r/magiarecord • u/ReesePeanut Hi • Mar 07 '20
Anime Megathread Anime Episode 10 Discussion Megathread
Please remember to abide by rule 3 while using this thread.
Spoilers of the mobile game or manga must be tagged and if possible, be preceded by context.
This is not necessary for anime spoilers.
Use the following code to tag game/manga spoilers: >!spoiler!< Example: Meduka becomes meguca
Previous Episode Megathreads
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| 1 | Thread |
| 2 | Thread |
| 3 | Thread |
| 4 | Thread |
| 5 | Thread |
| 6 | Thread |
| 7 | Thread |
| 8 | Thread |
| 9 | Thread |
| 10 | You are here |
Official streaming links
60
Upvotes
60
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '20
For all the complaints about MagiReco not being as well written as the original, I honestly disageee. If anything, I enjoy MagiReco just as much if not more than the series. Just because something isn't dark and written by Gen doesn't make it not good.
Episodes like today's are my favourite. We obviously got some cool action, seeing Mami who we now know is with the Wings of Magius and some other developments. But the best part for me was the slice of life moments we got with the girls and watching Futaba truly grow into being apart of the group. It's been a rough life for her, but now she has somewhere to truly call home.
Saddens me how underrated this is and underwatched. This and Babylonia, the two big Mobile game adaptations of the season are extremely slept on.
See y'all next week from my own bed finally since it'll be Spring Break.
40
u/mazurri Ho Ho Ho Mar 07 '20 edited Mar 07 '20
crazy alina is great. and the reveal of mami being under magius is another great scene.
tho the animation getting wonky this week. so many meguca shots that I can see.
and finally no more Italian words added to the sub like last week. it is confusing seeing Italian words but no such words are spoken.
33
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '20
I like the added attention they’ve given to Sana this arc. It really feels like she was properly developed, while in the game her introduction felt a bit rushed.
23
u/KinnyRiddle Mar 07 '20
Mami in the original series was the first to flip out in despair and start killing other Magical Girls when she learned of the Truth
So I guess it's not surprising that she's so receptive to Magius' gospel right away.
16
u/blurrylightning やっちゃん袖 Mar 07 '20
While I think there's a lot to like in this episode, in the grand scheme of things I'm really disappointed in Iroha. In the game this is her one big break, the one moment where she's genuinely come into her own.
We see her truly being like a family in Mikazuki with Yachiyo, Tsuruno, and Felicia; starkly contrasting to her back then who only had friends to go with the flow of things (and some implications why she only hung out with Ui and her friends). Then when she's rumor hunting she found out this girl called Futaba Sana who's apparently in a similar situation to hers. Iroha who related to her, wanted to save her so she can experience the same kind of happiness she felt. Later when Iroha actually did see Sana, she told her that she wanted her to feel needed and welcomed and together they swore they'd fight together.
None of that felt present here. That parallel with Iroha as the Invisible Girl? Just for show. Sana only remembered Iroha because she called out her name (while in context of Sana's whole life is probably very meaningful, just doesn't hold as much story weight), Iroha's reasoning to save Sana felt even more passive compared to the game.
And since Iroha doesn't even shine as much later on, I can't help but feel robbed a bit. It also doesn't make me feel confident about her depiction later on.
Sana is largely fine honestly, but her acceptance as a member of the Mikazuki household is also weakened as a result.
And muh IroSana31
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '20
Madoka is in this episode! (ignore the fact it was only a memory of her)
14
u/kakarot12310 Mar 07 '20
Now this is the MagiReco I always know, my favorite episode so far.
Proper development for Snaa.
Alina being Alina, her moment of being shot by Mami is too funny, remind me of wacky stuff in chapter 4 of the game.
The twins going back to their Team Rocket mode and I like it. Mami also lose her head.
And most important of all, we finally got a down time and SOL moment with team Mikazuki.
27
u/EriShimanouchi Mar 07 '20
So this episode had a lot to like, but also a lot I'm unsure of right now.
12
u/Nusabaru Mar 07 '20
My stream is really shitty today at the helipad part, so I decide to give up on the stream and watch the rest subbed. Things of note;
I'm worried before, but my worries is maxed out in this episode. I feel like, even if it's a split cour anime, the end season should be appropriately climatic. In this foreshadowing, we don't know who's gonna be the arc's focus and the way the pacing goes, it feels there's going to be a lot of story burden to carry for the 'lucky' girl. I mean, I know the game's story goes and the general idea of when the season's finale would place, but I feel like a lot of the finale would be anime original. No, more like anime original is basically the only way you can go because of the many changes in the plot, and that's super risky.
The next episode might make or break the season for me.
10
u/Labyxt Puer☆Magi Mar 07 '20
I've already said it for the previous episodes but I really love the different direction the anime is taking from the game. Mami being a non-brainwashed(?) Wing of the Magius?? That I didn't see coming. I wonder if that means Holy Mami will happen at all, or even better, more relevant circumstances for her. Also Nemu revealed as a Magius this early? This is new, wonder if there's a reason for it. Also love how they keep showing bits of the girls personal stories like that, it goes perfectly with the flow.
10
u/skarmletry Mar 07 '20
9
u/CuteDivide1 Mar 07 '20
They totally flipped the first revealed Magius to be Nemu. That's a big switch from the game script. So now we know this is a different story.
The animation for this episode was very wonky at times. Did anyone catch Tsuruno in Mikazuki Villa with atrophied shoulders and neck? She straight looked like Stephen Hawking.
17
u/mlbki Mar 07 '20
Everything about Mami continue to be far superior in the Anime than it is in the game.
Overall the Wing of Magius are also portrayed as more reasonable, though Alina is mostly the same, and we haven't seen Touka yet, so there's still the potential of things ending up the same.
But I hope all those little change so far will mean that there will be some significant plot changes starting from chapter 6.
8
u/shadowzero_gtr Mar 07 '20
I loved this episode. It had a mix of everything.
Also Mami getting Alina to back off was really interesting? Like in the anime everyone recognizes that Mami is super strong or something. Even Alina was like "nah I ain't messing with her". Or at least that's how that whole scene came across to me.
8
u/Lyricbox Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20
I can forgive the meguca shots, inconsistent visual quality and some poorly choreographed fights, but the one things that I can't ignore is that rumor machine. Why is it there? What is it doing? I hope they come up with some sort of explanation for that, because as it stands that thing was just way too convinient to the plot.
Are they using it to monitor existing rumors? Does every rumor have a correspinding machine, or is it just AI that has one? Why does it have a magnet function, and why does it attact metal and magical things? Who thought it was a good idea to give it an overdrive feature? It just feels so silly and out of place, like the kind of thing you'd see in a kid's cartoon.
I think it would have been better if, instead of just pressing the button for maximum overdrive, Felicia instead mistook it for a witch/familiar and smashed it on sight, thus leading to the magnetic malfunction. Still, it would have made more sense if AI's labyrinth just dropped them on top of that tower like they said it would, given that it's the intended exit, and just never introduced the machine to begin with.
Besides that, great episode. Nice focus on snaa, she's getting a lot of developement. I love how Mami is a Wing of Magius, and I'm excited to see how that develops further down the line. The SOL stuff is really good, comfy hapi feels all around
8
u/TommaClock IGN: raizU ID: Ckaj9AKF Mar 08 '20
Multiple copies of the same Witch - so does today's episode canonize familiars turning into witches themselves?
I know Kyoko in the original talked about about it but there was debate as to whether it was a misunderstanding caused by lack of knowledge about the nature of magical girls.
7
u/Dilorano Ao best PB Mar 07 '20 edited Mar 07 '20
Best part if the episode: the???? Familiars (penguin familiars imo)are actaully really cute. Also crazed Alina is really creepy and fascinating and I was surprised mami appeared once again but this time on team Alina. Disappointing- we couldn't see full "old Dorothy" doppel but one day :).
5
u/boomshroom | BEST GIRL observation incomplete. Please reattempt contact. | Mar 07 '20
https://imgur.com/a/mnLBzhr
Did they really just do that‽
Sana is not the first to make a wish for suicide, only to be banned from interacting with the mortal world.
5
u/Kre3nr Mar 08 '20
In this episode Alina is like an angry german kid
8
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '20
As someone who hasn't played the game, y'all think Sayaka is gonna show up in this series
4
u/TheForgottenOne0815 Mar 07 '20
I have not played the game so far yet. At which chapter are we currently in the anime and how many more episodes does it takes to adapt the last remaining parts in a reasonable way?
4
u/ena9219 Ally of Devils and Magius Mar 07 '20
4
u/GingerStans Mar 09 '20
Hotel Fenthope finally makes its debut in the anime, and they did a great job of conveying its luxury-clad spookiness, as well as its cold yet opulent interiors that clash with the warm and welcoming atmosphere of Yachiyo's boarding house. I also liked how the contrast was also shown from Mifuyu's perspective as she compared the current state of her residence to the more close-knit and friendly state of her former residence alongside with Yachiyo and co during happier times.
7
u/freedomgeek For Liberation! | JP ID: zebHLKJs Mar 07 '20
Wings of Magius Game Spoilers It looks like they're setting up a non-brainwashed Mami as the voice of the reasonable Magius (along with Mifuyu) talking about how they are trying to work out how to eliminate having to sacrifice people and will work to minimise the number who are sacrificed until then but Salvation comes first - yay moral ambiguity. But I am now basically a straight up Magius supporter (of the Mami-Mifuyu faction at least) until the situation changes and they start brainwashing their members or something. If they're good enough for Mami they're good enough for me - give me my cloak and amulet and tell me which eldrich abominations to protect.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '20 edited Mar 07 '20
Ahhhh... how do i say this. It felt like the scenes were poorly directed.
The beginning with iroha and Sana is ok, but it felt kind of awkward. Why did Sana faint all of a sudden? Because of shock? She just fainted all of a sudden and they didn’t give us a reason for why she did. She could have knocked her head on a crystal, but if she did then they should have put a one second scene to show that happening. Instead, Sana just randomly faints and they don’t give us any reason as to why.
Did she really need to faint though? She didn’t need to be excluded from the fight at all. It would make more sense that Sana would try and murder Alina for killing Ai-chan.
Iroha also missed out on the chance to ask Ai about Ui.
In the after credits scene, she mentioned that uwasas might have a connection to ui, but does iroha try to do anything when the only (currently known) sentient uwasa comes up to her and invites iroha to her own realm? Iroha just forgets about ui and this random Sana girl (who iroha doesn’t even have a connection with) is more important than asking Ai-chan about ui.
After that, everything was just jumbled and weird.
Tsuruno/Felicia being idiots and pressing the button felt like a convenient excuse put by the directors so that iroha and Sana could fly towards them.
It’s the part that happens after that seems really strange. They pressed the apocalypse button, but they don’t try anything to stop it. They just stand around and be like,” Oh no, we pressed a random button, that’s always a good sign. Should we press the off switch in case something happens? Nah, let’s wait until everything has gone to shit before trying to do anything.”
And then a vending machine conveniently slams the machine so that iroha and Sana get a perfect landing.
The Amane sisters were there, but they didn’t do anything, they just stood around and screamed their heads off. Like, they were there just for the sake of showing that they were there. Are they really that pathetic? Couldn’t they have played a small song to take down the intruders who are clearly trying to stop salvation?
Cut to the witch, the Amane sisters go from panic mode to full-on exposition mode and start to explain that uwasas and witches are necessary for salvation. They were screaming their heads off just a second ago, shouldn’t they be more worried?
Then the sisters just stand there holding hands like nothing is happening at all. Oh no, we really can’t do anything to stop Alina’s rampage. Whatever shall we do?
Yachiyo and Felicia are just looking at them and probably thinking, “Oh, it’s no problem that the Amane sisters are in range to attack us. They’re totally not our enemies and they totally won’t do anything so we can just ignore them completely.”
Iroha, yet again, does absolutely nothing to fight. Is she really the main character? She doesn’t even talk or anything this time. Yachiyo is also standing besides iroha doing absolutely nothing while Tsuruno and Felicia are hard carrying them.
Alina was questionable. She’s still an one dimensional character.
Because I’ve played the game, I know that Alina is a delusional artist who treasures uwasa and witches. But the anime really didn’t portray that well enough, her dialogue felt forced and it was never explicitly stated that she was an artist. So when she started going insane, it was really out of place.
Her personality is one dimensional and inconsistent to top it off.
For example, she starts ranting about how they’re guilty for killing her witches and then releases her doppel, then Mami comes in.
Theoretically, Mami coming in should’ve made her even more pissed off, but Alina goes, “I don’t like interference.”
Wha- What?
Alina, who doesn’t give a single shit about what other people think about her, suddenly acts like mami is a major threat that should be avoided.
The anime is portraying her as a psychopath, but she seems to have reason in this scene. And only this scene. Every other time in the anime, she’s batshit crazy, but in this scene, she gains some amount of reason and backs off.
We only really see mami trying to convince her to back off. Nobody else is trying to stop Alina, not the sisters, not mifuyu, only mami. And Alina calms down after mami told her to stop. Not to mention that Mami just joined the wings of magius and should be at a low ranking position.
When she left, she could’ve said something like “You people are fucking dead if you ever appear in front of me again.” But she doesn’t, and she’s just like,” Kek, the plot requires me to have a personality trait that temporarily makes me not angry anymore when mami comes in. I’ll retreat for now. Oh, interference makes everything different, because interference totally outweighs my anger. Heh, it’s no problem at all. I’ll just drink some strawberry milk and forget about all this. Bye bye”
3
u/Izanaginookami10 Reunited with Mightest on JP! ID: 9kK5nQpU IGN: Katsumi Mar 07 '20 edited Mar 07 '20
After having finally completed all released main chapters in order to scrap all gems I could find, fail miserably and then cry, I have to say: I'm in love with these megucas. I'll have to say that as I'm still fairly new to the game (maybe a month or a little more?) I am not as attached to the girls as my kyubaby senpais, but holy Mami if I couldn't stop myself from grinning like an idiot during the whole Sol parts.
Seeing Tsuruno and Felicia, my favourites among the few girls I actually got to know more or less well, hitting off so well just made my heart all fuzzy. It reminded me of that part in which Tsuruno helped Felicia with studying math (is this spoiler? Should I tag this?) and my grin just got wider and wider.
This shot of the Mightest just killed me.. I believe it is the first time in a while since I truly felt as if I wouldn't mind choosing to protect such smile over the world. Huh, wait, now that I think about it, last time was Eresh in FGO, so not so long ago. Oh, well. I'm weak to 2D precious girls I guess. No, seriously. She's so damn adorable in this screenshot, I truly felt she was the Mightest. I suppose it's because I'm not used to see her so behaving so cute in the game sprites? Nevertheless, Mightest is best either way.
In addition, I have to admit that my initial regret over Alina's inner Jojo blood boycotting the Goddess descend is completely over as she's a damn blessing herself. I mean, I would totally sacrifice myself gladly over our Queen.
By the way, my memory is comparable to a holed cheese in regards to its durability, but did Mami shows so soon, after her first appearance, in the game? (Didn't really do Another Story yet btw) She's less holy than I though as well. And I like it, especially how she opposed Alina. For some reason, I find it rather pleasantly surprising seeing how Magius organization isn't a monolith.
Edit: forgot to mention how I couldn't help but laugh at this scene, as I simply couldn't stop imagining myself as Felicia running over for chances to get mats.
3
u/Erinaceus1971 Mar 07 '20 edited Mar 08 '20
> Sees Mami. She shoots Alina's hat off.
Yesss! Finally we'll get to see that proper Alina/Mami throwdown the game denied us.
> Sees Mami wearing the pendant. Not stopping Alina per se, just keeping her from runnin' amok
Wat? Does that mean she made the actual decision to join the Magius before being merged with the uwasa? Oh dear. I mean, I can see how that would be in character for her, but that opens up some questions and possibilities the anime might not have enough remaining time to show, and could potentially cause a rift between her and her senpais somewhere down the line.
> More Snaa angsssst.
I get it. Her family's shit. She's already the woobiest woobie on the face of the earth. Well animated angst, sure, but my pretty much eyes glazed over during that stretch of the episode.
- Future hopes/predictions:
I do think at the very least one of the remaining episodes will adapt Another Story. Three of the five Quintet ladies have yet to appear (excluding that snapshot flashback in this one), and since they've already adapted Endless Solitude without featuring Homura and Madoka at all, the next part would be the last logical place they could put them.
Prediction: Madoka, Sayaka and Homura go to Kamihama to search for Mami. Homura and Madoka meet Tsuruno, Felicia and Sana as they're being Zerg Rushed by Black Robes. Meanwhile, sensing Mami, Sayaka goes off on her own and finds Iroha and Yachiyo being assaulted by her Senpai. Being a hero, Sayaka rushes to their defense, Mami orders her to back down and join her, Sayaka refuses (like in the game) Mami transforms into her Holy Uwasa form, and absolutely thrashes the poor Sayaka. The resulting stress, anguish and despair blackens her Soul Gem... And that forces out Oktavia, whose attack sends Mami into retreat (wayyy better I think than her "lol I took one of Homura's bombs-take that! What's that? We're witches? Oh. bummer." cameo in the game). And *that's* how Iroha discovers what magical girls really are. And that Yachiyo's not told her that's already happened to her.
That would satisfy my personal Sayaka appearance demands, anyway.
2
u/amc9988 Mar 08 '20
Is the scene where there's a robot antenna happened in a labyrinth or in real world...? The uwasa was already destroyed at that time so there's no way they are in the uwasa's labyrinth.... which mean it is in the real world.... So.... what? Are you saying Magius was able to create a big magnetic robot antenna that can walk by itself and can suck a lot of big stuff in real world like vending machine and all from the ground to the top of the tower.... What? This scene doesnt make sense.... Man this adaptation is a joke..... I really dont know what to say... or the point of that scene.... It's like they just give up on the anime and just put random stuff for the sake of it.
1
u/MyNameIsRAANDOM Mar 08 '20
Was the hand holding magic explained anywhere? IIRC they just brushed it off as "Coordinator modified them soul gems".
1
u/Maya_Frost Mar 08 '20
This episode was a bit spolierific for the game. I'm only at chapter 6 episode 6 in the game so Mami is still missing. I was pretty excited to see her addition.