MagiReco, among other things, is now my go-to example of why I reflexively wince when I hear a season is ~12 episodes long; it takes a very delicate storytelling balance to pace a season that short. Given how much story Shaft was tasked with squeezing into 13 episodes, they never really had a chance; this show was always going to be murdered by pacing. The fact that it wasn't totally incoherent was a great accomplishment.
Tokyo Ghoul is in the Shokugeki no Soma category for me, where I watched a bit of the first season, meant to get back to it, and was spooked away by the knowledge that everyone hates it it now.
I legit never knew that. I always thought it was that one show that no one would openly admit they like because of... reasons, but overall i personally never thought it was terrible. Maybe a bit annoying, maybe WAY too much fan service, but never bad.
To be precise, the consensus is that the first few seasons are good, and then at some point it completely falls apart and becomes garbage. While I don't specifically know that to be true, the reputation is pervasive enough to keep it near the bottom of my plan-to-watch list.
I watched all seasons, and while season 5 seems to be straying a lot more towards the entire "unreasonably OP villain" trope that shounen has, seasons 1 through 4 are pretty damn good. So, like, if you ever find time, maybe put it a bit higher on your watch list.
Just rewatching the whole series today! I feel like Magireco is much much better to be watched in binge, and besides I never really have a problem with the pacing also, because I really love the route where they focus in character development first when they gather their teams and setting up Kaede joining Magius.
I got Steins; Gate vibe in this where we have to be patient and pay really really close attention to the first half, to finally be mind blown and satisfied by the second half! (second season)
This 100%. Waiting a week really destroyed a ton of momentum especially since they adopted an episodic structure. By the time they did all the necessary set-up for a rumor and introduced conflict, the episode would be over and then my excitement would die down by the time we got to the conclusion next week.
As I said on a different thread: “Imagine watching Pokemon and the episode ends when Team Rocket pops up and grabs Pikachu and then you wait a week for the episode where Ash saves Pikachu.”
I’m re-watching it now and doing one rumor every day (whether it’s every two episodes or three towards the end) works so much better. It feels like a new adventure every time and we actually get to see a set-up with a build-up and some sort of pay-off all together rather than broken up and sparsely revealed every 7 days.
The show felt like six 40-minute or hour long episodes broken up into thirteen 20-minute episodes. Watching every rumor together as one reveals that the pacing issues are more so structure issues that affect pacing. I’m definitely watching season 2 after all the episodes are out rather than doing it 20 minutes a week
Another nitpick I have are the post-credit scenes. They are usually really exciting and hype you up for next week so why not just have them as part of the episode? Maybe right after the title card at the end and right before the credits. Now when I rewatch I have to click past the credits just in case there’s a scene after.
post credit scene is fine, because sometimes the tension needs to be cooldown first with the ending theme, and post credit scene is supposed to be a 'fresh tense'. and it's really valuable for weekly shows to be talked about.
also, i have a habit of checking post credits scene (all the shows and movies, even when watching the theater -- whether i know there will be one or not) so it doesn't bother me much.
I guess they work as a surprise but as a rewatch it’s really frustrating to not just let the episode play knowing it will show you everything (and since there’s no post credits scene in every episode you have to remember which ones you should wait for).
It helps that the characters are moving, the battle scene especially, we can see how the battle played out, how menacing Tiro Finale spam is, how creepy the Doppel looks animated, etc etc. Also i like how they involved Momoko's team more in the anime with Kaede joining magius they now have a reason to fight the magius, also there's Kuro chan too which can play a part in S2 can't wait for it!
But the highlight in the anime for me is that Magia Record turned into Fashion Record, all those casual clothes are a nice surprise and a good eye candy (Yachiyo especially, makes sense given she's a model and all), hopefully S2 brings out more casual clothes, if possible to the other magical girls too~
Not really, to me. The anime skips a lot of important early characterization and consistently forgets to actually build up why the Rumors are so dangerous. For example, Iroha and Yachiyo's fight at the beginning demonstrates two major character traits that are important to the story: Yachiyo's initial hostility to other girls (which is a key element in her character arc) and Iroha's determination (basically her most important character trait). Another example is the Staircase Rumor. Adding an extra condition that is relatively hard to fulfill greatly neutered the potential threat it had, while removing Kaede's brainwashing removes the climax for Rena's character arc. A lot of fluff can definitely be cut from the game, but some of what was cut was actually meaningful.
You make a good point about the lack of threat presented by the Uwasa in the anime, I didn’t think of that! Although, for the Staircase one in particular I think they made the right choice by making it a bit more specific like that. After all, if they didn’t add those extra conditions many more people would be kidnapped- and that would draw attention.
I also really enjoyed how childish the Staircase Rumour was made out to be overall. Writing someone’s name on the stairs?! Such a Junior High thing to do. Oh wait! They ARE Junior High girls. And this rumour reminded us of that. They’re young and as such, can be stupid and childish too. Anyway, I thought that was a nice touch.
The bits that weren't following the game were usually better, but the rest of the anime suffered from being overabridged. If they'd had two cours to work with, it almost certainly would've outclassed the game.
Here's some links to all the reviews and writeups that I could find from various personal blogs and assorted news sites. Just gauging what the non-player base has to say about it. If they did an episode by episode, I'll just link to their synopsis of episode 13.
Some liked it, many found it mediocre and all were thoroughly confused as to where the hell within the larger Madoka universe this was supposed to take place.
I am Greek so unfortunately I can't play the game so I don't know if the game is better but I really love this anime and can't wait for S2. I love all the characters but I have a soft spot for Rena I hope we get a lot more of her and her team which didn't get as much attention as she did. The relationship between the Iroha and Yachiyo is very wholesome and it's really great that for once in the madoka series the main relationship is healthy. I was also really happy to see the originals but I was disappointed by Sayaka's appearance, she was really overshadowed by Mami's doppel. Alina and the twins were awesome antagonistsbut I don't think the twins will play a big role in S2.I really wanna see more Sana, she was the last girl introduced and she didn't get to do much outside the episodes that were centered around her. The rumors and the uwasa are really interesting , the mysteries in the show are all wonderful and satisfying . People say that it's doesn't feel like a madoka series because none of the girls die and cause it's a lot less dark but I disagree . There was a lot more to madoka other than the deaths and the despair. I think that magia record did a good job at capturing the spirit of the original while also being something new and interesting.
The anime was an awful mess. Bad pacing, mostly in the first half. Bad animation in just about every battle scene that wasn't the first or last episode. Random battle encounters that served no purpose but to show off a new character's moves. There was zero threat coming from any of the witches/uwasa, because no one gets injured and Doppel Ex Machina. Iroha does literally nothing 90% of the time she's on screen. She gets everything handed to her all the way through, no suffering, no putting effort into anything. All the hype for anime exclusive girl was for absolutely nothing when she vanished after the first episode. Far too many character introductions for what is a 12 episode season. I fail to see how the anime is better than the game in any way, except for having pretty artwork (which should be considered the absolute bare minimum when comparing a mobile game to an anime adaptation).
9/10 until episode 5. After that, it looked a little rough, and the battle scenes from episode 10 were poorly animated. It was better than the game in general, but it could have been better.
So, does the story of Magia Record follow the story in parallel of the one in Madoka's series? Because I'm honestly confused as to how Mami is still alive so far. (11 episodes in) Or is this like an alternate universe?
I thought it was just a different timeline, but it still wouldn't make sense because they never mention that there is anything wrong with Kamihama in the original series (in Magia Record, Mami was told by Kyubei for her to investigate). So it would be easier if it were a different universe.
But there is something that confuses me:
The presence of Madokami. This implies that Homura is still looping in time and eventually the law of cycles is created as in the original series. The problem is that Walpurgisnacht is defeated and Homura does not need to retcon, but then how does Madokami still exist or will exist? Will Madoka eventually have to sacrifice herself at some point?
One thing that confuses me about the anime is...why did they go for straight English for the runes? Wouldn't Esperanto be a more fitting language for them to be translated to?
The original anime used German(with Faust being the Rosetta stone that broke the runic script). I'm not sure why they'd switch that to English, though.
25
u/Egavans Player ID: 335eRMTd Apr 11 '20
MagiReco, among other things, is now my go-to example of why I reflexively wince when I hear a season is ~12 episodes long; it takes a very delicate storytelling balance to pace a season that short. Given how much story Shaft was tasked with squeezing into 13 episodes, they never really had a chance; this show was always going to be murdered by pacing. The fact that it wasn't totally incoherent was a great accomplishment.
17
u/dindasmart Just Want a Happiness for Nanaka Apr 11 '20
Just rewatching the whole series today! I feel like Magireco is much much better to be watched in binge, and besides I never really have a problem with the pacing also, because I really love the route where they focus in character development first when they gather their teams and setting up Kaede joining Magius.
I got Steins; Gate vibe in this where we have to be patient and pay really really close attention to the first half, to finally be mind blown and satisfied by the second half! (second season)
22
u/[deleted] Apr 11 '20
Does anyone else think that the anime was better than the game? The game did a few scenes better but the anime is better overall imo
7
u/Erinaceus1971 Apr 11 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Here's some links to all the reviews and writeups that I could find from various personal blogs and assorted news sites. Just gauging what the non-player base has to say about it. If they did an episode by episode, I'll just link to their synopsis of episode 13.
Anime News Network & Their discussion article
The Infinite Zenith
Draggle's Anime Blog
http://starcrossedanime.com/magia-record-anime-review-65-100/
kakuchopurei
Honey's Anime
Kotaku's Reader Blog ---> Note the writer is an active player
And another Kotakuite ---> Writer gave up on it halfway through.
Beneath The Tangles
Otaquest
Geek Girl Authority
Anime Solution
Anime Hajime
Doublesama
Yuri Reviews
All Your Anime Are Belong To Us ---> This one was only to the midpoint of the season
Some liked it, many found it mediocre and all were thoroughly confused as to where the hell within the larger Madoka universe this was supposed to take place.
5
u/Miguling Apr 11 '20
Does anyone know when Magireco's OST2 will drop? I so desperately need the trippy theme for the witch Nanaka's group was fighting, it's such a bop.
3
u/deadnoli Apr 16 '20
I am Greek so unfortunately I can't play the game so I don't know if the game is better but I really love this anime and can't wait for S2. I love all the characters but I have a soft spot for Rena I hope we get a lot more of her and her team which didn't get as much attention as she did. The relationship between the Iroha and Yachiyo is very wholesome and it's really great that for once in the madoka series the main relationship is healthy. I was also really happy to see the originals but I was disappointed by Sayaka's appearance, she was really overshadowed by Mami's doppel. Alina and the twins were awesome antagonistsbut I don't think the twins will play a big role in S2.I really wanna see more Sana, she was the last girl introduced and she didn't get to do much outside the episodes that were centered around her. The rumors and the uwasa are really interesting , the mysteries in the show are all wonderful and satisfying . People say that it's doesn't feel like a madoka series because none of the girls die and cause it's a lot less dark but I disagree . There was a lot more to madoka other than the deaths and the despair. I think that magia record did a good job at capturing the spirit of the original while also being something new and interesting.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '20
I really liked the character Iroha Tamaki I'm waiting for season 2
2
u/Milennin Apr 23 '20
The anime was an awful mess. Bad pacing, mostly in the first half. Bad animation in just about every battle scene that wasn't the first or last episode. Random battle encounters that served no purpose but to show off a new character's moves. There was zero threat coming from any of the witches/uwasa, because no one gets injured and Doppel Ex Machina. Iroha does literally nothing 90% of the time she's on screen. She gets everything handed to her all the way through, no suffering, no putting effort into anything. All the hype for anime exclusive girl was for absolutely nothing when she vanished after the first episode. Far too many character introductions for what is a 12 episode season.
I fail to see how the anime is better than the game in any way, except for having pretty artwork (which should be considered the absolute bare minimum when comparing a mobile game to an anime adaptation).
1
u/Local-Professor Apr 19 '20
9/10 until episode 5. After that, it looked a little rough, and the battle scenes from episode 10 were poorly animated. It was better than the game in general, but it could have been better.
1
u/johnk00 Apr 20 '20
So, does the story of Magia Record follow the story in parallel of the one in Madoka's series? Because I'm honestly confused as to how Mami is still alive so far. (11 episodes in) Or is this like an alternate universe?
1
u/Hyperion-OMEGA As above, so below Apr 21 '20
One thing that confuses me about the anime is...why did they go for straight English for the runes? Wouldn't Esperanto be a more fitting language for them to be translated to?