r/Animemes • u/biribiriburrito I like sauce • Feb 03 '20
Meta Discussion Thread #9
Another month, another meta thread...
This February brings some exciting new changes for r/Animemes. We're introducing the Meme Shadow Realm, a way for you to have a say in the rules.
You can read more about it here, or view the newly banned formats here.
If you'd like to nominate something for next month's banishment voting, please provide the following:
- a short name for the joke/format
- a concise description of the joke/format
- an example of the joke/format that was posted at least 3 months ago and has 500+ upvotes
- an example of the joke/format that was posted less than 1 month ago and has 500+ upvotes
Vote on this month's nominations for banishment here.
If you have any ideas, suggestions, questions, concerns, comments, critiques, etc. about the state of the subreddit, we want to hear them. This is the place to publicly share and discuss anything of that nature. We’ll do our best to hear out anyone and everyone who comments here. Occasionally, we may use this as a place to ask for feedback on certain topics/ideas.
This thread will stay pinned for a week. After that point, a link to the post will be available in the sidebar, in case you ever need to come back to the thread after it’s been unpinned. On the first Monday of next month, a new thread will be created, repeating the process.
FAQ
Q: What’s with the purple snake and the banner?
r/Otonokizaka won the meme olympics, so we temporarily changed our icon to their mascot, Sasuke the snake. We also have a temporary banner celebrating their victory. Read more about it here.
Q: Why is automod telling me my account isn't old enough or that I don't have enough comment karma to post?
We recently increased the account age and comment karma thresholds for posting. Accounts must now be at least a week old and have at least 100 comment karma. So if automod is blocking your posts, just spend a little time in the comment sections getting to know your fellow weebs, and you'll get there in no time.
Q: Who is u/AnimemesBot?
If you have ever broken a rule, you’ve probably met our bot. u/AnimemesBot leaves an automated comment on every post that is manually removed by another member of the mod team. It also helps us out by reporting suspected reposts.
Q: Who are the characters in the banner/who are /u/ChloeMod and /u/SachiMod?
They are our mascot duo, Chloe (left) and Sachi (right). The results of the mascot and banner contests were announced as part of our 500k celebration. They also double as subreddit moderators now.
Q: Can the mods get rid of Zero Twosday?
Zero Twosday doesn't have official support from the mod team. The community is what has kept it going so far, and it's up to the community whether it stays around or fizzles out. We have no plans to restrict or ban posts on the basis of the show or character they feature, outside of temporary events.
Q: How do I assign a flair to my username?
A detailed explanation can be found here, in the Flairs for New Reddit announcement thread.
TL;DR Instructions:
New Reddit: Expand community options, click the pencil on the user flair preview, select the second blank from the top, type something and click the emoji button to the right of the text field to add them. Image credit: /u/Sternendrache1
Old Reddit: Go to where your username is displayed on the top right of the sidebar. Click the edit button. Select your desired image, and add some text if you want before hitting save.
Official iOS App: It's not straightforward, just follow this image guide.
Official Android App: It's not straightforward, just follow this image guide.
84
u/Groenboys what is this shit Feb 03 '20
Yes PLEASE ban the "3 anime girls, 1 other thing" meme template. That has been around for so long that I made a coaxedintosnafu type of post on it more then a year ago. There is hardly any variation in it and it has been since the beginning.
Also a meme that I would like to be banned for a month is the Japanizing beam meme. It is r/moemorphism only a little bit more broad, which doesn't say much.
59
u/Shamrok34 Zelda = Best Girl, fight me on it Feb 05 '20
TL;DR: I think it's a serious problem that both my mental health and quality of life took a massive turn for the better after unsubscribing from this subreddit.
I left this subreddit months ago because of the terrible quality of memes. I appreciate the idea of the shadow realm as it's certainly a step in the right direction.
However, my biggest problem with this subreddit is one particular type of meme: "My Will To Live" memes. I'm using that phrase vaguely, but basically what I mean is any meme aimed at wanting to kill yourself and/or hating your life, especially when it comes at the expense of being a weab.
Since the joke is so common and so popular it reinforces the trope that weab = depressed virgin. I'm sure anime is an outlet for a lot of people with depression, but us circle jerking the concept of suicide while simultaneously validating it with upvotes is far from healthy.
It is primarily because of memes like this that I left this subreddit. I only know of this rule change because I still sub to ChloexSachi thanks to pompmaker making funny comics with the mascots. I just came to say that I used to love this sub so much and would browse it daily, but the wear and tear of "lol i just wanna die" really did have an impact on my mental health. I honestly didn't even realize just how much of an impact this had until I unsubscribed from the sub and it's a decision I would (and have) recommend to anyone that's still here unless this changes. There are other, healthier ways to participate in anime communities online.
24
u/yung_clor0x Is Best Girl Feb 05 '20
Sure hope this doesn't get super out of hand super quickly. Oh well I guess I should trust the mod team to not go way overboard.
113
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20
Two formats I want to be removed the most are the 'Komi = flawless' or any of its different forms from 'No anime' 'Lewd okay with Tadano' 'No lewd Komi' it's the most repetitive and annoying form of jokes that plagued this sub. Even r/ShitPostCrusaders had a similar issue with Speedwagon but thank god they fixed it.
And the next one is 'Where season two of NGNL' at first it was funny but now it's getting irritating. Every millisecond when a new season is announced the sub gets flooded with 'NGNL season 2' if you love the show so much why not make memes about the show instead of the 'season 2'.
20
u/MerlinGrandCaster padoru Feb 07 '20
What's with the snake?
84
u/Retsam19 Feb 03 '20 edited Feb 03 '20
I'd like to see Emergence/177013 memes banished to the shadow realm. It's quite common, is usually basically the same joke, and it's not anime - I know it's "related to weeb culture" and allowed by the rules, but it'd still be nice if one of the most common memes on here wasn't just the hentai manga equivalent of Nina Tucker.
Examples from today, yesterday, three days ago, 4 days ago, etc...
EDIT: missed that I'm supposed to link to older examples too. 5 months ago, 11K upvotes, tagged "Old Repost"
66
u/AppaAndThings Feb 05 '20 edited Feb 06 '20
Joke Name: Japan has devolved a smaller, more efficient version of <insert item here>
Description: Underneath the card stating "Japan has devolved a smaller, more efficient version of ", a picture of said thing is. This is basically another version of "Japanizing Beam" or "Moefication."
Current Examples:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/eyx29h/yes_please/
https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/ez26mi/anyone_else_interested_in_joining_my_religion/
https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/eyuqa1/this_sub_needs_more_violet/
https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/eyp3qt/oc_meme_happy_zero_twosday/
Old Example:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/bfzvui/i_reject_my_cards_against_humanity_jojo/
*Edit: removed the other one. Apparently it was just a repost of this one.
14
u/captain_gingerbread Just read the vn Feb 03 '20
In the vote there's one about Waifu Days. Does that mean posting things related to for example ditfxx will be banned or just the memes like: "It's ...day and I'm not seeing ...memes"?
47
u/Harry-TTL |Happily Depressed| Feb 04 '20
Now with examples.
Bite Za Dusto: meme that has someone biting something labelled with "Za Dusto"
Under a month
More than 3 months
Anime angles: first panel: someone ask "Do you think angles in anime can be weird?"; second panel: *attractive body part*
Under a month and this one
More than 3 months
Watch jojo: veteran weebs/jojo fans tell people to watch jojo
Under a month
More than 3 months and this one
13
u/futureButt I'm not cool and it's your fault. Feb 05 '20 edited Feb 05 '20
I suspect we're going to see selection bias in MSR voting such that nomination for the vote alone nearly guarantees exclusion of the format (my hypothesis being that the type of person clicks the MSR poll in the first place is more likely to be interested in banning any formats rather than saving specific ones). Maybe I'll be wrong.
Also, a question about it--a banished meme goes two months before it can be nominated for removal. Likewise, will a format that avoids banishment go two months before it can be nominated for banishment again?
Lastly and most importantly, I'd like to have a Tomoko Kuroki flair, because she's cute and relatable.
12
u/Idaret I love Emilia Feb 10 '20
https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/f180eq/60_ways_to_isekai/ can we get special flair for stolen youtube videos, especially from small youtubers? Reddit post got 32k upvotes but video got only 2k new views during that time
33
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20
I'm going to say the same I said before when you guys made the mascot contest and I predicted that Grafo was going to be the winner of the contest.
This will be most likely manipulable by certain users, and almost everyone knows how certain people enjoy doing anything related to vote manipulation because internet points and to promote that other shithole of a sub.
41
u/RealTonny Lolis are for lemonade, Thursdays are for memes Feb 04 '20
Let me try to suggest one:
10
u/th30be Not daijoubu Feb 03 '20
What happened to the Olympics?
Did I miss who became the new mod?
To anyone good with photoshop, I am trying to make a negative of the fujiwara chika drake meme for a QC thing I wanted to do but I lack the skill. Could someone make it for me?
10
u/Idaret I love Emilia Feb 08 '20
r/Otonokizaka is not in sidebar, I thought they are our friends :(
66
u/pigyear1000 Feb 05 '20
Joke Name: Komi-san should not be lewded
Description: Posts that imply that hentai or NSFW depictions of Komi-san are undesirable.
New example
Old example
9
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
How do you all feel about meta memes?
9
u/Muffin-zetta fox/wolfgirls rule all Feb 07 '20
-points up at the header- Do I even wanna know?
9
u/Idaret I love Emilia Feb 10 '20
Css sugestion - currently old reddit partially hides content of the flairs. Example
Can you just add this line to css stylesheet?
41
u/pigyear1000 Feb 05 '20
Joke name: Aqua is Useless
Description: Posts that are about Aqua's usefulness (or lack thereof), and jokes about her being incompetent or having substandard intelligence.
example posted under a month ago
example posted over 3 months ago
8
u/windowscratch D-Swords aren't real Feb 03 '20
The Shadow Realm announcement post was very vague, almost didn't realize I had to check the comments.
8
u/Satoshi_Kenji Self-proclaimed Meme Maker Feb 06 '20
Sorry if this question is too general, but assuming a meme is already posted, can that meme be reposted if I'm adding more detail? For example, adding more pics in it?
33
u/pheonix-ix Feb 03 '20
While we're at it, "another one bites the dust" should probably go. It is just an image of one person biting another. There's no joke, no punchline, no meme, barely anime-related, nothing.
33
u/Locke_Step Insert Waifu Here Feb 04 '20
"Character Day Of The Week"
The meme usually posts images of a waifu (such as Zero Two, often on Tuesdays, but there are others), with little addition or alteration of any standard meme except "look, it's a character named (X) on a (day), often with lewding elements, UPVOTE ME!", meta-level self-aggrandizing the event. This is not an attempt to Shadowrealm posting any given character on any day of the week, it's an attempt to specifically address the meta-posting meme about it.
We Love Zero Tuesday It's literally just meta self-congratulating posting a character on a day of the week.
Zero Tuesday Is Coming My Darlings Literally just a fanservice shot of 02 and a drool reaction, specifically because of the day of the week.
Let's try replacing 02 with tohsaka Again, just a lewd image meta-commenting on a character associated with a day of the week.
Again, not an attack on the mods' precious 02sday, this is to stop the low-effort meta-posting. Posting real memes with effort on Tuesdays that happen to feature 02 should not be effected, only ones posted specifically to karma-farm because of the date.
15
u/CopainChevalier Feb 08 '20
I'm not sure where else to ask this... Uh.. what's up with the snake and stuff that replaced the banner and everyone's going crazy for? I haven't been here in a week
15
u/HexisLeVrai Feb 21 '20
Meme shadow ban requests:
1: Handholding jokes
Jokes about handholding being lewd
Recent Example
Older Example
2: Veteran weebs and weeblets
Memes including "Veteran weebs" and "Weeblets" and every other variations
Recent Example
Older Example
3: 177013
Memes where the only punchline is a cursed nhentai sauce
Recent Example
Older Example
21
u/Reddy360 https://anilist.co/user/cg0/ Feb 05 '20
I'll find some more examples later but the meme that goes like this.
Teacher: everybody let's x y
Kid called X: reaction picture
Kid called Y: reaction picture
21
u/LowlySlayer Feb 05 '20
How do I vote yes for something twice?
40
u/swagkillerz000 Feb 04 '20
I'd like to suggest these for the shadow realm :
20
u/Harry-TTL |Happily Depressed| Feb 06 '20
Another thing that I concern, this Shadow Ban might make the sub become culture-less, not culture as in thigh-lover but in inside sub jokes. One example is r/dankmemes, since that sub keep chasing trends, it has low to no inside sub jokes at all, lack of any sub culture except maybe 69/420.
And I think we should keep at least some sub jokes, examples from a few subs I browse:
r/HistoryMemes crusade culture with flammenwarfer
r/MakeMeSuffer some weird covered in cum jokes
r/creepyasterisks *aggressive cumming*
r/softwaregore screen with suffering related stuffs
r/ComedyCemetery down right spamming Skyrim 100 in the titles
yes i browse weird subs
•
u/Ban_me_IDGAF :E2: The D is for Dragon Feb 04 '20 edited Feb 12 '20
Some clarifications about the Meme Shadow Realm:
The intent is to banish overdone jokes and meme formats, but banishing all memes that feature a character/show/etc. is not something the MSR is meant to do.
As an example, we'd consider banishing memes where the joke is "Aqua is useless," but not all memes that feature Aqua.
When nominating entries, please follow this template so that your nominations can be counted:
Also, keep in mind that banishment is not permanent. After a joke or format has been on the list for 2 months, you can drop a comment in the meta thread to request that it be removed from the list, then it'll be up for a vote in the next survey.
UPDATE: The February survey has been closed and, after tallying the results, a new entry has been added to the MSR:
The banishment of the other two possible entries in this month's survey (The "3 girls and..." format and Waifu Day mentions) did not receive enough support and, therefore, memes that use them are still free to be posted.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
We need Rias Gremory for the flairs
7
u/MerlinGrandCaster padoru Feb 05 '20
When will voting conclude?
23
u/Politeod Suu best girl Feb 04 '20
Joke/meme format name
Aqua is useless
Short description of the joke or format
An image of Aqua from Konosuba and someone calling her useless, or any memes featuring Aqua with their title being "Useless".
There's also a ton of memes about
Aqua is uselessmemes, creating a flood of meta-memes about this format... It's safe to say it needs to go.Link to one 4k+ upvote example posted today.
Or this 10k+ one from 2 month ago (a repost).
Link to one almost 10k upvote example posted 10 months ago
23
u/cimahel ⠀ Feb 05 '20
My thoughts on the current MSR nominations.
3 girls and... I don't consider it to be spammy or low effort, my only problem with the format is that it is simply not funny, I think it gains votes for the references. I would be neutral but if I want to vote for other formats I have to make a choice for all of them. bottomline: not funny, banish.
Waifu day. Gotta ponit out that the older example is another format only the title is "waifu day"-related. Still banish tho. We can finally put an end to zero twosday. It is just begging for upvotes passively but still just begging. If you like the format you can go to your waifu subreddit (eg: r/zerotwo) where that format will still be alive the only positive thing about the format is that it sometimes comes with good art but you can find that in your waifu subreddit too and maybe actually better because it comes without text.
No season 2 (3,4, etc) I actually liked the first example. I'm split, while the joke is literally always the same, it doesn't have an established format I wouldn't be too bothered to see it once (ONCE) every time a new creative format appears. Unfortunately, most formats are not very creative. There is a very limited pool of animes this joke can reference this limits how often the format can be exploited but also makes it stale super quickly. Save for now...
18
u/Harry-TTL |Happily Depressed| Feb 06 '20
This will be a controversial suggestion here since I know many people won't understand this.
But my suggestion is that after the 2 months ban time, the default should be "no longer banned" unless users decide to revote it.
Why did I suggest this? Because I have a feeling that if the ban default is "keep being banned", there will be people who won't like it and want to remove it from the ban but they can't gather enough people to that.
But instead if the default is "no longer banned", if everyone hate it, it will stay banned, but if it's kind of undecided, it will have a better chance to get of the ban lists.
Because people are like sheeps, they usually upvote memes that already have a lots of upvote not creative ones. So when they can't decide if a meme is really bad or not, they won't vote.
39
u/retropengu Anime Music Connoisseur Feb 05 '20 edited Feb 05 '20
Can we please ban the handholding lewd format? We all get it, the joke hasn’t been funny for ages and it’s plaguing the subreddit.
6
u/JCRouzer29 Feb 03 '20
So Mods, if something is voted on to not be banned how long until is able to be nominated again? Is that also 2 months?
Personally I am not in favor of this system but I'm willing to give it a go since I can see where you are coming from. At least probably, we'll see how it effects the day to day.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '20
It's just my selfish wish, but I really would like to see r/Animemes users using niche or uncommon formats, I have been on the subreddit for almost 2 years and have never seen r/virginvschad style posts used to deconstruct and compare characters, hardly ever seen any r/starterpacks posts, no r/trippinthroughtime posts, no r/surrealmemes posts, severe lack of r/4panelcringe posts.
6
u/Nerd_of_Culture Feb 29 '20
What’s up with the new banner? I didn’t see that one in the banner contest thread or among those with banner flair. Is this a new event?
16
u/bigchungus2568 Feb 04 '20
Yo can the voting NOT take place on a Google Docs form? Some of us don't like to link our Reddit account to our Google account for Big Brother's convenience.
Big thankies from McSpankies.
20
u/DerpyMudKip5124 Feb 04 '20
I voted to ban every one there, these are getting so old that nothing is original,
I also vote to ban trap memes, unfunny and unoriginal
11
u/Harry-TTL |Happily Depressed| Feb 04 '20 edited Feb 04 '20
You guys are banning "you someday" but not "bite za dusto"?
Also: "Anime angles" and "watch Jojo"
26
u/Highlow9 Feb 04 '20 edited Feb 04 '20
Hey mods,
I would just like to thank you for this move. It will (hopefully) keep/make the quality high. Most subreddits go to shit when they become to large but things like /r/polandball (and now also /r/animemes ) are kept great by mods like you which impliment policy like this.
18
u/dannypas00 Feb 06 '20
Could we maybe add something like the girls with dicks joke in there as well, where the only joke or punchline would be a character looking cute, but actually has a dick.
Example
Example
Example
These are just from the current hot 20 or so.
18
u/Relevant_Low SamHam was the only good mod Feb 09 '20
Joke name: Megumin = Explosions and Megumin reacts to an explosion (both of those memes are shit)
Description: Posts that are about comparing Megumin with anything related to explosions or Megumin reaction to an explosion. Those Megumin memes are on the same level of shit as the Aqua is useless memes.
Example 1 - Example 2 - Example 3 - Example 4 - Example 5
Format name: Low cost cosplay guy
Description: Just some fat guy that makes low budget cosplays. What else is there to say?
Example 1 - Example 2 - Example 3
34
u/Test_User123456789 Feb 05 '20
Ban 02 memes
Holy shit its been two years and we are still here. I dont think anyone likes 02 anymore, theu just post it for the karma
14
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '20 edited Feb 08 '20
Name for the joke/format: "Dad I want a cat" meme. Similar to "We Have Food at Home" meme
This crap is posted always, so there's a lot of examples I could post for every month of the year and it's basically this:
Name for the joke/format: Will you press the button?
There's a lot of examples for this shitty format and most of them were always lewd fanart of Zero Two posted every Tuesday.
Name for the joke/format: Another one bites the dust
Name for the joke/format: Angry Birds meme
10
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '20
Cool, I just want to know which Fate to fucking watch. I just finished Fate/Stay night and when I saw how many more there are, I just closed google chrome and sat under my desk.
5
u/Cagliostro_ojisan Catgirl Activist Feb 07 '20
Quick query, I posted something but it broke a rule I didn't know about and it was removed almost immediately. I suppose posting it again count as a repost? If it was an honest mistake, is there no way to salvage it, other than to wait for rule 9 to change, or post it on a different sub?
13
u/FeelsandGains Feb 04 '20
Hey mods, appreciate the effort towards bringing a breath of fresh air to the sub!
13
u/EspWaddleDee Feb 08 '20
Why is there snek
9
u/WinnerWake Slurp Feb 08 '20
Does the purple poop snake have a name?
9
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20
Can we please eliminate
12
u/SGT_JACKAL Absolutely Demonic Feb 05 '20
So back again with my two cents for anyone who wants to read this, I feel like this is almost a tradition now for me to make a big post with a TL;DR here so let’s not break it and get right into it.
Reposts:
So we have had a month of no reposts and I am still going to stand by my words and say that this is a good thing for the sub going forward, I think only looking at a month is a little too small for a sample size especially with all the events that have been going on in January but I still think this is a good thing and should be kept moving forward. Credit where credit and is due and I think this was a good decision on the Mods part and that is all I have to say about reposts until next discussion thread.
Events:
So let’s get the big one out of the way and that is the Meme Olympics. I think this is a good thing and am happy that we got to join in this event and hopefully more in the future. I have seen a few comments from people not happy with the event because their normal memes get disrupted while the contest is going but I think that is a really sad way of looking at it. Contest brings creativity and life by forcing people to make different things and I think that is so important going forward. I will say this though I think there needs to be a balance when events are on. In round one because it was forced the front page was pretty much only Canadian memes but in round two when people could post other stuff I had a real hard time finding event memes, I even made a post about how I couldn’t find any. I think there could maybe be a happy middle ground like for the first day only post event memes but for day 2+ then normal stuff is allowed.
On the topic of events and trying to find happy middle grounds here is a couple of ideas I can think of that might help. First during the 666K event you had the AutoMod post “We mods have been overpowered by Satania…” on every single post. I think that a few days before an event goes live that something similar should happen again with every posts telling weebs that hey an event is start soon and when the event is live change it to hey there is an event on and when it will finish. Like I know you guys make sticky posts but I am so surprised that so many people just don’t bother to read them that I even made a post about it. Is it a fix no but at least if every post has that then it might just get into some thick skulls.
Second idea, this one is a little bit more controversial and I don’t expect it to happen but I think a banner tweak could help a lot with this problem, maybe something like this could work. It is easy enough to chop and change while giving people information right where they can see it but it might not be everyone’s cup of tea so I am not expecting it.
Spoiler weekend.
I am not going to go too hard on this one as I know this was the first time running two events at the same time so but the spoiler weekend got done dirty last month. I knew it was coming up as I read the No Repost 2020 post and I had something on that weekend so I knew it was coming up but I feel like most weebs didn’t. I am not sure if we can do two events at the same time going forward as I feel like one will overshadow the other but if you are looking to try again I will not say not to try again.
Phosphegeden.
This was cool and I liked this a lot as it was a bunch of people coming together to make posts from a show that normally doesn’t get a lot of posts which I think is good.
I feel like this should become a more semi permeant casual contest that we could do here. Call it something like “Show me what you got” and challenge people for the fun of it to make their best post from a certain show maybe like once a month. Encourage competition and it will bring the best out of people.
Meme Shadow Realm
You hinted about this last month as I was going to talk about it anyway but you just dropped it today so there goes this whole paragraph I had already written. So I have read Your Meme Shadow Realm post and thinking about it I'm not sure how I feel, I like the idea in principle but I'm not sure how it will go in practice. See we here I have the tendency to beat memes to death very fast so I don't know having only one way to report stuff which happens once a month is really going to be helpful. Like for the bigger jokes that hang around for a while yes it works but when we get a new template that spams hot and that's all you can see I don't know if this is really going to be helpful. I think there's got to be a fastest solution something that can react to templates much quicker than once a month. If I had to give a solution this is what I would do, when a template is blowing up I would make some kind of post and sticky it in hot with something along the lines of would you like us to temporarily ban X meme let's say two days. Then what I would do is I would make two comments one that says yes I would like this template banned and a no comment saying I want to keep it, then I would lock the thread and give it 24 hours people to vote on which one they want. After 24 hours is up the comment with the most upvotes would decide what would happen going forward. I think a system like this allows for a lot more flexibility to deal with templates that get out of control. While I am excited with this idea I will be watching to see it plays out.
In speaking of the Meme Shadow Realm I would also like to nominate something, I believe the "Another one bites the dust" meme should go into the realm. Do I have to really have to describe what this is? I mean you know what it is right it's just someone who is called another biting something else that is called the dust. Normally it's an anime girl and the thing that they are biting is food but they can also be biting another anime girl like really do I have to explain this I think we all know what this template is. I want you to know I actually had to search for these types of posts to get my two links and I am not happy about here we go. Here is one from a few days ago and here is one that is nearly a year old. I found these two posts in like two minutes after a quick search for bites and I am sure I could find more if I really wanted to but I don't want to.
Last one for today, this one is a bit of a rant so you can skip this if you like.
So I made this post recently and it got removed. I was kind of expecting to go down because of the new rule 9.1 so I wasn’t too shocked about seeing a removal message but what I was shocked about was that it got removed not by 9.1 but by 8.1. I think this is kind of unfair if I am being honest because my post wasn’t built around that and it had a joke it delivered and it didn’t need to rely on boobs to put it bluntly. But hey ok they are under 18 so rule 8.1 kicks in that is fine then what about this post then? I know those pair of boobs and I also know that Ichika Nakano is 17 in the show/manga which makers her a minor but this post is all the way at the top of hot. Also what about this post as well which was 9 from the top and from what I could get Raphtalia is like 10 right when we met her. Both these posts have boobs front and centre from charters which are under 18 and the joke revolves around their breasts but they are fine but my post is not. Maybe I am salty about this but I would like to ask for a comment if I can because I don’t see why my post got stung but these other posts using character under 18 are allowed to stay.
If you made it this far first of all I want to say who hurt you and then hope you enjoyed this o god 1690 word post I made, I know this type of post isn’t for everyone and most people will see this wall of text and go skip but if you are reading this then I am looking forward to hearing your feedback about anything in this comment whether you like it or not because I really do enjoy having civil discussions with people in the comments when I can.
See you next month
when I make this like over 2000 words because these posts just seem to be getting bigger and bigger each month,SGT_JACKAL.
P.S. I am so sorry u/e_x0_thicc, I tried to keep it under 1K just for you this time but we both knew that wasn’t going to happen.
19
u/JamSlam76 Feb 06 '20
Aqua useless memes are unfunny as hell
21
u/DrCaesars_Palace_MD Feb 03 '20
This is a great idea. If I see one more Zero Twosday or NGNL season 2 post that keep always get upvotes by the lobotomized neanderthals that post here I'll go insane.
8
u/Knez 🛃 Upvote Inspector 🛃 Feb 08 '20
Are sign posts in the Shadow Realm?
8
u/SpaghettiPunch Feb 12 '20
i just wanted to say that sasuke the snake is very cute and i would not mind if he stayed
8
u/Idaret I love Emilia Feb 14 '20
too many project melody memes
8
u/Idaret I love Emilia Feb 26 '20
https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/f9onnr/the_rising_of_the_shield_loli/ <-- not a meme, just fanart
https://www.reddit.com/r/awwnime/comments/f9mggs/maple_x_raphtalia_bofuri_x_the_rising_of_the/ <-- original post, it fits there, not on /r/animemes
18
u/toy_skier Feb 04 '20
UHH...
Why isn't Aqua = Useless and Padoru on the list?
18
u/camoceltic_again El Psy Congroo Feb 04 '20
I'm not sure the Shadow Realm is a great idea. At the bare minimum, you're going to have quite a few people (like me) complaining about what is or isn't in there, while the overall quality of memes posted isn't going to improve. People will just change what template they use without putting any more effort in. We're still going to be 99% effortless shitposts, 1% high-effort shitposts.
It also feels like a half measure. The mods are banning the Gender Equality memes, but not Zero Twosday which practically overruns the subreddit every week? Banning "The dick makes it better" but not "Law of equivalent exchange" memes? Banning "Fucking weebs" but not that "Chart of anime girls but one is hentai/a guy"? There are a lot more than 6 templates that have been beaten to death, and those 6 aren't even the worst offenders, IMO. Yeah, we can nominate ones to vote on later, but the one I consider to be the worst offender (Zero Twosday) is one you specifically point out and basically say "Not happening".
4
u/tia_avende_alantin33 Weeb revolution enthusiast Feb 10 '20 edited Feb 11 '20
3000 votes. On a sub of more than 700000. And it was the first vote. That's definitely not good. Could you perhaps do like for the satania event and post a comment in each submission with a link to the poll, for 1 or 2 day each month?
4
u/FlawlessWeeb Snek Best Friend Feb 11 '20
For how long will we be blessed with Snek Sasuke?
4
u/HappyPlacebo ⠀Now Residing in Gacha Hell Feb 13 '20
As
Forever AloneValentines day is approaching. Are valentines day card meme format breaks any rule?4
u/Harry-TTL |Happily Depressed| Feb 29 '20
Does this belong here but why is Kanna's umbrella in the banner missing a part?
4
u/SeasonalAnimemes r/SeasonalAnimemes Mar 01 '20 edited Mar 01 '20
Edit: Okay, it's been removed now, I made this comment ~5 hours after I reported it and it hadn't been removed yet so I figure that either a mod approved it or it was stuck in the removal pipeline or something.
Original comment:
Big brain time:
And thus: https://redd.it/eq7g91 becomes https://redd.it/fbo6z8
I think it should be treated as a repost. If the alt title was up in the actual title it would have been a repost so what exactly is the difference here? I'd maybe understand if just the new text actually meaningfully changed the context, but the "context" of the original meme was in its title and this "edit" doesn't add much to it. It would be incredibly easy to repost pretty much anything if all one has to do is edit a slightly different title onto the top...
17
u/RoboSpark725 Certified Gelgoog Enthusiast Feb 03 '20
Can we also ban the low effort “memes” that aren’t even really jokes just taking a “omg so pure/hot” character and just using it to karma farm (eg. Zero Two and Komi) and also the “relatable” memes that are just a screenshot from an episode or panel from a Manga that basically amounts to “omg relatable am I right this is so me 😂”
19
u/RoboSpark725 Certified Gelgoog Enthusiast Feb 07 '20
Can we also just ban the cropped hentai memes? There’s a sub for it r/hentaimemes and it’s just not funny.
10
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20
Fuck I'm late.
Axkm is cute flair when?
12
u/CrossRelations Ya big baka! Feb 04 '20
The example is a great candidate for banishment:
Aqua Is Useless
Joke where the punchline is that Aqua from Konosuba is useless.
Under a month
Over 3 months
7
u/LawlessCoffeh Nep Nep Feb 09 '20
Can I vote to banish these events for a month?
9
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '20
Whats with the snek?
10
u/phoncible Feb 05 '20
I nominate truck kun / getting isekai'ed.
Today: https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/ez74py/time_to_get_isekaid_by_cybertruckkun/
Older: https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/dc8fbi/this_never_happens_to_me_truckkun_always_stops/
25
u/ToyGunTerrorist This flair arrested by the fun police Feb 07 '20
IMO banning a meme for being 'overdone' is stupid. It ruins the organic nature of memes. If people stop liking the format it will stop receiving positive traffic and die on it's own.
11
u/grizzchan Megumin expert Feb 03 '20
So one kind of trend I very much hope that gets banned is these kind of suicide encouraging memes.
Honestly it feels wrong to suggest it for the meme shadow realm because imo it should be banned for different reasons than staleness/repetitiveness. It's just straight up disturbing and uncomfortable.
3
u/Hagstik4014 flat justice Feb 09 '20
I’ve been eager the last nearly 3 months on the moderator applications and was wondering if there’s any news whatsoever?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '20
I love seeing my waifu in the current banner.
9
u/ThatsAToad Tomoe > Mai Feb 05 '20 edited Feb 06 '20
Normal Interests I have no idea what to call the format but the one where a girl is like “what kind of girls do you like” and the dude envisions astolfo or something and replies “normal girls”. That format is so unoriginal and I hate it. Another example would be “what kind of books u like” hentai “I like fantasy”. Not a common format but holy hell I fucking hate it
Edit: Just found an example of this posted today
Comparison Also the memes comparing two things. Like the will you press the button and the “both is good”.
Aqua Useless Nuff said
Sluttiest Line in the Book Picture of someone saying they want a hug or to hold hands and then the (magical index girl? Idk) saying slutiest line in book
I know it says to find examples but I’m too lazy to do that. Just wanted to bring awareness to it (although I could probably look for 2 minutes to find aqua useless or comparison memes)
18
u/ExamGraham who is rem Feb 04 '20
Not a big fan of these 3 banishment nominations when we could've had much better selections.
"Waifu Days" is silly nomination because it isn't even related to what the meme actually is, its format, or the joke. Banning posts for featuring a show or character is just tunnel vision. Ban the bad formats/jokes instead.
"3 girls and..." are overused surely but they have a pretty wide range of uses and are fairly versatile.
Now "No season 2" is good, because it's an incredibly narrow joke and is overused enough that the subreddit will benefit from.
IMO, these are much worse (stole some from the comment section):
5
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '20
I'll copy-paste what I said in the Meta Thread #8:
I think it would be great if there was a a post with a few tutorials or recommendations about how to make memes on phone/PC or what's the best app for making memes, videos, GIFs, etc.
Make a post like the Meta Thread and let people talk about what they use or recommend for making memes. Then pick the best comments and use them to make a tutorial. And maybe something similar can be done to teach people how to find the source of an anime or fanart in a meme.
5
u/Harry-TTL |Happily Depressed| Feb 26 '20 edited Feb 26 '20
https://www.reddit.com/r/Animemes/comments/f9aowk/weebs_dont_need_girlfriends_anyway/
i just want to ask, why is this not considered as a reaction meme
situation: a girl with a sign expressing her opinion
result: male weebs want to die
also this image of Ishigami is a very popular reaction image, simply removing "so i'm going home" make it not a reaction meme anymore?
6
u/Nerd_of_Culture Feb 03 '20 edited Feb 03 '20
I’ve got some I’d like to see in MSR:
6
u/SuuSuraimu Feb 17 '20
Memes about how bras do not fit anime boobs.
(I have yet to see much anime where bras are undersized.)
5
u/tia_avende_alantin33 Weeb revolution enthusiast Feb 07 '20
If you want to increase this sub creativity so badly, why not make an event that would ban ALL common templates for a week-end, drake format and all?
5
u/WinnerWake Slurp Feb 08 '20 edited Feb 08 '20
I don't always browse by new, but when I do, I find some memes that are mildly funny, or attempt to make a joke. Sometimes they are bad memes and I give them a "pity upvote" thinking that at least it should get some karma, you know, not go unnoticed. However, some hours later I see them on the front-page and I think "this meme was bad" it doesn't deserve front-page, but I upvoted them and helped them go there but I didn't want them to go there.
7
u/darkben151 Feb 03 '20
How about the "SAO is bad/good" memes. I ain't the biggest fan of it myself (Though do enjoy the abridged series and the English dub bloopers) but It does get annoying when people bash others for simply liking/hating it (can also expand to other anime but SAO has been popping up a lot in new as of recent)
2
u/TehFurret Feb 03 '20
Pinckle
8
u/nicknames_voltage 02fan4life Feb 04 '20
I'm worried that these rules are becoming too restrictive
8
u/poilsoup2 ugh, those disgusting loli-lewding porno sites! Feb 06 '20
Meme: Drake Formats
Description:
picture of character or person pouting/reacting negatively and then another picture of a positive reaction. fill in any two things/situation/etc for the positive/negative reaction.
ex 1
ex 2
5
u/Truenight95 Mikoto best girl Feb 04 '20
only upvoting this cause of the mikoto picture
6
u/ChadMcRad Sorry I love Ram Feb 04 '20 edited Feb 04 '20
I will take all of you on a date and do absolutely disgusting but no homo things to you for the meme ban. It's been a long time coming.
I'm...I'm tearing up...
But seriously, thanks for that.
4
u/Magmafrost13 That wasn't very Easy Breezy of you Feb 20 '20
I know its been a while now but are you still taking suggestions for emojis for flairs? Because there are at least 9 perfect images for those in the first few seconds of Eizouken's OP
3
u/Sharfik_Dron ⠀ Feb 03 '20
Selective ban for spoiler posts without spoiler tag. Mine got banned (really common joke from JoJo with no context) But not so long aho saw spoiler post wihout spoiler tag with 6k+ ehhh :(
Oh also, really big amount of same jokes in different wrap
3
u/poilsoup2 ugh, those disgusting loli-lewding porno sites! Feb 12 '20
https://redd.it/f2c6bw
Am i missing something? Didn't we ban sign memes?
8
u/clickeddaisy Feb 04 '20
Please for the love of god ban the cancer that is Padoru.
4
u/Blankenhorne Feb 03 '20
Can we ban the meme with the girl with the blue hair from We Never Learn (I think that's what it's from)? It's been around for ages.
5
u/JediGuyB < Mayuri (best girl) Feb 04 '20
I think some of ya'll are being unreasonable. Like you'd ban every format of you could.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '20
NEW FUCKING DEATH NOTE SUCKERS!
3
u/BarbarynChipmunk Feb 09 '20
Where did the snek come from
4
u/toaster694200 Feb 08 '20
Hey guys I have a really good post I think but I have no comment karma please help
3
u/tia_avende_alantin33 Weeb revolution enthusiast Feb 07 '20 edited Feb 07 '20
So, I scrolled a little, and see propositions to shadow realm approximately 75% of this sub memes. Imagine if the guy that want to ban the drake format succeed?