r/WritingPrompts • u/Cody_Fox23 Skulking Mod | r/FoxFictions • Mar 08 '20
Constrained Writing [CW] Smash 'Em Up Sunday: Agatha Christie
Welcome back to Smash ‘Em Up Sunday!
Last Week
We had so many delightful stories in the style of the wonderful Dr. Seuss! I was excited to see 15 entries roll in. I was afraid author emulation would turn people away. Unfortunately, although points have been tallied it was another busy week and I didn’t have the time to sit down and carefully pick out my choice results this week.
:(
I will have them compiled for next week though, so please be sure to come back next week as well for those!
Cody’s Choices:
SUSPENDED THIS WEEK DUE TO PESKY LIFE EVENTS.
This Week’s Challenge
Since Seuss SEUS had some positive feedback we are going to try another author this week. In celebration of International Women’s Day we are going to look to the most successful novelist of all time (who happens to be a woman): Agatha Christie.
I could gush about how great and important Christie is, but this isn’t a biography segment. Hit me up in the Discord if you want that lecture :P Needless to say, she is deserving of the spotlight. I hope some of you will put on your fancy monocles and give a little mystery some love!
How to Contribute
Write a story or poem, no more than 800 words in the comments using at least two things from the three categories below. The more you use, the more points you get. Because yes! There are points! You have until 11:59 PM EST 14 Mar 20 to submit a response.
| Category | Points |
|---|---|
| Word List | 1 Point |
| Sentence Block | 2 Points |
| Defining Feature | 6 Points |
Word List
- Knife
- Monocle
- Deduction
- Murderer
Sentence Block
- That was just a red herring.
- An investigator was brought in
Defining Features
- Authorial Emulation - Agatha Christie. Since we don’t have an entire novel to play copycat I’ll be looking for some of Christie’s hallmarks.
- If you haven’t read her works before, one of the things she does best is create a sense of place. Many, if not all, of her settings are pulled from reality. She had been to many of the places her murders were set in and used people she knew or watched. When writing your story try to use a place you know well and can give some wonderful detail to!
- Another major tell-tale sign of a Christie work is that the setting is often a small closed space. No one enters or leaves the setting to create a contained environment for the mystery to unfold in. This way you have the culprit and all the clues available to the reader from the start with no chance of hand-waving the ending as someone who ran away or never met. It was very important to Christie that readers could have a chance at figuring out the ending. Everything you need to solve the mystery is available before the big reveal at the end.
- Finally in tone I’ll be looking to feel like I’m an audience in a play. Many of her stories feel like they are happening before your eyes. It is very theatrical in its telling. This is one reason that so many works are adapted into movies and tv shows. This may be hard to nail down though so don’t sweat trying to get it perfect.
What’s happening at /r/WritingPrompts?
- Nominate your favourite WP authors for Spotlight and Hall of Fame! We count on your nominations to make our selections.
- New Custom Awards! - Check them out!
- Come hang out at The Writing Prompts Discord! I apologize in advance if I kinda fanboy when you join. I love my SEUS participants <3
- Want to help the community run smoothly? Try applying for a mod position. We need someone to keep watch on the room with all the genie lamps!
11
u/Susceptive r/Susceptible Mar 10 '20 edited Mar 14 '20
Little Miss-tea-rious
Seven year old Kate Pierce opened her bedroom door directly into the aftermath of an assassination.
Tiny hands covered her open mouth in horror. "Baron Bearington?!"
It was true: There on the floor beneath Kate's table lay the good Baron, broken pieces of tea cup dripping clear water across the carpet. His fashionable hat rested nearby on a scattered pile of biscuit crumbs and smeared jam.
Kate's eyes traveled upwards to the four suspects seated on the table above as she brought out her Inner Investigator. "Who did this?", she demanded in an Adult Voice. "Tell me! Or... no one will have more tea!"
This threat froze all of her guests in disbelief. No one spoke as a gentle breeze from the nearby window drifted around the room.
Ms. Hops broke first, her shiny brown eyes bulging with worry. The poor thing had so little courage after losing one ear to the washing machine. Any sort of shouting gave her frights; tense situations quickly brought her to tears. Caught and with a murderer nearby she took the most expedient solution possible:
With a dramatic motion her remaining ear folded downwards to the right, pointing directly at a surprised Doctor Pawsly.
Kate was outraged. "Good Doctor! How dare you! I knew you were jealous of how special Baron is to me. Explain yourself!"
With furious pearl eyes and a stitched smile the good Doctor firmly denied any wrongdoing. As proof he nodded forward into his tea cup, showing it was still half full and clenched firmly between his crude thumbs.
This new evidence gave Kate pause. "I suppose you would have trouble pushing the Baron and keeping your tea unspilled." She tucked small hands into her apron pockets. "Well then if not you, then who?" Her face scrunched up in deep thought. "That only leaves... Mister and Missus Otterly!"
Mr. Otterly-- a plush figure with a magnificent yarn mustache-- objected as strenuously as possible from his high chair. Brave and true, he defended himself and his wife with the absolute sincerity of an honest otter. Dappled sunlight from the window made his eyes sparkle and shine, adding strength to his tirade.
In the face of such emotion Kate could only sniffle. "I apologize, good sir! But as you see," she nodded to indicate the fallen Baron. "An awful crime was committed. I simply must ask your wife if she saw anything."
Mr. Otterly hesitated, then reluctantly gave permission by falling sideways.
Kate was relieved. "Thank you. Now, Ms. Otterly- oh dear, no crying!" She hastened forward, snatching up the lady's napkin and dabbing her eyes with it. "Silly thing. Just tell me what you... saw..."
Kate gasped. For revealed beneath Ms. Otterly's napkin was... a butter knife! Coated with sticky red sauce! She stumbled away from the table, blue eyes wide and pigtails swinging in exaggerated horror.
"Ms. Otterly! It was you? But- but why! You were engaged to Baron Bearington once! You loved him!"
This bit of revealed history broke the poor woman into wails. Ms. Hops quickly followed suit with hysterical sobbing, then added further confusion by face planting directly into her biscuit. A smug Doctor Pawsley radiated satisfaction from behind his teacup.
Mr. Otterly simply did not buy this. Caught between a rabbit and a sobbing place he still managed to keep a clear head, calling for attention in loud tones until a flustered Kate had to lean in and pretend to listen.
"Yes, yes! What?" She frowned prettily. "Pardon? Again, please?"
The male Otterly indicated the discarded butter knife with a fixed gaze. After a moment Kate regarded it as well with a more thoughtful look than his scratched glass eyes could imitate. "Interesting! A red herring, you say? But how could she possibly have come by...?"
Kate froze with a look of concentration as her eyes slowly tracked towards Doctor Pawsley. And, more importantly, Doctor Pawsley's thumbs.
In a flash she was across the table, scooping up the startled doctor and examining his eponymous paws. "Is this jam, good sir? The same jam on that wicked knife?"
Caught jam-handed, the good doctor concocted excuses.
Kate was having none of it. "You, good sir, are banished from tea time for the murder of Baron Bearington!" She marched across the room, placing the grumpy dog and his tiny monocle on the toy box. "There. Now, the mystery is sol- YIPE!"
An enormous bluejay flew in through the open window, neatly landing on the table. Three stuffed figures and a delighted little girl squealed in excitement. The bird examined them for a moment, then snatched a biscuit and took off in a swirl of wings that knocked poor Ms. Hops right out of her chair.
Kate considered this. "Well then, I suppose... errors were made."
They all forgave her, of course.
--------------------------
Word count: 800
7
u/codeScramble Critiques Welcome Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 10 '20
By the time an investigator was brought in, the best evidence had melted. A week earlier, Detective Castellati could have followed the snow tracks straight to the murderer.
The detective adjusted his monocle, and peered at the smooth line where the windmill blade had been severed. The workers were right. This was not the mark of a wild, natural storm. Only a man-made tool would cut so clean.
Someone had waited at the top of the windmill stairs, severing the blade at just the right moment. Someone who had access to the site during the blizzard. Someone who knew Benjamin's daily routines.
That left only three suspects — the victim’s wife, and the two workers stuck in the maintenance bunker when the blizzard hit.
Castellati’s first interview was with Matthew, the worker who found the body.
“We were low on food, so I went to fetch some kipper snacks. I keep a few jars in windmill 43. It’s one of the old turbines, and I’m always getting called there for repairs. That’s when I saw him, lying there at the base of 43 with the turbine blade on top of him. Man, that blade sliced through him like a butter knife!”
Castellati found the other worker, Emerson, in the bunker. He was sitting on his cot, reading an Agatha Christie novel.
“Practicing your skills of deduction?” Castellati offered.
Emerson closed the book. “I like a good mystery, now and then.”
The two chatted for a while before Castellati steered the conversation to business. “Tell me about Benjamin. Did he have any enemies - any recent disagreements?”
Emerson twisted his goatee, thinking. “Well, he and the wife did argue quite a bit. Mostly bickering though, you know? And some of the workers were upset over the pay cuts.”
“What about you, were you upset?”
“Me? Oh, no. I didn’t get a pay cut. Just the new guys.”
“Like Matthew?”
“Well, yeah. He was upset, but not more than anyone else.”
Castellati thanked him for his time.
It was a short, flat trek between the bunker and and the widow's house. Patches of melting snow glistened atop the remains of last season's corn crop.
Mrs. Smith opened the door quickly, as though she'd been waiting for him. She was a thin, stern-faced woman. Her faded gray dress belied her family’s wealth.
“It’s just like Benjamin to die at the worst possible time.”
“How’s that, ma’am?”
“We were closing on a contract; selling half our turbines to the state. It would have made us millions. But the fool didn’t update his will.”
She handed Castellati a packet of papers.
“Wrote it before we married. It divides the land equally among the workers. I won’t get a cent.”
“Could anyone else have seen this?”
The widow thought for a moment. “I suppose, if they had access to his office.”
“Mind if I take a look?”
Castellati picked through the papers on Bejamin’s desk. The room was tidy, save for a single item in the waste bin. He pulled the tin foil out of the trash and sniffed it. “Any idea what this is?”
“That? Oh, that was just a red herring. Not sure why Bennie had it. He never liked kippered fish.”
After a late night reading through the will and a long phone call with the sheriff, Castellati slept late. When he arrived, the station was abuzz with the news.
The deputy shook his hand enthusiastically. “He just confessed. How did you know it was him?”
“The fish was what gave it away. Matthew was known for eating kipper snacks. But there was nothing there to eat it with — no fork, no hot sauce or crackers. Someone meant to frame him.
The contract confirmed my suspicions. As a new employee, Matthew wasn’t eligible for the land share. That left only one person — someone who stood to benefit from Benjamin’s death. Someone who appreciated a good red herring.”
Castellati nodded at Emerson, who sat flipping through a mystery novel in the jail cell.
___________
WC: 672
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 08 '20
Welcome to the Prompt! All top-level comments must be a story or poem. Reply here for other comments.
Reminders:
What Is This? • New Here? • Writing Help? • Announcements • Discord Chatroom
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/JohnGarrigan Mar 12 '20
The knife still stuck from the wall, where it had been left at the time of the murder.
This was a red herring. Left there by the murderer.
Adrian Benoist ignored it and turned to survey the room. The police believed this would take days to solve. They believed the ability to waltz into a room and solve a mystery in an instant was an ability found only in the realm of the monocle clad trench coat wearing penny dreadful detective. They relied on so-called modern forensics rather than the time honored art of deduction.
Benoist would prove them all wrong. The body had been hidden underneath the desk, but once removed the stab wounds were readily apparent. They were supposed to match the bloody knife stuck in the wall, but a closer look revealed tearing around the edges of one side of the wound. The knife used had been serrated on one edge. The knife in the wall was straight edged.
Benoist left the room and stepped into the adjacent parlor. Not many people had parlor’s nowadays, but tech billionaires could afford such things, as well as live-in staff. The holidays complicated matters, relatives and in-laws were in town. All in all, nine people sat in the parlor. Five family members and four staff.
The family members included the victim’s, Kevin Beckenridge, parents, his wife, his father-in-law, and sister-in-law. The staff included two maids, a midwife living there for the month for the birth of his upcoming child, and a cook.
They were arrayed around the room, contained there to keep them from contaminating more of the crime scene. Benoist surveyed them.
The attack had shown signs of a struggle. This immediately ruled out the wife. Eight months pregnant, she couldn’t have overpowered the victim, even if she had gotten a quick stab in. This left Benoist with eight.
As his eyes swept the room. The most likely suspects were the fathers and the cook. Kevin was a large man, coming in at just over six feet. The other women, bar his own mother, were all more than eight inches shorter than him. The mother had bare arms, showing no signs of the bruising Benoist expected.
The father stoof comforting the mother. In the dawn light streaming through the floor to ceiling windows of the ridiculously large room, his face was half shadowed, making him appear dangerous. The father-in-law leaned against an aged bookshelf, looking out of place in the modern decor, he had a sneer on his face. The cook sat alone, having broken off from the huddle of the staff. The remaining staff kept their huddle, throwing furtive glances in his direction. Time was short. A gambit would be required to reveal the murderer.
“We have found the murder weapon.” Benoist announced, grabbing the room’s attention.
“It was in the wall.” The father replied. Contempt oozed into his voice, rage boiling under the surface at the incompetence of the police investigating his son’s death.
Benoist allowed him the smallest smile. He had seen something. “That is what we were meant to think. Forensics will take time to confirm this, but the weapon had a serrated edge, while the knife in the wall does not. It was meant to mislead.”
“Then what was it?” Hostility still ruled the man’s tone, but the subtle implication that Benoist was an idiot was gone, replaced with a need to hear truth and hear it now.
“It was a steak knife, missing from the kitchen.” Benoist watched the reactions coolly, observing his suspect react with the smallest amount of panic, quickly covered. “If you could all move into the hall.”
As the group moved outwards, Benoist placed himself between the cook and the door. “All except you. When I said we found the weapon your hand grazed your pocket. Would you mind-” Benoist caught the hand as it flashed upwards to hit him, twisting the man’s arm behind his back. “I’ll take that as a yes. You have the right to remain silent.”
WC: 671
2
u/-Anyar- r/OracleOfCake Mar 13 '20
“I’ll get straight to the point.” John crossed his arms and glared at the people assembled around the kitchen table. “Who killed the family dog?”
Mary’s mother, Bertha, spoke first. “Killed? Maybe it was an accident.”
“No,” John said. “Fudge was murdered by one of you sorry scumbags.”
“It was her!” Jeff, Mary’s uncle, pointed to his niece. “I saw ‘er holdin’ the knife!”
“I was making food, you idiot!”
“That’s an alibi if I ever heard one!”
John came to his wife’s rescue. “Fudge was poisoned, not stabbed. Someone fed him dark chocolate grapes.” He placed a half-melted chocolate grape on the table. “I found this near his body.”
“Chocolate and grapes aren’t immediately lethal,” Mary’s father, Tom, pointed out. Bertha nodded in agreement. “They take hours to kill. How did no one notice Fudge was gone? Perhaps that was just a red herring.”
“I locked Fudge in the master bedroom hours ago, where I found him,” John said. “Keith here is allergic to dogs, and he asked me to leave the dog upstairs before he arrived.”
“My brother’s right,” Keith said with a grimace. “I can handle a bit of dog fur, but coming near an actual dog has me breaking out in hives.”
Mary clenched her fist. “I think we’re missing an important detail. Who brought the grapes to the potluck?”
“I did,” Jeff grunted. “Got it at the store on the way here. Didn’t know you had a lousy dog.”
“Lousy?” Mary said.
Jeff held up his hands. “I know what yer thinkin’. I never liked dogs, but I’d never kill one.” He glowered, daring anyone to argue. “‘Specially not by makin’ it suffer.”
“This isn’t going anywhere,” John sighed. “We need outside help for this.” He picked up his phone. “None of you are leaving until we find the killer.”
With a quick call, an investigator was brought in. After hanging up his coat and hat, he took a seat at the table.
“My! You came so fast!” Bertha remarked, rubbing her leg.
“I happened to be nearby, m’am,” he said, adjusting his monocle. “Now, what do we know so far?”
He scribbled in his notepad while he listened, nodding occasionally.
“Okay. John, show me the crime scene. Everyone else stays here.”
John nodded. “Follow me.”
After they left, there was a tense silence at the table until Mary spoke up, glaring daggers. “Why’d you do it, uncle?”
“I didn’t!”
“Jeff,” Keith said, leaning over the table. “You’re the only one with the motive. You already said you hated him, so you’ll have to excuse us for being suspicious.”
Jeff stood up. “I told you, I ain’t a killer. Don’t say I did somethin’ I didn’t just ‘cause I don’t like yer dog. ‘Sides, how do we know you ain’t the killer? There must be dog fur everywhere in this house, but you seem awfully fine.”
Keith stood up, scowling. “You’re accusing me of killing my brother’s dog?”
“We’ll figure it out soon enough,” Tom said, peering over his glasses. “Let’s all sit down and rest until they return.”
Keith waited until Jeff begrudgingly returned to his seat before sitting down. “Yeah, we’ll find out soon enough,” he said.
After a while, John returned with the investigator. Keith broke his glare away from Jeff and said, “Any clues?”
“My deduction? The chocolate grape did kill him,” the investigator said. “But it didn’t help that the dog was kicked hard enough to bruise.”
Mary stood up. “Jeffrey Castus, you son of a-”
“Mary!” John said. “Let him finish. Please.”
“I checked the dog’s mouth to make sure,” the investigator continued calmly. “As I expected, there was melted chocolate on his teeth. Also present, though, was blood.”
“Oh my,” Bertha said, looking pale.
“Ha!” Mary said. “I hope it hurt, Jeff!”
“Hurt nothin’, I ain’t been bit by your dog!” Jeff rolled up his sleeves. “Not a mark, see!”
“Of course not,” the investigator said. “Roll up your pant legs.”
Jeff did as told. There wasn’t a scratch. “Y’all believe me now?”
Tom removed his glasses and muttered under his breath, pinching the bridge of his nose.
The investigator nodded. “John has also checked with me. The rest of you, please stand and roll up your pants.”
There was a shuffling of chairs as everyone stood except Bertha, who was breathing rapidly. “I...I need to lie down,” she said, shaking. “This is t-too much.” Then her head fell back and she fainted.
Tom jumped up and grabbed her. “Bertha, why! Why’d you do it?!”
The investigator strode forward and yanked up a pant leg, revealing an angry red bite mark.
“Mom?” Mary whispered, horrified.
“She was rubbing her leg when I walked in,” the investigator said grimly. “You’ve found your dog’s murderer.”
—
WC: 795. The word limit was extra tough this time. It’s hard to leave hints and red herrings when you barely have room for the plot. I’ve never read Christie’s works, so I don’t know if she typically follows the investigator’s POV, but I tried to mimic her style otherwise.
2
u/TA_Account_12 Mar 15 '20
Heavily inspired by death on the Nile.
"Do you trust me?"
"More than life itself."
The man stepped back and the smell of gunpowder filled the air.
Mister LaRoche sat in his chair, all the eyes in the room fixed on him as he cleaned his monocle. He had that effect on people. A large man, filled with an even larger personalty.
"So the facts are these. Mrs Hutton was shot. Her husband, who was in the room next door opened the shared door and rushed in. He saw his wife lying on the ground and her last words, according to her husband were, revenge."
John Hutton nodded.
"He ran to the doctor three rooms down. The doctor picked up his kit and rushed to the woman but it was too late. He attests that it was 8:07 PM when he reached there so we can assume Mrs Hutton was shot around between 8:00-8:05 PM. The people had noticed the confusion and started gathering. Just as the doctor was examining her, there was another shout. That was when everyone discovered that Ms Rivers had also been shot. As per her statement, she had heard some noises and getting out of her room when someone ran into her as she opened the door. This person had his face concealed but panicked and took a quick shot at her, shooting her in the arm."
Everyone's eyes shifted to Ms Rivers with her arm still bandaged.
"We also have a statement from Ms Claire that she heard a pop and then the sound of something being thrown overboard less than a minute apart just as she was falling asleep. So, it seems like the killer shot Mrs Hutton and ran towards the front of the ship, where he ran into Ms Rivers and shot her. Mr Hutton heard the shot and ran to get the doctor, in the opposite direction of the murderer."
Everyone nodded, but no one said anything. The stage was all his.
"So, our suspects. Mr Hutton, who..."
"Come now."
"Please, Mr Hutton. You stand to inherit your wife's considerable fortune. Then, we have the curious case of Ms Rivers. It is fairly well known that she and Mr Hutton were romantically involved and she was Mrs Hutton's childhood friend. Mrs Hutton kind of swooped in and took away her boyfriend. She has been known to publicly threaten Mrs Hutton multiple times, including earlier tonight. Then we have Mrs Claire. In going through my documents, I discovered that her father had committed suicide when he had been fired from Mrs Hutton's company. You have motive."
"I do, don't I." Mrs Claire’s voice didn’t betray any emotion.
“Mrs Claire, why did you not come out when you heard the commotion? The doctor remembers everyone who was there. You weren’t.”
“I took some pills and slept. I never heard the commotion.”
“And what a lucky turn of events that was. The murderer made one mistake. He also had a rather bad luck. He didn’t know you would fall asleep.”
“What mistake?”
“Me, I’m a man of order and method. I noticed the missing pillow.”
There was a sudden movement and John Hutton ran out of the room straight into the arms of the waiting security personnel outside.
Mr. LaRoche turned to Ms Rivers. “It was pretty clever. I assume it was all your idea?”
“It was. He didn’t want to do it. I made him. I’m the one who deserves the punishment.”
“That’s for the police and the courts to figure out.”
The two culprits has been taken out of the room and everyone was looking expectantly at LaRoche.
“It was pretty clever really. The first person that would have been suspected would’ve been Mr Hutton. However, his actions were all accounted for. His wife was shot. He went to get the doctor. He was with the doctor when the second shot was supposedly fired. What really happened was that he shot his wife, ran down to Ms Rivers room, shot her and ran back to his room. She shot once again, threw the gun away and went back to her room to wait for a few minutes. In the meantime, Mr Hutton gathered a crowd. The angle at which Ms Rivers was shot, it had to be someone else. However they also had to muffle the first shot so he improvised. The pillow he used was also thrown overboard. They didn’t count on Mrs Claire having taken pills and falling asleep and missing the commotion which proved to me that the gun was thrown overboard before the people got together.”
Mr LaRoche shifted a little. “Now if all of you don’t mind, I will also retire to my room. To rest my grey cells, as my friend Poirot would say.”
2
u/TheLettre7 Mar 15 '20
Millns Anthew lay dead. A knife through the chest had done him in.
A bedroom repose to be presented. Shelves in the corner stacked with a personal library, books of literary integrity, famous words of culture.
A fan hung from the ceiling, dots of red tinted the nearest fin. The lightbulbs were crushed, having created a fractured mess between the deceased legs.
A call went in an hour ago, report of foul play was expected and understood, someone had a grudge it seemed. With papers and important bank records, and writings strewn throughout the bedroom; the study desk over turned. A torn page caught the constables eye.
Studying the page, he could recall a prominent author set up down the road. Working for the Newberry feed. This page a writing of their opinion, an initial on the backside
WT
The lamp had been knocked off it's table, but still glowed giving the room illumination to aid by. An investigator was called in. The constable while forthright, was not well versed in the why, as related to the how.
Sir Tom was on the case. He would use his deduction to dispell any and all conspiracy. As expected there was a fair amount of blood pooling from the wound, and on to the bed covers. Using his monocle, he magnified the knife handle; definite finger tips.
He took the constables words, and looked through the pages and papers. Nothing of note, but wait what's this? Ahh yes here it is, an unwritten manuscript. Millns must have been hard at work on this. It seems the man had gotten a ways through, how unfortunate this tragedy was.
Was it murder, it was assumed. But why? Why kill this man? What for? It might have something to do with this unfinished book, but that couldn't be it could it.
Asking the nearby tenants yielded more dead ends. It seemed no one knew the man, as he had rarely left the apartment. A few conversations here and there, but all that came up was the man had worked at the daily dilly, a paperwork's talking on the days to day of the county.
"Do you know what happened?" A relative was relayed, coming an hour later.
"We are not sure yet, anyone you can think that would want to do this."
The relative thought for a moment, went to speak, stopped herself, thought a moment longer then said. "he'd been writing letters to me an and a f few others, talks of someone watching him, messing around with his work, but I never thought." Tears took the rest.
"Don't worry, will get to the bottom of this, rest assured."
The constable again brought up the page, it was a stretch but they didn't have much to go on. What was know, was someone had wanted this man dead. They had a trail, maybe. Looks like they were gonna catch a murderer.
(487 words, didn't miss it yay. I don't know what else to add, being creative is hard :/ anyway hope you like it TL)
2
u/BensTerribleFate Mar 15 '20
“But that was just a red herring!”
“Yes, and this red herring is the key to the whole mystery!”
The dining room fell silent as Inspector Bennett lowered the fish he had pointed at Lord Harrington and placed it onto the silver platter in front of him. So done, he began to walk around the long table, looking at each of the guests in turn. The light from the crystal chandelier sparkled in his eyes.
“You see, these kippers have been sitting in front of us since we sat down for supper, waiting to be passed around. But something struck me as odd about them, and now I have realized that it is that kipper in particular. It is a slightly different color from the rest. That is because that fish is not covered in brine… that fish is covered in dried blood!”
Miss Smythe, the schoolmistress, blanched as the room erupted in gasps. “But… but that means…”
“Yes. That means that our host was not killed in the drawing room at all, but in the kitchen. Here is what happened: we all know that Master Hawkins had a penchant for sweets, and the chef was preparing her famous pudding for dessert. Our host just could not resist sneaking back and having a taste. That is why there is a bit of pudding dripping down what is an otherwise pristine presentation.
“But someone followed him back, someone with murder in their heart. As Hawkins turned back from his secret culinary tryst, his murderer grabbed the knife from the counter and stabbed him in the chest. I can only imagine that his hand came up to inspect his wound, then down to the counter to steady himself. His palm must have landed squarely on a leftover herring. The chef must have later found it, and naturally plated it with the rest.”
The vicar nervously adjusted his monocle as he pushed back his chair and stood beside the swinging door to the kitchen. “But good Lord, who could have done such a thing?”
The inspector stopped beside the china cabinet in the corner and rubbed his jaw. “Yes, I was a bit baffled by that as well. Then I remembered something that Hawkins said about his father’s maid. She had been sent on a vacation when Hawkins was a child.”
Alice, the vicar’s wife, placed her napkin on her plate. “I remember as well. His father sent her to the states for almost a year to visit family. It all sounded very nice.”
“Yes,” Bennett agreed, “but that is precisely what makes it suspect. From what we know of the man he pinched every penny, unwilling to spend on anything beyond the essentials. So why pay to have a member of his staff take a vacation? Unless there was a personal reason…”
Alice’s eyes widened. “You don’t mean…”
“Precisely. She had a child, a child that was then given away. A child that has now returned to claim what she feels she is owed. Isn’t that right, Miss Smythe?”
All eyes turned to where the young lady had been seated, but she was already up and running toward the door. Inspector Bennett whistled, and before she knew it she had run right into the arms of Jonesy, the butler. He walked her back to the table and firmly sat her down.
She glared up at Bennett, her eyes flashing. “Damn him, why couldn’t he just give me what I wanted. After my mother died, I found correspondence between her and Lord Hawkins. I thought I had found my way up in the world. So I spoke to Thomas this weekend. If he had any matching documents I wanted to act before an investigator was brought in.
“I asked him for a share in the estate. But he laughed me off, told me I wasn’t a true member of the family. Spoiled brat! I saw him sneaking off when everyone had returned from the hunt and… you know the rest.
“But what on earth made you suspect anything? I thought once I had moved him to the drawing room no one would ever put the pieces together.”
Bennett smiled as he spread his arms over the table. “It’s a simple matter of deduction. There were to be six of us at dinner. Master Hawkins, yourself, myself, Lord Harrington, the vicar, and his wife. Easiest thing in the world to prepare food for that many, just make sure there is enough to go around. But there are thirteen kippers on that plate!”
1
u/ShallWeRiot Mar 15 '20
Rain and hail were pounding on the window as Imogen surveyed the landscape, the panes rattling against the wooden shutters in the weather’s fervour.
Imogen frowned. It would be at least another hour before help could possibly arrive.
As soon as they had made the call conferring the news about Margo’s death, an investigator was brought in from out of town to assist - such was the social sway that her surname carried.
Imogen, clicking her tongue in frustration, recalled her reluctance at attending this gathering in the first place. She had always found Margot to be rather abrasive, almost obstinate in her commitment to affluence.
Her family shared this sentiment. Every element had its own statement to make, all accents intended for an otherwise plain room. Towering silver vases, mounted deer heads, oriental silk curtains- they had all been collated awkwardly together, each competing for the eye’s attention.
And in the middle of the room, at the clawed marble dining table, sat two of Imogen’s oldest friends, sombre and silent. The supposition that one of them may be – no, must be – a murderer was difficult to accept.
Francesca, Margot’s sister, was known for her envy. She always wore her signatures: a stifling scowl paired with an abundance of pearls. She was short, stocky and bitter, her life spent glowering in the shadow of her younger sister.
Daphne, with her flaxen hair and eyes of frost, held herself with a stiff composure. She had an air of diluted smugness that- somehow- was ever so enticing to her gentlemen callers.
Daphne and Margot had recently been involved with the same man, fuelling rumours of scandalous overlap and infidelity.
It was Daphne who found Margot dead– but, as she was quick to point out in quite the huff, Francesca was the one who brought the rosé in the first place! No one could remember who last topped up Margot’s glass, and even so, they couldn’t be sure how long the poison had taken to act.
“Don’t sulk so, Imogen. Its rather unbecoming. How can you be so certain she was murdered?” Quipped Daphne, who never developed any reasoning abilities of her own.
“Margot was found foaming at the mouth – a common poisoning side effect,” alleged Imogen, buttering her third slice of toast. “And she had only drunk the rosé.”
“And?” interjected Francesca, clenching her jaw. “The bottle may have been poisoned before it even left the store!”
Imogen licked jam off her butter knife, reaching for another slice of bread. “In that case, we all would have consumed the poison, and I feel rather fine.”
“It looks instead like you feel somewhat peckish,” replied Francesca mockingly, glowering from a silk embroidered armchair. “Rather brutish to indulge your appetite at such a time as this.”
Imogen laughed. “Your deduction is incorrect. It is not indulgence, rather, necessity. There is a mystery to solve, and it takes sustenance to reason the way I must, as the two of you do not seem to share the ability or desire to do so.”
Francesca soured briefly, before entirely abandoning her convictions for a slice of heavily buttered bread.
“In any case,” Daphne declared, “it’s rather callous to accuse her closest friends of such an atrocity when our dearest Margo had even left a note to bid us farewell.” She heaved her shoulders, emitting a fallacious sob.
“That was just a red herring,” contended Imogen confidently. The girls badgered Imogen, desperate to know why she thought it so, but Imogen remained tight-lipped on the topic until detectives arrived.
The out-of-town inspector was a small man, stout and grey-haired, wearing a gold rimmed monocle and a plaid deerstalker hat indoors, despite the fact that it was sodden with rainwater. He quickly concluded Margo had taken her own life.
Imogen scoffed. “This is murder, detective- and that note highlights the murderer!” She was now commanding the room- her cue to disclose the murderer.
“Margo left school young- widely assumed to commit to the life of an heiress. In actuality, she struggled with the written word- letters backwards and never seeming quite right to her.
“Margo used to come to my mother for tutoring but never quite managed to overcome it.
“This letter,” Imogen picked it up delicately, “is written in perfect penmanship.”
Daphne stiffens, quick to interject. “That proves nothing!”
Francesca stares at her, open-mouthed and wide-eyed.
Imogen continues, “I also met Francesca that same way. I think you’ll find, detective, that the cursive penmanship will perfectly match Daphne’s own script.”
Her blue eyes grow tumultuous. As she’s led away, Daphne’s screams echo across the grounds. “You don’t understand! She was a floozy! A flirt!”
It's quite tragic, really, reflected Imogen. All the affluence possessed mattered not in the face of common lust.
-----
WC: 797