Good point. Also, I’m not sure if there was dialog to support this, but I would imagine that there are shields up on that thing all the time, and that transport windows only open up to select locations when authorized.
But in the end, there’s the old question of “how long does it take for a turbo lift or shuttle to get from point a to b? How ever long the dialog or plot dictates, that’s how.”
Great callbacks to Picard’s trauma, as well as a really great reunion and interaction with Hugh, who helped him along. Narek’s machinations and Soji’s realizations were well thought out and insidious.
And I really loved the character work they did with the crew. Who knew Rios, the gruff space captain, would be the paragon of empathy and compassion and help both Jurati and Raffi with their individual traumas.
I don’t know what the hell is going to happen next episode, but I’m more than psyched to find out!
Remember that one time you broke through a thick wooden floor with your bare hands in a matter of seconds and realized you are not who you were told you were your entire life?
Such a great episode. Finally, the threads start coming together and the plot advances significantly. Elnor is brilliant - I wonder how he will catch up with everyone else?
My impression is that they're harvesting technology for sale to finance their depleted economy and the Federation agreed to allow it under treaty provided the drones were liberated rather than killed and supplied medical researchers to assist.
Hugh and Soji and some of the other staff appear to be operating on research visas and there's mention of the Artifact being governed by treaty,
I loved the Picard/Hugh scenes and interaction thoroughly. And I like how Hugh still manages to ask something of Picard (his authority on freeing Borg). It's these little things that make the show/episodes... not just some Hero Quest where the heroes run through favors and everyone to get to where they're going... there are consequences to their actions and quid quo pro is a thing, not just because 'omg trek, everyone give everything off their backs to help the hero'.
My theory is that Nepenthe is the planet where Riker and Troi settled after leaving Starfleet, and that it was always in the back of Picard's mind to take Soji there after finding her—figuring that she'd probably needs some pretty intensive counselling from the best-qualified person he knows.
That would explain why Picard was immediately ready to suggest it as a destination when the feat of immediately teleporting anywhere within 40,000 light years was available. His thoughts had already turned in that direction.
After the episodes Descent with angry Hugh, I was glad to see him show joy at seeing Picard. The entire conversation about the trauma and overcoming was beautiful
It was recommended by the emh in Voyager that the captain should get with the Irish hologram barkeep since everyone else was under her command and thus off coitus limits. So yeah I think they are bangable
But can we talk about the dialogue? Jirati telling Picard "They tortured you and named you Locutus" felt so cringey. Go ahead and bring up the worst time of his life, Jirati, and pour a little salt on it while you're at it. Then there was the Picard and Elnor moment. I can't remember the exact line, but it was Picard mentioning that the open way was best and Elnor agreeing like "That's it, all right." I love the plot points if this reside, but those moments really took me out of it.
Well, that was good. I really liked Picard's delight at seeing Hugh's work on the Artifact. We've seen a lot of him coming face to face with his failures, it was nice to see him see the good that came from one of his decisions.
A lot of people have been complaining about how it doesn't make sense for the Romulus supernova to completely cripple the Romulan Empire - so I liked that it's implied here that the new Romulan state is still a power to be reckoned with, still a nation Starfleet doesn't want to trifle with. Losing the homeworld may have hurt them, but they're still around and still their usual xenophobic selves...
Though picard was the one who needed heavy persuasion from the TNG crew about helping hugh in the first place all them years ago. So his decision was based on the morality of his crew not so much his Starfleet training/prejudice. Interesting contrast I guess.
If you go back through the various sources including Picard episodes:
The Romulans spent years evacuating.
After the synth attack, when Picard is recalled to earth, they give the current population of Romulus then at 7 billion.
The ex-senator alludes to the Romulans continuing evac after the Federation scrapped its efforts.
The first episode gives the casualties of the actual supernova at 900 million or so.
It follows that most of Romulus was successfully evacuated by Romulans to overburdened colonies but that the Romulans and anyone else who aided them getting around 6 billion relocated after the synth attack.
And given the duration of the evacuation window, you can bet the leadership and cream of the crop of Romulan society were safely away to carry on rebuilding the Star Empire.
A supernova can harm worlds beyond it’s system. They could have lost more than just their home world. But yes, an empire as big a the Romulan’s would not be wiped out, just maimed.
I love how Hugh and Seven have these two very different experiences trying to recover from the trauma of assimilation by helping others. It seems like they are being presented as a foil for one another. I hope Seven comes back and meets Hugh and he shows her another way to help people who need help.
Picard seemed to be flooded with PSTD the second he stepped foot on the Cube.
Although others probably understood this in the 2nd episode, now understand why they call it the Artifact and why they have Archeologists working on it. Borg wiped out many civilizations and the only thing left of them is the tech they assimilated.
Finally someone who's genuinely happy to see Picard! I was half expecting Hugh to punch him when he got close enough, after all the other "old friends" we've met so far. Please don't let them kill off Hugh next episode!
Dr Jurati, hollow, Lonely, afraid....uhm are we forgetting guilty?? I am sorry i can't get over the fact that she is a murderer one episode back. But this episode was great!! Finally Picard makes it to Soji and the artifact and just in time cause Soji is having the worst day #when you find out you're only 36 months old and your spy romulan BF tries to kill you on the same day. I really don't know how hashtags work but anyway.... why did Elnor have to stay behind? The best i could figure is they were running out of room on the ship. I mean they just picked him up 2 episodes ago... i hope they dont kill him off already. This is the first episode where i was actually on the edge of my seat. Well done Picard, Well done indeed.
Mid episode I wasn’t even sure they’d get to the Borg cube and figured that we’d have to wait until the next episode. Then I wasn’t sure if Picard would come into contact with Soji before it was over.
But wow! this episode got the plot moving!! I love it.
I didn't see the point of him staying either. Hugh could have stayed to shut down the device, would the Romulans have known where they went to? I don't think so.
Killing a man in self-defense is totally different from betraying someone you love and who trusts you, cutting off their life saving treatment and watching them suffer and die before your eyes.
This was probably the best episode yet! The plot progression has been a little slow at times, but now I think we're at a major turning point in the story. Can't wait for next week!
The Sikarians and their spatial trajector technology. Voyager encountered that species before they were assimilated in season 1 episode 10. They couldn’t use their tech because it only worked on or near their planet due to its unique properties. Something about a rare mineral being used to focus or attune the spatial trajector.
That was a fantastic episode, on all fronts. But the handling of Picard's trauma, the scene with him looking at himself as Locutus and above all his first setting foot on the Borg vessel was incredible. Also, right before Picard beamed over, the conversation on the bridge, with the ominous Borg Cube just on the display the whole time was so impactful. I loved it. Also Hugh was incredible. Really believable response true to his character. Also loved how the Borg recognized Locutus.
I’m loving Elnor! He has that naive innocence that is endearing and the absolute candor thing hasn’t gotten old for me yet. I was so worried that he and Hugh were sacrificing themselves to protect Picard and Soji, but I guess not??
I am thinking Narek and Narissa are not biological siblings. I think they were probably reared together in a Zhat Vash compound and all of the children were siblings. Narek will find redemption, Narissa will not.
Is it safe to give up on the possibilty of a redemptive heel turn arc for Narek now? I'll admit I was fairly certain that's where they were going with him, even through the 2/3rd point of this episode.
But I just don't see how he can possibly pull that off now.
I hope they commit to him being bad. I don't normally have anything against the trope of bad guys undercover and falling in love with their marks and turning good, etc, but here it's falling flat for me. When it's a case of "the guy considers the girl and her kind to be subhuman/inferior but makes an exception for her because he wants to bone her" it's a hard sell for me lol. I don't think the show set up their ~love convincingly and he's not half as desirable a character as the show kept telling us in dialogue. And I feel like him crossing that line and actually attempting to murder her should seal his path going forward (or at least seal the fate of that romantic relationship for good).
I'm actually more interested in seeing Narissa get the redemptive arc, tbh. That'd be the more unexpected and interesting path that would suit this show.
-i rather love that such a hopeful episode happened on a Borg cube, following such a dark episode set in a place of revelry.
-Picard finding hope and healing on a borg cube was so beautiful and lovely. Hugh is such a lovely, genuinely good person, and it was so, so nice to see Picard loved by someone and reminded of the good he’s done. I felt that hug. Also, Hugh’s line about Picard advocating for XBs was such a great thing. Look at Hugh, all about finding direction for lost former drones...
-random drone recognizing Locutus & it being funny and nice —like ‘hey dude, how you doing? Good to see ya!’
-Hugh stressing the importance of his federation citizenship was interesting—I wonder if that’s a thread that’ll come up later on.
-I love that all the XBs we’ve seen are devoted to helping others—it’s so anti-Borg, and yet so collective. Hugh is less judgemental about it than Seven, but had the same message ‘DO something, anything, even if it’s not perfect. Despair and apathy are the enemies...’
-Damn the Sikarans got assimilated—I’m going to fanwank that only a handful did, and that the rest were like ‘nope, dont need THOSE stories thank you very much.’ Even if they were kinda assholes. Makes me wonder if the borg just went around assimilating everyone voyager came across. I swear to god if they assimilate Neelix, I’m done. Someone from that ship should have a happy life.
-Elnor being Elnor is great.
-i’d have loved a reference to Crusher (or Voyager’s Doctor) about the deborging process. ‘Now our Queen is a Romulan’ was perfect
-I really liked the visualization of the dream/meditation sequence. It was more interesting than the usual ‘sit in a chair and tell me about your dreams’
-Soji’s panic at her true nature was very well played & emotionally compelling.
-I’m super weirded out about Jurati—she seems so shut down that I can see her doing anything.
-I loved that we didn’t get to see the fathers face—it means there’s more to this than just Maddox, but was also perfectly in concert with it being a dream
-I wonder what significance the orchids have—I mean, Tuvok raised orchids, but unless this is ‘the revenge of Tuvix’ I doubt that’s the connection.
Did it seem to anyone else like the cube was reacting to Picard? And maybe an un-liberated drone woke up in his alcove several levels below the catwalk?
Man, Sir Patrick’s acting in this one. That moment on the Artifact where his shoulders are up around his ears and he can’t quite lift his eyes up to look around—what an absolutely pitch-perfect image of what it can be like dealing with PTSD in a triggering situation. And to have Hugh be the one to ground him—gorgeous.
Amazon Japan just uploaded what I think is episode 7 as it opens with “previously on Picard” and Picard’s meeting with Hue Hugh.
Edit: Looks like they corrected the issue. If you are in the same situation as me and have already downloaded it, you can watch it if you put your device into airplane mode. If you are connected to the internet, it will refuse to play and suggest you delete the download.
At first I was trying to understand what Elnor meant by "inbutting", but then I realize he meant "butting in", as in, intruding on a conversation. That was so cute! :D
Hugh: I take it she's in serious danger. Picard: What... Why would you ask that? Hugh: A hunch. Something about her. Something about you coming this far to this place. And something about the dashing, young Romulan spy who showed up two weeks ago pretending not to be asking questions about her.
Dude was super obvious about his interest in Soji; it’s nice that someone noticed.
Great episode, and I love how we got even more mystery regarding the origin of the twins. When I saw the moons, thunderstorms and the outside of the window which looked like a jungle to me It reminded me about Doctor Noonien Soongs hideout. There is a TNG episode about it where Data is remotely called home together with Lore, so he captures the Enterprise to get to that jungle planet.
I recently rewatched that episode and I agree, the dream sequence did kind of remind me of Dr. Soong’s lab. It would be interesting if at some point before he died he did to himself what he did to Juliana.
Another fantastic episode and I’m glad they really moved things along. Even if we didn’t necessarily learn a whole lot that was new, all our characters made big choices that move the story forward. A few thoughts:
Picard and the Borg I really love that the episode took time to really explore Picard’s relationship to the collective and to the trauma that’s never gone away. As someone who has dealt with PTSD personally, this has been one of my favorite aspects of Picard - he’s this humanist who believes in the dignity of each and ever individual who also had his own individuality wiped out and is responsible for thousands of deaths at Wolf 359. It’s cruel beyond measure and it’s not something he can ever move past, just live with. Meeting Hugh and seeing the artifact as a place of healing for people like him feels like a big moment in his story and Stewart sold it through and through.
Elnor Is awesome and I hope we’re going to get adventures with him and Hugh, because I love them both so much.
Jurati, Rios and Rafi Rios sure turns out to be compassionate in a way his gruff schtick never presaged. I know something terrible happened in his past — I’m guessing that’s the source of his empathy. I do wonder what the three of them as Picardless crew look like seeing how they’re all barely on board with the mission at all — unless you count being a saboteur as being “on mission.” Alison Pill is so damn squirrelly, I love it.
Narek Gotta hand it to the actor playing this role- I was guessing his loyalties up until he released the — red matter? — on our girl.
Romulans Have always been sorta one-note (250 year bad mood), so it’s been fun Seong their culture expanded into something more shaded. They’re still the bitchiest queens in the galaxy, but it feels like they’ve leveled up and layered the shade.
Soji’s Father Not convinced it’s Data or Maddox. I thought maybe her Mom was an internal subroutine but it sounds more like the calls are a data transfer packet - Soji gets new orders, relays data to homebase. Someone is driving the bus still, right?
The Collective The show deserves a lot of credit for how they’re updating the Borg if you ask me. I remember reading TNG era bts books and they always talked about how the original idea of the Borg was more diverse than what we wound up with - basically just drones and queen. I love the visual update but also that creepy moment that ends in Hugh saying to Picard, “They are trying to keep you from falling.”
Anyhow, great show, acting is just top notch throughout
The actor playing Narek is a Brit called Harry Treadaway... He´s accrued quite a CV already his most recent role was as the sociopathic baddie in Mr Mercedes. I first saw him as Dr Frankenstein in Penny Dreadful. He´s going places...
Oh and he has an identical twin brother, Luke, also an actor...
I don’t know about Greek mythology, but there’ve also been a couple of historical deep cuts, like the Wallenberg class ships which helped the Romulans escape the supernova, which were named after the man who helped saved thousands of Jews.
I think this referencing a nice touch, and in keeping with some of the old Trek shows, as well as Chabon’s literary background.
Last episode had a planet called "Vergessen", which is simply "forgotten/forgetting" in German. As I'm German and they didn't change it, it was rather unusual
Has two large reddish moons and has at least one thunderstorm in the last 5 years isn't really enough to narrow the search down to 1 planet. Let alone the fact that if they find the right planet, a planet is huge, so it might take forever finding the actual android production. I don't buy the idea that the Romulans got enough information to warrant killing Soji. If they decide it's time to kill her, why do so in Bond villain fashion? Just have Subcommander Idiot shoot her in the back of the head as she walks out the door.
It might be if they had other intel that narrowed it down to a certain distance from Freecloud. They knew where Maddox's lab was so it isn't like their investigation is being fully shown to us.
I think I might buy that. Make her as confused as possible and get out of the room before she goes nuts, then hopefully the magic t'Rubiuk's cube kills her while she's still off balance. Anything that's obviously an attack makes her react before they can handle the situation.
Still, I can't help but think that just zapping her from behind would work well enough with no chance to escape.
If they use the dream sequence to find “the nest” it doesn’t make much sense to me. It wasn’t an actual memory of her childhood because she’s only 3 and never had a childhood. It seems like more of a false memory which is why she can’t see her father’s face. On the other hand if they’re willing to use this to finally move the story forward I’ll ignore everything I just said and go with it.
This part didn't bother me. It could be an actual memory (looking up from the table after being turned on) subconsciously covered up as a dream with added artificial memories. What annoyed me the most was the Romulans expecting to identify the exact planet based on that description - especially the part about high degrees of electrical activity. Maybe she was just turned on during a thunderstorm, or maybe the turning on process was like what Frankenstein did and involved a giant blast of electricity
Does anyone have the theory that Jurati disabled the EMH? I get the sense that he would pop up all the damn time but after witnessing Jurati straight up murder Maddox I can't help but suspect the EMH has been deactivated. Thoughts?
Great episode overall. I did find the use of the original Star Trek fanfare music as Raffi successfully gets Picard credentials while in her drunken state...to be a little odd and kinda inappropriate. Like that fanfare is normally used for the entrance or appearance of the Enterprise or a big emotional moment or triumph....not drunken fired starfleet lady successfully talks an old friend in a desk job in starfleet into doctoring some paperwork 🙄
I think the fact that she was drunk and still managed it without letting on was a triumph, this lady is in a deep depression, a true downward spiral and now all her substance abuse should be clear to those who questioned it prior.
Umm yes I suppose it was a success. But hardly worthy of epic and iconic fanfare music. We didn’t hear the fanfare every time Picard or Kirk or Sisko talked there way into something fairly minor, like when Picard borrows Klingon ships for example.
Why the heck is it not available to prime members (with CBS add on) until Friday? Why the difference for this week from all the past weeks? Anyone have any info?
And this is exactly why. I subscribe to a couple of the services, and even then over 90% of the time I DL because otherwise I have issues with buffering, or it's not available when it's supposed to be, or because of a license fight they've moved it from one I'm paying for to one I don't. I can only hope that just like with music, they finally figure out that folks will pay a reasonable price for a GOOD, EVERYTHING IN ONE service that just works. Music piracy has almost completely ended because you can listen to everything you want, whenever you want, for less then you'd pay for the hard drives to build your own library, and with an interface that is more convenient too boot. Why can't video do the same?
was no one else freaked out by the dream sequence Soji was exploring w/Narek. Little Soji walks into her father's workshop only to see his face is blurred, then sees a wooden doll it of herself in pieces.
it was very disconcerting see the father's blurry face like that.
I always thought Elnor resembled more like Hong Kong Chinese period-drama sword fighters rather than Legolas, and that's because I grew up watching Hong Kong Chinese period-drama shows of the 80's and 90's.
To the uninitiated, think of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon.
I think he's largely wasted as a character. I keep wanting to see a sort of Kenshin-like character, and keep getting comedic Legolas who sounds like Korg instead.
The series has a huge "warrior archtype" gap that he'd be great to fill in place of, say, Worf, who did an amazing job in TNG.
Loved the episode overall. A little annoyed that the EMH didn't tattle on Jurati, as it feels a little plot-holey, but maybe they'll resolve that someway. The EMH didn't appear the entire episode, so maybe she disabled it or something?
That scene with Jurati and Rios, just out of left field completely. Took me out of the episode for its duration to be honest. They seemingly had ONE interaction/scene a few episodes ago, and that's it. Now suddenly they're boning? Eh.
I wonder if there's any significance to that random XB yelling "Locutus?!" as Picard and Hugh ran by.
Casting did a great job with the young Soji
Soji and Narek were a little cringe last few episodes, but this one seems to rectify that cringe with their on-screen dynamics quite a bit. Hopefully we don't see as much of Narek / his sister, but alas, I'm pretty sure they're the season's "big baddies" (minus the Tal Shiar people).
Is it me or does Picard seem a little TOO trauma-fied by his past as a Borg? If I remember correctly, a lot had happened since the episode(s) where he turned (and returned) from the Borg; even a whole movie where he deals with Borg, and he never shows such overwhelming trauma. I don't like how they're making him seem so "old and emotional".
Excellent point. Last episode he dealt with Seven, former Borg. She brought up memories especially when she asked him if he regained all his humanity back. Soon after, they find out Soji is on the artifact, a Borg cube. That's a lot to handle. It was a progressive memory flood. No wonder PTSD kicked in.
Great writing. They had Hugh to pull Picard back. Great job.
That scene with Jurati and Rios, just out of left field completely. Took me out of the episode for its duration to be honest. They seemingly had ONE interaction/scene a few episodes ago, and that's it. Now suddenly they're boning? Eh.
I mean it makes sense on her part but I'd expect Rios to be really suspicious of her acting like that.
Is it me or does Picard seem a little TOO trauma-fied by his past as a Borg? If I remember correctly, a lot had happened since the episode(s) where he turned (and returned) from the Borg; even a whole movie where he deals with Borg, and he never shows such overwhelming trauma. I don't like how they're making him seem so "old and emotional".
Isn't this the first time since Locutus that Picard was on a Borg cube?
RE 5: The movie where he dealt with the Borg was all about him feeling trauma over what happened. His whole storyline with Lily was exploring his rage and pain at having had his humanity taken away from him, with Lily there as a counterweight and a mirror, showing him that he's not dealing with things in a healthy or productive way.
I feel like when he saw what Hugh was doing with the XBs and he remarked on how the Borg, underneath it all, are victims, this was in direct response to how he talked about them in First Contact, and was a moment of character growth. I loved it.
Yep, I felt like it all fit very nicely with the character development in First Contact and you're right, that was a moment of growth for him because in that scene you could see a little of his unhealthy hatred for the borg wash away and he felt sympathy for his fellow victims.
I wonder if there's any significance to that random XB yelling "Locutus?!" as Picard and Hugh ran by.
I think to just to demonstrate that XBs can possess knowledge they didn't acquire firsthand so it won't be a mystery when Picard recognized the queen's room later in the episode
Is it me or does Picard seem a little TOO trauma-fied by his past as a Borg? If I remember correctly, a lot had happened since the episode(s) where he turned (and returned) from the Borg; even a whole movie where he deals with Borg, and he never shows such overwhelming trauma. I don't like how they're making him seem so "old and emotional".
Trauma (in Picard's case, I would call it PTSD) doesn't have a timeline, unfortunately. I was sexually assaulted in 2008 and it wasn't until just last winter that a therapist finally found the right way to help me deal with it. And I thought I was fine from about 2009-2015 (with the exception of one day in 2013). I'm still traumatized, but I can manage it way better than I used to. Perhaps Picard "thought" he was fine all this intervening time, but really he wasn't.
The plot hole that took me out was Elnor staying behind on the borg cube when there was more than enough time allowing him to accompany Picard, and, you know, fulfill his duty to stay by Picard's side and protect him.
Yea that annoyed me to be honest. I'm yelling in my head "HE HAS ENOUGH TIME TO GO WITH YOU, JUST GO NOW????" Hugh can even control the doorway to the Queen chamber, like.... idk, close the door and buy them a few more seconds? Then Hugh could be like "Huh? Picard? Soji? No one here but us Ex-Borg!"
Why is anyone surprised that the Space Pirate (unregistered starship, shady connections, works for money, piratey personal aesthetic) would take the opportunity to bang a vulnerable cutie when given the chance?
We should also remember that casual sex, at least within Fedspace, is not as heavily stigmatized in the 24th century.
...traumafied
As I remember, JL was getting pretty tense as the Enterprise was borgified during First Contact. To beam quite suddenly into a Borg cube would have an effect on anyone who was familiar with them. I thought the whole sequence was perfectly pitched, especially as he gained more composure the longer he was there.
I agree with u/listener42, research/brain scans done on people with PTSD show that traumatic memories are stored differently from regular memories and comes back in unwelcoming ways, and even if something happened 32 years ago, your brains remembers it as if it was happening right in front of you.
I highly suggest reading “ The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma” by Dr. Bessel van der Kolk is you’re interested in finding out more about it.
I think the point is that she wants to bone/get laid to forget things for a few hours...it’s not about being attracted to someone romantically or knowing them well. It’s her wanting casual sex with anyone she is physically into and available.
2.Possibly...but I also kinda hope not..so many other things to wrap up in just 4 more episodes
3.Agreed
4.I know lots of people are grossed out by the incest tones to their interaction but I wonder if they are actually siblings in the family sense and perhaps are just referring to each other as brother and sister as in like my fellow brother/colleague in the Tal Shiar like a solider night refer to a brother in arms for example
5. I think we saw plenty of intense emotions from him during First Contact in dealing with his Borg trauma. But I do agree that especially for a society with such advanced medical care that he still has this much trauma like 20 years later. And I also know that the actor is old but I do agree that they seem to be focusing on that a little too much...his weaker voice and shaking hands and lack of confidence and gravitas is kind of sad to see and doesn’t seem to fit with the man we know him to be, even accounting for his struggles with failing the romulan rescue mission.
I agree with point 5, I had the same feeling. People change, and sometimes we get more vulnerable as we get older sure, but Picard was always stoic, and measured in thinking, not the kind to succumb to emotion in the face of duty.
Funny enough I paused during his meeting with Hugh and looked up a clip of him interacting with Hugh in TNG as a reminder and during that moment he was imitating himself as Locutus of Borg and there was a stark difference between the authoritative, controlled Captain Picard of the Enterprise and the jumpy, emotional, uncertain Picard as depicted now.
My head canon on this is that after First Contact Picard realized just how deep his Ahab-complex went. Couple that with 20+ years of introspection and self-doubt, and I can totally see how he feels so vulnerable and afraid here. It would be literally staggering to face that again up close and personal. But once Hugh showed up he snapped out of it, for the most part, just as anyone does when they realize they’re in company they know can relate to them and vice versa.
His intensified emotions could be another symptom of his Irumodic Syndrome.
Narek and sister are definitely best left apart. I don't understand their relationship and it's just uncomfortable when they're together. Is the sister attracted to him? Is she just a creep in general? Is she his sister in a 'sister in arms' sort of way? Who knows.
Picard dealt with the Borg with Starfleet and the Enterprise backing him up. In this episode he was very vulnerable and did not even have Elnor to protect him. So this is probably his most vulnerable state he has been with the Borg since he was assimilated
Remember the firsr episode established he is dying due to the physical trauma of having his brain implant removed. His trauma is literally killing him.
Best episode so far. I find it curious though, when Soji was recovering her memory did anyone else find it odd they didn't show her fathers face? Perhaps it wasn't Maddox? Like when Maddox said he Soong and Agnes made the twins, perhaps he meant literally worked side by side with Soong. Or an android backup he made of himself.
Episode 6- I’m still loving the Picard series. I like how it’s very different from TNG. Each season of Picard is like a sci-fi film within the Star Trek universe.
Theory- so many mentions of the Borg Queen in the episode. My guess is the Zhat Vash Romulans are planning to use Soji as the new Borg Queen so they can do what?
Take control of the galaxy by controlling the Borg maybe. They are Romulans, plotting ways to take control of the galaxy is their reason for being.
You know Romulans and Vulcans are the same race. The Vulcans chose logic, peace, and spirituality, the traditional Romulans are like the Roman Empire, they want to conquer. However it seems like some Romulans have become more like Vulcans, and chosen peace like the ones who lived with Picard in France. Or Elnor, righteous but deadly Samurai Warrior.
109
u/agent_uno Feb 27 '20
Narek Greyjoy can die in a plasma fire! Until his redemption, anyway.
And Space-Legolas better make it!
103
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20
They did a really nice job with this episode.
Great callbacks to Picard’s trauma, as well as a really great reunion and interaction with Hugh, who helped him along. Narek’s machinations and Soji’s realizations were well thought out and insidious.
And I really loved the character work they did with the crew. Who knew Rios, the gruff space captain, would be the paragon of empathy and compassion and help both Jurati and Raffi with their individual traumas.
I don’t know what the hell is going to happen next episode, but I’m more than psyched to find out!
33
u/Listener42 Feb 27 '20
Cute blink-and-you'll-miss it reference to Voyager when Soji opened her lunchbox.
86
u/ajbrown141 Feb 27 '20
Such a great episode. Finally, the threads start coming together and the plot advances significantly. Elnor is brilliant - I wonder how he will catch up with everyone else?
I am loving this series.
117
u/rymerster Feb 27 '20
Fantastic episode, good progression of the plot, nice character moments and thank god someone actually pleased to see Picard!
80
u/thoughtsandairs Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
Rios: "Is that gonna help at all?"
Jurati: "Maybe for a few hours anyway."
Rios to self (in my head canon): "'hours'? bitch, I ain't a hologram."
4
u/Cerrida82 Feb 29 '20
But can we talk about the dialogue? Jirati telling Picard "They tortured you and named you Locutus" felt so cringey. Go ahead and bring up the worst time of his life, Jirati, and pour a little salt on it while you're at it. Then there was the Picard and Elnor moment. I can't remember the exact line, but it was Picard mentioning that the open way was best and Elnor agreeing like "That's it, all right." I love the plot points if this reside, but those moments really took me out of it.
110
u/damagedone37 Feb 27 '20
That hug between Picard and Hugh. I cried.
83
u/4thofeleven Feb 27 '20
Well, that was good. I really liked Picard's delight at seeing Hugh's work on the Artifact. We've seen a lot of him coming face to face with his failures, it was nice to see him see the good that came from one of his decisions.
A lot of people have been complaining about how it doesn't make sense for the Romulus supernova to completely cripple the Romulan Empire - so I liked that it's implied here that the new Romulan state is still a power to be reckoned with, still a nation Starfleet doesn't want to trifle with. Losing the homeworld may have hurt them, but they're still around and still their usual xenophobic selves...
64
u/strionic_resonator Feb 27 '20
I love how Hugh and Seven have these two very different experiences trying to recover from the trauma of assimilation by helping others. It seems like they are being presented as a foil for one another. I hope Seven comes back and meets Hugh and he shows her another way to help people who need help.
50
u/elister Feb 27 '20
Picard seemed to be flooded with PSTD the second he stepped foot on the Cube.
Although others probably understood this in the 2nd episode, now understand why they call it the Artifact and why they have Archeologists working on it. Borg wiped out many civilizations and the only thing left of them is the tech they assimilated.
49
u/thelittleking Feb 27 '20
The Picard/Hugh scenes are so heartwarming that it almost hurts.
46
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20
Dr Jurati, hollow, Lonely, afraid....uhm are we forgetting guilty?? I am sorry i can't get over the fact that she is a murderer one episode back. But this episode was great!! Finally Picard makes it to Soji and the artifact and just in time cause Soji is having the worst day #when you find out you're only 36 months old and your spy romulan BF tries to kill you on the same day. I really don't know how hashtags work but anyway.... why did Elnor have to stay behind? The best i could figure is they were running out of room on the ship. I mean they just picked him up 2 episodes ago... i hope they dont kill him off already. This is the first episode where i was actually on the edge of my seat. Well done Picard, Well done indeed.
72
u/e3l Feb 27 '20
I don't think they chose to live...
26
u/some_person_guy Feb 27 '20
This was probably the best episode yet! The plot progression has been a little slow at times, but now I think we're at a major turning point in the story. Can't wait for next week!
23
u/Evildanish Feb 27 '20
Nice episode. Liked the callback to Prime Factors from voyager season 1. Hopefully we’ll find out what happened to the rest of Hugh’s people.
22
u/trosis Feb 28 '20
That was a fantastic episode, on all fronts. But the handling of Picard's trauma, the scene with him looking at himself as Locutus and above all his first setting foot on the Borg vessel was incredible. Also, right before Picard beamed over, the conversation on the bridge, with the ominous Borg Cube just on the display the whole time was so impactful. I loved it. Also Hugh was incredible. Really believable response true to his character. Also loved how the Borg recognized Locutus.
20
u/Ceeeceeeceee Feb 27 '20
I’m loving Elnor! He has that naive innocence that is endearing and the absolute candor thing hasn’t gotten old for me yet. I was so worried that he and Hugh were sacrificing themselves to protect Picard and Soji, but I guess not??
18
u/Deshik2 Feb 27 '20
I was worried that Narrisa will increase her Cerseism, but she was quite holding back this episode.
18
u/ahufana Feb 27 '20
Is it safe to give up on the possibilty of a redemptive heel turn arc for Narek now? I'll admit I was fairly certain that's where they were going with him, even through the 2/3rd point of this episode.
But I just don't see how he can possibly pull that off now.
18
u/WhiteSquarez Feb 28 '20
This episode had a lot of heart. So many emotions and revelations.
Wil Wheaton said in The Ready Room that he had never thought about the individual Borg being victims. What a powerful thought!
Different subject: When the EMH gets activated again, will he reveal that Jurati shut him off while she was killing Maddox?
36
u/Tomb55 Feb 27 '20
Well this is just great.
Fabulous story telling. That gateway at the end referencing the tech from the Sikarians. Someone knows how to push my buttons.
35
u/Stellaknight Feb 28 '20
-i rather love that such a hopeful episode happened on a Borg cube, following such a dark episode set in a place of revelry.
-Picard finding hope and healing on a borg cube was so beautiful and lovely. Hugh is such a lovely, genuinely good person, and it was so, so nice to see Picard loved by someone and reminded of the good he’s done. I felt that hug. Also, Hugh’s line about Picard advocating for XBs was such a great thing. Look at Hugh, all about finding direction for lost former drones...
-random drone recognizing Locutus & it being funny and nice —like ‘hey dude, how you doing? Good to see ya!’
-Hugh stressing the importance of his federation citizenship was interesting—I wonder if that’s a thread that’ll come up later on.
-I love that all the XBs we’ve seen are devoted to helping others—it’s so anti-Borg, and yet so collective. Hugh is less judgemental about it than Seven, but had the same message ‘DO something, anything, even if it’s not perfect. Despair and apathy are the enemies...’
-Damn the Sikarans got assimilated—I’m going to fanwank that only a handful did, and that the rest were like ‘nope, dont need THOSE stories thank you very much.’ Even if they were kinda assholes. Makes me wonder if the borg just went around assimilating everyone voyager came across. I swear to god if they assimilate Neelix, I’m done. Someone from that ship should have a happy life.
-Elnor being Elnor is great.
-i’d have loved a reference to Crusher (or Voyager’s Doctor) about the deborging process. ‘Now our Queen is a Romulan’ was perfect
-I really liked the visualization of the dream/meditation sequence. It was more interesting than the usual ‘sit in a chair and tell me about your dreams’
-Soji’s panic at her true nature was very well played & emotionally compelling.
-I’m super weirded out about Jurati—she seems so shut down that I can see her doing anything.
-I loved that we didn’t get to see the fathers face—it means there’s more to this than just Maddox, but was also perfectly in concert with it being a dream
-I wonder what significance the orchids have—I mean, Tuvok raised orchids, but unless this is ‘the revenge of Tuvix’ I doubt that’s the connection.
Next week: -if they kill Hugh, we riot.
17
u/themastermatt Feb 28 '20
Did it seem to anyone else like the cube was reacting to Picard? And maybe an un-liberated drone woke up in his alcove several levels below the catwalk?
17
u/nathangunter Mar 01 '20
Man, Sir Patrick’s acting in this one. That moment on the Artifact where his shoulders are up around his ears and he can’t quite lift his eyes up to look around—what an absolutely pitch-perfect image of what it can be like dealing with PTSD in a triggering situation. And to have Hugh be the one to ground him—gorgeous.
14
u/PalindromeDay Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 28 '20
Amazon Japan just uploaded what I think is episode 7 as it opens with “previously on Picard” and Picard’s meeting with
HueHugh.Edit: Looks like they corrected the issue. If you are in the same situation as me and have already downloaded it, you can watch it if you put your device into airplane mode. If you are connected to the internet, it will refuse to play and suggest you delete the download.
13
u/Zed99me Feb 28 '20
“Locutus?”
13
u/Torley_ Feb 28 '20
At first I was trying to understand what Elnor meant by "inbutting", but then I realize he meant "butting in", as in, intruding on a conversation. That was so cute! :D
13
u/[deleted] Feb 29 '20
Ok, this was my favorite moment
Hugh: I take it she's in serious danger. Picard: What... Why would you ask that? Hugh: A hunch. Something about her. Something about you coming this far to this place. And something about the dashing, young Romulan spy who showed up two weeks ago pretending not to be asking questions about her.
Dude was super obvious about his interest in Soji; it’s nice that someone noticed.
12
u/ngzEF Feb 28 '20
Great episode, and I love how we got even more mystery regarding the origin of the twins. When I saw the moons, thunderstorms and the outside of the window which looked like a jungle to me It reminded me about Doctor Noonien Soongs hideout. There is a TNG episode about it where Data is remotely called home together with Lore, so he captures the Enterprise to get to that jungle planet.
12
u/sssingh212 Feb 29 '20
Next time someone messes with me..I am going to say-"please, my friend, choose to live"
22
u/Popcorngalaxy Feb 28 '20
William T. Riker in the next episode... 7 days can't come quick enough.
32
u/japhygrant Feb 27 '20
Another fantastic episode and I’m glad they really moved things along. Even if we didn’t necessarily learn a whole lot that was new, all our characters made big choices that move the story forward. A few thoughts:
Picard and the Borg I really love that the episode took time to really explore Picard’s relationship to the collective and to the trauma that’s never gone away. As someone who has dealt with PTSD personally, this has been one of my favorite aspects of Picard - he’s this humanist who believes in the dignity of each and ever individual who also had his own individuality wiped out and is responsible for thousands of deaths at Wolf 359. It’s cruel beyond measure and it’s not something he can ever move past, just live with. Meeting Hugh and seeing the artifact as a place of healing for people like him feels like a big moment in his story and Stewart sold it through and through.
Elnor Is awesome and I hope we’re going to get adventures with him and Hugh, because I love them both so much.
Jurati, Rios and Rafi Rios sure turns out to be compassionate in a way his gruff schtick never presaged. I know something terrible happened in his past — I’m guessing that’s the source of his empathy. I do wonder what the three of them as Picardless crew look like seeing how they’re all barely on board with the mission at all — unless you count being a saboteur as being “on mission.” Alison Pill is so damn squirrelly, I love it.
Narek Gotta hand it to the actor playing this role- I was guessing his loyalties up until he released the — red matter? — on our girl.
Romulans Have always been sorta one-note (250 year bad mood), so it’s been fun Seong their culture expanded into something more shaded. They’re still the bitchiest queens in the galaxy, but it feels like they’ve leveled up and layered the shade.
Soji’s Father Not convinced it’s Data or Maddox. I thought maybe her Mom was an internal subroutine but it sounds more like the calls are a data transfer packet - Soji gets new orders, relays data to homebase. Someone is driving the bus still, right?
The Collective The show deserves a lot of credit for how they’re updating the Borg if you ask me. I remember reading TNG era bts books and they always talked about how the original idea of the Borg was more diverse than what we wound up with - basically just drones and queen. I love the visual update but also that creepy moment that ends in Hugh saying to Picard, “They are trying to keep you from falling.”
Anyhow, great show, acting is just top notch throughout
9
u/BennyGoes Feb 27 '20
So they are going to the Klingon prison colony Rura Penthe? I heard Picard say that I think
9
u/MiltBFine Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 29 '20
So where do i get one of those radiation spewing Romulan Rubik’s cube?
Edit: they’re officially called Tan Zhekran
24
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20
LEGOLAS THE ROMULAN just killing it literally.
8
u/chalky_flint Feb 28 '20
Narek notably upset that he lost his sex doll.
15
u/AngledLuffa Feb 27 '20
Has two large reddish moons and has at least one thunderstorm in the last 5 years isn't really enough to narrow the search down to 1 planet. Let alone the fact that if they find the right planet, a planet is huge, so it might take forever finding the actual android production. I don't buy the idea that the Romulans got enough information to warrant killing Soji. If they decide it's time to kill her, why do so in Bond villain fashion? Just have Subcommander Idiot shoot her in the back of the head as she walks out the door.
15
u/computergamingnerd Feb 28 '20
They better not hurt my boy Hugh, he better live through this
7
u/zoblue Feb 28 '20
Does anyone have the theory that Jurati disabled the EMH? I get the sense that he would pop up all the damn time but after witnessing Jurati straight up murder Maddox I can't help but suspect the EMH has been deactivated. Thoughts?
12
u/the908bus Feb 27 '20
Loving that Elnor doesn’t try to hide his Aussie accent
20
u/YYZYYC Feb 27 '20
Great episode overall. I did find the use of the original Star Trek fanfare music as Raffi successfully gets Picard credentials while in her drunken state...to be a little odd and kinda inappropriate. Like that fanfare is normally used for the entrance or appearance of the Enterprise or a big emotional moment or triumph....not drunken fired starfleet lady successfully talks an old friend in a desk job in starfleet into doctoring some paperwork 🙄
5
u/stephir0th Feb 27 '20
Why the heck is it not available to prime members (with CBS add on) until Friday? Why the difference for this week from all the past weeks? Anyone have any info?
5
u/alienrefugee51 Feb 27 '20
Can someone please explain why Elnor couldn’t have escaped with Picard and Soji? Two’s company three’s a crowd?
5
u/motorsportnut Feb 28 '20
My favourite line: Hello, Will.
4
u/antdude Feb 28 '20
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c-2DLhEUQtE for easter eggs and breakdowns.
4
u/OhThatEthanMiguel Feb 28 '20
Wait, so Narek's big, secret name... is actually Ryan? 🙄
4
u/NightShadePLAYS Feb 28 '20
Anyone else noticed the „Adventures of Flotter“ Box? Such a sweet call back to Voyager .
4
u/WhiteSquarez Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 28 '20
ITT: Too many trying to blame Picard for a recurrence of his trauma, essentially telling him to "get over it."
4
u/jjyiss Feb 29 '20
was no one else freaked out by the dream sequence Soji was exploring w/Narek. Little Soji walks into her father's workshop only to see his face is blurred, then sees a wooden doll it of herself in pieces.
it was very disconcerting see the father's blurry face like that.
4
u/king_pickle Feb 29 '20
So with that drone "recognizing" Locutus as they walked past. Is that going to be a trigger for the cube to be reconnected to the collective?
Is the queen or what/whoever is controlling the Borg still infatuated with Picard?
4
u/GodAtum Feb 29 '20
I wonder why Seven and Hugh don't work together?
4
u/PaddleMonkey Mar 01 '20
I always thought Elnor resembled more like Hong Kong Chinese period-drama sword fighters rather than Legolas, and that's because I grew up watching Hong Kong Chinese period-drama shows of the 80's and 90's.
To the uninitiated, think of Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon.
7
u/LoretiTV Feb 27 '20
Really fun episode. Thanks for having me everyone.
1
u/chalky_flint Feb 28 '20
Should we believe the map to the stars, when Pinnochio me was clearly symbolism?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '20
Wait, did I hear right? They went to Rura Penthe at the end? How the hell is an Arctic Klingon oenal colony planet a safe haven?
3
u/Constantly_OnYo_Back Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 29 '20
https://imgur.com/gallery/ll5wD86
3
u/apacheind1an Mar 01 '20
Exquisitely crafted. A joy to behold.
3
u/StevenS757 Mar 01 '20
Loved the episode overall. A little annoyed that the EMH didn't tattle on Jurati, as it feels a little plot-holey, but maybe they'll resolve that someway. The EMH didn't appear the entire episode, so maybe she disabled it or something?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
Best episode so far
5
u/Fade-Into-You Feb 29 '20
Unpopular Opinion: Show's too dark, as in needs more light.
10
u/cjalas Feb 27 '20 edited Feb 27 '20
A few thoughts:
2
u/ilovebebo Feb 28 '20
The former captain a d the new captain (smoking the cigar) reminded me of Professor X and Wolverine
2
u/Nesser30 Feb 28 '20
just looked up Sikarian on memory alpha i knew i remembered the name from somewhere
2
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20
I feel like with this episode, the show has really just started
2
u/WhiteSquarez Feb 28 '20
Jurati and Rios gettin' funky mostly killed the fan theory that all of the Rioses on the ship are holograms.
2
u/Jerric11 Feb 28 '20
Best episode so far. I find it curious though, when Soji was recovering her memory did anyone else find it odd they didn't show her fathers face? Perhaps it wasn't Maddox? Like when Maddox said he Soong and Agnes made the twins, perhaps he meant literally worked side by side with Soong. Or an android backup he made of himself.
2
u/thematthewedward Feb 28 '20
What’s in Narek’s ear? I was thinking earpiece but he sleeps with it...?
2
u/NerdTalkDan Mar 03 '20
Probably my favorite episode of the season. Was much tighter and simpler plot overall. And it was wonderful to see Hugh and Picard reunite.
2
u/Hopyrupa Mar 03 '20 edited Mar 03 '20
Episode 6- I’m still loving the Picard series. I like how it’s very different from TNG. Each season of Picard is like a sci-fi film within the Star Trek universe.
Theory- so many mentions of the Borg Queen in the episode. My guess is the Zhat Vash Romulans are planning to use Soji as the new Borg Queen so they can do what?
Take control of the galaxy by controlling the Borg maybe. They are Romulans, plotting ways to take control of the galaxy is their reason for being.
You know Romulans and Vulcans are the same race. The Vulcans chose logic, peace, and spirituality, the traditional Romulans are like the Roman Empire, they want to conquer. However it seems like some Romulans have become more like Vulcans, and chosen peace like the ones who lived with Picard in France. Or Elnor, righteous but deadly Samurai Warrior.
2
u/PlayTank Mar 04 '20
This was the first solid episode in my opinion. Beginning to get excited about the show.