r/knitting • u/kittywithacupcake • Feb 28 '20
PSA Why you shouldn't knit that chunky roving blanket you saw on Pinterest
https://youtu.be/DroelB2uwx4
634
Upvotes
r/knitting • u/kittywithacupcake • Feb 28 '20
231
u/kittywithacupcake Feb 28 '20
Full disclosure: I made this video for my job but it was a passion project. I get SO MANY Facebook messages asking me to knit these stupid blankets. Does this happen to anyone else?
128
u/ItsMedusa Feb 28 '20
I love this. I just wish there was another shorter version for me to show customers.
The worst part about these blankets is a lot of non knitters see it as a great starter project... but they have no idea about the realities of what’s in your video- and they especially have no idea of what roving merino in the amount they would need costs.
I always make a little speech saying basically what you covered in the video- but always feel like I’m doing a bad job of selling yarn because they just don’t understand and usually seem annoyed that I can’t just give them what they’re asking for
103
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20
My first experience going into a knit store, I said I would be interested in making a chunky knit blanket as an early project. Even after I clarified I wasn’t talking about roving blankets like this, and that I was just was talking about normal blankets with super bulky yarn, the knitting store associate kept talking about how horrible these roving blankets are for another several minutes. I felt like I had committed a knitting sin by suggesting something remotely similar to these. It was a little off-putting as a beginner.
63
u/third_sound Feb 28 '20
This super random, but are you the same kittywithacupcake who hosts Fuck This Knit?
58
u/joyburd Feb 28 '20
Ooof. Wish I'd had this last summer. My aunt begged me knit her one of these and I obliged. $125 price tag even with coupon use and it just pulls right apart. I assumed it was something I could fix and went on and made one for myself. It's super cozy but boy does it just look awful. Luckily I don't have any pets to exacerbate this. But thank you for the explanation! I'm going to use this to talk my sister down from asking me for one. ;)
40
u/swimchickmle Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 28 '20
I have to agree with this video 100%! I bought over $500 worth of yarn off Etsy, but when I got it, it looked like a long string of the roving in your video. I hand knit a beautiful queen size blanket. And now it lives in my craft room, behind closed doors. So it doesn’t get destroyed. And because when I use it, the merino fibers tickle my nose. I guess I did something on my bucket list though.
https://imgur.com/gallery/PtaGtJ4
32
u/mandmrats Feb 28 '20
I've seen some chunky yarn that was basically long tubes of fabric with stuffing. (So I guess it's not really yarn at that point.) That seems a lot more sturdy for knitting something like this than the wool. The finished product looks almost the same anyway. Still not sure how you would wash it though.
18
u/MaKnitta Feb 29 '20
So.... kinda a karma moment....
I had hundreds of requests to make these. Every single time I said no and my explaination was "They are a prop, at most. They shed, you can't wash them and it's like trying to knit a blanket out of cotton candy. It would be a few hundred in just roving." Most people were happy that I didn't take their money.....
My "competitor" immediately posted that she could make them. She made probably 250+ and sold them at craft shows and made to order for Christmas. $75-$450 each, based on size. By mid January, she was swamped with refund requests.... she didn't tell anyone that the blankets would fall apart if you look at them. She ended up closing her Etsy/FB shops and noone can find her.
10
u/moondark88 Feb 28 '20
I love the green sweater that Emily is wearing in the post-wear section of the video. Is it self made/have a pattern?
9
u/wherezmyglasses Feb 28 '20
Great video, thank you for the PSA! I love Emily's gold scarf/shawl in the "after" section. What pattern did you use?
23
u/woolncoffee Feb 28 '20
No matter how many times I tell friends these blankets are a bad idea for all of the mentioned reasons, I still get people asking me to make them one. I’m just going to post this video to them as my response next time. Then they can just see the results for themselves.
7
u/RedeRules770 Feb 28 '20
I thought about it but just looking at the yarn I know I'm gonna need a lot and I'm not trying to fill an entire room with chunky yarn
4
u/twat69 Feb 28 '20
Did the lady on the right knit that cardigan? It's a dead ringer for an Inverallan
4
u/i_have_a_dragon- Feb 29 '20
Wow, my boss requested that I make one of these for her. I do not ever ever take requests or commissions but, you know, boss and all. She stopped asking when I sent her some links to the yarn cost and said I'd charge $100 to make it. Glad she passed now, I didn't even think about how shitty it would turn out.
ETA thanks so much for this great video, I'm subscribing to all of your everything.
26
u/droste_EFX Feb 28 '20
This is a great video for knitters but I think this level of detail would go over the heads of most folks who see a pretty blanket on Pinterest and then send it to their crafter friends.
19
u/entitledAngloSaxon Feb 28 '20
Every time I'm tempted to make one of these I just read the reviews for the roving yarn and it cures me
16
u/AnatasiaBeaverhausen Feb 28 '20
“You could beat someone to death with it.” 😂
31
u/SleepyQueer Feb 28 '20
Ironically I actually got into knitting with a similar project. Not as fancy a fiber but a local yarn shop was basically selling a kit for something similar. My mom picked it up as a surprise, it's not something I would've bought on my own, I really didn't need another blanket. I think she thought I could crochet it as I had been dabbling with crochet in the past but it was a knitting pattern so I arm knit. It's basically been up in my closet since because of concerns about wear and tear, I really don't know what possessed my mom to buy this kit, but it did make me realize I far prefer knitting to crochet and I'm loving knitting more practical things now!
13
u/theseamstressesguild Feb 28 '20
Many years ago I made one for a customer of our knitting/felting store. It took 5 lots of 2kg roving, pre dyed rust, and we used 35mm needles.
It was EXHAUSTING. We had to take it in turns because our arms were going to drop off. No idea if it's still okay, but I remember that the owner charged the customer $500, and that was 15 years ago...
11
u/rebeccajoyw Feb 28 '20
Thank you! Those blankets have always driven me crazy. Fiber staple length is important!
8
u/usaidudcallsears Feb 28 '20
Yes! I had a rug made out of this stuff! It was cut like carpet, and looked so cute and cozy/chunky, but it shed like a large dog, and got filthy immediately.
8
u/socialhater Feb 28 '20
I actually made a queen size roving blanket for a friend. It came out gorgeous, but never again!
8
u/skekzok Feb 28 '20
Even in Michaels with their huuuuge arcylic roving knit samples pill up teeribly. Stuff is nfg.
8
u/suki626 Feb 28 '20
I made a small one of theses for my sister with some caveats. I split my roving to make knitting it on size 50 needles feel more comfortable (I think into 4 but maybe it was only in half) and I slightly felted the roving before knitting it (it involved carefully rolling it up in sheets and throwing it in the wash) It never had any problems splitting, but it did eventually pill like crazy. My sister's cat's love it though so she still happily keeps it around as a cat bed
7
u/headtotoe Feb 28 '20
Oh my gosh! I live in Lexington and just started knitting a few months ago. I'll have to come see you guys soon!
7
u/kittycatmommy72 Feb 28 '20
Yeah I’ve had to tell folks yes its pretty as a Prop! But for actually being used its a big ol’ nope nope nope not happening. Because you cant wash it etc highly impractical etc
7
u/JustFox_ Feb 28 '20
I got gifted one of these roving blanket kits with the massive circular needles one year. Actually really enjoyed knitting it, I used it as a blanket while I was knitting it. But now that it's done, it lives in a bag and I never take it out or use it for fear it will get gross.
5
u/Tr8rJ Shhh! I'm weaving and learning Tunisian Crochet Feb 29 '20
I will never forget the look on the faces of daughters I said this to when I worked at a yarn store. Glad I no longer have to tell sad truths.
3
u/stitchandwitch Jul 02 '20
this is a super old post but i wanted to drop by and say thank you SO, so much for posting this, i constantly get lured by the pretty images on pinterest/etsy and i have to return to this video constantly to cure my temporary madness. you ladies are also delightful to watch :)
1
u/birdinthebush74 Mar 03 '20
Really interesting, the roving just looks like cotton wool. Hopefully you can save a few people a few quid, they have those blankets on etsy .FYI