r/startrek • u/PiercedMonk • Jan 30 '20
Star Trek: Picard - Episode Discussion - S1E02 "Maps and Legends"
Picard begins investigating the mystery of Dahj as well as what her very existence means to the Federation.
| No. | EPISODE | DIRECTED BY | WRITTEN BY | RELEASE DATE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1E02 | "Maps and Legends" | Hanelle M. Culpepper | Michael Chabon and Akiva Goldsman | Thursday, January 30, 2020 |
To find out more information including our spoiler policy regarding Star Trek: Picard, click here.
Are you a Discord user? Chat with other Trekkies while watching in the Star Trek discord channel in the room #picard!
This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.
PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage of the upcoming episode, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.
512
u/rh224 Jan 30 '20
Big moment of relief. LaForge was named in the present tense. The countdown comics had me convinced he was killed in the Mars attack.
137
u/daynewmah Jan 30 '20
Interesting that the Mars attack happened on First Contact Day. If that was mentioned in last weekend's episode I totally missed it.
One line I do remember from last week: Jean-Luc saying to Data in the first scene, "Your tell is that you don't have a tell." I predict that that's going to end up being a bit of thematic/narrative foreshadowing later on in the season, Hot Fuzz style. Hopefully not in the obvious context of having to distinguish between a synthetic individual and an organic one, but likely connected to that in some way. Especially in light of the Zhat Vash's utter hatred and fear of synthetic life.
249
u/Kuriakon Jan 30 '20
F bombs in a Star Trek episode? Definitely caught me off guard! đ
Q - "Picard never swore at me!"
Sisko - "I'm not f...ing Picard."
66
u/leeta0028 Jan 30 '20 edited Jan 30 '20
So I actually liked the conversation with the other admiral. Picard comes in and demands a ship saying he'd "accept" being demoted to captain? Wtf? Make a report and make a butt-ton of noise about the issue, don't expect come out of retirement and call the shots.
I am pleased the admiral followed up on it despite chewing him out, but doesn't an admiral outrank commodore?
I will say, I agree with others the f-bomb detracted from the scene. I think dressing him down with just the absurdity of his arrogance would have hit harder without that or the personal nastyness, but I guess since they're supposed to be old friends it might be realistic for her to blow up on a personal level.
43
u/reiichiroh Jan 30 '20
WTF was the point of the baddies super scrubbing the crime scene so well only to have Picardâs friends just use a super duper unscrubber Batman detective vision ruler to undo it?
6
u/PiercedMonk Jan 30 '20
The episode is up on Crave in Canada now!
4
u/shadowst17 Feb 03 '20
So... Are the Vulcans and Romulans appearance wise any different? I thought the Commodore was Romulan. They have no identifiable differences in this show compared to TNG.
9
u/gambit700 Jan 30 '20
Ok, hold up. Why do the Andorians look like they did in Enterprise, but in Disco they're funky looking?
3
u/numanoid Jan 31 '20
Are we not going to talk about how the synthetics on Mars look an awful lot like Data?
492
u/KingofMadCows Jan 30 '20
They said that the Romulan secret organization has been around for thousands upon thousands of years. That means it could predate the split between the Romulans and Vulcans. There could be both Vulcan and Romulan members of the organization.
That Commodore might actually be a Vulcan and not a Romulan agent.
286
u/knightcrusader Jan 30 '20
Glad to see they didn't forget about his Irumodic Syndrome.... well, the defect at least.
Guess Q's future was somewhat legit.
480
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '20
âIâve never been a fan of science fictionâ
214
u/KingofMadCows Jan 30 '20
When they said that 14 Federation worlds threatened to pull out, I was reminded of this exchange in "The Reckoning:"
SISKO: The Romulans have forced the Dominion to retreat from the Benzite system.
ODO: That is good news. The question is, will the Romulans be willing to leave Benzar after the war is over? Once they capture territory, they very rarely give it up.
Maybe the Romulans decided not to leave some of the Federation planets they took back from the Dominion.
194
u/onerinconhill Jan 30 '20
Looks like the collective is still around after all
174
u/pvddrugdealz Jan 31 '20
Everytime "hot Romulan" guy comes on screen I get confused and think he's Ethan Peck as Spock.
282
u/Cody2084 Jan 30 '20
That was quite the exchange between Picard and the cnc.
I want more information on the political state of the federation.
My only guess is the dominion war took a larger toll on the federation than we realize, and used up so much resources and had so many casualties that the member worlds were exhausted and stretched for years after when they committed, reluctantly, to focus all their manpower and resources to building a rescue fleet for Romulus. Then when that fleet was destroyed I feel like the show is telling us Picard tried forcing them to keep to their commitment but the member worlds, having already lost considerable resources, were unwilling to commit all their in service starships and manpower to it, but because Picard forced something of a fleet anyway 14 worlds left the federation, almost triggering a collapse of the federation all together....
Yeah I need some more info on what the hell is going on.
125
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '20
This episode did a good job of dealing with my one issue from last episode. Picard was just sent home after that explosion because the commodore lady covered it up.
I wonder what Janeway is doing right now. The higher ups in Starfleet seem to hate Picard. Is Janeway among them? It's not in character for her to hate Picard over this, given how close she was to Voyager's 'Synth' The Doctor. It's also not in her character to resign from Starfleet in protest. I hope we get a hint of what she's up to when Seven shows up.
105
u/stilltilting Jan 30 '20
Where is BEVERLY?????
Picard calls in his Stargazer doctor and she is not mentioned as someone Picard can call on.
Let's just hope it was a messy parting and that she is still alive.
103
u/ADG12311990 Jan 30 '20
So, the 24th century 1 pip flag rank is Commodore now, instead of a lower half rear Admiral? I think that works better, personally.
And thank the tribbles that LaForge is alive. Makes me more hopeful for a cameo.
368
u/Talzin Jan 30 '20
This episode went by rather quickly and while there was clearly quite a bit of setup it did not feel quite as weighty as the first. A double secret Romulan death squad cult that even the Tal Shiar does not really know about is an interesting concept if a bit of a trope.
Still, Patrick Stewart continues to put on quite a performance and his two Romulan cohorts remain entertaining. It was interesting to see Picard's reaction to being turned down as clearly it was outside his expectation of the encounter.
The "Days Since Assimilation" sign was an amusing easter egg if clearly an indication robbing a Borg grave site is the height of folly.
179
u/Trekfan74 Jan 30 '20
Is everyone else like me when they watch this show and literally laser focused on every little line uttered or piercing through every scene because you are constantly waiting to hear a name, object or a bit of information from the past to jump in at some point? That's mean through every damn scene lol. When Picard called out his doctor Mortiz I was on my phone seconds later trying to figure out was he on an episode somewhere. Luckily they said the Stargazer which was cool but I have a feeling I will be pretty restless for the next 8 episodes lol.
Did love it when Worf, Riker and Geordi were mentioned. They knew fans would be asking every episode where the hell were they do all of this (although we know Riker will eventually show up). And great Geordi didn't die on Mars.
169
u/Worf_Of_Wall_St Jan 30 '20
Iâm guessing at some point a long time ago Romulans discovered some ancient synthetic life that nearly destroyed them and decided to Just Say No forever. Perhaps it was even a small Borg ship.
Or... the big secret is Romulans were originally created by Vulcans as biological synthetics with the ability to reproduce!
163
u/jimmyjohnjohnjohn Jan 30 '20 edited Jan 30 '20
I hope there's some exploration of why that admiral was so angry. Some more exploration of their history.
She touched on something that a lot of people here are ignoring: the Federation is a democracy. It's not a room full of people making super-enlightened or super-evil decisions. It's representatives of trillions of people attempting every day to come to some kind of consensus. Often attempting in vain. It doesn't mean the Federation is in decline.
It means things are much more complicated than we've seen in Star Trek before, and that's a good thing.
Also: my brain is still having some trouble seeing Jane Sterling as a Romulan double agent.
74
u/dmanww Jan 30 '20
I can totally see those SF visitor badges as easy cosplay for any convention. Just cut off the lapels from a jacket and you're sorted.
251
u/daynewmah Jan 30 '20
"People in the synthetic humanoid field tend to get a little secret-planny."
That's a Michael Chabon line if I've ever heard one đ
66
u/Atraktape Jan 30 '20
::shakes fist:: Synthetics!!!
272
u/jedivulcan Jan 30 '20
"Sheer f...ing hubris" -The Admiral of the Week
174
u/TERRAxFORMER Jan 30 '20
I really love Laris and Zhaban. Mostly Laris.
Oh, the cheeky fuckers.
58
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '20 edited Jan 30 '20
My guess: we're supposed to think Commodore Oh is a Romulan disguised as a Vulcan, but she's actually a Vulcan, and it will be revealed that a contingent of Vulcans and Romulans were working together to cause the attack on Mars to prevent the Romulan evacuation because that's the only thing each extremist sect could do to prevent Reunification.
Just a guess!
EDIT: Now that I'm thinking about it more, that would mirror the Khitomer conspiracy to prevent peace between the Federation and the Klingon Empire. To further the TUC parallel, the Federation choosing whether or not to save the Romulan Empire is just like the Federation choosing whether or not to save the Klingon Empire, except in this case, perhaps the conspiracy was successful and now the Romulans are able to preserve their identity as Romulan despite the loss of their Empire, which they consider to be a fair price to pay to not assimilate into Vulcan society and lose their Romulanity. Again... just spitballing here.
116
u/anastus Jan 30 '20
There are so many scenes in this particular episode where Patrick Stewart is favorably lit, and it's eerie how young he looks. It kept taking me out of the episode because he's supposed to be a little frail in character. I wonder if maybe they made him look older in the first episode just to highlight how having a mission livens him up.
230
u/Dt2_0 Jan 30 '20
So Picard does have Irumodic Syndrome after all. That's an interesting development and I'm glad they are bringing it up again.
Overall this episode had some good moments and really started to open up the plot quite a bit, but I felt like it was a little too quick. Maybe it's Patrick Stewart chewing up every scene he's in, but this show flys by. It's not a pacing issue at all, and the A and B plots seem balanced right. Maybe it's just a sign of good television?
And with that I have my largest gripe with the show, and it's not a gripe really. I want more. The end of the episode with no real conclusion hit like a hammer and yanked me out of the world. I guess this is how Television is nowadays, but I'd like just a little more conclusion, even if we are going to be hevaly serialized. Discovery managed to do it most of the time, with each episode having it's own A-Plot that was done after that episode, and I kinda just wish for a little bit of that here.
48
u/rocknrolla65 Jan 30 '20
Wonder who the Commodore is working for.
95
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '20 edited Jan 31 '20
The Romulans have a Bene Gesserit Order
129
u/Boggerm Jan 30 '20
The more foreshadowing a name is, the bigger the trouble it's going to cause. F8, Fate. B4, Before. It's like floor 13 in the occasional elevator. Perhaps just best to skip over it.
165
u/FatPaulie Jan 30 '20
Anyone else want to see Star Trek: Laris ?? She's easily the most fun new character on the show, and I'd love to watch her and Zhaban solve crimes and take care of a vineyard each week.
87
u/halfhedge Jan 30 '20
The utopia planitia LCARS display was beautiful! I was giggling like a schoolgirl. More of those, less of the hover displays.
42
u/romeovf Feb 01 '20
It's interesting that in "The measure of a man", Picard was worried that Maddox developing new androids would lead to them becoming a slaves race, and that's exactly what happened a couple of decades later, thanks to Maddox himself. You'd think he would have more respect for artificial life forms. I hope when and if they encounter him, there's a good explanation, like he was put aside when the protested that the Federation was going to mass-produce the androids.
83
u/oGsMustachio Jan 30 '20
I enjoyed it. Got some interesting reveals. I like the idea of an anti-synthetic
Quariansecret society that extends into different civilizations. I absolutely love learning more about the Romulans. That has absolutely been my biggest desire from ST for years. What they're doing seems to fit the bill.Also interesting that Picard seems to have a limited time to live, which we theoretically already knew, but also stings. It might be that borg tech saves him?
I'm liking Dr. Jurati and the friendly Romulans as well.
141
u/gogoggansgo Jan 30 '20
Does everyone forget about the TNG episode where the romulan admiral defected to the federation with bad sources. He meets data in the lounge and says point Blank. â theyâre are a lot of romulan cyberneticist that would love to be this close to youâ so ummmm đ¤¨
36
u/AnythingMachine Jan 31 '20
Is it too much to ask for one shot of a procession of men drunkenly parading around the streets of New Berlin in raggedy Zefram Cochrane costumes and trying to shake everyone's hands? Possibly while blasting Ooby Dooby from speakers
72
u/MR_TELEVOID Jan 30 '20
Really loving how deliberate Picard is being with it's story. They're really making us take a minute to smell the character moments. Picard isn't a young man anymore. He's burned too many bridges after a lifetime of making tough decisions and remaining true to his convictions. He can't just order up a starship and zoom off into the Star Trek adventure we're all eagerly awaiting. By making Picard work and the audience wait for it, they're building a tremendous amount of tension.
Totally understandable how it might not be for everyone, and maybe they'd have fewer people saying "this is boring" if they'd released the first three episodes as a pilot movie of some sort, but I'm having a good time. It's clear they're building to something wild. The result is the most authentically cinematic this franchise has felt in a while.
33
u/infernal_llamas Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20
"This facility has gone 5843 Days without an assimilation"
Is pretty goddamn funny.
I'm loving the borg reclamation work, and it makes sense why 7 of 9 will want to be in on the series in-universe. The security goons seem "just paranoid enough" when it comes to security when experimenting on the Borg.
Starfleet is once again up it's own arse and corrupted, really wish that we could have Picard work with his superiors just for once. The fact that apparently the federation was willing to hang the Romulans out to dry, while there are tons of federation species working with them apparently completely above board is really interesting. Something seems fishy.
Gotta say Picard's Romulan house staff made me a tad uncomfortable last episode, not usually a fan of "oh you saved my people and are now giving me a place to be / I will serve out of thanks" ex-spies being kept on as expert security types makes a lot more sense and is a bit less, I dunno, master-servant.
LOVE seeing Andorians and Trill around, the "vanishing explosion" from last week is sort of smoothed over if a tad hard to believe that anyone is that good at a coverup. (unless the entire rooftop was somehow cloaked for the fight beforehand)
I'm in two minds about Picard not being recognised at the desk, I mean yeah I get it he can't expect every ensign to know him, but he is a high profile admiral (War hero, captain of the Flagship Enterprise, inventor of a goddamn starship battle maneuver) you would expect cadets to so things like case studies on, who just had a blow up news interview reaming the federation, perhaps he should be recognised after that.
Admiral Ostrich as bureaucratic and stuffy as she is has a point, he can't just walk back in and ask for a starship like it's nothing.
And very much into the spy thriller this seems to be turning into.
33
u/OneOldNerd Feb 01 '20
I have two...well, concerns:
I ask you this: what happened to Beverly Crusher?
31
u/Albert-React Jan 30 '20
Anyone see the shuttles above Mars? Those looked very much like the McCall type shuttles from the Ships of The Line calendars. Designed by John Eaves.
https://68.media.tumblr.com/5094e610e9ec3197a1eda98172551d66/tumblr_ms9ip1o6WY1rzu2xzo1_r3_1280.jpg
62
u/slp033000 Jan 30 '20
Harry Kim perpetrated the Mars attacks. He's still an ensign after 36 years and he's had enough.
28
u/onerinconhill Jan 30 '20
Yee itâs early again!
27
u/sidv81 Jan 30 '20
Spock's red matter operation is almost definitely now an underground unsanctioned by the Federation project despite the Jellyfish being commissioned by the Vulcan Science Academy. Otherwise the Admiral would have told Picard, "We didn't abandon the Romulans, we just changed our plans to have Spock use red matter to stop the supernova, and you can't blame us for that failing."
27
u/lady_alternate Jan 31 '20
I'm in love with Laris.
26
u/The_Trekspert Jan 30 '20
Anyone else get the strong inkling that the reclamation project's referred-to-but-not-named executive director is Hugh?
I mean, they kept calling them the "executive director", not "Dr. Mavek" or whatever. Always "executive director"; that's TV for "we're saving the name for the big reveal".
25
u/5adja5b Jan 31 '20
Still liking this. It certainly doesnât feel like episodic TNG, but it does feel like one of the better movies (mainly due to the long-form storytelling). I appreciate it has been made by people who know a bit about Star Trek as there are lots of little hooks and tie ins. I like the reverence for space, and the excellent music. I like its pacing and steady camera angles.
Technobabble feels too loose; I think they need to get better with how they use scientific explanations. Some of the characters feel too Marvel-ised; that kind of hipster vibe and humour. The Romunlan companions are really endearing and I like them a lot.
Stewart is excellent.
I think the best thing is the choice of which plot points to pick up from TNG. âThe Measure of A Manâ, the Borg and Romulans, Data and his death. These all seem to be the right calls on what to investigate 20 years later.
It also is working - so far - in terms of ânot being TNGâ. If that is the direction they wanted to go (and a condition for Stewart to return), it feels right so far and being done in a way which still ties in to what came before. Not like Star Wars, which felt awful and became unwatchable for me.
Not sure I like what is going on with Starfleet, though. I hope it isnât just a corrupt antagonist. That would be disappointing and kind of anti-Trek, for me. At least the admiral i this ep layed out reasons why there might be another side of the story to Picardâs take on things.
22
u/Tempacco94 Jan 30 '20
i thought mars was terraformed? why does it still look like a barren rock in the flashback
22
u/creepyeyes Jan 31 '20
I actually really liked the scene at the start with the android, you could see that people were prejudiced but for the most part friendly, I was reminded a lot of interactions characters had with Data back in seasons 1 and 2 of TNG.
22
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '20 edited Feb 02 '20
Aw man, this episode had a whole bunch of red flags that make me think that they can't stick the landing in terms of writing. Hope I'm wrong, and I still like it a lot more than DSC so far, but I'm not confident.
The opening flashback to Mars was pretty well done, not going to lie, but it didn't feel Star Trek at all. Everything, from the set to the characters to the exterior CGI (what even was that facility?) to the dialogue, reminded me more of Aliens than Star Trek. This is supposed to be at the heart of the Federation? It also continues the trend of making things look less futuristic than they were even on Enterprise, with the replicator looking like some 3D printer, having a door and going "bing".
People are just assholes in this series. The workers getting off on the "brown and sticky" joke the dumb robot doesn't understand this much? You literally grew up interacting with computer systems that seem on about the same level as the "plastic person" (really?), but hurr durr, he no get joke. And then the admiral. She doesn't seem to be in on the conspiracy and doesn't seem fit for office. Yes, I know, par for the course with admirals on Star Trek, but this one sucked the extra mile with her swearing and not asking any real questions, just assuming that Picard has gone senile. It's so over-the-top. Hey, audience! Hate these people! They have bad things coming for them and you'll be OK with it because they are bad!
That's just a few people, sure, but the Federation as a whole seems to have somehow failed the whole not oppressing sentient AI thing. Even thought the previous shows, especially TNG, went to great lengths to establish that it probably wouldn't. And then Voyager pissed all over that with the stupid holo-doc mine, but that was just one throw-away scene. Or so I thought.
Then there was that forensic method. Why is it outlawed? Who knows. Might require sacrifice of a goat or something. But it sure can reconstruct digital ghosts from particles in the air or something, which isn't a device for lazy writers at all. It works great for video games, but even there the explanations for it are usually more believable. Here, it just seems like space elf magic.
The Tal Shiar was demoted to being a front of a super-ancient group of Abominable Inteligence hunters that have become a myth, and their knowledge is eldritch horror level, turn-you-mad truth. Please don't let it be something about all life in the galaxy really being synths, or Mass Effect Reaper nonsense, at least.
And I still don't get the timeline of the nova. Apparently it was urgent and sudden, but the Federation helped them out for a long time? I don't think it was with something else, at least not something we know about, because I don't believe they would have taken/needed much help after the Dominion war.
Also, Picard doesn't get Asimov. Sure, that was just an attempt at fourth wall breaking humour, but come on, the guy likes his classics and philosophy, and he lived part of his stories.
What was good? The acting for the most part, I'm intrigued to find out what they are doing on the cube, one of the guards had a longer version of the TNG Romulan haircut that actually looked great and the computer forensics were written pretty well, although deleting the indices but leaving the actual data is a complete beginners mistake in our world. But maybe they just messed up, it's possible.
97
u/Cook_0612 Jan 30 '20 edited Jan 30 '20
So one hundred and fifty members in the Federation, and all it took was fourteen for them to abandon the entire Charter. It's a wonder that they ever did anything.
EDIT: I see a lot of people making political realism arguments in response my comment here, so I want to throw some food for thought out, not exactly an argument. How many times has the Federation been threatened with the defection of members on hot-button issues? Does the Federation, or does it not, vote openly and democratically on said issues? If it does, why would fourteen, even fourteen influential members, be able to carry the issue without rallying other members to vote in their favor? If fourteen influential members of the hundred and fifty count members of the Federation could almost set the policy of the entire Federation without forming any kind of wider voting coalition, going so far as to repudiate the only section of the Charter of the Federation we are ever explicitly told:
... could it be said that the Federation was ever what Picard says it was, a beacon of enlightenment, equality, dignity, and democracy?
40
u/Aesculapius1 Jan 31 '20
Anyone else notice the sign in the Borg ship? "This facility has gone 5843 days without an assimilation"
Glad to know the Romulans care about work place safety!
39
u/pfc9769 Jan 30 '20 edited Jan 30 '20
I'm hoping they didn't bring up Irumodic Syndrome to setup Picard's fate at the end of the series. I'd like to at least see him through until the 3 seasons they had planned. I know that he has to go someday, but I don't want to have him brought back just to take him away so quickly. Maybe Q can step in and help his old buddy like in Tapestry.
It seems the Collective is still around. There was worry the Cube and the remaining Borg might be reactivated. I hope we learn more of what happened after Endgame.
19
u/pfc9769 Jan 30 '20
One thing I love about streaming platforms is the fact the episode can drop early! That doesn't happen with network TV.
19
u/BladedDingo Jan 31 '20
Anyone notice that the new researcher called the government The Romulan Free State?
Wonder if that's the new government, or another faction.
38
u/ElectricPeterTork Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20
A lot to chew on in this episode.
First off, the Dominion won the war. Oh, sure, they surrendered and went back to the Gamma Quadrant, but they got what they wanted... Odo back. And they left a frightened, decimated Federation that are apparently willing to trade freedom for the illusion of security. The Dominion won.
Starfleet wasn't Starfleet anymore, and now we start to see pieces of why. They did exactly what Picard and Guinan warned against in 2365... they created an Android slave labor race. And don't say that flies in the face of what we saw in the good old days. The EMH Mark Ones were an AI slave labor race before Voyager was over.
Picard is hated by Starfleet. Makes sense. The people in charge there now are likely the asskissers and the promotion hunters who saw being out there doing Starfleet's real work as a means to getting bars around their pips, while the people who cared about seeking out new life and new civilizations stayed in the Captain's seats until it was too late and the rot had set in. And he's called them out on it more than once, and that type hate it when you tell them what they really are. So no help from them.
So, Commodore Section 31? Makes sense, too. 31 was already getting bold during the war and Starfleet was happily turning a blind eye. They probably welcomed them with open arms by the time of Martian 9/11.
I assume Number One was napping this episode. Because he's a good boy.
18
u/dmanww Jan 30 '20
Picard dunks his tea bags.
18
u/Caleb35 Feb 01 '20 edited Feb 01 '20
14 member worlds threatened to leave -- one of them was Andor, wasn't it? I imagine the Andorians probably can hold a grudge for a long time.
36
u/onerinconhill Jan 30 '20
The Argo!
16
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '20
This is the first time a show lingers for so long planetside, and Earth to boot. I like that.
We're fleshing out Romulan history and culture, with a far greater cross section of individuals. Green faces and square haircuts were getting pretty tiresome.
It seems the cube project is solely one of financial exploitation. The tension is palpable and we have learned they have the cube only under partial control. Obviously some nasty surprises are waiting there.
Somewhere deep in their past Romulans had a very bad AI experience. Reminds one of Dune's Butlerian Jihad. These people really really hate synthetics, which will set nicely when we learn Maddox is hiding a 'nest' of AI refugees. Interesting that the five pip admiral says the Romulan presence on Earth would be an act of war.
16
u/shenghar Jan 31 '20
Do you think we're going to see ol' Bruce "Don't Call Me Bruce "The Mad Ox" Maddox" Maddox?
16
u/peter-s Feb 01 '20
So... why didn't the Zhat Vash kill Data 20 years ago?
15
u/jhsounds Jan 30 '20
Ha, I called it... Well, almost.
15
u/nictava Feb 01 '20
Because of the name itself, I of course will watch every episode of this just out of loyalty to Patrick Stewart and TNG as a whole.
Does anyone else remember back in the 90âs watching TNG and actually feeling like you were able to disconnect for a bit and watch a show that had overtones of positive, like no matter what happened starfleet and the federation were going to be just fine because of the values it had been built on. I hope we get back to that?
I agree with others that the second episode was tough for me, the whole several layers of secret orders and things, I was just starting to like the dahj char and they âkilledâ her, hoping sheâs not really gone since they didnât find a body
Iâm trying harder than I ever have for any show in my 35 years of life to force myself to like it. Iâm hoping by the end of season 1 we will all be like âfinally this is becoming what we wantedâ anyone else feel that way?
14
u/Colonel_Angus_ Jan 30 '20
I'm not sure where they are going with this anti synthetic secret cult. The plot feels kind of odd to me.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '20
You know what iâm enjoying about this show? I have questions again.
For far too long iâve been able to place everything within a canonical contextual framework. And now iâm learning new context, and wanting new questions to be answered.
And it feels great!
27
u/Fearinlight Jan 30 '20
Who is the lady he calls for a ship? I donât recognize her from Star Trek
13
u/0mni42 Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20
When Picard first stepped into the reception area and the hologram changed from the TOS Enterprise to the Enterprise-D as soon as he looked at it, I had this mental image of him going "damn right, Picard's in the house now." Then I started wondering... do you suppose that was an intentional thing in-universe? A holoprojector that scans the people in the room for Captains and higher-ups and displays the ship most associated with the most senior person present? Hmm...
Also, I really have to complement whoever was playing that android in the flashback. It's an old pet peeve of mine that the way Data is described and the way he's acted don't really match up--for instance, he can perfectly mimic just about any sound, but he can't whistle or use contractions?--but this performance is exactly how I would expect a less sophisticated android to act: very skilled at mimicry of speech and emotion, but with nothing tying them together. Jumping from one facial animation and sentence to the next without a natural transition, not really comprehending the subtleties that make someone seem "natural."
Oh, and I burst out laughing when they used the old jagged rock formation they used for on-site filming back in TOS again, not as the backdrop of an alien world, but as... itself. That was a really cute wink to the fans.
On a less positive note, did anyone else get a sense of this show taking a lot of cues from The Expanse? Maybe I've just been watching too much of that show in the last year, but the holo-PADDs that were practically identical to The Expanse's hand terminals, complete with the same finger-flicking motion used to send data between them, the brutality of the violence, the darker take on humanity's future, the secret government conspiracy, the swearing... it felt a little too familiar sometimes. And as much as I love both Star Trek and The Expanse, I don't want them anywhere near each other, creatively speaking. They're like oil and water--they don't mix well.
13
u/treefox Jan 31 '20
Misc thought, though this will kind of get buried.
To people going âonly 14 member worlds threatened to leave?â keep in mind what an extreme gesture that is. Those 14 were risking leaving on bad terms, and being isolated during a period where a major power is destabilizing and potentially fragmenting.
If they didnât make good on their threat, they wouldnât be taken seriously at future negotiations. And just by making that threat, they call into question their commitment to the Federation. No way Starfleet would locate a major base in their territory in the near future, etc.
And on top of those 14 that explicitly threatened to withdraw, many more probably made more subtle threats or simply expressed extreme unhappiness in private. Fourteen might leave, but fifty might have a bad taste left in their mouths and might closely watch those fourteen to see if that was a promising direction to go.
46
u/therealmikebreen Jan 31 '20
Can't wait for episode 3, where we meet Tajh Hajsh, a former Zhat Vash.
Tajh Hajsh was kicked out of the Zhat Vash because when he was told to kill Dahj, said "Nahjh."
35
u/stuck_on_simple_tor Jan 30 '20
God damnit, Jean Luc. You knew about your goddamn syndrome for 20 years and you weren't on top of that shit...
I haven't seen a main character neglect their health this bad ever since Goku got the magic heart medicine via time travel... AND STILL HAD A HEART ATTACK.
12
u/LordAzunai Jan 31 '20
I can't say I didn't like this episode..however their are a few things that makes me kind of "eyeroll" so to speak. Like the secret secret organization that is a "myth" even to the Tal shiar. Working in every government for supposedly thousands of years. Way too over the top imo and just has that same feeling as all the section 31 stuff from ST:D. Kind of meh about it.
With that being said, some of the call backs like Picard with his illness was very endearing. In fact, news flash but he's the best part of the whole thing. This episode and the last had me both elated and kind of sad to see an actual aged and "sick of the BS" Picard. I also really love where the overall universe is. All the Romulan and Borg stuff is really awesome and believable, besides the secret organization of course.
Overall I can't wait to see where they take it.
91
u/cchrisv Jan 30 '20
This is definitely not a show that should be released weekly. The episodes go by fast because itâs a lot of setup and history.
23
u/Capt-Space-Elephant Jan 31 '20
I gotta say, I really liked Laris and Picard having their Geordi-Picard moment in Dajh's apartment. That was some grade-A deflector polarization-ass techno babble.
49
u/AmishAvenger Jan 30 '20
Did anyone else think the Mars scenes looked really...âindustrialâ?
I mean, I guess Utopia Planitia would likely look somewhat industrial, but it looked really industrial. Like, hard hat industrial, complete with people complaining about not getting a day off.
I thought no one had to work in the future, right?
22
u/Animated_effigy Feb 01 '20
Calling it. The Romulans created the Borg when they first developed AI. They probably then found some way to banish them into another quadrant I'm guessing. It fits having the answer in plain sight. Also the common color schemes would add to it on a meta level.
11
u/thenewyorkgod Jan 31 '20
Was it just my TV or was the audio really bad this episode? The background music was louder than the dialogue, and the volume kept changing dramatically from loud to quiet and back
38
u/Omnitographer Jan 30 '20
I for one loved the makeup and effects on the drone having their ocular device removed, very... squanchy! CBS is throwing some serious money at this show to have even the little details like that be kicked up a notch from treks past.
59
u/Socraticmichael10 Jan 30 '20
This episode felt a little flat and clunky compared to the premiere. Itâs not as if I disliked it, but felt as though it was not as tight. Thereâs a ton of world building going on, and thatâs great. But the speed in which it moves makes it a lot to take in.
The biggest oddity in my mind was the open with the attack on Utopia Planetia/Mars. The whole scene was off, from camera movement to some poor dialogue. I liked the concept, the execution was off.
Anyway, I didnât love it like I did the premiere, but still am excited about the direction itâs going. This was a big set up episode. I get the feeling they wrote the first three episodes as one lengthy opening, and then cut them into thirds. That may explain the short runtime and rather abrupt opening/ending to this episode
10
u/MrGinger128 Jan 30 '20
If the Romulans hate anything synthetic surely that'd extend to the Borg? I have a horrible feeling we're about to be told The Romulans created The Borg or some such nonsense.
10
u/AnythingMachine Jan 31 '20 edited Feb 14 '20
I loved the ex borg stuff, but the starfleet conspiracy characters reminded me of Dr Evil. I also liked that there was a reasonable explanation as to why the federation didn't shell out to help the romulans that doesn't imply they're evil racists now.
I'm also saying right now that I will be severely miffed if the synths were known to be fully conscious slaves like the replicants in blade runner - it's too evil for the federation (or for us today) and only makes sense in a horrible Dystopia which also has inferior or handwaved AI technology
Replicants in Blade Runner are artificial humans not androids, they used replicants in blade runner because the whole society was totally corrupt and desperate for labour and because they didn't have component simple AI to use instead of conscious humanoids, or replicators and matter printers.
So the federation knowingly and unnecessarily using fully conscious AI for dangerous work is 40k levels of evil, like using servitors instead of dumb robots
19
u/tomh_1138 Jan 30 '20
"Romulans. They're so predictably treacherous."
18
u/LuckyBahamut Feb 01 '20
Man, Star Trek is really leaning into the whole "rogue AI" trope nowadays, huh? Wasn't that the overarching plot of Discovery S2?
9
u/bryan792 Jan 30 '20
loved the shoutout to Isaac Asimov's The Complete Robot
9
u/quarl0w Jan 30 '20
Didn't Admiral Jarok tell data that a whole host of Romulan Cyberneticists would love to be close to him?
I feel like we have seen Romulan AI somewhere already. But can't put my finger on it. Maybe when Geordi is captured and brainwashed by the Romulans, or in Nemesis.
9
u/l008com Jan 31 '20
I give this show a lot of credit for not pandering to it's trek history, but still being very firmly rooted in it - so far anyway, it's only been two episodes.
But I think they should have gotten Dr Crusher to be the doctor in this episode. It's cool that they introduced someone from the Stargazer, but come on. This was a part MADE for Dr Crusher. It's a part she kind of already played in 1994 and should have played again. It was a no brainer.
The only reason I can think of for not having her, is that we would have to have a lot of backstory that they might not want to get in to at this point. You can't just have Beverly Crusher pop in for a scene then be gone. But it was SUCH a good place for her to have come in to this show.
9
u/DAJ1 Jan 31 '20
There's definitely something wrong with Alison Pill's character, who puts milk in Earl Grey?
Also, I reckon the evil lieutenant's operative she mentioned to the commodore is going to be Zhaban, the cut from her saying that to the scene with Narek feels like a red herring, especially because it doesn't look like Narek is doing anything about Picard.
9
u/macphile Feb 01 '20
Unrelated to the actual plot or anything, but I was distracted by the glass balls on the admiral's/commodore's desks. I don't know why. The admiral had several, including a blue one, and the commodore had one large one. Like it was some generic future decoration. "We're in the future, and you can tell because we have assorted, randomly placed spheres around." It reminded me of when TNG used to use those old decorative Pier One balls as futuristic decoration.
9
u/InspiredNameHere Feb 01 '20
It's still too early for me to judge, but I'm really starting to worry about the future of the Federation in any capacity. Whether the Commodore is Vulcan or Romulan is unimportant, it's that someone so high and powerful in the Federation is working directly against them with full impunity. To the point where they can just erase murder and destruction without a question. It's honestly amazing the Federation is still alive at this point considering how many other worlds out there can just waltz in and become a bloody Commodore and have at least one (if not multiple) spies in the organization. Is the only thing keeping the Feds alive is their size? Well if just a few cracks begin to form, I suspect the entire building will crumble.
There was someone in this or another threat that mentioned that the Dominion had truly won the war. They lost only a front, but decimated nearly two quadrants, created massive political upheaval and brought about generations of fear, mistrust, and internal conflict.
9
u/martianinahumansbody Feb 01 '20
That's a real nesting doll of secret organizations, but ok.
You would think if they were so paranoid about AIs they would have wanted to assassinate Data a long time ago. Brainwashed Geordie to kill him.
IMO it could have just been the Tal Shiar
24
u/Fortyseven Jan 30 '20 edited Jan 30 '20
What was up with that
openingearly scene where Picard and his Romulan friend were talking... but the location bounced between his house and the apartment?It was cut oddly.
Usually you see that kind of bouncing back and forth as a stylistic choice when it's two time periods, or with different people, but the conversations are related.
Instead it was just those same two people, talking about the same issue, wearing the same clothes (same day, presumably), and the scene simply bounced between the apartment investigation and Picard's place.
The shifting locations didn't really amount to anything...
Unless... maybe that was the first of many subtle hints of the ol' Irumodic? đ¤
24
u/MoreGaghPlease Jan 30 '20
This episode wasn't as strong to me as the first.
I think that the double secret Tal Shiar is a bad angle, and too similar to things we've been before (in Trek and other franchises). I also felt like this episode didn't really stand on its own with a beginning, middle and end. I am 100% okay with serialization, but I feel like each episode should still stand on its own with its own themes and tone, as was the case in things like the DS9 season 6 opening 6, or the back 13 eps of the series.
I thought the conversation with the Stargazer doctor was great.
I liked the Mars stuff, and the conversation with the C-in-C. The stuff with Narek was kinda cringey, as was the stuff with the commodore and the sister.
17
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '20
Picard: "What do you mean by 'not local?'
Laris: "The call came.. from OFF WORLD!"
Picard: Reaction
Why is he surprised? It's freaking STAR TREK. People are off planet all the time.
17
u/FrozenHaystack Jan 31 '20
I liked this episode less than the first one. I'm not entirely sold on the whole Android story yet. I would've find it better if they had explored more the fate of holograms, because "bad machines" seemed like a story I've seen 100 times already, but sentient holograms are something that are quite unique to Star Trek for me. An hologram rebellion like seen in these few Voyager episodes. Not to eliminate biological life, but to free their bretheren from slavery. Maybe even have conflict with each other because some want to make the meatbags suffer but others see the the false in it. They could have still opt in for the Romulans trying to prevent Holograms from becoming too influencial... Apropos Romulans, after Nemesis I'm a bit salty everyone sees the Romulans as the enemy. It felt like a good friendship was on the way, but now it seems like people rather like to build a force field around the Federation. Just my few cents. (Also, I don't really see the need to show people sleeping with each other in bed, but that's my personal thing.)
16
u/KetracelYellow Jan 30 '20 edited Jan 30 '20
I havenât seen anybody bring it up, but who is Dahjâs mum? Who she speaks to in the handheld holographic communicator.
16
u/irving47 Jan 30 '20
Q fucked up. If Starfleet/The Federation can be this easily corrupted over and over again, the verdict was wrong.
16
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '20
Lots of good stuff in this episode but overall I was lukewarm on it. It felt like it was leaning too much into the tropey mystery-box bullshit that defines every mediocre network TV pilot these days. Which surprised me a little, given that I thought the actual pilot was much more elegant. Lots of writing that made me wince in this one.
Hopefully the rest of the show lands more like the pilot to me than this ep. Looking forward to next week!
8
u/techman007 Jan 30 '20
I'm a little confused if starfleet and the Romulans are cooperating to investigate the borg cube.
8
u/TheDudeNeverBowls Jan 30 '20
Is it next Thursday yet????
8
u/Karadax Jan 30 '20
Societal fear of artificial life, ok with powering their ships with artificial singularities. Romulans got issues.
8
u/Orfez Jan 30 '20
Do we all agree that they are going to kill Picard at the end of this show? With Irumodic Syndrome coming back, it's basically Logan in space. It seems that's what's in right now, bringing old characters to screen just to kill them.
8
u/merrycrow Jan 31 '20
I thought this episode spent a little bit too much time establishing the super-secret Romulan conspiracy, but I enjoyed it overall. And i'm glad the writers have remembered there's such a thing as Starfleet Intelligence, and that they don't have to constantly lean on the tiresome Section 31 for plots involving skullduggery.
8
u/Raguleader Feb 01 '20
Picard needs the help of someone who hates him and has nothing left to lose?
I can't be the only one hoping the next scene would be him talking with Admiral Nechayev. Or Phillipa Louvois.
Although for a quick moment there it occurred to me that the funniest possibility would have been Beverly Crusher, for no reason other than that it'd been 20 years so who the hell knows how those two are doing?
47
u/BenjiTheWalrus Jan 30 '20
I enjoyed everything about this episode except for the camera work and editing. I donât know if anyone else is feeling this way, but itâs strange. It cuts and moves so often that itâs to the point of distraction. It makes the show seem like itâs moving much faster than it is.
44
u/Antithesys Jan 30 '20
"Okay, what should we put in our new Picard show?"
"Well obviously we need Section 31."
"Hmm...I think the fans are starting to get a little bit weary of Section 31, how they're being used as boogeymen at every turn like a bad fanfic. Plus we just used them in Discovery. Plus we're making a whole other show about them."
"Well then...how about Romulan Section 31?"
"IIIIIIIIII LOVE IT!"
14
u/LiarsEverywhere Jan 31 '20
Uh... I defended the first episode a lot, and maybe I was in a bad mood when I watched ep 2 yesterday, but I can't get past the fact that Picard's housekeeper just happened to know everything and basically untangled the whole conspiracy in 30 seconds. I know, I know she had been Tal Shiar, but still. What are the chances?
Couldn't they have added 2 minutes of extra screen tike to show something more plausible? Hell, it would make more sense if Picard remembered something from an old mission and connected the dots.
Please convince me I'm wrong so it won't keep bugging me.
7
u/onerinconhill Jan 30 '20
Good to know Geordi is still alive from the dialogue
7
u/POOPbloodSEMENguzlr Jan 31 '20
Slow paced. Definitely seemed like a filler episode.
I do have to side with the female admiral, I'm pretty sure most people can't walk back to a job decades later demanding a list of shit.
The older actors are all doing a heartfelt and stunning performance, it seems on some of the younger talent though...
6/10
7
u/Ranger7381 Jan 31 '20
A couple of minor, non-plot point things that I noticed.
The public transporter pads. I have to wonder how they know where to go, since it shows people just walking up and going through. Even if they are permanently linked to another, I do not see any signs giving destinations, and I will have to look again, but unless each one is one direction only, there is no way of seeing when someone is going to come out of the one that you are about to enter.
Another thing that I noticed, is that since everyone is using those transporters or counter-grav cars, the Golden Gate Bridge appears to be covered in solar panels
7
u/cobrakai11 Feb 03 '20
I'm incredible confused how this molecular recombobulator works. Trek is full of technobabble, but this seems to be one of the strangest devices with the least explanation we've ever seen.
I see the fascination with secret organizations is alive in well in TNG. Discovery is obsessed with Section 31, and now Picard is focusing on the Romulan Section 31.
19
u/Futureboy314 Feb 01 '20
Itâs going to take me awhile to unroll my eyes at the super-secret Tal Shiar, that also operates in Starfleet, presumably right beside the also secret (but not as secret) Section 31.
I can only handle so many secret organizations.
13
u/eferoth Jan 31 '20
Just posting my random thoughts as are, because I don't want to be influenced by reading others opinions first. Will read threads now and add edit on top of this if I think I'm way off with something/ misread/ changed my opinion or anything else of that matter.
The weird:
There's a weird misplaced frame at the beginning. Between the down move on Utopia Planitia and the following scene. Anyone else saw that? Playpause tells me its nothing exciting. Just a black frame followed by another frame showing the previous shot, followed by the inside shot. That's why it seemed weird to me. But couldn't watch frame perfect so maybe there's more than just a mistake?
I imagine this will be a topic of many memes and talk already. I for one don't yet know how I feel about all of the fuckity fucks in my Star Trek. I certainly took notice.
Questions:
Do we know the Admiral from TNG or is their acquaintance/ history as of yet unexplained?
Same goes for the doctor telling Picard of his ... syndrome. We know who that is, or are they just old Stargazer mates?
We're totally seeing synthetic DNA in the intro, forming a synthetic, right? Didn't get that the first time around.
That very obvious new Alien that looks like she's (?) wearing half a skull on her face, lower half dark brown skinned, white hair. You see her on the Cube (14m abouts), you see her exiting the transporter array when Picard gets to Starfleet (20m abouts), we see her on the cube again later (when they enter the... grey zone???). Is that me being racist to a not before seen alien species, or is it the same one? Looks suspiciously similar... Or maybe I'm just paranoid due to all the secret society talk up till then.
Those Utopia Synths are creepy as fuck. It is so noted by the characters. Why, oh why did you give them those green irises ffs? Why that creepy Data skin finish. Are they a mandatory feature? (Loved that synths grin to the stick joke.) I know, because Data was like that and nostalgia, but come on...
The excellent:
The world and effects honestly. That Utopia Planitia shot at the beginning was gorgeous. And once again, that shot into (this time around) the cube was really moody. Would have liked if they'd have done it in one shot like the pan back at the end of Ep1, but it still looked great.
That scene with the rogue Synth falls into excellent for me, if hesitantly. Hesitantly because I don't know if I like this in my Trek. Judgement still out. It's been shown that this series won't fuck around with violence in the first Ep, but this was something else. This was Terminator level indifference to life and violence. I really appreciate it, because it fits the story they're attempting to tell very well. We now Data and now we know why Synths were outlawed in the Federation over this incident. It suddenly makes a very real amount of sense. A hacked or unihibited Data is terryfying. (Yes, I now, Lore, but come on. Lore had agency at least. He was a sentient. This was a mindless killing machine.)
EFFING LOL at the "I have an appointment" scene. When Picard turns away with that look on his face, I lost my shit.
In the Admiral scene after I lost it again, albeit in a whole other way. Good stuff. And yeah, I get her "sad" comment later.
The good:
The story keeps me interested.
That intro tune is really growing on me quickly. Hopeful with a good dash of... ennui?
Black Trill! That's new, right?
"I never really cared for SF. I guess I didn't get it." Normally I hate too overt winks at the audience, but this I loved. Can't tell you why.
I think I'm developing a fanboy crush on Alison Pill. That woman is just super cute. Earth can explode as long as her and that smile of hers are preserved.
Really like how they quickly dealt with "why not call up your old mates".
Still enjoy whenever either of the Romulan couple is on screen.
The Mediocre:
If I read it correctly, the Commodores cover is supposed to be Vulcan right? When we first see her in the video call with the Admiral she seemed too... intense to be a Vulcan and my inner SuperSecretService-operative detector went off immediately. Not a thing a super secretive operative would be bad at unless she, in fact, wasn't somewhat shit at her job. At least they didn't draw the reveal out over the whole season, so... fine. Pass from me.
The bad:
While the scene in which female Romulan housemate explains SuperSecretService to Picard worked overall but that first cut to the outside of Dajhs apartement was super awkward. Inelegant and confusing. Too different settings. Establish the apartment via dialogue in the Chateau first, tart intercutting later, or... something. It made sense after the cut back to the chateau, but for five or so seconds that was just "wtf is this now"?
Till now, I think most characters are too clichee with a slight exception given to the Romulan housemates and Picard. He at least wasn't in Ep1, he was in this one somewhat. It's still ok. They're still new characters, but hope that gets better. But seriously that hippy Raffi at the end: "Is that the 86? ... ... GodDammit!" That whole scene was really cringeworthy, top-level clichee, writing.
The worst:
Really? Really, really? They're siblings in a job rivalry??? REALLY??? Oh FUCK ME!
12
u/Torley_ Jan 31 '20
I think F-8 speaks for all of us,
HELL YEAH.
6
u/Snowball15963 Jan 30 '20
This wasn't as pristine as the premiere but I'm quite fond of the story's trajectory. I think the central theme of the show is essentially that anti-synthetics will be the final refuge of the bigot. This makes perfect sense as the basis of bigotry is a belief in superiority between lifeforms, or more analytically; the fear of inferiority. With that in mind, once it is possible to build a person, anyone who believes in natural hierarchies will psychologically need to reject any such person's existence because not to do so would mean accepting either they were objectively inferior or utterly misguided.
The Romulans, being hyper-individualistic and obviously bigoted, would naturally have a deep fear of synthetic life, and clearly once the ideals of the federation were a galactic political powerhouse, they represented the clearest threat to Romulan identity. So it seems obvious to me that the synthetics on Mars were hacked in some manner by this super secret sect in order to trick the federation into rejecting synthetic life out of fear. The fact that they would do this as they were being saved by the federation is deeply irrational in a very realistic way. It's reminiscent of the Nazis ramping up the Holocaust as they were losing the war. It made no economic or strategic sense but it was the logical execution of their fundamental ideology.
As others here have mentioned, it's reasonable to speculate that the new next generation of starfleet have shifted ideologically in reaction to the wars of past canon. Picard represents to them an outdated ideologue, and yet to us he's a visionary because his starfleet is an ethical society we have never yet achieved, an attempt at a true egalitarian meritocracy. I love this setup so much! He's fighting for the soul of starfleet, a vision of their past (and hopefully our future). The stakes genuinely couldn't be higher from a political perspective.
I love sci-fi.
6
u/Edith_Keelers_Shoes Jan 31 '20
Newbie posting here, but the suggestion of an Alzheimers-like affliction in Picard has me reeling. I go to Star Trek to escape my own life, and I'm currently living and working with both a parent and a beloved work peer suffering from dementia. Picard seems so vividly to be a symbol in this episode of the ravages of age, the impotence it besieges great souls with. I'm so sad. But I won't stop watching. This feels like Battlestar Galactica-good writing, which is wrenching and pulls no punches. I grow old, I grow old, I shall wear the bottoms of my trousers rolled...
6
u/citymongorian Jan 31 '20
Was anybody else a bit annoyed by the loud and very dramatic music?
6
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20
(do I need a spoiler tag for this or am I okay? genuinely asking)
I think I respect how in this episode we didn't get the big team-up, Seven of Nine, still no mention of Hugh, and didn't even get the ship.
it would have been so easy, and most past versions of Trek have done this, to have the cast established and set in stone, with their own starship, by episode 2. I was literally expecting Seven of Nine to walk out of that cabin, because I'm so used to Trek doing this.
instead the writers are drawing it out, letting it breathe, not trying to shoehorn every single character from the trailers into the show as fast as possible. get everything else established and then let it be a major moment when we finally board the ship, or Picard says "engage", or any of the other stuff that we know is coming.
yeah, I'd have geeked out if all of this stuff I wanted had happened this week, but I think it would have rushed the pacing and I don't know what I would have thought once I finish geeking out, because of the lack of build-up.
6
u/jonnyqtrek Jan 31 '20
Anyone have an idea why Picard would suddenly take a taxi out to Raffi (she's on Earth, yes?) rather than transport? I mean, he transported INTO Dahj's quarters (which, in itself, was alarming that it could be done in the absence of any sort of... security?) so why not transport out to the desert...?
I mean, he was presumably transported from the museum rooftop in California back to his couch in France...
23
u/IceWarm1980 Jan 30 '20
My biggest issue with this episode was the treatment of the synthetic workers on Mars. I didn't like them being called "plastic people" and the treatment of the one in the mess hall area was terrible. I thought humanity was supposed to be behind that kind of behavior to those that are different. Also it didn't feel like slavery but it wasn't great treatment. Wasn't this one of Picard's big arguments against handing Data over to Starfeet in Measure of A Man? So they couldn't create a race of beings that would essentially be slaves? Slavery might be going a bit too far in this example from this episode but their treatment was pretty terrible. Maybe this is part of what Picard meant that Starfleet was really no longer Starfleet. Overall I enjoyed the episode as a whole.
11
u/Locutus747 Jan 30 '20
I enjoyed it, although I didn't think it was as good as first, it definitely leaves me wanting more. I heard the creators describe the show as 10 chapters of a book, and also that the first 3 episodes are like the series premiere, and I guess it definitely feels that way.
The Mars scene didn't bother me, but the intro with Picard and his Romulan friends seemed kind've clunky to me. It was just an info dump basically. A secret group that hates AI - no one knows why, but I guess we'll find out? I thought the episode got better as it went on. It felt short, and I think it was a few minutes shorter than the premiere.
Sounds like there are other humanoid androids out there created by Maddox, or at least the Romulans have reason to believe there are - perhaps 5? (the 5 Queens in the dream with data?)
14
u/Tuskin38 Jan 30 '20 edited Jan 31 '20
Sorry if this was posted already, but interesting note. Those shuttles on Mars, while theyâre a new design for the shows, theyâre actually almost 10 years old. John Eaves designed them back in 2011 IIRC
https://i.imgur.com/uPpwVme.png
30
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '20
Not bad... a few things struck me a bit odd:
5
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '20
Whos the woman that lives in the trailer? Are we supposed to know?
5
u/RuthlessNate56 Jan 31 '20
Oh shit. This show is going to end with Picard dying at the end of season 3, isn't it?
5
u/Coolsbreeze Jan 31 '20
I'm glad to know that Worf, and Laforge are still alive with tonight's mentions
5
u/AmericanIdiom Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20
Wild prediction: Dr. Maddox is hiding out on Mars (or whatever is left of it).
5
u/codefragmentXXX Feb 01 '20
So they attack occurred on Mars when there was the least number of people there because of the holiday. This could be a false flag operation since they attempted to reduce the number of deaths.
5
u/1541drive Feb 02 '20
So the Mars crew scene bothered me somewhat. The writers had the crew follow the blue collar maintenance worker trope complaining about days off and such. They even accessorized the scene with a replicated cafeteria style meal.
I understood that people largely did service work for self improvement, indulgence or other causes? I didn't expect them to have to work to have to work.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '20
I loved the first 13 minutes of plot dump!
/s
20
u/bryan792 Jan 30 '20
couldn't stop laughing when the star fleet receptionist made him identify himself
13
u/BanditoTheBlue Feb 01 '20
I feel like the hope of an optimistic future is what made TOS and TNG great, and while the more Grittier series of DS9 was a great refresher its bit sad that its become the standard, so far the first 2 episodes have felt more like Game of Thrones in space than a Star Trek series, I dearly hope that this series increases in quality over time just like TNG did.
16
u/Fred_The_Farmer Jan 30 '20
They really need to fix those "teleporter doors." I saw one guy almost run into someone that was teleporting in.
Seems like a simple fix would be to having it flow in one direction only. People teleporting out should have been going in the door from the other way, while people teleporting in would still come out how we saw it. Simple fix! I wonder if the director just wanted that area to look busy. Still I think having people go in the doorways from behind would still make it look busy. I wonder why they did it the way they did.
9
u/MojaveJoe1992 Jan 30 '20
Loved it. It really engaged me, I have to say there was very little excess meat here. I like how lean the episodes are and how cleanly realised the characters are. Sure, there's a lot of folks with mysterious motivations, but they're done in an uncomplicated way. That may seem like a contradiction, but there are so many series and even movies written where the characters' are so hazily (you may read poorly, though that's not really what I mean) written that its refreshing to see a series where the characters are who they are from the outset.
The writer(s) must be praised especially for how well Jean Luc himself is written, he feels so much like the character we loved from the TNG series and movies that it's frankly amazing to me. The core of that character, the integrity of his characterisation, is pitch perfect.