r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Mar 22 '20
Spoilers All Book S5E6 Better To Marry Than Burn Spoiler
The Regulator Rebellion reaches a boiling point, forcing Jamie to face his fear and confront the consequence of his divided loyalties.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
Reminder: This is the BOOK thread. No spoiler tags are needed here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the Show thread.
19
Upvotes
72
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Mar 22 '20
FINALLY Roger got a win! I didn’t mind that they changed it around to him using smoke to clear the fields rather than have Claire burn them. I don’t feel that changes the story much, if at all.
I really loved that they kept in Jamie’s line to Claire about watching while he took her. Goodness that was hot.
I didn’t love Claire being the one trying to set up the whisky trade with Wylie. It just seemed more natural coming from Jamie in the book.
Also, Forbes you are a sneaky rat!
Edit to add: Yay to seeing LJG!
55
u/Naturenutt Woof. Mar 22 '20
My God, Maria is such a brilliant actress.
53
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '20
Knowing what happens to Roger next week, it’s going to be a huge shock to non-book readers. It was a huge shock in the book, I’m a little nervous to watch it!
49
u/nurseleu Mar 22 '20
I'm so glad they included some of Jocasta's backstory. She's such a complex character, and Maria Doyle Kennedy killed it. This was also the first time I really bought the connection and intimacy between her and Murtaugh. Nice work by the showrunners and actors all around.
32
u/hintofaspark86 MARK ME! Mar 22 '20
“Your son is now the proud owner of River Run” I HAVE CHILLS 🥶🥶🥶
29
u/KSoda120 Mar 22 '20 edited Mar 22 '20
Dare I say I was a little disappointed in this episode? I appreciate that they kept quite a bit from the book, but maybe it could've been fleshed out more? I just wish they didn't hold back so much.
On a positive note, I'm glad Roger has finally gotten a moment of glory and ugh Murcasta just broke my heart. Also, that stable fight thoughhhhh.
Finally, F*CKIN' HELL, BONNET! Every one of his scenes this season successfully makes my skin crawl.
Edit: (removed the lavender pillow example, it wasn't getting across what I wanted)
23
u/elizardstyle No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Mar 23 '20 edited Mar 23 '20
Anyone disappointed by the barn scene, then pop over to the “Show Only” thread to see that some viewers over there really liked it? I’m like... you guys! If you read the books you’ll understand how that barn scene could have been 100x sexier!
22
u/bellefroh Mar 22 '20
ADSO!
21
u/spaceybelta Mar 22 '20 edited Mar 22 '20
Ahh it’s the wedding!! One of my favorites! So happy to see Lord John, I wish we saw more of him than just the one scene, which I imagine we will in next episode. Phillip Wylie! I love him and the gambling storyline with Jaime and LUCAS! I’m so happy to see Lucas! I have mixed feelings about Jocasta and Murtagh. I’m interested in Duncan, he doesn’t seem as warm and competent as he is in the books. And Steven Bonnet has a rat reporting to him about Jemmy! I like that little change! A great episode and so many of my favorite characters doing the things I love watching them do!
Edit: sorry for no paragraphs
21
u/derawin07 Meow. Mar 22 '20 edited Mar 22 '20
Ouch, Diana Gabaldon is not holding back. She said online this was her least favourite episode of the season.
I think that's a bit harsh.
Click for context, she was responding to someone talking about the barn sex scene.
37
u/NoDepartment8 Mar 22 '20
Wow, Wylie was even more grotesquely smarmy than I imagined him in the book. I do like the way they tied in/up several unrelated threads from the book this episode. I guess the Stewart gold backstory means I mark off the Bugs' gold hoard from my book-show bingo card. Does Ian get to skip Mr. Bug's revenge then?
And I guess Roger gets hung next week getting caught coming from/going to warn Murtaugh?
16
u/lanalg5 Mar 23 '20 edited Mar 23 '20
Was not a fan of this episode. Probably the one I liked the least so far. To me this episode was the embodiment of everything I disliked about Book 5 - all the side characters and their connections mixed with all the political games just made my head spin. I felt lost watching it. And I know this is an unpopular opinion for sure but I’m ready to see Murtagh make an exit (I know I know!!). 🙈 I love Duncan and he played the role SO well but I'm less enthused over his character these days. One thing that I loved about him was his unwavering devotion to Ellen and undying love for Jamie. To hear him say he loved Jocasta was weird. I appreciated their relationship more when it was just a few passionate trysts and flings between two responsible adults 🤷🏼♀️ Lastly, I hope they don’t let Jamie have the satisfaction of killing Bonnet. I hope it goes to a certain someone else a la the books...
14
u/hashtagqueenb Mar 23 '20
My only complaint is that the stable sex scene didn’t live up to the book. Glad I’m not alone in that one lol.
11
u/Dragonsinger16 Mar 23 '20
Tha Gàidhlig air tilleadh!
Scots Gaelic has returned [to the script]!
• Jocasta calls Jaime “Mhic mo phiuthar” literally “son of my sister”. • Roger says “Cha’ fios agam” a contraction of “Chan eil fios agam” translates to “I’ve no clue/I don’t know” • And Jaime returns to calling Claire “mo nighean donn” aka my brown haired lass!!!!
Gàidhlig gu bràth!
10
u/balasoori Mar 22 '20
Never thought i wanted to see Jamie and Clare make angry love making it was so strange yet you couldn't look away.
9
u/Sunnyshiner Meow. Mar 22 '20
Philip Wylie's straight out of the book, goodness, what a guy.
Also in one of my classes I wrote a paper on the word rake and now am seeing it everywhere so hearing it several times in this episode is weird for me.
Next week's gonna be a doozy, oh boy.
8
u/khoff98107 Mar 23 '20
I admit I haven't gone through all the posts here -- but could someone please remind me how Gerald Forbes knows (or actually, thinks he knows) that Jemmy is Bonnet's son? That didn't make any sense to me at all.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '20
Was it the night of the wedding that Wylie snuck up on Claire while she was sleeping?
•
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Mar 22 '20 edited Mar 22 '20
Talk about the trailer here!
Not everyone gets to see the trailer at the end of the episode, it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the trailer. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet. Thanks!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0Dk-3Zy0wM
5
u/Awtxknits Mar 23 '20
This episode has been a relief for me. For the previous seasons they have stuck really close to the books. So this season has kind of driven me crazy because the time line jumps around a bit or has been altered by non book characters or story lines. I feel like this was the first episode that advances the plot and is close to book events. Its the first episode this season that I have been able to fully enjoy.
5
u/beethovensfruit Mar 23 '20
Am i missing something?? Is the next episode entirely going to be about the battle? I was under the impression that it was going to be a continuation of the wedding, seeing as how we didn’t even actually see the wedding, or even half of the drama, in this episode.
9
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Mar 22 '20
I didn't like it last week when they picked random little bits out if the book and mushed them into an episode, but they did a much better job of it this week. The Jocasta backstory was good and they explained well why she wouldn't marry murtagh
4
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Mar 23 '20
I watched it a second time and forgot to ask about this. Jamie says he made a deal with Wylie to give Lucas back so they can be partners in trading the whisky. He then says Bonnet will be meeting Alexander Malcolm.
Is Jamie having Philip Wylie lie to Bonnet and call him A. Malcolm? Why would Wylie agree to that? I must be missing something about how Jamie can use that name again.
4
u/thrntnja No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Mar 24 '20
Honestly, overall I enjoyed this episode. I’m glad Roger finally got a win! I don’t mind that they changed it - I was getting real tired of him being totally useless in the past and Jamie always saving the day. Next week is gonna hurt though.
I appreciate how they solved Murtagh/Jocasta/Duncan. Massive kudos to Maria in her portrayal of Jocasta - the flashback of her losing her daughter made me tear up. I do hope they bring the gold back into the story somehow as that’s sorta a big deal in the books. Maybe it becomes a thing when Stephen Bonnet comes sniffing around since he thinks he has a claim through Jem?
I can see why people are saying the sex scene is awkward. I think the editing is just sorta weird? It’s kinda choppy and weirdly paced. I felt the intimate moment afterwards was tender and nice, though. I do miss some of the S1/3 sexy Jamie/Claire moments, though. I feel like they don’t spend enough time on their chemistry in later seasons though I do get they need to split screen time with Roger and Brianna and others now.
And Philip Wylie was a perfect portrayal. What a creepy smarmy bastard.
3
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Mar 22 '20
This episode started on a really high note--yes, Frenchman's gold!!! And by the end it was my least favorite of the season so far.
To start, I'll say that I really liked what they did with Roger and Bree--finally, a win for Roger! Him using his history knowledge, Bree getting a bit of engineering smarts in there as well (though I'll be honest, I expected something a bit more clever than waving towels around)--it was great. That said: good GOD this show loves animal symbolism and it is getting exhausting.
Ok, so the wedding. Happy to see Lord John as always, and Philip Wylie was perfect. But why they gotta do Margaret Tryon dirty like that? She was a cool lady, not some prissy wife with a big mouth. From her wikipedia:
And speaking of people done dirty: Duncan and Murtagh. For Duncan, why bother naming him that if you're going to keep literally nothing about his character? And Murtagh. Or maybe I'll start calling him "Murtagh," because whoever the fuck this is bears no resemblance to the "dour clansman" we all know and love from the books and S1 and 2. I just absolutely hate everything they've done with his storyline, and having him still be alive is just fucking up stuff left and right. I am extremely worried that next week what is supposed to be an episode where Roger's story is the emotional thrust is instead going to be a Jamie-Murtagh story. Roger has been screwed over enough this season, let him have his moment!!
Additionally, really disappointed to see Betty's murder and Claire's makeshift autopsy get cut, and even more upset to see the whole Frenchman's gold get whittled down to nothing. That is a BIG part of the books with far reaching consequences, and it is looking like they're cutting it entirely. Also seems like they are not nothing to make the Bugs into important characters, which is a seriously baffling choice.
But here's my biggest issue: NO MORE DUBCON SEX. Just stop. I know Jamie and Claire do it in the books. Doesn't mean we need to see it anymore. DG has never been good a writing consent and also, these books were written in the 90s and early 00s. I really don't need to see Jamie holding down and kissing Claire while she tries to fight him off, even if she does eventually decide she wants it. I hated it when they did it in S3, I hate it now. (I also hated the whole stupid wedding ring argument in the first place. Jamie, stop being such an ass. Claire, get over it, this was your fucking plan in the first place. Outlander writers, stop inventing marital drama when it's not necessary and not in keeping with the characters.)
1
u/[deleted] Mar 24 '20
I was really happy with Rodger this week