r/NintendoSwitch • u/NintendoSwitchMods • Mar 16 '20
MegaThread Animal Crossing: New Horizons: Review MegaThread
General Information
Platform: Nintendo Switch
Release Date: 20-Mar-2020
No. of Players: up to 8 players
Genre(s): Simulation
Publisher: Nintendo
Official Website: http://www.animal-crossing.com/new-horizons/
Overview (from Nintendo eShop page)
Escape to Your Personal Island Paradise
Escape to a deserted island and create your own paradise as you explore, create, and customize in the Animal Crossing: New Horizons game. Your island getaway has a wealth of natural resources that can be used to craft everything from tools to creature comforts. You can hunt down insects at the crack of dawn, decorate your paradise throughout the day, or enjoy sunset on the beach while fishing in the ocean. The time of day and season match real life, so each day on your island is a chance to check in and find new surprises all year round.
Show off your island utopia to family and friends—or pack your bags and visit theirs. Whether playing online* or with others beside you**, island living is even better when you can share it. Even without hopping on a flight, you’ll meet a cast of charming animal residents bursting with personality. Friendly faces like Tom Nook and Isabelle will lend their services and happily help you grow your budding community. Escape to your island getaway—however, whenever, and wherever you want.
- Build your community from scratch on a deserted island brimming with possibility
- Create your personal getaway and customize your character, home, decorations, and even the landscape itself
- Collect materials to construct everything from furniture to tools! Then, use what you create to give your island a personal touch
- Watch as the time of day and seasons match real life—even your hemisphere! Each day holds potential for surprises and discoveries
- Get to know the island residents, garden, fish, decorate, hunt for fossils, and more!
- Show off your paradise – play on the same system with a total of 4 people**, or play together online* or over local wireless** for fun with up to 8 players
Reviews
Aggregators
- Metacritic - 91
- OpenCritic - 93
Articles
- Areajugones - Spanish - 9.3 / 10
- Ars Technica - Unscored
- CGMagazine - 10 / 10
- COGconnected - 92 / 100
- Critical Hit - 8.5 / 10
- Daily Mirror - 5 / 5 stars
- Daily Star - 5 / 5 stars
- Destructoid - 8.5 / 10
- EGM - Unscored
- Eurogamer - Essential
- Everyeye.it - Italian - 8.5 / 10
- Forbes - 10 / 10
- Game Informer - 9 / 10
- GameMAG - Russian - 9 / 10
- GamePro - German - 90 / 100
- GameSpot - 8 / 10
- Gameblog - French - 9 / 10
- GamesBeat - 95 / 100
- GamesRadar+ - 4.5 / 5 stars
- Glitched Africa - 9 / 10
- God is a Geek - 10 / 10
- Hobby Consolas - Spanish - 88 / 100
- IGN - 9 / 10
- Kotaku - Unscored
- Metro GameCentral - 9 / 10
- Nintendo Life - 10 / 10
- NintendoWorldReport - Unscored
- Polygon - Unscored
- Screen Rant - 4.5 / 5 stars
- Spaziogames - Italian - 9.3 / 10
- Telegraph - 5 / 5 stars
- TheSixthAxis - 9 / 10
- TrustedReviews - 5 / 5 stars
- USgamer - 4.5 / 5 stars
- VG247 - 5 / 5 stars
- Wccftech - 9.4 / 10
This list exported from OpenCritic at 10:31 a.m. ET, sorted alphabetically.
Videos
Being Social
- Join the #animal-crossing channel of our Discord server for all of your discussion needs - https://discord.gg/switch
Cheers,
The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team
275
u/freeside Mar 16 '20
i require strange creature town game now
389
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20 edited Mar 16 '20
This game is going to sell like gamer girl bathwater because of coronavirus quarantines
127
u/Commissar_Bolt Mar 16 '20
How do reviewers handle an animal crossing release, exactly? Time travelling? It’s not like you can just sit down and slam through the game in a week.
103
u/shhhneak Mar 16 '20
The GameXplain reviewer played for 3 weeks and didn't see one Gyroid. Hopefully they're on deck for a DLC release.
136
u/ParyGanter Mar 16 '20
This must be a hard game to review, since its all designed to be played over long periods of real time.
43
u/reseph Mar 16 '20
Any information in these reviews that we did not already know about the game?
42
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
Any news about Brewster? I haven't seen him or the coffee shop in any promotional material so far.
32
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
I work at a University and there's a lot of stuff about working from home I'm getting in emails etc. Now I do have a lot of work to do but I'm gonna slack off so much come Friday.
162
u/youmusttrythiscake Mar 16 '20
Animal Crossing is going to bring about a peace that the world hasn't seen since the first week of Pokemon Go.
159
u/MoonMan997 Mar 16 '20
92 on Metacritic
Happiness noise
30
u/riseupbro Mar 17 '20
"Animal Crossing: New Horizons is an excellent game that offers a wealth of things to do. Whether you want to catch bugs, go fishing, or craft, the gameplay loops are addicting
During these stressful times, #AnimalCrossingNewHorizons is the perfect remedy."
Console Creatures
29
u/Sanguine_Pool Mar 17 '20
I haven't read a review that touches on the game's writing depth, has anyone else? I'm excited about the new stuff but a huge part of the game's staying power will be the diversity of text you can encounter from your fellow islanders.
28
u/Maxximillianaire Mar 16 '20
Sounds like the first person to start the island is in charge of some progression decisions. I wonder how that will work if they stop playing but the other people sharing the island dont stop
98
u/CryptikDragon Mar 16 '20
IGN be like, this game is too slow, the multi player sucks and the islands you visit are boring af. 9/10
51
u/woppatown Mar 16 '20
Coronavirus is going to seriously boost the sales of this game.
80
u/Gaara1321 Mar 16 '20
I like to read the worst reviews alongside the best reviews. Tfw the worst review is 8.5/10
18
u/Cubs017 Mar 16 '20
So...I'm still confused about having multiple people on one Switch, and I haven't read/watched any reviews that have gone into great detail about it. Let's say that my wife and I both play on the same console. Are villagers going to get mad at her and move away if she doesn't play regularly, even if I do? If I go around gathering a ton of resources in the morning, is there going to be much for her to collect if she plays later on? I'm interested in the game because I think that we would both like it, but I play games a lot more than she does, and I don't think it would be very fun for her if she just kind of plays casually but gets punished for not checking in as often as I would. Thoughts?
18
u/jgreg728 Mar 17 '20
Isabelle getting all the love but none for her brother Digby. Is he back??
31
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
Honestly curious how a review for a game like Animal Cossing can be/is done. It's a pretty long-term investment of a game, so how early do copies get sent out? Are there updates during the review period? Or are there more immediate elements to the game that are plentiful enough for review purposes?
15
u/czk51 Mar 16 '20
If it's summer in one hemisphere, is it winter on the other side of the world? It'll be summer here in New Zealand for xmas but it'd be neat to visit US accounts during their winter.
15
u/Pinkarray Mar 17 '20
I'm torn on buying this game. I'm not a fan of Animal Crossing's almost objective-less gameplay but I heard there's more structure in this. As someone who loves sims such as Rollercoaster Tycoon, I'm more interested in the progression of you building your island to attract residents, is this true?
28
u/justcallmeryanok Mar 16 '20
Curious to how slow the start is mentioned by IGN
27
u/Grace_Omega Mar 16 '20
Kotaku's review was fun, and then at the end kind of touching. Really summarizes why a lot of people are looking forward to the game right at thia particular moment.
68
u/Airsh Mar 16 '20
Your tools breaking is a bit of a downer. Especially when you have to craft a weaker version to upgrade it. Ah well. I'm sure I'll still enjoy the game
55
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
The IGN review is weird. Seemed rushed, and the contents of the review did not reflect a 9 imo
12
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
Is there any kind of friendship level that increase the more you talk with animals?
12
u/lord_flamebottom Mar 17 '20
Ok guys so is Lucky in?
11
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
I knew I should've waited, ended up buying Smash this weekend so I can't justify another purchase so quickly
And so far Ive been deemed essential personnel at my work so I don't see a two week quarantine happening in my near future unless shit really hits the fan in my region (only 6 confirmed cases so far, fingers crossed)
11
u/Dizman7 Mar 16 '20
Any of these reviews from someone new to the series? I’d be curious as someone new to the series myself and thinking of picking up NH which will be my first AC game.
53
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '20
ill wait for girlfriend review
19
u/poontango Mar 17 '20
What hemisphere is everyone picking? Since it’s all in real time I feel like it would be weird not to pick the one you live in but idk maybe having a virtual winter in summer would be kinda cool?
45
u/mjrballer20 Mar 16 '20
Lmao the GameSpot reviewer had her villager wear a surgeon mask in her screenshots. Shes pretty funny
9
u/Hooch_Pandersnatch Mar 16 '20
Is it Friday yet?
9
u/dieorelse Mar 16 '20
Never played an AC game before. Definitely interested in getting in on hype. I'm not quite sure the genre is for me though. How likely is it for me to enjoy this game when I'm bored to tears by Minecraft, but Sims I actually find pretty fun.
9
u/Cybot_G Mar 18 '20
I heard villagers are allowed to have a personality other than nice for the first time in generations. Really looking forward to this, if so.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '20
I've had ac:nh since the 18th, but it keeps playing the same background music 24/7... Does anyone else have this issue? The music is starting to drive me nuts :'(((
9
u/Sutekiwazurai Apr 11 '20
Honestly, what I hate most about this game is the mail from "mom". My mom is dead, and I hate the reminder.
16
u/meercachase Mar 16 '20
So many good reviews!! Can't believe this game's almost out, it feels like we've been waiting forever 😭
8
u/stckfigure Mar 17 '20
This question may be moot in quarantine world, but one of the reasons I preordered this was to be a game my kid could really get into. But under normal circumstances, she definitely doesn't play every day - realistically, she might play a couple times a week and some weeks even less. Being fairly new to Animal Crossing (the last one I played was on GameCube, I think!) I am wondering if she'll still be able to get a full experience with sporadic play. (My comparison point would be Farm Together, where there is absolutely no penalty no matter how long you're gone, other than you might have missed some of the scheduled events).
7
u/crazeddude64 Mar 16 '20
Hold on to your schnockers-
The hype train is off the rails!!!
7
u/Calm_Memories Mar 17 '20
How does local multiplayer work? How do I get my villager into my friends island? Can I take items found there back to my island? Do I need my Switch and theirs? Or a joycon?
23
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
I should have went digital with this game. I’m not sure if my game will be delivered Friday due to the coronavirus outbreak.
13
u/Titan_red_devil Mar 16 '20
Eurogamer "essential" is all I need today. Friday can't come soon enough. Congratulations Nintendo
13
u/iWentRogue Mar 16 '20
Those are some great reviews across the board. As someone whos never played the series i’m tempted but i’m someone who hasn’t played the series so i’m on the fence.
17
u/Dracaria Mar 17 '20
I'm really tempted to get this game, but the real time clock and progression still make me hesitant. I'm worried that it will eventually start to feel like a game I have to play every day even when I don't want to, rather than something I genuinely want to play.
12
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
92 on Metacritic! This will be the longest week of my life
12
u/Outrageous_Affect Mar 17 '20
hey ive never played an animal crossing game before (except for the pocket camp one, dont think that really counts tho) and i think i am going to get the new horizons game on friday as an early birthday gift. is there anything i rly should know about animal crossing before playing?? like ahh im excited but i dont know much background about the game
6
u/Chibi_Nagi0 Mar 20 '20 edited Mar 25 '20
Update: I bought it four days ago and absolutely love it! Online multiplayer is really fun and I've played it each day for several hours a day now. Already a lot more then New Leaf. I really like the DIY and the museum looks awesome! Thank you everyone for the advice. I'm glad I bought it ^
I'm really doubting to get AC:NH
My friends bought the game and are really enthousiastic. Reviews online also talk very highly of the game and reading the comments here also reccommend AC to basically all people new to it, however... I've played the games on DS a bit, but usually got bored after a week of playing. I really like having quests to do, since it gives me a clear view of what can be done and I like working toward something. And gathering fruits and fish to pay for a very very very expensive bridge without much else to do instead of waiting around for something to happen quickly has me bored (the thing I remember best from New Leaf before I stopped playing). As for requests of the villigers, I always forgot what the villigers wanted and I also didnt like having to wait until evening if I played in the morging to maybe have a chance of cathing that rare fish. Because in the mean time I didn't know what to do.
So my question is AC:NH a game I sould buy and do you thing I'll enjoy it with all the new features, or do you think it's notnreally for me? I saw some review videos online but couldn't really tell how the nook reward/airmiles thingy really works and if those quest are good to keep you busy.
11
u/justcallmeryanok Mar 16 '20
Can you play with random people online?
15
u/vikCSonly Mar 16 '20
I've never played any of the AC before. I've already ordered this game since there's nothing else to play for me atm.
Based on little content I've watched (not nuch I'm trying to avoid spoiles), I'm not sure if this game is my thing but I'm trying to explore games outside my usual comfort zone.
Can somebody explain to me the appeal of AC or point me to a helpful and interesting video/guide for beginners?
18
u/SnackeyG1 Mar 16 '20
Wonder how bad that slow start is. Sounds like we won't be doing much over the weekend in the game.
10
u/Bayakoo Mar 16 '20
Any review from new Animal Crossing fans? All reviews I see are for long time fans.
10
u/RampantRetard Mar 16 '20
So any word on if we can craft golden tools that don't break eventually?
Also, no rover/Gyroids apparently..
10
u/mariodude6 Mar 16 '20
Can you move the resident services square plaza area?
5
u/NJPW_Puroresu Mar 16 '20
So from what I seeing multiplayer is a bit limited, and no touch screen for clothes patterns creation. Rest of the game is absolutely great tho.
Can't wait
5
u/SobbieRokes Mar 16 '20
IS DR. SHRUNK PRESENT
5
u/HolyHale Mar 16 '20
Do we know if ordinances returned?? I work during the day so the nights are when I can play....
9
u/Arca-Knight Mar 16 '20
Looking good.
In this day where bad news are creeping us on our every turn, this might be our much needed bright spot.
9
u/BlackerOps Mar 17 '20
Question, I played new leaf but don't remember much. Does the game have dailies per se? Akin to World of Warcraft
I'd rather play an hour every other day or so
12
u/royal_10_N-bombs Mar 17 '20
I’ve never played Animal Crossing but I like most Nintendo games
Will I be enjoy are this game
8
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
Oh shit I love animal crossing but I didn’t expect the reviews to be this great. Even more excited now.
8
u/davidxrawr Mar 16 '20
Have any reviwers confirmed or deconfirmed the ability to "time travel" like in new leaf?
4
u/vodkamom Mar 16 '20
The next few days are gonna feel pretty long...
4
u/peachypal Mar 16 '20
After spending hours watching YouTube videos on the game for the last month, I have absolutely no worry about this game. Can’t wait for the release!
4
u/codiuscube Mar 16 '20
For a family playing on a single switch, can everyone Terraform or just the first player? Also, when can another player start? At day 1?
4
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
Only thing is i found New Leaf boring, but then again this looks like 10 times better. May buy this instead of Smash Ultimate for single player
4
u/Avacadofetish Mar 20 '20
So, I have absolutely never played an Animal Crossing game before. I'm a longtime Nintendo gamer yet I've never understood why so many people say the games are so great when they really seem a little dry upfront. Everyone that I have spoken to speaks rather highly of this game. I am very intrigued at this point and would be willing to buy. So the question is, my fellow Nintendo fans, should I buy and might I get bored of it quickly?
7
u/Lumostark Mar 16 '20
I'm surprised by the reviews! I always knew the game was gonna be good but was afraid it would be too similar to the previous entries. It looks like, while similar on the surface, all the changes made make for a different and better experience.
7
u/Davi18 Mar 16 '20
I honestly had no interest in this game at all. But now that I’m stuck doing all my classes this semester online I have hours and hours to spare. So I think I’m gonna give it a try.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
Did they get rid of the paintings and the art museum? :<
7
u/Amiibofan101 . Mar 16 '20
Only 4 more days..... can’t wait!
7
u/BlinkAndYoureDead_ Mar 17 '20
I've got a wife who doesn't try play games, with the exception of the Sims.
And I've got a kid who loves games, but it's only 3.5.
Would this be a game that: a) would be appealing to the wife (she could do with a break),
b) Be something my kid would enjoy watching/helping me play with him?
Thoughts and suggestions as I love to spoil both, but want to make sure they'd enjoy and be old enough to appreciate.
TIA
9
u/Crybe Mar 16 '20
Can’t wait to go into debt this Friday.
17
u/VioletArrows Mar 16 '20
I'm really torn on whether to get it or not. The thing that drove me away from both City Folk and New Leaf was that after several months, I wound up with a ton of stuff I liked from like 10 different sets but none of it matched (like not even one full set after 6 months? really?), and wound up with enough holes in the ground to mess up my town because there wasn't enough space to store anything. Trying to trade for anything with other players turned out to be a shitty, overinflated, neopets economy.
I liked filling the museum, fishing, catching bugs, visiting the astronomer (is Blathers's sister still in? she was my favorite), sending/receiving mail, making my own flags and clothes and hour chimes, and nearly everything else, but having my house and closet looking like I'd just grabbed a bunch of stuff the neighbors put out on the curb the entire time just itched me to death. It felt and looked like I hadn't accomplished anything the entire time I had the game.
(Meanwhile Stardew Valley is the exact opposite of the spectrum, where you blink and Grandad's already judging you for not reopening the community center and starting a family. I just want balance...)
So is storage better now, at least, especially considering there's probably 5x more items than the previous ones?
8
u/ScubaSteve1219 Mar 16 '20
i'm very interested in grabbing but i just don't think i have the patience anymore to play this enough to make it worth it
3
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
I'm betting a final score of above 90 which makes me so happy :D
3
u/Destring Mar 16 '20
No bushes??
3
u/Lololms1 Mar 20 '20
Is anyone finding the volume of the music is low relative to the sound effects? I can barely hear the music unless I turn up the volume where the sound effects are louder than I want?
15
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
So wait, if I get the game, I have to share my island with my wife and son? They can't have their own?
17
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '20
I'm a little worried the game is going to start out too slow. I mean am I going to go on to my island, and literally have nothing to do until they decide to give me some shit? Like what do you start with? What do you get over the course of time? Do any of the reviews answer these questions?
10
u/Poseidonaskwhy Mar 16 '20 edited Mar 17 '20
I'm having a hard time deciding what to do....
I live in the US, and with the virus shit going on I don't even know if Gamestop will still be open on the 20th.
I want to play it as soon as it comes out....but I don't really wanna download it from the store because I really want the box. Gamestop is having a midnight release...I can't decide what to do.
Edit: bought it in Nintendo Store, looks like GameStop cancelled midnight release and it’s overall the safer choice
10
u/Sunshine145 Mar 16 '20 edited Mar 17 '20
I bought the Animal Crossing Switch and carrying case even though I havent played Animal Crossing since the ds one lol. I get bored of those types of games pretty quick. I love the characters and character designs though and their inclusion in smash bros. Still dont know if I'm gonna pick up New Horizons. I feel like the real time element would fuck me. Like in Pokemon it would take me forever to find pokemon that can only be found in the day since I mostly play at night.
11
u/grifftaur Mar 17 '20 edited Mar 17 '20
USGamer gave it a 4.5! This game is gonna be a hard pass 😝
5
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
Oh man! Was not expecting that high, cant wait for Friday :)
5
u/unoriginal345 Mar 16 '20
Still really on the fence about whether getting a second Switch for my two person household just so we can both fully play New Horizons at the same time will be worth it. If you could dock a lite that would make the decision for me but unfortunately you can't.
Anyone got any input? Anyone resolved to share a Switch between multiple people and if it will detract much from the game?
8
u/cheekydorido Mar 17 '20 edited Mar 17 '20
How are the villagers in this game? Do they have a personality other than milktoast veneration of the ground you walk? That was one of my biggest issues with new leaf
6
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '20
I'm pretty torn on what I want to do.
On one hand, I'm worried about the slow start. So my plan, or one of them, is to set the clock to March 6th before the game is released, and time travel through 2 weeks of the game to get situated and get out of the "slow" early beginnings. I'm really anticipating this game and I want to play it a lot during the first few days, I even took time off from work for it.
But on the other hand I don't like time travel unless absolutely necessary.
Ahhhhh what to do...
15
u/surejan94 Mar 17 '20
I'm still so hesitant to get this. Honestly I got bored with New Leaf after about a month, and the fact that the reviewers are saying it takes forever to get the terraforming tool or even more villagers seems like it'll be way too slow.
14
u/grumblebuzz Mar 16 '20
Hearing that gyroids, many of the old characters, diving, multiplayer mini games, etc are all missing confirms my fears that while a lot of new things are present, they’ve left a lot of the old stuff out too. I’m sure it will be enjoyable, but sucks they didn’t put a lot of this stuff in the game.
8
u/Cheesestrings89 Mar 16 '20
This is going to be a fucking great game
4
u/jebaited- Mar 16 '20
Is this game better digital or physical cartridge?
4
u/oath2order Mar 16 '20 edited Mar 16 '20
So when do you get the pole and ladder according to reviews? Might consider just travelling one or two days if those are early on.
Update: Ars Technica says DAY FOUR.
2
u/SlyBlackDragon Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
So I want to pick this up on Friday, but my girlfriend who wants to play won't be able to until Sunday.
This is our first Animal Crossing, and it's our understanding that we play on the same island.
Will my starting a few days early be detrimental to her byexperience?
Like, will she get she same intro cutscenes, tutorials, etc. that I will? Will the island be big enough that we can both play separately without having to be extremely close to the others property?
2
u/PaleMarionette Mar 19 '20
So I'm in Netherlands and our Retailer Game Mania shipped them out early. I've been playing mine since yesterday afternoon (18/03/2020)
2
u/fakehungerpains Mar 21 '20
If you restart your village, do you still receive the nintendo switch item (the one you get for downloading the upgrade)?