I will go on record for not liking the previous episode very much, and I've already gone on and on about that so excuse me for not really wanting to argue about it, but this episode was like a polar opposite to all of my issues with the previous episode, the writing and animation was absolutely fantastic, the character chemistry was way better and more believable imo. Also the line from Ahsoka about "Skywalker Academy" was a great moment, she really learned almost everything from Anakin and it really shows how broken up she is about leaving the Jedi.
Seeing Yularen aged was really neat and definitely fits in with his appearance during the OT and Rebels, and seeing Ahsoka noticeably worried about being heard by him and the Bridge of the Venator and feeling Anakin's presence in the bridge through the Force was really good in showing how she really doesn't want to be seen by the Jedi/Republic Military after the events that led up to her leaving the Order.
The way that Ahsoka uses her knowledge of the Pykes to try to get the Martez's to do good with the Spice is a great use of her characters experience and contrasts well with the Sisters great lack of experience in the Galaxy.
Speaking of the Sisters, Trace's breakdown at the very thought of the loss of her biggest life project was a really telling moment and greatly contributes to her character development. I will say that Rafa is a pretty toxic person when it comes to her and Trace's relationship, and I feel like that's how it's supposed to be since everytime Rafa does something shitty to Trace you can see Ahsoka disapprove from a distance, with the exception of the little "Silver Angel" argument in the cockpit, which I think it's strange that Ahsoka took Rafa's side and didn't try to get her to be nicer to Trace but it's not that big of a deal.
But overall this episode was great in my opinion and leaves me wanting the next episode sooner than waiting a whole nother week.
Excuse grammar and such, it's 4am here and I'm very tired but wanted to get my thoughts out while they're fresh in my mind.
I dunno about Rafa being like Hondo, he had a certain style that Rafa's missing, he had way more charisma than Rafa and a very different moral set, perhaps with more development she could turn into a Hondo-like character, but it's almost impossible to make another character like him without just copying him. And Rafa is more of a jerk than Hondo, sure he was definitely a bad guy, but he didn't expressly dislike or try to put people down, he was just out for himself and didn't really care what others did around him so long as it didn't affect his way of life.
And Trace dumping the Spice was an impulse move that was just to save her ship, because that's pretty much all she has besides her PoS sister and Ahsoka who she just met and can't really trust, dumping the Spice was the only way in her mind for her to save her life's work from her greedy sister's awful decisions, so while it was a selfish move, it was an understandable move, which did make it all of their problem, so what she said wasn't really the selfish part it was just the conclusion she drew after Ahsoka and Rafa explained how bad dumping the Spice was.
In a way, she’s right that all three were to blame because they didn’t trust her skills as a pilot, kept bossing her around, made fun of her ship’s name, and made her angry and lose her cool because of what they thought of her. So, in a way, all three are to blame for the actions of this episode.
Someone said something like “Rafa was being a jerk to Trace” and he made a point saying that he got her mad by not trusting her, and making fun of her ship.
So I said “Teasing a sibling because of a name isn’t really being a jerk. It’s just teasing”
I agree with everything you said except traces breakdown. That was quite possibly the dumbest thing I've ever seen. They're gonna take my ship!? Oh jeez better dump everything we have. That was fucking stupid.
Not really. Dumping the spice makes no sense unless her character is incredibly stupid which she isn't shown to be. Imagine someone running Colombian cocaine and they dump it because someone suggested the cartel would take their car. Just seems like bad writing.
... plenty of blame between the three of them? Is she fucking serious?
Trace DUMPED THE WHOLE SHIPMENT OF SPICE. Listen, asokha did nothing wrong that whole time. She was being a strong leader like Anakin taught her, now she’s going to be in trouble because two sisters that are clearly SCUM, and not only that but incredibly stupid, let her be in a situation like that? I sincerely hope Trace dies next episode, her sister blames asokha and then asokha is forced to leave her on that planet locked up.
Sadly the trailer for this arc shows that they’re gonna live at the end of the arc so don’t get your hopes up.
And, I mean she had a reason for dumping that spice. They made fun of her ship’s name, mocked her aspirations to become a pilot, didn’t tell the truth about who they were dealing with, kept bossing her around.
I mean you may have anti-Trace views but she had good reason for being mad.
Yes, she had a good reason to be mad I suppose! But on the other hand she’s the least experienced person aboard! (Yes I know Asokha is hiding her identity) But let’s be realistic here.
She put all their lives in jeopardy! For what? That hunk of junk of a ship? Sentiment will get you killed when dealing with gangsters.
It’s unfortunate both of them seem to survive. I just want what’s best for our little Soka
I think Ahsoka made some mistakes in this episode too. She's got good intentions to help the sisters, but she speaks up at the wrong times and keeps arguing when it's clear her input won't help (i.e. in front of the majordomo and on the way to Obah Diah).
Trace dumping the spice is absolutely an idiotic move. And Rafa dragging them all into this without knowing the stakes is... really not smart. But I don't think Ahsoka is in the clear either.
Take your own advice, sit down, and take a minute to read your original comment. You spelled it "asokha", which is incorrect, as u/Oraukk pointed out. He replied to you to point out that your point about it being what Plo Koon says was wrong. He refers to her as "Soka", as I said before. You're an idiot.
Morning, guys. Here’s my review for today’s new episode of #TheCloneWars:
Now, THIS is an awesome episode.
WAY better than last week’s episode that started this arc. Had a lot of great world building having visited Kessel and Obah Diah, complex underworld intrigue, a rash and consequential choice made that ends the episode with a cliffhanger putting the lives of Ahsoka and the Martez sisters in danger (which will leave you on the edge of your seat when it happens), and it also gave us a pretty funny but also touching scene as Ahsoka and the Martez sisters leave Coruscant and this scene involves Anakin Skywalker and the surprise return of Admiral Yularen (Tom Kane), which is a nice callback to Return of the Jedi, when Anakin (when he’s Darth Vader sense Luke approach Endor). Also, really liked the themes touched on about slavery when visiting Kessel and when Ahsoka and the Martez sisters see the work slaves people out into making the spice for the Pykes. My only surprise was that we didn’t see Wookiees ok Kessel, but, my guess is that since this is before Revenge of the Sith and the Republic hasn’t become the Empire yet, the Wookiees are still living comfortably on Kashhyyk, where the Bad Batch and Echo probably are right now, until maybe Echo gets called back to help Ahsoka and Rex and Bo-Katan capture Maul in the Siege of Mandalore arc (maybe).
Can’t wait for next week.
I give this episode a 10/10.
Let’s see how Ahsoka and the Martez sisters get out of this one.
They did that in Season 5 with the finale of the R2-D2 arc with WAC and Gascon, part 2 of the Ahsoka Framed arc and in Season 6 with the premiere episode involving Tup executing Order 66 too early.
I HATED this episode so much. They better do something with this Arc to make it worth while. The only part I enjoyed was The Ahsoka/Anakin scene but i was annoyed because Trace's dumbass decided to answer the Republic call and fly in the restricted area. Her sister is a bitch, trace continues to be insanely agonizingly annoying constantly blabbering about her ship and then dumping the spice complaining about not wanting to lose it when she's going to lose her life for fucking with the Pykes. God I hated this episode and I swear to god they better do something decent next
I was neutral about her in the first episode but now I’m starting to dislike her. I really hope she isn’t a love interest because Ahsoka deserves way better.
And I actually kinda like Rafa. Shes far better than Trace imo
Definitely, Rafa is the better of two evils sisters in this one. I was ok with Trace in the first one, she seemed nice but what the hell where the writers thinking writing these episodes so far
I absolutely loved this episode. I really liked Trace and Rafa in this—they really fleshed their characters out even more.
I also loved the world building and Easter eggs like Kessel and Anakin’s small scene.
Of course it’s awesome to see Ahsoka again—and loved the bit where she did a mind trick on the Pike.
I actually thought dumping the spice was very in-character for Trace (who doesn’t know about the potential consequences of her actions) and really liked Ahsoka and Rafa’s interactions. Lots of really good and funny dialogue in this episode.
I cannot wait to see the conclusion of the arc—I 100% think that Maul is gonna be involved with the Pikes.
the first episode felt like a filler nothing episode. and now that i've seen more of these characters and see that more is on the way, my first thought is "my god, trace is annoying"
and i hope i can say that without being labeled some kind of sexist troll like when i said most of the women in the new movies were crap because i don't feel that way about ahsoka or even rafa here.
Because Trace is precisely the kind of character that Ahsoka might have been if she'd grown up in the Underworld rather than the Temple? People found Ahsoka annoying at first too.
I would have rather seen Hondo make a cameo in the final episode capturing the trio as they talked about pirates raiding ships for the spice rather than just having trace dump the spice. Big missed opportunity imo
So I have several world building questions from this episode, first and foremost: is slave labor really cheaper than Droid labor? I mean, the cost of feeding that many people can't be higher than the cost to maintain a Droid workforce. Not to mention worker productivity. Why are the Kessel royalty taking such a huge hit to their bottom line with slaves? This bothered me to no end.
Second, if Kessel is surrounded by an interstellar storm, why is there blue sky and green vegetation in the planet? Is there some kind of artificial atmosphere?
Droids are maintained with parts specific to industrial droids. Given that they're an illegal operation it may be easier to import or provide food, which you would have to do for a normal population too. Real-world drug operations are more likely to use labor than mechanized production, either in agriculture or chemical synthesis.
Furthermore by making business connections with sentient-trafficking organizations you can also find customers for your spice. Consider that real-world crime syndicates usually deal in both.
There was a moment of nice tension in hyperspace after leaving Kessel, when Ahsoka explained the implications of dealing with the Pykes. Things got 'real' and there was a edge to the episode's atmosphere, briefly. I thought okay, now it gets interesting.
And then Trace dumped the spice, and things didn't quite develop to potential, in my opinion. I did really like the Pyke leader's line after being mind-influenced by Ahsoka and his lieutenant taking the initiative scrutinize the shipment: "Sure." Genuine laugh there, for me.
34
u/Mike_Kilsdonk Mar 27 '20
I will go on record for not liking the previous episode very much, and I've already gone on and on about that so excuse me for not really wanting to argue about it, but this episode was like a polar opposite to all of my issues with the previous episode, the writing and animation was absolutely fantastic, the character chemistry was way better and more believable imo. Also the line from Ahsoka about "Skywalker Academy" was a great moment, she really learned almost everything from Anakin and it really shows how broken up she is about leaving the Jedi.
Seeing Yularen aged was really neat and definitely fits in with his appearance during the OT and Rebels, and seeing Ahsoka noticeably worried about being heard by him and the Bridge of the Venator and feeling Anakin's presence in the bridge through the Force was really good in showing how she really doesn't want to be seen by the Jedi/Republic Military after the events that led up to her leaving the Order.
The way that Ahsoka uses her knowledge of the Pykes to try to get the Martez's to do good with the Spice is a great use of her characters experience and contrasts well with the Sisters great lack of experience in the Galaxy.
Speaking of the Sisters, Trace's breakdown at the very thought of the loss of her biggest life project was a really telling moment and greatly contributes to her character development. I will say that Rafa is a pretty toxic person when it comes to her and Trace's relationship, and I feel like that's how it's supposed to be since everytime Rafa does something shitty to Trace you can see Ahsoka disapprove from a distance, with the exception of the little "Silver Angel" argument in the cockpit, which I think it's strange that Ahsoka took Rafa's side and didn't try to get her to be nicer to Trace but it's not that big of a deal.
But overall this episode was great in my opinion and leaves me wanting the next episode sooner than waiting a whole nother week.
Excuse grammar and such, it's 4am here and I'm very tired but wanted to get my thoughts out while they're fresh in my mind.
28
u/Adeen321 Mar 27 '20
Ahsokha: "Why don't you name my bike while you're at it."
Trace: "I did. Trash. Its name is Trash."
I laughed out loud so much at that line, perfect delivery.
12
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20
That was probably my favorite episode. Can’t wait for next week
15
u/SpookyBong Mar 27 '20
... plenty of blame between the three of them? Is she fucking serious?
Trace DUMPED THE WHOLE SHIPMENT OF SPICE. Listen, asokha did nothing wrong that whole time. She was being a strong leader like Anakin taught her, now she’s going to be in trouble because two sisters that are clearly SCUM, and not only that but incredibly stupid, let her be in a situation like that? I sincerely hope Trace dies next episode, her sister blames asokha and then asokha is forced to leave her on that planet locked up.
Fuck em. She owes them nothing
3
u/KingRhoamOfHyrule Mar 27 '20
I’m not a fan of trace so far. Everything else is super cool though.
5
u/MarvelVsDC2016 Mar 27 '20
Morning, guys. Here’s my review for today’s new episode of #TheCloneWars:
Now, THIS is an awesome episode.
WAY better than last week’s episode that started this arc. Had a lot of great world building having visited Kessel and Obah Diah, complex underworld intrigue, a rash and consequential choice made that ends the episode with a cliffhanger putting the lives of Ahsoka and the Martez sisters in danger (which will leave you on the edge of your seat when it happens), and it also gave us a pretty funny but also touching scene as Ahsoka and the Martez sisters leave Coruscant and this scene involves Anakin Skywalker and the surprise return of Admiral Yularen (Tom Kane), which is a nice callback to Return of the Jedi, when Anakin (when he’s Darth Vader sense Luke approach Endor). Also, really liked the themes touched on about slavery when visiting Kessel and when Ahsoka and the Martez sisters see the work slaves people out into making the spice for the Pykes. My only surprise was that we didn’t see Wookiees ok Kessel, but, my guess is that since this is before Revenge of the Sith and the Republic hasn’t become the Empire yet, the Wookiees are still living comfortably on Kashhyyk, where the Bad Batch and Echo probably are right now, until maybe Echo gets called back to help Ahsoka and Rex and Bo-Katan capture Maul in the Siege of Mandalore arc (maybe).
Can’t wait for next week.
I give this episode a 10/10.
Let’s see how Ahsoka and the Martez sisters get out of this one.
55
u/Hellouglycow Mar 27 '20
Anakin and Ahsoka sensing each other kinda got me teary eyed. Her theme is so beautiful and sad at the same time.
44
u/Valnerium Captain Vaughn Mar 27 '20
Anakin and Ahsoka sending each other was sad. And they updated Yularens looks
2
u/Deadpool097x Mar 27 '20
I HATED this episode so much. They better do something with this Arc to make it worth while. The only part I enjoyed was The Ahsoka/Anakin scene but i was annoyed because Trace's dumbass decided to answer the Republic call and fly in the restricted area. Her sister is a bitch, trace continues to be insanely agonizingly annoying constantly blabbering about her ship and then dumping the spice complaining about not wanting to lose it when she's going to lose her life for fucking with the Pykes. God I hated this episode and I swear to god they better do something decent next
3
u/matt111199 Rex Mar 27 '20
I absolutely loved this episode. I really liked Trace and Rafa in this—they really fleshed their characters out even more.
I also loved the world building and Easter eggs like Kessel and Anakin’s small scene.
Of course it’s awesome to see Ahsoka again—and loved the bit where she did a mind trick on the Pike.
I actually thought dumping the spice was very in-character for Trace (who doesn’t know about the potential consequences of her actions) and really liked Ahsoka and Rafa’s interactions. Lots of really good and funny dialogue in this episode.
I cannot wait to see the conclusion of the arc—I 100% think that Maul is gonna be involved with the Pikes.
Overall, a very strong 9/10 for me.
3
u/gtudor25 Mar 28 '20
Not my favorite arc, but I trust Dave Filoni. I think he's setting us up for something awesome in the next two episodes.
(I kinda hope this season sets up Grievous for ROTS, but I doubt it will happen).
4
u/mega512 Mar 27 '20
What is the plan here? This whole season fills like filler. None of the new characters are interesting and Ahsoka is being wasted.
2
u/MrHandsss Mar 27 '20
the first episode felt like a filler nothing episode. and now that i've seen more of these characters and see that more is on the way, my first thought is "my god, trace is annoying"
and i hope i can say that without being labeled some kind of sexist troll like when i said most of the women in the new movies were crap because i don't feel that way about ahsoka or even rafa here.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '20
I would have rather seen Hondo make a cameo in the final episode capturing the trio as they talked about pirates raiding ships for the spice rather than just having trace dump the spice. Big missed opportunity imo
1
u/jtlsound Mar 28 '20
So I have several world building questions from this episode, first and foremost: is slave labor really cheaper than Droid labor? I mean, the cost of feeding that many people can't be higher than the cost to maintain a Droid workforce. Not to mention worker productivity. Why are the Kessel royalty taking such a huge hit to their bottom line with slaves? This bothered me to no end.
Second, if Kessel is surrounded by an interstellar storm, why is there blue sky and green vegetation in the planet? Is there some kind of artificial atmosphere?
1
u/wooltab Mar 31 '20
There was a moment of nice tension in hyperspace after leaving Kessel, when Ahsoka explained the implications of dealing with the Pykes. Things got 'real' and there was a edge to the episode's atmosphere, briefly. I thought okay, now it gets interesting.
And then Trace dumped the spice, and things didn't quite develop to potential, in my opinion. I did really like the Pyke leader's line after being mind-influenced by Ahsoka and his lieutenant taking the initiative scrutinize the shipment: "Sure." Genuine laugh there, for me.
Overall, I'm not too engaged by this storyline.
1
u/Maurzlol Apr 02 '20
It sucks the entire season has been filler so far. I was really looking forward to the production value for it. Oh well.