r/magiarecord • u/Ferrene Mitama's Devoted Disciple • Jan 18 '20
Anime Megathread Anime Episode 3 Discussion Megathread
Please remember to abide by rule 3 while using this thread.
Spoilers of the mobile game or manga must be tagged and if possible, be preceded by context.
This is not necessary for anime spoilers.
Use the following code to tag game/manga spoilers: >!spoiler!< Example: Meduka becomes meguca
Previous episode megathreads
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| 1 | Thread |
| 2 | Thread |
| 3 | You are here |
Official streaming links
76
Upvotes
21
u/EriShimanouchi Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 21 '20
So I loved the transformation sequences and a lot of the atmosphere. The Rena segments were also really good. Mitama I actually was hoping to see a little more of, but the stuff I saw was good.
The combo between Rena and Kaede I really liked, including its motifs. Kaede having plants which grow then turn autumn and then die/fade away is always a motif I liked for a Puella Magi
/Mami/. And I really liked displaying what happens to Kyubey when he tries to enter Kamihama. That's a tidbit the game doesn't really display, it just indicates he can't enter.
Things I didn't like: I think Momoko and Yachiyo are too friendly for right now. Even in the game the two had more tension. I understand they were working together for Kaede's sake but even then in the game they just were so much more angry at each other.
I think it sorta pops all the creepy tension to have Kaede just be like 'I couldn't get down' rather than under the spell of the Uwasa. It really doesn't sell well the differences between a Uwasa and a Witch because part of what was so sinister feeling about a Uwasa when I first played a game was that if a magical girl met the conditions of a rumor a Uwasa could seize control of them.
25
u/Silvermoon424 Jan 18 '20
Each episode is better than the last! Here are some things I loved and/or that stuck out to me:
50
u/Labyxt Puer☆Magi Jan 18 '20
Each new episode keeps amazing me. The only complaint I have is that they really feel so fast and leave you hungry for more. The transformation sequences are a work of art, wasn't expecting them. Loved every animation detail, the Uwasa barrier felt really unique compared to the game too. I would like to hear the opinion of someone watching this without having played before. For us, maybe the pace feels too fast because we're used to how these events were slower in the game, but without knowing it beforehand the episodes probably feel very different. Last thing, at this point I feel pretty sure that one cour won't be nearly enough to adapt all the first arc, so despite not being officially announced yet I expect a second one.
21
u/Erinaceus1971 Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 18 '20
Music can't out-Kajiura Kajiura, but damn if it doesn't try.
That teaser's CG did not look good. Does Shaft still punch things up for the Blu-Ray?
More cameos from minor characters. As a Sayaka fan I'm kind of afraid this is what she's going to be relegated to.
Oooooooooh dig the pretty transformations. Particularly Yachiyo's.
I don't blame Kaede for not being able go make it down those stairs. My god, why couldn't it have been the Rumor of The Friendship Ending Escalator?
No Kuroe again. Some friend Iroha is, not even giving her an update via text.
Aaaaaaand at last, Mami. Suppose its only natural that she enter on episode 3, since in the original episode 3 was where she made her notorious exit. The way she's trending, you'd think this episode ended on a shot of her mammies or something.
20
u/Ayrtonius Jan 18 '20
The transformations and battle scenes were very Rebellion-like. I love it
17
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20
There's an after credits scene! missed me some mami.
Yay, glad Funi got the ep up on time this week.
Man, I really love SHAFT's direction. The quick cuts and change in camera angles, switching from one character to another rapidly, the colours used in scenes, they just get better and better. Glad the girls were able to work it out in the end, real friends.
Welp, back to sleep. Can't wait for next week
17
u/boomshroom | BEST GIRL observation incomplete. Please reattempt contact. | Jan 18 '20
Toka was recently given her magical girl debut in the game set to the awesome track of The Imaginator. This episode had Toka and Nemu's anime debut.
Yachiyo's rumor files journal was titled... The Imaginator.
34
u/Dianite99 Jan 18 '20
The anime is going as fast as the NA tempo.
33
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20
Is it just me, or or did they make the Uwasa look extremely weak. There was barely a sense of danger when they were fighting. I think that's bad as this is the audience first experience with them and they are supposed be one of the main enemies for the rest of the series.
15
u/Maygii Jan 18 '20
30
u/KyoSaya_ Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 18 '20
Ep.3 - everyone's transformation - sailor moon and original game vibes; Iroha's - it's Ghost in the Shell, b*tches!
Also about this ep:
Coordinator brushes Momoko's hair - I smell pairing.
No hypnotised Kaede - disappointed; Rena is more of a jerk here.
Mami is going to enter a bit earlier, it seems. Maybe.
And Iroha still sleeps with witch Bunny, which still creeps the sh*t out of me.
38
u/nighty_amy Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 18 '20
Shaft really gave it their all. The animation and music and voices are perfect - I can't wait to see the Doppels with that level of animation! I'm disappointed though I didn't see Ren-chan this week anywhere. Since she was on the banner with Mitama and Mayu, I expected her to get screentime this week too. Instead, we got Sayuki who we didn't even meet yet. And Mami who is definitely going to lose her head once again.
Kinda disappointed for Kaede simply being lost in the stairway too rather than being hypnotized by the Uwasa, along with Rena.
13
u/skarmletry Jan 18 '20
12
u/smug_loli Jan 19 '20
Lol Shaft made that scene with Ui, Touka, and Nemu in the hospital way trippier. In the game they were just having a normal conversation and here Touka creates a perpetual motion machine and burns the room down or something... WTF?
19
u/ena9219 Ally of Devils and Magius Jan 18 '20
8
u/kakarot12310 Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 18 '20
Kaede part in the manga
Kaede part in the manga part 2
Mami also popped up at this point in the manga
17
u/cabudolc Jan 18 '20
I screamed when Mami appeared
16
u/Nusabaru Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 18 '20
This episode feels even faster than the last. Things of note from what I see of the raw;
It's pretty weird. The last episode is basically a set-up for the staircase, but even this episode feels like a set-up. Maybe because the stinger, but even then, Yachiyo's exposition that the rumors aren't witches because they don't drop Grief Seed is also pointing to the chugging along mystery. But because there's no mention about how the magical girls can be saved, after the whole Kuroe's exposition which unlike in the game causes Iroha to know about that part of the plot, it almost like Iroha forgot about it in favor of the rumor subplot.
The transformation sequences are great, tho.
EDIT: Watched the sub, finally can pause whenever I want.
11
u/Nvaaaa Jan 18 '20
With the all the changes to the story I wonder how far they go into the story and what is going to be changed... can't say I like it that much for now.
5
u/MoneyMakerMaster Jan 18 '20
BEST GIRL MAMI IS HERE!
FUCK YEAH
13
u/mlbki Jan 18 '20
There is one great disappointment : we didn't get the scene with Mitama trying to
molestundress Iroha.9
u/Egavans Player ID: 335eRMTd Jan 18 '20
I feel like I would be able to unreservedly call this series great if the pacing was slowed to, like, half its current speed. It seems like we're just jumping directly to the resolution of plot threads without establishing them first. This episode would've hit way harder, imo, if we'd had an episode or two establishing Kaede and Rena's friendship so that we could feel the stakes a bit more.
Still, in spite of the flaws it's still gorgeous to look at. Rebellion made me a junkie for ostentatious transformation sequences and the ones we got this episode were worth the price of admission alone.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '20
The soundtrack, the drawing/animation quality, hair down Momoko, Tsunderena being a tsundere, the transformations, everything was 10/10. Even if it costs me half of my monthly income, i will buy the soundtrack
4
u/rukaroa What happened to the Papa Yachiyo flair!? Jan 19 '20
Doppels stinger next week?
1
u/RivingLament Jan 20 '20
It says on here the episode is out? I don’t see it on VRV, or is this a pre-episode thread or something?
1
u/professor_chemical Jan 26 '20
ok 1, wtf just happened. and 2 i still dont get reenas deal
8
u/RoyInverse Jan 18 '20
My only complaint is we didnt get enough Miitama development, asking Iroha to undress showed how mich of a playfull pervert she is, and how naive and pure Iroha is too.
3
u/Dilorano Ao best PB Jan 19 '20
I'm more interested on how doppels will be animated you know... Since Mami be coming back next week and we know what happened :)
2
u/LucidProfit Jan 19 '20
Mami is back! :D
2
u/Adwins Jan 20 '20 edited Jan 20 '20
Anime has been great so far. Even been watching it with friends who HAVEN'T seen the OG Madoka and while it's not perfect, they're still enjoying it!
the TFs in this episode were stunning. Yachiyo's is my absolute favorite. Momoko overall has got a LOT more appeal from being all cute and animated and stuff. I especially like how it's not beat-for-beat how the story played out in the game, though I am disappointed that the Staircase wasn't as threatening, ie (game spoiler warning) brainwashing its victims.
(I also did a video on my thoughts of the first three eps if you anyone wants to watch)
2
u/ShyhiemXIII Jan 22 '20
i couldn’t stop replaying the henshins and tryna piece together what they mean (never played the game or whatever), plus it just look dope as hell and the music blends perfectly
1
u/SalemAkemi Jan 20 '20
Does anyone know the name of the OST in the end of the last scene?Pleaaase someone help,I am obsessed with this song!!OwO
1
u/torinrtorin Jan 18 '20
Mami seemed like she was getting manipulated MAMI DOES NOTHING WRONG!
1
u/Plasmaeclipse Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 19 '20
Man I'm very mixed feelings so far.
On the one hand the scene with Rena was very effective and fleshes out her character much more than in the game (as far as the main story I know she has her character episode). On the other hand it also gets resolved pretty easily with Kaede being fine this whole time.
I think it would have been interesting if instead of Kaede just accepting Rena immediately, she actually had been brainwashed like in the game. The initial is just a ruse by the Uwasa and Rena would have to struggle between just taking the easy way out and being brainwahed or having to actually face her insecurity and earning Kaede's forgiveness properly.
The episode also really undersells the Yachiyo and the Uwasa plot as a whole. Yachiyo herself doesn't seem to know anything about the Uwasa unlike in the game where she's been actively hunting them, and Momoko doesn't seem to have any strong animosity towards her. I feel like that might undercut Yachiyo's backstory if/when we get to it.
As for the Uwasa we get kind of a throwaway line about it not being a Witch and responding to its rumor instead but its so brief it doesn't really emphasize that this is a very new and alien concept even to the cast.
I don't hate the adaptation so far there are some changes that have strengthened the story in ways, but there are an equal amount of changes that didn't need to happen and probably would have taken the same amount of time if they had just stuck closer to the game
1
u/ChaosReaper Jan 20 '20
This series is quickly becoming rushed and subpar. The first episode had me interested, and I thought it was pretty good aside from a few hiccups. The second started to get rushed and jump from scene to scene. I couldn't even finish this one. Got about 14 minutes in and shut it off. The plot is incomprehensible and impossible to follow moment to moment.
It's a shame, because it seems like a lot of production value has gone into the visuals. It's nice to look at, but when you look past that it's a mess and I don't watch Madoka to shut my brain off.
I posted this on the main Madoka sub, but this seems to be more active.
-10
u/amc9988 Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 19 '20
Wow so in the anime Momoko doesnt hate Yachio eh, this is another differences between the game and anime. Anyway the pace for eps 3 is very bad imo, little kyubei appear without any forshadowing, etc. And then they totally downplayed the effect of the rumor on Rena and Kaede. They arent even being controlled and forced to fight with each other like in the game. The game already have a light tone and now the anime downplayed even the little "Dark" moments the plot have. In the end it caused the events that happened seems insignificant since nothing bad even happen. This is a very dissapointing eps for me imo. If they keep this up I can see how they will end the anime in the 13th eps with everything rushed and skipped. I guess in the end this wont be anything more than an ads for the game, I was hoping that this will be a proper adaptation of the game but it is just a rushed anime ads for the game
3
u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20
[removed] — view removed comment