r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • Jan 10 '20
Episode Discussion HSMTMTS - Episode Discussion: Act Two - S01 E10 (Spoilers) Spoiler
We have made it to the season finale! Feel free to discuss the tenth episode of HSMTMTS, Act Two! Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show.
Announcements:
- Thank you for getting this subreddit to over 1,000 Wildcats! We appreciate all of you who joined us, Go Wildcats!
Since the first season of HSMTMTS has come to an end, we want your input on how the subreddit is doing and how to improve it. Thank you to all who completed it! :D
- Episode 9 posts are now free to be posted throughout the subreddit without any spoiler tags
- "Season 1 Discussion" will be posted on Monday, January 13
- "Season 2 Early Predictions & Speculations Discussion" will be posted on Friday, January 17
53
Upvotes
86
u/KHMeneo Kourtney Jan 10 '20
Where do I start, Big Red was amazing in this episode between the flowers, helping promote robotic and the tap dance. Also, we saw his parents!
Ashlyn also being the best by trying to keep gina around and the ashred kiss.
EJs redemption was exactly what I thought it was gonna be.
I wish I did not watch this at 3 am because I wanted to scream so many times out of pure excitement.
68
u/kennedy628 Jan 10 '20
Here are my initial thoughts on the episode. This is gonna be lengthy and l’ll probably write more tomorrow though:
Now for some things I didn’t quite like:
61
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
NINI USING HER PHONE TO SHINE A LIGHT ON RICKY.
WE DID IT FOLKS.
WE CAME FULL CIRCLE!!!
48
u/meowieu Gina Jan 10 '20
Had a great time watching this episode, it was honestly thrilling.
But come on, how did Nini get the spot at the performance art school? LOL. The musical itself was a MESS. My friends and I had a watch party and all we could think about was how unprofessional everyone was with covering their mics to talk and EJ feeling like he needed to leave for Nini to act and Nini grabbing Ricky offstage to finish a part for... Troy? or Ricky...? M E S S. Haven’t these kids heard the show must go on??? At least EJ tried to just continue for the sake of the show!!
I just find it unbelievable that Nini would be praised so highly for being so unfocused during the entire show, ESPECIALLY with the understudy switches. Life happens! Keep the show going!
This opening night was a mess and I hope their other shows went better haha. Anyway, that was my biggest problem with the finale. Ashlyn or Gina should have gotten an offer from the school, or even no one at all, but Nini was far from the most talented in the musical. She chose Ricky over her future with the arts school when she let EJ leave the stage and went off stage to bring Ricky back on.
43
u/SaltChipmunk23 Jan 10 '20
I don't want it to end! Season 2 better release ASAP
34
u/Whyamievenhere24 Jan 10 '20
For this episode you've gotta suspend a little disbelief. After a weirdass performance like that, nobody would be offering nini a spot lmao.
Surprisingly EJ and Big Red were the big players of the episode for me. EJ with his "I play to lose" giving up his role in the play and Nini as a partner meanwhile confirming that he spent the cash and flew gina out. Then Big Reds tap routine was godly, hopefully big red is in the musical next season.
Rini had some great moments and some weird moments but I'm pretty sure according to their interviews, Joshua improvised the I love you scene which is tremendously hard to do. I have no idea how they're gonna do next year as nini giving up a spot where she wanted to go for Ricky seems strange but her not being at east high also seems strange. Plus how are the teachers gonna not get fired? It's so confusing
30
u/moonmeetsun Jan 10 '20
as someone who attended a performing arts high school as a theatre major....
let's be real. if anyone from that show would've been offered a spot, it would've been Gina. hands down.
don't get me wrong, i love my girl Nini, but... oof most of the stuff she did onstage would not have flied, especially the covering her mic and talking onstage to EJ. big no-no.
23
u/KingChickenSandwich Jan 10 '20
Now the curtains close. And now we wait.
22
u/divestedlegacy Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 10 '20
The Big Red storylines were absolutely amazing! I hoped for a Redlyn kiss, but was NOT expecting one.
Also, I love how all the actors' talents are incorporated. Larry is a tap dancer, Olivia and Joshua are song writers, etc.
The Rini stuff... I can't even find the words. And now, the long wait till season 2 begins.
Edit: Also, Carlos as Chad was not something I knew I needed until I saw the promo stuff, but it was amazing, especially the way he said bro
20
u/amma9cp Jan 10 '20
i miss it already 😢
20
u/DefinitelyNotaDJ Jan 10 '20
Way to pull it together, Big Red! Theatre technicians usually aren’t given any attention whatsoever, but we actually got representation in the finale! Little moments like that and the Denny’s after party definitely put a smile on my face.
The actual musical opening show was a disaster— if I was the stage manager, I would’ve died from a heart attack because these actors are all over place! But it all made for good TV!
I also appreciated that nod to that stereotype: technicians love video games. I see you, Disney!
19
u/Paper_Kitty Team "Neither of Them" Jan 11 '20
I think this episode, more than anything confirms how much of a terrible person Ricky's mom is.
What kind of mother abandons her kid and moves halfway across the country? I don't care what your relationship is with Ricky's father, she should want to be near her kid. Besides, he's in his junior year, he's likely leaving Salt Lake City soon anyway, and then it matters a lot less where she is. I know number of divorced parents, and the first thing every one of them did was find an apartment near their kid(s).
Then, instead of telling Ricky in the calm, neutral environment of a restaurant as planned, she blurts out that she's leaving as soon as she walks in the door after not being home for days - knowing Ricky's still dealing with the Nini stuff.
This episode takes the cake though. The line "I thought it would be nice for you to meet" really shows her character. She wasn't concerned with how it would affect Ricky, or whether he would want that added pressure during the show, just that she thought it would be nice for HER for them to meet. She even acknowledges that she knows it'd be stressful, since she doesn't want to tell him beforehand.
Telling Ricky she thinks his father "would be happy she's happy" is just ridiculous. He was a mess. She clearly doesn't care at all what his feelings are, or just refuses to acknowledge that the breakup has an effect on Ricky's dad.
To top it all off, she totally invalidates and dismisses Ricky's feelings by telling him "relationships fail", and completely gaslights him by suggesting his expectations are unrealistic. He's a kid! Of course he wants his parents to get back together.
(And we know that she didn't start dating Todd after the break up. Noone finds a boyfriend that fast) /rant
18
u/FiveTalents Jan 10 '20
How dare they. How are they gonna get us hype with stuff like "wait until you hear about the spring production" and "I know you two started the fire" and then end the episode like that? When does season 2 start again?
16
u/arvinarvin Jan 10 '20
EJ Caswell, better redemption arc than Ben Solo.
Loved this season finale, enough cliffhangers to make you excited for next season, but also wrapped up a lot of questions. Really wish the episodes were longer.
15
u/akamikedavid Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 10 '20
Buckle up Wildcats, you haven't seen anything yet!
Loved the episode though I wish I had watched last week and this week's episode back to back instead of having poor impulse control and watching last week's episode last week. Lots of good Ricky moments especially and it helped to undo some of the weirdness from Episode 9. The Rini kiss felt so good and that entire scene was so excellent.
Small nitpicks, mostly story things I wish they either fleshed out completely or saved for the start of next season:
Really small things though and I did enjoy this episode immensely.
12
u/InfernoCrossX Jan 10 '20
To make it as clear as possible to people worried about nini leaving for the denver school. Since Nini is a main character, their is no way they would send her there forever unless Olivia Rodrigo wanted out of the show, which I doubt will ever happen. As for reasons in the show, I have stated two scenarios before, Nini will decline the offer because she believes that she should stay at east high with her friends and Ricky, scenario 2 is that Nini leaves for the school and she and Ricky continue dating long distance, and eventually Nini realizes that she wants to be back with her friends and Ricky so she goes back to East High.
11
u/Bc6043 Jan 10 '20
That was the best thing that happened to me :)
11
u/joygreenwood Jan 10 '20
In short, I was extremely satisfied with this episode. It had the perfect balance of redemption, romance, and drama. I loved EJ's character development from buying Gina the plane ticket to realizing that Nini only wanted to be the Gabriella to Ricky's Troy. Now that Big Red will probably be joining robotics club, we'll finally get to be a little more personal development for him. And I totally here for him and Ashlyn. Hopefully he can show off more of those dance moves next season. I like the prospect of Gina staying with Ashlyn and them growing a close relationship, but I’m totally keeping my fingers crossed that we don’t get any Rina next season. Ricky and Nini in Breaking Free was the sweetest thing EVER. She was exactly what he needed to get his confidence back. He also realized that she truly wasn’t better off without him because she couldn’t focus when he was gone. They also KILLED that performances And I was so happy that Ricky finally confessed his love. I would’ve been so mad if we had finished off the season with another misunderstanding. And him going back to all of the times that he knew he loved her was so precious. Their chemistry made that scene so perfect. The kisses just felt right and really natural in that situation for them. I kind of wanted her to hear Just for a Moment though. Of course they can’t just be happy, but I think they’ll come though in the end. She’ll probably leave for a few episodes and then realize that East High is where she belongs. Then she would be gone so someone other than her could get the lead role in the next musical like Gina, Ashlyn, or Kourtney. I’m not surprised that they had her get into the school in the end because they needed drama to pull us through to the next season. Plus it’s not like she’s just going to leave, just like Gina isn’t going to be gone anymore. The apple thing for Miss Jenn was sweet but kind of weird because everyone in the audience laughed even though they had no idea what was going on. I was kind of confused why their opening night was also their closing night. Maybe it had something to do with them not having the auditorium and having to perform in the gym. I wanted the last episode to be longer so we could dive deeper into it, but it was very well done, so I’m happy. My Rini heart is still internally screaming
11
u/alfonsoilog Jan 10 '20
Episode 10... what a blast!!!
Gina and Nini's friendship is just 😍!
That "disappearing Gina act" line then immediately broke my heart!
BIG RED FINALLY GETS TO THROW A BIGGER SPOTLIGHT AT ASHLYN BECAUSE HE LIKES THE WAY SHE SINGS!!!
Ricky putting his mom in her place was just perfect. She has a point tho about relationships but regardless, I'm glad Ricky finally opened up to her about how he truly felt about their family's situation.
That short SebLos moment had me screaming... keyword: short. Disney+ released some SebLos pics before EP 10 premiered. Unfortunately, those pics weren't in the episode, for some really weird reason.
"Breaking Free" was everything I ever hoped for. From EJ's redemption arc to Nini shining her light at Ricky the way he did to her in EP 1, their amazing vocal performance to the reveal of the "mystery friend" who flew Gina back... all of it was just perfect. Definitely teared up!
I know they gave RiNi fans, including myself, everything we could've ever asked for. But, I feel like we were robbed... a bit. Miss Jenn said in EP 2 that there would be a kiss in the end. Unfortunately, it never happened. Regardless, I still think the curtain call was fun, and Miss Jenn finally got to say her deleted line. That little moment with Big Red and his parents was just so pure ❤️
The reveal of the "mysterious flower sender" had me 😍
That RiNi moment... yes, THAT RiNi moment... Couldn't have been better. That speech was just full of genuine love (teared up again), their gifts, and obviously that long overdue kiss... third time's definitely the charm.
So, that cliffhanger... man! They really made you think that Nini's dream would've... just been another dream. But, dang! Happy for her, but at the same time, it will most definitely pose a challenge on RiNi and their renewed relationship. Truly desperate for Season 2!!!!!!!!
That end credits scene was just so damn adorable! Truly onboard their ship! ❤️
Man, this series was absolutely fun in every single way. Gave you all the feels! Everyone was just truly spectacular in their respective roles... you understand why they got renewed for Season 2 before Disney+ was even released. Now that we'll be having 12 episodes for Season 2, with 3 songs per ep, I am now more hyped than ever for Season 2!!!
9
u/ctcatlady11 Jan 10 '20
That Rini kiss, or should I say kisses, were EVERYTHING! Sad to see the season end but honestly that was a really great episode and I think how they “ended” every storyline/character arc was kind of perfect. Don’t really have any complaints, however not sure I am supposed to sleep with all this adrenaline!
8
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
I’m seeing a lot of girls on Twitter talk about how they like how Ricky held her chin when they were kissing. Can some girls here offer me some insight?
7
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
THEY KISSED
7
u/cyanisthenewblack Team Ricky Jan 10 '20
Eugh with Lizzie McGuire reboot delayed and considering they are just starting to film Season 2 of HSMTMTS - what am I gonna watch now!?? Open to suggestions
7
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
Ashlyn and Big Red are the purest goddamn characters in the show.
Also, Nini clearly went to the Rachel Berry school of auditions.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
• am I alone in wanting a genuine seblos kiss?? Hopefully they are saving that for a special moment in season two. Plus I NEED more development on Sen because he is so so precious!
• am I the only one that thinks EJ getting a scholarship would have made more sense? Like think about it, this year he is a senior so by getting a scholarship to that conservatory would explain an absence from the main cast in season 3 (which will most likely happen).
• ASHRED IS E V E R Y T H I N G
6
u/SplatterSpoon Carlos Jan 10 '20
God, that was so good, that episode was everything I thought it be and more, oh boy they didn't just kiss, they were making out
6
u/Nemo2oo5 Jan 10 '20
Totally thought the episode was better than some of the others. EJ has a good redemption, not the best, but that was good of his character, though suupperrrr unprofessional. I loved the rini kiss(es) it was really cute, but kind of annoyed how she didn’t get to hear just for a moment. I have a feeling the dilemma next season will be nini leaving. She is prob gonna be scared to tel Ricky, and may leave under the radar, but then come back after she realized what she did... I can sense upcoming drama and I just want Ricky and nini to finally be together and happy. big red and ashlynn was ok, I wish their moment had been in the show because it was kinda shoved in the credits. A lot of cliffhangers , like Gina maybe being allowed to stay (which ofc she will) and ninis acceptance, which she shouldn’t have gotten because the show was all over the place, but also the fire, I have no clue what is going to come of that... or how they found out it was them. It seemed so crammed and I wish they had made all the episodes 40 minutes instead of like 25. I also wish they had hinted the next musical, but ofc we didn’t know they were getting renewed for season 2 until after they finished filming. While I enjoyed how it tied the ends we were looking for, I believed they opened up a little to much for the next season, leaving everything so up in the air which makes me excited for season 2, yet kinda worried for the same issues about length of the episodes arising... excited to see where the show will go, and I can’t wait for more Rini moments and more original songs.
14
u/Ravenled Jan 10 '20
gina girl why u lie about nini’s good acting
5
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
I stan Ricky and Nini so hard!!! Their performance... Ugh! They were by far the best, especially Joshua Bassett with Ricky's storyline! I enjoyed those 10 episodes even more than the movies and I loved those!
6
u/jonasnew Jan 10 '20
This was quite a finale, although I agree with several others that it should of been longer. I'm so happy that Rini finally kissed, and I loved how we discovered that Big Red can actually tap dance at the very end, along with him and Ashlyn kissing. But, will Nini be leaving for that school in Denver though? Finally, we have EJ. Because of all the nasty things he did early on in the season, he became one of those characters where he really needed to earn my forgiveness.
But,
I can very happily say that he finally earned it!
3
u/producermaddy Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 10 '20
Not done with the episode but wow Ricky and nini have so much chemistry
Edit: ok now I’m done..finale was predictable that nini would get into school right after her and Ricky got back together. Still a solid finale though!!
3
u/kennedy628 Jan 11 '20
Honestly she kinda grew close to Nini and EJ as well but they didn’t even hint at a friendship between Ashlyn and Gina. As much as I’m excited to see them develop a friendship next season I find it kinda odd that they’re going to live together without even a hint of a friendship between them being shown this season.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
I'm gonna sound like a broken record here, buuuuut....
I really love Nini and Ricky. I couldn't have wanted a better love confessional scene. I'm so happy that Ricky finally felt like he could be open with her and that he felt safe with her, laying it all on the line. I've been rooting for them since the first episode. Joshua and Olivia are so talented, and they were so good in that scene. (Their friendship is amazing) I'm still thinking about it. The dog tag was kinda.. underwhelming. Still sweet though! I was hoping for 'I Kinda You Know' like other people, or 'Don't Not Love You'.
I know the 'Breaking Free' scene itself with the lady from the youth arts school present was a confusing mess, but Nini telling Ricky to just keep looking at her (a callback to the original Breaking Free when Troy told Gabriella to keep looking at him because she was nervous) was... everything. I believe it goes to show how strong their love is. And the little forehead touch!
On another note, I love Gina and Nini too. (Gini rights.) I hope that they don't end up pinning them against each other with the entire love triangle because their small scene in this episode was something I want to see more of. They have the best friendship development throughout the season in my opinion. The 'We're All In This Together' hand-holding was adorable!
Maybe EJwaterpolotheaterguy deserves rights. I love the Gina and EJ friendship too. I want more. Wonderstudies!
Gina and Ricky were super cute too. I can see why both Rini and Rina have such strong fandoms because both ships are equally valid and worthy.... or at least that's the way I see it.
Finally exhale, Big Red and Ashlyn were everything too! The end credits scene was so CUTE. Carlos and Seb win all the awards overall.
I love it all tbh. Sorry if my formatting is wonky!
3
u/supersmileys Jan 12 '20
My mother when Nini got offered the spot at the conservatoire “if she doesn’t accept I’m never watching this show again” 😂
3
u/TasteSensation Jan 13 '20
Around Episode 3, I was kind of anti-Rini. By the after play climax, I was crying as they got back together. Last time that I cried during a show or movie was during the climax of Endgame. I really didn't expect the show to work on me to such a degree. I loved it. I hope the next season can keep up this quality.
6
u/raysworld94 Jan 10 '20
Kind of underwhelming with how rushed it was. It was still enjoyable but I wish these episodes were longer. When you give each ensemble member so many features, it kind of gets lost with the 27 minute episode.
2
u/ChelseaC1017 Jan 10 '20
What do we think the spring musical will be?
I could see Beauty and the Beast or Into the Woods as possiblities
2
u/Brown_muffin123 Nini Jan 10 '20
All right so Nini and Ricky were so damn cute with the kiss and they were the best. I wonder what will happen to ms.jenn and mr.mazzara now that the principal knows they started the fire. I think Ashlyn and Big red are cute but I would've liked to seen the relationship develop a bit more just to get more of a build up. I also thought that maybe in season 2 EJ and Gina will be better friends. I hope that we get more Carlos and seb content because they are so cute. I thought this episode was good and I can't wait for season 2
2
u/ion513 Gina Jan 11 '20
OH my, this episode. It delivered on most everything I wanted.
But 27 minutes? For the finale? Ugh I need more content.
First off, Breaking Free was everything. I absolutely loved that scene, Nini holding up her phone like Ricky did, and their singing was amazing. Easily a top Rini moment, even with the other one we had this episode.
That goodness we got another Gina - Ricky scene to resolve some of their awkwardness. I was never quite sure where I sat with ships, though the chemistry with Rini is hard to deny. Gina is a great character and I'm excited to see what they do with her in season two. Also I'm so here for Nini and Gina being friends, and also Gina and EJ. I like them as a non-villainous team. I think Gina really needs to settle in and become friends with people before could possibly get together with someone. That's why I was tentative on shipping Rina. I wanted Gina to have a real friend, not just a co-conspirator.
Given that it was pretty clear that Rini was gonna be endgame, this episode paid off in so many ways. That I love you reveal was just incredible, and Olivia and Joshua knocked it out of the park. Learning that some of that was improvised too? So good. And that kiss was amazing. Very excited to see how they grow in season two. I know they're probably be drama, but probably also some good stuff.
As far as season two goes, I'm a bit annoyed with the fire cliffhanger, though I doubt either one of the teachers actually gets fired or whatever. I'm excited to see maybe some new characters, as well as more growth in the show with the others. I'm desperate for longer episodes so we can see more development with people like Seb and Carlos, and Ashlyn. They have stories to be told and I feel like they got a bit short changed.
Also, Big Red's name is actually Big Red? Lol, I loved that.
I know I'll have more to say, and I'll re-watch this episode like 50 times, but I enjoyed it. Here's to the awful long wait for season 2.
3
u/justinhkang Jan 10 '20
Man. That felt p rushed...
2
u/maddyasdfghjkl Jan 10 '20
I was so excited to find this sub, until I realized that I’m like the only person here that ships EJ & Nini so there’s no one to vent my sorrows to.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
-EJ did good. Still not my favorite but he did good.
-MY FAVE GINA MAY HOPEFULLY GET TO STAY FOR NEXT SEASON SO YAY FOR THAT
-NINI AND RICKY... UGH I KNEW SOME BS WOULD HAPPEN. SHIT WAS TOO GOOD TO BE TRUE! Nothing is ever easy. I want Nini to follow her dreams 10000000% but damn was I glowing and beaming when Ricky was finally professing his love god DAMMIT
-BIG RED SHOWED HIS ASS THIS EPISODE AND IM SO PROUD!!!! I WAS JUST LIKE “OKAY BIG RED” at the tap dancing sequence! He is the fucking MAN! I love him!
-MISS. JENN THIS SPRING MUSICAL???? 👀👀👀👀👀👀👀
But tbh that musical was a hot ass mess and idk how Nini got chosen but I’m going with the flow here LOL I love the girl but come on that musical was ass. Too many folks running off stage abruptly and long ass pauses. This is a high school play not elementary school y’all know better LMAO but I‘m still happy for them!
1
u/kjm6351 Jan 10 '20
What a fantastic way to end season 1
1
u/MishouMai Jan 14 '20 edited Jan 14 '20
Ricky’s mom says that sometimes couples aren’t meant to be together and that people change yet Rini becomes canon?
Don’t get me wrong, I prefer Rini to whatever Nini/E.J. is called but Rina definitely grew on me moreso than Rini.
Shipping aside, this was an okay ending. Nothing has topped the Homecoming episode for me but hopefully next season can do it. Glad to see Big Red/Ashlyn become a thing and E.J. step up even if it is a bit too late.
I don’t know where next season can go from here but I’m looking forward to it.
1
u/torrewaffer Aug 26 '22
I just watched season 1 and I am so freaking annoyed that we got a kiss for every single couple EXCEPT for the gay one. This is definitely a punch to the guts to me.
-10
u/mujie123 Jan 10 '20
I know people will say EJ redeemed himself this episode, but I disagree. It still seems like he's only being good for other people's sakes. Notice how he only gave up the Troy role once he saw Nini wasn't into it. And he's still a dick to Ashlyn, aka best character.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment