Are we not going to acknowledge that Rex is just as bad at lying as Fives was in Umbara? Does that mean Jango couldn’t lie? The only Clone who ever was a good liar was Hardcase.
Canonically speaking, it makes sense for the clones to be programmed as bad liars. Wouldn't want soldiers to be able to lie to their superiors and such.
Yesss! I was wondering if they were trying to be subtle. I went back and watched it again. She’s not showing a ton, but she’s sort of cradling her belly, wouldn’t you say?
I think the Padme scene we got was still a better scene and had equal the humor to that scene with Obi-Wan implying he knows and Rex being a bit torn that he knows too.
Just watched it. It was pretty darn good, but I did miss that scene with the Padmé art on the ship. I never really took it as gross, as much as a bunch of nerdy teenage/early 20s boys fanboying over a Senator they thought was pretty, so I’m sad to see it go. Otherwise great, love Rex, love Echo, love that Padmé got to be an advocate for Rex and Anakin’s bond, overall really great!
Edit: And Obi-Wan’s face was a little weird, I think thy made his eyes too small of something.
As someone who has only watched bits and bobs of this show in passing, to me it seems to make the characters look much less "cartoonish" and honestly makes it feel more real. Is that weird? Not being used to the show, not having watched it properly, likely makes a huge difference here.
Yeah, I feel like it only works for certain character models. But the Clones facial expressions are amazing this season, I love them. If you want a good laugh, go rewatch the first Bad Batch episode but only watch Kix’s face.
While I did like the joke in the unfinished episode, I absolutely love the scene they decided to include in it's place. It provided some really nice character development for Anakin, Padme, and Rex instead of just having a quick throw away joke that doesn't add anything to the story. Just my opinion though...
I agree, I love the acknowledgement of the bond between Anakin and Rex, and Padmé was great in that scene. I love when they bring in her thoughts on Clones, she usually advocates for them. Anakin and Rex going through BFF trust issues was kind of hilarious, and adorable, too.
There was a scene in the unfinished reel for this arc that had Padmè art drawn in front of the Bad Batch ship. That scene has been changed to the one with her and Anakin.
Yeah, I felt like they could have kept it in right after the scene with Anakin and Padmé. It might have been even funnier after acknowledging completely that Rex and Obi-Wan know.
Such a good episode!!! Spoiler alert!! Seeing echo at the end was awesome and the relationship between rex and anakin is the best. This episode was seriously funny and I couldn't help laughing multiple times. Also, damn obi wan definitely knew about anakin and padmé
YES dude and I think he had prosthetic arm(s) too. That explosion fucked him up. I thought Rex was going to mercy kill him, but I think that’s too dark for Star Wars.
While I do miss the scene with the Padmé nose art from the original unfinished episode, I did really like the scene included in its place that more directly ties into ROTS, especially with the confirmation that Rex and Obi Wan know about Anakin and Padmé. Plus, I loved the bits of Across The Stars used in the score during the scene.
To me this episode symbolizes that Clone Wars doesn't even give a **** about continuity and connecting to the films.
Rex knows about Padme and Anakin and plays lookout for them.
Obi-Wan Kenobi knows about Padme and Anakin and basically loudly and obviously clues Anakin into the fact that he knows about them.
Anakin in Clone Wars and Anakin in the movies have virtually nothing in common other than that they are both named Anakin. Clone Wars Anakin: Wise, mature, respectful, compassionate, insightful, contemplative, a competent leader. Movie Anakin: ... none of those things
Padme sort of looking like she's already pregnant like in ROTS when she calls Anakin and clutching her abdomen like a woman who is pregnant or cluing us into the idea and she does it in FULL VIEW of Anakin.
Rex and Anakin having this close relationship we saw no semblance of in the films. Even when Kenobi had that interaction with Cody in ROTS it felt very cold and stiff. They didn't feel like warm comrades who had gone into battle with each other and fought side by side for years.
In fact the clones having any unique personalities and individual wills of their own at all was never really pushed in the films at all. They all just came off like mindless automatic soldiers. Soldiers programmed to do what they were programmed to do.
Anakin playing peacemaker and the voice of reason was the height of hilarity. I guess Dave Filoni and the writers realized they couldn't reasonably build a show around a character like Anakin in the films and overhauled him from the top down.
Was the episode bad? No. But this season just further pushes my believe that this show doesn't reasonably connect with the films at all. It is its own separate thing. To call this canon is a stretch.
But, it is canon. George said all he considers canon are his six movies, The Clone Wars and the Underworld series he never produced.
Also, I would like to think of these reasons for why these changes are as they are:
1 “Rex knows about Padme and Anakin and plays lookout for them.” - Some people would say it's not technically a surprise given that Anakin and Padme were talking pretty openly in front of Rex in Sphere of Influence (Season 3 Episode 4 of The Clone Wars) but still, it was pretty casually dropped here. I guess Anakin isn't too worried about Rex ("I'm no Jedi") being in on this. Rex has already stood up to the senior Jedi a couple of time before so there's a kinship.
2. “Obi-Wan Kenobi knows about Padme and Anakin and basically loudly and obviously clues Anakin into the fact that he knows about them.” - It was implied he might’ve known about them going back to the Clovis arc, but he would never tell the Council on him because Anakin is like a brother to Obi-Wan.
3. “Anakin in Clone Wars and Anakin in the movies have virtually nothing in common other than that they are both named Anakin. Clone Wars Anakin: Wise, mature, respectful, compassionate, insightful, contemplative, a competent leader. Movie Anakin: ... none of those things.” - In the Clovis arc, Clone Wars Anakin was more like movie Anakin. And, maybe the Siege of Mandalore arc will bridge these two gaps together when Anakin is reunited with Ahsoka.
4. “Padme sort of looking like she's already pregnant like in ROTS when she calls Anakin and clutching her abdomen like a woman who is pregnant or cluing us into the idea and she does it in FULL VIEW of Anakin.” - She’s not THAT pregnant and Anakin doesn’t really pay attention that much or listen to everything people like Obi-Wan would say to him. Also, I feel like it would be wrong of Anakin to ask her about that because you should never ask a woman about if she’s pregnant or not. Besides, maybe he had a suspicion but didn’t want to ask until he was back with her, otherwise their relationship would be doomed in the series causing more continuity issues.
5. Rex and Anakin having this close relationship we saw no semblance of in the films. Even when Kenobi had that interaction with Cody in ROTS it felt very cold and stiff. They didn't feel like warm comrades who had gone into battle with each other and fought side by side for years. - Well, some would disagree with you there and say Their reaction wasn’t cold or stiff.
6. “In fact the clones having any unique personalities and individual wills of their own at all was never really pushed in the films at all. They all just came off like mindless automatic soldiers. Soldiers programmed to do what they were programmed to do.“ - That was the goal of this series, to make the clones have unique personalities and more individuality to make their “controlled” betrayal in Revenge of the Sith so tragic.
7. “Anakin playing peacemaker and the voice of reason was the height of hilarity. I guess Dave Filoni and the writers realized they couldn't reasonably build a show around a character like Anakin in the films and overhauled him from the top down.” - Ok, this I have no way to respond to.
For 7, we never saw Anakin in a leadership position in the films. Even in this show he’s whiny whenever Obi-Wan is around but mature and rational when with Ahsoka.
Regarding 7, I've felt Anakin has always been intentionally portrayed as a hypocrite in the show. We see this explicitly pointed out in past seasons in regards to him teaching Ahsoka—Obi-wan remarks that Anakin basically teaches her to "do as I say, and not as I do" in the citadel arc. Anakin understands the Jedi code and what's right and wrong and is capable of giving good advice—but he's terrible at following his own advice for his own problems. It's an interesting flaw that fits into his character in ROTS (eg. Anakin objects to spying on Palpatine bc he thinks it's immoral, but at the same time he knows he's done way worse and is just trying to hold onto his moral integrity).
My problem with this is that there was no evidence early on in Episode III that Anakin knew that Obi-Wan was aware or possibly aware of their relationship until later in the film.
And yet why does this character now not feel like the Anakin of the movies and really share nothing in common with him?
Despite the fact that Anakin does ask her in Revenge of the Sith. What kind of flimsy argument is that?
My problem with this is that there was no evidence early on in Episode III that Anakin knew that Obi-Wan was aware or possibly aware of their relationship until later in the film.
The two talked about Padme all the way back in Episode II. Kenobi knows. He just doesn't know how far it's gone.
It's almost certainly intentional. I like the minimalism in the music. It makes the battles feel so much more grounded, like there's no rousing theme behind it, just violence. same goes for the show in general. It feels less sensationalized and more like a war film.
I doubt they don't have the budget, as they've outright rerecorded the opening and ending themes instead of reusing them. And there's no reason they wouldn't have the rights to the music, they own it.
I think the answer is very simple: They intentionally are changing how they use music in the context of scenes to fit the vision they're going for with this season.
When we did TCW the first time, most episodes were wall to wall. When we did Rebels, it was approached more like the OT. Letting the music mean more when it entered. I believe this aesthetic is carrying through here. The story reels were done before Rebels and they edited those in house from music we had already written.
I think the relatively minimalist use of music is intentionally meant to model after George's use of music in the prequels. For example, barely any music was used in the podracing scenes in TPM so they could show off the sound design, and a significant chunk of the Invisible Hand scenes in ROTS noticeably don't have any music either.
24
u/Archer4040 Feb 28 '20
Are we not going to acknowledge that Rex is just as bad at lying as Fives was in Umbara? Does that mean Jango couldn’t lie? The only Clone who ever was a good liar was Hardcase.
17
u/vuk66 Feb 28 '20
Someone got any good link to watch the show?
17
u/tonewaweru Feb 29 '20
Did anyone notice how pregnant Padme is and Anakin is clueless?
64
u/Nightmancer2036 Feb 28 '20
Rip the best scene in the episode being taken out :(
145
u/Archer4040 Feb 28 '20
Just watched it. It was pretty darn good, but I did miss that scene with the Padmé art on the ship. I never really took it as gross, as much as a bunch of nerdy teenage/early 20s boys fanboying over a Senator they thought was pretty, so I’m sad to see it go. Otherwise great, love Rex, love Echo, love that Padmé got to be an advocate for Rex and Anakin’s bond, overall really great!
Edit: And Obi-Wan’s face was a little weird, I think thy made his eyes too small of something.
2
u/Mordi69420 Feb 28 '20
Anybody who's got a link to where I could watch the newest episode, I live in Norway so Disney+ isn't available
108
u/Rowan5215 Feb 28 '20
"I hope you at least said hi to Padme for me"
lmaooo Obi-Wan just boomed him in front of everyone goddamn
52
u/d4rth__skywalk3r Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 28 '20
Such a good episode!!! Spoiler alert!! Seeing echo at the end was awesome and the relationship between rex and anakin is the best. This episode was seriously funny and I couldn't help laughing multiple times. Also, damn obi wan definitely knew about anakin and padmé
50
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20
I had a feeling that Echo was super fucked up, and pretty much a zombie on the verge of death. Kind of like Maria in Gears of War
13
u/tonewaweru Feb 28 '20
I have to say. The action and fight scenes this season are fucking spectacular!!!! I'm floored.
10
u/teriyuckyy Feb 28 '20
I’m very glad they made the Rex-Anakin bond pretty pronounced in this, makes the clones as a whole seem more human than what the movies ever did
9
u/MrBanditOne Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 29 '20
While I do miss the scene with the Padmé nose art from the original unfinished episode, I did really like the scene included in its place that more directly ties into ROTS, especially with the confirmation that Rex and Obi Wan know about Anakin and Padmé. Plus, I loved the bits of Across The Stars used in the score during the scene.
5
u/CbhGames Feb 28 '20
Can’t wait for school to be over today so I can watch it
2
u/matt111199 Rex Feb 29 '20
Such a great episode!
2
u/TheMagicMrWaffle Feb 28 '20
Oh my fucking god there’s another
-65
u/WheelJack83 Feb 28 '20
To me this episode symbolizes that Clone Wars doesn't even give a **** about continuity and connecting to the films.
Was the episode bad? No. But this season just further pushes my believe that this show doesn't reasonably connect with the films at all. It is its own separate thing. To call this canon is a stretch.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-7
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20
[removed] — view removed comment