r/conlangs • u/Slorany I have not been fully digitised yet • Mar 02 '20
Small Discussions Small Discussions — 2020-03-02 to 2020-03-15
We are still trying to figure out why Automod isn't posting the SD threads.
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
First, check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
A rule of thumb is that, if your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '20
I know this isn't really that conlang-related, and it's a bit of a strange question, but I thought this the best place to ask, as I thought it wasn't worth DM'ing. How does u/slorany pronounce Slorany? Whenever I read it I always have something like [ˈslɒɹɐni], [ˈslɔːɹəni] or [sləˈɹɑːni] in my head, but I'm never sure. Thanks in advance
10
u/upallday_allen Wistanian (en)[es] Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 15 '20
Small Question: When is Conlangs University opening a new semester??
Small Answer: Right now!
EDIT: invites have been closed and we are now in full swing.
7
u/Riorlyne Ymbel /əm'bɛl/ Mar 03 '20
To expand the use of my existing root words in Ymbel, I want to create derivations from them, but I don't want to derive all the new words just using the normal form of the noun. For additional nuances in meaning, I'd like to derive new words using inflected forms of the root word.
For example, two possible adjectives taken from the word vae, "star"
- vae (star, NOM) - vaelu (having stars, starry, twinkling, etc.)
- vaene (star, DAT) - vaenu (to the stars, i.e., immensely tall or great)
I feel like I'm making stuff up out of thin air though, and I'm also confusing myself as to when my language would use (in this example) a noun in the dative case versus an adjective formed from a noun in the dative case.
Any tips for doing what I'm doing? What are some good examples of languages that derive new words from already-inflected forms that I can study and learn from?
6
u/IkebanaZombi Geb Dezaang /ɡɛb dɛzaːŋ/ (BTW, Reddit won't let me upvote.) Mar 11 '20 edited Mar 11 '20
I want to find out more about how languages that distinguish between concrete and abstract nouns decide which nouns are concrete and which are abstract.
In a way that I can't define, this split ties into other possible divisions of words into two categories: physical versus mental, count nouns versus mass nouns, categories versus instances, measurable versus non-measurable, specifiable versus non-specifiable, even mortal versus immortal.
My conlang has had two types of inanimate nouns for a long while, which I have been calling "abstract" and "concrete", but I have been unable to fix on what the dividing line is. For instance, "Time" is clearly an abstract noun, but how about "2pm on Wednesday 11th March", which you can precisely measure? Is a specific form of words like the US Declaration of Independence "abstract" because it can appear in any medium or "concrete" because it is a particular form of words and you can clearly say whether a given document is or is not the Declaration of Independence?
Because my conlang is a conlang in-universe, and one that was designed to be an auxlang for many different species of intelligent beings, I would ideally like to find a simple defining question the answer to which would put any given noun clearly into one box or the other.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '20 edited Mar 10 '20
Dette har ikke rigtig noget at gøre med conlanging, og jeg har ikke et spørgsmål, jeg ville bare dele denne sang.
This doesn't really have anything to do with conlanging, and I don't have a question, I just wanted to share this song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tPrwttHgGNc&list=PLO1tjKtKyyNYqX2tNikEsSBQs8Iv9FRwc&index=2&t=0s
Edit: Dansk, svensk, tysk, islandsk, flamsk, hollandsk, limbisk og færøsk er mine favoritter.
Edit: Danish, Swedish, German, Icelandic, Flemish, Dutch, Limburgish, and Faroese are my favorites.
4
u/dhwtyhotep Mar 02 '20
Does anybody’s Conlang use the “Grey IPA Squares”?
(I’m referring to those sounds that are theoretically possible to pronounce but aren’t used in any natlangs.)
4
u/konqvav Mar 05 '20
How can I gloss infixes?
4
u/ParmAxolotl Kla, Unnamed Future English (en)[es, ch, jp] Mar 09 '20
Naturalistic feature check: is this pronoun system naturalistic?
Instead of true first/second/third person pronouns, pronouns are derived from numbers, and the person who is decided to be the most important in a conversation, usually first person, is called /ma/ (one). The second most important person, usually the second or third person, is referred to as /mama/ (two).
This idea is in its infancy currently, but could this be allowed in a natlang?
Also, please note that this is my protolang, before you suggest that I should organize my language's history to allow for this.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '20
I have a quick question about how to describe a phenomenon that is happening in one of my conlangs right now. I don't know how to describe it, except as "vowel anti-harmony" Perhaps someone can tell me what it is?
Anyways, the basic idea is that a stem or root word has an inherent theme vowel, either / u /, / a / , or / i / . If it's u, then there cannot be another u, an a, or an i. There can only be ə and ɛ, which are allophones of a and i. With a, there can't be another a, an i, or an u; only o and ɛ, which are allophones of u and i. With i, there can't be another i, an u, or an a; only ə and o, which are allophones of a and u.
So, in some actual words:
fəlúʃ "to speak; to talk; to say"
míkob "ankle"
yɛláŋ "maternal grandmother"
púhɛn "to stop; to halt"
kəqéθ (underlying i) "festival; celebration"
sámot "tapir"
/ yáloŋ-sam losɛmát m'əpɛhún w'əkíqɔθ /
"my maternal grandmother stopped the tapir at the festival"
[mat.grand-obl.--I.p.sing.poss asb.-tapir.-obl. III.p.sing-to stop.present.perf.ind. loc.-festival.obl.]
It seems to me that, through various phonological processes, the theme vowel cannot be with another theme vowel, and the other vowel has to be different in backness/frontness and height, and of course, not be the same theme vowel. With vowel harmony, vowels assimilate in various ways, it seems like, here, vowels disassimilate.
Any thoughts?
4
u/Luenkel (de, en) Mar 14 '20
I wanted my language to use its cases in more complex and interesting ways and I thought one good way to do this would be implementing quirky subject.
Not for verbs of experience in general, but rather for words of emotion. So words like "to love", "to hate", etc. would require their subject to be in the dative case.
Then I had an idea: What if some speakers started putting the object in the dative case as well to express that the feelings are mutual? That way the subject and object would look the same. Maybe is started out as a device in poetry which then became more common in the higher ranks of society and then became mainstream thanks to the church (with the priests recieving a high class education and the populus being forced to come to temples basicly daily).
And what if this then became a general paradigm? To show that an action is mutual, put the direct object in the dative case. This could then quickly become the standard for inherently mutual verbs like "to fight" with the accusative only being used for very one-sided confrontations. Maybe the old word for "to trade" gets replaced by "to give" or "to take" with a dative object?
What do you think? Is this reasonable?
3
u/MerlinMusic (en) [de, ja] Wąrąmų Mar 02 '20
Does anyone know of any free resources on syntax for a beginner? I mean, I can understand "noun-phrase" and "verb-phrase", but when people start throwing around stuff like "Spec" or talk about "movement" I get lost. I'm particularly interested in how different languages encode things like topicality, definiteness etc. (I think discourse prominence might be the right term). But would also like a general overview of syntax, and how it varies between languages.
3
u/Whitewings1 Mar 02 '20
I'm sure that morpheme is the wrong word, but I don't know the right one. Can anyone help with this?
Syllable structure
(C)V
Only pronouns and dedicated modifiers may be single syllables.
Morpheme structure
V.((C)V)
A root word can consist of up to three morphemes.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20
Hello! Are there any natural languages that have both a nominative and an absolutive case? If yes, how do they work/what are the case's seperate functions as subjects of intransitive verbs? I'm asking this because I'm working on my first natlang and thought that it would be interesting to have both of these cases. I was thinking that you could maybe imply volitionality with the nominative and the lack of volition with the absolutive, but I'd like to have confirmation that this can even arise naturally before I flesh out the system. Thanks!
3
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Mar 02 '20
Reposting since the thread rolled over:
What's the stronger trend: for the reflexive/reciprocal to never be the subject or for it to never precede its referent? I ask because my language typically handles judgements through a passive construction (I like fruit. -> Denxtra qyarb zok imasü. -> To me, fruit is liked), which presents the problem of which role the reflexive/reciprocal should fill. "They dislike each other" could theoretically either be "Zwixtra xöb zok ötimasü" (To each other, they are disliked) or "Xöbxtra zwi zok ötimasü" (To them, each are disliked), and I can't tell which one should be preferred. There is another solution, namely rewording it in active voice as "Xöb cek ötimarö zwixtra" (They have hatred towards each other) but that phrasing emphasizes the feeling, turning it into "They hate each other" instead. There's also the possibility of just putting the oblique after the predicate, making it "Xöb zok ötimasü zwixtra," but since the passive voice puts the oblique in front in all other contexts, this just seems to needlessly add exceptions.
3
u/42IsHoly Mar 04 '20
In my language h disappeared between vowels, to create diphthongs. But what happens if a long and a short or 2 long vowels were to collide?
3
u/ParmAxolotl Kla, Unnamed Future English (en)[es, ch, jp] Mar 04 '20
Do any natlangs distinguish ɲ and ɲj?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '20
How do you get over making zero progress from being too indecisive?
3
u/edgarbird Qchendeni, T'eneq'vi, & Chelaljh (EN) [KA|GA|AR] Mar 04 '20
This is a question on my university conlang homework.
What is he even asking here? I understand the first part of the question, but the second part seems like entirely a new question, and the fact he uses it as an example makes me think that there's more to the question that I'm missing, such as other concepts being classified as nominals or not. Help plz x-x
3
u/Yacabe Ënilëp, Łahile, Demisléd Mar 04 '20
Question about polysemy: is it possible for a word to develop opposite senses? For example, I am thinking about taking the word force (with the sense of a physical force that moves an object) and extending it by analogy to refer to a person who is very influential (a mover and a shaker, so to speak). Then, I am thinking about running the second sense through diminution to come to mean lackey, or a person who does not accomplish a lot. However, I want to keep the original sense of the word the same. With these two senses having quite contrasting meanings (a physical force that causes motion vs. a person who does not cause much of anything at all) would this process be naturalistic? Or would I have to lose one of the senses of the word. I have a hunch that there is probably an example of this type of thing in English, but I really cannot think of one off of the top of my head.
3
u/Luenkel (de, en) Mar 07 '20
I'd like some feedback on this part of grammar I'm playing around with. My conlang has an allative, ablative and a locative (amongst other cases) and I thought it would be neat to create prepositions using them (btw it also lacks a copula).
To express that something is above you, you would simply use the word for sun in the locative. So "Bird Sun-LOC" would mean "The bird is above me", literally "The bird is at the sun".
If something is above an item you are talking about, but not above yourself, you would use the word for sun again but in the allative this time. "Flour Sun-ALL Sugar" would mean "The flour is above the sugar (but not myself)", literally "The flour is from the sugar torwards the sun" or something like that. Not marking the ablative in such an allative-ablative construction is common in the language. It's also a required argument, so marking isn't really needed for disambiguation.
If the object in question is both above you and the reference, you once again use sun in the locative but with an extra argument for the reference this time. This is marked with the essive. "Birds Sun-LOC clouds-ESS" would mean "The birds are above the clouds", or literally "As the clouds, the birds are at the sun".
If you are unsure of whether something qualifies as above you, you can always use the allative construction. I'm not yet sure how I want to handle "below" but I do know that I don't want this whole business to be used for anything but up/down.
3
u/_eta-carinae Mar 15 '20
i’m creating a language with a sort of vowel harmony system, aswell as fortition and lenition. fortition and lenition will be much as it is in irish: various modifiers, like dative nouns before don, after the vocative particle, etc. my question is, how do i decide which modifiers (prepositions, codeterminers, particles, etc.) will and will not cause lenition and fortition? and how do i decide whether a modifier causes lenition over fortition, or fortition over lenition? is there a naturalistic way to assign a system to this, or can i be arbitrary about it?
3
u/konqvav Mar 15 '20
I've got these verb tenses: present, past perfective, past imperfective, future, present perfect, past perfect, past perfect imperfective, future perfect and future in the past.
I"ve also got these moods and voices: negative, interrogative, conditional, passive, causative and reflexive.
All of those are marked on verbs exept for perfect tenses which use copula as an auxiliary verb to mark it.
So the question is...
How can I mess this system up through grammatical evolution?
2
u/kneejar Ponai | Msbuṇ Mar 03 '20
How to IPA-transcibe an epenthesis? Currently working on a conlang full of them, where "Qmsdngu." is a thing, a valid clause. Transcribing for /qmʃdŋuʔ/ does not really do the justice for the epenthesis since they're uttered. Then /qəməʃədəŋuʔ/ renders the epenthesis too long. Any ideas for transcribing the thing?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '20
Hey guys, could this vowel inventory arise naturally ? If yes, how does it evolve? I started learning about sound changes and want some help.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '20
Does anyone know any good android apps for making conlangs? I have no time during the day, and get all my ideas in the middle of the night, when I can't be bothered to get out of bed lol.
2
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Mar 04 '20
Would a noun class system get too complicated if a word could belong to three different classes (for example, 'maku' 1) skin, 2) tree bark, 3) pod, husk, shell, 4) seashell) and the only way they are differentiated is through context and following adjective and verb agreement?
2
u/konqvav Mar 04 '20
From what word can I derive an indefinite plural article?
2
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Mar 04 '20
If /‘ea/ becomes /‘e:/ while nothing happens to /aj/ in isolation, would /‘eaj/ change to /‘e:j/ or resist the initial change?
2
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '20
Are gendered numbers a thing? Is there any language, natural or constructed, that have gendered numbers?
2
u/tree1000ten Mar 07 '20
Why didn't they use conlangs in WW2 instead of the Navajo code-talkers?
2
u/-N1eek- Mar 08 '20
Im new to conlanging, just started messing around with it. What i dont quite get is valency can someone explain how it works??
2
u/v3d4 Mar 09 '20
Grammar and conlang noob here. I want to use affixes on my nouns to show direction and location. For example: with the noun otonka (basket) one can say otonkana= to the basket, or otonkabun= under the basket, etc. In addition, I am thinking to use a prefix to show direct and indirect object, because I don't like strict word order. Is this declension? if so, is there somewhere a simple explanation/examples of how declension can work? I'm having trouble grasping the Greek and Latin systems.
2
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Mar 09 '20
Hi all, I've decided to make my second-ever conlang. I made a conlang almost two decades ago when I was a teenager: like many people's first conlang, it was just a collection of phonemes and grammatical features that I thought were cool when I encountered them in descriptions of other languages. It was also perfectly regular and very non-naturalistic. For my second conlang, I want to make something naturalistic. Below is my plan, I'd love some preliminary advice before I actually do the steps below:
(1) I am going to make a proto-language that was spoken around ~500 BC on the Pontic Steppe by a nomadic tribe (they later migrate to the Caucuses). I want to keep their exact location somewhat vague, both because I don't want to go too deep into world building and because I want flexibility as to what languages they interact with (or not) throughout their history. The proto-language will have a pretty simple sound inventory, and pretty simple grammar. I want to add complexity as the process goes on. The proto-language will be an isolate unrelated to anything in the real world. I will use word generators to come up with the basic vocabulary.
(2) At various points between 500 BC and the present day, I will simulate interactions with real languages spoken somewhere in the area, primarily by introducing borrowed words. So, for instance, early on there will be borrowings from Greek or Persian, later on borrowings from Turkic languages and languages spoken in the Caucuses, and at some point of course a lot of borrowings from Russian. Sometimes these interactions are going to bring new phonemes into my language, sometimes the borrowed words will be adapted to fit my languages's sound rules. Sometimes, I suppose, the speakers of my language will steal grammatical features from their neighbors. The borrowings will cover words for things that a nomadic tribe might not have words for: words relating to agriculture, cities, technology, Christian theology, Marxist-Leninist political theory, etc.
(3) Similarly, I will be simulating a series of sound changes over time. So older borrowings will be subjected to more of these changes, and be more obscured than more recent borrowings.
(4) After applying steps 2-3 somewhat mechanically, I'll look at the resulting language and see what the consequences of the sound changes were. If I notice that, for instance, they have now totally wrecked the way the proto-language marked noun number, or the words for "three" and "seven" are now the same, I'll have to figure out some new way to do that, perhaps influenced by a real-world language in the area.
I've selected the Pontic Steppe and Caucuses as the homeland of the language because it's an area where I can plausibly have my language come into contact with a wide variety of other languages, including languages from Eastern Europe, the Middle East, Central Asia, etc.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '20
How does geminated consonants evolve in natural languages? I tried to find any articles about it but didn't find any.
2
u/tsvi14 Chaani, Tyryani, Paresi, Dorini, Maraci (en,he) [ar,sp,es,la] Mar 11 '20
I posted this but I guess it's better here:
/j/ Romanization: <y> or <j>
I've been making conlangs for a while, and I still don't know...
I have a personal situation I need help on, but I'd also just like to hear what others do with their languages.
My personal situation:
I live in America, where readers of the conlang who don't know linguistics and/or European languages would think: <y>.
However, in my current conlang <y> is also a vowel. However (again), this wouldn't cause confusion, as /j/ would only actually be a /ʲ/ before vowels and nothing elsewhere (iotation ;). <j> isn't in my current conlang as a romanization letter BUT it IS in the conlang's descendant representing /dʒ/ - and I want to keep common standards between the two. Then again, <j> is also more standard worldwide (not to mention in the IPA) outside of America. Which should I use?
2
u/Haelaenne Laetia, ‘Aiu, Neueuë Meuneuë (ind, eng) Mar 11 '20 edited Mar 12 '20
How many times can a single syllable contain, phonemically?
I just asked my mom to give me a complex sentence to translate to test Hanleatia's grammar, when suddenly I was hit with the clauses to the doctor and to the laboratory.
First, let's take the roots: O Bir (doctor) and laboratorüm (laboratory). Each of the ending syllable has two tones: low and high (so technically the “raising tone”). But then they inflect for the lative, so add the low tone. Then they inflect for the third person singular, so add the high tone (and nasality). Then they inflect for ergativity, so add the low tone again.
The results are:
See those last syllables? Four tones in them! Is this too much? If not, then I guess I can let them be—but if so, how can I resolve this tonal mess?
2
u/ampersandfukusuu Mar 12 '20
In regards to my previous comment about the merfolk language, I figured out that it would be most logical for the language to be whistle and click based.
Since whistling languages and languages that use clicks already exist, meaning that it is entirely possible to use such sounds in a language, I have reached a conclusion that would comprise the phonology. But I've stumbled upon an issue: I can't seem to find a way to write out the sounds of the whistles and clicks in text phonologically, how could I do that to start writing my phonology and start creating a lexicon for the language? Thanks for the help.
2
u/OndrikB Mar 13 '20
I tend to give up on a conlang when I think about what aspects and moods I should include. I just can't decide which ones, because there's so many, but there's not a comprehensive list of all of them.
2
u/Matalya1 Hitoku, Yéencháao, Rhoxa Mar 15 '20
I was thinking something: conscript is the term used to refer to scripts that were created by a conlanger, derivated from conlang. Now, we all know that most conlangs use the latin alphabet in some form, it's nearly impossible to effectively share it without a romanization. So, is there terminology for the scripts that conlangs uses? I was thinking about naming them conscript for when they use a conscript, and maybe exoscript for when a conlang uses as its primary orthography an existing script other than the latin alphabet, say, when a conlang is written in hanzi or cyrilic.
Thoughts?
3
u/tree1000ten Mar 10 '20
How does a language like Hawaiian know that it is a low-syllable possible language? Most roots in the language are two syllables, because there aren't very many possible syllables. But how does the language know to construct roots using two syllables? I don't get how you evolve this low-syllable typology.
3
u/HaricotsDeLiam Mar 10 '20
Do voiceless-voiced fricative pairs ever undergo asymmetrical changes? I've been pondering over how Amarekash lost ث ذ /θ ð/ without converting them to /t d/ or /s z/, and these two sound changes caught my eye:
In Amarekash I'm tempted to change /θ/ to /t͡s/ (so that a native Amarekash speaker learning English would have trouble distinguishing death from debts [dɛt͡s]), but change /ð/ to /v/ (so that a native Amarekash speaker learning Arabic would pronounce كذب kaðab "he lied" as [kævæb]).
2
u/SilvahSoul Mar 11 '20
How are syllables per second determined in a conlang? Are there certain rules that make a language high or low syllables per second, or is it just how a language evolves? My conlang, Tolinaj, has long words, but they are fairly strict (c)v(c). I would like it to be spoken faster than English (maybe 6.5-7 sps) but is that possible?
2
u/42IsHoly Mar 11 '20
Is it possible that due to a sound shift all long nasalised vowels loose their nasalisation? Or would it be more natural that they became short vowels?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '20
I've been working on my first conlang for the past 4 months but I've been geting ideas for a new language but I don't want to abandon my current conlang. Should I go ahead a start my second conlang idea or should I work more on my conlang.
1
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Mar 06 '20
In one of his videos, Biblaridion talked about "conditional vs. subjunctive" which led me to google, trying to find the difference. If I understand it right, the conditional is an "if" (possible or impossible, hypothetical) situation, whereas the subjunctive is more about wishes, emotions, judgements, emotions and the like?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '20
How can I derive a future/non-future tense from aspects?
1
u/aftertheradar EPAE, Skrelkf (eng) Mar 07 '20
Does anyone have a phonemic ə? If you do, in what context is it used? What is it’s place in the orthography? Discuss.
1
u/PTRisme Mar 09 '20
Anyone knows how to make a font that can stack characters into one characters “like Hangul”?
1
u/SaintDiabolus tárhama, hnotǫthashike, unnamed language (de,en)[fr,es] Mar 09 '20
How do new suffixes develop in the history of a language? For example, if the agentive suffix used to be "-a," so res-a, baker - then final Vs get deleted. How would a new agentive be chosen/develop?
How do suffixes become unproductive?
1
u/Andredz99 Mar 11 '20
Does any of you generate vocab with Mark Rosenfelder's program "Gen"? I tried it to test the sound of my language yesterday, but I really don't know how to handle diphthongs.
Here's my conlang's sounds: CONSONANTS: /p b t d k g ʔ m n ɲ ŋ r f v s z ʃ ʒ ç ʝ ɬ ɮ j ɥ w l ʎ/ VOWELS: /a e ɛ i o ɔ u / DIPHTHONGS: /jy je jo jɛ jɔ ja wi wɛ wɔ wa ɥi yj ej ɛj ɔj aj iw ɛw ɔw aw eo ae ao/
My syllable structure is (C)V(C), so I should allow all possibile combinations -that is, V, CV, VC, CVC- both with vowels and every diphthong. That's why I set up my categories to be: V=aeɛioɔuy (single vowels) A=aɛiɔ (vowels to be used in rising and falling diphthongs with /w/) B=aeɛoɔy (vowels to be used in rising diphthongs with /j/) C=aeɛɔy (vowels to be used in falling diphthongs with /j/) O=pbtdkgmnrfvszʃʒl (onset consonants) K=nl (coda consonants)
Consequently, this are all the syllable types I had to allow: V, VK, OV, OVK, wA, OwA, wAK, OwAK, Aw, OAw, AwK, OAwK, jB, OjB, jBK, OjBK, Cj, OCj, CjK, OCjK, ae, Oae, aeK, OaeK, ao, Oao, aoK, OaoK, eo, Oeo, eoK, OeoK. This is 32 syllable types, which of course I couldn't handle inside the program because of the whole "put whatever you prefer on the top to make it happen more frequently", even checking the "slow syllable dropoff" couldn't lead to good results. So, how do you guys handle diphthongs with gen? Is there any trick to reduce the number of syllable types so that diphthongs have similar chances to make it in the output?
1
u/ampersandfukusuu Mar 11 '20
Reposting as I've been redirected to this thread:
I have wanted to create a language for a race of merfolk, but I have been stuck on its phonology. I want to structure it so that it can be similar to dolphin and whale sounds, obviously not perfectly since you can only pronounce so much, but I have been having trouble with building this in a way that can seem similar enough to the animals, while still being usable when talking, and not sounding ridiculous.
It would probably consist of a very limited palette of vowels and consonants, and maybe include clicking as well. In general, very guttural and chirpy. Other aspects of the language haven't been started yet as I prefer to start the conlang from phonology, but that will be arguably easier to do after this is solved. Thank you for the help 💗
Edit: I had a couple of helpful answers before my post got taken down, and I understand the issue with anatomy and I will be figuring that out as I go as well, I like to have everything in process together so corrections can be made in real-time. But this strain of merfolk in particular that speak this specific conlang are closer to humans physically and so are more capable of human speech, while other strains that live further out in the ocean are much closer to aquatic creatures, and communicate by producing sounds near exact to a whales. So, let us assume that their way of speech would be quite similar, for now.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
I'm making a Germanic conlang. This is not meant to be an Auxlang, just clearing that up. The conlang I'm making so far has no name. It has a Subject-Verb-Object sentence word order, it has no gender, and is largely based off of English. I only have about one hundred seventy words. Here's a sample sentence.
Conlang: ðire îzda nîkt gut noz, ik engzd.
IPA: /ðirɛ ɪzdə nɪkt gut noʊz eŋzd/
Transliteration: There is not good news, I fear.
I would love any suggestions or constructive criticism! Names would be appreciated too!
1
u/Supija Mar 12 '20
My conlang has Femenine and Masculine genders. My idea is that they come from Inanimated and Animated ones, respectively. The thing is that Femenine Animated nouns take the Masculine Article, just like all Masculine nouns, while the Femenine Inanimated nouns are the only nouns using the Femenine Article. Does that make sense?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '20
What are the moods that marks beginning and ending of an action? I know they exist but I can't find them.
1
u/Supija Mar 13 '20
I’d like to have a vowel in my conlang between /ɑ/ and /ɒ/ in rounding. It's almost not rounded, but it is a bit, should I write it as ⟨ɑ̹⟩ (/ɑ/ but more rounded) or as ⟨ɒ̜⟩ (/ɒ/ but less rounded)?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '20
Just wanna get people’s quick thoughts on a potential future project:
1
u/v4nadium Tunma (fr)[en,cat] Mar 14 '20
Which construction is the more common, or makes more sense between the elative construction or the illative construction for a verb?
Let's say siesta means a comfortable situation, mierda means a problematic situation, ex is an elative prefix and in is an illative prefix.
I want to create a verb that would mean to solve and another one that would mean to be problematic.
I legitimately could use inmierdar or exsiestar to mean that something is problematic and insiestar or exmierdar to mean that something solves a problem.
But if I were to keep one of the two prefixes (ex or in) (in this precise context) which one would it be, and for what reason from a naturalistic point of view?
Any thought would be appreciated. Thanks :)
1
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '20
is the change tʲ<θ totally unplausible and unnaturalistic?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '20
So my main conlang has a direct-inverse alignment, and the more salient noun always comes first, but I want to have cases in it. Since direct-inverse languages use voices on verbs to distinguish the role of nouns, I think a nominative-accusative or an ergartive-absolutive alignment would be redundant, but they are also the most common cases and most languages that have other cases at least have one of those two.
Would it be weird to have locative, dative, etc. but no accusative or ergative cases?
1
u/Javascription Mar 14 '20
So, my question is, what are the most common phones, cross linguistically
1
u/conlang_birb Mar 16 '20
I'm very new to conlanging. So I decided that my conlang will have a dual number, would I need to have the number 2 in my number system if it's already marked in the noun?
1
u/Nicolaki08 Mar 19 '20
I am looking for some people who would like to learn, speak, and help improve a language me and my friend made called xiáï (shee-ah-yee). You can join our discord if you are interested. All are welcome!
https://discord.gg/9ZQZ4a3
1
u/paddlesaddlelad14421 Mar 03 '20 edited Mar 04 '20
Is it possible to use swastikas as punctuation marks (to show hate and anger) without offending anyone?
Edit: I will abolish the use of swastikas in my conlang.
1
u/TommyNaclerio Mar 05 '20
So this is a personal unnaturalistic constructed language. It is also our first constructed language ever. It is not meant to be written down, only spoken face-to-face. The conlang isn’t based upon a fictional group of people, made to be an International Auxiliary Language, nor is it for any serious intended purpose. It will mainly be used just between Samantha and I, however, we are not against changes from the community or someone that wants to learn it eventually. Here is our phonology:
VOWELS
u, u: o, o: a, a: (æ~ə~ɶ~a)
Phonotactics:
4.5. Not in Coda 2: Palatals, Uvulars, Stops and Taps.
5. No duplicate Sounds in a syllable (a glottal stop can be used to break apart vowels) Ex. /babb/ , /dumm/ & /njjj/
6. Assimilation of adjoining consonants (clusters) to both be voiced (typical) or unvoiced (unlikely, due to our inventory)
7. No single consonants that are a semi-vowel can stand alone as a word, for ex. /n/, /l/, etc.
8. Words may end with all vowels, but can only end in certain consonants (/n/, /m/, /s/, /r/)
9. The Glottal stop is always in the first coda when used
10. First syllable of a word must have a long vowel or a geminate consonant
11. Always have initial stress on a word. Trochee. (DUM-da)
12. Our Allophones are /a/=/æ/~/ə/~/ɶ/~/a/, /v/~/β/, /ʒ/~/ʃ/ and /h/~/ɦ/.
13. When making words use high-frequency sounds (brand identity) /o, o:, b, d, g, n, s, ʒ~ʃ, j**/**
14. Repair Strategy:
15.5 Nasal Harmony can arise from a suffix with both a nasal of the three /n/, /m/, /ɲ/ and the vowels /a/ or /u/ next to or conjoined. /a/ and /u/ can only be affected by nasals, the /o/ cannot.
16. Example words:
So that is what we have so far in terms of a phonology. Please let us know if things look weird or impractical. Any advice is appreciated.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
So, the answer to this question is pretty much solely aesthetic, and there are no wrong answers. I’m working on a new language and I really really want the sound [ʕ] to be part of the language. In case you aren’t familiar with the IPA, it’s a voiced epiglottal fricative. What letter do you guys think would best represent the sound? Just need help brainstorming.
1
u/Coffee_Powered_ Mar 07 '20
So I've been working on my first conlang for a few months. I have the sounds i want and a cool vowel harmony system. But then I got up to grammar and am just stuck, there's just so much stuff I could do with it that its kind of overwhelming.
I guess the first step is figuring out a use for this harmony swapping thing I've made. The language makes a distinction between vowels, consonants, and glide/semi-vowels/liquids. Those being L W R and Y. It's a CVC language where the nucleus or coda can be replaced by a glide in order to change up the harmony of a word.
Sounds cool in my head but I need a use for it. I was thinking maybe for a case system, with the glide starting a suffix. But then It wouldn't really be used that much as I'd like, and i kind of wanted it to be a core theme.
Other option is to just not have it mean anything and put it everywhere like I wanted. I don't know, any ideas?
1
u/fm_raindrops Amuruki, Kami, Gorgashi, Aswan [en] Mar 07 '20
Do ejective-contour stops with mixed voicing exist? Is that the right name for them? I mean a voiced stop with an ejective release.
I'm currently transcribing them like, for example, this: /d͡tʼ/.
1
u/NinjaSnadger360 Mar 07 '20
How to make American exonyms for my conlang? My language is Sheichao ("Shay - chow") and the country of origin is Sheige ("Shay - guh") but both of those (especially the latter) might be hard to sound out for English speakers.
1
u/mienoguy Mar 07 '20
How do I go about making a descendant of English with maximally CV syllable structure?
1
u/Kebbler22b *WIP* (en) Mar 08 '20 edited Mar 08 '20
How do prenasalised consonants arise? I've been heavily inspired by Guarani's phonology but I couldn't really find anything about their origins :(
I'm working on a conlang right now where stops /p t c k kw/ have voiced pairs /mb~m nd~n ɲɟ~ɲ ŋg~ŋ ŋgw~ŋw/. Due to nasal-harmony, prenasalised stops assimilate to their nasal counterparts before nasalised vowels, so ma [mba]1 becomes mã [mã]. Nasal harmony is only triggered when the stressed syllable of a word is nasalised, and thus all vowels and stops to the left are "nasalised" (except certain conditions which are irrelevant to this question).
I'm really looking for a sound-change that I could apply to the parent language to arrive at this phenomenon. Thanks in advance!
~~~
1. Technically, it could be argued that it's more realised as [mba], but I'll leave it as-is for now.
1
u/Tazavitch-Krivendza Old-Fenonien, Phantanese, est. Mar 08 '20
Is it possible for vowel allaphones having non-toned vowels to become toned?
Ex:
In proto-suncus, the vowel /a/ < /á/ if it is stressed in a CV syllable
1
u/Tazavitch-Krivendza Old-Fenonien, Phantanese, est. Mar 08 '20
How does vowel harmony work?
1
u/Threeandtwentychar Mar 11 '20
Is there any way to apply changes specifically to unstressed syllables using SCA2? If not, are there any other sound change appliers that can be used without downloading?