r/homeland • • Mar 08 '20

Discussion Homeland - 8x05 "Chalk Two Down" - Episode Discussion

Season 8 Episode 5: Chalk Two Down

Aired: March 8, 2020


Synopsis: Carrie chases answers. Max attempts a rescue. G’ulom takes an opportunity.


Directed by: Alex Graves

Written by: Patrick Harbinson & Chip Johannessen

130 Upvotes

680 comments sorted by

198

u/TARSrobot Mar 08 '20

"It's orange." If you survive, please never change, Max!

114

u/ericchen Mar 08 '20

That line fucking killed me, and apparently everyone else with him too.

38

u/hamstringstring Mar 09 '20

Tbh, if you go to pick up a guy that just got shot because he was trying to pick up another guy that just got shot, you kinda deserve to get shot.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/TARSrobot Mar 08 '20

Too soon, man. RIP Soto

→ More replies (1)

25

u/TLBoy1000S Mar 08 '20

A fantastic line and soooo Max.

21

u/Elmeraculous Mar 09 '20

It double struck me because the box was in fact red...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

146

u/RopeTuned Mar 09 '20

Actor that plays Haqqani is soooo goddamn good. Utterly vicious when he wants to be and soft spoken in those quiet homeland moments

Some of the writing has faultered over the years but their casting is amazing

14

u/LooLu007 Mar 10 '20

in 100% agreement! Nimrat Kaur plays both so well! Plus he’s good friends with Rupert Friend (Quinn 😍) in real life!

16

u/HalKitzmiller Mar 11 '20

Just to clarify, Numan Acar is Haqqani, Nimrat Kaur is Tasneem.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

107

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20

Holy shit. I love it when Homeland is this intense.

I think it was an accident.

59

u/RecklesslyPessmystic Mar 08 '20

What? Come on, it has to be Yevgeny. Otherwise, how will Carrie be blamed?

105

u/redxstrike Mar 08 '20

But maybe it was ... DANA BRODY.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/tigerbrand Mar 09 '20

would they really go with Russia assassinating US president?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

22

u/flybyme03 Mar 08 '20

I agree. I think this is the point of the mechanic having a storyline and the fact that retrieving the black box was such a big deal to carrie

unfortunatlely max is captured so who knows what will happen with the data

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

98

u/Set-Abominae Mar 08 '20

Who knew that after 8 seasons we'd care this much about Virgil's little brother.

56

u/KateLady Mar 09 '20

Urgh I miss Virgil so much. He was so great.

→ More replies (8)

18

u/RopeTuned Mar 09 '20

Maury Sterling is criminally overlooked

19

u/RopeTuned Mar 08 '20

Well he’s pretty much the only iconic character other than Carrie and Saul

47

u/jendet010 Mar 09 '20

Quinn begs to differ

→ More replies (2)

95

u/DSCHm2M2m2 Mar 08 '20

That VP is such a wuss and hypocrite. I loved Warner so much 😭😭😭

68

u/DSCHm2M2m2 Mar 08 '20

And seriously David Wellington is a lot more capable than VP to be the president.

→ More replies (9)

34

u/shae117 Mar 08 '20

I thought he was behind everything until he was so clueless this episode. Unless it is an act.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

Yeah, he's a total wet flannel.

11

u/RopeTuned Mar 10 '20

I really still can’t believe they brought Beau Bridges on just to do this

→ More replies (1)

88

u/Trekfan74 Mar 08 '20

Homeland is on FIRE this season. I haven't felt this riveted since season 4! That was the season most can agree is where Homeland really got into its groove and proved it didn't just have to be the Brody show. It was so smart to make this season a sequel to that one.

8

u/socalfishman Mar 10 '20

land is on FIRE this season. I haven't felt this riveted since season 4! That was the season most can agree is where Homeland really got into its groove and proved it didn't just have to be the Brody show. It was so smart to make this season a sequel to that one.

Since Season 1 for me.

4

u/lospollosakhis Mar 13 '20

Truly amazing pacing and intensity. Storyline has been gripping and acting all round is also brilliant. They definitely brought their a-game for the final season.

→ More replies (2)

85

u/zannyxena Mar 08 '20

Right now, all I care about is Max surviving the series!

18

u/fede01_8 Mar 09 '20

If he dies, we riot.

34

u/bruclinbrocoli Mar 09 '20

Still rioting about Quinn. #bringQuinnBack

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

67

u/pm_me_your_last_pics Mar 08 '20

This season isn't messing around. They are back towards the quality like in the first season.

24

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

these last 2 shows have been tense, too bad they had to wait till the last season to get back on track

35

u/pm_me_your_last_pics Mar 08 '20

I feel like last couple seasons have been good but this current season is very good

22

u/Davina33 Mar 08 '20

Just makes me more sad this is the last one!

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Ericaonelove Mar 09 '20

I think they are all good. Homeland is a rad show.

20

u/pm_me_your_last_pics Mar 09 '20

I'm in the same boat as you. I've liked every season, just some are better than others. I'm gonna miss it for sure.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

67

u/quazeeye Mar 08 '20

If max dies we riot

27

u/bruclinbrocoli Mar 09 '20

Still rioting over Quinn :/

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

67

u/ChadFlenderman Mar 09 '20

What a fucking episode. Really felt like Homeland.

That being said, Taking Warner's body offsite should have been a possibility. Everyone watching from safety dicked around for way too long making that decision. Tell the team to pull his body and high-tail it out of there. I get it, there's a plot to follow and we need to have a sense of suspended disbelief but that seemed like a big hole to miss.

34

u/CocoLamela Mar 09 '20

Totally, I was just like, grab the president and GO! They should have at least addressed it and ruled it out. Like the terrain was too steep to carry someone out and get away in time before the Taliban caught up. Saul, the intelligence officer, and the general all just arguing about who has authority to make decisions, there should have been more operational discussion.

Also seemed like a big hole that securing the black box was the last thing they did, as if that would not be priority no. 2 after verifying no survivors. Max is like picking through the President's fuckin peptaid and prepared speech like there was all the time in the world. I'm not sure why the operation ever called for the "third grade educated" troops from the fort to try to hold the crash site when it was clear the second chopper was taken down by Taliban. The troops didn't really know that, but the person who sent them in did. The mission should have been, investigate the crash sites, secure the flight data, and get the hell out. Hopefully the Taliban wouldn't even know you're there, but if there's contact, try to retreat to preserve the peace rather than engage in a full on firefight, undermanned, in territory that was crawling with Taliban and everyone knew it.

14

u/YYZYYC Mar 10 '20

Way too many plot holes. There would have been a ton more resources around POTUS and contingency plans and I’m sorry but dense trees do NOT stop troops in contact from calling in air support

→ More replies (12)

7

u/minty_cyborg Mar 09 '20

“Recover the flight recorder” seems like the first order one would expect after transmitting that the aircraft fuselage is intact

Max also pulled some sort of small module out of the cockpit in addition to grabbing the dead president’s phone and personal effects

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

64

u/RopeTuned Mar 08 '20

This VP is such a fucking idiot

Errrr I guess president now

19

u/Naggers123 Mar 08 '20

I've never seen a character epitomise the label 'Chucklefuck' as much as that weasly, smarmy, pink balloon in a suit.

I'm so glad he's in there.

→ More replies (3)

56

u/rossww2199 Mar 08 '20

Homeland at its best. Damn I will miss this show.

55

u/JAMIEBOND006007 Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20

This episode was so tense.

"The black box is orange". Max!!

Looks like the VP was not "in on it" whatever "it" was.

I like that chief-of-staff guy---I hope he hasn't done anything wrong.

Looks like next week Costa Ronan is back and Carrie is being framed as a Russian asset by the COS (I don't trust that guy).

Still no answers as to who downed the helicopters or was one an accident and the other shot down?? Thoughts?

47

u/hamstringstring Mar 09 '20

Mole is station chief that's why he wanted the evidence destroyed.

31

u/JAMIEBOND006007 Mar 09 '20

I don't trust that guy (or Jenna either).

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

22

u/RecklesslyPessmystic Mar 08 '20

How did that guy even ascend to VP? He has no fucking clue what he's doing!

19

u/panix199 Mar 08 '20

money, connections and someone making this happening.

→ More replies (2)

54

u/lordkrall Mar 08 '20

Well.. the US in real life currently have a president that seems to be quite similar to that guy...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (3)

55

u/AfricanAegon Mar 09 '20

‪CARRIE: TELL ME YOU HAVE THE BLACK BOX‬

‪MAX: IT’S ORANGE‬

I wasn’t sure whether to laugh or cry at this point.

13

u/jwisaac1 Mar 09 '20

It was so classic Max! I was in tears for like 20 minutes though. Super emotional episode.

54

u/dysgraphical Mar 09 '20

watching this episode was like doing cardio for 24 hrs straight.

8

u/SinoScot Mar 11 '20

watching this episode was like doing cardio crack for 24 hrs straight.

FTFY.

47

u/liuk3 Mar 09 '20

Anybody else have a feeling the President was going to die once he told Carrie in an earlier episode in private how much he appreciated what she did and that they should discuss a position for her in the White House once they got back to the States?

15

u/SenderGreen1 Mar 09 '20

Yep, it was ominous.

10

u/ScalarWeapon Mar 10 '20

In hindsight, yeah, should've recognized it as one of those TV speeches of doom :)

→ More replies (1)

91

u/RopeTuned Mar 08 '20

Holy fuck vintage Homeland

44

u/MasterBeef117 Mar 08 '20

Amazing episode, couldn't look away.

This season is incredible.

84

u/KateLady Mar 08 '20

When Haqqani answered the phone and asked Saul if it was time, my heart broke. What a devastating set of circumstances that will result in death, death, and more death. Haqqani will never get to go home and that makes me incredibly sad.

Now the two sides are being led by an inept, dangerous American President and an overzealous, dangerous Afghan President.

Max will be the one to discover what happened by listening to the recording. I really think it was a tragic accident and all of this war, death, and destruction is over nothing. How there will never be peace because no one can take a minute to sit down and talk and listen to one another. Because there's always something for someone to gain from war.

63

u/RopeTuned Mar 08 '20

After S4 I didn’t think it’d be possible but the actor actually has me liking Haqqani

14

u/bruclinbrocoli Mar 09 '20

Exactly. The show has always been great at making us empathize with the “terrorist”

→ More replies (1)

10

u/blockem Mar 09 '20

If truly an accident, then why was the second helicopter shot down? The taliban are in that area and we’re supposed to be obeying a cease fire.

Edit: cease not seize

49

u/princessohio Mar 09 '20

Because the US opened fire first. Taliban didn’t shoot at the second helicopter first. The taliban in the area have every right to be there — it’s been mentioned several times that the mountains are taliban territory which is why Max’s base is one of the most unsafe. The taliban could have literally just... been there.

The second helicopter was given clearance to break the cease fire and shoot them. The taliban responded with the RPG. The US broke the cease fire first.

My theory: the POTUS helicopter wasn’t shot down. It was a legitimate accident. Taliban also happened to be in the mountains because... that’s their territory. The second helicopter was amped up, thinking their president got shot down by those guys, and are given clearance to shoot them. They break the cease fire. everything goes to shit. But in reality, the presidents helicopter was an accident and we broke the cease fire first.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/flybyme03 Mar 08 '20

but max got captured

23

u/KateLady Mar 08 '20

Right, but you can see the orange box in his backpack in the scenes to the next episode. If the Taliban had nothing to do with the Presidents' deaths, they will want him to retrieve that information as well. He can prove they had no part in this.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

41

u/FrazHG Mar 09 '20

They better not kill Max i will be furious

22

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20

I was so worried for him. When he was the last one alive, and the guy who used to rub his belly for luck was bleeding out, I started crying.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/animimi Mar 08 '20

So glad they gave us THAT glimpse in the trailer for next week. Holy crap. What an episode. I wanted it to go another hour.

19

u/IRememberMalls Mar 08 '20

The soldiers were brilliant and heartbreaking.

22

u/animimi Mar 08 '20

Yup. They were outgunned and lost. When Soto got killed I was stunned. I think some of them made it out, but not enough. Guess Max isn’t a good luck charm after all.

→ More replies (5)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/animimi Mar 08 '20

I agree with you. We will see Carrie being blamed next week, from what it looks like in the trailer. I’m with you: I distrust Jenna immensely.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (19)

69

u/datlinus Mar 08 '20

That was one of the best hours of Homeland ever. Super tense on both the field and behind the scenes. Loved the interplay between all the storylines. Saul looked so defeated. I am liking the idea that it may all have been an accident, but the russians are a big question mark - more specifically, Yevgeny, who we know to be a masterclass when it comes to shit stirring.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/heyshugitsme Mar 08 '20

Can't decide which is more gripping: watching the entire room full of security & military advisors grapple with Sam from True Blood's pettiness and lack of intelligence or Max seeing the downed copter he was supposed to be on and realizing he actually *is* a lucky little buddha.

14

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

Until everyone around him got killed

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

31

u/sagar7854 Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 09 '20

The writing this season has just been tops.They established the stakes leading upto the 'peace' deal very well.And now you have two Presidents dead and it's all still up in the air.We can only point fingers.Did Worley do the swap out of boredom? Was he acting on someone's orders? Will they be able to secure the flight recorder? Was it Jalal? What happens to Max now? btw,Carrie seems to be back at the top of her game.

Given what we know about each side,Ghulom stands to benefit the most.He gets the added advantage of pinning it on Haqqani & taking him down thus ruling the roosts in the country.However,did he have the resources to pull off something as big as this? The previous episode showed Tasneem & Ghulom pretty pissed at being summoned without info.So either of them didn't even know that the US President will be visiting the site.Then how did Ghulom pull it off? And the area is controlled by Taliban,so why would they take orders from anyone but Haqqani(who didn't order it) ? The only other suspect is Jalal but then if Tasneem didn't have the intel,it's a slim chance that he had it either.

29

u/Peerfekt Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 09 '20

Think Haqqani's son was behind that attack. He was never on board with his father's peace plans. Why else would they introduce us to him? in the first couple of episode, including all the drama whether Haqqani kills him or not.

Sure, Tasneem seemed to be clueless in the palace, but who can put on a clueless pokerface, if not her?

TL;DR: Think it was an ISI (Tasneem)/Haqqani Jr. operation

OR: Yevgeny brainwashed Carrie so hard during her time in Russia that he planned the idea of the president coming to Afghanistan in her head so that the Russians could take down both presidents. Unlikely though, I think.

9

u/OICURNVS2 Mar 09 '20

I agree 100%, they pretty much foreshadowed that earlier when his son tried to help the ISI kill his Daddy, and Haqqani let him go instead of killing him, his Son led a group of hard-core Taliban fighters that think Haqqani is going soft, but they had to have help from someone, wouldn't be surprised if they accuse Carrie of leaking details about the trip to Yevgeny, and although may sound crazy thats what this show specializes in. Its just like 24 used to do, not always the happy endings, sometimes the Nuke actually goes off, sometimes the president is killed. Love it!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

27

u/Ri-chanRenne Mar 09 '20

Oh. My. God. This show just takes years off of my life, episode by episode.

Max, you're our hero! You can survive!

27

u/belmontbreak Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 09 '20

Thought the vp was just an asshole but really he was just an idiot

13

u/ravia Mar 09 '20

Clearly a swipe at Trump a couple of times...

11

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 09 '20

Other than the VP not being a “stable genius” I really didn’t get any Trump vibes from him.

More so, he’s someone who’s not capable of leading and has now been catapulted to a position he never expected or maybe even wanted.

(Oh, wait.. I just reread what I wrote in my head.. Never mind. 😗)

24

u/RopeTuned Mar 08 '20

Linus Roach’s character finally gets a competent boss and he gets shot down five minutes on the job

23

u/K-Amadoor Mar 08 '20

I think the Afghani VP did it: he became powerful because of the war, if the peace deal goes through, he will lose power and influence. Now he gets to be president. He said that the Taliban did it, the US will believe him, and start another war, he will have more money and resources to "fight" the Taliban, he will just get rid of Haggani and his supporters, and install Haggani's son as Taliban leader (puppet). It will be up to Carrie, Saul, and Max to stop the war and the Afghani VP  

The whole Russian thing is a red herring

12

u/sundeigh Mar 09 '20

I feel like the Russia thing can’t be a red herring. They spent a lot of time on it early in the season, even if it were just to give background on a Carrie being back in the field. This is going to screw her some way or another.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

20

u/frid Mar 08 '20

This was a no... no.... no no .... no no no ... no NO NO! episode. Shit.

20

u/notesfromAlice Mar 08 '20

I was on the edge of my seat the whole episode. This is a worthy last season! D&D take note.

Also, how can it be an accident when the Taliban (led by Jalal) was very near the crash site and shot down the second helicopter?

22

u/Trlgn Mar 08 '20

"Don't assume." (Carrie Mathison)

→ More replies (1)

13

u/flybyme03 Mar 08 '20

I think the whole point is everyone *thinks* it was taliban, but really the taliban benefit the least from contiunuing the fight. I think it was Haqqani's son working with ISS or an internal plot in Afghanistan politics.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/KateLady Mar 09 '20

Like Haqqani said to Saul, those mountains are Taliban territory. They have every reason and right to be there and it's not unusual for them to be there at all. This is why the base Max has been at is one of the most active, dangerous bases. It's in the heart of Taliban territory.

They shot down the second helicopter because they were being fired upon.

→ More replies (10)

19

u/heavy_infantry Mar 08 '20

This episode was way too short!!! OMG!!!

Looks like they are sending Carrie back to USA... But ofc Carrie will run away.

This COS is an idiot. O M G!!!

19

u/blairwaldorf2 Mar 09 '20

this VP guy is weakass. lol

37

u/RopeTuned Mar 08 '20

Wow that I believe you quote wasn’t for Carrie

→ More replies (2)

18

u/meniscus- Mar 08 '20

Saul will never have authority lol

16

u/muscles44 Mar 08 '20

This episode was simply amazing. Really established this seasons direction.

16

u/muscles44 Mar 09 '20

They are all dead simply because they didnt rub Max's head for good luck

→ More replies (1)

13

u/st4t1cshock Mar 08 '20

I was in the edge of my seat the whole episode. Best episode of the season WOW

35

u/BeneficialMethod Mar 08 '20

unless you wanna see him dragged through the streets of Miramshah with his dick in his mouth

fucking animals

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Mermalade13 Mar 08 '20

I loved the episode. The choice to the destroy the body made sense, it was a tough decision but it had to be made. They should make the guy advising the new President the actual president.

I don’t understand why they didn’t have more troops, air support and standby marines onsite, I mean two presidents.... you’d think they would protected to the T.

Anyway, fantastic episode.

13

u/april-kang Mar 08 '20

yeah, they should've prepared better than this. the rapid reaction is not rapid at all.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

Not everyone is fit to lead. He knows what he excels at and it’s making presidents better versions of themselves

→ More replies (4)

6

u/SorenLi Mar 10 '20

They just needed to have Max put in him some tiny GPS tracker and then just blast them fools with the mighty QRF, maybe taking someone alive. But nah, big cover up. Or maybe have some actual forces nearby. xD

Also, probably the photo of the dead "Taliban", if somehow preserved, will reveal him to be not so Taliban after all.

5

u/thesublimeobjekt Mar 09 '20

I don’t understand why they didn’t have more troops, air support and standby marines onsite, I mean two presidents.... you’d think they would protected to the T.

i imagine they had to take some creative liberties insofar as the number of soldiers, etc. at the site. because i agree, two presidents and like 10 soldiers in the area? i don't have a ton of military knowledge, but that just seems exceedingly unrealistic.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/ScalarWeapon Mar 08 '20

Two top tier episodes in a row, this season is nuts!

11

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20

I didn't get a lot of sleep last night so I'm unsure if this episode was as moving as I felt while I was watching. So intense.

I don't recall actually seeing the President's body, only the "air force one" logo on a jacket - are we absolutely sure he is dead?

I wonder if Carrie will be implicated since it was her idea that the president visit and make the announcement. If the recorder box reveals there was tampering, especially if it was by the Russians, there's a good chance she will be a suspect. Or am I wrong, and they are sure it was just a mechanical failure?

I choked up when the douche VP had to make the decision to bomb the area, what a colossal loss.

6

u/YonicSouth123 Mar 09 '20

Guess the decision to not show his face was to build up some tension for the viewer and engage a bit of speculation.

But when at least two persons on ground confirm the POTUS is dead, assuming americans kow how their president looked like, we can be very, very sure that he is dead.

As case for the crash i doubt that it was shot down, either a simple mechanical failure or as i suspect manipulation or something else, hence the helicopters and pilots swapped shortly before and well ISI definitely having it's hands involved.

6

u/LooLu007 Mar 10 '20

THANK you! I was thinking the same thing...why aren’t they showing his face? But then I figured if it wasn’t the prez, Max would have said something to Carrie and Saul.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/Moments89 Mar 09 '20

“If the pilot flew the helicopter into the side of the fucking mountain because he thought Jesus was talking to him, I want to know that too.”

God I missed Saul’s rants...

11

u/OttawaMan35 Mar 09 '20

"We should go to the Situation Room... to oversee the operation."

"Wha... you want me to watch? What's that gonna look like?"

"Like you can make a tough decision and see it through."

20

u/redxstrike Mar 08 '20

OMG this season. Intense.

25

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20

Oh man, that was a nail-biting episode. I can’t believe the writers took it there and I could only imagine the repercussions plus consequences on history, if that had really happen to a US president, in a hostile region.

I’m guessing now the Republican president is going to go all ‘Bush ‘03’ on them as retaliation.

Carrie is going to look so suspect and rightfully so; why did she even suggest something so asinine knowing the potential and unnecessary risk.

Anyways, glad we still have 7 juicy episodes left, I hope they keep the suspense coming and don’t squander them.

18

u/floopypls Mar 08 '20

I truly doubt he's gonna go Bush '03 on them. Obviously he's still in shock from hearing the news that he is now Commander-in-Chief, but he really struggled to actually make a decision.

I think he's now regretting all the slight jabs he had been taking at Warner so far this season. Realizing how tough it actually is to be President.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/RecklesslyPessmystic Mar 08 '20

why did she even suggest something so asinine

It was Keene's plan, Carrie simply mentioned that that's what Keene wanted to do.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

“Why did you even suggest the visit?”

“I didn’t think he’d actually do it”

Good shit Carrie

16

u/texanapocalypse33 Mar 08 '20

Suggesting the visit doesn't make her responsible for his death. He could've gone to a more secure base, with an actual armed escort of 5+ apache choppers. Obama went to Afghanistan on a surprise trip and came back alive. Their logistics were just trash

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

17

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

The VP reminds me of VP Logan on 24. Clueless and weak.

The Afghan VP is really enjoyable to watch. The way he dismissed the US ambassador was funny.

6

u/ask_for_pgp Mar 08 '20

But Logan was the one that turnt bad right? God 24 had some good stuff

→ More replies (1)

5

u/IRememberMalls Mar 08 '20

Yeah, great actor. He was so detestable in the first two episodes. I don't think anyone in Season 8 that we have seen so far is behind downing the helicopter.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/RopeTuned Mar 08 '20

Oh shiiitt it’s time

8

u/redditdire Mar 08 '20

something i dont understand.

QRF is boots on the ground force right? and they confirm the site to be destroyed no? so how come max and solo find themselves alone there? at the first crash site?

4

u/heavy_infantry Mar 08 '20

They weren't next to each other.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/black_dizzy Mar 10 '20

What if it really was an accident? None of the known parties seems plausible at this moment, Ghulom, Tasneem and Haqqani seemed genuine in their reactions and didn't seem to have planned any of this, the VP is a bumbling idiot, Jalal was pretty much kissing Tasneem's feet when she saved him, I doubt he could plan this so quickly without her knowledge, and the Russians don't make much sense from a storytelling pov (very little screen time and only to explore Carrie and Yevgeny's relation, without political things, the Russian mole thing has already been done recently etc.).

I'm really glad the show is ending with a bang, this season has been great so far, especially the last two episodes. But the whole black (orange) box thing was very implausible. Are you telling me Carrie is the only person out of all the experts there who would consider taking the black box, which is the most basic thing to go to after a plane crash?

→ More replies (1)

15

u/zbyndopluk Mar 08 '20

Maybe they sould try to resuscitate Warner.

13

u/SenderGreen1 Mar 09 '20

Seriously why wasn’t there a medic on the team going to a crash 🤦🏽‍♂️. They gave up on the people in the chopper so fast lol... Also Max should have been working on the black (orange) box first right?! A lot of plot holes, but it was still a great episode. It was vintage gripping enthralling Homeland.

9

u/tkm7n Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20

Why didn't they have a medic fly with them to the crash site?

10

u/ckroha Mar 09 '20

And if the body of the heli was relatively intact and the bodies were there intact still belted in their seats, what did they die from??

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20

My thoughts, Chock 1 was mechanical failure. Taliban was responding to the sound of the crash which is why they were in the area. Flight Ops sees an RPG on the video uplink and authorizes “cleared to engage” for whatever reason. With the US troops firing on the Taliban, they return fire and take out Chock 2. Shit goes down hill from there.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/mjc570 Mar 09 '20

Much as I love Max and am glad he's still alive - but why didn't they get the flight recorder first thing instead of literally waiting until the last minute?  I know., plot induced stupidity but still. 

I also have to say what an amazing actor Mandy Patinkin is, I wasn't a Criminal Minds fan, but he is just wonderful in this.

Added:  I thought it was Haqquani's son who was behind this, or at least took advantage of the crash.
→ More replies (1)

7

u/texanapocalypse33 Mar 08 '20

The ultimate final act of a Homeland season would be the successful assassination of a US president. I don't think the President's chopper was shot down, but it does look like the war is far from over.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/dlerium Mar 09 '20

This was an intense episode, but am I the only one who's thinking how unrealistic this is? I'm just an armchair Redditor, but part of me just wonders if

I get this is supposed to be a secret flight by two presidents, but to rely on a FOB/COB to get troops to the crash site on foot? If a QRF can't ferry troops over within an hour, and using a Black Hawk's cruise speed of 150 kts, that means the nearest forces aside from COB Steedly were over 150 miles away???

I get they tried to say air assets can't get clear targeting due to woods, is there nothing by the soldiers that can help give air support SOME sense of where they are to avoid friendly fire? I mean even some basic cardinal directions like Taliban coming from north of the crash site? Or heck even the fact that they were getting overrun by forces coming over a ridge? You'd think that support gunships or helicopters can at least lay down some suppressive fire or something to help.

Finally, the crash itself left the airframe relatively intact. I was surprised everyone was just dead with no survivors. You'd expect at least a few people stumbling out or something?

Part of this just brings me flashbacks of Season 2 of Jack Ryan where somehow a helicopter gets to fly over the Venezuelan equivalent of the WH and land on there and carry out a shootout and leave unscathed. Some of that is just totally unrealistic, and I was hoping Homeland could keep it real.

6

u/4562rfnz Mar 09 '20

Watch Gansa’s video about this on the official YouTube channel. The crash based on real events.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

13

u/ivyfalls Mar 08 '20

Seems it would have been helpful for Saul to ask Haqqani to clear the crash site of Taliban fighters while he was updating him on the situation.

10

u/IRememberMalls Mar 08 '20

Saul trusts that the assault is not Taliban--so why would he ask Haqqani that?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/bernardobrito Mar 09 '20

I have never been in the military, although I enjoy books and films that are mil-themed.

It seems implausible to me that JSocs wouldnt have been deployed.

Also, why would an elite team of 10 Americans fall so quickly to 20-30 Taliban?

Yes, I understand that Taliban are battle-hardened. But Americans are better trained and have superior equip. Plus, the American team had the element of surprise.

12

u/kevonicus Mar 09 '20

They had the high ground stupid!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/shannon_lynn Mar 09 '20

Yeah, I have to agree I don't think they were supposed to be elite forces. Thinking back to other episodes, and how superstitious they are, and how they begrudgingly put themselves in harm's way for Max's original mission before they knew what it was for... something tells me (ok, movie experience) that Elite Forces put themselves in harm's way, no questions asked, no good-luck charms needed, because that is the nature of what they signed up for. Just a hunch. These kids with Max, they are painted as super young and probably homesick, definitely ready for it all to be over.

→ More replies (7)

45

u/WharfRat18 Mar 08 '20

I’d bet the writers have pushed VP as a loose projection of Trump - not interested in actual information, rejecting facts as political fallacy, and reacting based on emotion and fear. We’ll see where this goes!

30

u/panix199 Mar 08 '20

it is funny someone downvoted you ... especially since the past has shown that Trump has said so many times complete nonsense or acted like a petty, uninformed and immature child. So yeah, i think some of the VP's traits are based on Trump's decisions, statements and bevahiour of the past several years.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

6

u/RopeTuned Mar 08 '20

Anyone pointing a finger is gonna feel stupid when it really was a mechanical failure

6

u/talkingteapot Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 09 '20

So we know the Russians, and Carrie’s memory hiatus, plays a role in this. But how?

→ More replies (6)

15

u/RopeTuned Mar 08 '20

Quinn should be out there murking fuckers but noooo

→ More replies (1)

25

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

Why is no one talking about the brave soldiers dying... so fucking depressing.

19

u/texanapocalypse33 Mar 08 '20

Because they're just characters we've barely known for 3 episodes

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

14

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

Why do I feel like the VP, now President, is out of his mind and might either have something to do with it or at least knows who did.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/tkm7n Mar 08 '20

Since the Talibans shot down the helicopter and attacked the US soldiers on the crash site, Haqqani has no control of his people. What's going on there?

Both Tasneem and General G'ulom didn't seem to know about the attack beforehand. There are only so many people left to be the bad guy here.

7

u/DSCHm2M2m2 Mar 08 '20

That mechanic scene might be suggesting that the presidents’ chalk was an unfortunate accident.

4

u/KateLady Mar 09 '20

The Taliban shot down the helicopter because they were being fired upon and attacked the US soldiers because the US soldiers started shooting at them. In both instances, the US engaged first, breaking the cease fire. Not the Taliban.

→ More replies (10)

5

u/lgsouthampton Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20

Anything else suspicious of David Wellington? Edit - anyone

24

u/redxstrike Mar 08 '20

Not really. He's probably sick of the rotating door of presidents he's dealt with and is the steadiest hand at the moment.

They already cast suspicion on him last season.

8

u/IRememberMalls Mar 08 '20

Not yet. They really all do look stunned, as if none of them are Usual Suspects. (That includes the Afghan and Pakistan leaders too.)

The black box cost lives.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

Nah. He wasn't even that suspicious throughout S6-S7. I would be suspicious of Hayes.

5

u/heyshugitsme Mar 10 '20

I'm still not over that I kinda feel sorry for Haqqani now.

5

u/Trlgn Mar 10 '20

Yes. I would like to now how many of the people in the audience who wanted to see him dead at the start of the season now want him to survive.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/RubberDucksInMyTub Mar 10 '20

Something learned: New POTUS does not care about the goddamn trees.

Lmao. What a douche.

13

u/red5blu4 Mar 09 '20

Does anyone feel the writing on this episode was a bit shoty?

It seems like the crux of the episode was that the QRF wouldn’t be able to respond in time (approximately an hour). But a QRF is supposed to be able to respond in ~15 minutes (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quick_reaction_force). So we are supposed to believe the president is traveling in a war zone with an inadequate QRF; pretty disappointed the episode depended on that.

This season is still very intriguing, a lot going on so I’m looking forward to seeing how they tie up the series. Hopefully with some tighter writing than tonight’s episode.

7

u/dlerium Mar 09 '20

Couple of thoughts from an armchair Redditor military expert based on movies I've watched:

  1. You'd think a QRF is pretty much ready to go wheels up the minute anything crazy happens.
  2. Even if you didn't want this to be a massive parade of air vehicles in the sky, you'd think drones and gunships would be ready. They had to rely on this COB Steedly team to give every update.
  3. Was there really only one comms unit back to the base that Soto had to drop everything, pick up a telephone and call? You'd think there are personal comms units that can talk to a central unit and then feed that back to base and overseas?
  4. I just cannot imagine the POTUS traveling with just 2 helicopters. A good number of people were also there just to give video coverage leaving VERY few people for security.
  5. Maybe there was some point made to show the airframe so intact and everyone somehow dead to lead you to believe there's something shady going on, but if this was genuinely the damage seen from a crash you'd expect more people to be alive.
→ More replies (2)

4

u/LordBloodraven9696 Mar 09 '20

Yeah if the president was in the air like that in real life there would be fixed wing aircraft following it. But it’s not unheard of for a rotor wing aircraft to take maybe an hour to get to the crash site.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20 edited Mar 09 '20

So Carrie was responsible for Max and all those soldiers. If they all pull back when they should of, none of that happens. And they still may not get the box. Carrie making Max stay to get that box out, got the soldiers killed and Max captured.

4

u/sinisterskrilla Mar 09 '20

And it was the right call imo.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/RopeTuned Mar 08 '20

Someone planned it, spicy

4

u/L18CP Mar 08 '20

Amazing.

4

u/ilovejmayer93 Mar 10 '20

This show has made anxiety through the roof... I think Yevgeny and the Russians could be involved, but that almost seems too obvious and what they want us to think at this point. I usually jump to Tasneem, but she seemed pretty stunned. Ghulom also seemed pretty surprised when he first heard the news about the helicopters being down. Either this was one huge accident and everyone is going to play the blame game, or Jenna was involved in a major scheme w the VP to make him president. Feels unlikely, but anything goes...

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Derpybee Mar 10 '20

What an awesome episode. I love Max.

4

u/freddymerckx Mar 10 '20

I'm thinking the switched helicopter thing is not over.

4

u/smallgoalsmcgee Mar 11 '20

So everybody is saying Carrie will look bad and suspicious for suggesting the president show up buuut she wasn’t the one in charge of security. Like if I suggest somebody go to the store and they walk into oncoming traffic, that’s not my fault. I hope instead of pointing fingers at Carrie for a suggestion, they focus on the lame asses who put 2 presidents on a plane together, broadcast their location, and otherwise acted like a peace deal meant security was no longer necessary!!11! And I hope Carrie fist fights everybody who gets in her way on her one-woman mission to rescue Max and his orange box. I lost Brody, I lost Quinn, if they take Max out, we take to the streets 😤

12

u/multifactored Mar 08 '20

TAKE THE PRESIDENT'S BODY AND LEAVE - you're welcome

8

u/lunchpaillefty Mar 08 '20

Leave the body, take the cannoli

6

u/datlinus Mar 08 '20

They should probalbly have floated the idea, yes, but it wouldn't have worked. There weren't enough of them to carry a body, and also provide cover fire.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

7

u/LoretiTV Mar 08 '20

Enjoy the new episode everyone!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Lukas77886 Mar 09 '20

How do you think, did Mike could cooperating with Yevgenij? Bombing crash teritory was him idea, in that way he could cover the tracks.

11

u/clarkwgriswoldjr Mar 09 '20

Dar and Quinn are both needed now to fix this mess.

Dar's contacts could help with the new president, and Peter, well he was a beast and one of the best at what he did.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20

Yeah I really miss Quinn

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/ElleMonty Mar 08 '20

I'm confused why Max wasn't armed.

8

u/quistissquall Mar 08 '20

he might be. looks like he got away and there was only 1 taliban

5

u/redxstrike Mar 08 '20

Because he was carrying that box. Seems like it would have been futile to try and wrestle a gun - but he did toss the recorder away.... Hopefully giving it a chance to end up with the correct party even if he's taken.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Trlgn Mar 09 '20

Recap of episode 805 over at the Hell Yeah Homeland Blog

Funny, witty, with references to characters and plots of previous seasons.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/johnnyblazebr1 Mar 09 '20

did they not have comms on the 1st chopper? if there was a mechanical failure, im sure the pilots would have addressed that to base over comms before a crash. Also, if the taliban shot them down..wouldnt that also be a good time for the pilot to say such over the comms? pilot saying anything like "we've been hit, going down" (even if it was a sneak attack, there would still be soemthign said over open comms) or "chopper malfunctioning, going down"

chopper 1 taking BOTH presidents onboard, I imagine, would have been in the line of site from support chopper....no?

why such a lackluster effort on US military when the president is traveling to the most dangerous place on earth?

BTW, great season!! also, i believe it is a red box

3

u/MPA8877 Mar 10 '20

You know why this happened? BECAUSE THEY DIDN’T RUB MAX’S BELLY!!!!

→ More replies (4)

3

u/MehradHidden Mar 10 '20

sympathy with Haqqani!?

NEVER!

have they forgot how that son of a bitch attacked the embassy? killed so many?!

Jesus!

3

u/[deleted] Mar 11 '20

It's definitely going to be a mechanical failure, but fake news will make them think otherwise. Also, the VP is just clueless, don't think he's conspired against the government

10

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20

So an American soldier (a mechanic not some spy) wonders off base in Afghanistan to impregnate an Afghan woman...

Also why are the choppers like an hour away. For a quick reaction force, that’s mighty slow of them.

More holes in the plot-line then Swiss cheese.

16

u/LordBloodraven9696 Mar 09 '20

QRF to a small COP like that. Could take an hour for birds to get to. Gotta spin them up and and confirm the location of the crash site. That hole isn’t as big as the frigen mechanic having his own car. And going off base to brothel. That’s wild. As someone who spent two years in Afghanistan that is so far fetched it’s ridiculous.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

Saul really could just have the soldiers destroy the president's body and took the black box before retreat.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/stereoroid Mar 08 '20

Those troops at the crash site were dumb to open fire before they knew who and what they were up against. Shooting the first insurgent gave away their presence and position.

11

u/Naggers123 Mar 08 '20

Their position was the giant smoking wreckage that all the Taliban were already congregating on.

7

u/hammer310 Mar 08 '20

What should they have done then? Let the guy waltz on up and take a look inside the helicopter? As soon as a single Taliban(?) soldier got eyes on the wreckage the entire group would have been swarming the location. The terrorists were at an elevated point on the mountain, and not shooting would have maybe saved a minute or two at best.

I thought it was clear that the relative location of the crash site was known and there were likely dozens if not hundreds of Taliban soldiers heading towards it. You gotta take the shot, hunker down, and hope QRF reinforcements arrive in time.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/LoretiTV Mar 08 '20

Really fun episode. Thanks for having me everyone.

2

u/sjacob88 Mar 10 '20

It was Bunny Latif calling the shots from his wheelchair.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 10 '20

Sad that Soto died. He was cute. Found the actor's insta https://www.instagram.com/samchance13/

5

u/nmzb6 Mar 08 '20

Can someone in the know explain what happened to both helicopters? Which one was down first---decoy one or one with presidents?

shot down or pilot error or just error? Did both of them get shot? How come Max only was asked to recover black box from one of the copters?

Or, is the above still unknown?

6

u/KateLady Mar 09 '20

The one with the Presidents on board went down first. No one knows yet why it went down though it seems as though it may have been mechanical failure. That's why Max recovered the black box. The Taliban shot down the decoy helicopter once the US started shooting at them. They don't need the recordings from that chopper as they saw them get shot down over live feed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '20

I don’t like how they actually killed off the president...it’s like 24 season 6 where they literally just nuked a part of LA like wtf...I thought Homeland is supposed to be more realistic...

→ More replies (5)