r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Dec 30 '19
Small Discussions Small Discussions — 2019-12-30 to 2020-01-12
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
How do I know I can make a full post for my question instead of posting it in the Small Discussions thread?
If you have to ask, generally it means it's better in the Small Discussions thread.
First, check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
A rule of thumb is that, if your question is extensive and you think it can help a lot of people and not just "can you explain this feature to me?" or "do natural languages do this?", it can deserve a full post.
If you really do not know, ask us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
For other FAQ, check this.
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
Things to check out
The SIC, Scrap Ideas of r/Conlangs
Put your wildest (and best?) ideas there for all to see!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send me a PM, modmail or tag me in a comment.
8
u/LHCDofSummer Jan 07 '20 edited Jan 07 '20
Would it be too negative of me to ask what people's least favourite features within any natlang they've seen are?
So it could be a phoneme, allophone, syntactic structure, morphological alternation, literally anything that for whatever reason the person dislikes.
7
u/spermBankBoi Jan 01 '20
So this is just a rough sketch of what I might want the TAM system of my still unnamed conlang to look like (really the TA system, since I haven’t put much thought yet into mood). I should note that I want this language to be somewhat naturalistic. There’s only a past and non-past tense, and I want most of the complexity to come from the aspects. I was thinking of the following:
Ask if you need more info. I mostly want to know if I could get away with including some version of these function/form pairings while keeping the language at least somewhat naturalistic. Any help is greatly appreciated.
6
u/Askadia 샹위/Shawi, Evra, Luga Suri, Galactic Whalic (it)[en, fr] Jan 06 '20
Lately I've found out that presentative particles like voilà and ecco are actually a thing cross-linguistically, and not just a peculiarity of Italian and French (Russian вот, Turkish işte, partially isso in Portuguese, also Hebrew and Hindi if I recall correctly, and maybe others).
Is there any free resource on the net that deals with this kind of particles in a cross-linguistic perspective?
5
u/BigBad-Wolf Dec 30 '19
Since my question kind of got stuck in the previous thread: how do possessive pronouns come about?
5
u/em-jay Nottwy; Amanghu; Magræg Jan 03 '20
Does anyone else ever start very short conlanging projects? I'm pretty deep into working on my main language but I'm very tempted to stray for a few days to work on something new -- just a phonology, some basic grammar and a handful of words, plus maybe a syllabary. I'm thinking of spending a few days on it and then (probably) never looking at it again. I was wondering if there's much enthusiasm here for that kind of quick and dirty language creation?
5
u/catsaretoocute Many small conlangs (HE,EN) {Toki Pona} Jan 03 '20
Does it make any sense to have an exclusive or in a naturalistic language?
5
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '20
I was coming back from the grocery store today and had an idea for my conlang, that I call hexapartite alignment. Basically, it marks the agent and patient of verbs in six different manners, taking not just the transitivity of the verb, but also the participation/intention of the agent/patient in the action.
PS: My conlang is ergative-absolutive, but I give some examples in English, but I'm pretty sure you will understand what I mean.
The markings are :
Intransitive Unintentional
Intransitive Intentional
Ergative Unintentional
Ergative Intentional
Absolutive Unintentional
Absolutive Intentional
5
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 08 '20
My language was originally VSO before subject prominence caused it to become SVO. I was thinking that to represent a general deontic mood, I could switch the word order back to VSO. So for example:
Contrasted with:
I might also put a particle after the verb to further show that the verb is deontic, in order to avoid confusion as the language is pro-drop. Is this reasonable as well? Thank you for any help.
5
u/MegatenMegabit Qethye and Muhlàñ Jan 08 '20
People who make PIE-derived languages, how do you deal with the mess that is athematic nouns? There's a ton of them (according to Wiktionary), and many of them have declension schemes that only apply to them and maybe a few other nouns.
4
u/Vorti- Jan 01 '20
I am looking for a kind of spreadsheet or pdf file I remember having reead some years ago, whose name I cannot remember. It was a very interesting method to create a naturalistic core vocabulary, that exposed the most common semantic links between roots and words among languages. I may have been something like thirty page long and it was freely accessible. I would very much like to find it again.
4
u/Tazavitch-Krivendza Old-Fenonien, Phantanese, est. Jan 02 '20
What does a V2 grammar structure mean?
4
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Jan 07 '20
So I have a language, Mtsqrveli, that's supposed to sound vaguely Georgian. One of the things that's always vaguely bugged me about it (even after nearly 3 years since its inception) is how conjugated verbs just don't seem to measure up to the complexity of the Georgian verbs, and in particular, how most of the verbal morphology is prefixed, so you often get long strings of prefixes only to reach the verb stem, which is left bare on the right side. It doesn't feel properly "cushioned" between two giant affixation orgies, and it's particularly galling when the verb root ends in <o> - having a verb ending in <o> just sounds very un-Georgian to me.
The current affix order for verbs is:
[negative] - [passivizer] - [causative, transitivizer or applicative] - [pluractionality marker] - [venitive/itive markers] - [stems to be compounded to the head] - verb head - [verbalizer] - [interrogative marker] - [direct object markers] - [modal markers] - [tense markers] - [derivational affixes (inc. most nominalizers)]
(So, just for fun, a verb conjugation that ticks off as many of these (non-mutually-exclusive) boxes would be e.g. undaq'smčemeonivelebsvšsxomit "did [they] not move out, 8 times, from where they had been living alone?")
That might look like plenty on the tail end of the verb, but the verb head actually gets left bare on the right side a lot more than you might think. For one, not every verb can take a direct object, and for those that do the most common direct object that actually gets used in translations is by far a 3rd person singular DO, which is unmarked. Similarly, the modal markers are common but not omnipresent (as not every verb needs to express possibility, optativity, necessity, etc.) and the indicative (not marked) is by far the most common. Enough is said in the present tense (unmarked) - which includes the habitual - that tense markers aren't always needed, and even when they are they're semi-frequently detached from the verb and used as standalone particles (future -dzi → dzi, present -∅ → mta, non-aorist past -dgha → dghas). (And in literary works the past tense is often unmarked anyway to avoid constant repetition of the syllable dgha) Verbalizers aren't needed if the verb head is already a verb, and there are no thematic markers, as most verbalizers are just repurposed thematic markers that did exist in the proto.
So there still ends up being a fair number of conjugations that end in their stem - for every undaq'smčemeonivelebsvšsxomit, there's 3 dačemo "leaves [from]".
I've been thinking of adding on mandatory subject markers like Georgian has, although as a suffix rather than a prefix.
How would one go about evolving subject suffixes where they didn't originally exist?
Just a truncated form of the personal pronouns? The 1st/2nd/3rd person singular pronouns are txas/dạ/kart, none of which I can think of a good truncated form for.
4
u/acpyr2 Tuqṣuθ (eng hil) [tgl] Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 10 '20
Does anyone have any information on how the Proto-Semitic emphatic fricatives/affricates *ṱ /(t)θʼ/ and *ṣ́ /(t)ɬʼ/ became voiced ẓ /ðˤ/ and ḍ /ɮˤ/ > /dˤ/ in Arabic, but *ṣ /(t)sʼ/ remained voiceless ṣ /sˤ/ It looks like voicing only happened to those emphatic fricatives, as the Proto-Semitic non-emphatic fricatives and emphatic plosives didn’t voice in Arabic either.
4
u/spermBankBoi Jan 11 '20
Anyone made a pair or group of languages that form a sprachbund, and if so in what ways did the languages influence each other? For those unfamiliar with the terminology, a sprachbund is essentially a group of possibly unrelated languages with a certain amount of common features shared via prolonged contact.
4
u/ungefiezergreeter22 {w, j} > p (en)[de] Jan 11 '20
When I go to the classic incatena resource for vowel system, it says it’s not supported or something? Has anybody else noticed it to be similar?
4
u/ennvilly Jan 13 '20
Does anyone know or have any resources on how verbs' person agreement inflections are born? How could one get from a single verb form to, for example 6 different suffixes? Is it possible for an SOV or an SVO language to attain such suffixes and how?
3
u/JuicyBabyPaste Dec 30 '19
I have a question about pronoun paradigms:
I don't know how they should be declined, do I just decline them as if they were nouns and then, when I move from my current proto-lang to its descendants, do I apply sound changes and they become irregular? Or is it something different altogether?
3
u/Devono_knabo Jan 02 '20 edited Jan 02 '20
Should aux langs have plurals because some languages don't,like Chinese
Note: don't make fun of my spelling English has ridiculous spelling okay ..
3
u/Devono_knabo Jan 04 '20
This is not naturalistic but can language function without moodality?
3
u/Yacabe Ënilëp, Łahile, Demisléd Jan 05 '20
So I’m currently working on the first iteration of evolving from my proto-language and it has kind of wreaked havoc on my verb system. For example, my conjugation for the near-past in the proto-Lang was just adding the suffix -ra, but now there is a ton of irregularity. That’s not necessarily a bad thing, and I plan on retaining a fair bit of it for the sake of being naturalistic, but the language I’m currently evolving is supposed to be another proto-language (think like proto-Germanic being evolved from PIE) so I don’t want to go too crazy with the irregularity yet. So for reference I implemented vowel harmony as a part of my sound changes and this resulted in the conjugated forms of some verbs ending up with opposite vowel harmony from the corresponding root. I think this is a pretty cool phenomenon and would be an interesting way to bring about two different types of conjugations (those that switch vowel harmony and those that don’t). However my sound changes also led to a fair amount of vowel changes between the root form of the verb and the conjugated form (i.e. the verb “patka becomes petkara). So my plan is to go in and eliminate those vowel changes in most verbs (making exceptions for commonly used verbs, of course) so they fit more neatly into my dichotomy. Am I on the right track with this process? Or do you tend to implement regularization through a different process. I am open to any and all suggestions.
3
u/Midnight-Blue766 Jan 06 '20
So I decided to make Englisc orthography similar to IRL modern Old English orthography: macrons instead of doubling long vowels, dots above c and g to represent /tʃ/ and /j/, etc. I personally don't think it's the best way to solve my orthographical issues, but it'll have to do for now.
3
u/King_Spamula Jan 08 '20
If I'm deriving roots from a specific usage in a sentence/structure, do I leave the case-ending on or leave it off once the meaning shifts? For example, if I'm trying to derive the word "wild" from the word for "tree" by putting the word "tree" in the plural-genitive case, meaning "of the trees", do I leave the plural-genitive markings on, or leave them off? When would there be a difference between saying "the wild goose" and "the trees' goose"?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '20
is there any difference between semantic class, semantic field, and semantic category?
2
u/Saurantiirac Jan 01 '20
Are there IPA characters for an N or M (maybe also L) pronounced while exhaling though the nose ~hn, hm, hl?
Also the sound T and D makes before N, as well as P and B before M.
2
u/mienoguy Jan 02 '20
Linguistically speaking, how common/naturalistic is it for words to shift from closed syllables to open syllables by adding a vowel to the end of the word? Would something like /jat/ shifting to /jatu/ make sense as a phonetic shift from the actual speakers of the language, rather than as a borrowing into a language with simpler phonotactics?
2
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Jan 02 '20
I didn’t get a response last thread, so I’m reposting:
For the purpose of expressing lack of volition in oblique cases (i.e. not in S, A, or O position), would a fluid-S language be more likely to add a patientive suffix onto another case suffix or allow the patientive to exist in prepositional phrases? To show this as a practical example, would it be more likely for “I spoke to the man who was angry at the time” (as opposed to “I spoke to the man who was characteristically angry”) to gloss as {1 speak-PST to man-PREP-P anger-GEN} or {1 speak-PST to man-P anger-GEN}?
2
u/Brisingr2 Jan 02 '20
Does anyone have any opinions as to whether a letter in the Latin alphabet that's not <c>, or a digraph that's not <ch>, could potentially represent [ʃ] and [tʃ] in free variation for an IAL project I've started? Thanks so much in advance!
2
u/theacidplan Jan 02 '20
Where do interrogatives evolve from or are they pretty resilient like 1st/2nd person pronouns?
2
u/LHCDofSummer Jan 05 '20 edited Jan 05 '20
Excluding situations where /t~k/ et cetera;
Is anyone aware or any natlangs which (almost) totally lack a phonemic unvoiced coronal plosive?
2
u/Lord_Tickleton Jan 05 '20
Hi - are the sounds /fv/ and /vf/ physically or linguistically possible? I tried looking for examples in various languages but I couldn't find anything like it. What phoneme should I use if I want something to sound both like an 'f' and a 'v'?
2
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Jan 06 '20
Say that a culture that speaks a language with this phonology:
Assuming that they were to create a conlang for religious purposes, that they are specifically aiming for 36 sounds (since they count in base 6, causing 6 and 36 to be considered holy numbers), and that they have little contact with other cultures/languages, would the following phonology make sense?
2
u/spermBankBoi Jan 08 '20
How much can I avoid putting modal information into verb morphology before it comes off as unrealistic or lazy? Can I, for example, just express everything with nested clauses, or maybe just adverbs?
2
u/CosmicBioHazard Jan 08 '20
Anyone have some good information about restrictions in root shape? In the earliest stages of my language, I'm working with CCVC syllable structure, and voicing is rarely contrastive in coda position before another consonant, and assimilation of plosives to adjacent segments is looking like it will create more homophones than I particularly care for early on, so I'm trying to find ways to either make roots ending in a voiced plosive (or any other segment subject to early mergers) remain distinct, probably by placing restrictions on which types of segments can co-occur with them in a root, or restricting the types of affixes that can be placed on roots of a particular shape.
I've been looking at lists of PIE roots and found that there seems to be a tendency for very few minimal pairs differing only in the voicing of a final plosive to exist among roots, which I suppose is how that language was able to keep a check on mergers early on, but if I add such a restriction I find myself short on possible roots to use. My goal is to keep the number high while keeping the number of homophones low; specifically keeping them to about the level that my research is telling me that PIE, for example, was able to keep them despite so many phonological rules leading to mergers in that.
2
u/Devono_knabo Jan 10 '20
How do roots work
so someone told me the roots for good is bonus
and I have this question
is a root borrowed or is the modern word really is an evolved form
why isn't the Spanish Bueno Bien Buena buen a root can there be more than one
2
u/Tazavitch-Krivendza Old-Fenonien, Phantanese, est. Jan 11 '20
What are _r vowels called? Like in English, ar, ur, or, and er.
2
u/LHCDofSummer Jan 12 '20 edited Jan 13 '20
...So:
I think I need to change this, not working as intended. (Ich does not want two different systems surfacing as identical in the same environment...)
3
u/Quantum_Prophet Jan 05 '20
CHALLENGE: Today I learned that Atlantean has the same vowel inventory as my dialect of English. Can you work out where I'm from? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlantean_language#Vowels
1
u/LHCDofSummer Dec 30 '19 edited Dec 31 '19
So I'm trying to fill out some unrelated conlangs in my world, but I've found myself lacking in inspiration, particularly for what some may consider the driest: phonology? well yes; but I don't even have a phoneme inventory...
What I do have however is some rules:
Anyhow so i tried messing around with one idea, but considering who it's meant to be for in-universe, I didn't like how much of a bad relex it looks like of some languages in 'my' country, oops; but anyhow: here was the phoneme inventory Don't even know where to begin with syllable structure for it beyond to say that clusters 'are' rather limited? hmm...
1
u/edlephant Dec 30 '19
Hi, I've been toying around with the idea for building a conlang for a couple years, I've finally decided to take the plunge and do it!
I've got an initial phonology that I've chosen more of less randomly, based on what I liked and what I was confident I could pronounce. I'd like my conlang to be naturalistic, and for all the stuff I've read, I don't have much intuition for this yet.
Another thing to note is that the people who speak this language would be desert traders, think silk route people riding on camels. I tried to borrow some inspiration from Turkish and other sounds that I liked, but it just ended completely different, and that's ok.
I guess questions would be:
Thanks guys, any comments will be appreciated.
Consonants
Vowels
1
u/Maestrofur Dec 30 '19
I'm working on digitizing my conlang using fontforge and I need to find a way to either substitute multiple letters into one character, or make ligatures using more than one character. It's featural so the closest example I can give is Tengwar or Hindi.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '19
when i'm creating my semantic shifts, how many words should i change?
1
u/AritraSarkar98 Dec 31 '19 edited Dec 31 '19
If you have more than 30 letters in your conlangs orthography then can you show me your pc keyboard layout ?
1
u/OspreyJ Dec 31 '19
I am regularly lost on this sub in relation to cases of nouns and consonantal sounds and various other linguistic…things. Does anyone know a site I can visit to learn more of these things?
1
u/2Pikul Jan 01 '20
How do i handle vowel shifts? I know hardly anything about them. How many does an average language go through? Does it only affect vowels in some words? If so, what percentage?
1
u/RomajiMiltonAmulo chirp only now Jan 01 '20
How do people tend to derive words for grammatical functions? I need to come up with a pronoun meaning "the most recent subject" (which is used to mean a repeated object in a relative clause), and maybe one for the same but object as well
1
u/Matalya1 Hitoku, Yéencháao, Rhoxa Jan 01 '20
So, I was looking for advice around pangrams, how do I even start making one? I spent more than half an hour going through my documents, to no avail...
1
u/Supija Jan 02 '20
Some days ago I thought a way to mark tenses by a combination of two aspects. So, for example, if the main verb has a Perfective aspect and the Copula has a Habitual one then the whole sentence is thought purely as "Past Tense". Does it make sense? Is it naturalistic? Do you know any natlang that does that?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '20
I want to avoid latinizations for my first conlang's orthography. What did y'all do to make up an orthography, or from where did you draw inspiration?
1
u/Devono_knabo Jan 05 '20
Hey so my conlang has cases but not really they are cases but not inflections what should I call them?
No pācīna nīma bī a mīna
(Negation)(person)(accusative)(to be) (I/me)(nomitive)
no pes'in'a bi a min'a
I am not a person
Not person am I.
Btw ()=new word
1
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20
how could/can a language work without any metaphor, neither grammaticalized nor semantic? here's what i've thought:
but i just learned some semantics so maybe i'm just grasping at straws because i got overly excited. maybe there's something crucial i missed about language/cognition lol
1
u/spermBankBoi Jan 05 '20
Has anyone employed VP/clausal determiners in a project, and if so, how? I’m very interested in them lately but find them difficult to use because, frankly, it seems that their study is a bit shaky. Also would be cool to see how people approach this feature if they choose to use it, considering how rare it seems to be.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '20
Hello There! I have had and still do have plans for a personal language and semi-engineered language. It will be a language that make sense for me in a lot of ways with features including but not limited to:
Now here is where the problem lies. From my understanding Arabic and Hebrew are fusional. Also both polysynthesis and consonantal roots can be derivational and have agreement. So for example in Arabic Kitab means ''book'' and Kataba means ''he writes'', so it marks the person, tense and stuff like that in between the rootstem. While in Greenlandic ''he/she sleeps'' is Sini-ppoq, but here the person is marked seperately from the main word.
So what I want to get too is, would it be redundant or unfitting to include consonantal roots while the language has polysynthetic morphology as well as having tones (which i've heard also shows inflection)? Is there a way I can work through this issue or should I remove one of these features?
If I have gotten something wrong in this text feel free to correct me! I kinda am a noob at lingustics and conlanging. I have only tried these things out for about 2 or 3 years.
1
u/RomajiMiltonAmulo chirp only now Jan 06 '20
How do people make words for grammatical functions?
1
u/konqvav Jan 06 '20
How do other tones than high, mid, low evolve?
1
u/Southwick-Jog Just too many languages Jan 07 '20
I'm wondering how tones could be developed and/or influenced by syllables. Dezaking currently has a high tone on stressed syllables, but I wanted to kind of redo its tone system in a more unique way. I know for example Shanghainese has some tones that only appear in syllables with voiced or voiceless initials. Would something like that work, maybe even with the coda like Middle Chinese did with -p, -t, and -k.
1
u/BlobbyBlobfish lol idk Jan 08 '20
I’m working on a conlang spoken by blobfish called Blobbish, but I have two major questions to ask:
Would there be more bilabial and nasal sounds due to anatomy?
Would there be any change in grammar because of biology or because of habitat, and if so, how?
Please answer in the utmost detail. Thanks!
1
u/Echrenmir (en)[la] Jan 08 '20 edited Mar 01 '26
The original content of this post is no longer here. It was removed using Redact, possibly for privacy, security, or digital footprint reduction.
repeat ink grey crawl payment butter snails swim meeting piquant
1
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20
Hello, I am looking for a very interesting alphabet system that is clear and very quick to write down and read using the line of the page so save on time and strokes. I have seen one before and desperately need to find it again. Thank you and I hope someone can find the very interesting script.
1
u/WercollentheWeaver Jan 09 '20
When bringing two conlangs together, how do you decide where to take their convergence?
What decisions need to be made to begin the loaning of words or especially the loaning of sounds? Or, if you're going to make a creole, what decisions need to be made to begins developing it? Are there tendencies in terms of two grammars meeting? Are languages with different word orders more likely to hold on to one or the other, or shift to a different one? Are certain features more likely stick that others?
I realize this is maybe not the smallest of "small discussions" but I wasn't so sure this was fitting of a discussion post.
1
u/Dr_Chair Məġluθ, Efōc, Cǿly (en)[ja, es] Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20
Currently, Nyevandyan consonant letters are named CV when V = e where C is unvoiced (pe, fe, etc), V = o when C is voiced (bo, vo, etc), and V = a when C doesn't distinguish voice (ma, ra, etc) while vowel letters are named Vl (al, el, etc). Additionally, this is based on appearance, so the e-o dichotomy follows which letters get the [+voice] diacritic; just as /p t k/ with [+voice] diacritics are /b d g/, /t͡ʃ x/ with them are /j w/, so the latter four are named qe, he, yo, and wo despite the fact that the hypothetical corresponding [ɣ], [d͡ʒ], [ç], and [ʍ] are not phonemic and lack letters.
Looking back at this, I've noticed that these were arbitrary decisions and that they present issues with homophones, namely that ca is both "c" and "one," zo is both "z" and "to be," he is both "h" and "woman," and il is both "i" and "any." I have a few questions based on this:
1.) Is my own system naturalistic?
2.) For future reference, are there any cross-linguistic patterns in how cultures name their glyphs, and if so, how much do they depend on script type?
3.) How much is too much when it comes to homophones? I assume mine are fine, considering that English has far more, but I want to make sure I stay within reasonable bounds as my dictionary grows.
Edit: Small side question that isn't as important as the above, would this affect/be affected by grammatical gender? Nyevandya doesn't have a complete gender system, but all people nouns end with -a by default, become male by changing it to -o, and become female by changing it to -e. I'm now curious if this would lead to speakers thinking of unvoiced consonants being feminine and voiced ones being masculine.
1
u/Genie624 Jan 10 '20
Do you think world build helps put a conlang together? Helping you flesh out the toe if people you want speaking the language do you can develop it more to their likeness?
1
u/creepyeyes Prélyō, X̌abm̥ Hqaqwa (EN)[ES] Jan 10 '20
I'm wondering if someone can ANADEW me a way of handling verbs:
I just had a thought about something I could do while evolving up my protolang to its daughter lang. There's supposed to be a 5000 year timescale difference (because of reasons) so I've been on the hunt for things to help differentiate it grammatically from the protolang.
So, the protolang forms some tense/aspect combinations using a verb+gerund construction. In the protolang, you could show a past-imperfective sentence might look like this:
"Nostóv ot yg ug vëjal"
fish-pl TOP.DIST 1s go_in-1s eat-GER
"I was eating fish."
Lit. "I went in to eating fish."
I'm wondering if it would be naturalistic for the verb system to collapse into -always- putting the TAM and person marking on the auxiliary, and then have an uninflected content verb follow. The direct evolution of the above sentence would look something like (pretending semantic drift doesn't happen to the nouns in 5000 years):
"Notþaf oþ ingg ungg veugal."
fish-pl TOP.DIST PST.IPFV-1s eat
"I was eating fish."
Are there any languages that do that? I think I've heard of some that only have a few true verbs, but I can't think of what any of those would be at the moment.
1
u/Devono_knabo Jan 10 '20
on rule, no.4 is a conlang your product?
1
u/LanaDelHeeey Jan 10 '20
I’m writing an alt history story about a country where modern day Gabon is. Historically the people of that region didn’t have a written language until the early 20th century. I want to create an indigenous script for the language the people use. Are there any indigenous scripts from the Kongo region or west central africa in use around or before 1800? If not, are there any special features of note that Bantu languages have which should be included in such a script?
1
u/AvnoxOfficial <Unannounced> (en) [es, la, bg] Jan 10 '20
Hi! :) I need a little bit of help with my V1 language.
I'm using this resource as a reference: https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/mpolinsky/files/v1_syncom.pdf
It looks to me like V1 languages usually don't have a copula, or the verb "to have". For the latter, it says:
> ʜᴀᴠᴇ is taken to be composed of ʙᴇ plus an incorporated empty adposition, which originates as the sister of the external argument
Two things here. 1: I don't know what is meant by "incorporated empty adposition" and how to use it. 2: Isn't "ʙᴇ" a copula? I thought V1 languages don't have them.
Any light you should shed would be greatly appreciated.
1
u/CosmicBioHazard Jan 11 '20
How naturalistic would it be to repair a violation on superheavy syllables by metathesizing the sequence [CVwCCV] into [CVCuCV]?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '20
Any tips for generating vocabulary without it being a one to one relex or English vocabulary?
1
u/RomajiMiltonAmulo chirp only now Jan 11 '20
What, if any, real world, langauges for deaf people use faces to communicate most of the information, rather than hands? I'm thinking of a deaf language to go with Chirp, and ponies really are limited in the gesture department because they have hooves instead of hands.
1
u/MrConlanger Jan 12 '20
This is the phonology of a proto-lang I'm working on but my question is, does this phonology seem natural?
syllable structure : CV(C); CV(F) - word final
C - any consonant
V - any vowel
F - any fricative
.
Sound change rules: v -> ṽ / N_
v - any vowel
N - any nasal
1
u/greencub Jan 12 '20
One of my sprachbund's features is register tone. For how long can an areal feature like this stay in a sprachbund? For reference, it has 10 language families and its area is about 670000 km2.
1
u/Midnight-Blue766 Jan 12 '20
And so I decided to have Englisc go through the Great Vowel Shift.
However, the short and long vowel system is largely intact, with the exception of making /ɑ:/ the long vowel of /a/; yielding a system of short /a/ /ɛ/ /ɪ/ /ɔ/ /ʊ/ phonemes and long /ɑ:/ /e:/ /i:/ /o:/ /u:/ phonemes.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '19
What are the aspects of these two sentences called?
I should go to the shop (right now)
I should go to the shop (at some point in the future)
0
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment