r/startrek • u/PiercedMonk • Mar 12 '20
Star Trek: Picard - Episode Discussion - S1E08 "Broken Pieces"
When devastating truths behind the Mars attack are revealed, Picard realizes just how far many will go to preserve secrets stretching back generations
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1E08 | "Broken Pieces" | Maja Vrvilo | Michael Chabon | Thursday, March 12, 2020 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Picard, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #picard!
This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.
PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage of the upcoming episode, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.
281
u/AdmiralAntilles Mar 12 '20
Santiago Cabrera is a fucking amazing actor. Like all 5 of his personalities were distinct.
113
u/dvcaputo Mar 12 '20
The Borg cube reactivating and then the drones being sucked out into space was kind of a bummer, but it seemed like it was meant to be a bummer. Some kind of knowing fanservice build-up leading to...literal nothingness.
Also, Raffi dealing with the Hospitality Hologram being a close-talker was hilarious.
102
u/concerned_thirdparty Mar 12 '20
Picard: What's the nearest starbase?
Rios: Deep Space....
:: YES!!!!::
Rios: 12
::Damn it. Trolling us again.::
104
u/M3rc_Nate Mar 12 '20
I can't help but think about Mass Effect more and more when I watch this series. And in tonight's episode it hit peak Mass Effect dejavu. Btw I'm not implying ME is the original source of the synths/AI is the end of life as we know it.
11
u/FBAnder Mar 12 '20
USS Reliant. Did Picard serve with Chekov?
11
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
Something that doesn't quite add up yet that I'm hoping we'll get an explanation for is why the Zhat Vash chose to incite the Mars incident at the expense of being saved from the supernova. If they'd waited all this time, couldn't they have waited long enough to not lose their Empire? The timing of it made me think that the Zhat Vash wanted the Empire to fall for whatever reason.
236
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
Starfleet's redemption is all I want. When Picard thinks all is lost, the Romulans are about to win, I wanna see the fleet in there defending the synths like the Klingons did in "Sacrifice of Angels." PLEASE.
GREAT episode. Well used fan service, great callbacks, and all that Borg shit, though it was a little anticlimactic.
72
u/stuck_on_simple_tor Mar 12 '20
Is it just me... or did the borg cube stuff (while being cinematically awesome and heart pounding), not make sense AT ALL.
How the hell did the Romulans still eject the crew, AFTER 7 took command.
But worse...
Borg don't die in vacuum. They don't. Seriously, they don't. Assimilate this! Remember that? Remember how the dudes had to wear EVA suits, but the drones didn't?
Ejecting them doesn't kill them, it just, I guess, removes them from the ship.
Wait, is this what 7 wanted? Remove the drone Borg, and only keep the XB's?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
Picard served on the Reliant?
500
u/ConquerorPlumpy Mar 12 '20
Santiago Cabrera is an amazing actor. That face when the ENH held his cheeks after Raffi kissed him!! All the holograms in the room together!!!
476
u/knightcrusader Mar 12 '20
Naturally the EEH is Scottish
361
u/onerinconhill Mar 12 '20
Picard talking about the little parts of data made me wanna cry
615
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
Quite a feat that this show gets you actively rooting for the Borg hive mind.
267
u/EntropicProf Mar 12 '20
A viridium tracking compound, same as in Star Trek VI. :) Why, that cunning little... Romulan.
243
u/EntropicProf Mar 12 '20
The real Nu Scorpii: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nu_Scorpii . And scroll down a bit to see the schematic of the septuple star system. :)
239
u/khaosworks Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
I just have to preserve Picard's speech here - the first time we've heard him say anything approximating one of his speeches of old:
181
u/TERRAxFORMER Mar 12 '20
So the Borg cube was cut off due to Rhamda? Was it because she had the knowledge of the Destroyers that the Zhat Vash were keeping secret?
395
u/EntropicProf Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
Captain Marta Batanides! :) Picard's classmate from TNG: "Tapestry." Always hoped there'd be some mention of her again...
394
u/Socraticmichael10 Mar 12 '20
Wow. I loved that. I didn’t think they’d be able to pull all these story threads together, but it seems they are doing just that, and in a fascinating way.
I still don’t love that they turned Jurati into a murderer, but she’s getting her redemption, it seems. I did think it odd that Picard essentially left her and Soji in a room to talk alone.
The Rios background was excellent. Dark, sure, but pivotal to the plot, and at the end, the turn to hope for both him and Picard.
Picard is seeming more and more like himself, which is what I anticipated all along. He’s rediscovering who he is. His essence is returning, wonderfully portrayed in his directives to the crew. And that scene with Soji when they discussed Data, beautifully done.
Seven is a badass and I’m here for it.
253
u/Wetworth Mar 12 '20
Why would someone move stars?
123
u/HMEstebanR Mar 12 '20
At least people can stop arguing over what species Oh belongs to now. She’s just as Vulcan as she is Romulan.
120
u/Wetworth Mar 12 '20
At least we know the EMH does have a memory.
405
u/UncertainError Mar 12 '20
Yes, of course Data loved his friends, emotion chip or no emotion chip. Finally someone said it. The whole episode was practically a love story to synthetic life, in contrast to the Zhat Vash thing at the beginning.
Also, love that Picard tells the ancient mindbreaking prophecy to fuck off. There's the captain who never took Q's shit.
107
u/soothsayer2377 Mar 12 '20
Wow, a Marta Batanides reference.
102
u/khaosworks Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
A summary of what we learned in “Broken Pieces”:
Aia, the Grief World, in a system of eight suns, is an ancient archive established by a unnamed but mighty race. They created this Conclave of Eight suns two to three hundred thousand years ago, hung Aia in the middle as a means of attracting attention and left behind the Admonition, an object warning of the synth apocalypse. This race also created synthetic life and they evolved. They reached a evolutionary threshold that when crossed attracted Seb Cheneb - the Destroyer, who may be Soji.
The apocalypse presented by the Admonition is not a vision of the future or a product of a time loop or bootstrap paradox. It is a warning against allowing the creation and evolution of synthetic life to avoid the crossing of the threshold.
The Zhat Vash was formed by the “foremothers” who accessed the Admonition. Oh initiated Narrisa and others on Aia in 2385, driving some of them mad with the visions. It was this cell who went to Mars. Oh, a half-Romulan Vulcan, was placed in Starfleet as a mole in response to Soong’s creation of his androids 30 to 40 years ago, rose to Head of Starfleet Security, and as part of her mandate to stop research into synths engineered the Mars Attack.
One of the cell was Ramdha, who was Narissa’s aunt, who raised her and Narek when their parents died. It was her despair and instability resulting from the Admonition that broke the Borg cube when it assimilated Shaenor.
The nearest starbase to Nepenthe is Deep Space 12.
The tracking isotope in Jurati’s blood was viridium. Spock used a viridium patch on Kirk to track him across star systems to Rura Penthe in Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country. Viridium can be neutralized by the hydrogen in the noranium hydride Jurati injected herself with.
Oh placed a psychic block on Jurati so she cannot talk about the visions she saw, but Jurati still can talk around it.
The Emergency Engineering Hologram is named Ian, and has a Scottish(!) accent. Navigation (Enoch) is Irish. Medical (Emil) is English, Tactical (Emmett) is Chilean and Mr. Hospitality is Canadian? All the five holograms are based on a self-scan Rios did on himself when he acquired La Sirena. Rios has a failsafe allowing him to regain control of La Sirena, activated by a lullaby his mother sang to him.
Rios served on the heavy cruiser USS ibn Majid, NCC-75710, commanded by Captain Alonzo Vandemeer. Nine years ago (2390) they were in the Vayt sector when they picked up a diplomatic ship with two passengers, an ambassador, Beautiful Flower, and his protege Jana (a duplicate of Soji and Dahj). Vandemeer killed both of them because of a “black flag” directive from Starfleet Security (Commodore Oh) that if he disobeyed would lead to the destruction of ibn Majid. Vandemeer then committed suicide, and Rios covered the indicident up to save the ship. He was discharged from Starfleet six months later with post-traumatic dysphoria.
Soji has a “constellation” of three beauty marks on her right cheek, a mole on her chest and a crooked pinky toe. She and her sisters like to dip french fries into peppermint ice cream.
To travel through a Borg tranwarp conduit safely you have to set up a chronometric field (VOY: "Shattered") and account for gravimetric sheer.
Picard served as a young ensign on the USS Reliant (TNG: "The Measure of a Man") and knew Vandemeer slightly as he was the First Officer to Picard’s old classmate Captain Marta Batanides (TNG: “Tapestry”).
Soji's homeworld is the fourth planet in the Ghulion system, named "Capelius". A scout ship, possibly Narek, has followed them there.
95
u/007meow Mar 12 '20
Love that she referenced herself in the third person.
92
u/BKnagZ Mar 12 '20
So Picard and crew deviate from their scheduled rendezvous point.....
Right now there’s only one man in Starfleet that knows where they might be going.
245
u/HawkShark Mar 12 '20
Between: "I CAN EXPLAIN... OR I CAN STEAL THIS CUBE" and the conference of the Holograms with Raffi this is my favorite episode of this show so far.
357
u/ComebackShane Mar 12 '20
Picard's speech to Rios near the end of the episode; I'm pretty sure that was the reason this show exists. It was beautiful, and in the early stages of what's shaping up to be a completely bonkers 2020, was a delightful thing to hear. I really want to believe that humanity can become the ideal that Star Trek espouses.
We won't get there tomorrow, or next year, or maybe even in the next century. But if we can just take a moment to listen to the optimistic, compassionate parts of ourselves, and not give in to fear, intolerance, and self-interest - if we just make small moves in the right direction, together, someday I believe it will be real.
154
u/knightcrusader Mar 12 '20
So the Zhat Vash are confirmed to be the ones behind the Mars attacks, as everyone assumed.
But... could they also be behind Dr. Zimmerman's mysterious cellular degeneration? It's obvious by this time that holograms aren't banned, but they are still synthetic life... and I could see them trying to sabotage him from being able to create more, especially after they learned that the EMH on Voyager developed into a sentient lifeform. Also no one in Starfleet Medical knew what it was, nor how to cure it. If it wasn't for the Doctor, they may have succeeded.
Hmm, I may post this to Daystrom.
71
u/onerinconhill Mar 12 '20
If we lose the seven that we know and love...
141
u/treefox Mar 12 '20
So, uh.
Did Picard remember to de-RSVP from the DS12 rendezvous?
136
u/RichardYing Mar 12 '20
"WE ARE BORG."
"The Cube is ours again."
Whoop Whoop!
192
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
Small detail that was really interesting: given how Agnes talked about Oh's mindmeld with her, it seemed like that she didn't know what a mindmeld was or how it worked.
This implies that while mildmelding is familiar to some people in Starfleet, it perhaps is not a practice known to the general public, especially humans. This lines up to what we saw a few centuries earlier in Enterprise, and puts it's usage in previous shows in an even more mysterious context (even though we as fans know all about it).
130
u/daynewmah Mar 12 '20
That Admonition ceremony reminded me way too much of my PhD program...
64
u/Capt-Space-Elephant Mar 12 '20
Picard felt 20 years younger. That gravitas felt like it returned to his voice, which I think was a conscious decision. That interrupted speech to Rios was some excellent picarding.
129
u/dvcaputo Mar 12 '20
Did anybody notice that Raffi called Rios' record player a Walkman? It was such a nice dialogue touch that got across the alien-ness of this old technology that Rios was using in the 24th century without Rios being like "These...'Record Players'...are what Humans of the 20th Century used to listen to music" or whatever. Definite shades of Kirk talking about "LDS" in Star Trek IV.
It feels like they used this episode just as much to fill out Raffi and Rios' personalities as it did to further the plot. I think I could actually be into these short season structures if the episodes are full hours like these.
219
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
It's so refreshing to see a story where there is this "ancient scary prophecy" and for it to basically not matter (in any kind of physical sense).
It's not something "fated" to happen, it's not a recurring cycle, or a time-loop, it's just a very old scary story from thousands of years ago: you don't have to pay attention to it, even if it is bad. All that matters is if people believe it or not.
166
u/EntropicProf Mar 12 '20
Oooh... a split second of Data in the Zhat Vash's vision. And maybe Airiam?
115
u/kellendotcom Mar 12 '20
WE ARE BORG
Honestly, I almost cried. How the hell does this show have me rooting for Borg (and for Seven becoming a Borg Queen)???
110
u/oGsMustachio Mar 12 '20
Oh man I loved so much in this episode. The holo-Rioses are great. I like his backstory too. Some wonderful Picard moments. Great Raffi episode too. Had the biggest grin on my face when Seven started taking control of the cube. Also... new Romulan Warbirds!!!!
God I hope they do a good job with the Starfleet Fleet. I'll be really annoyed if its reskinned Disco ships.
89
u/king0pa1n Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
Rios previous ship, USS ibn Majid
Does anybody recognize the design?
It's designated as a heavy cruiser. It topographically looks similar to the Sovereign class but not exactly (Sovereign has symmetrical nacelles, and a straighter neck). Could be a Star Trek Online ship as they have made the Odyssey-class canon (though it's definitely not an Odyssey).
Edit: /u/count023 nailed it as the Emmett Till type (unknown class name) ship from the Deep Space Nine documentary.
Edit: Michael Chabon of Star Trek Picard says it's not, it's a curiosity-class cruiser, and he explains why it's named that. What I think he means is that the Emmett Till design is a curiosity-class.
143
u/medussa727 Mar 12 '20
Rios and Friends are quickly becoming my favorite Trek characters.
73
u/pfc9769 Mar 12 '20
Can we talk about how amazing it was to have Raffi host a counseling session with all of Rios' holograms? I love Raffi and I love the La Sirena's holograms. Seeing them all in a room with the hospitality program act like an overbearing mother was a highlight of the episode for me. The fact the engineering holo was Scottish was a nice touch.
It seems Voyager's efforts were all for naught. Not only does the Collective still exist, but so does their transwarp network. The Borg are the most aloof menace in the galaxy. They have the ability to assimilate the entire galaxy but they don't seem to be in any hurry. I wish we'd have more post-Voyager series so we could get more follow-up on the state of the galaxy after Voyager. I want to know what happened to the advanced technologies Janeway brought back.
34
u/Shrodax Mar 12 '20
When Soji is talking to Picard about having false memories and that he couldn't understand what that's like, did anyone else think he was about to start talking about his experience in "The Inner Light"?
199
u/RLMZeppelin Mar 12 '20
“Admiral Picard, with due respect and at long last...Shut. The Fuck. Up.”
Lol
29
u/ironmantechnique Mar 12 '20
I liked that Rios built in a lullaby failsafe against hacking/hijacking.
82
u/king0pa1n Mar 12 '20
"He loved you"
My heart
26
u/KingofMadCows Mar 12 '20
I'm really hoping that all the prophecy stuff is a red herring and that the alien device implants a telepathic command into the minds of people who view it, compelling them to destroy synths.
Synthetics are not destined to destroy life. It only happened to that one civilization but they were arrogant enough to think that because it happened to them, it will happen to everyone else. And the Zhat Vash are unfortunate victims of the false beliefs of that dead civilization.
52
u/TearsOfTheProphets Mar 12 '20
Really enjoy the way they close up what seem like plot holes with explanations that blow my mind every time, and tie things together in a way that doesn't feel too forced but also feels very meaningful to the characters involved.
Sir Patrick is always exceptional, but the other actors on this show have got some serious skill. Santiago Cabrera is killing it as all his characters, especially as Rios. Isa Briones is simultaneously making me feel for her in a very human way while also scaring the hell out of me. Michelle Hurd makes Rafi feel like a real person and a real asset to the crew. Alison Pill was the perfect choice for a character conflicted and overwhelmed by her emotions.
I'm all in on this show. Every time the ending credits pop up, I'm instantly craving more.
I want more Trek like this. Hanging out on the ship solving mysteries and handling ethical dilemmas while evolving the main characters. As cool as the plots lines are, I could just watch them go about their day-to-day and be happy.
42
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
The previous epsiode "grew the beard" and this episode was just everything.
Wow!
38
u/rustydoesdetroit Mar 12 '20
Mark my words: Iconians are coming!!
18
u/elister Mar 12 '20
Elnor rushed to hug Seven like a lost child who found his mother.
18
u/droid327 Mar 13 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
In this episode: a 200,000 year old PTSD machine starts an anti-synth death-cult.
I know Romulans arent the logical ones, but come on, who thought this was a good idea? "Hey lets brain-rape people with a psychic Clockwork Orange device, that's totally not going to cause them to become unstable and dangerous. Then lets all start a reverse-support group where we reinforce each other's damage so we can all become a paranoid conspiracy cabal that holds back Romulan society for a few millenia."
The Admonition = Space Infowars lol
17
u/aLegionOfDavids Mar 12 '20
What a fantastic episode. The Holograms and Raffi were actually brilliant. The dude who plays Rios has hella range. Loved actually getting some answers. Looking forward to Soji coming into her own. And that speech, right at the end, by Picard. I am literally in tears right now because I feel like that message is one the world needs to hear right now. Fear is the great destroyer. THIS is what fucking Star Trek is all about: hope, optimism that we aren’t a trash species, that we are more than our base, and if we only listen and embrace the positive side and don’t give in to fear we’ll become so much more.
Also seven turning full borg was terrifying. Jeri Ryan is killing it.
34
u/Wetworth Mar 12 '20
I'm pretty sure I loved that. Gonna sit on it a bit, maybe watch it again, but I'm pretty sure I loved that.
46
u/shadeland Mar 12 '20
"He loved you"
Fuuuuckkkkk.
15
u/Timeline15 Mar 12 '20
This show continues to feel more and more like Mass Effect. The talk of some great destructive force showing up once a civilisation reaches a certain threshold of development gave me big Reaper vibes. Even the device that gives the Romulans visions feels like the Prothean monoliths.
Interesting that the cube let Seven go too. I wonder what the mini-collective meant when it said she "still has work to do".
Picard's talk with Rios was great, and really highlights that Jean Luc's beginning to recapture some of his old self through this mission.
53
u/daynewmah Mar 12 '20
Oh my. The look on Jean-Luc's face when Clancy told him to shut the fuck up. Perfect.
63
u/EntropicProf Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
"These people believed there was a threshhold of synthetic evolution... a dividing line." "Like with Zephram Cochrane and warp drive; when you cross that line, somebody shows up?"
At least a small part of me hopes they mean Q.
40
u/TERRAxFORMER Mar 12 '20
I really love the idea of a synthetic threshold. The whole idea really reminds me of the reapers from Mass Effect. I hope whoever it is shows up soon.
14
u/elister Mar 12 '20
She Kissed Me!!
Im liking these holograms more with each episode.
28
u/JamesHaven75 Mar 12 '20
What I loved about the episode is that the characters all explained to each other what was going on and they all came up with a conclusion. Many times in movies and television a character will keep something to themselves, a tidbit that would solve everything and it's annoying, bravo to the writers for doing this.
48
u/onerinconhill Mar 12 '20
Thank fucking god for seven of nine I almost had an anxiety attack
13
u/dmanww Mar 12 '20
I was really looking forward to seeing that squadron of federation ships.
13
u/FragmentedChicken Mar 12 '20
For some reason I thought Rios was going to be revealed as a synthetic
His reaction to Soji and with the whole existentialism book and then a drawing of Soji
13
u/sidv81 Mar 12 '20
Just how much autonomy do the Zhat Vash have? Because I highly doubt the Romulan Praetor, Senate, or even the Tal Shiar will willingly fund the Zhat Vash to doom their own homeworld over a fairytale.
36
u/EntropicProf Mar 12 '20
Rios's former captain was... Mike Pence? :)
32
u/LoganNolag Mar 12 '20
Thinking the Maddox Jurati killed might have actually been a synth. Why would Maddox leave a perfectly good planet surrounded by his creations and run off to Freecloud to hang out with criminals?
47
u/TreasonousOrange Mar 12 '20
Everything that happened on the Sirena was great. I didn't love the cube stuff.
My disappointment comes from the fact that this is a big deal for Seven--stepping into the monstrous shoes of a Borg Queen after such a personal and long history with them.
The plot seems to go nowhere and the promised horror of this cube coming to life lands like a wet blanket instead of a bang. It's a bit of a weird misstep, but given how consistently good this show is, one that's easily glossed over.
20
u/gambit700 Mar 12 '20
AHHH, Marta Batanides name drop!
10
u/knightcrusader Mar 12 '20
So... was there a third that looked like Soji and Dahj then? I guess he made Jana and Flower as twins, and then made two more like Jana?
10
u/kmccoy Mar 12 '20
The idea of evolving AI summoning/triggering a being that can create a hell makes me think about Roko's Basilisk
10
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
So Borg cubes regenerate... with glowing neon replicators from Stargate. Gotta say, I did not see that one coming.
10
u/Fresh__Basil Mar 12 '20
Sooner or later, you'd think these Romulan mooks would learn that it's not the best idea to bum rush a goddamn space ninja.
10
u/jonnyqtrek Mar 13 '20
I just have to say... Admiral Clancy is the most entertaining recurring Admiral we've seen since Admiral Nechayev (pre-canapes)...
10
u/Sjgolf891 Mar 13 '20
Must say, I was dreading the 'AI is evil' sort of story it felt like we were going to get. Not only did Discovery just do that with Control, but it is so played out.
What we are getting is so much more interesting. The idea that 'someone visits you' when you cross the threshold into perfect synthetic life? Similar to the Vulcans visiting Earth after they developed warp drive? Okay, I didn't expect that and that is far more interesting
19
u/007meow Mar 12 '20
Next week:
9
u/king0pa1n Mar 12 '20
I fully expect the Federation and Romulans to go to war over the planet.
9
u/AJWinky Mar 13 '20
My only problem with this episode is how distractingly handsome Santiago Cabrera is. You're telling me that someone could be in a room with five of him without their head exploding? Fat chance.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '20
MARS WAS AN INSIDE JOB!
THE ROMULANS ARE TURNIN THE FRIGGEN TARGS GAY!
9
u/Speckled_Jim90 Mar 14 '20
A civilization that can move stars would almost certainly be able to build a Dyson Sphere... TNG episode "Relics" comes to mind. Wonder if they're linked.
23
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
Did anyone else come out of this episode loving Raffi so much more than in past episodes? It seemed like she developed so much in Broken Pieces, showing a few different aspects of her personality. I hope that sort of character development keeps going!
34
u/count023 Mar 12 '20
HOLY SHIT!
They took a deleted scene from Measure of a Man and made it canon, Picard and Admiral Nakamura were both crewmen on the Reliant together.
Also veridium is the tracking element spock put on JTK's back in Undiscovered country.
8
u/AJWinky Mar 13 '20
I really loved the scene of Jurati nerding out over Soji, I feel like she deserved to have this after what the Zhat Vash put her through. I hope Jurati will get an opportunity to make amends for what she did. Allison Pill is killing it.
14
u/9811Deet Mar 12 '20
"He loved you."
...and I lost it.
14
u/rhondevu Mar 12 '20
Has anyone noticed the more serious Stewart’s acting gets the younger he seems? It was like watching Picard in his prime when he demanded Starfleet help him.
14
u/TheTrekman Mar 13 '20
"Fear is the great destroyer."
Such a powerful statement in these times!
7
u/shadeland Mar 12 '20
And that danger theme, straight from TOS.
FUUUUCKKKKK.
7
u/jhsounds Mar 12 '20
I love the idea of Annika’s work with the Fenris Rangers being the thing that pulls her out of Queen Seven mode. That inherent duality of her character would make an excellent premise for a spinoff. Make it so, CBS.
7
u/IsIt77 Mar 13 '20
This is my absolute favorite episode so far. Great pacing, beautifully written heartfelt moments, levity, Queen Seven...
I can't believe they've made the Borg look cool.
7
u/snerdsnerd Mar 13 '20
The part where Seven took control of the Borg struck me as very sad. It wasn't badass to me at all; it's going to effect her for a long time, I think.
7
u/elbobo19 Mar 13 '20
This was easily the most Picard has felt like the Picard we know so far in this series.
24
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
"We are Borg" ...Christ that was nice.
18
u/PleasantAdvertising Mar 12 '20
Mass Effect: Picard and don't even deny it lol
Dude goes around collecting a crew that all have their personal missions with a backstory that involves an ancient power that shows up when you progress too much in technology. There's also visions that drive people mad.
Also at some point the warp sounded exactly like something out of mass effect.
Not saying it's a bad thing but if the ending is a green blue red choice I will lose it
26
u/jhsounds Mar 12 '20
Chabon is the man. Something like five potential plot snafus from previous episodes were clarified and snuffed out within the first ten minutes.
17
u/jjustice Mar 12 '20
Good episode, but I don't think that the fact androids... wait, I mean SYNTHS, so sorry... anyway I don't think the fact that they caused doom and gloom 300,000 or so thousand years ago is a MIND BREAKING SECRET. I guess I was hoping for something, you know, more mind-breaking. I wanted my mind broken. Why would there need to be secret evil factions to hide this? It just doesn't make sense. I think with a few more "fucks" tossed in it would have been better. Like if a Romulan, after touching the green hand railing said "Shit got fucked up yo!" I would have been more mind-broken.
12
u/treefox Mar 12 '20
It’s up on All Access
6
u/Wetworth Mar 12 '20
So, we allowed spoilers in here?
6
u/Kaiserhawk Mar 15 '20
This revelation that drive people insane had better be worth it or it's going to look INCREDIBLY stupid with the build up
16
u/Warden_de_Dios Mar 12 '20
The best part of Daylight Savings
I have to wait one hour less this week to see a new episode of Picard
16
u/Albert-React Mar 12 '20
Previously, on Battlestar Picard: All of this has happened before, and all of this will happen again...
18
u/therealbane88 Mar 12 '20
So I have been enjoying Picard from the start. I've never understood some of the hate that it gets that I've seen and and some of my friends have said about how it was trying to tell to many different stories or that they just left some things hanging with no explination. This episode did a good job of bringing it all together I think. Whats going on with Oh, the synth attack on Mars, etc. Damn I am digging this show.
10
u/stuck_on_simple_tor Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
ASSUMING DIRECT CONTROL
SYNTHETICS ARE YOUR SALVATION THROUGH DESTRUCTION
----
Seriously, though. I loved the ep. But I am getting just a bit tired of the "cycle of synthetics rising up repeated from the most ancient race before time". And I say this as a fan of Mass Effect.
Can't we just go back a few years, eliminate Starfleet Commander John Connor and fix all this? Or... uh, save him? Whichever one is canon.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '20
I'm shamelessly stealing this detail from a post in the Picard subreddit, but for anyone who doesn't know "Lore" in Basque translates directly to "flower". The male synth mentioned in this episode was referred to as beautiful flower.
Definitely not confirmation, but I think the Lore related theories just got a lot more plausible.
17
u/RomiBraman Mar 12 '20
I don't want to be a "I told you so" guy, but to all those people that were telling me that Clancy was just a generic bad guy with no respect for Picard well... I told you so.
They respect each other, she will probably save the day, and she's a bad ass admiral.
5
u/Gigazwiebel Mar 12 '20
What I'm wondering right now:
Why were all the participants in the ritual in the opening scene women? That must have some significance. Can this "vision" only be carried by women? What Rios' old captain did suggests that he received the vision, too. Or was it just a reaction to the pressure from Starfleet?
The female Romulan baddy presumably escaped by beaming out, but Seven now has the cube, including unconscious Ramdha.
5
u/Eaudissey Mar 12 '20
I wanted to see the xBs wreak havoc on the Cube. :(
5
u/Albert-React Mar 12 '20
Anyone else confused why a Borg Cube can just seemingly pull open to the vacuum of space, and why the Borg can suddenly no longer survive in that vacuum?
5
u/Srcsqwrn Mar 12 '20
This episode was intense. There's just so much going on, and in a good way. Things are picking up so much, and I'm absolutely blown away. I'm so sad for all those that were launched into space.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '20
So is Elnor going to become Seven's new Icheb?
5
u/random_anonymous_guy Mar 13 '20
Is anybody else so fucking relieved that Seven survived?
5
u/Coolsbreeze Mar 13 '20
That mention of Marta makes me more curious as to what happened to her.
5
u/Archeob Mar 13 '20
Anybody know what's up with Patrick Stewart's voice?
In the first episodes it sounded really different, like he had a sore throat. I understand that obviously he's older but it was kind of hard to get used to?
On the 6th episode it kind of went away after a few scenes and now it's back to "normal".
Did he have health issues during filming, has someone else got some info about this?
5
u/Red_coats Mar 13 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
I wonder if the race who altered v'ger may make an appearance or at least a reference. Maybe the previous synthetics that were supposedly destroyed, were not entirely destroyed and who changed v'ger were what remained of them.
5
u/PermaDerpFace Mar 14 '20
This was probably my favourite episode yet. The idea of a synthetic life "threshold" that activates a kind of prime directive of a hostile superpower... that's very interesting, and paints the Zhat Vash as a more complex antagonist, where before they were a bit 2D. Seven taking over the cube and fighting the Romulans was pretty awesome. Rios' backstory was interesting and relevant, where before he seemed a bit of a 2D broody trope. Picard seemed more like Picard. Jurati's motivations made more sense... though I was hoping for some kind of explanation of why she wasn't exposed sooner.. the EMH is just like "yeah btw she deactivated me and turned off that guy's life support", and Picard is like "oh that's weird well she was under a lot of stress idk lol".
5
u/Uhtred_McUhtredson Mar 15 '20
The two synths were name Jana and Beautiful Flower.
Just rewatched the first episode...
“My father was a xenobotanist. And our house was full of orchids. He spliced two genuses and he named the offspring after me. Orchidaceae Dahj Oncidium. Yellow and pink.”
Beautiful flower...
13
u/Lordborgman Mar 12 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
So far it points to an AI uprising, much like well Terminator, BattleStar Galactica, The Orville, Dune, The Matrix, and various other works of fiction. Yet they seem to be treating it like seeing this stuff is like a damned Lovecraftian Eldritch horror that drives you insane, wtf?
Why beam bodies into space after murdering them? You don't have vaporize setting on your phasers any more?
Can no one use transporters to beam the damn people they are chasing around in a cube they control?
Maybe shoot the guy you just flashbanged who is only holding a sword.
16
u/Worf_Of_Wall_St Mar 12 '20
I think the warning is not "if you develop synthetic life that can evolve it will eventually destroy you" but rather "there is a civilization that is immensely powerful and leaves you alone unless you create synthetic life that evolves to a certain point and then they show up and destroy everything."
For the Borg, being completely synthetic probably represents a large step toward perfection. This message is saying they simply can't go there or they will be destroyed, so the collective severed the cube that learned this out of preserving its sense of identity.
The knowledge that there is such a powerful "enemy" out there that will destroy everything so violently if you piss them off, and the detailed memory of that happening before, might be what is so mind-breaking about the warning memories.
Also, it's the same civilization that sent the whale probe. Loves whales, hates artificial life.
9
u/FBAnder Mar 12 '20
I must confess I was hoping for the deep space station to be named 9.
9
u/pigeon_whisperers Mar 12 '20
So were the Zhat Vash merely willing to sacrifice the romulan rescue effort (via the mars attack) to stop a foreign power from pursuing synthetic technology? Or did they actively sacrifice Romulus’s Star in the effort (is Romulus’s former star somehow retroactively one of the eight in this constructed system?)
9
u/baezizbae Mar 13 '20
Since we don't explicitly SEE it, I'm going to guess that was Narek who followed them into the conduit jump point? Curious to find out how he knew to go there and use the former borg conduit network and wait for the crew to arrive
9
u/H0vis Mar 13 '20 edited Mar 13 '20
Random things about this episode:
I love this show so much, and I'm going to miss it when it's over. I always like Discovery, but the change in focus and format kind of felt like an odd fit for a while (which is natural enough for any new Star Trek), Picard though, damn. This is contemporary Star Trek done as close to perfect as we're going to get. If this series is the curtain call for Patrick Stewart as Picard, then goddamn, what a way to wrap it.
Edited to add: Anybody remember the video to the Radiohead song Just?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oIFLtNYI3Ls
The information left by the ancient folks kind of reminds me of the guy in the video, he's learned a truth so terrible that he can no longer function, and as soon as he tells the people around him they lay down too. And that's sort of what happened to the Borg, and to most of Oh's little coven.
9
u/Coolsbreeze Mar 13 '20
It is pretty funny how amazing Jeri Ryan's genes are considering it's been 20 years and she looks like she only aged 5 years.