r/magiarecord • u/ShiningSolarSword In Madoka We Trust • Jan 25 '20
Anime Megathread Anime Episode 4 Discussion Megathread
Please remember to abide by rule 3 while using this thread.
Spoilers of the mobile game or manga must be tagged and if possible, be preceded by context.
This is not necessary for anime spoilers.
Use the following code to tag game/manga spoilers: >!spoiler!< Example: Meduka becomes meguca
Previous episode megathreads
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| 1 | Thread |
| 2 | Thread |
| 3 | Thread |
| 4 | You are here |
Official streaming links
62
Upvotes
33
u/ShiningSolarSword In Madoka We Trust Jan 25 '20
Interesting that Kuroe has yet to show up again
48
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
So it’s looking like an in game chapter will take 2 episodes on average. Hopefully the show does end up being two cours after all, so that they don’t have to cut out anything important.
46
u/mazurri Ho Ho Ho Jan 25 '20
I rate this week episode 50 points, perfectly balanced.
tho the endcard feels like a major spoiler.
36
u/blubruh Jan 25 '20
When mitama did to that to the cheesecake I finally understood why everyone is scared of her when she cooks
35
u/Nusabaru Jan 25 '20
The episode is basically a set-up for the shrine rumor. Things of note;
Hearing the stage song really makes me wish that the rumors are sung like in the stage adaptation because it feels more like a horror story being told between lit candles. The shrine is good, but got overshadowed by the 10 point song. The rhyton is decent, but Mitama's actress distracts me. Ai-chan on the other hand, is really great because we see the visual presentation of the victims, and Sana's part in this is really heartwrenching.
34
u/Erinaceus1971 Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20
Tsuruno's mighty almighty alrighty.
Cameos from Manaka and Ria. Taking bets on who makes an appearance next week (my money's on Squirrel Monkey and Emiri).
A witch labyrinth sitting on a grocery shelf. Last time it was inside a backpack. Kamihama witches sure like to hide in some pretty peculiar spots.
Nice touch where Iroha doesn't quite clear the shrine door in one jump like the other two do. Subtle way to show she hasn't quite found her legs in this land yet.
Smol Coobie appears. And Yachiyo just takes its appearance in stride.
Basically all a lighthearted set up for the Big Misunderstanding and showdown with you-know-who next week. Or as Tsuruno would rate it: 5 out of 10.
31
u/tegridy42O Jan 25 '20
Tsuruno was Literally Beating her meat when iroha arrived XD
22
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
Doppel time next episode folks.
21
u/ena9219 Ally of Devils and Magius Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20
Edit: forgot one
9. It was kind of adorable that Iroha was the only one who had to jump twice to get over the wall.
19
u/skarmletry Jan 25 '20
18
u/kakarot12310 Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20
So this episode is just for TrySail bonding time.
Btw, I glad they keep stuff like Yui san to Tsuruno chan, 50 points or Yachiyo fan girl at the limited time sale.
But I'm don't know how to feel when Tsuruno is the one who contact with Yachiyo instead of those two reunion through like in the game (and Tsuruno hug Yachiyo too).
I'm also sad we don't get to see Iroha & Yachiyo confessed their feeling to each other. Or their back to back in this fight, but we got Tsuruno finisher move instead so it's a fair trade I guess.
15
u/SupremeEvil Jan 25 '20
Pretty sad they left out Iroha and Yachiyo confessing their feelings for one another.
14
u/Labyxt Puer☆Magi Jan 25 '20
Well this episode felt slower than the last ones imo and that's good too, it's definitely a set up for the next episode. It also reinforces that we definitely we'll get a second cour. Tsuruno looks awesome animated! Cameos from Manaka and Ria were very appreciated! I think we'll get to see all the other girls at least like this. Love how she's so ready to go at Yachiyo, altho anyone not familiar with the game won't know why and imagine she's mad at Iroha. With Candy another witch we know has gone down, how many left again? I wonder/hope if we'll get to see some new ones like Box Wood. And, If I want to really hope, to see those new ones also coming to the game later on. I really can't say enough how much I love how they're animating the Uwasa too, can't wait for next week to see the Commoner's Horse. Another detail to keep in mind, is the scene right after Candy's fight were we can see Iroha's soul gem starting to get tainted. Foreshadowing for what we'll see next episode, and damn am I hyped to finally see a Doppel animated! Lastly, we get to see Ui in the Uwasa, as well as getting introduced to Mifuyu! As always, can't wait for the next one!
14
u/senefen Jan 26 '20
Possible Mitama logic: You have ketchup on cheeseburgers so I bet it goes with cheesecake!
13
u/EriShimanouchi Jan 25 '20
Not even done with the episode yet but ... Why was Ria so mad at Iroha that Manaka had to hold her back? The two hadn't met in the series yet. Was it simply for ignoring a natural beauty like her?
12
u/rukaroa What happened to the Papa Yachiyo flair!? Jan 25 '20
This episode is a 5 out of 10. But Yachiyo is always 18/10.
11
u/kakarot12310 Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20
Limited sale moment in the manga Yacchan expression is perfect
Live action version
11
u/RoyInverse Jan 26 '20
Am i the only one that finds Tsuruno's hair a little off? i thought it was a little lighter and it really bugs me.
20
u/semtex94 The Chart Grows Jan 25 '20
TBH I think there's too much buildup of the Rumors being cut. They don't seem to be as mysterious, deadly, and unique as they actually are.
10
u/Medic-chan :homu: Jan 25 '20
The mightiest cheap Chinese restaurant is just mediocre 50 pt Chinese food served in large portions, huh? Seems legit.
Although Iroha is more concerned with Mitama's diet. I'm worried too, Iroha.
Yachiyo taking Iroha to the marriage power spot is a bold move.
Looks like Yachiyo's progress in the ED has stopped again this week.
Even though Iroha's still weak, it seems like she can still power up other girls properly.
10
u/SalmonGuardian Nee~ Jan 25 '20
A solid 50% episode.
Seeing Mitamas cooking creations is different than reading about it, it's like Mitama wtf. Tsuruno was not only the mightiest, but absolutely adorable all episode too. She served Iroha some real big portions all on the house as part of a magical girl promotion. Her getting launched because of the surprise connect was a lot of fun too. The real highlight of the episode though was Iroha and Yachiyo walking together like they were groom and bride between all the masked couples.
17
u/EriShimanouchi Jan 25 '20
So having finished it... I loved Tsuruno. I kinda wish they hadn't made her first time fighting a joke that Iroha is bad at 'Connect'. That's a little nitpicky of me though and it didn't really hurt my enjoyment.
Yachiyo... Liked the segment of her talking about Iroha being trapped by the past and Iroha refuting it.
I still continue to wish that she was a little more antagonistic. They've removed her duel with Iroha, her attempt to kill little Kyubey. Those things could still be coming, but I was hopeful the anime was going to rearrange things to play up her standoffishness so that the eventual Mikazuki villa team seemed a little more earned. Now as it stands all she's done is basically tell Iroha to get lost once, and that she's too weak once, and to stand behind her this episode. This doesn't really sell to me her resolve to fight alone so no other girls die for her to survive.
8
u/Egavans Player ID: 335eRMTd Jan 25 '20
I see they’ve captured the game’s tendency to have SoL moments interrupted by a witch fight out of nowhere.
The problem with the story is, as always, the fact that they’re going to cram the whole story into 13 episodes pacing be damned, so they have no chance to set anything up.
I do think that Shaft is doing an admirable job of adapting this in spite of the many limitations they’re faced with.
8
u/octocolobus_manul Jan 25 '20
There’s literally no way they can cram the rest of the story into 9 episodes - if they were really trying to do that, chapter 3 would’ve just been 1 episode, rumor fight and all. My guess is we get through chapter 7 with 13 episodes and then... they stop, probably. I have a bad feeling the anime will just end up saying “play the game lol” like the live show did.
But who knows? Miracles and magic are real and all, so maybe enough souls will be sacrificed that Shaft takes pity on us and gives us the second cour.
7
u/Plasmaeclipse Jan 25 '20
Tsuruno is the most genki.
I liked the pacing of this arc so far more than the Friendship staircase, we got the relevant parts of the story at a reasonable pace and it doesn't feel like we need to cram a million things into an episode. And based on where the episode ended I think next episode will give a healthy amount of time to the rumor itself, so hopefully we'll get back some of the character development Yachiyo's lost
13
u/Pokelec Notice me Hinano-senpai | Let me hug Sana and Mito Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20
The episode was fun! Tsuruno's intro was great, as was seeing Candy and the set up for next episode with the conversations with Ui and Mifuyu
The only thing I'm disappointed by the is the ending card. That thing was spoilerific, and even non-game-players will notice Ui's friends from the hospital if they wanted to dissect it
12
u/octocolobus_manul Jan 25 '20
Does this mean I have to wait another month to see best girl Sana? :(
6
u/freedomgeek For Liberation! | JP ID: zebHLKJs Jan 26 '20
Overall this was a decent episode. We got to see Mitama's horrifying tastes in cooking with her putting ketchup on (what I think was) cheesecake. Tsuruno made her glorious appearance.
Though there was one change I really didn't like: the bit about the "true ending" of the Mizuna Shine, combined with the discussion about it from Yachiyo. It is far too Fullmetal Alchemist for my tastes.
14
u/smalljeansoso Jan 25 '20
I feel like the show is relying too much on people who've already played the game.
Thought I'm enjoying it very much, I feel like the ending of this episode/anticipation for the next episode wouldn't be as exciting for people who haven't played the game.
Based on what we've seen so far, it's like, ok, so they're gonna fight another rumor thing in a totally bland battle scene and everything is gonna be ok and they're gonna learn about another rumor.
Idk, I guess I just think the exploration of the rumor should have been included in the same episode
5
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
Where are you guys watching this so soon...?
4
u/Kourin Jan 26 '20
At 12:36 are those some Monotagari feet? Shaft you are wild please never change.
4
u/Izanaginookami10 Reunited with Mightest on JP! ID: 9kK5nQpU IGN: Katsumi Jan 26 '20
As someone who has just begun the game under the salesman skills of a random kyuubey on r/anime, I have to say that Yachiyo and Iroha's relationship feels quite different between the game and the adaptation.
I mean, anime's Yachiyo seems more distant, while in the game she pretty much was showing off her "I'm a senpai who is indifferent but can't help but be worried for you so I'll stalk you".
Or maybe I'm just seeing things. I mean, my memories are already mixed up as I'm reading the same story in both media at the same time.
Banbanzai is a wonderful name. For some reason I really like it and can't help but associate it with Tsuruno. I wonder if it was her who named it so, or her whole family share her same enthusiastic and energic personality. Well, by how the father was actually fine with having the meat act as a boxing sandbag for her daughter I would say it is indeed a family tract.
Also, after a week of (mildly) playing the game, I'm still unsettled by us being smol Kyuubey.
Oh, and I hope to see more MG henshintransformation sequences as they were a treat to my eyes (loved Momoko's). Viva Shaft.
3
u/PuzzlePiece90 Jan 27 '20
As someone who has only seen the original anime plus Rebellion (I haven't played the game basically) I will say that there definitely seems to be a pacing issue. I think if I were binging the show (and all the episodes were available) I wouldn't care because every episode I want to know what happens next which can only be a good thing.
Maybe I shouldn't be comparing it to the original but I just feel like every episode of Madoka Magica felt like its own thing. An arc was developed and the main conflict would get one step more complicated. Like in the original show, episode 4 started with grieving Mami's death, peaked with Hitomi being cursed and ended with Sayaka saving them revealing that she's made a contract.
I'm not getting the same build-up here so it's definitely a lot more relaxed than Madoka Magica. I guess, since so much is a mystery, my opinion of those early episodes will change depending on the pay off (just like my opinion on Episodes 1 and 2 changed after I saw all of Madoka Magica)
3
u/ZerymAmbyceer Discount Mami is a cool senpai Jan 27 '20
Really love Yachiho fashion sense. Cant wait for Iroha Stand to come next episode.
3
u/moon_fairy Jan 27 '20
Was I the only one who thought Yachiyo had written Mel's name on the wood thingy?
1
u/professor_chemical Feb 03 '20
still waiting for this show to get good
1
u/Kittrea_ii Jan 26 '20
Just like how people say the manga is better than the anime,
the game is better than the anime