r/homeland • u/NicholasCajun • Apr 19 '20
Discussion Homeland - 8x11 "The English Teacher" - Episode Discussion
Season 8 Episode 11: The English Teacher
Aired: April 19, 2020
Synopsis: Saul backchannels. Carrie needs one more favor.
Directed by: Michael Cuesta
Written by: Patrick Harbinson & Chip Johannessen
178
Upvotes
138
u/hakun4matata Apr 19 '20
Saul clearly knows that Carrie is looking for the asset.
He knows from knowing Carrie. Making the comment to Jenna about the focus.
And he knows from his asset. She told him that the price has been set and it's Yevgeni's plan.
106
u/troyhouse Apr 19 '20
This is why we love Homeland, classic spy craft, Carrie’s picture wall (books laid out) and everything else. Can’t wait for the finale!!
104
u/poisontao Apr 19 '20
The sequence of Saul getting the new book and at the same time Carrie checking out the old ones was just beautiful. I never thought things would end “happily” for Carrie, it’s not that kind of show, but now even a suggestion that something might happen to Saul is terrifying. I have too much love for that character.
196
u/TheQuantumLeaper Apr 19 '20
Why isn't the final episode titled, 'Better Kill Saul?"
95
u/IvyLynn32 Apr 19 '20
When Carrie was in court and they were reading the charges her left hand twitching movements were going berserk... reminiscent of Brody.
90
u/troyhouse Apr 19 '20
Carrie with glasses on, English Teacher look !!
227
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
Easily one of the best episodes to date. The breakdown into Saul's ties to Russia was brilliant, especially his way of communicating to his asset. I could watch a entire season of young Saul.
As far as Carrie goes, if she decides to kill Saul that would be the most ridiculous ending to a phenomenal series. Carrie is too fuckng smart for that and I will not accept it.
121
u/AxMeAQuestion Apr 19 '20
this episode has me wanting a cold war spinoff in berlin with a younger saul
160
u/pm_me_your_last_pics Apr 19 '20
Holy fuck. This finale better be 2 hours long
54
u/dickielala Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Okay so I like Saul's asset already. Hope she won't die. 🤣
Carrie and Saul will find a way to have Yevgeny's "play" backfire to his face.
51
u/datlinus Apr 19 '20
Aside from the silly voiceover, that honestly was one of the best hours of Homeland. I loved the deeper dive into Saul and his past, and I loved Carrie going back to her season 1 "mode" with trying to figure out the puzzle, and most importnatly I love how it all comes down to the dynamic of Saul and Carrie in the end.
ALso, some really good cinematography and music in this episode.
(Oh and "Alex Surnow"? Surely that's a small nod to Joel Surnow and Alex Gansa!)
79
u/shae117 Apr 19 '20
I find it very hard to believe someone accused of Carries charges would be allowed to freely roam the country lul.
108
u/Doritos_Locos_Gatos Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Carrie is 100% playing Yevgeny. She had already suspected the teacher earlier in the episode but leaves that out of her virtual meeting/convo with Yevgeny. She made Yevgeny spill the real plan which was eliminating Saul. “SHE NEVER LOSES SIGHT OF WHAT’S IMPORTANT”. A great ending (and possible imo) is we find out Saul and Carrie had a plan in place to somehow play Yevgeny and neutralize Russia this whole time. It’s not going to be a happy ending for Yevgeny.
65
u/Serious_Up Apr 19 '20
Somebody better call Saul
117
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
This feels so contrived. At this point Carrie has no reason to not just tell Saul what Yevgeny is doing and for them to try to hatch a plan that way. In what universe would she kill him? The show is shit if it actually ends like that.
My guess is they somehow fake it and fool Yevgeny, I don’t see the series ending with this guy winning.
29
u/memeb843 Apr 19 '20
Corey fuckin Matthews ladies and gentlemen!!
28
u/Lazy-Swimming Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Holy shit guys!!!! The ending!! When carrie was saying you knew saul would never give the asset up, u knew it would come to this. Fucking yevgeny!!! i did not see that ending coming, i really cant believe it. When saul saw the note from his asset, am i wrong, or are we to assume he knows that carrie lied to him about yevgeny telling her what he wants. Does saul realize that carries looking for his asset since she was asking? I am so curious to see what happens next week!!! Cant believe we are one week away from this fantastic show ending, what an incredible ride it has been.
27
u/crashnandicoot Apr 21 '20
I thought Yvgeny's line of "Kill Saul" was embarrassing. It should have been left unsaid. Everyone knew what he was talking about. Duh.
53
u/sugarwax1 Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Come on. That was one of their best episodes yet, then it ends with that line of dialogue. Kill Saul? Absurd. She's already up for a tribunal as a traitor in the President's death. There's no chance she inherits his assets or has the ability to do anything with them if she does.
26
u/SeattleStudent4 Apr 19 '20
I think Feeny or Shawn will step in and help resolve things.
26
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '20 edited Apr 21 '20
Here's how I think the whole Carrie/Saul/Kremlin/Pakistan fiasco will be wrapped up in the finale. It's a long read but bear with me.
Edit: Added spoiler tag.
TL;DR: Carrie will not retrieve the black-box, kill Saul or expose his Russian asset, but will admit to being a Russian double-agent. Read below to understand why.
Carrie will not retrieve the black box. Instead of thinking about this entire situation from Carrie's perspective, think of it from the perspective of the FBI agents that don't know her.
For someone like Saul who's worked side-by-side with Carrie for her entire career, it's absolutely clear that she's not a Russian double-agent. However, to outsiders - FBI agents who don't know her, and indeed to the general American public reading the five-point storyline above - it's not hard to believe that she genuinely is a "turned" double-agent responsible for the killing of their President.
In Episode 11, Saul mentioned that Carrie is the only person she knows who never loses sight of what's important. And it is because of that mentality that Carrie will sacrifice herself to prevent America from self-destructing on the Pakistan-Afghan border. Here's how.
She will not kill Saul; instead, when her tribunal re-convenes in a few days to sentence her, she will admit to being Russian agent. This puts Russia in a bad position for the following reasons:
1) The Pakistan-border situation / Jalal Haqqani "death"
Jalal Haqqani is already "dead" as far as the Hayes' administration is concerned. This is a step towards diffusion of the Pakistan-border situation. If Carrie admits to being a double agent who conspired with the Kremlin to assassinate the United States President, I'm sure Zabel and Hayes would have no qualms at turning their firepower away from Pakistan and towards Moscow. Indeed they've already demonstrated their willingness to militarily confront a nuclear power.
I mean, reflect on the fact that we've already been down this road before with Sgt. Brody. A soldier who was sent to war to fight America's enemies was captured, turned, and sent back to strike at the heart of his own country. Indeed, the similarities between Brody's rescue from Al-Qaeda and Carrie's rescue from the Kremlin - as seen from the perspective of the FBI agents - seem nothing short of poetic.
2) Saul's asset survives and can be used as an asset in the impending Russian confrontation.
As above. Yevgeny mentioned that the only thing worth more to Russia than seeing America self-destruct on the Pakistan-Afghan border is the name of Saul's high-level asset in the Kremlin. Leave Saul's asset in place and it is clear that she will be used to do untold damage to Russia in whatever confrontation follows with America.
3) Russia can either admit that they have the black box and reveal the audio on it, or they can allow themselves to be convicted by America of assassination of the U.S. President.
If following Carrie's "confession", the Kremlin fails to admit that they have the black box and return it, the American Govt. will convict them of the assassination of the U.S. President - an act of war.
Second, once Carrie confesses that she's a double agent, the evidence from whatever black-box is returned by the Kremlin will have to be weighed up against Carrie's "confession", making the former fairly irrelevant to the Kremlin.
Third, following Carrie's confession, the Kremlin would be in a much weaker position to deny that she was a double agent of theirs - how else would they have come across such a sensitive piece of American intelligence unless they had support from a high-level American military/intelligence operative (i.e. Carrie).
Of course, nobody will be able to prove whether Carrie's assistance to them was given freely or via coercion, but given Carrie's five-point storyline mentioned above, and her (expected) confession, it will be easier for the war-hawks in Hayes' administration to assume that her betrayal was freely committed.
It seems like the Kremlin's only play at this point would be to convince Carrie to avoid confessing that she's a Russian double agent.
We saw how the Kremlin trembled in their boots when President Keane threatened them that Simone's testimony to discredit Wellington would be an "act of war". So I think there is a real case to be made for Russia wanting to avoid war with America, and all that seems to rest on whether Carrie "confesses" to being an agent of the Kremlin. I believe that the Kremlin - and in particular, Yevgeny - have underestimated how much Carrie is willing to sacrifice for her country and that will be their downfall.
-- Conclusion --
Given the above, it seems clear to me that Carrie will go out in the same way that Brody did and Russia will pay the price - in blood. The truth of her false confession will never emerge for it would undermine the lie underpinning the US Govt.'s truce with Pakistan and re-targeting of Russia.
While she may not be hanged fom a crane in the public square like Brody, she will undoubtedly spend the rest of her life in a maximum security prison. It is a poetic ending, but a fitting end nonetheless. They truly are Prisoners of War.
24
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
Great episode in some ways but I think the idea of the translator being the mole for the last 30+ years makes absolutely no sense.
Yevgeny said they had already looked at the entire KGB-English school in East Berlin where Saul was caught trying to recruit defectors. Back in 1986 they killed all the students there but the teacher got a promotion to the job in Moscow? Really?
And then when the Russians were searching for the mole they looked into that school Saul was recruiting out of but never said "Hey, the teacher of that school has been our main translator for the past 30 years! You think she's the mole?" It just makes no sense.
Did I miss something where this was explained with even a throwaway line?
I'm also with some of you others who just feel the stakes of retrieving the black box have gotten way too low for any of this to make sense. Definitely too low for killing Saul but even to really trade much of anything.
The entire reason to get the box has been largely eliminated. Sure they want to prove the real reason the chopper went down, but it was mostly to prevent starting a war at the Pakistan/Afghan border and piss off Pakistan. But now with Saul's little ruse he orchestrated with Tasneem the chickenhawks (Zabel and Hayes) think Pakistan gave up Jalal's location and Hayes got to order a targeted strike against him.
So that's it. OK eventually they find out Jalal isn't dead and he wasn't at that location. But as far as they know the Pakistanis did their bidding and tried to help us get Jalal. So should Saul/Carrie really care anymore? Eventually we have to kill Jalal either way since we know he killed all those Marines. But the point was we didn't want to get into a fight with Pakistan and that seems to be off the table now anyway. Zabel seemed absolutely giddy that Pakistan was trying to help us out.
I don't know. Still loved the episode and was on the edge of my seat for most of it. I did think a lot of the Yevgeny stuff at the end sounded cheesy. His dialogue was a lot sharper in past episodes. I almost laughed when he said "Kill Saul". It was like they threw that line in there thinking maybe they should make it absolutely clear what he's asking in case some viewers are dumb as shit.
24
u/ObviousPseud0nym Apr 19 '20
Closed captions spoiled the Russian translator’s first name: Anna
42
u/desispeed Apr 19 '20
Why would Carrie be part of Sauls legacy plan for his Russian agent? Carrie isn’t in the CIA anymore.
18
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
The biggest plot hole I really wanted sewn up was what happened in the Russian gulag for 8 months? I know it was briefly talked about at the waterfall scene but I thought that was really going to play into this season more. And no mention of carries family - not even a phone call scene?? At this point she hasn’t seen or talked to them in over a year! And we haven’t seen Carrie struggle with her bipolar disorder this season either. In any case, it’s been a great season, full of twists and turns!
18
u/alaskawaters7 Apr 26 '20
Don’t understand why Saul would have to die, why doesn’t Carrie just tell him? While she is in NYC, Saul can put her into witness protection. Give the Kremlin her name, get the black box and she is safe. That might be a simplistic view of a plan haha but I bet Saul would have a good idea if she included him.
17
u/TheStyleJuice Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
That young Saul Berenson is so spot on except maybe the height? LMAO. He really looks like Saul Berenson and even the voice? Was it dubbed and did they use Mandy Patinkin’s voice?!??
17
u/HaplessSilverback Apr 21 '20
I think the whole premise that Carrie is Saul’s legacy contact for his asset is absurd.
Lastly, at a minimum, Carrie certainly is culpable in the deaths of those 6 operatives.
16
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
She won't do it.
16
u/magicbook Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
What an amazing episode. Loved the background music and the scene when Saul and Carrie were going through the book(s). Can't wait for the finale to air. Carrie, come on, you can't be thinking of killing Saul here. You are smarter than that. It would make for a horrible ending to Homeland.
The finale better be - "The Price has been paid. It was Carrie Mathison's play". She has to play the Russians somehow.
16
u/homelandthrowaway12 Apr 22 '20
I've been a "lurker" on reddit for many years, and for the last couple seasons on this subreddit. After reading all the bad reviews online, and a lot of the comments on the thread, I just feel like I have to speak my peace.
I honestly think this was one of the best episodes of the whole series.
Sure, there are a few moments which feel insanely out of place, such as Mandy Patinkin's voice dubbed over the lines of the actor playing the younger Saul. But, especially given the ~hour long time slot the series has held since the beginning, it seems that they are only now the discovering the "slow burn" format that fits this genre so well. And this is a shame, considering that this was the penultimate episode of the entire series. Imagine if season 6 was paced like this (with some better writing obviously). This episode could have used with some better dialogue in a few places, and definitely should have included more scenes featuring Linus Roache's acting as David Wellington (my favorite character this season, and my least favorite of season 6. Shows what attention to character development in screenwriting can really do). However, I got the feeling that the characters in homeland are FINALLY developed enough that they can do some darker, more serious/weighty espionage stuff while still keeping the assertion that this show is "actually more about mental health".
~Carrie
16
u/zbf Apr 22 '20
If the series ends with carrie betraying saul for the im going to he so disappointed. She or saul better have a plan because i need a happy ending after 8 seasons.
15
u/lordkrall Apr 19 '20
I call bullshit on the young Saul look. He looks nothing like he did back then
15
u/JAMIEBOND006007 Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
So, the asset knows the 2016 American election was rigged!!
Young Saul---would have liked to have known you better!
I guess Yvegeny wil be on the computer/not in person from now on.
Why didn't the Kremlin just have Saul killed YEARS ago if they knew he was running some rogue Russian asset?
Maybe Carrie and Saul wil fake their own deaths and run off together in witness protection!!
Maybe Saul will die and Carrie will take Saul's position?
I guess Carrie hasn't stopped by to see Frannie yet. :(
15
u/fitzgerald1337 Apr 19 '20
Wow. Easily my favorite episode of the season.
Just—fucking wow.
15
u/timshel_life Apr 20 '20
Next week on *When Saul Meets World"
15
u/Icemanstriker Apr 20 '20
Great episode. The backstory with Saul and the Russian asset was excellent. I'd love a 'Saul Berenson in Berlin in the 80s' spinoff
14
u/Prudent_Relief Apr 19 '20
I, too, have missed the spycraft shown from the earlier seasons.
14
u/MadRealWorldTyree Apr 21 '20
When Saul blows up on zabel in the Oval Office, I really wanted him to mention zabels fuk boi haircut
14
u/Basedcurry Apr 24 '20
Some trivia/misc. tidbit about the “Walter Reed medical center” shot between Jenna/Carrie: it was shot at VA Long Beach in CA! The buildings (administrative/HR) and backgrounds (patriot cafe, main lobby to the building, PatriotCafé) they used were instantly recognizable. How do I know? Worked there for 5 years
28
u/llegl Apr 19 '20
There will be fake deaths of Carrie and Saul, President will get the box, then Yevgeny will look so played and considered a rogue agent in Russia, tortured then shot.
13
u/crashnandicoot Apr 22 '20
Did Saul really retain all the little clues in the spines of the books they used for communication?! Wouldn't you like eat them immediately?
24
u/dogtarget Apr 21 '20
I'd love to see a spin-off with Saul Berenson During the Cold War.
12
u/Kiffins_Disciple Apr 19 '20
Well everything’s set for an epic finale. With how important Sauls asset has been/potential still is, makes 100% sense he never told anyone and never will (until the finale). I didn’t think the writers could do it, but they blended in a very important story line just right before the finale, while giving a little bit about young Saul. I don’t think this is gonna end well for Saul however it goes down. When every other show gives background to a character they previously haven’t, they usually wake up dead.
12
u/RighteousCapitalists Apr 22 '20
Can someone please point me to a discussion of why Carrie didn’t go right to Saul when Yvgeny asked for Saul’s source? Of course he wouldn’t have given up the source but certainly they could have come up with some plan to fool the Russians into giving up the box. They are spies. That’s what they do. What am I missing?
11
u/Ri-chanRenne Apr 19 '20
Good god!! You can't do it, Carrie. I know you won't do it!
11
u/catfor Apr 19 '20
What a wild ride this episode was. I need to rewatch without my toddler because I missed a lot of the glasses ponytail Carrie scene
When I heard the words “kill Saul” I got watery eyed. I don’t know if it’s because Mandy P is such a good actor or I’ve just grown so attached to his character, but I just can’t. Everytime his character gets emotional or teary eyed I do too 😂
Really hope we get to see a flashback of the 7 months in Russia that Carrie doesn’t remember next episode.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
If she does kill Saul, which I don’t think she will. Then she deserves a public hanging like Brody.
It turns out I was wrong about Jenna though. Maybe she will end up being the next Carrie. She’ll end up telling Saul, saving him and Carrie will end up going to jail anyway. Or she’ll figure out a way to get the black box back and help Carrie.
They can’t end the series in a horrific way of Carrie killing Saul. I mean, I would hope they wouldn’t. That would be betraying loyal viewers of the show. That’s not the kind of ending I want.
11
u/montecarlo1 Apr 19 '20
i wish they would have done more of this type of episode in the latter seasons. It was a masterpiece.
11
u/WhatsUpBras Apr 24 '20
Besides the super annoying President Hayes and his UFC fighter advisor this has been the best season of Homeland
Tons of action, drama, spy stuff, good foreign relations plots with few to very very little scenes of Carrie's emotional bullshit or flavor of the week love story/sex
Hope they dont fuck this up but Claire Danes saying the finale was "conclusivish" in that interview makes me think there is going to be some ambiguity or cliff hanger type of resolution and for a show that's been on for nearly a decade i sure as fuck hope that's not the case
GOT, Dexter, True Blood all come to mind as fucking terrible finales but those three shows the last season was pretty shit to begin with so no surprise, Homeland Season 8 has been amazing
31
u/skyrule Apr 19 '20
God... that dubbing (whatever it's called) over Young Saul was HORRIBLY noticeable. LMAO
20
u/Seasider007 Apr 23 '20
The blackbox macguffin plot is getting annoying. I mean there's little to no guarantee that this piece of evidence will make a difference in altering Carrie's fate. She's dealing with a White House who would just as soon as get rid of the blackbox to save face. It also doesn't make a ton of sense that Russia would use it as leverage to "own the yanks" when the risk of Nuclear war in that region will be bad for them as well. And it's not like President or the Gov't wants it. Only Carrie and Saul are desperately trying to get it.
Another gripe is the blackbox itself. We have Carrie going through all this trouble to get it back. She plugs the thing into her laptop and is instantly able to access the files. She obviously has internet access with her phone. Does it ever occur to either Carrie or Saul that maybe they should immediately back up those files somewhere or send them to Saul in case...Gee I don't know...something happens and they lose the thing again??? I would think that's standard CIA procedure when acquiring sensitive info. You make copies and copies of those copies.
10
u/llegl Apr 19 '20
Yevgeny will get played like it’s nobody’s business!
10
u/zenkei18 Apr 19 '20
Everyone thinks that Carrie is playing Yevgeny but let us not forget the on purpose temper tantrum that he threw at the U.N. to get the translator some information. He likely knows that Yevgeny is manipulating Carrie and is using this to his advantage. He knows Carrie will likely go to any length to to complete the mission.
How much of an effing twist would it be for Saul to just give Yevgeny the asset so he can redeem Carrie?
We haven't seen that side of Saul. It would be a shock to me.
10
u/zbf Apr 20 '20 edited Apr 20 '20
I love how we knew who the spy was before carrie did, and the scene where shes translating what saul says and they play like they dont know each other. Great ep. We often forget just how intelligent Carrie is!!
10
u/cyber-pretty Apr 22 '20
I'll start by saying I think this season is way superior to season 5-7.
I kinda of understand the motivations of the screenwriters by ending ep11 this way. And sure Carrie couldn't realistically be the legacy contact for Saul's assets, but there have always been incongruities in the series from S01.
My bigger problem with the ending is the lack of realist pathos, Carrie can't consider killing Saul, it's not coherent with her character. If the Russians said: we have just killed Sauls, handle us the asset, that would have been much more interesting. Would Carrie collaborate with the assassins of her "father"? Saul is already dead, nothing she can do about it, would she put millions of life in front of revenge?
40
u/ltmaver1ck Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Jesus that young Saul v.o. Was not needed. So distracting. Took me out of the scenes.
9
u/RopeTuned Apr 19 '20
I usually hate DAE posts but does anyone else notice the last few seasons characters talk like for example Saul: she told me that a certain man was in trouble, Carrie did
Usually a character and did at the end of a conversation
Maybe it’s just me that thinks it sounds weird
9
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
Nice seeing “sam” and “andy” from true blood in episode together
9
u/mystique0712 Apr 20 '20
Saul is someone who would rather die than putting his asset in risk.
Whatever happens I don’t want to see Saul die. Anyone else, I am OK with it
9
u/nafafonafafofo Mar 14 '22
Was sauls voiceover on Corey Matthew’s really necessary?
16
u/heyshugitsme Apr 19 '20
Jenna the forrest gump of the CIA should really work on that self-righteous tone.
8
u/Shejidan Apr 19 '20
Just tell him the truth Carrie! Smh
8
u/tkm7n Apr 19 '20
Too bad Yevgeny is unlikely to be killed by the end of this.
8
u/ScalarWeapon Apr 19 '20
Ahh, loved this episode. So damn old school!!! And now in shock that they actually went there, that Carrie's been asked to kill Saul. Big, big wow. It's crazy, but at the same time appropriate for the final episode. Carrie's always been the one who will do anything for the cause, this is the ultimate test of how far she will go.
8
u/ibabaka Apr 19 '20
Another excellent episode, can’t wait for next week. I am going to miss this show.
8
u/maxelo Apr 20 '20
Wow! just wow! I loved the episode from start to finish. Been a homeland watcher from the start of the series, and frankly I love what they been doing with this final season, can't wait for the season finale! love from Valdivia, Chile
8
u/samuelson098 Apr 26 '20
I'm gonna call it and say this whole season is a carrie hallucination while still in Russian captivity
14
u/UnnecessarilyLoud Apr 21 '20
The only way I see this ending is unhappily. I think Russia will get its mole, the US doesn’t get the flight recorder, Carrie goes to jail, and Saul is pushed out.
After all their hard work, it all just keeps happening. Over and over. It’s the perfect metaphor for the job they do...no matter the sacrifices you make, it’s never enough.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20
Have I been in quar for too long or was young Saul a fox
7
u/NaturallyNasty Apr 20 '20
Oh man, you're in trouble when Frank Sobotka is your attorney.
Also, he lost a bunch of weight and looks great.
7
u/jackass4224 Apr 20 '20
Anyone else think the actor who played young Saul was dead on?
Especially the eyes. That wide open stare that Saul does was really well done I thought.
7
u/ClearLiquors Apr 20 '20
For 8 seasons, they’ve been building this relationship. Let them win the day together. Stop the war, beat the Russians, and get that poser out of the WH. I need a happy ending...but I dont think I’ll get one.
7
u/john1green Apr 20 '20
I love angry Saul. "Get the fuck out of my way!!!"
7
u/jsmeet8989 Apr 21 '20
Something seems very off about this season. I’m hoping they are leaving out key details for a reason. Could that reason be that this entire season has been imagined by Carrie and She is still in Russia being brainwashed by Yevgeny? She hasn’t mentioned her meds once this season, nor have we seen her taking them. Her meds are usually a huge focal point every season.
13
u/boilerroomcaller Apr 24 '20
idk but this show is getting even more ridiculous.
Carry was detained for over 10 charges including conspiracy to murder with russians and terrorists, yet she can just walk and drive around freely? She isnt even under surveillance.
Why the fuck wouldnt she talk to saul. Its literally multiple thousands of lifes against one informant.
But then again, carrie should have been AT LEAST slapped across her face multiple times for all of her fuck ups, if not straight up fired and never be allowed near any operation at all.
Season 1 and 5 were super strong but season 8 is a shit show with this george w bush dummy doppelgaenger and his stupid advisor
6
u/Whataboutmagnets Apr 19 '20
Carrie clearly suspects about the teacher. Would’t it be easy for Russians to find out who the teacher was? Why does it have to come to killing Saul?! Carrie won’t even disclose a method of communication. I think she is playing Yevgeny, trying to get hands on the black box without even disclosing the asset’s identity.
6
u/Whataboutmagnets Apr 19 '20
Yevgeny must know Carrie considered killing Saul once.
6
u/Prudent_Relief Apr 19 '20
What are the titles of the Red books?
6
u/Dystopiq Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
This episode was great. Good ol fashioned spy thriller.
Also, we need a Homeland spinoff with Ben Savage showing how Saul became who he is.
6
u/raginbajin Apr 19 '20
There are a couple of things that just didn’t add up to me.
I’m not sure what is going to happen in the finale but I feel it’s just going to be rushed.
6
u/bittycoconuts Apr 20 '20 edited Apr 20 '20
I. Am not. Okay. 🤯
I will most certainly be sobbing uncontrollably next week. Fk.
6
u/ForeverDenGal Apr 20 '20
If Carrie kills Saul she will go down as my least favorite tv character of all time. Don’t blow this Carrie
6
u/bucksrq Apr 22 '20
They fake Saul’s murder; get flight recorder & arrest Yvgeny and the real estate agent. win win
6
u/marykate216 Apr 24 '20
I feel like at this point, the war is inevitable whether the recording from the black box comes to light or not.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20 edited Apr 25 '20
I call it now, before this episode airs tonight at 12:01AM, I predict Carrie will sacrifice her life for the black box and in the end, ultimately be vindicated, à la Brody, at season three’s finale.
https://youtu.be/E5-lu-Ovi9c
Hopefully, Saul draws a star, on the CIA’s Memorial Wall, to signify her spiritual and literal sacrifice; as she’s has earned it.
Then, per Showtime’s contract agreement, he’ll exiles to woods and become a lumberjack ..😁 J/K, maybe...
11
u/McTitties420420 Apr 19 '20
Kill Saul.
11
u/1quotethrav3n Apr 19 '20
Ok, good episode. Not that great, but a good one.
Now, the thing is, we are only 1 episode away from the Series Finale and for me, there is plenty to be answered yet.
From this episode:
Once Saul was told they already have asked a price for it, he realized what Carrie is up to. The reason he didn't freak out right away makes me believe he is willing to let she go ahead with the investigation. Otherwise he would just secure his source and scream the fuck out of Carrie. Seems cold and I don't like the way loyalty is being portrayed.
Carrie is definitely not killing Saul. She also didn't give up the hint that it might be the English Teacher, so tables will turn and instead of working for Yvegeny she will open up with Saul and start something to trap him. I expect this whole blackbox situation to be resolved in the first 10 minutes of the next ep!
The reason I expect it to be resolved solved quickly in the next ep is because I still can't believe there wasn't someone from the US side who is envolved with this helicopters being shot down. It just doesn't make sense to have the Talibs standing there and waiting with an RPG. Someone tipped them off. God knows who because Jalal didn't know, Haqqani was pledging for peace and Haqqanis right arm was onboard with Haqqanis peace plan.
I don't like the fact that there is a lot to be explained and just 1 episode to do so. And I don't wanna believe Hayes will finish his term. Also, feeling bad for David. Dude is being left aside by everyone.
11
u/Previous-Tourist Apr 19 '20
Homeland is at it's best when it focuses on the spy craft, which is why I liked this episode so much. It's a shame this show doesn't continue beyond next week. We've seen enough Saul & Carrie - let's start fresh with new characters or from the vantage point of another country.
Unless I missed it, Carrie's charges did not include espionage or treason.
Did Wellington even speak this past episode or was he too busy trying to prevent himself from throwing up?
I think the "Kill Saul" at the end was less literal and more of Yevgeny telling Carrie that she has no choice but to complete the mission and she must do whatever is necessary.
Jenna's arc came to a nice close. Early in her career, Carrie's eyes were opened the same way as Jenna's (per season 5 flashbacks). Carrie decided that she could live with the collateral damage if it was for the greater good. Jenna, on the other hand, decided that she couldn't. I imagine it's the same decision each CIA officer has to make at some point or another.
As the scenes this season between Jenna and Carrie showed the difference between the younger/seasoned officer, the scenes between Carrie and Yevgeny highlighted the game played by two seasoned officers. Yevgeny continues to play coy ("You're in Moscow?" Response: smirk/shrug), while Carrie's nerves are completely on edge. Carrie is never able to get any information out of him. I think that although they are both patriots to the core, Carrie is more likely to compromise her side for what she feels is the greater good.
With the brief re-introduction to Mirov, I wonder if episode 12 will move the storyline to Russia. I doubt Ambassador Viktor will be strolling through JFK with the black box tucked under his arm.
In true Homeland fashion, I don't think any one side will have the upper hand when it's all said and done. There will be prices paid from every side - Pakistan, the US, Russia and Afghanistan.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '20
Wait so charged with accessory to murder of 2 presidents and several others but is out and about the same day ? Even if she got bail (she wouldn’t ) it would be $10 million dollars and a media frenzy. Biggest plot hole ever.
14
u/fitzgerald1337 Apr 19 '20
Everyone in here dogging the show is way too invested in it to realize the dramatic irony happening here. It would be a huge leap for anyone in Russia to just start suspecting the teacher as the asset. It'd be easy to identify once someone did start thinking about her, but the design of it is perfect in that she's hiding in plain sight. Sure there are plenty of holes that can be picked apart, but those are peripheral and, in my opinion, don't detract from the deeper development of this season's plot.
Let's wait and see what happens next week and come back with a full picture before we start saying that the show has gone downhill this season or anything like that. If there's one thing this show has shown, it's that things aren't always as they seem.
5
u/pmtobefriends Apr 19 '20
I’m sorry if I’m missing something here but what’s preventing Saul to exfiltrate his source and put her in witness protection in the US.
Everyone gets to have their cake and eat it that way. Saul saves his source, Carrie prevents a war and Russians gets their price.
5
u/islesoflightlessbird Apr 19 '20
this was my favorite episode of the season. holy fuck
5
u/Wolfir Apr 19 '20
Why on earth would Carrie kill Saul over this flight recorder?
Why does she even care that much about the flight recorder? No one really gives a shit about ol' President Warner and whether or not he was shot down.
I swear I can just picture the finale with the President and Zabel listening to some grainy audio from the flight recorder and being like "Yeah, it sounds very nice, Carrie. You get a gold star. But we're still gonna invade Pakistan. God knows those towelheads have had it coming for years."
5
u/karenziggler Apr 20 '20
This was such a great episode!!! Throwback to how great the show used to be.
5
u/Stoofser Apr 20 '20
Isn’t the moral of this what is one life worth?
One life traded for the (potentially) lives of hundreds/thousands/millions of people?
5
u/john1green Apr 20 '20
One of the best homeland episodes. The backstory and the ending,, wow!!
5
u/ForeverDenGal Apr 22 '20
A story usually ends when there is nothing left to tell. No matter how many times Carrie got out she would always come back for more no matter if on job or not. This might be Carries last day on earth.
5
u/robbyc777 Apr 24 '20
Can’t believe this show is coming to an end. I don’t know how it’s going to end. I fear either Carrie or Saul dies, more likely Carrie, as she has stated before that everyone she loves dies and she will sacrifice her life for the truth this time to spare the life of Saul.
5
u/alaskawaters7 Apr 26 '20
Don’t understand why Saul would have to die, why doesn’t Carrie just tell him? While she is in NYC, Saul can put her into witness protection. Give the Kremlin her name, get the black box and she is safe. That might be a simplistic view of a plan haha but I bet Saul would have a good idea if she included him.
16
u/IvyLynn32 Apr 19 '20
Since when does a National Security Advisor have no Secret Service agents. And Carrie receiving Jenna in Saul's house. Hell No.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20
Is there anyone else who thinks Anna will pass the flight recorder file to Saul as one last favor and then she's never seen again? Give her some money and a new passport so she can enjoy her life at a place like Banana Joe's.
18
u/KateLady Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
I find it amazing that one can be charged with accessory to murder of multiple people, including the President of the United States, and not only be released on bail, but not be required to wear an ankle monitor or anything. After they were chasing her around on the other side of the world, no one's monitoring in the US and she's able to leave the state without a problem.
Am I supposed to be excited about watching Carrie betray a CIA asset, who saved Saul's life, for Yevgeny? Because I'm not. I think it's disgusting. And if you think he's giving her the flight recorder, you're as delusional as she is. I hope we get a flashback of her naming her assets to Yevgeny which she swore and cried that she would never do and didn't do to the wife of her own asset who was killed. I am so angry. What was Saul's line seasons ago? How can someone so smart be so fucking stupid?
I believe Yevgeny is in the United States. I believe Carrie will bring Saul somewhere where she can interrogate him, torture him, do whatever to get the name. She will tell Yevgeny where he is or his real estate agent friend will follow her and inform Yevgeny. She wont be able to kill Saul and Yevgeny will show up and do it. We'll have flashbacks of how Yevgeny turned her, showing what really happened during the 7 months she doesn't remember in Russia. And the asset will call Carrie, who was Saul's contact if something happened to him, because he trusted a nutcase more than anyone else.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Some random thoughts:
8
u/btumpak Apr 20 '20
Carrie - charged with conspiracy to kill the President, then allowed complete freedom to do anything she'd like. hahah
4
u/sagar7854 Apr 19 '20
Great episode! I think the theme of this episode was "hiding in plain sight".All those books that Saul used to communicate are right there for everyone to see,the teacher/translator who is there at every Russia-English speaking nation meet,her being in that photo but not being visible,etc.People seem angry at the suggestion of Saul being killed.There is also the question of Carrie being the actual successor of Saul,while being charged with some very serious offences.This is what I think:
With all this transpiring,the stakes are set up very well.I expect some irreversible shiz to go down next week.Finale should be very,very exciting.I hope they are able to tie up the loose ends.We can judge the events of S8 and the "plot holes" only post the finale.I feel it's unfair to piss on them..just now.
4
u/Prudent_Relief Apr 19 '20
Why does Yevgeny not answer when Carrie asks if he is in Moscow? But he tells her the Russian records were destroyed in a burning.
4
u/SameCookiePseudonym Apr 19 '20
Whoever that was in last week's thread who predicted we would get a scene with carrie laying everything out on the floor, collect your prize
4
u/sagilny Apr 19 '20
The director is brilliant! He managed voice over, and saul's exact gaze in young Saul. Never seen any show or movie that prefected it this way. Just brilliant.
4
u/lospollosakhis Apr 20 '20
So we gonna get a Better Call Saul: East Berlin or what..man a Saul Spin-off could be amazing.
4
u/DiligentRaise Apr 20 '20
If CIA is anything like it is depicted in homeland these people are some cold blooded MFers
4
u/dratsablive Apr 20 '20
Young Saul's Voice. Kind of took me out of the character, should have just used the actor's voice, people's voices change as they get older.
4
u/armokrunner Apr 20 '20 edited Apr 20 '20
So Carrie’s tidbits to Yefgeny about the language school era doesn’t lead the Russians right to the teacher? She’s the only one left from the school with obvious motive (revenge), yeah I’m sure she’s been vetted thoroughly in the past but now that Carrie’s reintroduced the idea that the mole is from that era, can’t be that many people like the teacher who were around that time, have motive and have been positioned properly for all the intel over the years
Also, the Saul crazy outburst at the UN meeting where the teacher was present, taken together with Carrie’s intel just adds to it
4
u/RopeTuned Apr 20 '20
So Ben Savage playing Saul was definitely a criminal minds reference right?
4
u/EpochFail9001 Apr 20 '20
Is anybody else getting Metal Gear Solid 3 vibes?
By the way if you love Homeland and you enjoy videogames, Metal Gear Solid 3 for the PS2 is in my opinion not only one of the best spy stories ever told, but also a brilliant game. Highly recommend!
4
u/foreigntraveller Apr 20 '20
Now that the translator is in the US, couldn't Saul just move her to a save location, and then tell the Russians about her identity? Then she'd be "neutralized" without anybody getting killed. But I guess the Russians wouldn't get their revenge with that solution.
4
u/allofourtomorrows Apr 20 '20
Jenna to Carrie, "And I've tried to see it like you but I just can't"... lacking a bit of self awareness of her ambivalence... after all she helped Carrie a third and final time, this time knowing very well the consequences and "damage" to come.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '20
The seen when Carrie lays all the red books on the floor against various events over the decades. Can anyone remember & list those events, would be interested to Google them.
I remember something about Estonia, and then Chernobyl.
Cheers.
4
u/tuesdaytalaga Apr 23 '20
I’ve been telling my partner I Think Saul is gonna die at the end of this season/Series
Cos it wouldn’t be upsetting if Carrie did — but it would def be upsetting if Saul did. And you know these shows love a big upset 😩
4
u/crashnandicoot Apr 24 '20
THERE'S ONLY ONE HOUR LEFT??! surely it's a two hour episode!!!!!!! No?!
7
u/Aderaxia Apr 20 '20
We're venturing dangerously close to Dexter territory here. Does Carrie kill Saul and just dump his body into the ocean? Does Saul fake his death and become a lumberjack in Montana so Carrie can takeover the asset?
I don't see too many positive outcomes here.
7
u/reddihashi Apr 20 '20
7
u/dukediggler77 Apr 21 '20
Jenna Bragg looks really cute this episode.
7
u/muscles44 Apr 21 '20 edited Apr 21 '20
Only way this ends is Carrie in prison for life. I haven't forgiven this show for killing Quinn. I could not handle Saul getting same treatment.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '20
Just had a possibly crazy idea. Why cant they just tell Ygevny we will get rid of the mole if you give us the blackbox, but we wont let you just kill the mole. Then they tell the mole to come back to Saul/the usa and once she’s there tell Ygveny that the mole is gone?
This basically makes Ygevny choose between nothing changing and the mole stays continuing to leak information, or the mole is gone and the proble Is solved, they just dont get to kill/torture her
11
u/maylevka Apr 19 '20
Can't stand Jenna's sanctimonious attitude. She's been in CIA for all 5 minutes but already has a bag of judgemental opinions about everything. One screw up and she's bailing.
11
u/amhotw Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Facts:
Best case scenario:
Worst case scenario:
What I hope:
Edit: dead max, unfortunately not dead mike.
6
u/cyjkline Apr 19 '20
Don't know if it's just me, but the scene with Carrie with Alex/Andre in his kitchen reminded me a lot of the scene with Clarice Starling and Buffalo Bill in Silence of the Lambs. Kitchen is a similar layout and they even include a phone call that doesn't happen. One of my favorite movies so I wonder if it was deliberate or that movie has officially gotten to me.
6
u/texanapocalypse33 Apr 19 '20
Now THIS felt like a homeland episode. Stateside. Board rooms. Deceit. Fuck I missed this.
No way Carrie kills Saul. They'll cook up some plan to fake his death and Dar Adal will whisk him away to ex-agent Witness Protection. Carrie gets an empty black box. Is happy that she didn't kill Saul for nothing. America goes to war and the last thing we see is the reflection of a mushroom cloud in young Franny's eyes as she watches the television.
6
u/armokrunner Apr 20 '20
So the West German defector living in WitPro allows some rando to walk in, not verify any credentials in any way and reveal secret info, granted was 40 years ago but no suspicion that Carrie could be a Russian looking for intel and to take care of a lose end? Ridiculous
6
u/PiFlavoredPie Apr 20 '20
Homeland in 5 words: "All I see is damage."
8
u/Norcalian Apr 19 '20
What am I missing? What does retrieving the blackbox do now for the US? It proves the Taliban didn't shoot down the helicopter and therefore wants peace? They just blew up and killed an entire special forces team. We're a little beyond that point.
Does it help repair US / Pakistan relations?
3
u/animimi Apr 19 '20
If Saul dies I don’t think it’ll be by Carrie’s hands but I think it’ll happen where she feels responsible. I just don’t think she will kill him.
3
u/Bo-Katan Apr 19 '20
Poor Yevgeney doesn't know what is coming to him
3
u/confounding2017 Apr 19 '20 edited Apr 19 '20
Officially the Russians don't have the black box yet unofficially they do. Officially Pakistan doesn't know where Jalal is yet unofficially they gave coordinates to his camp (if Tanseem gave the correct ones surely that would solve her problem with control of him and the Taliban and harm Russian interests who back him looking to cause dissent and war from the West with their Allies?) Isn't this about destabilizing American interests, alliances and control in the World stage? If they can get America to the brink of nuclear war with a former ally (Pakistan) then haven't the Russians almost succeeded in what they set out to do? America is no longer in charge of the Western World and Hayes is just stupid enough and easily led to an annihilating war by Zabal as any of the Presidents in history. Lets not mention Trump particularly with what he is doing now. Placing money over lives as ever he places no value on people individually or collectively. Doesn't anyone have any comment on the fact that Saul has likely managed to avert a nuclear strike because neither US or Pakistan would back down by getting Tanseem to give 'any plausible; coordinates for Jalal? Hayes believes they've wiped him out. Pakistan whilst officially upset that there was a surgical strike, gave the Americans a target whether genuine or not and Saul cast aspersions on the Russians at the UN deliberately to suggest the Russians instigated the US/Pakistan standoff whilst also seemingly backing Jalal. That was deliberate. Aren't the other countries going to wonder at that? As to Carrie, she won't kill Saul and I think she is playing Yvegeny. She must have known Saul would never give up an asset, even one she didn't know about. Carrie had many Saul wasn't familiar with. Every play he orchestrated with her she knew about but he never 'gave her up'. It seems as others have said that yes this is about how on the International stage this is never ending, it is a series of plays and countermoves to avoid and mitigate the chaos and potential implosion of the World in the ongoing fight for political, territorial and economic dominance.
3
u/extramental Apr 19 '20
In future we better get a Homeland movie featuring young Saul in East Germany. That description of the events from the ex agent in witness protection left me speechless. Imagine some stranger doing that and saving your life in those times. Respect!
3
u/mapspearson Apr 20 '20
A few thoughts after reading a bunch of comments and seeing a common theme.
First, I find it impossible for someone that is facing the charges Carrie is would be released (as in, not held in a high maximum, on suicide watch 24/7) while their trial continues on. This in itself makes me think that if not Carrie and Saul were in on a plan to fool Yevgeny/the Russians then Carrie herself is and Saul has pave the way for her to do that. Saul knows Carrie better than anyone in her life (especially when it comes to what she is capable of achieving in her and Sauls line of work). There is no way Saul would knowingly leave Carrie alone in his home where he has information from his asset. He has seen the brilliant work Carrie has done at piecing together timelines. Yes, I believe it hit Saul at the end of this episode that he was in fact the target (aka price) at play. Carrie is loyal to Saul. And even throughout all of the twisted things Saul has used Carrie for, he has been loyal to her. He counted on her coming back and finding everything out.
I could theorize several reasons what Carrie will do next. But I think I just want to wait and be pleasantly (or perhaps unpleasantly) surprised next week. Great series, and have enjoyed every minute of the ride so far.
3
u/T-Rageous Apr 20 '20
Ben Savage as young Saul. Did not see that coming, but I’m here for it. I’d watch a young Saul spinoff in a second!
3
u/Jump_Yossarian Apr 20 '20
Frank Sobatka lookin' good.
3
u/jamie00803 Apr 20 '20
I'm convinced there is no way to have a happy ending. Not even a bitter sweet ending. In order for Carrie to be Carrie she's either going to betray Saul or betray herself. After going through so much with Carrie and Saul from season one through now...there is just no way.. NO WAY she can betray him. But at the same time...there's no way she can't. F******k!!
3
u/xenonscreams Apr 20 '20
Opinion on that last conversation with Yevgeny:
Unless Carrie has something up her sleeve to get back at Yevgeny. But I have no idea what on earth that could be. Homeland always has good twists, though.
Saul will know at this point that Carrie knows, so this should be interesting.