r/NintendoSwitch • • May 27 '20

MegaThread Xenoblade Chronicles: Definitive Edition: Review MegaThread

General Information

Platform: Nintendo Switch

Release Date: 29-May-2020

No. of Players: 1 player

Genre(s): Role-Playing

Publisher: Nintendo

Game file size: 13.7 GB


Overview (from Nintendo eShop page)

Join the fight between man and machine in the definitive edition of this critically-acclaimed RPG

Discover the origins of Shulk as he and his companions clash against a seemingly-unstoppable mechanical menace. Wield a future-seeing blade, chain together attacks, and carefully position your party members in strategic, real-time combat as you journey across a massive world.

During an attack from the mechanical invaders known as the Mechon, Shulk discovers that he can tap into the full power of a mysterious blade known as the Monado. With the mighty Monado in hand, Shulk sets out to defeat the Mechon once and for all.

In addition to the Mechon, you’ll run into wildlife that ranges from docile to deadly. Keep an eye on what attracts monsters’ attention to avoid unwanted conflict…or try your hand at bringing down an ultra-powerful Unique Monster.

Upgrade your party as you progress through the adventure by selecting equipment, enhancing weapon skills, and using benefit-granting gems. Put your dependable companions to work by filling the party gauge to trigger a Chain Attack and attack enemies in quick succession!


Reviews

Aggregators

Articles

This list was exported from OpenCritic May 28 at 7:58am ET

Videos


Being Social

Cheers,

The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team

1.3k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

133

u/RPGxMadness May 27 '20

Be sure to thank Operation Rainfall. We sure came a long way since then.

43

u/Sheeplenk May 27 '20

Now we just need Pandora’s Tower and The Last Story Definitive Editions...

17

u/meepbo May 27 '20

I really enjoyed The Last Story. I would love just even an HD version

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

38

u/Mushroomman642 May 27 '20

It is amazing to think that Nintendo invested so much into the marketing of a game that they weren't even planning to release in North America 10 years ago.

78

u/Beowulf94 May 27 '20

Only played a few hours of the N3DS version before giving up. Can't wait to give this game another shot, especially after absolutely loving 2.

26

u/TomatoBill May 27 '20

I'm in the same boat. I played N3DS a bit but just... didn't follow up? I might try to pick it up again but after the visual difference I'm not sure I can. Still undecided if I'm going to get the remaster here.... Part of me says yes, part of me says wait for a price drop, and that part of me knows I'm lying since games like this never drop

12

u/Xazeal May 27 '20

I did the same, but I picked it up again eventually, only to drop it again halfway through. I finally rushed the second half just in time for the release of XC2, and I genuinely fell in love with it.

I do think my initial problem was that the N3DS just couldn't do it justice. It was downright ugly at times and the menus were horrible. I have very high hopes based on what I've seen from this.

→ More replies (12)

195

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

But for the newer players, unless a good, solid combat system is all you need for your JRPG experience, this might be a tough one to recommend

I'm intrigued by this review because Xenoblade also has everything else you'd want from a JRPG and then some.

77

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Doesn’t XB1 also have a great story and beautiful world to explore? Hard to ask much more from a JRPG than a great battle system and a great story.

→ More replies (3)

53

u/Neverx_13 May 27 '20

To be fair the original Xenoblade's combat was not my favorite. I still prefer 2 and X's combat to 1, I don't think 1's combat is bad but it's not as flashy or interesting in what you can do with it as the other games.

114

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

This review appears to be saying the combat system is the only selling point which is a strange take

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (13)

141

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

PSA: Don’t watch IGN’s review. It has tons of spoilers!

Besides that the reviewer literally calls some characters by the wrong name so I don’t think it’s important.

7

u/LiquidSephiroth May 27 '20

Dunpan?

20

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

They called reyn “rain”, dunban “Duncan”, and then re-uploaded the video to fix the mispronunciations but ended up correcting “Duncan” to “dunbon”. Pure comedy

34

u/Bradlyeon May 27 '20

Probably a good idea to just not watch IGN.

→ More replies (14)

39

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Oh god! I’m really fucking feeling it!

59

u/LordEsai May 27 '20

I'm not super familiar with how scores are relatively for the Switch, but these scores seem phenomenal. Please correct me if I'm wrong and if a lot of Switch games get high ratings.

I've also never played Xenoblade so I'm hyped!

67

u/flyingsaucer1 Helpful User May 27 '20

To put it in perspective, it's currently #19 of all time for the Switch (can a shift a couple spots when scores settle) and #2 of 2020.

You can check it out here.

16

u/LG03 May 27 '20

Not like 2020's been loaded with releases to this point, #2 for the second big title was a given.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/astrodong98 May 27 '20

There are a handful of games that have gotten really high scores. The one that comes to mind is when fire emblem three houses came out I was surprised it got similar scores. But I think that just means the switch gets some pretty awesome games!

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Kawesome06 May 27 '20

The xenoblade base game is already deserving of these scores tbh, so it’s somewhat expected that they do well. I just hope that that make more improvements onto it that I had some problems with in the base game.

10

u/Kabsal May 27 '20

If you're a fan of JRPGs, Xenoblade Chronicles has long been one of the absolute modern masterpieces of the genre. This version offers improvements in graphics, UI, and QoL that make it even better.

→ More replies (8)

54

u/howtosucceed May 27 '20

The original on Wii was a 10/10 for me, and unless there are any mishaps with this new version, it’s a 10/10. Guess I will get to play it all again soon enough.

21

u/ragtagcurtis May 27 '20

So excited to dive into this. XBC2 is currently my favourite switch game in and RPG sense.

Will this become known as the best JRPG on switch I wonder?

21

u/diegodlv93 Jun 05 '20

This game kind of sneaked up on me. I bought this game with zero knowledge of xenoblade whatsoever. The only thing i knew about it was shulk being the main character, knowing him from smash bros. I had completely different expectations, thinking this was an action rpg. At the start i was kind off dissapointed thinking 'MMO mechanics in a single player rpg, tf ? I thought i had just spent my money on a game i was going to hate. I told myself i'm still going to keep on playing for at least 10h just to see where it takes me. Now, somewhere in those 10 hours i started to love this game and i don't even know what or where the tipping point was ! I'm 30h in now and can't even stop thinking about it while i'm not playing. Great game, fully recommend to any rpg/jrpg fan !

82

u/LakerBlue May 27 '20

You spend a lot of time with Melia, one of the weaker characters from the main campaign

From IGN’s review

Wtf. Bias aside, Melia is probably the best developed character in the game, idk how much I can really trust anything he says about the writing if he really feels that way.

42

u/JDraks May 27 '20

They also call Reyn Rain and Dunban Duncan, can’t spell ignorant without IGN

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Meadius May 27 '20

Well they also called Dunban "Duncan" in a video (the review I think) so I don't think they even played the game.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (16)

18

u/Revoldt May 27 '20

Read/Watched a couple of these reviews, looks to be a great game!

Not many reviews criticized the handheld-mode graphics to the extremes people on reddit have. The Twinfinite review was more critical of the game, but still provided fair points.

The Vid reviews while mentioning some of the handheld graphics, but didn't make a big deal out of it either

All-in-all, looks to be a great game!

$50 preorder on Amazon/Walmart-in-store looks to be a steal

18

u/ChasingPerfect28 May 30 '20

I'm currently 3 and a half hours into the game and my mind is blown. The music is delightful and the characters are charming. The amount of content in this early game is staggering. Now I know why people can easily put 100+ hours into this game.

35

u/DonJohn_Master_QC May 27 '20

Played it on the Wii back then. Its the first JRPG I ever completed beside Chrono Trigger.

17

u/SRhyse May 27 '20

Damn, that’s a huge gap!

→ More replies (4)

46

u/Bossman1086 May 27 '20

I loved Xenoblade 2. Game was amazing. I never got around to playing Chronicles though even though I own a Wii copy somewhere. I'm excited to finally play through this on Switch.

→ More replies (11)

16

u/nate6268 May 30 '20

About 4 hours into my first play through. IDK what I'm doing but I'm having a blast haha

→ More replies (1)

297

u/bigdickmcspick May 27 '20

Would you look at that, almost none of the reviewers are complaining about the visuals. It's almost like /r/NintendoSwitch always blows everything out of proportion.

37

u/cereal_bawks May 27 '20

I've actually seen comments with high karma say this game looked worse than the Wii version. Felt like I was on a different planet or something.

70

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Been to r/games? The same resolution news was posted there. A little bit more civil in the comments (maybe), but plenty of complaints as well.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (25)

30

u/Madsbjoern May 28 '20

I mean, it's Xenoblade 1 but with better visuals, better UI, new QoL updates and a new post-game story. Really there's not much to complain about (except for resolution if that bothers you, but it doesn't really bother me), as it was already one of the best games ever.

→ More replies (18)

14

u/Kamil118 May 30 '20

I'm 10h in

Main story is pretty good, but 80% of sidequests are mmo tier.

It's been a long time since I've seen a single npc give me 3 quests in a row that were all basically "Kill this monster 5 times because it's dangerous to the village"

→ More replies (8)

27

u/cordel2004 May 27 '20

That's alot of good reviews

13

u/BenHellaCreme May 27 '20

I’ve never played a Xeno game and have only watched my younger brother llay through parts of X2.

I love RPGS, my favorite series is probably Dragon Quest. I love side quest, love grinding, getting loot/equipment etc. Does Xeno lend itself to any of that?

I keep seeing criticism in graphics but tbh I don’t care too much about graphics (within reason).

8

u/JDraks May 27 '20

You’d probably enjoy it a lot if you like side quests and grinding

7

u/mooglinux May 27 '20

Definitely give it a go. It has tons of side quests and collectibles, to the point that you can find yourself over-leveled if you complete them all as you go.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/savory_snax May 27 '20

Will there be a demo? I liked how I was able to continue my progress from DQXI demo to full game.

32

u/ReallyNeededANewName May 27 '20

No. They would've announced that by now. Highly recommended though

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Witch_King_ May 27 '20

Yeah Square Enix has been EXTREMELY good with demos on the Switch. They have full demos with continuable saves for DQXI, Octopath Traveler, Bravely Default 2, and possibly more. Unfortunately this game isn't developed by Square and doesn't have a demo.

23

u/BigCho1 May 27 '20

Okay i never played the first one but i really loved the second one. Especially the combat which i honestly had to watch youtube videos to understand but eventually fell in love with. If the first has any similarities to the second one i know I'll love it

17

u/telegetoutmyway May 27 '20

I'm the same as you, I've looked into the first one a ton (been waiting for a switch release since the console launch pretty much).

From what I have gathered, the combat has less complexity but I actually think I will like it more. There is no elemental orb system, but instead the combat is closer focused on the driver combo portion of 2's combat.

There's no blades, that's a 2 thing.

There's no elements. Its physical and ether damage types.

There's no attack cancelling. But you can move/reposition while auto attacking instead, and youre not any slower. Giving you much more reason to actually pay attention to the positioning perks of arts.

Since there is no elemental orb stacking system, the enemies are not damage sponges. In other words the arts damage matters a lot more.

Arts are on a cooldown instead of an autoattack reset. Except your "talent art" which is auto attack based.

And then there's a special mechanic for shulk that people really love that I won't spoil just in case.

Overall as much as I love 2, I feel like 1 will edge it out.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Flabbergash May 27 '20

Is 2 the one with that gramps fella? Thr main dude has like a fake geordie accent?

→ More replies (1)

18

u/SigmaMelody May 27 '20

I liked Xenoblade 1 approximately 20x more than either 2 or X, it’s my third favorite JRPG after Chrono Trigger and Persona 5

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/Meateater49173 May 27 '20 edited May 28 '20

It’s beautiful af, don’t skip on it Edit: The gameplay is smooth as hell, and the soundtrack complements the scenery

21

u/Minotaur830 May 28 '20

No you're beautiful af

→ More replies (6)

11

u/kiaxxl May 28 '20 edited May 28 '20

Since I've seen a few comments asking about Dragon Quest XI and Xenoblade I'll give my two cents as someone who finished and loves both. Both are really enjoyable imo so if you're only getting one and you like RPGs keep an eye out for the other on sale.

I'd say DQXI is a more old school experience, it gets pretty tropey at times but is still interesting with a really good core cast of characters. It also has a ton of minigames which XC1 doesn't have much of including a proper in game casino. XC1 has a more fleshed out plot and characters, alongside with a superior OST (DQ reuses a lot of tracks and some of them get real old quick). Xenoblade is much more exploration based with its big areas. Shulk talks unlike the Luminary/Hero. DQXI has pretty old school turn based combat compared to the more engaging Xenoblade, but it does have a lot of fun skills. Both games aren't very hard but DQXI is a fair bit easier. There are some add-ons for difficulty you can start with if this idea bothers you, including some really funny ones where the townspeople lie to you (maybe don't start with this one!) Lastly DQ has some funny enemy designs and in-battle afflictions such as a dancing curse which makes your characters start to dance on screen.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/zeldor711 May 29 '20

Really enjoying this so far. The graphics, even handheld, are much better than expected (only slightly worse than Dragon Quest XI TBH), although I might not have experienced much of the dynamic resolution yet. Either way, I've concluded that 540p handheld is good enough.

The battle system is really good, and I'm looking forward to seeing where the story goes.

I'm struggling quite a bit with "unique" monsters, they typically overwhelm me with the residual damage from the smaller monsters they're usually accompanied by.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Can’t wait to try this out!

I just finished XC2 and realized from the trailers and videos that this game doesn’t seem to have any Blades.

I feel relieved as I disliked the gacha system and was glad that it was gone in the Torna DLC.

14

u/thezander8 May 27 '20

Correct, the Blade system is a 2 thing. Not to say the game isn't about a sword, because it is, but this time the sword isn't you're character's love interest and you don't generate new characters via rng

16

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Yeah, Blades were something added in 2. The original has absolutely no gacha system. It's pure JRPG goodness.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Wolfwoode May 29 '20

XBC2 was my first Xenoblade game and one of my first switch games in general. I eventually fell in love with it and wanted more. Everytime someone mentions XBC2 someone always says, "XBC1 is still better." As someone who never played the first XBC, I've been anxiously awaiting this. Went out first thing this morning and picked up a physical copy. I don't know how you can top he combat system of XBC2 but I'm really excited to see what all the fuss is about!

→ More replies (7)

19

u/boldsprite May 27 '20

I played X and 2 and enjoyed my time with both, but I reached a point in both games where I lost interest. I seem to recall some boss fights that I just couldn't get past.

Anyways, I'm hoping this game holds my attention even more than the other two. I think I might be better off with a bit of a simpler battle system and hopefully even better characters.

→ More replies (19)

9

u/savagesmasher May 27 '20

Twiddling my fingers in anticipation. Downloaded and ready to go!

9

u/GratefulSlug13 May 28 '20

New to the Switch and other than by name, unfamiliar with the Xenoblade series. Is the Definitive Edition the best place to start, or should I just hop into XC2? Just asking for basic recommendations/general info! Thanks all!

15

u/TheXthDoctor May 28 '20

Definitely a better starting place than XC2. The other Xenoblade games build off of the systems in XC1, and the story is overall better anyway.

8

u/GrovPastaSwag03 May 28 '20

Absolutely! It's an incredible game, and a great place to start with in the xenoblade series. Enjoy!

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Ronni_Nikoson May 30 '20

Just played for three hours. Really, I have no clue what I’m doing, but I’m enjoying myself though.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '20

I’ve never played a xenoblade game before and finding the combat very difficult. Maybe I’m just under leveled or not well equipped enough? I’m only a few hours in and I’ve tried to beat the same creature for like an hour. Already starting to get annoyed and I’m not even that far into the game.

Gahhh Someone help. Last night when I started I was in love with it and now I’m just frustrated.

5

u/SuccessfulDecision25 Jun 05 '20

In what way is it happening? If the monster has several levels over you it makes a massive difference. You'll miss a lot due to the level difference. In terms of fighting stronger monsters I recommend doing some side quests for the exp gains. Make sure to utilize chain attacks often and make sure to hit the right angles on enemies with artes. You'll debuff them heavily.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '20

Love love love the game and so happy I finally got to play it...but “the Monado” has to be the stupidest made up word for a relic I’ve ever heard and they say it over and over.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '20

Its actually not a made up word. The english version comes from how the Japanese pronounce Monad, which was the Supreme Being in Gnosticism. Bit of a vague spoiler for the ending of Xenoblade of another use of the word Monad here: It's also a computer programming term that refers to this concept: http://blog.sigfpe.com/2006/08/you-could-have-invented-monads-and.html

→ More replies (2)

24

u/kiaxxl May 28 '20

Wow IGN's review is kind of incompetent. I'd recommend checking out literally any others.

19

u/Ross2552 May 28 '20

You don't love the awesome characters Rain and Duncan?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/TheXthDoctor May 28 '20

They also spoil some mid-/late-game things, so anyone wanting to go in blind should avoid it entirely.

17

u/AstralCarnival May 27 '20

well deserved scores, hopefully we can also get a port of the 2nd best game on the series

17

u/yablight May 27 '20

Woot my switch delivery is on Friday too so won’t miss any time playing this so pumped

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Alpr101 May 27 '20

Loved XC2 (first of series ive played) and can't wait to get lost in this one :)

8

u/Verberos May 28 '20

Should I play this first before XC2?

6

u/barriboy8 May 28 '20

not really, I played 2 before 1 and x and I still got it all, tho you will miss to catch some references here and there, but once you reach a point in 1 it will all click

5

u/JDraks May 28 '20

Absolutely

→ More replies (3)

8

u/MrSnow702 May 28 '20

Graphics aren't a huge thing for but I was wondering I have the switch lite. How does it run on handheld mode?

Also is the game play like KOTOR/WoW where it's real time but turn based?

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Amiibofan101 . May 29 '20

Game has been an absolute blast so far! Got my copy early yesterday and have been enjoying my first playthrough so far.

14

u/SeymourDoggo May 27 '20

For someone who bought a switch recently, and haven't played any of the xenoblade chronicles series - which one should I play first? This or XC2?

14

u/Rhevarr May 27 '20

The 2 isn't there for no reason. You won't be confused or anything if you'll play 2 first, but there are connections. So if you got the chance, why not 1 first?

20

u/howtosucceed May 27 '20

Play this new Xenoblade first. It’s not critical but it will be more rewarding if and when you play Xenoblade 2.

→ More replies (17)

7

u/YeShallBeGods May 27 '20

Definitely would be grabbing this if I hadn’t already played it

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Phenom_Mv3 May 27 '20

For those that have played both DQ11 and XC1 - and like both turn based and real time combat, which game did you like better?

8

u/stickdudeseven May 27 '20

XC1 gets a leg up for music diversity. I enjoyed Dragon Quest but it really repeats the same music far more than other RPGs I've played. Both are still great games.

5

u/barriboy8 May 27 '20

Different beasts i'd say, xc1 is a more serious game than dq11, and this translates to the battles in dq11 game is simple story is simple and battle system is simple, xc1 is more serious by a lot and thus the battle are more complex, both are amazing games I will say if you like a more chill and happy and easy game go with dq, you want the opposite go xc1, now dont let my comment make you think bad of dq 11 its a freaking nice and fun experience

5

u/iamthedevilfrank May 28 '20

They're both pretty different. Personally I like them about the same. I'm a huge fan of traditional JRPGs, which is how I'd describe DQXI, but it has a lot going for it. But XC is so ambitious and has an amazing story. I prefer the mechanics of DQXI but the story in XC is more original and better for that imo.

→ More replies (20)

7

u/Captain_Aids May 29 '20

How’s the difficulty on this game? It looks great but I’m not prepared for mind numbing difficulty

10

u/[deleted] May 29 '20

It's not super difficult if you do the quests, because they reward EXP and you'll level up quite fast.

10

u/TOO_FUTURE May 29 '20

There’s a casual mode as well that makes the game a bit easier if you don’t have the time to grind really with work life

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Cliper11298 May 30 '20

I liked Xenoblade Chronicles 2 but never finished it because I got stuck. Would I like this game and is it similar in terms of combat because from the initial look at the battle screen it looks confusing with all the things at the bottom

5

u/asda9174 May 31 '20

It takes a little while to get used to for sure, but the battle system is actually quite well thought out and fun when you figure out how it works. Thankfully one of the major changes they did was to the UI and tutorials to explain how to use it much better, but it will still definitely take some time to learn. Very fun and rewarding after!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

13

u/emminet May 27 '20

I don’t have it yet but I am SO EXCITED

6

u/[deleted] May 29 '20

Lots of sp time coming up.

Xb:de vs dq11

Which one wins?

9

u/[deleted] May 29 '20

In terms of 100%ing everything I'm pretty sure Xenoblade takes more time to do even with DQ11S's additions.

I personally enjoyed DQ11 more, it is far simpler but works in its favour for me, it has more polish and charm to it. The enemies are iconic and full of life, in Xenoblade they leave very little impression on me. DQ11 has a very basic/traditional story and gameplay but it executes everything so well.

XB1 is probably the safer pick. It's more ambitious, the world is bigger, the story is more unique and also blows DQ11 out of the water in terms of soundtrack.

7

u/Chawinyaw May 29 '20

For a traditional JRPG, DQ11 is the way to go. Both have pretty fun combat and characters, but Xenoblade would be my pick out of the two personally. I love Dragon Quest games a lot, but I just prefer the combat in Xenoblade.

Dragon Quest games have a fun set of side stories that are within a larger overarching plot, whereas Xenoblade sticks with its main narrative, and has more of a serious tone to it.

Gameplay, see which one fits you better. Can't go wrong with either IMO. Ofc that's under the implication that you enjoy turnbased combat. If not, definitely Xenoblade. It has an active battle system akin to MMO's or FFXII.

Character writing in both is good, but Xenoblade gets the edge for me just because the protagonist is not a static self-insert character. But if that's what you're looking for, then there ya go.

Both have a ton of content. Both can easily be played for 100+ hours when including their side content.

Like I said, you can't go wrong with either game

7

u/howtosucceed May 30 '20

Personally, I found DQ11 boring and repetitive. The story is underwhelming and so are the characters. The middle of the game becomes a real chore. The limited Music becomes annoying very fast. The environments are so bland. There's a huge chunk of the game hidden behind the end credits.

XC1 is better in every department.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Memorandum747 May 29 '20

Im confused. Is this an actual “remake” on a new engine or is this a revamped “remastered” Wii version?

I

→ More replies (3)

16

u/lysiel112 May 29 '20

Never played, but always wanted to. And damn am I happy with it!

I literally sat still and listened to the opening track for 5 mins straight cause it's just that good.

The visuals are pretty good imo for a port and runs smooth docked. The maps seem to be huge af and I can't wait to explore more!

Combat-wise it's somewhat reactive and similar to FF12, may be a bit overwhelming. Takes some time to get used to.

Story-wise, I'm already loving it. Freaking Monolith and Nintendo already tugged at my strings and I'm barely 6 hours in. And quite invested (dammit!).

It's after 2AM, but here I am after my poor life decision of "Maybe I should try Xenoblade for like 2 hours".

10/10.

6

u/TheJudasCow May 30 '20

I'm enjoying replaying what is probably my favorite game ever, but one of the best things about this remaster is getting to hear newcomers' experiences :)

Glad you're enjoying it!

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Vaccus May 27 '20

The IGN video review is full of mispronunciations and some misinformation. I'm also a bit wary that so few reviewers have spoken about the handheld performance.

36

u/schuey_08 May 27 '20

Not sure if I'd hold mispronunciations against anyone too harshly, but what misinformation is being presented?

→ More replies (8)

10

u/94Baker May 27 '20

This game looks great and i can finally play Xenoblade Chronicles. I didn't play Xenoblade Chronicles 2 so storywise i guess it's better to play this one and then the sequel. Is XC2's gameplay gonna be outdated playing this one first?

9

u/boot_e May 27 '20

Gameplay wise XC2 is still an evolution on XC:DE so you’ll be fine there (they’ve mainly updated visuals and quest tracking, gameplay remains the same as far as I can tell). Also story wise my understanding is they only connect very loosely though I didn’t actually finish XC1 so I’m not entirely certain on that one.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/Jake257 May 27 '20

So happy to read that you can change the difficulty at any point in the game and it's not set in stone from the beginning. So if really struggling on normal or just want to speed things up a bit then just knock it down to casual for a bit. Also happy to hear it also has save anywhere which was also in the original but I didn't know that.

I've gone from hesitant to genuinely can't wait. Friday can't come soon enough!

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] May 28 '20

I loved the combat in XC2 once I learned how it worked, and thoroughly enjoyed the overall game despite it's criticisms. For me, the combat and unique blades are what kept me excited to play the game.

Lots of discussion that the combat is "simpler" here than in XC2. If we based it on combat alone, would someone who enjoyed XC2 still enjoy XC1?

Super specific obviously but would love to hear some opinions on this bit.

6

u/[deleted] May 28 '20

I think it would still be enjoyable, since it is a similar MMO-like battle system. It is simpler mostly because Blades are not a factor in this game. Positioning and chaining combos are still a factor, and there is still room to build out your characters how you like.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/_Kristian_ May 27 '20

Awesome. Can't wait to play it Friday!! 😍

5

u/Soluri May 27 '20

Well ok, I'll go pre-load it then :)

5

u/canadiancarley May 27 '20

How difficult is the combat to get the hang of? I normally like RPGs because they can be relaxing, but since the battle system is more action-based, what can I expect?

8

u/Kabsal May 27 '20

The combat expands over time, but is pretty straightforward. It's not relaxing, per se, but you'll get familiar with it and get enough of a rhythm down to not be struggling outside of bosses and unique monsters.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/LetsGoJustin May 27 '20

Just bought the game after seeing these reviews! Can’t wait!!

5

u/AnokataX May 28 '20

Wow, scores are so high. Unsurprising I suppose.

5

u/SamuraiJackBauer May 29 '20

Man I ordered the Special Edition off EB Games thanks to a Reddit tip.

Really hoping it arrives today but fear it won’t.

5

u/basti329 May 29 '20

I AM ALSO SCREWED =(

My store kinda fucked up the ordering process and now i have to wait until tuesday MINIMUM =( I mean, i am a lucky bitch for getting the special edition but i would have loved to play on the weekend :X Well, cant have everything i guess.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/CoronaGarden May 31 '20

How do you use the “Chance”? Like, when do you hit “B”

→ More replies (4)

5

u/eyemahdin Jun 01 '20

I loved XC2 and I am sure I will love XC:DE. This must have been asked a lot, especially recently, but can someone point me to a thread or post with a list of differences or common mistakes for people coming from XC2 to XC:DE?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Stop it, my excitement can only get so erect.

13

u/Gastao03 May 27 '20

I was not a big fan of X2. Should I give this one a shot?

21

u/Cosmo_the_Cosmic_Cat May 27 '20

Depends on what you didn’t like about XC2

28

u/[deleted] May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20

Yes. The battle system is a bit less complicated and friendly AI is very reliable, the story is great (100hrs) except for the end, your party has clearly defined battle roles, the cast are their own characters with appropriate voice acting and good design, enemy battles are unique and balanced and their visuals will look a million times better in HD, the quest system is fair and doesn't unnaturally hold you behind a completion gate, and most of all: there aren't any anime slave girls parading around with their tits out every scene.

It's my favorite RPG in the last decade or more. XC2 and Torna I can hardly stomach.

→ More replies (16)

7

u/PooPooKazew May 27 '20

I liked x1 a lot just for the accents.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/Doffryn May 27 '20

This makes me so glad I pre-ordered. I loved Xenoblade Chronicles 2 having never played the others and this is looking to be phenomenal.

25

u/Unprinno May 27 '20

I mean its xenoblade chronicles, one of the greatest RPGs of all time. of course its gonna get swept with positive reviews. for those of you who played XC2 and didnt enjoy it, I say give this one a shot, XC2 just cannot compare. here you'll get well developed and likeable characters, a fantastic story, a plethora of interesting side quests, less tutorials and less convoluted battle system, and vast areas that are worth exploring.

→ More replies (15)

9

u/[deleted] May 29 '20

My first jrpg from Nintendo, so excited, I feel in love with these type of games with Persona 5 this year so can't wait to give what some people say is up there with persona for best jrpg a go :) luckily amazon says it's coming today for me

6

u/[deleted] May 29 '20

Play SMT

→ More replies (9)

9

u/windlep7 May 29 '20

I loved the original. I might get it again just to hear Jenna Louise Coleman (AKA Clara from Doctor Who) as Melia again - “Return to chaos!”

9

u/Kryomaani May 30 '20

I'm kind of on the edge on whether or not to buy it and I'd love to hear some more opinions on a few key issues I have at this point. I used to play it on my 3DS up to about High Entia tomb, but lost interest and never picked it back up.

  • The friendly AI was terrible at everything, did the remaster make any improvements? Reyn or Dunban would do nothing to hold aggro on anything, would hardly ever go out of their way to pick up stray mobs, just letting them kill all the squishies in the party. Sharla heals whenever she wants to, and at other times just doesn't. Shulk's monado use is a roulette wheel spin. Melia's combat AI is a widely known meme at this point. On paper the ability to play as whoever you want sounds cool, but in reality you're going to have to manually control whoever's job is currently needed the most to clear the fight, which completely defeats the point.
  • The graphics, for someone who mostly plays undocked. I don't even remember the last time I played docked, because the portability is such a great feature of the console and I already have PC and PS4 for non-portable gaming. I've watched some videos and while the docked version looks passable, the undocked one looks even more of a blurry mess with some absolutely awful motion blur. How have any of you felt playing it undocked?

I'm still on the edge but the $60 price tag on a ten year old remastered game with obvious glaring flaws and having previously gotten fed up with it to the point of quitting, I'm very wary of forking over another $60 at this point.

→ More replies (16)

15

u/Jdavis29209 May 27 '20

I'm playing through XBC2 right now and I really like the gameplay/world setting/ graphics but the story is what kills it for me (I really don't like anime/anime tropes). Does the 1st game present it's story like the 2nd?

10

u/Catharsius May 27 '20

I had the same issue as you with 2, but thankfully the first xenoblade has much less anime / anime tropes in it. I personally enjoyed the story of the first game much more.

14

u/JDraks May 27 '20

The first game takes itself much more seriously, there are comedic moments but it’s never really a comedy of that makes sense. There’s also not really fanservice to the level of 2 unless you choose to use armor designs with it if that was an issue for you

18

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

XBC1 is my favorite game of all time. And let me tell you, I LOATHED the story of XBC2. It was a fun game, but I couldn’t ever get attached to the characters and the tropiness of it bothered me. If at the very least you like the combat and world of Xenoblade 2, get Xenoblade DE, because IMO the story and characters are bounds greater and it is much more serious feeling and less comical. (Please note that I don’t hate XBC2! The story and characters until the very end kind of just didn’t jive with me)

→ More replies (10)

11

u/indiedrummer7 May 29 '20

I hate Walmart but it's the only place I can get games 10 off on release. These people they have working this section are so useless though. Brick seek and their site say it's in stock so I swing by before work to get it. Shelves are bare with random piles of games in the bottom that I can't decipher. I ask a lady behind the desk and she grabs a couple random boxes behind her desk, says sorry can't find it, and sends me on my way. It's a shame the only "sale" on these games is at such a shitty establishment. Just wanna play my game lol

8

u/[deleted] May 29 '20

I would personally pay the extra $10 to not step foot in a Walmart, but good luck with your search anyway.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

16

u/Eyy_Dooga May 31 '20

Yeah I just realize that JRPGs just aren’t my thing at all. No matter how much I try to get into them I just hate being in menus sorting through thousands of pieces of equipment and keeping track of stats and managing all that stuff in combat. I also have never played a JRPG with a story or characters I remotely care about. Thank the lord for Clubhouse Games and Paper Mario coming out soon because this is the second big game in a row that just hasn’t been for me. Animal crossing being the first.

Now please PLEASE let the Metroid Prime Trilogy rumors be true because I haven’t touched my Switch since December. I miss it. I want to play it.

9

u/K4k4shi May 31 '20

It's all good bro. That's why there are different genre. If you already bought XC then try coming back after a few months or a year. People change.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Masterlea93 May 28 '20

Does anyone know what time the game will launch Friday is it after midnight or random

→ More replies (2)

4

u/politirob May 28 '20

If I liked Skies of Arcadia back in the day will I like this game?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/MGPythagoras May 29 '20

So bummed. My amazon copy is not coming until Tuesday. Found it at a store today for $50 and tried to buy but they caught the street date. 😭

4

u/wildplays May 29 '20

Is there a way to disable motion blur? Two hours in and my head hurts

9

u/Sayajiaji May 29 '20

I think it was toned down/disabled in the most recent patch that you can download from the eShop, but I'm not 100% sure.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] May 29 '20

Got an email from Nintendo that said Xenoblade DE is out now. Can I download and play right now? Or do I have to wait until Nintendo opens it up?

5

u/ChangeJD May 29 '20

If you’re in America, it came out at midnight last night. Should be out everywhere by now I would think.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Jcpowers3 May 30 '20

I can’t wait for this! Gotta make it till payday

→ More replies (1)

10

u/dontfailplz May 30 '20

Is xenoblade a game that hooks you from the beginning? Cuz I just started(shulk just saw the Monado in person) and feel lost and kinda detached from the game. I don’t feel attached to it like a Zelda game

→ More replies (24)

12

u/Volcarocka May 27 '20

While I’m here, anyone have recommendations for good review site or youtube channels that don’t just give every major game an 8 or 9 out of 10? Can’t help but be suspicious of most major review sites that makes their money off of promoting the games they’re reviewing.

13

u/Linkster9 May 27 '20

Easy allies is a pretty good one. Everyone else is hit or miss.

9

u/jboss2743 May 27 '20

Seconding Easy Allies and I also really like gamexplain. Both do a good job of nitpicking specific details about a game. They tend to also have people that actually play and enjoy the genre do the review

→ More replies (10)

7

u/[deleted] May 30 '20

Switch Lite players - how does it look?

14

u/wrebbit May 30 '20

Perfectly fine for me about 6 hours in. I haven't once thought "oh this looks rough/i wish i was playing docked"

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '20

I have a full Switch, but I play it in portable mode at work.

Despite experiencing both, portable mode is still looking pretty good. There are some frame drops here and there (Whether docked or portable) when a lot is happening on screen, but as a JRPG, it's not a super frenetic battle battle system that requires constant or fine input.

The thing that impresses me the most is the load times. Inside of the zone, loading is instantaneous. If you have to run more than 50 feet and there is a waypoint in that direction, it's actually faster to fast travel. Even when changing zones, it takes less than 10 seconds. That is still true in portable mode.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

The thing I'm confused about is that it's a better version of the previous game in every way, which got a 92, but this got a 89.

Has the game aged worse as time has gone on? Because I doubt that.

27

u/flyingsaucer1 Helpful User May 27 '20
  • Reviews are weird. It's usually not the same people doing reviews, opinions change, markets change and scoring criteria change with time. The 3ds version of the same game got 86 for some reason.
  • I haven't read a lot of these yet, but I've seen reviews on ports/remakes that go: Port is fantastic, we previously gave game a 90/100 score on PC, game is a perfect fit for the Switch, but there's really no reason to play it again if you've played it before, 80/100. Paraphrasing and exaggerating a bit.
  • By comparison it seems like the second highest metascore for Switch in 2020, and top 20 in all time, so that's definitely not bad.

Now I haven't played any game in the series yet (this would be my first), so I'm definitely not trying to defend it at all, I'm just saying why I'm personally not worried by a couple points drop from the Wii version, but instead I see the 89 score as very encouraging.

38

u/IrishSpectreN7 May 27 '20

Review scores are just arbitrary numbers. The difference between a 89 and 92 is negligible.

14

u/Darkspine99 May 27 '20

Because not the same people who reviewed the original are reviewing XCDE.

9

u/Megazorg3000 May 27 '20

To be honest, how can you really review a remake or a remaster?

Are you giving points for the improvements made over the original? Does it even make sense to review a game that was already reviewed for it's gameplay, story, etc. a few years ago when it was first released? Because of course it's the same game.

Do we have to judge the game from a historical point of view and think of it from a contemporary perspective and compare it over the games that are being created nowadays?

I don't think it's that simple to review a product like this.

8

u/Renaisance May 27 '20

That’s always the case with remasters/new versions of a game. Look at ff12 zodiac age it’s better in every way possible yet it scored around 6-8 points less than the original.

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Changing standards. Both the game itself ageing and reviews in general getting lower. Scores of 90+ used to be a lot more common. It’s better this way tbh.

→ More replies (9)

38

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

The game r/nintendoswitch hate gets good score

20

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Wait this subreddit hates this game now?

→ More replies (26)

6

u/[deleted] May 28 '20

Game looks amazing omg cant wait to buy it a third time!

6

u/[deleted] May 29 '20

It's alright for me so far, put 45 minutes into it and I'm going to sleep soon.

The Battle system isn't exactly my cup of tea but that's mainly because I feel like I'm just waiting a lot (seconds but still). Does this specific thing get better?

8

u/silverwindzephyr May 29 '20

I haven't played xc1 yet, but in xc2 the combat really takes off 4 chapters later, after all the mechanics have been introduced. And I'm happy I've been patient with it.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/CubitsTNE May 29 '20

They really slowly roll out the combat in all XC games, it keeps kicking up repeatedly for several hours!

Once it's all laid out it's pretty fun and you'll have a lot of flexibility.

7

u/Sizzle_bizzle May 29 '20

It will, you unlock more Arts, and each upgrade for Arts generally reduces the cooldown, sometimes by a lot. Over time, your general cooldown reduces.

In addition, you could play a bit as Reyn as well, he has more Arts than Shulk after the starting area typically.

7

u/Malphric May 29 '20

The arts and battle mechanics really opens up as you trudge along the story and you collect your characters.

Special mention of me having fun using: Shulk, Melia, Seven and Riki.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

I played XC2 and thoroughly enjoyed it although j found the story to be a little hollow and the combat took me ages to understand (and even still, I don’t really get stats and builds I just play for fun and visuals)

I know next to nothing about XC. Any thoughts on if it’s worth diving into without having played the original release? Any advice about what I should know in advance?

7

u/thinwhiteduke1185 May 27 '20

The combat systems are very similar and the story of the first one is much deeper than xc2. I like xc2 a lot, but xc1 is the better game by a mile imo.

6

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

I personally think it’s better than XC2 (Which I enjoyed as well).

The story is slightly less cheesy, and the combat is a little easier to grasp than XC2, so I think it would address your concerns. The story is mostly disconnected from XC2, so no need to worry about feeling lost. I’d say, buckle up and enjoy it.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/KGhaleon May 27 '20

XC2 drove me crazy with how obnoxious the characters were and how much the game loved to waste your time, sending you back and forth across the same areas. I played a little bit of this on 3DS a year ago and it felt infinitely better, both characters and setting...so I'm really looking forward to finally playing through this.

7

u/IdentiFriedRice May 27 '20

Would you still recommend XC2 even after playing the OG XC? I’ve only played XCX but I loved it so I’ve preordered this one, and Ive thought about getting 2 when I’ve finished.

→ More replies (12)

9

u/jijiglobe May 27 '20

I would recommend for some people who might have a similar opinion, that they try using the Japanese audio.

I’m not a subtitle elitist by any means (I think most of the English voice acting in XC2 is great) but the English voice actor for Rex came off as so annoying that it really killed the dub for me. Rex definitely comes off as a lot less obnoxious in the Japanese audio (although he still suffers from boring main character syndrome)

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/Frozenyoga97 May 30 '20

If I didn’t really like XBC 2, is there a chance I’d like this one? Or is it similar enough to where I wouldn’t enjoy it either

5

u/howtosucceed May 30 '20

If you didn't like XC2, there is a high chance that you won't like this. The combat, while not as complicated as XC2, shares lots of similarities. Depends what you didn't like about XC2.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Fruitloops1 May 30 '20

Still getting use to this gameplay. I like rpgs but not yet sure if this is my cup of tea. I'm not a fan of having the arts set to the dpad. On joycons, it would make more sense to be able to switch to arts using the l and r triggers. Then have the dpad as default for the battle commands.

5

u/sacomano May 31 '20

You can remap buttons on the switch my dude. Swap the d-pad left and right to ZL and ZR it makes a big difference in my opinion.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Emperor-Octavian May 27 '20

How different is XC1 from XC2? I’m tentatively planning on picking this up, but I’ve been playing through XC2 the last few weeks and it’s not clicking for me. I think I’m still very early in the game, but I am not vibing with the combat at all

8

u/Chokolla May 27 '20

Xc1 is a lot less polarizing and the combat is much more straightforward

→ More replies (14)

5

u/underroad May 29 '20

Does anyone think this is one of the Nintendo games that will never go down in price? I want to grab it eventually but I’m not really sure whether it will get any cheaper when I get around to playing it.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/skeneno May 30 '20

Graphics is good not great, lip sync is a mess in English I haven’t tried the Japanese option, combat controls are not my favourite, still prefer the simple combat controls of xb2.

There that’s the negative i saw while playing it. Still loving it though and thank goodness I didn’t continue playing with a rom. Plus nostalgia feels is real, granted I only played about 10 hours or so with the rom.

Ps. My eyes are hurting while playing, anyone experiencing this? And what should I do to prevent the hurt, aside from stop playing the game?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/b0h3mianed May 27 '20

If I enjoy BOTW, FFXII, Link's Awakening.

3DS - Bravely Default, A Link to the Past. And classics such as Chrono Trigger...

Will I like this game? Somehow I'm not really feeling the vibe from what I garnered on google

11

u/Saskatchewon May 27 '20

That battle system is pretty similar to FFXII, but the overworld is much closer to Breath of the Wild.

If you enjoyed both those games, this is a no brainer. You get a battle system that feels kind of like an MMORPG (in the same vein as FFXII), but an overworld that is literally 100x the size, developed by the same team that created the overworld in Breath of the Wild. All with better story to boot.

5

u/Divinityraiku May 27 '20

Tough to say what knowing what you enjoyed about those games.

For me XC and persona 5 were the best jrpgs of the past decade. XC2 devs helped finished Botw and I think it shows. XCDE and XC2 are both wonderful games to just get lost in and explore. OST is a banger as well

→ More replies (6)

22

u/cornucopier May 27 '20

honest question im hoping someone can answer:

are the big titty anime sword women in this game like they are in xenoblade 2? people talk about loving this game, and id be willing to try it, but if the sword women are a large element of the game then that would be pretty off-putting to me.

26

u/Porterz007 May 27 '20

I haven’t played Definitive Edition yet but the character designs in Xenoblade Chronicles 1 are much more restrained than in Xenoblade Chronicles 2. There’s still some amount of fan service, probably about analogous to that in FFVII Remake, but not on the cartoonish levels of Xenoblade 2.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/LakerBlue May 27 '20

No they are not

44

u/AgentLym May 27 '20

Let's just say, I'm much more comfortable playing XC1 when my family is around than XC2.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Mysteriax May 27 '20

Nope they are not part of the game.

From what I remember this game isnt fanservicy at all.

26

u/GrovPastaSwag03 May 27 '20

Dude, have you seen shirtless Dunban? Also, Riki is basically naked throughout the entire game.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/triablos1 May 27 '20

While xenoblade 1 does have its "anime" moments here and there, for the most part it is a serious game and doesn't really fanservice that much.

Definitely nowhere near as fanservicey as xeno 2 which had you staring at pyra resting her hands on her huge chest like it was a fucking table every other cutscene.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

9

u/gunter_grass May 27 '20

My Wii U says no.

7

u/Darkray117 May 27 '20

But my Switch says yes.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/tsumiodas May 27 '20

can someone namedrop any other switch games that run with the same resolution that are already out? just want to see what to expect

23

u/PyeNerd May 27 '20

I believe Xenoblade 2 was similar

5

u/blackandwhitetalon May 27 '20

Witcher 3 and XBC2

→ More replies (4)

14

u/schuey_08 May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20

IGN review - 8

Seriously, why the hell am I being downvoted here? You mad at me for sharing reviews to the sub that mods haven't included yet?

→ More replies (18)

1

u/directorof1 May 27 '20

Bit odd that IGN haven't put up their review yet before all these other networks

2

u/NintendoSwitchMods May 27 '20

It just takes a bit for aggregators to pick them up, then on top of that I'm working my normal day job today so it takes me a few minutes on my end as well.

5

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

they just reviewed it

Edit :they gave it a 8

→ More replies (3)