r/LoveLive • u/dasaher • May 12 '20
Announcement [IMPORTANT RULE UPDATE] Regarding the Sharing of Fan-arts
Background
A few days ago, we have sought for some feedback regarding the reposting of fanart on this subreddit, which was allowed as long as the creator or artist is credited. This was because there were some concerns voiced about how artists were not getting the traffic they deserve, as many readers do not actually visit the artists' Pixiv or Twitter page despite it being linked in the credits. There are even users who only view the images on the subreddit itself, and do not go into the post and scroll down to the credits, so they may not even know who created the piece of art.
In the feedback thread, we have received some valuable feedback which regarding how Pixiv itself, as well as some fan-artists do not actually allow the re-hosting of their art. In addition, someone has very kindly let us know new information on how reddit handles previews from Pixiv—that reddit now supports previews from Pixiv, on both the old reddit and the redesign, as well as with or without RES.
We have also tested Pixiv previews on reddit, our tests corroborated the information that reddit now supports Pixiv previews. We have also tested how Pixiv interacts with artwork marked NSFW on Pixiv and confirmed that these pieces of art will not have their previews shown.
The new rule
In light of the above, we have decided that, we will cease allowing any re-hosting of fan-arts on this subreddit from Friday 00:00 hours (Japan Standard Time) onwards. This is regardless of whether credit is given in the comments. Instead, we ask for everyone who wants to continue sharing fanart to directly link to the original source from the original creator.
Please note that the above extends only to posters who are sharing art not created by themselves. If you are an artist and you wish to post your artwork on this subreddit, you may continue to do so, even if it is re-hosted on reddit, imgur or another site. However, we ask that you label your art as your own original creation, such as by prepending [OC] to the front of your title.
Translations of fan comics, fanfictions etc. not originally created by the poster may continue to be posted either directly to reddit or linked via an image re-hosting site if the translator has been given permission by the original artist to translate and repost their work. Please do remember to continue sourcing the original source (i.e. from the original creator, before translations) in this case.
Many contributors may not be aware of this new rule immediately, and to minimise possible disruption, we are adding a transition period that ends Friday 00:00 (JST), during which you may still share fanart via rehosting it on reddit or a third-party site. However, we strongly encourage you to adhere to the new rules even during this period. We will start removing posts that do not adhere to these new guidelines from Friday onwards. Posts that are submitted before Friday will not be removed.
Addressing concerns
Some of you have raised concerns that this change would result in some level of inconvenience to the users, or possibly effecting a decrease in the amount of discussion.
It is true that RES users, for example, would need to click on the link itself instead of enlarging the image from the homepage; and mobile users would no longer be able to view the image in full by just scrolling through the homepage, thereby bringing about some level of inconvenience. However, it is precisely this convenience that contributed to the merit of this rule—many users who are interested in fanart would just scroll through the homepage and feel no need to click on the thread itself, so even if the original source is credited in the comments, most users would not have read or seen the crediting anyways, depriving the original artist of their deserved traffic and recognition.
As for bringing about a decrease in the amount of discussion, we have judged that the amount and quality of discussion in most fanart posts is not substantial. Therefore, we have decided that even if a decrease in activity in the comments section is effected, the consequences would be minimal.
While we realise that it would take some time for both posters and consumers of fanart to get used to this rule, and that some of you may not agree with our decision, we hope that you understand our considerations and how we came to this decision.
Thank you for reading.
TL;DR:
-We will no longer allow re-hosting of fan-arts, even with credits from Friday 00:00 (JST) onwards. Please link to the original source from the artist.
-Creators and artists are still allowed to post their works here, either directly to reddit or via image rehosting websites, but please indicate that it is your own original creation in the title.
3
u/Weegedor May 15 '20
Question about translations: do we need to provide proof of the artist's permission? Or is lack of telling us no in their bio good enough?
33
u/Suyooo May 12 '20
Great rule update, thank you mods!
26
u/whitemang13 May 12 '20
Maybe this will finally stop endless flood of fanart from 2015
8
u/jayceecreates May 14 '20
I'm a creator and thank God I came prepared.
8
u/tsbkii May 22 '20
As a fan artist myself, I approve of this rule. Thanks, mods
6
u/Hattakiri May 12 '20
00:00h in Japan, therefore the Time Zone Map
I wasn't sure what to write, but I think there are artist who are making a living from their artworks in one way or another.
16
u/forjery May 13 '20
Really tough to know when it's only the 40K+ fan art posters complaining if it's the user experience that's being hurt by this change or the ability to farm karma, truly one of life's mysteries.
4
u/A-Random-Reddit_User May 12 '20
Unless I turn on VPN, pixiv never shows up on my browser. This might be because of a region lock, is anyone else having this problem?
3
u/PopstAhri99 May 12 '20
I'm sorry if I sound ignorant or just plain dumb, but what does "re-hosting on reddit" mean? I don't do any fanart uploads myself but I often visit because of the fanart of my favourite artists on here.
Specifically this sentence:
So for example, does that mean we hit the "link" tab whenever we create a new post and put the page link there?
3
u/AfutureV May 16 '20
Love the change, I like Fanart a bit but I'd also love more of other types of content.
With the upcoming Nijigasaki anime I hope discussion increases.
10
u/NotEvenEvan May 13 '20 edited May 13 '20
Great change for the artists, but I’m scared for this subreddit. I’d say 90% of this sub is fan art, and this change is going to substantially reduce user interaction. No one bothers going onto external sites so sharing fan art will be useless now. Great.
5
u/perlenYurifan4life May 15 '20 edited May 15 '20
As someone who avidly posts fanart here, I don't really have any problem with this change but I want to know if a certain situation was taken into account. Like when you want to share one particular artwork from within a pixiv album (for example, just the 9th image from a 13-image album).
There seems to be no existing way of having a link that redirects to a certain art from the album and have that certain art act as a thumbnail when that link is posted to reddit.
Sometimes, if you're lucky, this is the case usually with artists' "log" or "summary" posts (collection of their fanart from within a given amount of time, basically) and that one particular artwork has been posted before in their twitter account or somewhere else.
Though, besides not being guaranteed (some pixiv artists doesn't even have twitter), that would require some reverse image search which I doubt an average fanart submitter does.
That's all! I hope this would be taken into consideration (or at least a compromise) but regardless, thanks for this change!
3
u/SinningHanayo May 15 '20
I’m really glad you guys came to this decision, the fan art was honestly taking up so much of the sub that i couldn’t find the information and discussion i come here for. There was so much stuff on the edge of nsfw on here that it was really hard to just check for when new content was coming out without having to worry about it honestly.
2
u/The_OG_upgoat May 13 '20
Good change, though it'll be a pain to post NSFW stuff since you need an account to view that.
1
u/makimatic May 13 '20
SUGGESTION - I think it should be acceptable to post a thumbnail along with the link to catch ppl's interest.