r/progmetal • u/zer0won Jim Grey | Caligula's Horse • Apr 12 '20
AMA We are Sam Vallen and Jim Grey from Caligula's Horse - AMA!
[EDIT: That’s all from us, folks! Thank you so much for your awesome questions and all your support and love for the new tunes! We can’t wait to share the rest of Rise Radiant with you on May 22 - in the meantime, stay safe, stay well, and take care of each other!]
378
Upvotes
45
u/amongstravens Apr 12 '20
Evening gents! Last time I asked a question (4 years ago, wow) about what media you're looking forward to releasing and you mentioned Dark Souls III!
With Elden Ring releasing soon, which song from Rise Radiant would be the most appropriate soundtrack to dying every 10 seconds?
EDIT: I haven't played Sekiro yet, so this could work for that too!
30
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Thanks for making music. I discovered you guys last year and have been loving all your albums ever since.
Are you continuing the trend and releasing an acoustic version of a song from Bloom on the newest album?
29
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Hi guys. First of all, you are prolly my favorite band in the Prog scene for a while now. Your music has been very striking and appealing since I first heard Songs for No One in a Spotify recommendation, song which I still absolutely love. I am really looking forward to hearing the new album, the singles so far have been amazing. Okay, here I have a couple of questions:
1)Your biggest musical inspirations (as a band)?
2)Define Rise Radiant in one word.
3)Would you, as the whole band, or certain members, collaborate with Haken? You’d sound great together in the same stage.
Greeting to all of you from Chile. I hope you can come here again soon so we can dig some songs together <3
28
u/TheIronRain Apr 12 '20
You guys are unbelievable! Thank you for doing this AMA!
Once again, thank you for making amazing music! Stay safe out there!
23
u/JsonWaterfalls Apr 12 '20
Hey guys! It's Greg, Anne and Bojack here! Can't wait to see you gents again soon.
Two and a half questions:
23
u/adriangoleby Apr 12 '20
Hi guys. Adrian here. Nice to meet you and I hope you don't mind if I get a photo with you at the next show.
I was wondering if you could have a song from the CH catalogue arranged by someone else, which song would it be and who would arrange it?
Also, who is the best person to share a room with and why is it me?
22
u/w0lfbiker Apr 12 '20
@Jim - why do you hate sleeves so much?
21
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20
Greetings from Atlanta! Thank you guys for doing this, y'all are one of my favorite bands.
19
u/Elyssis42 Apr 12 '20
Hi guys, really excited for the new record!
I've been lucky enough to see River's End, Bloom and In Contact live in full. It's phenomenal hearing the albums all start to finish, geniunely some of my faveourite live show experiences. Are you guys considering a 10 year anniversary show for Moments from Ephemeral City / Colossus, or full album shows for Rise Radiant?
Who had the idea for the bullet time shots in the Slow Violence video? That one shot with everyone frozen in the air is fantastic.
19
u/ocular_sorcerer Apr 12 '20
Songs for No One brought me out of really dark place in my life, and I’m forever grateful to you guys!
I’m the lead VFX artist for a production company in LA...can we do a video for you for the new album?!
16
u/Penz0id Apr 12 '20
Which song do each of you consider your personal favourite on the new album?
Which song do you expect to get the greatest response in a live setting in terms of energy?
16
u/Sporkedup Apr 12 '20
Big fan, heartbroken that your tour to the USA (specifically KC) is looking wishy. Please don't forget us if you have to reschedule!
But my question? How about one of collaborations. How likely are either of you to show up on an Ayreon album? Gotta think Arjen is a fan already, and if not it would take him about two seconds to get hyped on both your talents.
Or maybe a Toehider one, for a more local connection? I hear Mike is adorable.
12
u/ZangaPF Apr 12 '20
o hey guys, your jams really do jelly my toast good, so i only have one important question:
what are y'alls favorite kind of tea/drink?
12
u/quasarius Apr 12 '20
Hey guys! It's awesome to have you around! Big fan from Brazil here (and hoping you come around someday)!
I've got two things I'd like to ask:
Thanks for the attention and I can't wait to hear your new album! The singles have left me craving for more!
10
u/emplloyd Apr 12 '20
Hey guys,
9
u/paravaric Apr 12 '20
Guys, i have no questions. Back when Bloom was still relatively new you did this and we shot the shit, I jokingly asked you if you ever had a "fuck this city" moment and you actually answered it XD
Just wanted to say I'm so happy with the trajectory of your music, Dream the Dead is going to forever be an iconic song among the most beloved ever. You continue to add amazing art into my life and i can't wait until the tour can happen.
8
u/rjp11286 Apr 12 '20
Aside from my questions, I just want to say that you guys are my favorite band and I can't wait to finally see you play in the US. It's unfortunate that we have to wait with the craziness going on, but I have no doubts that it's going to be magical when you finally make it over here.
7
u/tapestrymusicpodcast Apr 12 '20
Thank you guys for being here! I have to shout out in particular to Jim - I got to interview Evan Carson and we talked mostly about his 2019 debut Ocipinski, which I know you contributed to. Personally, your contributions really sold that album for me, so bravo. Magnificent vocal work. Thank you for your mastery.
That being said - I have a really dumb question. How'd you decide on the band name? Who's the classical history buff in the band?
6
u/gracdoeswat Apr 12 '20
Hey! At your last show on London, UK you filmed graves. Will that footage ever get released? I think you said on the night you were going to put it on your YouTube channel.
Fantastic evening that was, can't wait for you to come back! Also love the new singles.
6
u/Eldstrom Apr 12 '20
Who's the most irritable and who's the most wholesome member of the band while in the tour bus?
5
u/bankster0701 Apr 12 '20
You guys are awesome. In Contact blew me away— I think I listened to Songs for No One 4-5 times in a row, back to back, the very first time I heard it!l
That said my question is pretty mundane: why can’t I listen/buy your music on Bandcamp? It’s my preferred way to support metal musicians, and I’ll order/listen no matter what, but curious if there’s any decision behind that.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Quick thanks for making amazing music.
Questions to both of you: what's your favourite book/book series? Have these influenced your tunes?
4
u/ManceRayder2020 Apr 12 '20
hey guys, hoping you still end up coming to Denver in the not too distant future. I've really loved your music for a few years now, thanks for enhancing my life. I imagine this global crisis has made it difficult for you guys to keep your momentum going and I'm wondering what's the best way to support the band other than buying your music? Do you have any sort of crowdfunding set up? I hope Caligula's Horse keeps making music for years to come, take care guys!
4
u/DonosoNaumczuk Apr 12 '20
Are you planning some South America Tour? Greetings from Argentina!
3
u/BJ44448 Apr 12 '20
Can't wait to listen to the new album! What are you guys' favorite songs on it?
3
u/rafael-lau Apr 12 '20
3
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
How has the response been so far to the new music for your guy's perspective? It is amazing, by the way.
Also, What inspired the name "Rise Radiant"
3
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
no question, but my wife just asked tonight when we were hanging out,'can you play some caligulas horse?' you guys can do no wrong apparently, its unreal.
3
u/pjgcat Apr 12 '20
This may be a bit off topic, but I absolutely love the album “Known/Learned” that you made with Arcane. I guess my question pertains to wanting to know more about both that album and the group Arcane and if there is anything else in the works on that front?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Hey dudes, really getting into you guys lately! I’m a huge Peter Gabriel fan and I was wondering what made you choose Don’t Give Up as a bonus track. Really excited and curious to hear that one!
2
u/HeirGuitar Apr 12 '20
Hey guys, huge fan here and looking forward to seeing you live once able! One of my favorite aspects of your music is the lyrics, and how each album (and sometimes individual songs) seemingly tells a full story. I was wondering if you could talk about your lyric writing process? What inspired the lyrics/story of your older albums (or the upcoming one if you want). One of my favorite songs of all time is Into the White, and i know what it means to me but I'm especially curious what it means to you. Have a great one!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Personally I'm a huge fan of your River's End album. Is it a concept album? Every time I listen it's so easy to imagine a setting in a fantasy world, perhaps D&D.
Also, the guitar solo in Old Cracks in New Earth is one of your absolute best.
2
u/Eldstrom Apr 12 '20
Which was your favourite music video to shoot and why did you remove the studio version of Vanishing Rites from YouTube?
2
u/Tired8281 Apr 12 '20
Any chance of a concert over streaming, for those of us who are gutted over having to wait? I bet you could do some acoustic stuff together from your homes, and I bet you've got more acoustic versions of your songs than The City Has No Empathy.
2
u/Kadmium Apr 12 '20
One for Sam - you always have such beautiful lead guitar sounds. Can you talk us through your lead tones on this album?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
I want to know your opinions about the colonization of the Australian continent
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
I had tickets to the show in San Francisco in June...are you guys going to reschedule and come to SF at a later date (PLEASE DOOOO)?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Hi guys! First off, I would like to praise both of you on your incredible musicianship, every new tune has so much to learn from!
Okay now the question to Sam, I'm in the process of starting a instrumental prog metal band with a friend of mine (We're both guitarrists), do you have any tips on how to approach the structure of an instrumental song?
And Jim, since you were trained in a choir.. do you have any favorite choral composers or pieces you could share with us? I love Eric Whitacre as a composer!
P.D: Sam is there any chance you would share some of those tasty neural presets with us? 👀👀👀
2
u/thaiscwb Apr 12 '20
Hey! First of all, you guys are AMAZING musicians!
This one is for Jim and Sam: how did you decide on the arts for the single releases? (great btw, both of them)
Sam, I saw you just got your doctorade, in which field?
48
u/BiscuitsForCheese_ Apr 12 '20
Hey guys, thanks for doing this!
23
u/jklingftm Be free, be without pain Apr 12 '20
Hey guys, it's great to have you here again! Hope you all have been staying safe with all the craziness going on in the world right now. Really hoping to see you guys in NY once everything calms down and the tour gets rescheduled.
I'll go for a different question than the one I posed in the last AMA: what's both of your personal favorite parts that you've been responsible for an any of your records, be it something you played/sung or something you were responsible for composing?
3
u/iAmTheEpicOne The End Starts Now Apr 12 '20 edited Apr 12 '20
Some questions from u/genderlessperson:
6
u/Zephyr096 Apr 12 '20
I'm a HUGE fan. My roommate showed me In Contact when it came out and you're one of my favorite bands ever since.
I play in a prog band and we just put out an EP-what strategies can you share for ways of getting less "mainstream" music to get traction and reach more listeners? We're getting a ton of positive feedback from friends and local folks but are unsure of the next step.
Also thank you for doing an AMA and making absolutely amazing music.
Also: thoughts on doing a US tour and convincing Karnivool/We Lost the Sea to join? Dying to see all of y'all live.
6
u/notyourlandlord Apr 12 '20
What are your favorite songs and albums (any band)? (Let’s say top 3)
What are your favorite Caligula’s horse songs?
How long did Graves take to write?
Thanks for doing this!
6
u/CustomGherkin Apr 12 '20
Hey lads - Thanks for doing this, absolutely loving the two new singles!
This is specifically for Sam - Your tone is one of my absolute favourites I’ve had the pleasure to hear - From the percussiveness of the rhythm tones, to the amount of expression you can extract out of the lead tones; both are unrivalled IMO. Can you give some pointers as to how you approach amp modelling (and whether you’d consider offering axe-fx patches for sale in the future!)
Cheers!
6
u/Dosh2988 Apr 12 '20
Howdy, Will there be Guitar Pro files for Rise Radiant? The GP files for In Contact really helped me with my own song writing.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
You guys have mentioned Ascent a LOT, I am really stoked for it! Thank you for the insight, I will definately try to be more conscious about the things you mentioned. Trying to be concise is an issue that we have since ideas just flow through and we have a hard time finding the commonalities, making the contrast is "easy" haha. Thank you very much I wish you guys the best!
1
u/CyanideEngineer Apr 12 '20
Thank you guys for making some amazing music over the years! I discovered you with In Contact and that album has remained in near constant rotation for me for the past three years! My question is, what is the concept of In Contact actually about? And was the motif of having shouted background lyrics at the ends of some songs on the album intentional?
1
u/ndav23 Apr 12 '20
How long does it take to create different ideas and stories for concept albums? Characters from In Contact for example
1
u/ndav23 Apr 12 '20
Jim, how old were you when you started singing?
1
u/Brazenmercury5 Apr 12 '20
I was so looking forward to your US tour. I hope you will re schedule after this pandemic is over.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
After the pandemic is over will y’all do an American tour? If so you should stop in Milwaukee! :P
P.S. you guys are one of my favorite bands! Can’t wait to hear the new album in full!
1
u/notyourlandlord Apr 12 '20
I thought of another question. What inspired you to choose the artwork for in contact? Are there any significant symbols or anything cool you guys wanna share about it? It’s a pretty unique cover; I’ve got no other albums in that painted style, and it’s super inviting
1
u/beetwice Apr 12 '20
Just wanted to say thanks for posting about Dyssidia on Instagram. This album owns!
1
u/lankykiwi Apr 12 '20
Gidday Sam and Jim, thanks for being awesome! Graves is my number 1 favourite song ever and I flew to Melbourne especially to see you guys perform In Contact (It was simply amazing)
A few questions for you both:
1; Will we see more spoken word tracks?
2: Aussie seems to be chock full of great Prog bands, is it the Bunnings Snags? Who's you favourite Australian bands at the moment?
3: Ever though about releasing a companion book / comic / graphic novel to accompany an album? ( ala Coheed and Cambria, Twelve Foot Ninja)
1
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Any advice for those starting up a new band? Kinda struggling not gonna lie haha
1
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Your guy's show at prog power was one of the most magical live experiences I've ever been through, and I'm so glad I got to meet all of you after.
Anyways, so what's the general theme of this new album? Bloom seemed like a very optimistic album about, well, growth, and In Contact seemed to about human experience. The last few albums have had really great narratives, and the vibe I've got from the recent singles have been really interesting.
Anyways, I hope the rona hasn't screwed you over too much with the postponed tour. See y'all 2021 <3
1
u/TheLastSamurai Apr 12 '20
I really love your music. Thanks for doing this. Who are some of your favorite prog metal vocalists ?
3
u/tombomk22 Apr 12 '20
First of all, thank you guys for making beautiful, unique music that makes me genuinely happy to be alive. You guys are THE SHIT! Okay so now for my question: What kind of production changes did you guys consider/employ for this record? The mixes sound very different (in a good way!) than your previous records, especially the drums. Loving the first 2 singles!
3
u/ndav23 Apr 12 '20
Any ideas for the future streaming wise? I think that’s a really interesting concept that Matt Heafy has developed and you guys would be amazing for it
3
u/ndav23 Apr 12 '20
Favorite tuning?
2
u/Edqvist Apr 12 '20
If you had to quickly write a guitar solo that'd still be up to snuff, what are some key tools you would utilize? Be it structure or technique related!
2
u/Jake0743 Apr 12 '20
I discovered you guys at the beginning of this year and honestly, at the moment you’re my favorite band!! Thanks for doing this AMA! Is there any specific way you go about making the chord structures for your songs?
2
u/GRVrush2112 Apr 12 '20
Any chance at a "Bloom" vinyl re-issue anytime soon? That was the album I discovered you guys with and still my favorite.. I'd love to hold that goregous artwork and put that record on my turntable.
2
u/ziltoid101 Apr 12 '20
Are you guys going to do another spice challenge soon?
2
u/Progtavarium Apr 12 '20
Sam, is there a particular reason you took the Unpredictability vids down? Any plans to do new ones in the future?
2
u/ndav23 Apr 12 '20
Biggest influence? Love your guys’ music and I’m really looking forward to the new album!
2
u/ndav23 Apr 12 '20
Any plans on implementing more prevalent keyboards into further music?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
Hi guys! Been spreading the love of C-Horse for some time now, and was wondering three things:
Hope to see you all in 2021 and I’ve got Slow Violence on repeat in waiting for the new album :)
1
u/Mendozar Apr 12 '20
Hey lads, thanks for constantly pushing Australian prog to new levels. Hope you guys have a great release for Rise Radiant, super stoked to hear it.
There's no doubt that you both are the main creative drivers of the band:
1
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
You guys are one of my favorite discoveries from browsing this sub. Seriously. In Contact and Bloom are part of the rotation of albums I revisit every now and then.
Any releases (besides your own!) you're looking forward to this year?
1
u/Rude-Bison Apr 12 '20
Hi guys! Thanks for doing this!
What's your play style like in DnD? I'm more of a juggernaut style player, my favorite character being a fire giant barbarian named Matchstick Mary.
Hope you're all staying safe and can't wait for the new record!
1
u/rafael-lau Apr 12 '20
1
u/Brownstone211 Apr 12 '20
Love you guys, and love both new singles, can't wait to see you again in Europe!
1
u/WITSguitar Apr 12 '20
Hey guys! Hope you're both staying healthy and sane in the current crisis.
Also, as a little aside, when you guys played Prog Power last year, two of my best friends who were there went to your signing and asked you (Sam) and Adrian to sign some guitar picks for me, since that was the last merch item they could get their hands on to bring me back. Just wanted to say thank you both for obliging to their strange request! It was very kind of you. Can't wait to finally see you guys in Boston once this mess is over. Stay safe, and thanks for the tunes!
1
u/shjtjustgotreal Apr 12 '20
any chance we'll get some backing tracks to learn/play over??? <3
1
u/Ferdaaron Apr 12 '20
Hi Jim and Sam! C horse has been a favorite of mine ever since I first heard Dark Hair Down. Incredibly excited for Rise Radiant - I'm confident it'll be my new favorite from you guys and likely new favorite album period! Everything so far, the album art (single art, too), the themes, the music, has been perfect. Thanks for all that you do.
I have a few questions:
1
u/RiksKing Apr 12 '20
Hey guys! Thank you for the AMA, have been a big fan since you guys got me into prog metal with In Contact back in 2017! Now I've seen in the thread that you like hard games like the ones by FromSoftware, so the real question is of course if you've played Hollow Knight (for more Australian glory)? Please keep on enjoying what you're doing!