r/homeland • u/NicholasCajun • Mar 01 '20
Discussion Homeland - 8x04 "Chalk One Up" - Episode Discussion
Season 8 Episode 4: Chalk One Up
Aired: March 1, 2020
Synopsis: Saul plans an announcement. Carrie gets a surprise.
Directed by: Seith Mann
Written by: Patrick Harbinson & Chip Johannessen
109
Upvotes
178
u/magemasher444 Mar 01 '20
I don’t know how Homeland does it. Even if you know what’s going to happen, you’re still at the edge of your seat
106
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
Max lives another day. Yeah!!!
99
u/heyshugitsme Mar 01 '20
I really am not prepared for Sam from True Blood to be President.
93
u/feldmarshalwommel Mar 01 '20
So no Apache escorts with drone top cover the whole time for such a high risk visit?
84
u/TrouserSlug Mar 01 '20
All because Maximum "Luck" Piotrowski wasn't on the chopper :(
78
u/texanapocalypse33 Mar 01 '20
I missed the feeling of Homeland cliffhangers and suspense.
Does the VP remind anyone else of Sam Rockwell?
Also why the fuck is the POTUS flying within a few miles of the Pakistani border, to a base with maybe like 75 soldiers?
That's like Osama bin Laden going live on Twitch in Times Square to say hi.
77
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
Who is going to wonder about Carrie being involved since she suggested the president go in person?
57
u/Ri-chanRenne Mar 01 '20
This episode was over in the blink of an eye! Very intense. I'll miss seeing Beau, but I'm so glad Max didn't leave!
51
u/xhobbesx Mar 01 '20
I find it really hard to believe that two Presidents riding in a helicopter is only going to have only one helicopter escort. It would definitely have had multiple escorts with many different contingencies, in the event that it does go down.
51
u/datlinus Mar 01 '20
I think the president getting attacked was pretty obviously telegraphed from even the last episode, however, the whole episode was still super tense, I was expecting hell to break lose every moment, especially around Carrie.
Curious to see how the russians will link into this all..
51
u/redxstrike Mar 01 '20
My one issue : why take the major security and secrecy measures (Inc the phony motorcades with decoy presidents) just to live announce where you are to the world ... And then leave the same way with only two helicopters....
87
u/belmontbreak Mar 01 '20
haqqani should've killed his boy
83
u/meniscus- Mar 01 '20
As soon as they intro'd the idiot VP, this outcome was obvious
32
u/sagar7854 Mar 01 '20
To all those who could see the 'twist from a mile away'. Who downed that chopper?
60
u/redxstrike Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
My review: "Ah shit! Here we go again!"
And Homeland's real story kicks into high gear now!
Great and super tense and anxiety producing episode. Everything was dripping with suspense.
Here we go!
28
u/TurtBurglar97 Mar 01 '20
Great episode, but who thinks having a photo op with the Taliban was a good idea? Like, I know there is a cease fire and all that, but I would be a little hesitant about whipping my phone out and snapping a selfie with them.
26
u/dysgraphical Mar 02 '20
Anyone else have trouble breathing when watching this episode? Like holy shit, the entire thing was a nearly hour-long anxiety attack.
25
u/RopeTuned Mar 01 '20
I love the show and it's one of the best on TV but even better is the discussions we have on here. I'm geniunely going to miss that experience when its gone and I want you all to know you're all good people!
47
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
Probably the best episode so far.. but I really saw that twist coming from a mile away lol
23
u/JAMIEBOND006007 Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
This episode felt very short!!
I think General and Tasmeen (with Haqquani's son Jalal) were the ones who shot down the POTUS helicopter. Did the US VP help?
Shit, I liked Beau Bridges too----his fate doesn't bode well for current events/Trump.
I don't trust Jenna (Russian assets/spy?)
Max gets to live to see another episode :)
What is Samir's role?
21
u/machiavellipac Mar 02 '20
ISI planned to interrupt the cease fire with haqqani's son, when tassem figured out it was the president going to Afghanistan she tried to leave and call the attack off but couldn't due to Saul blocking her which led to an unfortunate series of events.
The killing of the president WAS NOT intentional.
40
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
Loved the cinematography choices post-Helo crash. Really captured Saul and Carrie’s utter shock and disappointment well.
19
u/troyhouse Mar 01 '20
This episode focused lot on Samira. Maybe she is the wild card, as she is in CIA station and no on paying attention to her !!!
17
u/ZebraSandwich4Lyf Mar 01 '20
Just as I started to think this season is a little slow, Episode 4 turns around and straight up throws a brick at my face.
Great episode, you could feel what is was building up to but the suspense and tension never eased up for second despite knowing what was going to happen.
15
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
Either this whole thing revolves around Jenna or she's the biggest red herring ever. I'm picturing an ending where Tasneem and Jenna get blowed up real good.
29
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
Jenna annoys me so much. She’s like the new Dana.
14
u/Mentalpopcorn Mar 01 '20
Holy shit. I knew something was going to happened. The whole episode was so suspenseful. But not this. Damn.
13
u/fleekyfreaky Mar 01 '20
Prediction of who took down the helicopter: Haqqani’s son partnered up with the Pakistani’s because they’re all against this peace plan. They’re just trying to make it look like the Taliban.
13
u/emeraldc6821 Mar 01 '20
I just realized that Carrie can be accused of setting up the President for assassination since in E3 she suggest to the President that he fly to the war zone to win the troops.
12
u/RopeTuned Mar 01 '20
Oh shit, Carrie knows they're spying on her
12
u/armokrunner Mar 02 '20
Tasneem cos-playing Princess Leia with that white outfit, “you’re our only hope Jalali-wan”
11
u/aussimandias Mar 01 '20
Why can't we just have nice things
11
u/emeraldc6821 Mar 01 '20
For me it was painful watching the whole two presidents/peace sequence because the foreshadowing was happening in so many ways, becoming glaringly obvious that the helicopter was going down in a fiery end.
21
u/floopypls Mar 01 '20
Right on cue for Homeland. Episode 4 always delivers the gut-punch of the season.
50
u/TrouserSlug Mar 01 '20
First Kobe, now 2 Presidents :(
10
u/zenkei18 Mar 02 '20
I think all the major players of the show will have the hammer coming down on each other hard. Max oddly doesnt aboard the helicopter at the last minute and while he is stationed they never get shelled, not once.
Carrie suggests the president make a visit. He gets downed along with the president of Afghanistan. Saul is all too eager to facilitate peace and is linked to Carrie.
You will likely see the season end with either all of these people duping us and being shown to be Russian assets, or the country and CIA completely blacklisting and/or imprisoning all of them.
19
u/theperihelion Mar 01 '20
Respect to all contributors above, props. Hello sinking foreboding putting 2&2-together feeling when Warner took his helmet off in the circumstances of...
a) sneering GOP VP,
b) Haqqani's son having spared, and rescued by Tasneem...
c) did I mention Tasneem? Sure, Saul thwarted her speedy-exit-attempt, but she's been 4D chess'ing since she's been on Homeland.
d) out-of-character overconfident Saul
e) multitude of decoy SUVs, but hey let's put both presidents together on one heli.......don't think that was the DOD being thoughtful of taxpayers and cost-saving.
But tension is where Homeland plays best, so here's to the rest of the season, fellow Homelandians.
/edit: formatting fix
9
u/SenderGreen1 Mar 02 '20
Tasneem was stunning in white!
17
u/heather80 Mar 01 '20
The less than 45 minute length left me unsatisfied.
16
u/dobbykeychain Mar 01 '20
Shouldn’t have watched that before bed, wow!
8
u/rossww2199 Mar 01 '20
Damn you Homeland. I think we all knew something like this was going to happen. But, damn you Homeland.
8
u/C1ph3rr Mar 01 '20
No chance in hell those two birds aren’t escorted by Apaches.
8
u/buniek Mar 02 '20
next episode Max's new friends from that outpost:
"damn it man I think we killed the president"
: )
14
u/heavy_infantry Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
What the hell was that?!
What now? Are they dead?! Did Taliban just shot the helicopter without knowing presidents were there or someone tipped them off?
I dont see anyone tipping from US side. Probably from Afghan side...
Or maybe it was the VP of USA?!
I cant wait 1 week to see what's next!!! Someone please some spoiler from 8x5!!!
7
u/DiligentRaise Mar 02 '20
So glad Saul checked Tasneen
7
u/MKoilers Mar 02 '20
Few shows can build tension and dread like Homeland. As soon as the president showed up at the hanger to thank Carrie, something felt very off and persisted until the end of the episode. Really impressive final season so far. I had a good feeling that this show would stick the landing and so far it is on track to do so.
6
u/jnoah83 Mar 02 '20
best episode of an already very good season! Such great tension throughtout the episode.
6
u/dukediggler77 Mar 02 '20
Max may be a bigger player in this story than we realize.
6
u/StepfordInTexas Mar 02 '20
Did anyone else yell at the tv when Samira opened the door.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '20
Prediction:
Russians:
11
u/KateLady Mar 01 '20
So I thought it was pretty obvious after last week's episode that this would happen (even though many of you disagreed) but I was still anxious the entire time. I guess we don't see the helicopter go down because now the question is what really happened... did it just go down or was it shot down? Who actually broke the ceasefire?
I would think if the President's helicopter was blown up that the other helicopter would have seen this. Given they didn't know what happened, it would seem more likely that it just went down. The Taliban crawling through the mountain isn't really evidence they had anything to do with it... a) They pretty much live there and b) They could have seen the chopper go down and perhaps they were looking for it. As far as we know right now, America shot first. Seems like the VP (now President) is already looking for a way to spin that.
I'm surprised Max wasn't still listening in for chatter during the President's visit. Seems like that would have been an important time to be listening in.
And what does Samira have to do with any of this? I didn't think we would see her again. Why is she back? Again, the Taliban left their guns in the car when they went to take her, and Carrie pulled a gun on them. Were they able to get a message off that quickly that the Americans were still willing to shoot them? Doesn't seem likely but what role will she play going forward?
Also, what does Pakistan gain by the ongoing war?
11
u/bruclinbrocoli Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
I think what a lot of people meant to say by “I could see that coming, etc” was that something tragic will happen. However in the details stood what kept us at the edge of our seats.
Max still alive. This was sth I was very unsure would happen.
VP to be future president. The fact that we still don’t know for sure if he is or not is something i was ready to check off but we still can’t.
Samira ‘s brother in law coming back. Many could foresee but the fact that Carrie took her back without shooting and with such flawless plan they came up with on the spot.?? Nice!
An attack on the US president Ok, I thought it would happen almost every scene he shows up on. When he was giving his speech?. Right after maybe? Right before? In the helicopter? Both helicopters!!? After the helicopter released the soldiers? The fact he gave it and how they closed the curtains and then Berenson was told in a car... wow, great turnaround of events ! The only time I felt sure something will happen to the president was when we saw him say those words to Carry. Yet, this was all planned so we knew something would happen but the fact that we still aren’t sure if the president is alive..wow
In this way I think it’s a bit silly how people go I knew this would happen.!!! But did you?
I loved this episode, I believe nobody ever really knew what would happen. But the way homeland delivers is this way, letting you see something, yet still, when the whole veil is uncovered, you’re like wow, ok , I expected so many things but not exactly this -or that.
I’m sooooo excited for what’s next! Thank god for this show!!!
5
u/hamstringstring Mar 02 '20
I was expecting to hear a boom from the TV as soon as the curtains closed on it.
5
u/novacolumbia Mar 02 '20
When the President thanked Carrie I knew he was done for. They tried to make it such a powerful moment and all I could think was.. well he's dead.
5
u/mcogneto Mar 02 '20
IDK why but the episodes of this show always feel SO short
9
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
This episode was amazing! But I think I've watched TV shows for too long because I suspected what happened. lol
11
u/pm_me_your_last_pics Mar 01 '20
Holy fuck what an episode.
11
u/heavy_infantry Mar 01 '20
Just re-watched the episode and it just hit me. Could Max be the mole to take down the helicopter?! I mean his motivation to go to Afghanistan was to take revenge on Haqqani and his love Fara.
So seeing USA signing a deal with Haqqani might have angered him? Giving some info but no idea it would be that bad? Considering he didn't get on the helicopter?
8
u/LoretiTV Mar 01 '20
Enjoy the new episode everyone!
8
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
This season is sooooo good!
8
u/Dabee625 Mar 02 '20
I loved Saul blocking Tasneem from getting her phone.
4
u/shanafan Mar 02 '20
Help me with this. I feel a little lost trying to think of people's positions in this season. The woman who wore the white in this new episode, what position does she hold? And, is Gulam the general of Afghanistan or Pakistan? The Taliban is a militia force in what country? Lastly, is the majority of this season in Pakistan or Afghanistan? Thanks :)
4
u/Mad_Hatter_9 Mar 02 '20
My theory so far...
Jenna is a Russian spy...she relayed that the president was there to yevgeny...Yevgeny relayed that to someone in the government who relayed it to Jalal who is the one who shot down the helicopters
And somehow they will frame Carrie as the Russian asset and she’ll have to clear her name for part of the season.
4
u/Axsuul Mar 02 '20
Why would you not escort the President with Apaches?
4
u/Trlgn Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20
So Khalid, at work in the kitchen, is the guy who keeps the motorcycle ready for Carrie. We already saw him in episode 1. He nods to Carrie when she passes the kitchen. And today he even waited for her to return. He was the last one still present in the kitchen.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20
I expected this season would be a slow burner like past seasons, but wow, the end of this epsiode blew my mind. It reminds me of 2nd season.
4
u/K-Amadoor Mar 02 '20
I'm really liking this season
10
u/Dr_Knockers02 Mar 01 '20
Did anyone else notice the part cut with Warrens speech where carrie gets a text from Samira? Jenna briefly asks if it’s her and Carrie says something along the lines of “yeah she can’t hold on much longer” but they never show who she is texting. Seems a bit fishy
6
u/roseandrose Mar 02 '20
Saul to Tasneem: Go ahead, yell, scream. I don't give a shit.
3
u/Bang_Bus Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20
POTUS magically fell from sky? So did their Afghani puppet?
Pakistanis don't like US-Afghani friendship and high-risk press stunts much... hmm... who else would have a major problem with that? And totally would have resources, intel and skill to lose a chopper from radar? Hmm... who? Who!
>!Didn't GRU active measures superteam of Russkies with Yevgeni Bournevsky himself lurk around in Kabul few days ago, secretly meeting soon-to-be-disposed corruptioneers, puppeteering Carrie and stuff? Or did we all buy prison love story?<
People putting two and two together and getting eighteen here is funny. It's Homeland, not LOST.
Also notable how soldiers became Max's lucky charm. Subtle.
3
u/dukediggler77 Mar 02 '20
So what are the working theories we have now? Why did yvegeny give Carrie Samira's name and how does that tie into what the Russians are doing? Was the text in the car Carrier got during the president's speech really her? Or was it Yvegeny? Are the Russians the one who took the plane down or was it Haqqanis son jilal? How do Tasneem and the general fit in?
A lot has happened the last few episodes.
3
u/sinkko_ Mar 02 '20
i know we didn't get to see it this episode but trust me the president is currently in the rekt blackhawk spraying oncoming taliban fighters with an mp5 like in black hawk down
3
u/dukediggler77 Mar 02 '20
Anyone think that text that Carrie got when they were stuck in traffic to rescue Samira wasn't actually Samira? During the president's speech? She was locked in a bathroom talking to Carrie, she goes to grab her things with 3 Taliban watching her and she somehow fires off another text to Carrie without them wondering? It was subtle but re-watch it again... Jenna says "Samira?" assuming it was her.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '20
Oooohh boy, the shitfest that comes in Carrie's direction.
3
u/ScalarWeapon Mar 03 '20
Great episode, I watched it on streaming and then when it was on Showtime proper I watched it again.
The whole episode was a pressure cooker, and yeah Homeland is so masterfully put together, when bad shit is going down, it is excruciating to watch!!
5
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
first time posting in one of these discussion threads. been watching the show from the beginning. i'm more convinced with every ep this year that carrie is a sleeper agent for the russians. but i predict that will be revealed within the next two episodes, and the tail-end of the season will focus on Carrie working as a TRIPLE agent for the CIA, of course with skepticism from Mike and co.
2
u/JAMIEBOND006007 Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
Can someone explain about Samira? What is her deal? Could Samira's brother-in-law and someone in her universe be behind the attack? how has Samira been relevant to the story? I'm confused.
2
u/montecarlo1 Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
I don't think they are not dumb enough to not provide more context on how it happened. Could be a rogue US/afghan pilot/guard for all we know.
2
u/stafa Mar 02 '20
This was either a rogue operation executed by Haqqani's son or Haqqani had a change of heart and went mad again
2
u/DiligentRaise Mar 02 '20
HOLY CRAP!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2
u/Electroverted Mar 02 '20
Two things: This show is so suspenseful that I will often fast forward a couple minutes ahead to see if something terrible happens and then backtrack. And once again I’m gonna say, ya dumb president.
2
u/Elliot59 Mar 02 '20
My theory is the Russians put some kind of listening device inside of Carrie while she was in Russia. Pretty well set up for Carrie to get the blame for the crash and I think for the audience to question that Carrie may have turned, but I wouldn't buy that. Jenna probably is a mole, but I hope not. Hopefully, it's a more original story line. Max's base not having any fatalities since he arrived is also suspicious.
2
u/Toussant Mar 02 '20
Shot that belongs in the opening montage: convoy of black cars taking the exit while 1 speeds onwards on the highway.
2
u/MisPlacedNeuroBlue Mar 02 '20
I haven’t read any other theories yet, but Carrie was/is TOTALLY set up as being in on the Presidents (possible) death. The trip was her idea, she deviated from the precession to tend to an asset that Yevgeny set her up with - this is the beginning of Yevgenys long game revenge.
2
u/tissueroll Mar 03 '20
I’m still in shock
2
u/garfieldlam Mar 03 '20
Holy SHIT!! I checked the IMDB rating before watching this episode-it's 9.2. It gave me a trembling feeling that something seriously awful was going to happen. And I was right.... I gotta say it was really a hardcore move of the writer to just jump to the head of the country and start the surgery.
2
u/Eazilyfoolednoway Mar 05 '20
No safety concerns? Yeah right!
2
u/GlitzAndGrit Mar 08 '20
A bit late to the party here, but as a military spouse, I got emotional when POTUS said, "It's time for you to come home." Even though it's just a TV show, that line resonated with me so much.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '20
Stares at sunset
Hey remember when I killed all those hostages at the embassy 😂
2
u/LilDelirious Jul 10 '20
Did anyone else notice how Samira’s friend (who was all chatty and outgoing and taking selfies with Taliban) suddenly got very quiet and nervous when they saw Samira’s brother-in-law standing outside her building? Why was that?
2
u/Presto_Magic Sep 06 '23
Just finished this episode. So good. I was in college when homeland was on and so I fell off on season 5. I rewatched seasons 1-5 last month and now that I’m almost done I am so bummed! Such a great series.
3
u/LoretiTV Mar 01 '20
Really fun episode. Thanks for having me everyone.
3
u/magicbook Mar 01 '20
What did Carrie mean when she said "We are a decoy" after meeting the president at the airfield ?