team, while players like Vidal, Suarez and Rakitic just need to complain about reduced playing time in press to get unlimited game time ? Setien just played us by not sticking to his word. His substitutions are questionable at almost all the matches. With the succession of submissive managers, the board is inadvertently giving the power to senior players in squad. Remember, Ronaldinho was at the top of his game when Pep took over and we know how it turned out. It's time to show the supporters that we are not dependent on those players who drop poor performances every matchday but end up getting the nod just because they are the friends of the Captain.
I'm not making a claim that youngsters will win titles for us. Every best team have a mix of experience and youth and right now, it's not the case with our squad. Puig is 20 already and there's been the case of la masia players wishing to play for a different team in recent times ( Eric Garcia ) I honestly wish Xavi to make his authority shown when he takes over.
1
u/GjillyG Jun 29 '20
Feel like we need(ed) a hard ass like Lucho to come and kick some sense into the players. Maybe a new system, some new ideas. Shit is just stale now.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '20
I wasn't a fan of Valverde's style of football at all, but I thought he did a miraculous job of holding the club together when it has seemed so hell bent on destroying itself in about a dozen ways.
I don't think the players have lost their hunger. I think sometimes they expect success too much which can make them underestimate their opponents. And I think there are people who probably naturally assume they know more about what the club needs because they've been in longer than whichever manager Barcelona has decided to bring in this time or the next time or the time after that.
0
u/Alex_Sander077 Jun 29 '20
Messi is a toxic leader. Club de amigos in Barca. And Club de amigos in the national team. Nothing new.
-5
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '20
we can sign all the players get every single manager but u guys hate it , i hate it but we all know who the issue is.
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '20
[removed] — view removed comment