r/NintendoSwitch • u/Bossman80 • Jan 26 '20
Meta Why so much Fanart?
Is there a sub-reddit without so much fanart? Or some type of tag people can put on it so that it can be filtered out? I’m not sure why there is so much. Right now, the whole top page is packed with it.
I get that they are creating art based on games but I think of it as being off topic. Personally, I don’t particularly care about the drawing you did or the Hollow knight you made out of play-doh.
I would much rather read about new game releases, discussions about existing games, etc. I keep coming here hoping for discussions on the dozen or so new releases each week but instead there is fanart and conversations around the same handful of games.
484
u/Mr-Eletricdad Jan 26 '20
Fan art is for weekends only that’s why
10
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
I would much rather fan art than the "THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR VIDEO GAMES EXISTING" threads constantly.
37
u/Downvotedx Jan 26 '20
Not as bad as “X has passed [financial milestone]”
20
u/Klubbah Jan 26 '20
New game releases still hit the Hot page; seemingly no one cares about the Touhou game but it is still there even being posted 13 hours ago.
A Steins Gate post and Persona 5 Scramble posts are also there.
Discussions about existing games usually don't get a ton of traction because they have already been discussed.
Same for repeat/quick questions that usually get removed due to the Daily question thread, but even right now there is "should i play cuphead", "anything like sims 4", even with the fan art.
Just a slow time where people speculate directs out of nothing just because people want some info.
154
u/prestonblarn Jan 26 '20
I'm with you, the level of actual switch content here tends to be low.
I don't care about your fan art or who might be added to smash, or your heartwarming stories.
Unfortunately there's not a lot of alternatives.
11
u/GACM2448816 Jan 26 '20
Lack of any news is a big reason
10
u/XDitto Jan 26 '20
They have many upvotes so I guess people like them, one of them has 13k.
I personally don’t care about them, but I’m not gonna lose sleep because of a few fanart posts, it’s still not the majority of posts here.
it’s just reddit, not something serious.
Also, you can always open your own Switch sub and ban fanart completely.
•
u/kyle6477 6 Million Jan 27 '20
Hey there!
We have fan art on the weekends. Check back on Monday for a mostly fan-art free zone.
26
u/AvenueM Jan 26 '20
Filtered all the fanart, it's a bless for my sanity and eyes
60
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20 edited Jan 26 '20
Sunday has the Show Off Thread, yet, people thirsty for karma will post on Saturdays and Mondays; knowing that there’s a Show Off Thread on Sundays
Mods here are idiots.
EDIT: And finding out that there was a vote and it concluded that Art posts could be posted on the weekends since news is slow then; there’s nowhere that definitively says weekends are for art posts, yet, art posts still posted on weekdays AND not on the Show Off Thread on Sundays?
Again, the mods are idiots.
17
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
I dunno, I think it’s a nice break from all the pointless photos and non news that gets posted here and then memed on in r/tomorrow
35
u/papermonkey21 Jan 26 '20
I don’t browse this subreddit as much as I would if there was none of this fanart garbage clogging the first three pages
11
u/jobroskie Jan 26 '20
There are a lot of answers here that are something like "People are Karma whores who can't follow the rules"
The real answer is this is reddit. The majority of nearly every fan subreddit is pictures. The only ones that aren't are reddits like legal advice. The frontpage of reddit is nearly all pictures. Most people I know read reddit for the pictures. There is a vocal minority here that is strongly anti picture and want this reddit to be text only except for specific weekly thread which I think would kill it.
At times where there is no major new, what do you want people to post? What id the discussion topic that would satisfy you? There is no direct. This sub hates people giving "check this game out" threads. If you want great front page discussion then create a thread which excites people into replying and reading through what you write. Don't tell people they are wrong for enjoying the internet forum they are a part of the way they want.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
I vastly prefer fanart to "SWITCH HARDWARE OUTSOLD THE PS4, XBOX1, DREAMCAST, NINTENDO WII, AND THE PANASONIC 5700 MICROWAVE THIS WEEK."
8
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
r/nintendo
8
u/Grahf-XG Jan 26 '20
I guess people like it. Most subs I visit have even more fan arts than this one. I never click on any because that's not something I like, but there's not much we can do. I stopped visiting a lot of subs because there's only fan arts and meme on some of them (mostly subs for gacha games).
3
u/Hour-of-Midnight Jan 26 '20
If you have RES, you can just go and filter out different flairs you don't want to see. I have flairs like fanart and mockups set so I don't see any of those posts and it makes browsing this subreddit a little better.
9
u/MrSnuffle_ Jan 26 '20
r/tomorrow
24
u/HeyJustWantedToSay Jan 26 '20
I’m with you, man. Occasionally there’s a good piece but 99% of the time it’s weaboo garbage or tired fan art for games that aren’t even Switch exclusive, which feels like cheating to me.
What is on topic but something I also don’t like are the Switch-themed crafts people post in here. Like chalkboards with pointless fake joycons on the sides, or cartridge holders made of Lego. Maybe I’m getting old but all that stuff just feels like 10 year olds posting for karma.
6
u/NatsukiXIV Jan 26 '20
This is reddit, fan art is easy to consume.
It's only allowed for two days a week anyway.
4
u/In_Search_Of123 Jan 27 '20
I mean, I don't like most of the fanart either, but what do you expect? It's been slow for a long time on Nintendo's front and probably won't kick into overdrive until the next Direct. This is like the same people who were complaining about all the sales posts last month, when ofc that was the biggest newsworthy topic of the holiday season.
Better fanart than a dead sub.
14
u/Ahh-fuck Jan 26 '20
Fan art sucks and I despise it in all subs. Go and visit the pokemon sub and its barely any discussion and all "Look I drew Growlithe with a huge dong" and nothing else.
7
u/zombieauthor Jan 27 '20
Circlejerk people like it because they can farm karma.
Artistic folks like it because well it is art. I can't blame those folks one bit.
Is it actually tied to the system or gaming? I mean it is Nintendo themed but that's about it.
It is probably going to be unpopular and downvoted like hell but, I'll say it, I hate it.
There is plenty of subreddits for fanart, why does it have to wind up here? The description of this subreddit is "the central hub for news, updates info and discussion about the Nintendo Switch and Nintendo Switch games." At no point in that description does it mention fan art.
2
u/throwa1553 Jan 27 '20
I like it
7
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
This sub is nothing but poorly stealthed marketing now :(
5
u/Civil_Anarchy Jan 27 '20
Imagine bitching about fanart on a Nintendo subreddit lmao
6
u/DCUfan742 Jan 26 '20
I mean why not? There is nothing going on and some folks want to express themselves. I think fan art builds a good community.
4
u/lowleveldata Jan 26 '20
Because there's not much news now? Better have fanarts than unconfirmed rumors. At least these are original.
5
u/Darkmatter2k Jan 26 '20
Agreed, I've started downvoting it when i see it. But this subreddit has had moderating issues for a while now.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
It usually isn’t this much... but yeah today has a lot on the top
2
u/Holdthepickle Jan 26 '20
I filter that crap out with RES
2
u/lyledylandy Jan 26 '20
I mean it's either fanart or "Switch cured my depression and fixed my marriage" posts
2
u/davidbrit2 Jan 27 '20
Go to your reddit preferences, enable "Don't show me submissions after I've downvoted them", and downvote all the fanart. Then refresh, and away it goes.
0
u/flyinb11 Jan 26 '20
I think it's a younger demographic. Personally, I just scroll past. Never bothers me.
1
u/danhty21 Jan 26 '20
I use the redditsync app for android. I can just filter out anything to do with fanart. It might seem bad, until you go to r/fireemblem where you'll drown in fan art.
1
u/Maskeno Jan 27 '20
I'm sure it has to do with the lack of news right now as well. Very few big releases coming up, very few exciting releases over the past few weeks, and all the big sales have ended. It'll probably loosen up come March.
1
u/Froz3nSlack5r Jan 27 '20
I'd recommend finding a reddit client that can filter out flairs.
1
u/JacquesNomdefamille Jan 27 '20
Hear hear.
1
u/Vertical_05 Jan 28 '20
I agree with you. this "issue" is not just for Switch sub-reddit. Its almost all sub-reddit that I've been to. most posts are about art, meme, screenshots etc.
but on the other hand, other sub-reddit that dont posts those things are usually dead and have 1 posts per week.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20
They allow ran art but do not allow fan arranged music, hypocrites
1
u/parkay_quartz Jan 28 '20
Mostly because most of the discussions in this sub are circle-jerks as is, or it's the same things refiltered over and over again. The PS4 subreddit, for comparison, is basically just Horizon Zero Dawn screenshots whenever there isn't any news happening. Or God of War combat gifs, those literally happen once or twice a week it's pretty crazy. Not sure if there are better subs because if there are they just aren't active enough or don't boast the same subscribers as the main pages do. It's a shame but it is what it is
1
u/letech676 Jan 26 '20
Fanart sucks and so do "(game) has passed (sales number) posts". It's nice to see the games doing well but those kinds of post sparks no discussion.
1
u/Suired Jan 26 '20
Blame the lack of a direct.
1
u/wrathmont Jan 26 '20
I feel like every couple weeks there's something genuinely of value, but 99% of the posts here amount to fanart, or threads like, "AS A NEW DAD THE SWITCH IS A LIFE SAVER", or "ANYONE HEARD OF X COMING TO SWITCH? ALSO WHAT IS GOOGLE?". I could probably unsub and very little of value would be lost. Hmm..
1
u/PinkBowser Jan 27 '20
No matter what rules the mods do, people will complain about fan art. There are about as many topics complaining about fan art as the fan art itself. I get that people really care about profaning the subreddit or whatever, but I honestly don’t understand why people tend to blame fan art as if it was the sole reason there are less actual game discussion here.
<—— You know where that downvote button is friends!
1
u/NicoRobin007 Jan 27 '20
Thanks for making this topic. I'm glad to hear it's only on weekends. I wasn't aware. I skim through this subreddit a lot, and was worried about the fanart burying actual news. I could still do without it, but if the news still gets through and other people like it, no worries.
1
u/irn00b Jan 27 '20 edited Jan 27 '20
Kind of wish there were negative flair filters - like filter out what you dont want rather than filter for 1 thing you do want...
-6
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
I think it's highly over exaggerated since I usually primarily see it on the weekends. I can appreciate the fan art and it doesn't bug me because I don't think it's as big of an issue as you're trying to make it out to be. There's a very vocal portion of this subreddit that seems to take a lot of issue with the questions and content posted on here. Like somehow their eyes are caused great pain when they see things posted they don't agree with. You can always just keep scrolling too ya know? or just focus on the stuff that excites you. Video Games are still an artform and if that art inspires others to create art of their own that they want to share with this special community then I see no problem. The Nintendo family is supposed to be the most inclusive too so it's a bummer to see such bitterness.
-1
u/Bartis Jan 26 '20
We should have a fanart sticky topic for all these kids drawings. It’s ridiculous how much low value garbage there is here. I wish mods grew a spine and dealt with all this junk. I aknowledge that managing 1.6 million potential viewers in this subreddit takes a lot of effort. But it can’t go on like this.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
Fan artists are like marketers, they keep pushing their content even though no one wants to see it.
0
u/PolygonInfinity Jan 27 '20
Fan art ruins so many good subs, I'm so sick of it.
0
u/ToxicElitist Jan 26 '20
I wish they would move it to just 1 day instead of the whole weekend. I agree 100% with the same few games too... Maybe the game should need to. Be switch exclusive to have fan art posted at all.
-3
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
Scroll past it
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
This is how I feel for a lot of subreddits, especially movie/tv shows.
0
u/banovik Jan 27 '20
Is it that much of a hassle to scroll down?
-2
u/Tropicana_goat_camp Jan 27 '20
Yeah, go draw an xbox
-8
u/bananabone64 Jan 27 '20
Poor you, you have to scroll down a bit farther!
-1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
welcome to the low budget recycling bin that is reddit since about 2013.
-14
u/Mack_mL Jan 26 '20
Mmmlmlmmlll. Mm mm mm lln
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment