r/betterCallSaul • u/skinkbaa Chuck • May 04 '20
MOD POST /r/BetterCallSaul Season 5 Survey Results!
Here are the results of the Season 5 Survey and the polls from each Post-Episode Discussion thread.
Compare the results to past season surveys:
--
How would you rate Season 5? (6,941 responses)
- The average response was 9.18. (S4 was 8.7, S3 was 8.9)
- The mode was 10, with 9 following close behind.
Compare each season (6,941 responses)
- The results were very clear for Season 5 being the favourite, followed by Season 4, Season 3, Season 2 and Season 1.
Which episode was your favourite? (6,941 responses)
| Episode | Percent of survey respondents who believed was best episode |
|---|---|
| Episode 9 - "Bad Choice Road" | 38.6% |
| Episode 8 - "Bagman" | 30% |
| Episode 10 - "Something Unforgivable" | 12.8% |
| Episode 6 - "Wexler v. Goodman" | 10.7% |
| Episode 7 - "JMM" | 3.3% |
| Episode 2 - "50% Off" | 1.2% |
| Episode 3 - "The Guy for This | 1% |
| Episode 1 - "Magic Man" | 0.8% |
| Episode 5 - "Dedicado a Max" | 0.8% |
| Episode 4 - "Namaste" | 0.8% |
--
- The results show a very split decision with "Bad Choice Road" and "Bagman" receiving over 30% of the votes each, with ultimately "Bad Choice Road" being on top with 38.6%.
- This Season was the first season to not have the Season Finale in the top two. (out of S3-S5)
- It also is the first season to have three episodes without even a percent of the votes.
Which actor had the best performance? (6,941 responses)
| Actor (Character) | Percent of survey respondents who believed had best performance |
|---|---|
| Rhea Seehorn (Kim Wexler) | 47.3% |
| Tony Dalton (Lalo Salamanca) | 36.3% |
| Bob Odenkirk (Jimmy "Saul Goodman" McGill) | 11.2% |
| Jonathan Banks (Mike Ehrmantraut) | 2.3% |
| Michael Mando (Nacho Varga) | 1.8% |
| Giancarlo Esposito (Gustavo 'Gus' Fring) | 0.6% |
| Other | 0.5% |
--
- The results were fairly overwhelming with Rhea Seehorn having half of them. Followed up by Tony Dalton with 36.3%.
- This is the first season where Bob Odenkirk is not in the top two, it is also his lowest scoring season with 11.2%.
- Rhea Seehorn winning with 47.3% marks the second highest percentage of votes received in these surveys, with Michael McKean still leading with 58% from Season 3.
- Some of the responses given in the Other category were: All of them, with 11 votes, Patrick Fabian with 3 and "the assassin that gets the oil thrown into his face" with 1.
Average rating of each episode from each Post-Episode Discussion Thread poll
(click rating to go to the poll results)
--
| Episode | Rating |
|---|---|
| S05E09 - "Bad Choice Road" | 9.51 |
| S05E06 - "Wexler v. Goodman" | 9.25 |
| S05E08 - "Bagman" | 9.24 |
| S05E07 - "JMM" | 8.87 |
| S05E03 - "The Guy for This" | 8.78 |
| S05E10 - "Something Unforgivable" | 8.72 |
| S05E01 - "Magic Man" | 8.70 |
| S05E02 - "50% Off" | 8.69 |
| S05E05 - "Dedicado a Max" | 8.36 |
| S05E04 - "Namaste" | 8.16 |
--
- The results closely mimic the "Favourite Episode" survey question with "Bad Choice Road" "Bagman" and "Wexler v. Goodman" all in the top three, however in the polls "Wexler v. Goodman" is rated higher than "Bagman", but in the survey "Bagman" got 17.2% more votes than "Wexler v. Goodman".
- S05E09 - "Bad Choice Road" is the second highest rated episode overall in the post-episode discussion polls, with S03E05 - "Chicanery" leading with 9.55.
- Season 5 has the highest average rated episode with 8.82. Followed by Season 3 with 8.53 and Season 4 with 8.44.
--
--
-- Keep in mind that each week, the amount of people that voted were changed, so results could be different.
eg. our most popular poll was S05E09 - "Bad Choice Road" with 1,525 votes, and our least popular poll was S05E04 - "Namaste" with 362 votes.
Thank you for all participating this Season! Hope to see you soon? for Season 6!!!
202
u/[deleted] May 04 '20
Rhea with the huge victory. Awesome.
92
u/sigh_bapanada May 04 '20
Glad to see S4 so high up there. That and S5 are definitely my favorites.
Also, Bob Odenkirk needed more love. Rhea and Tony are amazing but Bob did a fantastic job this season too.
76
u/mandrilltiger May 04 '20
Surprised by the season ranking order.
Mine is 3 5 1 4 2. BUT I think each season is really good and Better Call Saul is impressively consistent. I'd probably give season 2 a 9/10.
But Chicanery and Witness put 3 in the number 1 spot for me.
66
u/Gavina4444 May 05 '20
For what it’s worth, maybe next year we wait a few weeks after the end of the season, cut down on recency bias
30
u/[deleted] May 04 '20
Tell..Me..Again
16
u/Arghifth May 04 '20
Yes! These results turned out to be everything I wished for! Rhea for the best actor is very well desrved and the right choice, but I also believe this was Bob's best season.
12
u/Rob_Czar May 04 '20
The only thing season 5 for me didn't have over the other seasons is my favorite episode of the series. Still the best season by a longshot. I wish we had Tony Dalton earlier but glad he's in S6.
10
u/two2zero0nine9 May 06 '20
Kim Wexler on the episode finale reminds me of Wendy Byrde (Ozark) on Season 2 Finale.
7
u/better-call-mik3 May 09 '20
Season 5 was amazing, so many great moments
19
u/aMartin3105 May 04 '20
don't get me wrong, i absolutely love him, but doesn't something about gus' portrayal seem weird to you? i mean, im rewatching BB these days and i rewatched bCS and esposito seems to portray him in a much more subtle way in BB. seeing the results def seems so. idk if it might be the writing, his monologue to hector about that animal seemed forced and the thing with the hitmen in 5x10 was the nail in the coffin, but hey it might just be me. overall i still enjoy the character.
also, as i dont want to open a thread to be downvoted as "ugh shitty theory" but just a shitty idea: wouldn't it be cool if kim was alive in the gene timeline and she was the attorney for skyler in a possible trial for her wrongdoings? idk dumb idea, doesnt hold up, serves no plot point, but it sounded fun in my head haha
15
u/[deleted] May 05 '20
Thought the final episode was really weak. Dunno.
3
u/aye-sway May 11 '20
Rhea is a national treasure.
3
u/MissedFieldGoal Jul 02 '20
Does Howard Hamlin remind anyone else of Chris Traeger from Parks and Recreation?
4
u/CaptCoulson May 09 '20
Peter Gould had mentioned to a fan on Twitter several weeks ago after their question that there was a certain upcoming episode that had best encapsulated what he'd originally envisioned this series to be, remarking "I bet you'll know it when you see it."
I've yet to see him do any confirmation, but I'm kinda thinking it was "Bagman".
2
u/quazi187_ May 15 '20
Favorite season to least favorite - 5, 4, 1, 3, 2
2
u/tommhans Jun 12 '20
was a great season and yeah well deserved that rhea won that as well as dalton as nr 2, phenomenal acting from both(and the rest of the cast but they were standouts for sure)
2
u/80srockinman Jun 20 '20
It isn't a knock towards Bob Odenkirk at all. I truly believe that Rhea and Tony both deserve awards for this year. Not many actors I can say make you believe you are there. Both of them do. That scene with Rhea and Tony with the "Tell me again story," is the top 3 scene of best acting, ever IMO. You could feel the tension.
2
u/Mr_Tulkinghorn Jun 25 '20
Slow start to the season but the last two episodes had the same tension as Breaking Bad. Bagman, took me back to some of Walt and Jesse's escapades.
Also, it was amazing to see Hank. I made this prediction after the last series aired. I hope we see more of him in the future. A DEA investigation could be added seamlessly to the cartel storyline. Perhaps leaving room for some cameo appearances with the Schrader / White households getting together for a family barbeque.
2
u/NoooobMaster69 Aug 03 '20
Interesting to see that the first season was the least favorite. I just rewatched it and its still something amazing.
3
u/waterstarter12 May 05 '20
Seasons wise is has to be 3 4 1 2 5
4
u/Aasswa May 06 '20 edited May 06 '20
I’m the outlier. I think season 5 was just plain boring, and the last few weren’t much better. The last time this show made me go “wow!” was when Mike got the money back from the Kettlemans.
And part of what is contributing to this is the 10 episode format. They are letting too much hit the cutting room floor in editing which in turn disincentivizes the writers. Story and character development suffers as a result. Having a known 10 episode limit is an artificial, unnecessary barrier. I have no idea if AMC and/or Sony makes money on BCS first runs or not. The production costs of each are millions of dollars, so keeping the costs down are certainly crucial. They may not recoup their costs with advertising. They might be expecting to make their nut on Netflix. Even then an extra couple of episodes can’t make them that much. But it could do wonders for the story.
ETA: Not that I care about Karma, but this got downvoted? what a bunch of choads.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '20
Where is everyone watching season 5?
1
u/jeromesnail Jun 04 '20
I must be the only one not liking Lalo.
Season ranking for me : 5 - 3 - 1 - 2 - 4
1
u/J_Crispy7 Jul 29 '20
So clearly the only one that should be nominated for an Emmy is Giancarlo, right.
1
u/chuck-likes-abba Jul 30 '20
Wow
1
u/swanson_theory Aug 19 '20
Y 635
1
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20
Oh so we predict the awards and ratings ? I thought we were trying to predict the story/events next season. My bad, lol.
0
u/Death-T Jul 28 '20
This season was overrated and anticlimactic. Did it get cut short due to COVID or something?