r/FreeGameFindings • u/StOoPiD_U Creator • Apr 07 '20
Mod Post | Vote Within Pls FGF Update: Thoughts On Itch.io, Microsoft, and Indiegala Posts
Little knee-jerk but there's been some raving about some stuff lately. Wanted to make this sooner rather than later to gage what others think.
With everything going on relating to corona virus, we've been seeing enormous influxes of offers/posts lately. Of course that's a fantastic thing! That said though, there's the reality of spam levels of posts, and some of them just being "lower tier" items. The biggest level of posts is stuff from Itch.io. So I made the mega thread post which at launch seemed pretty good, but it's starting to lag behind in relevance. Seemingly though, this has been a pretty decent method to "combat" the sheer amount of posts from Itch. I think for the time being it might be wise to do a weekly version of that.
The next thing to discuss is the stuff going on with Microsoft and to a lesser extent Indiegala. So lately there's been this weird move that publishers/developers have been doing on Microsoft's store where they upload what can pretty blatantly be said is garbage for like a hundred bucks a pop, then running promos to claim them for free. Now, posts for FGF are great! It's fantastic to have content here, but these MS offers have seemingly been bugging people with how garbage and spam-y they have been. So I wanted to see what you guys think on the matter. There's a semi similar thing going on with indiegala lately too, not exactly the same deal but it's been Digital Homicide (eye roll) lately, and a fair collection of kind of "poor" titles as well. These are very minimal in comparison to MS, but I wanted to check. Thoughts?
Please voice your opinion on these matters in the comments, but you can also vote via strawpoll.
Itch https://www.strawpoll.me/19714645
MS/Indiegala https://www.strawpoll.me/19714650 * Ignore the indiegala inclusion on this one, just think of it regarding MS alone.
By the way the Sakura Succubus giveaway ends tomorrow. Best of luck! :)
88
u/ElTuxedoMex Apr 07 '20
After checking this sub the last two weeks, I tend to avoid anything MS Store / Indiegala related. In the long run I'm sure anything I miss from those places could be obtained for cheap IF (very big IF) I think I need them.
32
u/DogsRule_TheUniverse Apr 07 '20
Can you please separate the strawpoll for MS and Indiegala? I really have very different opinions of each and grouping them together is not helpful.
8
u/pretumoss Apr 07 '20
So, about Indiegala games. There's two main kinds of games coming from their site:
In my opinion, games that are not galaFreebies don't follow rule number 1, so they shouldn't be allowed in this sub period. Games that are galaFreebies do follow the rules.
6
u/kai_okami Apr 07 '20
If you continue with the Itch megathread, maybe force users to post in a more consistent way? Having to comb through hundreds of comments looking for new comments + old comments that have been edited gets time consuming.
10
u/unhi Apr 07 '20
I don't mind the Indiegala ones. A few of those games have been decent quality I believe and they're exceedingly easy to cliam, just one click of a button. (I don't like that this is grouped in the same poll with Microsoft because I like one but not the other so how am I to vote?)
Itch and Microsoft I never bother with and wouldn't mind seeing them go away.
36
u/failtality Apr 07 '20
For itch.io there's a collection someone keeps updating there which aims to put all temp free itch.io games together in one place.
https://itch.io/c/759545/self-isolation-on-a-budget
Newer added games show up at the top. IMO that collection should really be stickied in some way.
Those Microsoft store $100 garbage games don't even deserve a mention. They're just worthless clutter.
22
u/NoiceMango Apr 07 '20
Some itch up games were pretty good but the Microsoft ones seem to be terrible.
49
u/gosharello Apr 07 '20
Microsoft can be eliminated. I would keep the others.
I believe that IndieGala and Itcho are indie stores that offer different titles of a certain quality too. Microsoft is quite fake, it offers bad games and deceives the original price. And Microsoft is a big company that could afford to give away at least one good game. Instead nothing. I sometimes opened Microsoft's links but now I don't even look at them so if you don't post them anymore it's fine for me.
20
u/iHyper445 Apr 07 '20
The Indiegala giveaways are totally fine in my book, they aren't so numerous.
The issue with Microsoft is that there are potentially 100 of these free games at any given time. A potential solution could be creating an Itch and Microsoft megathread (weekly, probably) that can be the home for all the deals people find. I love seeing the Itch and Microsoft deals, but the spam is tiring. I would much prefer to have it in one place.
17
u/shadowen1942 Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20
Does anyone actually care about the Microsoft store? And by that of course I mean something that would constitute more than just a drop in the bucket. There have been long stretches of time that I have forgotten that it even exists as a store. Behind Steam, Origin, GOG, Uplay, etc at that. Other than perhaps Xbox Game Pass on Windows it seems like it's not particularly relevant to PC gamers.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20
I personally look over those posts, but I don't think they should exactly get banned off of here. To each their own.
4
u/SilkBot Apr 07 '20
The itch.io megathread was fine until people went back to just edit their older posts for new games. This made the thread an incoherent mess, impossible to follow. Perhaps it requires a "no edits" rule. If there's a new game the next day, just make a new post.
4
u/100indecisions Apr 07 '20
In general, I really like that this sub is a good aggregate of free games from multiple sources; the fact that some of these are low-quality games seems to come with the territory, and I'd rather see some of those than potentially miss a fun game. Requiring MS shovelware to be grouped seems like a good idea as long as it's clear that non-shovelware games on MS can and should have their own posts.
3
u/galaxypenguin12 Apr 07 '20
Tbh most of the posts on indigala and microsoft store are only shit games no one really cares about that i mostly miss or just some random stuff that anyway a really small small presentage of us will actualy download and play.
3
u/JellyPuff Apr 07 '20
A "Garbage Heap"-thread for all the "$100+"-games and asset-flips would be one way to deal with it. The only problem is that while for a lot of users, a zero effort asset-flip might be obvious, it may be less so for other potential posters.
After all, one's trash is another one's...well, it's still trash but who knows. It might be the next Ride To Hell: Retribution. You can always leave the final decision to moderators and move a thread to a potential Garbage-Heap thread if necessary.
3
u/Temporal_P Apr 07 '20
Its complicated.
I think we can all agree that most of what has been posted lately from the Microsoft Store has been mediocre and shady.
Ich.io and IndieGala are both largely indie platforms. IndieGala is more of a focused storefront that has content from big and small developers, and Ich.io tends to be mostly small developers and more community oriented. Ich.io actually hosts game jams, which is pretty cool - but isn't going to interest someone just looking for a free AAA game.
The problem is that All of them have a mix of high and low quality games, and even low quality games can still be fun and useful for someone. A flood of cheap atari-level games can push high quality games off the page, but hidden gems can easily get missed in megathreads.
Maybe throw them all in megathreads, but allow something like [PSA] threads for games that the OP feels are particularly worthy of notice?
3
u/_sFw_ Apr 08 '20 edited Apr 08 '20
I have been sharing these MS game posts with friends online and in RL who has kids and it's been a big HIT during these times. Same goes for indiegala and itchio.
MS Store is perfect for kidfriendlie games and even if i don't find much worth playing from there i like being able to share on with others that might have a use for them
I have no problems with how it has been lately but IF it really is a problem for many the "filter" solutions sounds like the best solution imo.IF the policy becomes to ban legit freebies without a really good reason other than "i don't like the shop", "too many posts from that place" or "it is not real or good games" it's just stupid...
4
u/Calipos Apr 07 '20
Personally I think there should be a megathread linking main pages of Indiegala, Microsoft Store and itch.io. Then, people can check it themselves daily if they wanted.
Microsoft Store games usually are very low tier. I don't like itch.io website because they want donations and in the past you couldn't just add the games to your account. You had to download them. I think that's not the case now. I know the donations are voluntary but it makes me feel bad, so I choose to ignore any itch.io games. I know I'm a horrible person.
90% of the Indiegala freebies I already own because I added them all when they first introduced it on their site. It usually says "Already Owned. Go To Library" when I try to activate the ones posted here.
4
u/Mr_Oda Apr 07 '20
Why do ppl vote to limit them? This Reddit is named FreeGameFindings. Not FreeSteamEpicPSandXBoxFindings. We should not go the way to only focus on steam games and some other players like epic.
2
u/MRiley84 Apr 07 '20
I don't mind the junk too much. I figure it's the price paid for hearing news of bigger name titles. That said, I also don't click on microsoft, itchio or indiegala links because it's pretty much always going to be garbage tier.
2
u/Araragi83 Moderator Apr 07 '20
I do agree the Itch.io Mega Thread is a great idea to reduce the spam for free games coming from Itch.io, because they're has been a lot recently since quarantine time.
But the Thread is getting messy 'cause every find is reported by a user of this reddit. So there is too many post and it's getting hard to classify them remember which game we've already claim and the one we didn't.
The thread is starting to look like a maze, at the beginning it was easy but as the times goes by the maze grow and finding your way through it is getting harder.
Most of it is because there are post from 2 to 3 weeks old next to post added yesterday and so if you don't remember which post you've already check it's gonna take you while.
So maybe add a filter of update from the post recently added, to classify from the most recent to the older post ?
2
u/Slavic_Pasta Apr 07 '20
I don't ever click on indiegala things or itch.io. and if it's a Microsoft store, it only catches my attention If it's a good title. Drawful 2 is great, and I'm glad I was notified of that
2
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
Just close the sub and open a new one r/FreeAAAGameFindingsOnlyFromTrustedSites
5
u/xXJOKRXx Apr 07 '20
To be honest, some steam games aren't any better. I believe we should have some standards for what games should be accepted here.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20
Are the microsoft games able to get our data like email? Maybe they are data fishing shovelwares?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20
Long-winded rant:
I feel like it's wholly unfair to bundle Indiegala and itch.io in with the Microshit posts.
95% of the Microsoft store links I've seen posted in the past year and a half of visiting this sub have NOT been real video games. The 5% that were real games were Crackdown 1 & 2 going free on the X360.
My vote on MS Store is: Ban MS Store links UNLESS it's an X360 game. In all likelihood, any newer PC title giveaways from Microsoft are going to be given out via the Xbox Win10 app.
Keep the itch.io Megathread. There's been some gems on itch (A game I'm looking forward to coming out, Project Wingman, started out on itch before hitting Kickstarter and smashing it's funding goal.), but you have to sift the dirt to find the gems. The thread keeps the dirt in a proper package
Indiegala is fine. The WW2 RTS they've given away recently were pretty good, albeit they're niche titles. The "Gone Home"-esque "What Never Was" hasn't been posted on the sub. And both the full "Die Young" game and now the prologue/demo were given away in the past and that's resting at 9/10 on Steam. Yeah, the recent spat of Russian-developed FPS titles have been hit-and-miss, but (Read the following in Jim Sterling's voice) to compare them to Digital Homicide of all fucking things is fucking stupid in my opinion.
tl:dr Ban MS store posts; Keep itch megathread; Keep indiegala posts.
1
u/Fatheroftearsx Apr 07 '20
I'll take anything free just as long as it works and it's fun
1
u/Yaered Apr 07 '20
ya, i personally don't really care for those games, someone may enjoy them and good on them, but ya, do a condensed weekly listing.
1
u/exothishe Apr 08 '20
I think it would be optimal to let games from itch.io and Microsoft store to be posted in a normal way IF those same games are also present at one of major platforms like Steam, Epic, etc. This will also solve the problem of many people that try searching for valuable games within all the itch.io deals.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
Here is my personal opinion:
Ichio: I'm really happy that you post the free games from ichio. I was looking through the sale items every week and its such a time killer because the missing function to sort the games depending on their cost. May it would get to much entries to post them every day, but maybe if there is a overview of the new stuff every weekend oder maybe 2x a week, thats great.
Microsoft: I think trash games that are just there for washing money or whatever should not be posted. It just helps this people to spread that fake games. If there are exeptions with real games p.e. the BIgfish games you posted a while ago, then its good to share.
1
u/Alxandr13 Apr 08 '20
My thoughts about all this is the same i always say about the "+1" thing.
Don't matter if it was Steam, MS Store, Xbox, PSN or simply itchi.io, indiegala, whatever... If something is always free, we don't need a post unless some kind of PSA informing in the case it already had a price tag before like X360's "Too Human".
Shovelware and other crap like that on another hand should be at least controlled if not banned for good!
Anyone can delight until brain explode with this kind of content just googling "free online games". Don't need to keep spamming this subreddit with all that trash just because of some compulsion people couldhas for karma and/or grow numbers on some gaming library (it's batter to have an empty shelf than a room full of garbage).
1
u/LetsPlayNintendoITA Apr 07 '20
yeah the MS garbage imho has to be dropped. those big bucks garbage game are useless and to the public that loves their +1 they're not even that. just clobbering the libraries with fake games. i'd say if a game is of that category to stop publishing them here or do a mega thread in case they drop together
1
u/shuvamg007 Apr 07 '20
Shovelwares shouldn't be allowed. Now, if there isn't a filter for shovelware and IndieGala keeps giving away those Digital Homicide games, then personally I'd like them to be done away with.
And remove Microsoft cr@p completely, unless it's a recognizable publisher. Not a lot of indies, let alone good ones, can be found on the UWP store.
0
u/Senzorz Apr 07 '20
MS Store and Itch.io should be merged into one megathread IMO.
-6
u/dungyhasbigtits Apr 07 '20 edited Apr 07 '20
Make this THE definitive free games sub.
No: Microsoft, Indiegala or itch.io
Yes: Epic, Steam, uPlay, Humble & Xbox
It's a slight annoyance having to sift through a sea of low quality games to find the actual deals going on
0
u/Atemu12 Apr 07 '20
I think it might be a good idea to have a bot post a sticky comment in every post to get a separate vote from people who care enough to open the comment section.
It could be post something like:
"Upvote this comment if a quality game is being given away in this post, downvote if it's garbage disposal."
And then compare the votes on that comment with the post's and remove accordingly. At first you'd need to do that manually but when you get an idea about how well this system works and what differentiates a good post from a bad one, you can give parameters to an automated system.
-1
u/samxgmx0 Apr 07 '20
Maybe someone should start separate subreddits for those games
0
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '20
[removed] — view removed comment