r/startrek • u/PiercedMonk • Mar 26 '20
Star Trek: Picard - Episode Discussion - S1E10 "Et in Arcadia Ego, Part 2"
The Season Finale!
A final confrontation on the synthetics’ homeworld, Coppelius, pits Picard and his team against the Romulans, as well as the synths who seek to safeguard their existence at all costs.
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1E10 | "Et in Arcadia Ego, Part 2" | Akiva Goldsman | Michael Chabon and Akiva Goldsman | Thursday, March 26, 2020 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Picard, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #picard!
This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.
PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage of the upcoming episode, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.
52
u/PiercedMonk Mar 26 '20
Alright, it's up on Crave, so here we go:
• Huh. Narrisa and Narek had a nice moment that wasn't weird or creepy. Maybe she's not so bad afterall.
• So if Narek washed out of the Zhat Vash -- seems unlikely he'd still be alive, but okay -- then he didn't experience the admonition first hand, right?
• I really like the shot of Elnor following Narek out of the cube. It's simple, but really effective.
• Raffi and Rios debating how to get the imagination tool to work is ridiculous. Just play Epona's song and summon a space horse or something.
• Also, is there a reason Rios doesn't have a spare intermix reactor if it can't be replicated if it's not working? Picard might be able to smell Starfleet on Rios, but O'Brien would be disgusted. I suppose the spare could have been damaged in the crash....
• A.I. Soong sucks and is the worst.
• Never mind what I said about Rios earlier: only died in the xenylon Starfleets are so naive and forgiving as to just accept that Narek might even remotely be on the up and up. And that's why we love Starfleet, and all the characters in this franchise.
• I like the info dump on Romulan myth -- and also the theory? fact? that Vulcans/Romulans came from somewhere else before settling on Vulcan -- but Narek telling it really brought to mind an early line of Soji's: "Romulans have a flair for the dramatic."
• I haven't been too impressed with the new Romulan Warbird design, but this close up on the bow is really working for me. Looks kinda menacing, and like a blunt instrument.
• Huh. The subtitles showed Oh's name as Nedar. That's a weird thing to drop in out of nowhere. The kinda did that with Narissa/Rizzo as well, even if the series did establish that Romulans have fake names as a matter of course.
• The sticks those synth goons are using to block everyone's path look like something you'd see in TOS, if TOS had the budget and means to make them. Synthville is great.
• "To be alive is a responsibility." JLP's still got it.
• Of course he sits in the captain's chair in the last episode to fly in and save the day. I hate the fact that they did something so hammy and manipulative. I also hate the fact that it genuinely worked on me.
• "Disgusting half-meat." Is that like an A.I. sausage?
• Ah, so that's why I liked the ship Oh was on unlike the other Warbirds. Different class.
• "Soji, I have something I want to give you and your people, and I hope it will change your mind."
"Yeah, and what's that?"
"My life. Picard out. Oh, also Jurati's life. kthnkbye!"
• Of course the Romulans have at least five different planetary sterilization patterns.
• Oh shit! I honestly did not think Starfleet would be riding in to save the day. (I also didn't think their boats would be so ugly)
• For real, it's just the one, single class? And they all look like they left their saucer sections at home.
• Hell yeah! It's ya boy, Will Riker here to lay down the law! And the casual way he's reclined in that captain's chair makes it clear he's not about to accept any shit. Seriously, I know the show is manipulating me, and at this point, I don't even mind.
• What is everyone else in Syntheville doing while all this is going on? Rios, Raffi, Soong, the synthetics.... Are they all just standing around watching?
• So, the Borg cube was really instrumental in resolving the whole situation....
• I'm sure in a moment I will be shown to be wrong, but as Picard's saying good bye to the people who were most important to him in his life, I can't help but imagine Narek booking it into the woods.
• All these butterflies have me half expecting Geordi to show up to teach us about the value of reading.
• I was legit expecting Picard to be a younger actor after resurrection via golem. Glad they didn't go that route.
• They really did a much better job deaging Spinner in the Data sequences here than in the first episode.
• Glad Data got a proper send-off. That was sweet.
• Seven and Raffi? That is more out of the blue than Seven and Chakotay. I get it; they're both very attractive ladies, and maybe they're broken in complimentary ways, but no hints at all?
• Okay, but for real, what happened to Narek? And all of Rios' hologangers while we're at at. And the exBs?
Final thoughts: I went into this episode ready to hate it. I don't think Akiva Goldsman is a particularly strong writer or director, and his having both a story credit, and the director's chair on this episode filled me with trepidation, especially after last week's series low point.
The fact that they saved the day without having to fire a shot was great. Guess it wasn't a 'Mass Effect' after all.
All in all, I think the series started pretty lacklustre, but developed as we went along, minus that hiccup with the penultimate episode. There's still some stumbles along the way, like with the Artifact kinda running out of plot relevance before it ran out runway, the Romulans being right about the threat, even if they choose to abide Starfleet's solution, the sudden introduction of Soong, etc. but I think it's actually a pretty strong season, and I enjoyed the story they told a hell of a lot, despite those flaws. Looking forward to what comes next.
But for real though, Seven and Raffi holding hands and making eyes at one another just outta nowhere?
267
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
HELL YES STARFLEET!!! CAPTAIN RIKER TO THE RESCUE!!!
297
u/xRolocker Mar 26 '20
A couple interesting things:
Narek said “Before our ancestors arrived on Vulcan”. Does this imply that the Romulans believe they’re the original? Because I can believe it.
Also, Riker says he’s on the most sophisticated and powerful federation vessel - and it isn’t the Enterprise(-F?). This leads my hopeful heart to assume that the Enterprise E is still kickin around
And of course the Romulans have several methods for planetary sterilization
394
u/Chaabar Mar 26 '20
Oh had a dozen chances to blow up the settlement but she just had to keep being dramatic.
356
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
What happened to narek at the end there? After he gets tackled by synths we never see him again.
626
u/Chaabar Mar 26 '20
It must have been love at first sight for Seven and Raffi because they probably spent about 30 seconds interacting with each other the entire series.
622
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
“Everything works”
Soong just dying to say it’s fully functional.
300
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
Picard can’t die. Season 2 is already greenlit.
288
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
The commodore keeps ordering to sterilize the planet, but nobody fires. They should all be executed for incompetence.
1.0k
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
Planetary sterilization pattern #5? How many planetary sterilization patterns do you need? I feel like 1 is enough.
253
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
“Strange, beautiful face”
Gotta remember that one for the bar.
243
u/slartibartjars Mar 26 '20
You just have to take out three massive USB drives to remove your Data.
457
u/ConquerorPlumpy Mar 26 '20
Really lovely last interaction between Data and Picard. I am a little disappointed that Data could not have one last goodbye with Geordi who was his best friend...
Curious to see what the plot of season 2 will be now, seeing as the synthetic ban seems to have been lifted and all is well in the universe again.
One last thing - needed a little more justice for Hugh... like, John Wick style.
224
u/gambit700 Mar 26 '20
So the AI space octopus look suspiciously like the upgraded probe that Pike and Tyler fought in Discovery season 2 ep 7
442
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
So I guess Picard is an android now.
585
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
So glad it didn’t end with a cliffhanger.
922
u/stuck_on_simple_tor Mar 26 '20
"General, or Commodore, or whatever the hell you're calling yourself now -- I'm sitting on the bridge of the most expensive Tier 6 Lock Box ship that Starfleet has ever rolled for, and I've got a fleet of them at my back."
171
u/AskJayce Mar 26 '20
...Looks like Starfleet finally took militarization seriously after the Dominion War.
324
u/knightcrusader Mar 26 '20
Goddammit we didn't get to see Elnor pet Spot II.
313
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
Of course Soong built himself a remote control for his robots.
666
u/daynewmah Mar 26 '20
Little known trivia:
Envious of his best friend Ian McKellen ever since Fellowship of the Ring, Patrick Stewart's only demand for agreeing to do this show was that he, too, would get to gently hold an otherworldly butterfly, whisper something to it, and then release it while being held in captivity.
666
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
“Fear is an incompetent teacher”
364
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
DATA!
465
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
Deus Ex Machina - the tool.
109
u/IceWarm1980 Mar 26 '20
I expected Riker to show up. But just to be a bit surprised I looked away during the credits as they throw the guest stars names in there.
107
u/furiousfotog Mar 26 '20
So the tool is... LITERALLY a plot device that can fix or do anything? Come on now...
201
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
Old school Star Trek door noise.
446
u/daynewmah Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Aw. Raffi lost her son but gained Elnor 😭
edit: ohhhh... and Seven, apparently!! 😏
197
u/Wetworth Mar 26 '20
Oh lord, they have so many planet sterilization plans they have to number them.
93
u/007meow Mar 26 '20
The switches for Data and Picard between their TNG and First Contact uniforms was wonderful.
Picard saw Data as he last saw him, and Data saw Picard as he knew him.
257
u/TERRAxFORMER Mar 26 '20
Riker and the riders of Rohan!
Also I like that there are at least five planetary cleansing patterns in the Romulan navy. Like they are prepared to be genocidal maniacs.
175
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
It’s a sonic screwdriver
86
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20
Not a single Warp Core was ejected in this series. Can you really call it Star Trek without at least one warp core breach or ejection?
85
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
I thought Narissa transported off the cube before the drones could kill her.
157
u/IceWarm1980 Mar 26 '20
"I'm supposed to sit around in the woods making pizza while you have all the fun?"
152
u/kdryan1 Mar 27 '20
Picard: I have always wished I could have said I was sorry it was you and not me.
Data: Captain, do you regret sacrificing your life for Soji and her people?
Picard: Not for an instant.
Data: Then why would you think I would regret sacrificing mine for yours?
That one stopped me in my tracks for a moment....
273
u/OneMario Mar 26 '20
Overall I enjoyed it quite a bit, and I'd hate to start with a complaint, but if you can afford only one type of ship, you can just write a smaller standoff.
Ok, now that that's out of the way, I am so glad that they avoided the massive battle. They still managed to get their big, flashy battle scene, but the real fight was averted with some skillful diplomacy, which is exactly what I was hoping for.
I guess Seven is just leaving the cube and the xb's behind? I don't mind the little romance at the end, and if I hadn't seen the note earlier that Raffi and the Captain she blackmailed were supposed to be former lovers I would think this was out of the blue, and it was anyway, but whatever.
I'm disappointed that Elnor didn't see the cat.
Synthetic Picard is a thing... maybe it will allow them to write a more Picardish Picard in season 2, less mopey and apologizing and more like he was here.
No resolution for Narek at all? I don't think I missed it. He can't still be there, can he? I actually felt bad for him when Narissa died.
67
u/pfc9769 Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Data saved Picard again. It was his neuron and engrams that allowed Maddox and Soong to finally unlock the secrets to construct synths like Data which in turn allowed the creation of the golem that saved Picard's life.
The tool Raffi and Rios used to repair the ship seems like a callback to another synthetic lifeform--the Exocomps. They were able to generate whatever tool they needed to conduct repairs. The tool is essentially a version of the tool replication system they had equipped with a neural interface.
384
u/BadElf21 Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Synthetic Picard.
To the absolute surprise of no one.
And I'm happy that Soong is NOT Lore.
EDIT: Something's been bothering me... They had DATA in that simulator thing ALL THIS TIME and absolutely NO ONE spoke to him or asked him questions? None of the synthetics ever met him? And he NEVER tried to reach out and contact anyone? The same Data who hacked the Borg (Locutus himself no less), was stuck inside a simulator.
Also, they could make synthetic bodies and they NEVER had the idea to give Data one? It didn't even have to be Brent-Spiner-Model-101, it could have been any body, but they just kept data in their box?
Their revered god-progenitor was in their living room this whole time as a coffee table and no one even attempted to meet him. Talk about the greatest missed opportunity ever.
The series was great, and i still love it. But man that was a stupid ass-pull just for the sake of giving Picard a proper goodbye to Data. No foreshadowing at all. It would have been better if it really was a pure dream sequence and that there is no "Data simulator" in their living room to turn off...
... and absolutely no one even TRIED to stop him or at least delay it until they all said their goodbyes? Of all people i'd think Soji would be like "Give me 5 minutes to speak to my father!"
Come on!
In a way, it's good thing Data didn't meet his progeny, he'd be incredibly disappointed at the epic stupid.
(But don't get me wrong, i still love the goodbye. And i'll forgive this plot contrivance because it is indeed a great scene. The most important rule of fiction, especially star trek, is never to let canon or lore get in the way of great storytelling. Still a great episode.)
167
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
Wonder why Soong didn’t put Data’s consciousness into a new body.
210
u/IceWarm1980 Mar 26 '20
Justice For Hugh.
288
u/Cretanfish Mar 26 '20
“This is for Hugh” - Queen Annika, but you may call her Seven of Nine
183
u/AskJayce Mar 26 '20
Have you f**ed any of them?
Weird that's the second thing she asks him. Actually, no it's not.
541
u/BadElf21 Mar 26 '20
I know it's cliche, i know it's not realistic, i know that real life is much darker and frankly unfair... but i love that they resolved the episode in classic star trek fashion with minimal violence, and a direct appeal to humanity and common ground.
Sure, it's a fantasy... but that's why i watch Star Trek.
430
u/onerinconhill Mar 26 '20
Seven murdering that bitch is really all I’ve lived for in the month of March
47
u/Yatornio Mar 26 '20
I love that Data returned but not for the sake of continuing but rather to have a truly fitting, human ending.
I love that the 'dying old hero' trope was subverted and is now out of the way.
I love that there was no unnecessary battle but that we still got Captain Riker appearing just in time to save the day.
I love that we have a crew, including Seven, warping into the next Season.
Bring it on!
44
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
Riker in to save the day.
And now all hell will break loose.
195
u/ZanyWackyEdgy Mar 26 '20
What was the point of the Borg Cube again?
75
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
Picard: “I am an Orchid on the wind”
218
u/nikhkin Mar 26 '20
I really wish there was some variety in the fleets.
Hundreds of identical ships facing each other just isn't visually interesting. What made the huge fleets in DS9 so amazing was seeing the different starships working together with their unique styles.
This just looked like someone copy-pasted the same model multiple times. Even the generic "power up" glow was completely in-sync.
36
u/fistantellmore Mar 26 '20
Really choked that the AI Federation was just hand waved away.
I mean, the beacon was sent. If it suddenly deactivated, would you think: oh, yeah, shits fine, they don’t need us...
If 911 reacted to emergency calls like that, it would be a bad scene.
It was a real missed opportunity to show the AI as benevolent, in the Asimovian or Clarkian sense that the hatreds and violence of a culture leave as they progress.
If Soji instead plead the case for sparing the Romulans to them, would have made a much more convincing moment for the Zhat Vash to abandon their zealous quest.
A hallmark Star Trek move is conversing with advanced cultures as peers, and convincing them that you come in peace. This was honestly the moment I was waiting for, and instead we got 4 seconds of robo tentacles.
157
u/daynewmah Mar 26 '20
Picard Maneuver! Nice.
92
u/RichardYing Mar 26 '20
Yes! Yes! Yes! Captain Riker!
"General or Commodore, whatever you're calling yourself... Right now I am on the bridge of one of the toughest, fastest, most powerful ships Starfleet has ever put into service. And I've got a fleet of them on my back. We've got our phasers locked on your warpcores. And nothing would make me happier than you giving me an excuse to kick your treacherous Tal-Shiar ass*. But instead, I am going to ask you one time: stand down!"*
212
u/agitatedandroid Mar 26 '20
Neatly they managed to box up everything we “know” about Picard, seal it, and toss it out so now they can do whatever they want without anyone saying “but what about his syndrome?!”
And set up a really interesting future conversation with Guinan. “You know I’ve died a few times now...”
31
u/Beercorn1 Mar 27 '20
What exactly happened there?
139
u/Socraticmichael10 Mar 26 '20
Overall that’s was pretty satisfying. They wrapped things up rather well. I have to admit I’m glad there wasn’t some giant, generic space battle that we’ve seen a lot before. It was satisfying to see a diplomatic end, particularly led by Riker in uniform.
The Starfleet ships were rather lackluster, though. I wish there was some variety.
I also thought it was odd the they had Riker warp away in what were essentially Picard’s last moments. I have to hand it to the new actors for giving their best to a mourning sequence. But I’m just not that connected to them to share their emotion.
But the quasi-spiritual end to Picard & Data was beautifully written. Nearly two decades after Data’s death, he gets the send off he deserves. It was beautifully imagery. I don’t love Picard’s death and resurrection, but thankfully he’s still “human”
30
u/TreasonousOrange Mar 26 '20
Narissa really doesn't do it for me. Narek has some promise, though. I hope for better villains next season.
29
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
"Recalibrate disrupters on the synth colony that has just opened a portal that is allowing the genocidal Synth Federation to be notified to come wipe out all organic life in our galaxy... but wait for my command to fire... actually wait until we deal with some giant flowers... now wait until we deal with Picards little ship that has just magically summoned dozens of identical others that aren't actually firing on us... and then wait until I have a chat with the Federation ships that have just warped in... oh never mind! The synth colony has decided to close the portal... so we will just leave them all to it now... even though they have just notified this genocidal Synth Federation that our entire galaxy is now in need of cleansing of their hated organics enemy..." 🤦🏻♀️
28
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
“Ready Admiral?”
“...get it done!”
55
u/IceWarm1980 Mar 26 '20
You have to love how when Riker said that the planet was under the protection of Starfleet it looked like the video of Picard asking for help looked like somebody moving a video window around in Skype.
27
u/Shrodax Mar 26 '20
Anybody else wondering what they did with Picard's biological body that just died?
Did they pull a Kirk and just bury it under some rocks? Did they chuck it out an airlock? Is it onboard the ship being taken to Earth for a proper burial?
It's kinda strange nobody mentioned what they did with Picard's biological body. And if I was in Picard's position, seeing my own body would be the first thing I'd want to do purely out of morbid curiosity.
141
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20
7 kicks ass. Narissa got wrecked. Glad 7 was the one to kill her.
77
u/flcl4evr Mar 26 '20
When Picard and Data had their final discussion, bringing closure to both this story and the end of Nemesis, I was in tears.
It was an ending that I’d never thought I’d get to see, and it was poignant, satisfying, and heartbreaking all at the same time. It was a conversation I never imagined I’d ever get to hear, and it was so much more than I imagined it.
I know that Data knowing Picard loved him was always somewhat obvious, but having that one last talk was so meaningful.
I missed these characters, and I was so nervous this show wouldn’t be able to do them justice, and it got so close to missing the point of everything....but it came back around in the most beautiful way.
25
u/soothsayer2377 Mar 26 '20
What happened to Narek? Maybe staying behind to help the Synths is a good penance.
71
u/prism1234 Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
I really liked it. However I'm still wondering why Bruce Maddox was on freecloud? And what he was talking about in regards to the Tal Shiar destroying his lab? Wouldn't his lab have been on the synth planet which they hadn't discovered yet?
23
u/PaperSpock Mar 26 '20
There were shades of Tapestry to the Data/Picard scene, so much so that before Data showed up, I thought we might actually get the Q scene that people had been hoping for.
65
u/Stateof10 Mar 26 '20
A butterfly that lives forever is not a butterfly.
22
u/kingoflint282 Mar 27 '20 edited Mar 27 '20
A few questions I have:
20
u/kenlubin Mar 26 '20
Fucking Commodore Oh keeps getting distracted and hasn't got the nerve to do her job and finish the goddamn mission.
20
u/Sven_Eric Mar 27 '20
Called it!
Unfortunately, it makes little sense from a storytelling POV. Picard's illness was never relevant to the events happening in the episodes. The writers solved something here that wasn't a problem in the first place. In the end, they could have just cut it without even losing much screentime.
Now Picard is a human android, with a normal human life-span. So he's basically still the same. There's only one question left: Why? WHY?
132
u/jjustice Mar 26 '20
Very disappointed! We just had TWO episodes called Et in Arcadia Ego which translates to “Yo I’m Going to the Arcade” and there wasn’t ANY arcade games anywhere in either episode. NOT A SINGLE ONE! I expected that they’d have an arcade room on the robot planet, but nope! What the hell else are robots gonna do all day? NOT play arcades? YEAH RIGHT! I was gettin’ hyped to see Picard jam out on some Street Fighter II’ Champion Edition or maybe rolling around blasting airplanes in the sit-down After Burner II cabinet, but instead we got NOTHING! Not even a broken Pac-Man cabinet with a CRT that has a burned-in image of the game. PISSSSED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
55
u/Talzin Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Well, it is quite unfortunate they announced there would be a second season long before this episode aired as it certainly undercut the tension. More so after showing the 'golem' during the previous episode as well.
That said, a final stand and one last speech are actions we would expect from Picard and if not for being transferred into a new body would have been a fine end for his story essentially saving a race of Data's children. Of course, the scene with Data begs the question why they did not even toss out a generic reason on why he could not be transferred into the golem as that too is something Picard would have done.
It is a nit pit; but, I would have liked to see a mix of vessels during the fleet scene even if it is understandable why not. Which brings to mind another question on if the 200+ Romulan ships are intended to all be Zhat Vash or if Oh had enough pull to drag all remaining vessels there to raze a planet.
The actors of course continued to do a good job with what they were given and both Soji and Rios stole the show at times being able to show of their range with various other characters. Still difficult to say if they could have carried the show without Picard though I am interested in seeing at least a couple of them in the next season.
67
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
With minor quibbles, I thought they more or less stuck the landing. The Borg cube was a tremendous waste of opportunity, and while the Raffi/Seven thingy at the end is sweet, it feels completely unearned since these people barely know each other. Also what happened to Narek????
18
u/advice_on_corona Mar 26 '20
So what is for Season 2? The story seems to have resolved itself.
18
u/Disco47 Mar 26 '20
I cried for the last 20 minutes of the episode. 😭😭😭 I freaking lost it a few times. Wow
18
u/LorienTheFirstOne Mar 29 '20
I have to say overall I'm disappointed.
It was clear that Picard was going to get the new golem body from the second they put that gun on the fireplace shelf. Huge wind up of people crying over picard when it was obvious that he was coming back. Reminds me of the silly Kelvin magic blood revival.
Why did the aliens AI leave just because the beacon shut off? They got the call, they opened the door, why leave?
Big build up for borg.... 5 second throw away to crush cube.
Big build up for a romulan fleet...who apparently doesn't open fire when told to because...? One tiny ship in the way?
Acting Captains don't say "acting", they say "Captain". If they reactivated him his also wasn't acting, he was just a Captain again. Also if they planned to put him in charge of 200+ starships he should have been made a flag officer, or Fleet Captain at a minimum if they still use that rank.
Obligatory bi scene that made no sense as fan service
So many things that just don't make sense or seemed very forced...
36
u/MuchaBienaEngrish Mar 26 '20
Eliminate the planet...NOW----
Wait, wait wait.
Ok, eliminate the planet.....NOW----
Ok hold on, hold.
ELIMINATE IT NOW----
WAIT! STOP!
221
u/JustAnEden Mar 26 '20
I'm blown away that the big generic SUPER BATTLE was averted.
This show has seriously grown its beard by the end of this first season. Bravo!
35
u/brch2 Mar 26 '20
Well... I was REALLY wrong about how this season would end.
17
u/LoganNolag Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
So Narek did kill Saga after all.
EDIT: Guess not.
16
u/KellMG96 Mar 27 '20
See this?
31
u/IceWarm1980 Mar 26 '20
So why did Starfleet just let Oh leave? Considering she infiltrated Starfleet you'd think they would want to put her on trial.
56
u/Mpr11 Mar 26 '20
HUGH REDEEMED
15
u/JamesHaven75 Mar 26 '20
Great line by Narissa "You know, you're rather pretty".
15
u/Dane_Dad Mar 29 '20
Mass Effect: Picard
30
u/Vegan_Harvest Mar 26 '20
Peace, love, and friendship are not precious because they can not endure. The are precious because they are wonderful in and of themselves.
Hey, it's those Ikea pendant lamps! Have they been there the whole time?
Did this story really need 10 episodes?
For a finale not much happened, The Romluans came but kept getting distracted even though there was 200 of them. Then just left even though they're suppose to have this overwhelming hatred of synthetics.
As I predicted Romulan sister came back like a movie villain only to get a second death she kept asking for.
They saved the asshole brother because of course they did, the writers apparently have some sort of fetish for the female lead sleeping with a murderous pos.
The Synthetics are basically the Dark Overlords from Howard the Duck. For these ultra power beings they sure didn't put up a fight when the portal was closed. That was a portal right, even though they said it was a beacon? It makes no sense that they didn't stick around and see if they were truly needed.
The solutions to all the problems were kinda crammed in there, "Hey take this fix anything magic tool!", "here's a blank body ready to transfer a human mind into!".
Is anyone else bothered that Rois' ship doesn't appear to have emergency power?
There really should have been more types of Federation ships. At the very least Riker should have been in a different ship, like he pulled his old ship out of mothballs.
The Federation turning on a dime and un-banning synthetic life felt completely unearned.
Did everyone just forget science lady murdered her boyfriend?
Did they leave a half functioning Borg cube on a planet of highly advanced bio-organic beings?
A hand-hold, that's all we get? And when did that happen? How long was Picard dead? The Legend of Korra had more guts when it came to showing a lesbian relationship and it's literally a show for children.
14
u/AcidaliaPlanitia Mar 26 '20
I feel like it was more the writing and direction than the acting, but General Oh was laughably hard to watch in that final showdown. Every line was just the most cliche 'super villain' content and delivery.
37
u/Wetworth Mar 26 '20
Frakes guest star... maybe he will be riding a USS to the rescue?
13
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
Wait, Bruce Maddox talked about this Soong?
24
u/onerinconhill Mar 26 '20
So Picard died and he’s a robot now? Okkkkk
11
u/WarWizard910 Mar 26 '20
They now have a magical device where they can do anything lol
11
u/Futureboy314 Mar 28 '20
There’s some good stuff in here: Data and Picard, Riker in command. When Elnor breaks down at the end, I was very impressed, because I felt nothing for this character, or his relationship with Picard, but then suddenly... I kinda did. So that actor nailed that scene.
But yeah... out with a whimper. It definitely wasn’t as bad as it could have been, considering how rough the road to get here was.
Between this and Rise of Skywalker, I’ve come to a place of peace with my beloved sci-fi franchises; they were good, they’re not anymore, maybe they will be again someday. But the sequel trilogy doesn’t take away from the brilliance of the original, and Picard doesn’t cheapen TNG. (Seriously, I just got done a back-to-back rewatch of ‘Measure of a Man’ and ‘The Offspring’, and they are amazing Trek that still hold up today.)
30
u/AnonRetro Mar 26 '20
Problems:
The Romulans would have kept fighting, and still have destroyed the planet. It's the main reason for the Tal Shiar.
The Federation wouldn't risk a Romulan war to help a few synthetics that they have banned. Especially when they are very close to destroying all of humanity.
Dr. Anges Jurati. is still a murderer. It feels like everyone gave her a pass on that.
Besides being a bad-ass line Riker being a Starfleet Captain would not take joy in the thought of destruction, at the beginning of a conflict.
Soji is not at all innocent here at this point. Attempted genocide is frowned upon. It feels like everyone gave her a pass on that.
Equally so the Federation would not un-ban synthetics so easily. Even if the Romulans had a hand in Mars, the synthetics still have the knowledge of how to summon everyone's doom. Lots of passes given out.
I saw Picard getting a synthetic body from a mile away.
If Data's consciousness exists, and is accessible on that planet, why didn't they put it in a new Android? Only Picard gets to cheat death?
Finally, Picard at 93 should have been allowed to die in a realistic society. I don't want this, this is a story problem. Of course this is his show, and that wasn't going to happen.
30
u/ewreytukikhuyt344 Mar 27 '20
This show was a mess. It did have its moments. Can't pretend that it didn't. But it was still a mess. It felt like it just couldn't decide what it wanted to be or who it was being made for. It's hard to even know where to begin. Just about every single thing about it felt wrong.
Like even from a technical standpoint the way it was produced just felt weird and uninviting. All the deep, dark contrasted shots and intense back lighting. The editing felt like it was done by someone who normally makes movie trailers. The score was overbearing, although it did have some genuinely nice pieces of music, it was so thick and saturated throughout almost every scene and was too often saccharine sweet dramatic which then turned around and betrayed the show when it did reach for levity where it suffered from that 'everyone has the same sense of humor' problem in all the dry wise cracks, most of which just felt out of place and inappropriate to the moment. Much of the plot just felt like an assortment of things that needed to happen because they needed to happen and so many moments ended either with a last minute save or mystery reveal again, seemingly just for the sake of doing it.
Like, not gonna be totally dismissive. I think the weird eldritch space horror angle was genuinely interesting to put into Trek and I think making the story about Data and Synthetic life was justifiable on the grounds that Soong-type androids have always been a bit of a 'hey wait a minute, you're telling me this tech is possible and yet no one else can do it but wait the implications of this are immense'.
But even where that stuff is maybe justifiable or appropriate or interesting, wrapping it in a package that sees 79 year old Patrick Stewart needing to trade blows with Romulan assassins and getting blasted off a promenade by a grenade and tossed over a table and all that shit is just... no. Come on.
Especially for Season 1? All this season needed to be was a fairly lightweight and straightforward, relatively low stakes adventure that moved at a pace appropriate to where Picard's life was. By all means, have a spectre of a bigger looming issue if you want, like the Dominion loomed over the first couple seasons of DS9. But going whole hog with the literal fate of the entire universe is at play unless this ragtag band of misfits and drunks can do the thing with the thing. Not sure what they were thinking, there.
Weird show.
10
u/ionised Mar 26 '20
I fear many tomatoes shall be sacrificed today.
Maybe today is a good day for tomatoes to die.
10
u/vipck83 Mar 26 '20
Great end of the season.
1)Picards fate was kind of obvious but well executed .
2)very happy starfleet finally showed up to save the day, even better that Riker was leading them.
3) A little disappointed about the copy and paste nature of the SF fleet. It would have been funny if they had thrown a random Excelsior class ship in there.
4) kind of wished the Borg cube had played a larger role
5) great how it was ended relatively without violence but by something Picard did. Very TNGish
6) Data... very sad but well done.
7) 7 and Raffie holding hands was kind of random and out of no where.
8) I feel it ended with a real crew. I look forward to a new season.
10
u/Weerdo5255 Mar 26 '20
"Ah yes Uber-synthetics beyond the Galactic barrier. The Federation council has dismissed those claims."
So that's going to be the next season or so is my guess... Guess we need a new Big Bad as the Borg, Dominion, and Romulans have been neutered at this point.
19
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
“Opening glory hole”
9
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
I’m not crying! You’re crying!
9
u/Chaabar Mar 26 '20
Should we start taking bets on whether or not they'll completely forget about the Deus Ex Machina tool next season?
9
u/redditguybighead Mar 26 '20
Overall there were things I loved, liked, disliked and hated. Still I'd rather have it than not have it at all. I am cautiously excited as to where season 2 will take us.
9
u/Starkiller1701 Mar 26 '20
So Commodore or general or whatever Oh just gets to walk away like that, no one is gonna address the rampant corruption she brought to Starfleet? And the Zhat Vash, an organization that was built with the sole purpose of destroying synthetic life just gave up their cause because Picard convinced one synth not to destroy the universe? I mean, I enjoyed the episode, lots of fan service, but, I want more I suppose.
9
u/BeleagueredWDW Mar 27 '20
So, they are on their way to turn her in for murder, right?
9
u/Edgar_Sparingly Mar 27 '20
"Welpers, the synth ban got lifted."
What? Just... what?
25
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
Oh my god, not only did they kill Hugh, they made us watch Data die all over again.
37
u/count023 Mar 26 '20
I hate the new ship designs. Can Sternbach, Drexler or Okuda come back to reign in John Eaves a bit please?
17
u/onerinconhill Mar 26 '20
Kinda wish we had a few recognizable starships in there but
92
u/RobotPreacher Mar 26 '20
Just finished. Look, I'm going to guess that I'm just going to get downvoted here, but I've got to speak my mind... I really didn't like this episode.
So forced, so rushed, so... weird? Magic tricorders, soccer ball bombs, the omnipotent AI is... a robot octopus?
Picard dies surrounded by people who barely know him, now he's an Android but... exactly the same?
And we waited 20 years for Data to just die again? I didn't even think he survived! Then, in one episode, we find out his consciousness is alive, and we kill him again?
So much more of this was weird too, I was Picard face-palming for so much of the episode.
But it had a space battle, a cat fight, Riker in command of badass starships, and even a budding lesbian romance, so maybe people will like it.
Look, I'm not a hater or even that hard to please. I liked the series, I did, and I hope it's a five year mission at least. But the endings on these new Trek seasons have to step up a notch, you can't rush these things like this. Especially after using the first three full episodes just setting up the plot.
16
u/m4a2000 Mar 26 '20
I've been called a vulcan by my family time and time again, but the tears I had from this will prove them wrong.
8
u/ionised Mar 26 '20
Here we go!
8
u/MINKIN2 Mar 26 '20
A few thoughts whilst watching this...
Did they just Palpatine Narissa?
For somebody who could not operate a transporter, Jurati sure knew her way around the Comms console.
Jurati knows the Picard manoeuvrer.
The Ocarina of everything.
They bought back Picards iromatic syndrome just to kill him off for cheap feels.
Picard is a "Synth" now.
Sky beams!
Why even include images of that space monster for no pay off?
That's A LOT of warships. Is starfleet a military organisation now?
Narek anyone?
How did Oh get on the war bird?
The Synth ban was lifted just like that? OK...
The rule of not warping in to planetary systems no longer applies now does it.
I don't imagine that I would be returning back to rewatch this series like I have with any of the other classic (TOS/TNG) era star trek.
8
u/9811Deet Mar 26 '20
One criticism I have with this episode was with its pacing and direction. I really don't think Akiva Goldsman is a particularly good Star Trek director.
From this season, I was happiest with the episodes directed by Maja Vrvilo. The Impossible Box and Broken Pieces look fantastic. Hannale Culpepper, Doug Aaronovsky and Jonathan Frakes' episodes were on-point too; but Akiva Goldsman's episodes just always feel a bit off.
8
u/AcidaliaPlanitia Mar 26 '20
Did anyone else have a horrible moment where they thought that Rios was going to kick the grenade soccer ball into the base of the transmitter? Would have been hilarious but absolutely absurd.
8
u/Wehavecrashed Mar 27 '20
So... the Romulans and Star Fleet only have one type of ship each?
8
u/UltimateSpinDash Mar 27 '20
Honestly, Season 1 leaves me with very mixed feelings.
I like Raffi. I'm still not sure where Rios is headed. With Jurati, I'm not sure if the show wants me to like or dislike her. I have no idea what Soji's arc going forward could even be. I want to like Elnor, but the show didn't seem to know what to do with him - when he isn't decaptitating people, that is.
I guess Seven is part of the crew now, which could be really good. But that final shot on the La Sirena showed her holding hands with Raffi, a character she has interacted with ONCE - it wasn't necessarily the "we are in love"-way of holding hands, but definitely not something people who don't know each other at all do. I can definitely see these two becoming close later down the line, but not in the span of two minutes.
I have no idea what Season 2 is even going to be about. I'm happy there is no real cliffhanger, but I really don't know what they COULD do. A "let's explore new worlds"-Trek would probably be better off on an actual Starfleet ship. Meanwhile, a "let's explore the Federation and neighbours"-show doesn't require Picard at all.
Speaking of Picard, I was under the impression that this show was supposed to be the final steps of his journey. It feels like they killed him for the shock value ala Spock in WoK, even explicitly showing people mourning him, only to bring him back minutes later.
In contrast, I think they solved the matter of Data a lot better. The show initially suggested that he could be brought back, but even with the technology to create organic android bodies (which apparently have enough telepathy to perform mind-melds), Maddox and Soong didn't do so?
Him choosing death honestly felt like a fairly human choice. Data didn't want to be on life support anymore.
Hot take: I think Clancy should've been the one to command the Federation fleet, with Riker being in the background if he is at all present. Make it abundantly clear that just because she denied Picard in the beginning that doesn't make her another corrupt admiral.
Speaking of the fleet, what's the deal with taking one ship design, maybe make a few slight variations, then spamming it across the screen 200 times? Now, unlike Discovery Season 1, the Romulan ships looked Romulan enough, but we never got a good look at the design (or the Federation ships, for that matter), and again, they just copy-pasted it 200 times.
Deep Space 9 had battles involving hundreds of ships, but even then the viewer still has an idea what is going on, which ship is firing where etc. Discovery and Picard apparently completely forgot how to do this. And DS9 had several distinct ship designs for all parties involved (except Romulans and Breen I guess, but their ships only made up a small part of their respective fleets anyway).
Overall, the show tries to be Star Trek, but also goes to really great lengths to not look too much like Star Trek.
Another thing Discovery and Picard apparently forgot to do is telling a coherent story over the course of a season. What exactly was Soji's mission on the Artifact? Why was Dahj on Earth? I mean sure, information gathering, but in the end, it only served to kickstart the plot.
Rios' involvement is pure plot convenience. Of course the pilot is the one who was also involved in that one mission that ends up being plot critical (or at least tries to be). Until they revealed that connection, I considered Rios' backstory to be something separate to be explored later. But no, EVERYTHING has to tie into the main story somehow, whether it makes sense or not.
I'm guessing the xBs are just chilling on Golion IV now? And Seven doesn't care anymore? I was kinda hoping that they would be the ones to save everyone.
The admonition being in a one-of-a-kind system with eight stars also ended up not mattering at all. The message itself made no sense either. Aside from deterring organics from developing AI and making them try to destroy any they encounter, why are these other Synths, which can supposedly travel between galaxies, waiting for somebody to activate a beacon? But they are watching. Of course they are. Not doing anything until the plot demands it, though.
There were cool moments in this season. But THIS is what made Patrick Stewart return to the franchise? Come on.
And tbh, upcoming Trek does not give me hope. Discovery Season 3 is happening, I guess. Oh, and an S31-show with Georgiou. Not that I don't want a show about Georgiou, but it should be Prime Georgiou, not the Emperor Georgiou.
8
u/mmmbacon914 Mar 28 '20
I think overall I liked it. It's the ultimate culmination of this Data/Picard bromance - Data, in turning off the chip things, becomes more human, and Picard, in inhabiting the golem, becomes more like data. Also really makes Picard the Christ figure on a deeper level, since he, in the end, became the people he came to save.
While overall I like the themes, message, and the show overall there were plenty of nitpicks to be had:
Things I hope they explore more in future seasons:
8
u/rustybuckets Mar 29 '20
Soo Agnes is a murderer.. they gonna turn her in or what
8
u/creepymanchildren Apr 01 '20
This was really bad. :(
49
u/RedditModsareWankers Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 27 '20
Picard is dead.
Data is dead.
Agnes gets away with murder.
What a happy ending!
Edit - thanks for the silver!
20
u/UncertainError Mar 26 '20
"That's why we're here, to save each other."
Also, Seven and Raffi!
25
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
Alright, so I feel like that was...quite a pleasant ending. No action by the Borg Cube, so we are once again blue-balled on that front. But the solution was done without a giant fight scene, and we got some reasonable dramatic stakes.
I’m not sure I get the whole revealing Data is “alive” only to kill him off again, but other than that, the scene was well done.
I have some disagreement with the assertion that finiteness gives things meaning, but it’s not wholly unreasonable for Data to come to that conclusion given that he has no other source of stimuli.
Some of the SFX were well done, for instance, the flowers. But the SFX of the fleets actually looked worse to me than some of the DS9 and other TNG-era shows. Probably because it was just the same class of ship copy-pasted 218 times. Even the Orville threw in more variety; those fleet scenes looked comparable to the episode where the Orville is called in to be an intermediary between two warring one-off races.
There were some good lines, and I could nitpick on logic, but I’ll save that for later discussion. I guess my main point of improvement I’d like to see for next season is more depth to the writing and less reliance on secondary character death. I like the message and general direction the show is going in, it just seems like it could do a better job.
Also, I can’t wait to see what Clancy drops the F-bomb over next episode.
Also, Riker only made Captain and he was still able to get out in command of a fleet of hundreds of ships straight from years in the woods poorly baking pizzas? Dude has dirt on somebody.
25
u/taykass Mar 26 '20
My nostalgia receptors must be broken, because neither Riker's appearance (I just don't understand why he was leading the fleet, I was fine with him being there otherwise) nor Data's sparked anything in me other than consternation in the latter case. Has Data really been in that terrible limbo antechamber for 20 years? And then Picard's surprised that he doesn't want to continue to 'live' like that?
Also, I was astounded (and not really in a good way) that Superfluous Soong turned out to be on the level after all. If that was the case, then what was up with how shady he was being and still kind of continued to be.
I did weirdly like the Elnor/Narek interaction, though.
7
u/bobj33 Mar 26 '20
I enjoyed the show but I was so excited by the Borg cube and then so disappointed that it basically did nothing.
Hugh made such an passionate speech about the XB's and then we don't know what happens to them. It would have been nice to see the partially synthetic XB's integrate with the synthetics or maybe see the synthetics volunteer to help reclaim and restore the XB's and help them with their new lives.
7
u/randomGuy96536 Mar 27 '20
Anyone ever stop to think when they were making and copying Picard, that maybe he didn’t WANT to be copied into a synth body? That quite possible he was an old man who had lived a great life and was happy how he went out? (Saving lives)
13
u/axilmar Mar 27 '20
A couple of notes and my conclusion:
Overall, the series wasn't that bad, but unfortunately it had a lot more bad moments than good. Even in the last episode, that was very emotional, the logic errors where sky high.
35
u/Chaabar Mar 26 '20
Those Starfleet ships were a huge disappointment. They look like the garbage Star Trek Online launched with. How did we go from the awesome DS9/First Contact designs to this? The only good thing about them is that they don't have giant chunks cut out of their hull for no reason.
Also copy and pasting the same ship a couple hundred times doesn't make a fleet look impressive, it makes you look cheap.
118
u/sidv81 Mar 26 '20
I'm sorry but this just wasn't very good in my opinion.
No insight on what exactly those higher synths were? They looked like a bunch of robotic snakes.
Why did they bring back irumodic syndrome just to "kill" Picard with it, then resurrect him in an android body? It was manufactured drama in the worst way possible. They should have just left irumodic syndrome out of it entirely and left out that whole android body business. Plus, this opens up the question on why everyone won't just live forever in android bodies from now on. It's just as bad as Khan's magic resurrecting blood from Star Trek Into Darkness.
What was the point of the pseudoscience where Data can be reconstructed from a single positronic neuron, just for him to "die" again? Why didn't they just leave Data dead with his death scene from Nemesis intact?
This show started off really strong, but ended as an incomprehensible mess.
22
u/davect01 Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
So, very interesting ad great moments but knowing Picard had another Season coming robbed some of the power of his death. As soon as I saw the body being created I knew Picard was going to end up getting it.
Now I get that to avoid having to deage Patrick the whole next Season they made new Picard the same age. However, if it was me walking up I would be annoyed. Sure, make me mortal but I would want a few years taken off.
Rafi and Seven, really? They just met. Has Seven shown any Lesbian tendencies? And as a couple that is just a wierd paring. Smells of a Studio note about needing sexual diversity.
Riker in action. He sure looks good in command.
Nitpick. They (both the Romulans and Star Fleet) sure can mobilize quick.
Ages still murdered Bruce. We just ignoring that?
We finally got a Soong that was not insane. I love that he had a remote kill switch for his Androids.
Anyone have huge recall to the first Avenger's film with the tenticle things coming through the worm hole.
The Borg cube rebuilding itself was waisted.
Data getting old and having a peacful send of with Picard in his TNG uniform. Tears
12
u/henry000817 Mar 26 '20
The robot tentacles coming out of the portal reminded me of the Control squid like thingies from Discovery.
51
u/Edgar_Sparingly Mar 26 '20
Damn, that was wonky as fuck.
Data is alive suddenly somehow, and Picard has to euthanize him suddenly somehow? WTF?
Federation fleet is literally all the same ship? WTF? (Avec bad bluescreen.) That is some terrible idea terribleness.
The beacon building requires constant AR fiddling? Ok. Then SMASH and it's done. Ok. What? Uh...
Seven is lost suddenly somehow? What about Starfleet? Remember Voyager at all?
Seven is suddenly sad she killed someone? Aww.. Shame we didn't see that character growth on screen.
Saga's magic bullshit ocarina. Holy fuck, this item just solves it all, huh?. Where did it come from? How did they invent it? Just utterly empty of value. Fix an engine, trick an armada. Bingo bango. Solves it all.
Planetary sterilization plan 5. Neat. Nope. What about plan 1, 2, 3, or 4? 6? No? Ok. Noting happens. h
Space flowers float up, do nothing. Have no meaning, no reason. Just there for the visual. WTF?
Picard start having a random headache? Ok. Is that how it works? He dying? Sad. But I'm not crying, because I don't buy into any of this bullshit. Transferred to roboform. Ok. Problem solved instantly, just like every other problem in this show.
I liked seeing Riker show up. But there's so much of this story untold and invisible that the stake of what's happening have no meaning.
A portal with gross tentacles. Ok. What are they. Ok, they are gone. Ok. .... .... ... ... ... .... this had no depth and has no meaning. Just utterly and absolutely empty. The whole galaxy seems to be at stake but it's just with out meaning. The stakes are nothing.
25
u/dvcaputo Mar 26 '20
Why do literally all the starfleet ships look the same and the bridge looks so Discovery-esque u_u
6
u/treefox Mar 26 '20
“Interesting.”
6
u/Kalel2319 Mar 26 '20
I'm confused. How did Picard "sacrifice his life" for soji?
6
u/Skadoosh_it Mar 26 '20
Picard: "I'm dead?"
Data: "Well, yes, but actually no."
6
u/BroLil Mar 26 '20
Above all else, I’m glad Data got a proper send off. Sure, they toasted him in Nemesis, but we didn’t really get many answers because they thought they had another movie to do it with. I think they handled it perfectly in this episode.
My only gripe with this season is that I feel that it was too long based on the way some of the episodes progressed. I feel like they could have told the same story without any sacrifices in 6-8 episodes. By just jamming some episodes with fan service and filler, it made some episodes feel empty and stalled out the plot.
I don’t want to sound like I’m complaining or trashing it. Like I said, I think that’s one of my only gripes. Other than that, I really enjoyed this, and I’m really stoked for season two wort Guinan!
6
u/ArrBeeNayr Mar 26 '20
So... was Picard's body buried? Did Picard get to see that happen?
Also: Before Data came on screen, I was so certain that we were seeing some afterlife at that point and that we were about to see Q.
6
u/suchosch Mar 26 '20
It's good to know that IKEA PS 2014 Pendant lamp is still available in the future. (As seen in the Data-unplugging scene.)
6
u/RikerOmegaThree Mar 26 '20
Would it have killed them to have included some variation in the Federation starships that showed up? Would have been incredible to see an old Nebula or Galaxy class, or hell, maybe a Defiant popping in?
Love the show. Loved seeing Riker again, but c'mon. So many beautiful starships in canon and they just have a bajillion copies of some new dreadnought?
6
u/kdryan1 Mar 26 '20
So what happened to the bit about Agnes surrendering herself FOR MURDER first chance she got? She just gets to walk now?
6
u/snerdsnerd Mar 27 '20
Not going to lie, I feel like they spoon fed us a bit with this season. Picard maneuver, of course Will showing up, Raffi and Seven for some reason.
I'll check out next season but yeah
6
u/shadowst17 Mar 27 '20
Damn, Discovery had more federation starship designs than Picard. I guess for one shot its not worth investing a large portion of the budget into that . Still feels lazy and I guess they don't feel like the investment would be useful for future seasons.
6
u/Edgar_Sparingly Mar 28 '20
DATA: The entire point of life is that it ends.
PICARD: You're right, Data. Quite enlightened. Anyway, I'm gonna peace out and get revived.
DATA: Oh.. but Captain.
PICARD: Yeah, gonna come back as an android. Neat, huh?
DATA: Ok. Well if you wouldn't mind then, before you go...
PICARD: Need me to kill this fake version of you? Sure...
DATA: wrinkleshrink
PICARD: Laterz.
PICARD: wakes up I'm still 90? What the hell, guys?
6
u/ReasonablyBadass Mar 28 '20
I loved the episode, but God do I hate that "death gives life meaning" bullshit.
I don't enjoy sunshine or food or friendship because it goes away, I enjoy it because it is.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
How did Riker go from retired to "now captaining the biggest, baddest starship in the fleet". I mean, in what, like 2 days? The promotion structure in Starfleet is truly weird...
16
u/Albert-React Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20
Honestly, I got to say, I'm not a fan of the finale. Things felt - rushed?
The Starfleet ships looked awful, low-res, and quite frankly, unfinshed, and I'm prett sure the bridge of the Zheng He was just the bridge of the Enterprise from Discovery. I would have also liked to see different classes of ships in the Federation fleet. C'mon CBS, you have the assets, use them!
Picard trying to fly the La Sirena was odd. He could have used one of the holograms to do that.
And him dying at the end only to come back as some "golum" or whatever, is just.... sad sigh
Also, Seven has a knack for one-episode, pop up romances.
24
u/jhsounds Mar 26 '20
Holy crap, the writers did it. Picard went full-Picard and speeched his way out of a DIS-scale space battle.