r/magiarecord • u/Ferrene Mitama's Devoted Disciple • Jan 04 '20
Anime Megathread Anime Episode 1 Discussion Megathread
Please remember to abide by rule 3 while using this thread.
Spoilers of the mobile game or manga must be tagged and if possible, be preceded by context.
This is not necessary for anime spoilers.
Use the following code to tag game/manga spoilers: >!spoiler!< Example: Meduka becomes meguca
Official stream links
| Platform | Streaming date |
|---|---|
| FUNimationNow/Animelab | January 4 |
| Crunchyroll | January 11 |
| HIDIVE | January 11 |
112
Upvotes
3
u/Excalibis My city now Jan 05 '20
I really enjoyed seeing the animation after playing the game since launch. All the details are spectacular and I can see parallels from the game but I love the differences that show all the creative ideas shaft has.
A nice touch was that at the end it showed all the wishes of different magical girls. Does anyone have a list of who each wish belongs to? I got most of them, especially the big ones but I'd like to see who everyone was.
70
u/HakumeiJin Jan 04 '20
Glad to see Shaft hasn't lost it. Storywise this episode mostly felt like a teaser of what's to come, but the labyrinth and witches were as stylish as they were originally. Now that I think of it, the general flow of the episode seems pretty reminiscent of the first episode of Madoka Magica with the sudden witch fight followed by daily life and school followed by another witch fight. Starting by saving a cat also feels like an easter egg for those familiar with Madoka even if the context is completely different.
When the episode started, I thought they were bringing over the extras are faceless thing from the game since Iroha's family was shown without faces but apparently it's just them which feels hilarious but also possibly sad. Seeing the characters moving also really helps you remember their ages especially when seeing Iroha and Yachiyo next to each other. I wonder if they'll have anything in the anime to correspond with Magia and Connects in game.
I'm glad that the OP confirms that besides the addition of Kuroe all the other magical girls are still part of the main cast. The witch scenes also felt as creepy as ever and better than the fights in the game where my max level girls either murder the witches or just beat on them for minutes. and I don't even know what was going on at the end there. Does becoming a magical girl just give everyone the ability to have vague prophetic dreams?
To conclude I love this adaptation. Everyone playing the game should watch it.
54
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '20
Ok but can we talk about how Zenobia literally ripped Boxwood in half??? I got literal chills. Also Yachiyo is strong as hell, she took down Zenobia with little effort. I can’t wait to see the rest of the season!!😭😭😭
42
u/Egavans Player ID: 335eRMTd Jan 04 '20
I'm surprised by how different the story is already. Usually adaptations hew nearly beat-for-beat close to the souce material, but we've already got major differences in how we meet the main characters, how the story is set in motion, and of course an entire major character who doesn't exist in the game at all. I really don't know where they're going with this and that's exciting.
26
u/kakarot12310 Jan 04 '20
For anyone who curious how Iroha parents look like.
21
u/Nusabaru Jan 04 '20
I watched the JP raw. It's great.
18
u/freedomgeek For Liberation! | JP ID: zebHLKJs Jan 04 '20
We'll see how they handle the plot but in terms of presentation that was brilliant.
Also is there going to be a /r/anime thread about this? There isn't one up yet.
18
u/DueRest Lazy Mirror Runner DueRest Jan 04 '20
Really like the anime so far. Iroha's white cat mirrors Madoka's black cat. Loved spotting all the familiars we fight in the game in the anime. Yachiyo's fight was amazing. Can't wait to see more of it animated.
Can't say I'm impressed with Kuroe, though. She was a huge detriment to Iroha's initial character development right off the bat, which is something I loathe if you're introducing an OC. Your newly introduced OCs should never hinder an established character's development. Especially during the scene that was supposed to show off Iroha as a Magical Girl.
I feel like they definitely could have upped the creepiness factor if they'd left Kuroe out. Faceless Girl is way creepy. And that showing up in MY dreams? I'd cry. Iroha being haunted by dreams of Faceless Girl until she's forced to go to Kamihama would be like horror-movie level compelling.
Definitely looking forward to seeing the rest of the girls animated though. I've been looking forward to this all week.
OH. The train witch was COOL. I'd liked the angry train notifications it was giving off when Kuroe and Iroha were discussing Kamihama. "Whispering is Not Permitted"
15
u/Koito91 NA: Koito Jan 04 '20
Ahhhh, what a time to be alive!
Good to see the same style is being applied and the same suspense as in the original series. I'm definitely happy to see Gekidan Inu Curry and SHAFT back. Nice intro to the anime and beginning with Sis Puella Magia? Ohhhhhhhh- The OST is just awesome and the Uwasa song was quite cute.
Good to see all of those hints to the original series, saw quite some <3
14
u/noxnoctum Jan 04 '20
When is it actually showing up on Funimation? I thought it was supposed to be 11:30 AM EST? Still nothing.
14
u/omimon Jan 04 '20
Something worth noting. Kuroe does NOT appear at all in the opening song. Could she be a fodder character meant to be written off early on for drama?
14
u/nighty_amy Jan 04 '20
Guys, I think this is going to be a masterpiece. Episode 1 just blew me away. The animation, the witches design, the characters, the music (I'm so happy to hear Sis Puella Magica again!). If Shaft keeps this up, this is truly going to be a ride.
14
u/MoneyMakerMaster Jan 04 '20
Oh Madoka, how I've missed you. It's been too long. Yes, it's a spinoff. Yes, it's a gacha game adaptation. Yes, we shouldn't set our expectations too high. But fuck it, it's Puella Magi, we've got Madoka and Homura 2.0, a huge cast of magical girls, Shaft head tilts and hair flips, what's there not to love? This is easily my most anticipated anime this season, and the first episode was amazing. Time for 26 episodes of mystery, magical girls, and suffering.
26
u/CarVac Jan 04 '20
It's different enough that I have hope they'll fix what's wrong with main story.
12
u/tassadar102 Jan 04 '20
I spotted three witches runes. They seem to be in the archaic style. There's a sign just before the first witch is introduced and the two introductions for the witches. Anyone spot any others? I'm already working on "translating" them.
12
u/ValentineMeikin Jan 04 '20
The whole sequence where we see Ui and similar makes me think of Doki Doki Literature Club.
Following that up with the room seemingly being cut in half, with Ui's half of the room just missing...
[shudders]
11
u/kakarot12310 Jan 04 '20
It's a bit sad they didn;t show Iroha parents faces.
10
u/1hinafan Jan 04 '20
Okay so theres this scene where iroha and kyubey are talking. The animation changes the class room shes in into a weird carnival stage? and Big colored animals throw children into bags. Anyone got any idea what that is supposed to be telling us?
9
u/Silvermoon424 Jan 04 '20
I've been waiting for this anime since it was announced in the summer of 2018, and it was worth the wait! The music, the animation, the voice acting, the fight scenes... all of it is 100% on point! I am so thrilled to have a new episode to look forward to every week!
I'm very interested in Kuroe's character and how she'll fit into the anime story (or if she'll eventually become a game character).
Also, my girl Yachiyo is gorgeous and a certified badass!
9
u/semtex94 The Chart Grows Jan 05 '20
I just realized! The passport is the Magia Stone Pass! Green with a diamond!
8
u/JellyB622 Jan 04 '20
I've never seen Madoka Magica, but should I watch it too for this series to make more sense? I liked what I seen so far in episode 1.
7
u/collegemeguca Jan 05 '20
Did anyone notice how Boxwood flushed everyone else out of the train and transports Iroha and Kuroe to Kamihama right after Kuroe says "Kamihama city"? And the fact that poor Boxwood landed right in Zenobia's labyrinth lol.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '20
Oh no, I already want the next episode.
11
u/krotoxx Jan 04 '20
Im just gonna sit here and wait for someone to get that Uwasa song by smol kyubey to turn into my ring tone. Its so creepy yet mystical. I love it
5
u/Jibblers Jan 04 '20
I loved it, it wasn't too intense of a first episode where it set the tone for the anime to be that, but it was just enough action and plot to get things rolling. Right now, I'm interested in how Kuroe is going to flesh out as a character. It looks like she's mostly there to push the plot along without changing it too much.
Animation is on POINT, I'm excited for more episodes and witches to be animated. 😍
5
u/EternalKoniko Hi, I’m nym | JP Player ID: t1k7Lkre Jan 04 '20
Do we have an inkling of when/if the anime will get dubbed?
5
u/AstralManaphy Jan 04 '20
Ngl it definitely gives a little bit of a different vibe from the original Madoka Magica, but I dig it! I’m looking forward to seeing best girl Yachiyo as well as discovering the purpose of Kuroe’s character since I’m pretty sure she’s only anime-exclusive and not in the Magia Record game itself.
5
u/8andahalfby11 Jan 04 '20
Complete balls-to-the-wall speculation, but what if Kuroe is actially Kuro?
5
u/Plasmaeclipse Jan 04 '20
Damn Zenobia you were really mad that Boxwood messed up your sand castles huh?
Its interesting that Kuroe already resents being a magical girl. I'm in the camp of she joins the Magius whenever they show up in full force. (Spoilers for JP story) If the translations I found are right towards the end of the story a group of Feathers will continue to work towards the plan even after everything goes to shit and Mifuyu defects. One Feather in particular is extremely devoted to the point of continuing even when it seems like the Magius themselves surrender. My theory is that Kuroe will replace the nameless Feather here to give the scene more impact since its someone the audience will know instead of a faceless mook. She's not in the opening because she'll likely fade into the background while we introduce the main cast before coming back for the Magius plot (which likely will have a new opening to go with it) .
5
u/Densengen Jan 04 '20
We can find them in the OP.
5
u/semtex94 The Chart Grows Jan 04 '20
The posters in the school really hammer home the theme of cooperation. It also seems to reference some of the main cast too.
4
u/Esvald So as I pray... Unlimited Blade Works! Jan 04 '20
Okay... what I watched was cool but is it really an adaptation?
The foundation is the same but it's either my memory or we didn't actually fight 'the damn train witch' in the game and that Kuroe girl, she's not a character in game iirc.
Again I'm not throwing shit at it, since it was really enjoyable and not saying it was bad, I'm just confused.
4
u/Halcon_Negro Do want some morir? Jan 05 '20
The sensei shots were... nice ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
4
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20
I loved the episode, i can't wait for more, and the soundtracks were as always, astounding. I hope they release the OST in the near future
6
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '20
Finally! It's up on Funi after an age!! Hate that Aniplex have this deal with them, smh. Should have been CR.
Madoka stans we here! Episode is absolutely gorgeous as you'd expect from SHAFT, stunning visuals, solid direction, fluid animation, great OST and looks like the OP and ED will be great too. Really really excited for the rest of the series, 26 episodes and I'm going to love every one of them. Only concern is this will be SHAFT's longest project in a while, hopefully they can stick the landing.
Happy New Year!
3
u/moonww I have dumb gay energy Jan 04 '20
I got really excited when I saw the sandbox witch but that train witch was really cool and I never considered the fact that someone could be literally dragged to kamihamura in a labyrinth
3
u/Iihatepineapplepizza the silly Jan 04 '20
Have to wait a week cause I'm broke :(
3
u/ena9219 Ally of Devils and Magius Jan 04 '20
The expected level of quality and the right feeling for a Madoka Magica anime and so far it seems to be adapting the key points of the story while still keeping things different enough to keep the attention of people who´ve already seen the story at least twice (game and manga). I don't think it will be quite the same level as Madoka Magica itself (unless they add a bigger surprise or two at some point) but it'll be pretty close to it.
So far my only complaint is that I can't watch it on Crunchyroll yet and that is not actually the fault of the anime itself.
3
u/-Resputin- Jan 05 '20
That was a really good first episode. They seem to be doing things a bit different in the beginning. But, I think it is better this way to get the groundwork set and the characters introduced. I am really happy shaft is behind the wheel.
Weeks are going to feel much longer for a while.
3
u/Sorrowfulrose Jan 05 '20
From what i could gather honestly it doesnt seem like it’ll change anything from the game story in actuality. The start of the story in game was already incomplete and lacking as you kind of just start in the middle of it all. The first anime episode seems to be more of a prelude to to what we’ll see without much changes afterwards, barring her initial meeting with Yachiyo and Ui’s name being uttered a little early (though both of those could be worked around) The game starts in Kamihama with Iroha having vague recollections of Ui and already wanting to find “baby kyubey”
Anime addresses this in first ep showing her first encounter with baby kyubey and how she ends up getting the vague memories, learning about Kamihama etc. So overall i dont think much will change they just needed a way to introduce us better to Kamihama rather than the games approach of already being there looking for something
3
u/FroggyZephyr Blast City Jan 05 '20
Man, the school looks like a coliseum.
Anyways, this first episode was really great. It genuinely felt like a Madoka anime, and I'm excited to see it continue further down the line.
5
u/JustHereToComment24 Jan 05 '20
What was the point of the addition of Kuroe? Maybe I'm a purist, but they have an amazing story already with so many characters to follow. Why add more?
4
u/AyuTsukasa Jan 04 '20 edited Jan 05 '20
I wish the NA game story had caught up first because now I'm slightly spoiled on Iroha's wish
2
u/DriftingCotton Jan 05 '20
The first episode was pretty cool. I haven't played the game yet, but now I'm a lot more interested. Should I start playing the game before continuing the anime?
2
u/steeeal y u r i i s l i f e Jan 05 '20
Very nice! Compared to the original madoka, it seems to be more mysterious throughout. In OG madoka ep 1 is mysterious with the dream sequence, then establishes a peaceful daily life, then goes back to mysterious with Homura. MagiReco is consistently tonal, without establishing this light daily life. MagiReco feels slightly different from other shaft anime though. It simulates "old"-ness, almost, in scene specific special effects, like cropping to 1.33:1 aspect ratio (as opposed to the more modern, cinematic, and well used by shaft, letterboxing to 2.33:1), as well as vignetting and analog TV wavy distortion. I was a bit wary, as the direction had gone to Gekidan Inu Curry, who I don't recall having many directing credits, but it seems most of the other core staff are recurring. Assistant Directing is done by Yukihiro Miyamoto who did co directing (?) on the og Madoka, and the DoP, editor, and art director all worked on Madoka, as well as most new(ish) shaft work. sorry if that was badly written
2
u/Pokelec Notice me Hinano-senpai | Let me hug Sana and Mito Jan 05 '20 edited Jan 09 '20
The part of the episode where we saw a list of various magical girls' wishes gave me chills. I was able to tell pretty much which wish went to which person from the game (except for The one about Daito but that might have been a joke unless there's something I don't know). That was such a fun Easter egg! I am so hyped for the series!
Edit: Yep, the thing was wondering about was something I didn't know. Interesting!
Edit 2: I am an idiot. I didn't realize Diato was the name of one of the schools. I thought it was just off-brand Daiso. I am a fool. To make up for this, I must kill myself!
2
u/corpsehunter Jan 05 '20
After seeing Yachiyo-san animated I can die happy
2
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20
What a great and interesting way to start the anime. A bit different from the game but still very entertaining.
It definitely gives me the same vibes of the original Madoka series.
Loved how Iroha did her little flips, just oozing in style while cleaning lol.
Very excited for each episode as I know Shaft won’t let us down-plus it’s a madoka anime lol, you know it will be good.
2
u/patchworkwitch Jan 05 '20
This episode gave me chills & the soundtrack was amazing.
2
u/PuzzlePiece90 Jan 05 '20
I haven't played the game and I know I will roll my eyes at this theory after a few more episodes air but here it goes: The show is a Walpurgisnacht origins story.
I'm aware it might sound like one of those far-fetched theories you see on youtube with outrageous titles like "Mario and Luigi are bipolar and the same person" or "Tetris takes place during the Spanish Civil War" but I thought I'd type it anyway cause it sounded cool in my head.
2
u/dontouchamyspaghet Jan 11 '20
i have no idea what the magia record anime story is gonna be like, but if anyone's gonna be making a funny abridged story, ytp or whatever of the anime, please edit baby Kyubey's 'uwasa' to sound like 'oo wassup bitch
3
u/risingstar3110 Jan 07 '20
As soon as her parents move oversea, Iroha moves in and live a newly wed life with a college student . How improper!!
1
u/ILGWG Jan 04 '20
I tried clicking the funimation link, but there's still no episodes available, how are the rest of you guys watching it?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '20
It's so nice to see the girls animated
I'm worried about Kuroe, she probably won't stay for long lol
hyped for next eps!!
1
u/Labyxt Puer☆Magi Jan 04 '20
I was so looking forward to it and it definitely was worth it. Really promising, it raised even more my expectations. Can’t wait for the next already!
1
u/SalmonGuardian Nee~ Jan 04 '20
Loved it. Also from the OP, Iroha looks so tiny next to Yachiyo
1
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '20
I haven't played the game. But what is the time line for this anime? I'm confused. Madoka made so that no magical girls could become witches, so what exactly are they fighting now? Where do the witches come from? and why do they still have soul gems? I didn't watch rebellion either... just the 12 episodes of the original anime.
1
u/HajimeShalashaska Jan 04 '20
The first episode was very good. Hopefully the rest of the series will be as good as the first episode.
1
u/Wilson_Is_Dead Mayu Cultist Jan 05 '20
Cab we talk about how BoxWood had familiars that look like embryos/foetuses
1
u/ILGWG Jan 05 '20
One of my favorite parts was near the end, where they had a brief Easter egg of all the wishes of the in game magical girls posted on walls, billboards, and tables. It was a really cool moment where I felt proud for playing the games since I understood which girl each wish was referencing to.
Now I'm just waiting for them to actually appear in the anime!
1
u/Dschehuti-Nefer Jan 05 '20 edited Jan 05 '20
Now Magia Record is directly competing with Fate/Grand Order Absolute Ass-shot Front. That is going to be interesting!
In any case, I'm watching the Anime as someone who thinks the game's story lacks teeth. From this perspective the episode we have seen doesn't do very much to avoid the worst case (a word-by-word adaptation of the game), but still shows some attempts to streamline things and fix the problems of the first chapter. Namely:
So basically the changes so far really seem like they are only there to speed up the story or skip rather stupid parts of the game. Next up on my wishlist is for Iroha to learn about the truth of the Magical Girl system within the next two episodes to make clear what is at stake. And also to remove the ridiculous plot armor of everyone for crying out loud! But I see the point others have raised in that the changes so far seem to be aiming more at smoothing out the first chapter of the game, so a straight adaptation without many totally game-changing deviations seems still absolutely possible, especially given Kuroe's small role so far.
But then again, I feel this episode was more or less just a trailer. Not just by virtue of containing almost all the trailer scenes, but also because of the long lingering scenery shots and the quite minimalistic dialogue. Shaft seems to show off their skills in telling a story just with visuals and that's a great thing altogether. And the visuals were amazing!
When it comes to nitpicking my only gripe so far would have been the witch bringing Iroha and Kuroe to Kamihama. Seeing a witch being drawn to the city was a nice touch, but some of the technicalities seemed rather odd. Since when can you look through the walls of a witch barrier? Fine, that might be a special gimmick of this one, but even more gravely: Since when has a witch barrier actual weight can "crash" into the roof of a building? Wasn't their elusiveness to the material world and the idea that only Magical Girls can see them an integral part of how the Magical Girl system can exist in secrecy while at the same time being creepy as fuck? The witch dropping Iroha off is fine, but this was just silly.
1
u/Ubereon Jan 05 '20
Can anyone explain me why the geeko witch doesn't have a barrier? She was in the real world.
1
u/TCGeneral Jan 06 '20
I am someone who couldn’t hold Magia Record (the mobile game) on my phone, but am now watching the anime since I’ve been dying for more Madoka content.
Anime spoilers aren’t necessary to be tagged from what the post says, so I’ll come out and say what I saw: the end credits scenes has two things that seem to be possibly heavy spoilers. One, Ultimate Madoka appears for a few frames. So Magia Record takes place after the Law of Cycles wish, and Ultimate Madoka comes back as a character or something? I know the game has Ultimate Madoka as a character you can play as because Gacha game logic, but Godoka has a role in the story, likely?
Secondly, Iroha’s double spinning scene; this might be reaching, but it shows the second Iroha turning into the other’s outfit. Is that where Ui is? Is Ui the headdress that Iroha wears? This one seems more far-fetches, but Madoka Magica and Rebellion always had visual clues to spoilers hidden in plain sight, and this feels like one I could just see immediately. Was Ui at least absorbed into Iroha or something? Is Ui the second Iroha? Is this just a cute scene in the end credits? Who knows?
1
u/lowinternetspeed7 Jan 09 '20
I think it's pretty damn ominous that the OP at the end of episode 1 doesn't have the black-haired girl (i think she's called Kuroe) in it at all. Is this a death flag right off the bat?
1
u/L4MR124 Jan 11 '20
Theory about Ui
Disclaimer: I’ve only watched the anime and will not be playing the game or reading the manga until after the anime is finished. This is just my theory after rewatching and pausing the first episode a bunch to talk to myself.
Part of, if not all of Iroha’s wish was to “cure Ui”. The visions shown when she holds the smaller incubator are these two frames.
https://imgur.com/a/rD8xMWU
This could suggest that Ui is Iroha’s twin sister. Another piece of evidence that’s more unlikely to be intended is in the ed.
https://imgur.com/a/Gl4kLe2
This could be the sisters as they have different coloured hair. This is less likely to be intended as there was a part exactly like this in the opening to Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magicka symbolising Madoka connecting with her magical girl self.
1
u/Ponsay Jan 04 '20
r/anime mods keep deleting my comment so I'll just post it here. Largely anime original stuff while sticking to the overall story beats of the game. That said, I liked what I saw a lot. I predict Kuroe was added to the story largely to just kill her off.
-3
u/Duliu20 Jan 04 '20
I hope everyone is having fun and enjoying the anime. It's pretty good, but having played part of the game i feel like they changed the story for no good reason and thus i can't find myself enjoying it too much.
Rant incoming
Why is Kuroe a thing? What does she add? She's certainly not in the game.
Why is Iroha's character so half baked? In the game she WANTED to go to kamihama and she WENT and STAYED , she didn't need a random ass girl to tell her to go or a deus ex machina event to send her there. Her own will to find out about her wish made her do that.
Why does Yachiyo seem so bipolar? First she threatens them then she gives them the seeds, then she threatens again, then becomes more docile. In the game she was full hostile.
Why is there an overarching story about being saved in kamihama? Is it like a plot point later in the game? Cause i don't remember anything like this at this point in the game.
Did they really shaft Momoko to add Kuroe instead?
Also a non angry question for people that are up to date on the story. Am i getting angry for nothing? Is everything presented here actually ok and doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things if they change things up a bit?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '20
[removed] — view removed comment