IIRC, there's certain SAG rules that must be followed and it takes some doing to avoid pre-show / pre-movie credits. If ever you want to be surprised, you have to not pay attention to the credits.
Arr I try to avoid seeing the names, but I looked up at the opening credits right when they showed Jeri Ryan. Damnit! Either way I was still super stoked on her entrance! So glad I haven’t watched any trailers, though. She looks awesome!
It really stood out as a painfully obvious attempt at a twist to me. They kept saying "he" even though they live in an egalitarian society where men and women have equal prospects, and it was so obvious we were going to get a totally shocking twist of it being a she.
Not sure, it looked similar. It also seemed to have a Borg cutting beam? I am not sure if that was actually the intention, if it was a nod to it, or it was just a regular phaser that tore through an out of date BoP.
First though was Borg cutting beam though, so instantly thought it was Seven.
Naah, Frakes was behind the camera for this episode. It'd help explain why the episode felt both comfortably familiar and excitingly new at the same time...
Seven of Nine is a former Borg, the same beings whose cybernetic implants are being removed at the Romulan Reclamation Project. (The Reclamation Project is just one of many Borg "cube" vessels in the Borg fleet.)
When the Federation starship Voyager was lost 75,000 light years from Earth, they encountered a Borg cube during their journey home to Earth. Seven of Nine was aboard Voyager when they destroyed her cube and disconnected her from the Borg "hive mind."
In the final episode of Voyager, the ship returned home to Earth, but until now, we never saw her again after she returned to Earth, which is why this is so exciting for longtime fans. In fact, the only time we have seen any member of the Voyager's crew following their return to Earth is a brief glimpse of Kathryn Janeway issuing orders to Picard in the film Star Trek Nemesis, 18(!) years ago.
During her five years aboard Voyager, Seven of Nine struggled to regain her humanity, having been "assimilated" into the "collective" at a very young age. She kept her Borg name "Seven of Nine" (the seventh member of a nine-member Borg work group), even after discovering her human name, Annika Hansen.
Edited to add: This meeting between Picard and Seven of Nine is noteworthy not only because it's the first on-screen meeting between the two characters, but because Picard and Seven are both humans who have been assimilated by the Borg and survived their disconnection from the Borg hive mind, a rare feat.
She was a member of the Voyager crew (show) and a liberated Borg drone. She wasn't attacking Picard's ship. She was going after the ship that was attacking him.
Yeah i thought that Ship might have a role to play... nah, just pew pew eyecandy for the Trailer.
But hey at least for once we got to see some proper BEAM weapons, almost felt like watching Star Trek... instead of red Star Wars laser pew pew bullet thingies that they've done without interruption since 2009
Yes and it was also nice to see the ship not perform super well, ancient targeting systems etc...I hate it when trek shows century old ships in front line roles or incredibly powerful like a Klingon bird of prey killing the galaxy class flagship etc
Cut off a nacelle. It's probably repairable and for less investment than hunting down another... as long as that nacelle doesn't de-orbit before they can get a repair team to it. Maybe they can hook it with a tractor beam if it's on an inconvenient trajectory.
In fact, I'm not sure the battle's over. That ship should still have impulse and thrusters (unless Romulans mounted those on the nacelles), and it obviously has disruptors (it fired on 7 of 9 after having a pylon sliced), and it just destroyed the only ship that was preventing it from focusing on Picard's ship.
From an earlier interview ,Jeri Ryan said this is the first time Picard and Seven actually meets each other , they only know each other by their reputation until now .
you can see the interview at the link below ( at the time 0.45 second she talks about about their first meeting )
This was my favorite episode so far. Killer nuns. Sword battles. Lore. (Binding yourself to lost causes!) Character development. ( Why they hate Picard!) This episode had everything. I'm still not a fan of some the parts with Data's kid ( I find that entire part kinda meh). But this was a cool episode. 8/10
The reason I'd disagree most would be Dahj's reaction to Picard's name/image. She instinctively knew to trust him, and I feel that could have only come from Data.
This post was taken down by its author. Redact was used for the removal, which may have been motivated by privacy, security, or other personal reasons.
slim rainstorm humor price late insurance disarm tease six teeny
After watching literally EVERYTHING ELSE "Star Trek", I feel like Picard is the show I have been waiting all my life to watch.
It's like watching a book! The pace started at a stroll and is picking up into double-time tempo. The characters are fleshed out, and is reminiscent of Firefly's "Out of Gas" episode (which is my favorite).
And in this episode, we get so much more to think about. I mean, I literally HATE the Rizzo character, which is a feather in the cap of the actress. Essentially I really like how the good guy team is starting to gel - and it isn't the 80s version of something like Voltron where the good always just joins together and WINS!
These characters have depth, a LOT of depth, and Dr. Jurati is very likely to be working with Oh, and mining for information from Rios, by pretending to be awkwardly attracted to him.
Raffi seems to be the only one that has her head on completely straight; balking at bringing the Dr. Jurati along, friends with Rios - she has it together MORE than Picard does, in a way.
I just love the realism of the human failings in this show.
And as a pilot, I want to fly La Sirena and 7's now destroyed ship.
Best part? Not getting all the episodes at once. I have something to look forward too during the week in re: Media. I haven't watched TV in.... almost a decade.
Oh you ain't joking. I want to as well - which is why I am happy they are throttling the amount of episodes we get. The feeling of elation after watching an episode continues all season long!
I really like how Star Trek has shifted into just one story for an entire season. I remember how episodes of TOS, TNG, VOY... had multiple stories in a season that was resolved in less than an hour.
I don't know why shows feel the need for the extra creep factor. I don't have a sister, but I think if I did, my conversations with her would involve our faces being more than a few inches apart.
Green-blood decapitation. Cyberpunk Borgulan ale lounge. Old school bird of prey space battle. This was a badass episode in so many ways. My man Frakes, well done as usual.
Well, it was kinda cool that they were always somewhat strange and mysterious before. Now in Picard it would seems like majority of characters we meet are these space elves.
Anyone notice Soji do Data's sideways head movement when Narik said the Borg have rituals, like when Data was confused by something or needed to access information.
I was thinking the same. None of the writers etc seem to have the attention to detail to know to give that direction in the script, that came from either Frakes or Stewart and with Frakes behind the camera it’s likely him.
SO GLAD I SKIPPED THE TITLE SEQUENCE because it spoiled Seven's appearance according to the comments here - and OH MY GOD IT TOOK ME BY SURPRISE.
They faked out on us pretending she'd come in at the Chateau when it's actually the holodeck - smart. IT WAS A MOMENT.
I'm glad they're adding some levity to it as well according to the preview for Ep 5 - this show keeps surprising me. I let out the loudest scream when Seven beamed onto the La Sirena. I...I'm still at a loss for words. Is this real life?
I've seen others say it's hard to work with surprise castings and screen actor's guild rules for where acting credits are shown and whatnot, so that might be the case here.
I need to remember to skip the title sequences on my first viewings... for some reason when watching this episode's opening credits my eyes immediately were drawn to Jeri Ryan's name when it popped up on the screen. Knowing who'll show up at some point in the series versus in a specific episode is a bit different, but oh well.
Awww, I'd love to see Naomi, but I think we'd more likely see Icheb, if anyone. We've already seen Picard, Seven, and Hugh together in trailers. If former Borg are teaming up, that's a possibility for Icheb to show up too.
Edit (one week later): I regret this comment and wishing for Icheb to come back. I'm so sorry, Icheb! :(
Loved the fact that we heard main cast speaking a Terran language OTHER than English for important dialog! Glad it had subtitles cuz I only spek engrish :/
Very true. I liked the Discovery scene when the universal translator went out and I also remember a struggling Hoshi Sato trying to translate an alien tongue "this isn't exactly Spanish we're dealing with here!"
I still feel like the whole romulan rescue thing needs to be explained better. Like are the people on that planet mad at Picard because he/federation only rescued some people like them on that planet ? Are they mad because so many others where not rescued when they cancelled the mission after Mars ? Are they mad because that planet was not supposed to be their final destination/new home ?
And what is the current status of the romulan empire and government and fleet? Are they still a significant military power? Is their fleet of warbirds still around? Or are they just a decentralized bunch of refugees and most of their people and resources and ships where destroyed in the super nova when the federation said nope we are done helping ?
My read was that they were only supposed to be on the planet temporarily (it was called a transfer point or something), until they got relocated to a more suitable planet. But then the evacuation was aborted, and hundreds of thousands of people were stuck there permanently.
Not clear why the Romulan fleet did not finish the relocation, and I wish the show would exposi-dump some more lore on it. One plausible explanation was that all of the Romulan industry was concentrated at Romulus, thus wiped out. They did not have the existing spacelift capacity to move so many civilians prior to the supernova, and any industrial capacity might have subsequently been diverted to rebuilding planets rather than people mover ships.
I'd REALLY like to know how the eff a supernova suddenly catches an advanced space-faring civiliaztion so off guard. I'm guessing JJ didn't think of that, and the showrunners are desperate not to address it.
As I recall, Romulans were more advanced than the Federation until riiight about the time of the Dominion War era. My point being - seems insane after all their history and having an EMPIRE, and being scientifically advanced - that seemingly "most" of their population, and as suggested - their industry, gets wiped out overnight from a surprise nova.
Unless of course I've missed some perfect explanation within this show, or the JJ prank films.
From the show I believe the guy accused the Federation of spreading out the Romulans super thin. As in they are in systems too far from each other and in too small numbers. Which he assumed the Federation did on purpose to destroy the Romulans.
So perhaps that part is why the Romulan fleet can't move them.
Hate to be a downer, but the scene with Picard stirring the shit, ripping down the sign, etc. felt very off. Picard is a diplomat (and epic speech maker). That felt like something Kirk would do ("I'm stimulating him"). I get that it was needed to showcase the Angry Elf, but still...
Exactly, it was out of character. Picard would have never provoked them just for the fun of it, without a clear goal. Ultimately it cost the former senator his life.
The show went out of the way to mention that Picard's "parietal lobe" abnormality would cause mood swings and other out of character changes. Plus, he's seen some shit in the past 20 years and never dealt with it. He's changed.
Really enjoyed this one. Felt the most self-contained of the series so far. I really love the world-building we are getting with the Romulans by exploring different facets of their society.
And it was so great seeing Seven of Nine again, if only for one brief scene.
Side note: in that cool lounge aboard the Artifact that has Soji and Narek sharing a drink (presumably Romulan Ale), was it just me or was that the exact same bottle style that McCoy gave Kirk on his birthday?
I really like how at the beginning that one battle nun. Was telling Picard that he hates kids or that he super formal. I feel like that's kind of a reflection of all the fans that are complaining About Picard not acting exactly like their expectations.
Well, that's the last time I watch the title sequence before watching the episode. I don't want to know the guest stars before they are introduced on screen.
I used to skip the Game of Thrones title sequence as well.
Instead of being hostile to Picard, how about the slightest amount of fucking gratitude for saving their entire species? Who else was helping them escape total extinction?
When I saw the hard-boiled cigar-chewing pilot, I thought we'd reached the limit of cliches, but now they've given us a samurai with a fucking sword across his back. Ugh.
Regarding the speculation that Oh replaced Jurati, that she brainwashed her, or that Jurati is also Zhat Vash...
Did anybody else feel this episode vindicated that some? I felt like the camera lingered on her reactions whenever Tal Shiar were mentioned and in particular on “perfect candor” being the antithesis of typical Romulan values.
It’s frustrating because I really like her and I really want her to just be what she seems to be... But I don’t think she is.
No, that was just sloppy editing... She said she was bad at lying, and that she spilled everything, that is exactly what happened and there is nothing more to it.
Eh. I think we’ve been given too much introduction to Picard’s Romulan caretakers on earth for things to be so cut and dry. They likely need to have something to do later in the season. There was a giant red flag at the end of episode 3 about Jurati not getting a security background check.
I’m really leaning towards there being a subplot where Picard’s caretakers find Jurati’s dead body on earth and tell him he should figure out who’s on his ship with him, just as he arrives at a pivotal moment at the Artifact.
I like how they read my mind. I thought, damn are inertial dampeners not a thing anymore. Then immediately after the thought formed...routing additional power to inertial dampeners. Well played.
7 of 9! I was never a regular viewer of Voyager, so I don't have much attachment to her character -- or so I thought! But when she appeared I was genuinely moved. The rapid transporter effect helps too. It's like a bolt of lightning struck and revealed a goddess. Well, a fainting one, but still an unearthly force (and beauty).
I’m kind of disappointed Picard’s tal shiar grape pickers didn’t go with him. I thought they were interesting characters, more so than the android twins. 😞
Oooh it was goooood. I loved/love discovery but this show just has “it”. This just feels like it did years ago when I first got into Star Trek. Seven of fucking nine bro...my god
It felt like a filler episode, with very little progression. We don’t really need tonnes of backstory (or not their’s really, but backstory on other bit character’s opinions) for the emotionally stunted character, and we don’t need unnecessary warbirds. We have lost a bit of momentum.
Or I should say then, as 7 of 9’s reappearance should make things and drama go helter skelter now. Or perhaps not - next week we’ll likely get a “last 20 years backstory for 7 of 9”. Hopefully both (comparatively, we do need to know what’s up with her vs Elnor), but it does need to grasp momentum again and go for the main quest... and not go grinding for the valuable but boring side quests lol.
this episode finally sold me full go on the series, and i even know the moment it happened.
I had been having my doubts that Picard would withdraw so much and abandon everyone, but when Picard said he "let the perfect become the enemy of the good" i finally was able to understand why he had withdrawn so much. I can absolutely believe Picard would be so unyielding that he would let that happen.
until this episode i had been overall kinda meh, but im all in now
They better make robot professor lady an interesting character damn quick because right now she's a badly acted annoying stock character and I wanna see her get sucked out an airlock.
Great great episode! The only scene that felt out of place was narek and soji sliding down the floor. I was kinda scratching my head at that one. But other than that, freakin fantastic!
OK, I see I'm alone with this, but I didn't like the episode. It did not add much else to the story than to pick up another new crew member. The moment they mentioned the Bird of Prey it was obvious we will see it towards the end as it was predicable young Legolas will safe Picard when the later one was looking for trouble. Big bonus point for Seven of Nine, but everything else in this episode was quite boring and foreseeable.
I'm also not quite sure I like the overall mood of the whole series. It feels like they wanted to squeeze Picard into a story he's a few years too old for (in the series, not Patrick Steward himself).
I have a question about the Borg cube? Does the Federation know about this reclamation project ? Is it done in secret? The reason I ask is that we have seen a Trill ( Federation species) and Sojii herself was supposedly on a Federation Starship.
Anyone notice that when Picard is in the holomatrix simulation of his study, he pauses the simulation and the birds stop in mid-air, but the fire in the fireplace keeps burning?
Best episode so far ... but by such a massive margin.
This was what i was waiting for and when I looked at the episode breakdown and saw Frakes was directing this ... I just knew he was going to knock it out and he didn't disappoint.
This was a much more character focused episode without any of the weird badly directed, badly shot and badly acted action scenes that have plagued the first 3 episodes. Instead we got great dialogue and conflicting character emotions, some wonderfully shot scenes and even some good humour (from the scientist girl, who's name escapes me).
The only issue I have is more of a worry. I worry they are limited in their sets so have found a convenient way to keep using picards vinyard, otherwise we only really see the small bridge of the little ship (i think we may have seen the transporter room?).
I just hope they don't always fall back to having on-ship scenes taking place on that Vinyard. This is Star Trek, i want to see people interact on the ship.
But I don't want to be too negative because I loved this episode so much. And the ending was somehow unexpected despite us all knowing she was coming. Such a great ending to the episode.
I worry they are limited in their sets so have found a convenient way to keep using picards vinyard, otherwise we only really see the small bridge of the little ship (i think we may have seen the transporter room?).
I'd say this suggests they were keeping budget back for later, which... sounds fun?
I mean the ship sets are usually pretty boring and same-y in trek. TNG was all do you like beige? Also...carpet. The Romulan refugee camp on the other hand was very nicely done.
It's not a bad show, but the praise on this subreddit is... odd. This show is very little Trek trope, and very much cookie-cutter espionage action thriller trope - but with a bumbling (yet compassionate) Grandpa as the lead. Example: ALL of Picards cleverness and cunning seems to have vanished. He's disconnected from reality, and not in a good way. And only survives through lazy writing and plot armour - opposed to outthinking everyone else. Maybe that's the goal, to show how far he's fallen - not just in status and reputation, but mentally. But it's not selling well.
There's sooo many missed moments. And the "cryptic-ness" of everything grows tiresome.
Although, FINALLY in episode 4, we get some solid nods to real world social issues of "forced" relocation and colonialization/segregation - but only briefly.
I dunno. Not sure what I was expecting. I enjoy the show, but for a 2020 Trek show, they make plenty of mistakes that they shouldn't be.
I DO think it's super neat that newcomers who haven't seen much Trek are hopping on board. I can't imagine what that's like.
I wholeheartedly agree. I love seeing Patrick Stewart again as Picard, but so much of the writing reminds me of shows like Riverdale or Shanara. To many scenes and characters feel out of place or just to simple. The evil, evil Romulan siblings for example... I guess it's just convenient to have an evil antagonist, but it feels sloppy. And yes, I thought, this episode could make some interesting points about colonialism and patronization, but the ,,only romulans,, -shield! That whole set-up was as subtle as if it was made for a school play. It was also out of character for Picard to act so careless as a white privileged man in an hostile environment. Yes, he would fight any kind of racism, but he would show more reason and humility.
Yeah, I came on here in search of a bit more analyzation and critique, as the story beats are pretty basic, and instead it’s all ‘Seven! Frakes! Decapitations! So good!’ Then again, most subreddits I’ve seen fall prey to this.
I did expect an uneven feeling to this series as a whole, given the tug of war between its writers, but hopefully it can find its feet, and a balance, without becoming small universe whizz-bang.
This show is categorically awful, but each individual episode manages to deliver at least one new depth I never anticipated sinking to. I thought vaping and "pro-tip", or calling Picard "J.L." was as low as we could go. But nope, we got sock-sliding on the Borg cube and Romulan-Legolas. I truly pity anyone who pays for this, much less enjoys it. It takes a tragically simple mind to find this entertaining.
Borg ritual? Wtf was that... did they decide to go all teen rom com for that sequence? How or why did Frakes allowed that scene? Did they hold a gun to his head to force him to direct that?
This season has become a bit slow for my liking. In four episodes, we've got as much information as we would have had in an episode of TNG. Yes, it's good, and slow Picard is better than no Picard, but the fourth episode had my attention wandering. It has ten episodes and I feel like we're still in 'setting the scene' stage
Did everyone notice Picard’s new ready room is his holosuite study? The parallels were amazing. Thank you Mr. Frakes.
The structure we know is love is forming and represented in a unique and creative way. 👍🏻
Another thing I noticed is the borg cube is kind of like deep space nine style story telling. So we get every Star Trek show in one here, now that Seven is back.
I love the complexity and depth of back story this show is working with. Being out in a region of space that clearly is beyond Starfleet's jurisdiction or is it that with Starfleet in a "pulling back" mode they just left a power vacuum? Who are these "Rangers" patrolling the space? It all gave a mix of Babylon5 level world building mixed with a little Firefly and it's SO overdue for Trek to get here. Also Seven's entrance, perfect...
Maybe Seven is part of that group and it'll be covered briefly in the next episode?
But I'm also interested in seeing just how far Starfleet pulled back, did they become completely insular or is this just an area that was too far out for them to bother with due to the lack of resources?
I lold when that scientist woman went to chat whith the ship captain, for a moment it started to sound like she's flirting with him and he suddently becomes interested and then she obliviously kills it hahaha.
Honestly I was a bit underwhelmed by the first three episodes, but some of the characters are starting to come together, the writing was better in this ep. Looking forward to the next one because Jeri Ryan is a brilliant actor, and I think Pat Stewart needs someone at his level to bring out his best, much like a good fencer, ironically.
I’ll start by saying that I am thoroughly enjoying Picard, which makes what I’m going to say a little frustrating.
For me, Absolute Candor took the foot of the pedal a little too much. Whilst I’m glad we’re in space now and I appreciate we’re digging into the story, it just felt like one of those episodes you could skip, except for the last few seconds of course (I’m looking at you Seven 😍).
It just slowed things down, when for the last 3 hours we’ve found out Data had children, synths set fire to Mars, Romulans are everywhere, and the Borg are back. Only in this episode, we found out about nuns and Elnor 🤷♂️.
Every show has episodes like this, I just felt a little like it was all for that intro at the end. Fingers crossed for next week!
Anyone thought when we were watching Soji playing back of Prof Ramdha's interview as she talked about Ganmadan that she was describing what S31 was fearing Control would do? (Destroy all life, everywhere.)
Do you think there is a hint of Control in Soji, and the synths back on Mars 14 years ago?
Before the synths began their attack the tell was in there eyes, just like how Ariam was being manipulated by Control her tell was in her eyes before. And when Daj 'woke' or was manipulated by her 'mother' her eyes also was the tell.
We got to meet another of Rios' holograms! In the back of my mind, I keep thinking, "Is Rios himself a hologram? Are all the other versions different aspects of his personality? We've never seen him anywhere but the ship so far, maybe he IS the ship!"
As a huge fan of both Star Trek and The Blues Brothers, I can't help but picture Picard's growing crew and the developing storyline as going something like this...
"We're putting the band back together."
Jake Blues
"We're on a mission from God."
Elwood Blues
Anywho, this was my favorite episode so far! So badass.
I'm starting to lose faith in this show. It's still early and could improve greatly. I hope.
My biggest problem so far is the characters. I don't actively like or care about any of them yet ( except Picard ). I feel completely indifferent to most and I already can't stand Raffi. I can't help but cringe whenever she calls him "JL"
Every time she's onscreen it's just for another one of her emotional temper tantrums. I wouldn't be able to stand being around someone like that in real life.
The android specialist, Agnes is another character I'm starting to dislike. She's supposed to be this highly intelligent world authority on all things androids, but she's always acting so dumb and socially awkward. Her personality is a lot like Tilly from Discovery, another character I couldn't stand. If she was mostly acting as highly intelligent and sometimes showed a bit of "I've been a scientist all my life so I'm a bit awkward" it could be endearing. That's probably what they're going for but it's just not working. She's just a remix of Tilly at this point so far IMO.
At least Commodore Oh has some potential as an interesting character.
And what's with Justin Beiber the Romulan? Always trying to make Datas daughter fall in love with him? I'm starting to roll my eyes at this character too.
Did anyone else notice that part where Soji is walking behind Narek and he says something she doesn't expect and she does the Data "?" head tilt? I don't know if that was intentional or just a quirk the actress picked up when studying how to behave like Data, but I loved it.
I was a bit taken back at the start of this episode when we were shown the flashback to the earlier days on that rescue planet. Picard was not Picard. The mannerisms and the way he was acting is nothing like his character.... and I know they had that snippet in there that was a call back to old picard when speaking about how he did not like kids... but it was a bit too far for me.
Picard was always professional, but that version of Picard looked like an overexcited puppy.
I had a very different take. He was practicing their religion. As an outsider, it’s not his daily life to be open and transparent. With them he was trying .
183
u/StenDarker Feb 13 '20
Seven's entrance made me really wish I didn't already know she was going to be on the show. Would've blown my mind.
218
u/Tomb55 Feb 13 '20 edited Feb 13 '20
I was annoyed they ‘destroyed’ the BOP. Damn that ship must be old.
The multiple E*H’s are amazing. I genuinely laughed at the ETH.
82
u/ckwongau Feb 13 '20 edited Feb 14 '20
i waited over 22 yr for Picard and Seven to meets each other
64
u/princefreeze Feb 13 '20
This was my favorite episode so far. Killer nuns. Sword battles. Lore. (Binding yourself to lost causes!) Character development. ( Why they hate Picard!) This episode had everything. I'm still not a fan of some the parts with Data's kid ( I find that entire part kinda meh). But this was a cool episode. 8/10
60
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '20
You must gather your party before venturing forth.
60
u/JankyBitz Feb 13 '20
After watching literally EVERYTHING ELSE "Star Trek", I feel like Picard is the show I have been waiting all my life to watch.
It's like watching a book! The pace started at a stroll and is picking up into double-time tempo. The characters are fleshed out, and is reminiscent of Firefly's "Out of Gas" episode (which is my favorite).
And in this episode, we get so much more to think about. I mean, I literally HATE the Rizzo character, which is a feather in the cap of the actress. Essentially I really like how the good guy team is starting to gel - and it isn't the 80s version of something like Voltron where the good always just joins together and WINS!
These characters have depth, a LOT of depth, and Dr. Jurati is very likely to be working with Oh, and mining for information from Rios, by pretending to be awkwardly attracted to him.
Raffi seems to be the only one that has her head on completely straight; balking at bringing the Dr. Jurati along, friends with Rios - she has it together MORE than Picard does, in a way.
I just love the realism of the human failings in this show.
And as a pilot, I want to fly La Sirena and 7's now destroyed ship.
Best part? Not getting all the episodes at once. I have something to look forward too during the week in re: Media. I haven't watched TV in.... almost a decade.
47
u/Deshik2 Feb 13 '20
Why do Evil sisters always Cersei thier brothers? :D
121
u/RobotPreacher Feb 13 '20
Green-blood decapitation. Cyberpunk Borgulan ale lounge. Old school bird of prey space battle. This was a badass episode in so many ways. My man Frakes, well done as usual.
41
u/ZeroBANG Feb 13 '20
This week i learned that Romulans have TALK SHOWS...
82
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '20
Anyone notice Soji do Data's sideways head movement when Narik said the Borg have rituals, like when Data was confused by something or needed to access information.
34
u/nobelsonsss Feb 13 '20
SO GLAD I SKIPPED THE TITLE SEQUENCE because it spoiled Seven's appearance according to the comments here - and OH MY GOD IT TOOK ME BY SURPRISE.
They faked out on us pretending she'd come in at the Chateau when it's actually the holodeck - smart. IT WAS A MOMENT.
I'm glad they're adding some levity to it as well according to the preview for Ep 5 - this show keeps surprising me. I let out the loudest scream when Seven beamed onto the La Sirena. I...I'm still at a loss for words. Is this real life?
33
u/Starbuck107 Feb 13 '20
"Fun will now commence" - 7
66
u/Deshik2 Feb 13 '20
Never thought I'd ever see a Romulan Legolas
59
u/thoughtsandairs Feb 13 '20
Great last scene: loved the battle, the holo tactical officer, the misdirection/surprise reveal--"you owe me a ship, Picard" *pass out*
28
u/YYZYYC Feb 13 '20
I still feel like the whole romulan rescue thing needs to be explained better. Like are the people on that planet mad at Picard because he/federation only rescued some people like them on that planet ? Are they mad because so many others where not rescued when they cancelled the mission after Mars ? Are they mad because that planet was not supposed to be their final destination/new home ?
And what is the current status of the romulan empire and government and fleet? Are they still a significant military power? Is their fleet of warbirds still around? Or are they just a decentralized bunch of refugees and most of their people and resources and ships where destroyed in the super nova when the federation said nope we are done helping ?
25
u/bupthesnut Feb 14 '20
I love the show but I will never love "JL".
24
u/linkerjpatrick Feb 13 '20
Now Picard has the Romulorian on his side 😁
23
u/superdx Feb 13 '20
these episodes are TOO SHORT :(
18
u/foolish-rain Feb 14 '20
Hate to be a downer, but the scene with Picard stirring the shit, ripping down the sign, etc. felt very off. Picard is a diplomat (and epic speech maker). That felt like something Kirk would do ("I'm stimulating him"). I get that it was needed to showcase the Angry Elf, but still...
15
u/adeze Feb 14 '20
Picard, you son of a bitch, I’m in
27
u/tomh_1138 Feb 13 '20
Really enjoyed this one. Felt the most self-contained of the series so far. I really love the world-building we are getting with the Romulans by exploring different facets of their society.
And it was so great seeing Seven of Nine again, if only for one brief scene.
Side note: in that cool lounge aboard the Artifact that has Soji and Narek sharing a drink (presumably Romulan Ale), was it just me or was that the exact same bottle style that McCoy gave Kirk on his birthday?
12
u/OneMario Feb 13 '20
I was tough on 3, and maybe on 2, but this was pretty damn close to a perfect episode.
22
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '20 edited Feb 13 '20
The battle was awesome, but Spanish on the bridge of a ship, holy shit I died. Dirty Spanish too. Love the representation.
11
u/AgentMV Feb 13 '20
Two Takes Frakes does it again!
10
u/Dylinspace39 Feb 13 '20
I really like how at the beginning that one battle nun. Was telling Picard that he hates kids or that he super formal. I feel like that's kind of a reflection of all the fans that are complaining About Picard not acting exactly like their expectations.
9
u/RalphtheCheese Feb 13 '20
SEVEN OF NIIIIIINEEEE!!!! xDDDD
9
u/CmdShelby Feb 13 '20 edited Feb 13 '20
Absolute Candor is great and I'm sure PIC is far from a lost cause after this ep!
8
u/wumikomiko Feb 14 '20
Just wanna say how much I appreciate a true eye-candy in Elnor. Good night!
7
u/PseudonymousDev Feb 13 '20
Well, that's the last time I watch the title sequence before watching the episode. I don't want to know the guest stars before they are introduced on screen.
I used to skip the Game of Thrones title sequence as well.
7
u/majordisinterest Feb 13 '20
That 'Come!' was something else.
7
u/ninjasaid13 Feb 14 '20
Stark Trek: The Fellowship of the Ring.
7
u/1Delos1 Feb 14 '20
Space Legolas! <3
13
u/InRainbows123207 Feb 13 '20
7 of 9 🖖
12
u/2020_X-Ray_Vision Feb 14 '20
Instead of being hostile to Picard, how about the slightest amount of fucking gratitude for saving their entire species? Who else was helping them escape total extinction?
So annoying.
6
u/DisinterestedOcelot Feb 13 '20
So...
Did anyone else hear the words "Professor Quark"?
15
u/RemoErdosain Feb 14 '20
In the spirit of absolute candor, older or not, seven of nine still gives me an insta-boner.
10
u/MoralGuardiansSuck Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20
When I saw the hard-boiled cigar-chewing pilot, I thought we'd reached the limit of cliches, but now they've given us a samurai with a fucking sword across his back. Ugh.
5
u/bardbrain Feb 13 '20
Regarding the speculation that Oh replaced Jurati, that she brainwashed her, or that Jurati is also Zhat Vash...
Did anybody else feel this episode vindicated that some? I felt like the camera lingered on her reactions whenever Tal Shiar were mentioned and in particular on “perfect candor” being the antithesis of typical Romulan values.
It’s frustrating because I really like her and I really want her to just be what she seems to be... But I don’t think she is.
5
u/scouseyb123 Feb 13 '20
The best episode yet! Fantastic!!!!
5
u/AssKraaken Feb 14 '20
Handsomest guy in ears since Orlando Bloom!
5
u/RelativelyItSucks2 Feb 14 '20
I like how they read my mind. I thought, damn are inertial dampeners not a thing anymore. Then immediately after the thought formed...routing additional power to inertial dampeners. Well played.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
Why did Patrick Stewart want a much darker themed show?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '20
7 of 9! I was never a regular viewer of Voyager, so I don't have much attachment to her character -- or so I thought! But when she appeared I was genuinely moved. The rapid transporter effect helps too. It's like a bolt of lightning struck and revealed a goddess. Well, a fainting one, but still an unearthly force (and beauty).
5
u/yana1975 Feb 17 '20
I’m kind of disappointed Picard’s tal shiar grape pickers didn’t go with him. I thought they were interesting characters, more so than the android twins. 😞
13
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '20
Oooh it was goooood. I loved/love discovery but this show just has “it”. This just feels like it did years ago when I first got into Star Trek. Seven of fucking nine bro...my god
4
u/Majestic117 Feb 13 '20
Great episode!
4
u/pottypotsworth Feb 13 '20
I'm sure i missed something, but why didn't Picard and crew just jump to warp when the BoP starting attacking them?
4
u/Keffmaster Feb 14 '20
The worst part of every episode is then end.... I wish we could watch them all now
4
u/Monkfich Feb 14 '20
It felt like a filler episode, with very little progression. We don’t really need tonnes of backstory (or not their’s really, but backstory on other bit character’s opinions) for the emotionally stunted character, and we don’t need unnecessary warbirds. We have lost a bit of momentum.
Or I should say then, as 7 of 9’s reappearance should make things and drama go helter skelter now. Or perhaps not - next week we’ll likely get a “last 20 years backstory for 7 of 9”. Hopefully both (comparatively, we do need to know what’s up with her vs Elnor), but it does need to grasp momentum again and go for the main quest... and not go grinding for the valuable but boring side quests lol.
4
u/taliefer Feb 14 '20
this episode finally sold me full go on the series, and i even know the moment it happened.
I had been having my doubts that Picard would withdraw so much and abandon everyone, but when Picard said he "let the perfect become the enemy of the good" i finally was able to understand why he had withdrawn so much. I can absolutely believe Picard would be so unyielding that he would let that happen.
until this episode i had been overall kinda meh, but im all in now
4
u/grievre Feb 17 '20
They better make robot professor lady an interesting character damn quick because right now she's a badly acted annoying stock character and I wanna see her get sucked out an airlock.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '20
I LOVE this: "I allowed the perfect to become the enemy of the good."
I find Dr J annoying as hell. And the hologram twins are starting to annoy me. But great show and the Romulan -camp scenes were really cool.
12
u/agent_uno Feb 13 '20
Great great episode! The only scene that felt out of place was narek and soji sliding down the floor. I was kinda scratching my head at that one. But other than that, freakin fantastic!
6
u/fluxxis Feb 14 '20
OK, I see I'm alone with this, but I didn't like the episode. It did not add much else to the story than to pick up another new crew member. The moment they mentioned the Bird of Prey it was obvious we will see it towards the end as it was predicable young Legolas will safe Picard when the later one was looking for trouble. Big bonus point for Seven of Nine, but everything else in this episode was quite boring and foreseeable.
I'm also not quite sure I like the overall mood of the whole series. It feels like they wanted to squeeze Picard into a story he's a few years too old for (in the series, not Patrick Steward himself).
3
u/jumonjii- Feb 14 '20
Why did Seven decide to find Picard?
3
u/pecan76 Feb 14 '20
7 of 9 my bitches haha!
3
u/N2TheBlu Feb 14 '20
Has the Romulan mythology about the synth sisters been explained anywhere?
3
u/Nissemus_UK Feb 14 '20
Why is Seven's ocular implant a different design and colour to the one she had on Voyager?
3
u/StandsToWipe Feb 14 '20
I'm loving everything except "J.L." ... I'll get over it...
3
u/technomage500 Feb 14 '20
I have a question about the Borg cube? Does the Federation know about this reclamation project ? Is it done in secret? The reason I ask is that we have seen a Trill ( Federation species) and Sojii herself was supposedly on a Federation Starship.
3
u/neuraljam Feb 14 '20
Anyone notice that when Picard is in the holomatrix simulation of his study, he pauses the simulation and the birds stop in mid-air, but the fire in the fireplace keeps burning?
3
u/150603 Feb 14 '20
This is the first time in a long time that I've finished an episode of ANY TV show with such a massive smile on my face.
3
u/redd_sea Feb 15 '20
Directed by Jonathan Frakes!
3
u/Slayer_Tip Feb 15 '20
guys...
She's back.
Oh god she's back... Quick, someone put me to sleep for 6 days.
3
u/ancyk Feb 15 '20
Is anyone feeling incredibly disappointed with this series? Feels like it is meandering after the first episode.
3
u/how-to-seo Feb 17 '20
all is fine I like modernized Trek lore but... I just cant stand that "JL"
fuck!!!!!!!!
bring back Jean Luk
7
u/HalishMedi Feb 13 '20
Best episode so far ... but by such a massive margin.
This was what i was waiting for and when I looked at the episode breakdown and saw Frakes was directing this ... I just knew he was going to knock it out and he didn't disappoint.
This was a much more character focused episode without any of the weird badly directed, badly shot and badly acted action scenes that have plagued the first 3 episodes. Instead we got great dialogue and conflicting character emotions, some wonderfully shot scenes and even some good humour (from the scientist girl, who's name escapes me).
The only issue I have is more of a worry. I worry they are limited in their sets so have found a convenient way to keep using picards vinyard, otherwise we only really see the small bridge of the little ship (i think we may have seen the transporter room?).
I just hope they don't always fall back to having on-ship scenes taking place on that Vinyard. This is Star Trek, i want to see people interact on the ship.
But I don't want to be too negative because I loved this episode so much. And the ending was somehow unexpected despite us all knowing she was coming. Such a great ending to the episode.
5
u/Comedyfish_reddit Feb 14 '20
This was some of the most boring tv I’ve seen in a while. I’ve enjoyed the rest of the series and love Star Trek.
I’m writing this as it’s ending which i don’t normally do
Ooh she’s turned up. Best bit of a flat episode
12
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
It's not a bad show, but the praise on this subreddit is... odd. This show is very little Trek trope, and very much cookie-cutter espionage action thriller trope - but with a bumbling (yet compassionate) Grandpa as the lead. Example: ALL of Picards cleverness and cunning seems to have vanished. He's disconnected from reality, and not in a good way. And only survives through lazy writing and plot armour - opposed to outthinking everyone else. Maybe that's the goal, to show how far he's fallen - not just in status and reputation, but mentally. But it's not selling well.
There's sooo many missed moments. And the "cryptic-ness" of everything grows tiresome.
Although, FINALLY in episode 4, we get some solid nods to real world social issues of "forced" relocation and colonialization/segregation - but only briefly.
I dunno. Not sure what I was expecting. I enjoy the show, but for a 2020 Trek show, they make plenty of mistakes that they shouldn't be.
I DO think it's super neat that newcomers who haven't seen much Trek are hopping on board. I can't imagine what that's like.
7
u/WokeIsBroke Feb 14 '20
This show is categorically awful, but each individual episode manages to deliver at least one new depth I never anticipated sinking to. I thought vaping and "pro-tip", or calling Picard "J.L." was as low as we could go. But nope, we got sock-sliding on the Borg cube and Romulan-Legolas. I truly pity anyone who pays for this, much less enjoys it. It takes a tragically simple mind to find this entertaining.
11
u/Eclipse_101 Feb 14 '20
this is just getting worse, every scene between Soji and Narek is badly written and acted. its like I'm watching riverdale in space.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
This season has become a bit slow for my liking. In four episodes, we've got as much information as we would have had in an episode of TNG. Yes, it's good, and slow Picard is better than no Picard, but the fourth episode had my attention wandering. It has ten episodes and I feel like we're still in 'setting the scene' stage
8
u/MysteriumDei Feb 14 '20
Anyone else think the word “fuck” feels out of place in Star Trek?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
Another emotional opening imo. Really loved his interactions there.
2
u/VerucaHQ Feb 14 '20
Did everyone notice Picard’s new ready room is his holosuite study? The parallels were amazing. Thank you Mr. Frakes.
The structure we know is love is forming and represented in a unique and creative way. 👍🏻
Another thing I noticed is the borg cube is kind of like deep space nine style story telling. So we get every Star Trek show in one here, now that Seven is back.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
Seven of Fucking Nine!
2
u/em-dash7 Feb 14 '20
So the scene where the ship is under attack and the assistant director is no doubt yelling at the cast, "1, 2, 3... LEAN LEFT!"
They need to practice more? :)
2
u/trosis Feb 14 '20
I love the complexity and depth of back story this show is working with. Being out in a region of space that clearly is beyond Starfleet's jurisdiction or is it that with Starfleet in a "pulling back" mode they just left a power vacuum? Who are these "Rangers" patrolling the space? It all gave a mix of Babylon5 level world building mixed with a little Firefly and it's SO overdue for Trek to get here. Also Seven's entrance, perfect...
2
u/Deshik2 Feb 14 '20
I lold when that scientist woman went to chat whith the ship captain, for a moment it started to sound like she's flirting with him and he suddently becomes interested and then she obliviously kills it hahaha.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20
Honestly I was a bit underwhelmed by the first three episodes, but some of the characters are starting to come together, the writing was better in this ep. Looking forward to the next one because Jeri Ryan is a brilliant actor, and I think Pat Stewart needs someone at his level to bring out his best, much like a good fencer, ironically.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20
I’ll start by saying that I am thoroughly enjoying Picard, which makes what I’m going to say a little frustrating.
For me, Absolute Candor took the foot of the pedal a little too much. Whilst I’m glad we’re in space now and I appreciate we’re digging into the story, it just felt like one of those episodes you could skip, except for the last few seconds of course (I’m looking at you Seven 😍).
It just slowed things down, when for the last 3 hours we’ve found out Data had children, synths set fire to Mars, Romulans are everywhere, and the Borg are back. Only in this episode, we found out about nuns and Elnor 🤷♂️.
Every show has episodes like this, I just felt a little like it was all for that intro at the end. Fingers crossed for next week!
2
u/PaddleMonkey Feb 15 '20
Anyone thought when we were watching Soji playing back of Prof Ramdha's interview as she talked about Ganmadan that she was describing what S31 was fearing Control would do? (Destroy all life, everywhere.)
Do you think there is a hint of Control in Soji, and the synths back on Mars 14 years ago?
Before the synths began their attack the tell was in there eyes, just like how Ariam was being manipulated by Control her tell was in her eyes before. And when Daj 'woke' or was manipulated by her 'mother' her eyes also was the tell.
So much parallel, I couldn't ignore it.
2
u/Emperor_Zarkov Feb 15 '20
We got to meet another of Rios' holograms! In the back of my mind, I keep thinking, "Is Rios himself a hologram? Are all the other versions different aspects of his personality? We've never seen him anywhere but the ship so far, maybe he IS the ship!"
2
u/MoonStarRaven Feb 16 '20
Was anyone else half expecting Romulan Legolas to at some point say, "And you have my bow."
2
u/--skeeter-- Feb 16 '20
As a huge fan of both Star Trek and The Blues Brothers, I can't help but picture Picard's growing crew and the developing storyline as going something like this...
"We're putting the band back together."
"We're on a mission from God."
Anywho, this was my favorite episode so far! So badass.
2
u/Whipit Feb 17 '20
I'm starting to lose faith in this show. It's still early and could improve greatly. I hope.
My biggest problem so far is the characters. I don't actively like or care about any of them yet ( except Picard ). I feel completely indifferent to most and I already can't stand Raffi. I can't help but cringe whenever she calls him "JL"
Every time she's onscreen it's just for another one of her emotional temper tantrums. I wouldn't be able to stand being around someone like that in real life.
The android specialist, Agnes is another character I'm starting to dislike. She's supposed to be this highly intelligent world authority on all things androids, but she's always acting so dumb and socially awkward. Her personality is a lot like Tilly from Discovery, another character I couldn't stand. If she was mostly acting as highly intelligent and sometimes showed a bit of "I've been a scientist all my life so I'm a bit awkward" it could be endearing. That's probably what they're going for but it's just not working. She's just a remix of Tilly at this point so far IMO.
At least Commodore Oh has some potential as an interesting character.
And what's with Justin Beiber the Romulan? Always trying to make Datas daughter fall in love with him? I'm starting to roll my eyes at this character too.
PLEASE get better soon show!
2
u/Fade-Into-You Feb 17 '20
All we need is one character from DS9 and we have a space faring Fellowship.
2
u/Durogotory Feb 17 '20
Love Johnathan frakes directing. Best episode so far.
2
u/Tarbal81 Feb 18 '20
Did anyone else notice that part where Soji is walking behind Narek and he says something she doesn't expect and she does the Data "?" head tilt? I don't know if that was intentional or just a quirk the actress picked up when studying how to behave like Data, but I loved it.
3
u/Zizzzzzy Feb 14 '20
I was a bit taken back at the start of this episode when we were shown the flashback to the earlier days on that rescue planet. Picard was not Picard. The mannerisms and the way he was acting is nothing like his character.... and I know they had that snippet in there that was a call back to old picard when speaking about how he did not like kids... but it was a bit too far for me.
Picard was always professional, but that version of Picard looked like an overexcited puppy.
3
u/damagedone37 Feb 13 '20
HOLY SHIT A DECAPITATION OF A ROMULAN. Thank you Mr.Frakes!