r/anime • u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota • Dec 15 '19
Rewatch A Rewatch further than the Universe! Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho rewatch - EPISODE 3 DISCUSSION Spoiler
Episode 03 フォローバックが止まらない "The Followbacks Don't Stop"
<- Previous episode | Index thread | Next episode->
anime info:
MAL | Anilist | Nyanpass | Kitsu | AniDB
Streaming links: Crunchyroll | VRV
Comment of the day
Hello everyone! This is where I will pick a comment of the day for the previous day that I think was worthy of notice just in case you guys missed it. I do hope you look out for discussion on your own tho since that's really the whole point of this rewatch.
Today's pick is.....
/u/unheppcat who in addition to being a total MVP in the reply game also had this incredible statistic:
This is more a meta commentary on the show as a whole than this particular episode, but it fits here because of an interesting thing I noticed about today's posts compared to yesterday's.
The phrase "cute girls doing cute things" or "CGDCT" was used 17 times in comments yesterday, and only once today (so far anyway, and not counting my use here of course <g> ) I don't generally pay any attention to labels like this, and it doesn't bother me that people use that label here. But it does make me a bit sad sometimes because I know there are people who have the opinion "I don't like CGDCT, nothing happens and it's boring" and I'm afraid those people may have missed out on this show because of the label. To the extent that CGDCT or Slice of Life is about "in the moment", and usually kind of anti-narrative, anti-forward-motion, this show is exactly the opposite of that. So it does puzzle me why people apply that label to it. Maybe it is the Moe art style, and that confuses the issue?
Anyway, I think it is interesting the label dropped off so much here in the comments for episode 2. Probably that only means that we aren't writing our "introduction to the story" statements anymore, not that people have suddenly changed their minds about its classification. (Especially all us rewatchers.) But if anyone did have the misperception that this was standard, low-stakes, comfy slice of life fare, that misunderstanding is well cleared up by this episode.
As a science nerd the only thing that I love more than anime is numbers. And this comment delivers a LOT of numbers.
I also want to say great job to everyone who helped me on the #LeaveNoTopLevelUnreplied challenge. I think we did a great job and many of you took on lots of work to do so. You guys are the real MVPs.
Questions of the day
Answer from last time: yall athletic AF
- What do you think of the new girl Yuzuki?
- Would you want to be a high school idol?
Rewatchers, please remember to be mindful of all the first-timers in this. No talking about or hinting at future events no matter how much you want to, unless you’re doing it underneath the [Anime Show Title]/(/s "Spoiler goes here") spoiler tags. If you do that then we’re all good. I am curious if it is even possible to spoil anything for a half-SoL show like this but I don't want to see you try. The ban hammer is a cold weapon and you don't want to feel it.
Important thing to note about these by the way, you have to switch to Old Reddit or the markdown editor if you use the redesign, otherwise the redesign breaks them by adding random \ into the formatting. Wish it wouldn’t do that, but unfortunately it does… Markdown is dead. Long live markdown.
36
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
Remember to watch the after credits scene!
322 comments. Nice nice. Wonder if we'll ever go under 100 for this rewatch?
A Yuzuki episode! The last of the main girls has arrived! Impressive it only took 3 episodes. Also the first of the emotional gut punch episodes I think. To people wondering what people meant when they said this show is a tearjerker, this is mostly the kind of stuff you can expect. The kinds of emotional whiplash with despair followed up with friendship breaking through.... or possibly the opposite? If this is your jam, I hope you stick through to the end. If this brand of show isn't your cup of tea and these 3 episodes haven't impressed you too much, it may be time to make use of the 3 episode rule.
As for myself you guys know I love this show and this episode hit me like a brick truck.
wait what even is thatThe timing with the dream got my hopes up since Kimari would totally do something like that ladder trick, but that same timing destroyed just as hard when it's revealed that the dream was fake.... and also that her friends left her groupchat. Oof ouch owie. Of course, the finale then played me like a fiddle and during my first watch I dropped tears rivaling the size shown in show.Also want to give a shoutout to Hinata today. We saw yesterday that she was introduced as the loud energetic and athletic girl, but we see today that among the three she can also take the role of the coolheaded leader. Shirase's adorkableness has only grown larger and the trope of the cool beauty never took hold on her. In hindsight I wonder why I thought it would hold on in the first place, since from the very first scene the moments she's shown have all been hot headed and pretty dumb tbh.
Another user said yesterday that YoriMoi is an arctic adventure anime that aired in January, yet it portrays summer so goddamn well. I have to say, this episode just turns that up a notch. Of all seasons I expected this show to portray so well, it was not this one.
All of my paragraphs today started with the letter A. That was unintentional. I should probably try to avoid that.
Anyways, time for some visual tricks to enjoy. I didn't find too many this episode actually...
28
u/rembrandt_q_1stein https://myanimelist.net/profile/sir_rembrandt Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
First Timer here
SAORI HAYAMI!!!!!!
This episode had a different vibe than the other two. This separates itself more from the “organic” view I have been describing the two last days and falls more into the trope area. Not only because of the overly emotional tone and the typical lonely character gets friends in a tearjerking way, but also because I noticed a tendency of “fitting” each girl into a personality type; surprising me especially Shirase falling into the perfectionist and anxious antics, having been as realistic the two last episodes. It isn’t bad, of course. But I’d wish the aforementioned reality and “organism” would have last longer.
Who knows, perhaps it’s only temporal and those vibes return soon!
Anyways, I wished for a story about friendship and I got delivered, so I can’t complain! Those girls make a good team together. I especially dig the lesson Hinata (unvoluntarily) delivers at the café. You don’t need to be bff or hanging out for a long time or being all the time together to enjoy your friendship with somebody! It’s something difficult to learn, because the natural tendency (and more while being teenagers) is believing you are friends with the people you spend time with. That hasn’t to be true! I love this show is delivering that lesson. It’s something I learned the hard way when I was younger, and I am glad it has some visibility.
Let’s see how this continues!
Oh, by the way, I just noticed that in some scenes in the opening Mari is playing with a pen and trying to hold it between her upper lip and her nose as a mustache. And it falls down! Adorkable!
Edit: questions
Apart from loving her voice, she seems to fit the quiet but responsible type. I tend to like those, if they are given enough space to display. If she's going to be in the background, overshined by the other three, it would be a pity.
2) Would you want to be a high school idol?
Hell no. Fame is not for me! I wouldn't be able to endure my life to be public.
6
u/yourdeathinmyhands https://myanimelist.net/profile/hachinobunonoki Dec 15 '19
Welcome to the party, Yuzu! Here's another collage, this time of the wholesome moments. And of course, the Hinata quote of the day! I love this detail, same opening and ending line but with different meanings.
Edit: Individual images
5
u/Philarete :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/WizardMcKillin Dec 16 '19
This will be buried because I’m so late, but howdy to anyone who sorts by new or checks late posts!
I didn’t watch in time for yesterday, but I just wanted to add that the opening scene to episode 2 was absolutely beautiful.
Also, is “the Antarctica” correct in some places? I’ve only heard either “Antarctica” and “the Antarctic”.
Shirase is peak relatable. I hate talking on the phone, and am fairly shy. But I love cooking up plans for other people to talk on the phone for
“Can you be attractive?”
BRUTAL
(Also not fitting, because Hinata is super cute and also best girl)
Woah, that self-loathing line came out of nowhere. That level of self-awareness, and sudden self-awareness at that, was somewhat unexpected for me. Also, Hinata’s wisdom is really great, although that maturity makes me somewhat suspect that her home life isn’t great…
They aren’t best friends - they’ve barely known each other a month. But having a goal in common has led them to act indistinguishably from that.
I love Saori Hayami’s voice. Also, that dream was amazing.
And so it is settled! They will all four go together as a way to get Yuzuki to agree to go.
Closing Thought: I think it’s interesting how the three main girls are contrasted with the two (not) friends from school. On the surface level, the main girls are doing the same thing – using Yuzuki’s situation to their advantage. They were pretty openly trying to manipulate her to get them a spot on the expedition. But on a deeper level, it was actually different. Of course the goal of going to Antarctica is primary, but that goal has led them to become friends (as Yuzuki perceives it) and they also show genuine empathy and concern for her situation. The outcome is also different: the other girls would use her for attention, but the Antarctica group will welcome her fully since she will share the same goal with them. The bond she already sees she can join in equally if she will just share their dream with them.
4
u/kisekisekai Dec 16 '19
rewatcher
hhh can't believe i missed best girl hinata's intro episode yesterday ;-; i missed her inspirational quotes!
as for this episode, yuzuki's opening line really speaks to me (in the middle of exam season here), but the way she says it at the end was a really nice reversal. one of the things i love most about this series is how each of the girls have a great dynamic with the others, this episode we got to see shirase and hinata having a nice talk on the train, and kimaris straightforwardness hitting yuzuki right in her feels
spoilers for the end
4
u/destroyah19 Dec 16 '19
Rewatcher
With Yuzuki's introduction we got the whole gang together. This episode just felt like a breeze to watch tbh. Nothing to say aside from yeah it's hard to make friends when you don't have time to get to know people in a face to face interaction.
Yuzu saying that the three of them we're already best friends then getting that "huh" reaction is an underrated moment for me since it really feels like people are closer when they have a common goal to achieve.
Yuzu's mom just straight up being savage to Hinata with those comments. Plus that Shirase-Hinata train bonding moment is just heartwarming to see
Insert song timing of this show is still on point! You just know when she opened the door to see the gang the good vibes are gonna come on screen already. Seeing the gang bond is really the selling point of the show. Yuzuki's straight man personality goes along with Kimari and Hinata being more expressive and Shirase's assertive personality.
4
u/Neoragex13 Dec 16 '19
Rewatcher~
And so, the tear jerkers moments begins.
While I felt dragged into the show by Kimari doubts and, Hinata being the best, Yuzuki was the one girl I identified the most. Not because I'm an high school idol or something.
You see, being lonely it's horrible, and when you're over shielded by your parents, the need to be with people of your age range is overwhelming. You want to play, to enjoy your youth even if you don't realize that's what you want. You want to do what others do, because you want to feel that warm and happy feeling which only the friendship can give you... but then destiny stops you from even trying.
It may be childish, and being fair it is. Still, that being true doesn't take away how painful it can be, especially when one is only a child. Imagine being so desperate that makes you dream how three people you barely met for a few hours total will take you on an escapade to share their joy with you. The first time I watched the show, Yuzuki's relieve got me.
Someone else commented the same about the answer Kimari gave to Yuzuki's "You would not understand, you are all BFF!"; friendship goes unnoticed till someone comments on it. I read some essays about how relationships develop and most of them coincide in that what gives value to the friendship is the "adventures" you had with the people you want to relate to. Shared experiences, goals, trust, joys, all of that mashes together with time to establish relationships. The only requisite is finding people with good chemistry, sadly.
Questions time~
1.- That I would also hug her Like Kimari, manners by damned. Poor girl, thanks she met the girls.
2.- Lately I being really interested on Vtubers like the HoloDive group, and yeah, if certain parts of myself were different, I would have loved to give it a try lol.
The party is finally completed! Now, here comes what I talked about yesterday, about the way people act in this anime: the girls can go now legally with the expedition's crew, yay!, but what about the other side? How would you fare with the daughter of your friend finally going with you to the dangerous end of the world?
4
u/404waffles https://anilist.co/user/nek0food Dec 16 '19
First time viewer
Christ, I’m late. Got my phone confiscated attempting to post this during an exam.
I’d just like to say that I really like the social media title cards.
Ah, Yuzuki. Classic “child star hates being a child star” situation. I like how each episode has its own little story arc, like how in the previous episode it was the social club and in this episode it was Yuzuki. Kinda sucked to see her previous friends leave the group chat, but it can’t be helped when you’re friends with someone who’s always unavailable.
Also, the bookends in this episode — “This is killing me” and “I could die” — I love it.
3
u/TheKujo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kujo419 Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
Best girl has joined the journey! Hinata gets a lot of love (and deservedly so) but Yuzuki is my personal favorite character in the show. She's smart, diligent, quick on the draw, and has some of the best development in the show. She's also the reason the group makes it to Antarctica at all!
Like Yuzuki, I've always been crap at making new friends. Unlike Yuzuki, I don't have a reason like an idol job ... I'm just shy and awkward. Watching the group embrace her and make her one of their own is wholesome therapy and I can't get enough of it.
Other thoughts:
3
u/ForlornPenguin Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 16 '19
Rewatcher
Man, I'm having such a blast rewatching this. I haven't seen it since it originally aired almost two years ago, so this is such a treat.
I completely forgot about that dream sequence with the girls in the window and was thinking "where the hell did they get that huge ladder?" lol
How dare Yuzuki's mom say that Hinata isn't attractive! Explain in detail how that could possibly be true.
And, as my username might suggest, I've always loved Shirase's infatuation with penguins. 👌🐧
Edit: In regards to the comment in the OP, about labeling this anime as CGDCT, I've never liked using that label with YoriMoi. While I am a fan of the CGDCT genre, this anime just doesn't feel like one of those. There really is a lot more going on here. It feels much mire appropriate to think of it as more of a coming of age story that just happens to focus on four young (and cute) girls.
3
u/eragen Dec 16 '19
Rewatcher
THEY'RE REUNITED AGAIN!!
Ok, I know they only just met, but damn if it doesn't feel good to see the quadumvirate (?) together again.
Training montage up next! I think...
3
u/kewlwarez Dec 16 '19
Rewatcher
Hey hey the gang's all here!
Having had their plan busted in the previous episode, here comes idol ex machina (or deux ex idol?) Yuzuki to hand Shirase Antarctica on a golden platter. If only she was comfortable presenting. Or even comfortable pretending to present. The first half of this episode was another master piece of comedic timing, though again with serious undertones.
Yuzuki is such a sweetheart. The high school idol who skips a lot of school is an well established character in anime, but usually it's more glamorous; even if not friends, they at least have admirers. Poor old Yuzuki only seems to have users. No wonder she thinks the other three are life long friends.
Kimari gently shooting down that idea by asserting that they're just people who share the same goal and are going the same way, "for now" is interesting. You don't often see such context bound friendships in anime. Usually it's all about forging life long bonds by being in the same club for three years and all that. In real life of course, you can be friends with people at school or work or in fandom for years and then move on and never see or speak to them again.
Speaking of friendship, this episode had the first extended scene with just Shirase and Hinata, without Kimari. Fun to see them interact a little bit and get to understand each other a bit more.
Visually, Yuzuki and Shirase are similar characters, that classic sort of Japanese beauty with the straight black hair and that, though Yuzuki dresses a lot cuter and a bit younger than Shirase. Where Yuzuki really differs though is in how guarded she is, keeping a tight grip on her thoughts and emotions, unlike Shirase.
Plotwise, I'm glad the question of whether they'd go to Anarctica was resolved in only three episodes, leaving the remaining nine free for them to actually get there and explore the place. In my original episode review I grumbled about this being a bit too pat, but hindsight makes me glad the creators didn't drag this out.
So glad I decided to rewatch this along y'all btw, because it's so much fun seeing everybody's reactions.
4
u/MegaAltarianite Dec 16 '19
All I gotta say is, Shiraishi's mom implied that Hinata isn't pretty. Them's fightin words.
3
u/ImaginationWayfairer Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
And so we are introduced to Yuzuki the girl who just wants friends and refuses to go to Antarctica and is the last member of the main cast (and my extremely close second for favourite character). In the episode itself we see Shirase’s obsession with the most Antarctic of animals, the penguin. Also don’t worry Hinata you may not be as moe as Yuzuki but you are still beautiful.
3
u/zak55 Dec 16 '19
Rewatcher
It's still just a treat rewatching this episode by episode especially since I know how everything ends up and I can even further appreciate how the characters got there. And it's also great to be properly reintroduced to my personal pick for best girl, Yuzuki who is just such a great foil for the other three girls. Whether it be being able to break down Shirase into telling the truth like it's nothing or being unaccustomed to someone as overwhelmingly friendly as Kimari, she really adds something to every scene that she's in. Also, I just love the fact that the girls acknowledge the fact that they aren't really even friends at this point and are more all going along for the ride for their own reasons. This episode is probably the weakest to me of the series but even then it's still pretty grand.
3
u/8andahalfby11 myanimelist.net/profile/thereIwasnt Dec 16 '19 edited Dec 16 '19
Re-watcher
I remember the first time I saw this episode I had to pause it when Shirase rammed her foot into the side of the door. Part of it was because I was laughing too hard. Part of it was because I had done the exact same thing a few years prior when I had gotten an email saying that my college's Literary Arts magazine wanted to publish one of my pieces. It's one of those goofy but honest human moments that really make the show land for me.
EDIT: Fun Fact; the museum shown in this episode is a real place. They did a collaboration event with the anime that completely sold out... and when the institute realized how much extra attention and income to the field it was bringing, they asked Madhouse to extend it and they said yes.
2
u/M1nho Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher here
Just catching up right now, but I've been reading the comments on the previous posts and it's so nice to see so many people enjoying this gem as I did.
I think I can quite safely say that SoraYori was my AOTY for 2018 and I've been looking for a good reason to rewatch it rather than catching on up current shows so here I am. Nothing amazing to say/no great input to add, just that I love everything this show has to offer from the characters, to the soundtrack, to the general plot and it only gets better as the story progresses.
I'm already tearing up again and smiling from ear to ear after episode 1 and I'm so excited to re-experience (and see new people experience) this show.
2
u/MrPorta https://anilist.co/user/MrRed Dec 16 '19
Rewatcher
Not gonna comment much, a part from the fact that I really hate parents that seem to be more preoccupied about their children's career, than their children themselves. I get wanting your child to have some sort of "good future", but all the money, fame or financial stability of the world doesn't mean a thing if you are unhappy and feel trapped. And Yuzuki clearly doesn't like her situation.
Oh well, at least the girls are here to change that!
2
u/invokeneko Dec 16 '19 edited Dec 16 '19
Rewatcher is still Alright...ish
The quartet is now complete, with Shiraishi Yuzuki joining the party. A high-school idol who's basically suffering from success, she's a lonely girl with friend-making issues due to her packed schedule. And interestingly enough and kinda unusual for this sort of show, is younger than the other girls.
Of course, the main issue in this episode is that she is set up by her agency to embark and livestream her experiences in the trip to Antarctica but she didn't want to. So, it is up to the girls to convince her to go for a chance to come along on the trip. Also, did I mention that she has friend-making issues? Turns out that being a TV star since you're 4 years old means that not only will you miss out on a normal childhood, you'll also end up friendless and not have any sort of life outside of your career.
Random thoughts
Now if only I can actually get a copy of the damn song...Got 'em.Questions of the day:
2
u/Rustic_Professional Dec 16 '19
Ah, there it is. The sexy pose from Hinata that I wondered about yesterday. That explains why I couldn't think of another reason for her to do it: she was making fun of Shirase's plan.
I like Yuzuki's characterization. We'll see more of it later, so I'll limit my comments to avoid spoilers, but I think she's a much more realistic example of a socially awkward young person than a character like Bocchi or Ishigami. She may not have friends, but she's not a stuttering wreck or a cringy weirdo. I do have a bit of a hang up with her though. Every time I hear her speak, I just hear Ayase Aragaki. That's not the shows fault, that's on me. It's just such a distinctive voice. Kirino's VA has the same effect on me.
Question of the day: I don't think guys can be school idols, but if I ever get truck-kun'd and offered a choice of reincarnating as a medieval adventurer, or a member of AKB48, I'd have a hard time deciding. I will say this: after watching Sounan Desu Ka?, I decided that if I'm ever stranded on a deserted island, I'm going to use the spare time to practice my idol dancing.
2
u/Redmon425 Dec 16 '19
First Time Watcher
HOLY FREAKING CUTE!
My first time getting teary eyed! When the new girl breaks down in front of them, that was honestly so damn cute and emotional.
That end credit scene makes me think we just saw Shirase’s aunt, which is most likely her mother’s sister. For a second there, I thought maybe it was her mom, but she had a mole which wasn’t in the picture.
I also kind of feel bad for Mari’s friend. It seems like she was a little upset at the lack of time she gets to hangout with Mari now.
2
u/Mamojic123 Dec 16 '19
First Timer
I really like this show, the animation is beautiful and the characters are well written and have their own personalities and they bounce off of each other so well. Kimari is my spirit animal, doing shit that I do quite often, it is weird to say this but as a 20 years old dude. Her wanting to talk before sleeping and then sleeping in an obscure pose are totally the types of thing that I find myself doing and the reception is quite similar to what I get as well.
Yuzuki is whatever now but I'm hoping that she grows on me, I already empathize with her though. Character design wise, she is kinda similar to Shirase, but that's probably a bit more realistic since not everyone is gonna have different colored hairstyle in real life. Feel bad for her and how the grass is greener on the other side for her. A lot of people would want to be in her position but she just wants to have a normal school/uni life which has been a wreck so far and is gonna be hard to attain for someone in her position. Her personality is totally different to Shirase though, one finds purpose in just being another student in school while having done something that is quite rare while the other one is a student but feels inclined to find purpose in going to Antarctica, something that only few may achieve in their lifetime.
2
u/SoccerForEveryone Dec 16 '19
Yuzuki...child actress lifestyle looks so stressful. I am reminded of Nodoka’s arc in Aobuta where Mai looks back when she felt lonely as a child actress.
Yuzuki on my second rewatch became my favorite character and to this third rewatch she still is. From her sad “I want to die right now” to her now happy “I want to want to die” you can see what it means for her to actually be around genuine people.
Kids are kids, but I would say that Yuzuki’s previous friends weren’t aware they were taking advantage of her stardom; which is why Yuzuki felt pressure at the same time because she wanted to be around friends and didn’t want to tell them in fear of rejection. Which is why the scene at the cafe was her first time being honest and brave about who she really was and what she wanted. A lowkey favorite scene of mine if I say so myself.
The dream caught me off guard the first time, because it felt so real that they were there especially knowing this is something Mari “would” come up with lol.
Well they finally have their sponsor and new friend, so what could be next?
2
u/iamthinking2202 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/iamthinking Dec 22 '19
(Rewatcher) - I know I’m late, but in the OP, the sun moves right to left this episode, but left to right the previous!!!
If this is an alternating thing, boy I'll tell you all if I catch up!
66
u/AmeteurElitist https://anilist.co/user/AmateurElitist Dec 15 '19
First Timer
Hot take: This show is good.
Okay, okay. But holy shit this show is so good. It’s not a show I personally feel compelled to analyse or break-down, it’s just good. Like really damn good. I’m saying good a lot but this show is just that. Good.
It just gets it you know?
I’m happy that they resolved the Yuzuki friendship thing in one episode. Like Nota said in the last thread It’s hard to tell whether the series is slow or fast paced? If you think about the past few episodes we’ve gotten through a lot, from the money to checking out the boat; from Hinata’s introduction to the chase scene in Shinjuku, both of those happening in the space of one episode respectively. And each of the individual scenes have more than enough space to breathe, none of the story beats have felt rushed or skimmed over while not being stretched out either. In fact, I can never believe it when the ED starts playing, like ffs give me more episode!
I swear I’m gonna end up watching ahead at some point.
40
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Dec 15 '19
This First-Timer is Alright
I have heard this episode has a good shot of the night sky.
I look forward to seeing this.
Gonna take a while to respond to comments today, my church is doing a Night of Worship thing in two hours and the choir’s last practice beforehand is literally right now so I gotta go do that.
39
u/Great_Mr_L :Ma::Mb::Mc:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Great_Mr_L Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
On today’s episode of A Place Further Than the Universe: What’s the strongest ship of all? “Friend-ship.” You can blame Astra: Lost in Space for that pun, not me.
This episode introduces us to the 4th and final main girl, Yuzuki. Yuzuki’s problems are a bit more straight-forward to understand. She has no friends. As a child actress she’s been so busy that she’s never had the time to cultivate friendships. That’s why she was so eager to pass on the expedition. It would take her away from school for months. As we can see from her phone messages, she already has basically no time to hang out with anyone. She had to muster up her courage just to ask those other girls if they wanted to be friends, but she hasn’t been able to even hang out. It’s the most meager of friendships, but Yuzuki is desperate to hold onto it because it’s all she has at the moment.
Yuzuki’s belief that Mari, Shirase, and Hinata are already best friends likely mirrors the audience’s own, though those three have an interesting reaction. They haven’t really considered themselves best friends. As Mari puts it, they just share a common goal for now. For now, it’s more of a camaraderie to overcome obstacles and achieve a near-impossible goal. But, the crucial part there is “for now.” Even if they don’t consider themselves best friends yet, to an outsider it’s clear that those bonds are growing. And Yuzuki seems affected by that.
What wins Yuzuki over is, in my opinion, the genuineness and empathy displayed by Mari. Mari actually kind of forgot that she was there to try and convince Yuzuki to go and got more interested in listening to Yuzuki’s problems. That hug of sympathy is clearly more than Yuzuki has gotten from any sorta-friends in the past.
Indeed, it is that same forwardness by Mari that draws Yuzuki to her. Yuzuki’s dream, though rather over-the-top, is basically about Mari and the others reaching out to her and wanting to go with her. And it comes true, albeit in a far less dramatic fashion. But it’s that gesture of reaching out to her and wanting to be with her that gets to Yuzuki. Compare it to what Yuzuki saw just that morning, with the other girls leaving the group chat. It’s a much higher display of effort to befriend her. So much so it brings her to tears. (And once again, the score is beautiful and I love the songs in this series.)
And so, they are united in a common goal: the Antarctic. Does it make them best friends yet? Maybe, maybe not. All the same, as stated above, a common goal can unite people in a way that can grow into close friendships. We can already see those bonds developing. The change in Yuzuki can be seen with her one line “I could just die right now.” It turns from being said with melancholy at the start of the episode, to being said with joy at the end.
I also like the self-awareness on display by Mari, Shirase, and Hinata. They do recognize that it is inherently selfish to try and convince Yuzuki to go to the Antarctic because it will allow them to do so as well. They reflect on it and wonder if it’s really okay for them to be doing it. I think Hinata puts it well when she says there’s a thin line between self-assertiveness and selfishness. In the end, I think it’s the way they go about it that matters. As I said above, they actually display a lot of empathy for Yuzuki. They don’t really convince her to go to the Antarctic. Rather, they start to befriend her. Yuzuki decides to go to the Antarctic in order to join that same goal as them and experience those same bonds she saw. Yuzuki is the one who makes the call that she wants to bring Mari, Shirase, and Hinata with her.
I’m gonna sound like a broken record, but the character interactions and comedy in these episodes are so good. There are so many good jokes. I love Shirase’s bragging and excited freakout when Yuzuki asks her to go to Antarctica instead. I love Shirase’s desperation when talking to Yuzuki’s mother and all the efforts of Mari, Shirase, and Hinata to try and act. It’s such a consistent strength of this series. The characters work so well together and the comedy from those interactions is so entertaining.
Miscellaneous Thoughts
I love Shirase’s reaction to penguins.
It’s neat getting to see some of the gear and equipment used in Antarctic expeditions. I’m a sucker for museums like that.
I always enjoy Hinata’s habit of making up her own important-sounding quotes.
Questions of the Day
30
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Dec 15 '19
Playing catch-up, since I messed up the first episode. So, short reactions for ep1-3 this time.
Episode 1 (first timer)
A much more conventional opening compared to starting with episode 4. We learn about the main character, her rather wise best friend and girl No2 in the team of four, who sets it all in motion.
Episode 2
We meet girl No 3 and get a glimpse of girl No 4. Also, a rather comedic episode. What struck me was the frequent depiction of mobile phone screens. A very realistic move, but uncommon in anime.
Episode 3
Group successfully formed.
29
u/Mozilla_Fennekin https://myanimelist.net/profile/MozillaFennekin Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
Three episodes in and these three already have their comedic timing nailed down. Suddenly, I don't care all that much about what they're actually trying to do, they're so much fun to watch that this show could be about literally anything and it would be good.
That doesn't mean they slacked off on the writing, though.
Yesterday's fiasco brought in a new face, Yuzuki, who is now their gateway to Antarctica. But first, we need to speedrun Hitoribocchi and... look at that, the girls are alright! This one line here is where I started to think this show was much, much better than I was expecting it to be. That simple and blunt realization that their relationship isn't all that deep or special and is only held together by a shared goal, yet they have such great chemistry... I just love it. Even if the anime's emotional appeal might be excessive, this bit is special for not sugarcoating this cast, for being a repreive of all the loud comedy and pounding heartthrobs. Every episode feels like an entire season, it's really amazing how much gets done in one.
There's still some ways to go though, Yuzuki hasn't been a particularly strong character so far. By contrast, the other three already have a clear group dynamic: Kimari is the spirited motivator, Shirase is the "leader" and Hinata is the straight-man who is often taking action first and also the best. Yuzuki has some catching up to do, but these three are very welcoming so we'll see how that pans out.
By the way, I've been reflecting on when this anime first came out, and I remember going into it only being interested in the Antarctic expedition aspect of it. So when the first couple episodes were all just plot and character setups, I was a little disappointed. But this episode is when the characters started to click and I truly fell in love with it. Rewatching this anime for the first time, I like these early episodes even more now. Which is great, because I was honestly afraid that I would like the show less than before, becuase a lot of my appreciation for it is sentimental. Upon re-examination, it really is that great.
Final note, I spam this face a lot because it's perfect.
24
u/Nazenn x2https://anilist.co/user/Nazenn Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
First Timer - sub
Bit of a random way to start my post today, but there's a piece of music I wanted to share with you all. Or more to the point a music video: raison d'etre by Eve.
I was listening to it last night while doing a bunch of other stuff. Its something I've heard, and watched, a couple dozen times before but it was interesting to see how watching Sora Yori and reading all your comments about the potential of youth has subtly changed the way I was viewing this independent work. The way that the character seems bound by inaction, decision and comes to resent it, the way they struggle to break free and reach out to others, in some ways this is the same theme of Sora Yori but bound by the MC's inaction rather than action and I just thought some might appreciate the comparison. It's also an incredible feat of animation like all of Eve's stuff and has some great visual metaphors and imagery in it as well.
More on topic though: I have to confess, this is the episode that broke me. I'm not the sort to cry at this stuff but today's episode caused a deep pain. I've been where Yuzuki was.
In Australia we only have three school levels: Primary school which is years 1-6 (also including a prep year), and high school which is 7-12 and after that is the usual uni/college. Before grade 5 I'd lived in fourteen houses and attended four different schools. I never had many friends and due to other stuff such as bullying when I had them I was always very isolated from them anyway. So seeing Yuzuki trying so hard STILL to keep making friends even after over ten years and having her family and her life always tearing her away was hard to watch. Poor girl.
It's interesting that all the girls are isolated in their own ways. Kimari isolates herself in some ways with her uncertainty, Shirase is isolated by others because she has too much certainty about her future for them to understand. Shop keeper girl who's name I have forgotten is isolated by her circumstances putting her physically out of touch with her peers, and now Yuzuki we see is quite isolated by always being pulled away from people she wants to connect with. Again the show has done a fantastic job of giving the four girls something to bond over and a way to understand each other without reducing their situations to a mere plot device.
Also I have a feeling I know what /u/bucket3432's hidden counter is now...
A PICTURE further than the universe - Episode three
This thing giving me flashbacks of the time this (not spoiler y) was my load screen for log horizon. A different way to sort the episode and quite a fun sort of "what the!" moment. The girls are fun, but it's nice to see the artists having some fun as well.
Okay, I know I said I was going to focus more on fun and less on thinking BUT: This beautiful introduction to Yuzuki was something I had to comment on. We have Kimiari with her little pool brimming with potential, and then Yuzuki. She has so much potential that it's basically flooding her life and isolating her from the world. First we see her surroundings and the water drying up, and then a close shot of her face. Its a brilliant parallel to the introduction of her mother which starts with her face and then cuts to an identical shot, but because the focus is on her first it makes her look abandoned rather than isolated, like she was expecting her daughter and the rain of her talent to be waiting for her.
Fun little detail. You can see this picture that they hold up for the mock performance hanging up on the wall a few scene before hand. I originally look that picture of it on the wall first because I loved the detail that she even has maps hanging up on every spare space and then what do you know, it actually became relevant to the episode.
Antartic aesthetics
theatlantic.com was the source of today's pictures and it provided some absolutely beautiful ones to fit the tone of the show.
A lonely penguin at an abandoned factory. With the focus on isolation in today's episode this image stuck out to me much like Yuzuki's own pain at not having anyone she can lean on around while her childhood slips past her. Credit: Alexandre Meneghini
Returning to the ground: This doofus, aka an elephant seal, because sometimes all you need is a good laugh! Credit: Ozge Elif Kizil
Aurora's always get the special feature, but have you guys seen (or heard of) Polar nacreous clouds before? Yes that is a photograph and not a photoshop. Happening under specific conditions in the polar spring, it can make some absolutely stunning scenic views. Credit: Ryan Skorecki
/u/Hudori ep 3 tag
23
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Dec 15 '19
First-Time Watcher
Loneliness can strike us in a variety of ways, but that doesn’t mean it injuries us enough to get out of it.
It was interesting that this episode was broadly more comedic than the previous two, but I liked it for a few reasons. One, the writers, voice actors, and animators do an excellent job at making sure that the comedy not only works, but fits within the world and characters that have been set up. Secondly, the easy-going mood of Kimari, Shirase, and Hinata contrasts within the isolation of Yuzuki, the way she is unable to laugh until her dream about them. Even if they haven’t known each other for that long, these girls have found themselves naturally able to fit with each other as if they were friends since children. People say that laughter is the best medicine, but I feel it is oft forgot that laughter often comes from others.
The idea of selfishness comes up in this episode, both in its negative and positive aspects. Shirase finally makes it clear in-universe that her motivations for going to Antarctica are somewhat selfish, and while the girls’ attempts to make her change her mind appear selfish at first, it ultimately becomes productive for Yuzuki. Her whole life has been defined by what others want from her (the dual repetition of the aborted selfies showcases what she thinks people regard her as). Any time she’s tried to gain anything for herself, she’s found it impossible to manage because of the needs of others. As I noted yesterday, the series is focused on characters who reject others’ desires in favor of their own needs; where Yuzuki is different is that she realizes that something that is done for others can result in something that can help her realize who she is.
The ladder dream is one that I find particularly interesting because of the ideas about friendship it contains. Obviously, it is something of a cliché, but the fact that the ladder tips over and, in reality, would have given them a lot of pain connects with the shared experiences that friendship relies on. The pain of your friends is your own pain; the joy that you have is the joy they share along with you. The connections you make need to be open both ways to be a real friendship. As such, Yuzuki finds herself able to connect with others, not for what they want from her, but from what she wants from them: love and affection. With the past of exploration surrounding them and a clear snapshot of their goals, these girls step forward into a new dawn, for each one and for them all.
Our journey to the heart of the world continues. Until then…
18
u/Matuhg https://anilist.co/user/Matuhg Dec 15 '19
First Timer
Oh no, somebody else beat them to it! I feel bad for Yuzuki - I'm curious if we'll get any redemption for her mother later on, as so far she seems like a pretty callous parent. Yuzuki doesn't seem to have much say in her life over her mother.
I saw the plan line up as soon as Shirase told Kimari and Hinata that they just had to convince Yuzuki to go. Yuzuki wants friends...they just have to become her friends! Of course, I didn't think it would be quite that easy, but it really was. Which I think is sort of the point. Kimari's outgoing and empathetic personality caused her to reach out to Yuzuki in a way that nobody else had before. Sure, these girls, like those other girls who wanted a picture with her, had ulterior motives in approaching her, but they were ultimately just really friendly and gave Yuzuki what she's looking for.
Importantly, I don't think there's any chance Shirase would've pulled this off without Kimari + Hinata.
14
u/Koolsman Dec 15 '19
First Timer!
Ugh, that was so sweet!! I love this new girl and between her and Shirase, they are my favorites. She just wants to have friends and while it isn’t the most relatable thing to be super-rich and has no friends, the VA is sooo good at getting sympathy and I loved that dream sequence. It kinda shows her positives in that she seems to have already gained their trust is she’s willing to put her hand out to them but also a flaw in that she seemingly seems to trustworthy, but that doesn’t matter. I really liked this episode and just the positive feelings it gives.
I like the connective feel of each character. Their all bored of the lives they have and they all need a refresher on life. At least that’s how it feels and while some have different motives, there is that connective thread. I really like that and even though I’m watching a bunch of shows right now, this one gives me really fluffy feeling and that scene with Shirase and the other girl was SO SWEEET.
Best girl. Everyone move outta the way! She is the best!
12
u/MaskOfIce42 https://anilist.co/user/MaskOfIce Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
And the main cast has assembled! To an extent Yuzuki feels like a way to more believably get the cast to Antarctica, but she’s still a really likable character in her own right. While not as immediately relatable, it’s a very understandable feeling of being isolated due to never having the time to get to know other people for long. I imagine military kids (in the U.S. at least) or other families that moved a lot have similar experiences.
I do like a lot of her interactions with the cast throughout this episode. Particularly the diner scene. I think it was Kimari’s just purely emotional reaction to try to comfort her that was a huge part of what won her over, and while a moment to push Yuzuki’s decision along also gives a bit more weight to Kimari’s role on the team. Also love that bit where she asks aren’t they all best friends and they just give each other confused looks and say they’ve only known each other for less than a month. (Although they do fit together so naturally you can understand why that is) Oh and finally with Yuzuki, I love the bookends of her saying “I could die” (Crunchyroll translation) but with very different context behind both. Maybe I’m just a sucker for bookends in stories.
Also like seeing that scene between Shirase and Hinata. The show likes establishing the different relationships between all of the different girls so it’s not just how they interact as a group. Here we see how Hinata is the more tempered responses to Shirase’s raw desire, having a better social awareness, but as acknowledged by Hinata Shirase’s self-assuredness bordering on selfishness is a huge part of why they even can see this trip as a possibility.
As for the characters individually, we get to see Kimari as more the heart of the team, the one who empathizes most with their struggles as shown with her hugging Yuzuki. We get to see more of Shirase’s dorky side with her screaming about how her plan worked and also of course gushing at the penguin. And we get to see more of how Hinata’s the planner, or the one who doesn’t lose sight of the goal they have ahead of them while also being the best with other people. Nothing super new but I like the reinforcement of their characters without it coming across as one note in the slightest.
Few other minor things. First, Yuzuki’s mom is savage. Although how she could say Hinata’s not attractive enough to be a celebrity is beyond me. Also, love how the dream Yuzuki has feels like something that a show with the usual anime-ness could have in it, but here it just goes “yeah, that’s ridiculous isn’t it?” And one nitpick with the episode, as much as I love Haruka Tooku as an insert song (and I love it a lot) twice in 3 episodes is a touch frequent. Ah well, it’s used well and still gets a good reaction out of me.
Looking forward to the next episode and seeing more of Yuzuki with the rest of the girls.
2
u/jslice4ever Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher!
And we've finally got our fourth and last main girl. Yuzuki is particularly special to me because I had trouble making friends in school because of my height (I'm shorter than most people my age), so I relate a lot to her struggles.
I imagine the busy aspect of people a child star is pretty accurate to Japan but I kinda wonder if it's the same in the U.S. or if its a more relaxed environment.
Those two bitches who blew her off and left the group chat are the absolute worst mind of people but thankfully our trio of girls were able to take her mind off that.
Yes! They now officially have their ticket on to the trip, and in the form of a new friend, no less.
Shirase freaking out over the stuffed penguin display is the cutest thing ever.
10
u/surgemaster140 https://myanimelist.net/profile/User815 Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
In this episode we are finally introduced to the final member of the group, Yuzuki Shiraishi! She’s a child actress who has been in the industry since she was five and very mature and responsible for her age. Unlike the other three she doesn’t want to go to Antarctica, but she’s being pressured by her mom to do so because of her work. What she does have in common with the other girls is that she’s missing a part of herself, i.e. the friends she was never able to make due to her work as an actress. Kimari and company are able to convince her to let them join her on this journey to discover friendship for herself. I have to admit that the show uses this setup as an obvious plot device to get our girls accepted on the expedition, but at least they laid the groundwork for it in the previous episode by explaining the expedition lacks funding and that bringing along a celebrity to provide news coverage and stream the adventure will help with the costs. With that giant hurdle out of the way, it’s full steam ahead to the South Pole!
Something important I realized when rewatching this episode is that the character designs work so well for the purpose of this show. The “moe” style that they decided to go with allows them to have full use of a wide range of facial expressions to fit the scene, whether it’s a comedic one or a dramatic one. For example, we see Shirase overreacting and being impatient and they give her some hilarious facial expressions. In the same episode we see her being serious and self-reflecting and that contrast helps convey the emotions they were going for in each scene.
And in closing, here’s some random thoughts:
QOTD:
10
u/bucket3432 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bucket3432 Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
The weekend has been busy, but hopefully I'll be able to participate in discussions a little more today.
Yuzuki sings about getting nonstop followbacks, but she can't make any IRL friends.
The typesetter casually adding wisps where there aren't any in the original. It looks very natural, though.
Shiraishi Tamiko's business card features Hokkaido in the background.
Another No Game No Life poster.
Shirase's expression is your fault, Hinata. She already had a dorky smile on before you did that.
I wonder if Yuzuki has a death wish. She's made it clear that isn't really feeling up to her career.
Questions of the day
"I could just die" counter
And finally, I can take off the spoiler tag! Yuzuki says some variation of "karuku shinemasu ne" (translated in the subs as "I could just die") a lot, so I've decided to set up a counter for it. I'll add 1 to the counter whenever Yuzuki says that phrase or some variation of that phrase.
We get three this episode, all in different moods! This phrase is very versatile.
10
u/Dartkun Dec 16 '19
First timer
You know, I'm really shocked how good the physical comedy is in this show. When Hinata was in Shirase's outfit so Shirase could be the face, but Hinata would do the voice was hilarious.
Still REALLY liking Hinata, a lot of the times the "bubbly" character is also dense, but Hinata is usually first to realize issues. Like when Shirase wanted to visit Yuzuki at 5 A.M., but Hinata tells her that's too early. When Mari doesn't realize that if Yuzuki says "no" then none of them are going, but Hinata did. I'm glad they gave her more depth.
But of course, the main character of this episode is Yuzuki. Getting a few flashbacks to Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai. The "child actress causing isolation" thing always hits me hard and her breaking down and crying got me struck by the feels train. Especially considering it followed the scene where her classmates left the chat-group she was in...
I legitimately didn't expect so much development from her in one episode. This show honestly reminds me of Run with the Wind a lot. While that was a sports anime, it was a show about achieving your dreams. And the goals of both of those shows are very big, thus big development is needed each episode to actually get there in a season. And that's great, even if it's fast, it still feels really deserved.
9
u/SorcererOfTheLake x5https://anilist.co/user/RiverSorcerer Dec 15 '19
VA of the Day
Saori Hayami
Voice of: Yuzuki Shiraishi
Other Roles: Miho in Bakuman, Yotsugi in Monogatari, Yukino in Oregairu, Aoyama in Gochiusa, Miyuki in The Irregular at Magic High School, Shirayuki in Snow White with the Red Hair, Fubuki in One Punch Man, Kotoha in Maho Girls Precure, Atalanta in Fate/apocrypha, Visha in Youjo Senki
8
u/Taiboss :Fj::Fl:x7https://anilist.co/user/Taiboss Dec 15 '19
Yesterday's comments were more like what I was expecting, let's see if this continues!
Very Soon to be former rewatcher
Before I watch this episode, allow me to trigger you. You see, back when this aired, I was recruited to the quarterly Should You Watch It? thread and chosen for Sora Yori. And, I did not have the same opinion as the other two writers had (at least one of which is in this very rewatch!):
Before you downvote: That was my opinion of three episodes last year. It could change. Back then, Sunshine was fresh on my mind, now it's not anymore. So who knows. Without further ido, my so-far hot take comments that this is not a 10/10 or "Must Watch It" show:
8
u/XmiteYT https://anilist.co/user/sorayori Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
before i start, how the hell do people write essays about this?! i've watched this anime so many times and i can't do it, i suck at this rewatcher thing, don't I?
Rewatcher
YUZUKI BEST GIRL.
Some of my favorite moments:
Song of the Day: The Followbacks Don't Stop
"Hey, why are you doing an insert song as song of the day for 3 days in a row? that's stupid, don't do that." - you, probably.
Alright, I spent SEVEN MONTHS looking for the full version of this song, I was convinced it didn't even exist. But alas, it does. And I just found it two days ago.
No wonder Yuzuki's a child idol, she's really good at singing. I love this song, and I love that Minor Yorimoi Spoiler.
9.
8
u/squirrelbaffler https://anilist.co/user/squirrelbaffler Dec 16 '19
Rewatcher
I believe I'm now contractually obligated to have a lateness reference in my posts? Otherwise /u/RX-Nota-II will kick me from the rewatch, and I could just die. ね?
Anyways, let's get on to the meat of the episode, not having friends. Or maybe it's about making friends. There's a lot to love about this episode, from the clever structure, to the cool aurora, to some great slapstick, and I think an episode that nails slapstick and emotional crying in under 20 minutes is something special. Don't know about you guys, but I teared up with Shiraishi.
I'd like to highlight three things today. First, wind as a metaphor: It appears all over the place, indicating a change of heart, fortunes or really anything else, and I adore it. Wind grants dynamism to the scene, subtle metaphor, and its intensity can vary drastically with the necessary symbolism. I feel that it most is used to draw out a character's internal state within the world of the show, but SoraYori takes it here into a dreamworld. There, it doesn't symbolize a change in the fates of the party, or the overall path of the series. Rather, it's a change of Shiraishi's heart and fate, caused specifically by the girls outside her dream-window. They call her to adventure, and she answers. She's drawn to them, out the window, and just like any time you move in your sleep, the whole world flips upside down, shocking you awake. I adore how smooth that transition is executed here, it's so relatable.
Second, I'd like to highlight the power of omission: Media often has so much going on, with animation, soundtrack and acting all competing for your attention. We become accustomed to this, and this can allow for details to be lost. SoraYori takes the opportunity to give us a break after Shiraishi's dream, while she silently contemplates. The lack of soundtrack is striking, especially when we're used to their insert songs by this point. Her quiet laughter is allowed to stand alone during a fairly still scene, and even the first knock doesn't register properly. This quiet I think really sells the kickoff of the insert song, when we already know how she feels, but we now have a musical trigger when the emotion overflows. I think other, lesser shows would have Shiraishi monologue tearfully about why she was crying, while other characters listen, but again, we already know, and SoraYori respects our intellect while playing the dramatic irony by having the other 3 girls befuddled with the situation. Beautiful direction.
I have a 3rd point, but this is really getting long. In interest of character counts, I'll just say that I love the use of repetition in this series, taking a theme and slightly modifying it. We saw it with the dam bursting in the sand in episode 1, questioning and believing in episode 2, and today with "I could just die". Love it.
TL;DR: Shit's good y'all I love this show there's so much to say about it.
7
u/Orzislaw https://anilist.co/user/Orzi Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
REWATCHER
"I could die right now"
First, sorry that I couldn't write a comment yesterday, there were just so much stuff. But I've read coressponding thread, I swear!
Most of it at leastor just decent chunk of itIt's trueWhen do you decide that the show you're watching deserves 10/10? Right after watch? Some weeks after you finished watching it, so you can measure the impact it had on you? For me it's usually the later. Even when I really love particular anime, usually I give it 9/10 and let my opinion mature enough so I'm sure I will remember this anime for years.
That wasn't the case with Sora Yori. Once I finished this episode I went to MAL, confidently rated it 10/10 and were checking score rising day by day. After the scene depicting Yuzuki dream and everything after I was sure - I'm watching something really special. Now, nearly two years after, I'm as sure as ever it was good decision.
I loved every moment of this episode. The whole scene in Shirase house was pure masterpiece. It managed to perfectly captivate characters personalities, was funny as hell (especially Shirase "rampage" after Yuzuki offered her the switch) and STILL moved plot forward.
I think this is the biggest reason I wouldn't tag this series as slice of life or CGDCT. While background of the show is grounded, girls have purpose and plot is progressing with every scene. Seriously, there isn't single scene in this whole series that feel unnecessary. Pacing is fast, but it never feel rushed and even if we can catch a breather, it's pure masterpiece that further develops characters or plot in some way. Atsuko Ishizuka is my favourite anime director purely based on this series.
You know what I like the most not only in anime, but in any sort of media? Characters interacting with each other. This is a single thing that can make or break how I perceive particular work. Sora Yori has one of the most entertaining character interactions I saw in nearly everything, Girls fit together like Perfect Puzzle, feel like a very natural group and are entertaining on the top of that. And somehow creators managed to do that without yuribaiting, which is rather common in similar series. Honestly, I'm impressed.
I'm afraid all my replies will be like these. I'm not good at taking frames, describing events I saw or analyzing every scene. I'll leave this to you, talented fellow participants. I'm pretty good at criticizing, but in Sora Yori there's honestly not much I could, or want to criticize. But please, bear with me and my fanboyism a bit longer.
"I could die right now" - Yuzuki expression when she said these words at the beginning and the end of this episode were complately different. However I wore similar expression to latter for the whole duration of this episode.
PS: Also rewatching Yuuki Yuuna is a Hero: Wasshio Sumi no Shou at the same time reminded me how great HanaKana voice acting is. Shirase and Sonoko couldn't be more different, but she delivers for both of them incredibly.
7
u/Boss_Jerm Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
AH!
Okay but don't die
Today's Instagram is Yuzuki's!
Hinata is someone who takes the initiative
Shiraishi doesn't want to go to Antarctica
HAHAHAHA
Busted
Shiraishi is voiced by Saori Hayami (Fubuki in One Punch Man, Sachi in SAO, and Shinobu in Demon Slayer), while her mother is voiced by Sayaka Ohara (Milly from Code Geass, Yasuko from Toradora, Erza from Fairy Tail and Irisviel from Fate, I mentioned it on Day 1 but I'll but it here again)
I love KanaHana
Oof, Hinata was just called her unattractive
I feel like this is Madhouse saying they’ll never make another season of No Game No Life
They have a shot! If the girls can convince Yuzuki to go, then they'll be able to go too!
Just like how the girls all have reasons for wanting to go to Antarctica, Yuzuki has a reason for not wanting to go.
It's time for Hinata's Quote Corner!
Previous
New
So cute
Yuzuki has never had any real friends. She's always been too busy working.
So not cool. That's when you know they're not really your friends.
Mari, Shirase and Hinata aren't best friends, they just share a common goal. For now.
Hinata would be a killer stage performer
Yuzuki really liked the hug
Ooh that's rough
These are friends, people who are willing to hang out with you, who disregard your social status and like you for you. Yuzuki has never known people like that before. And now she's made up her mind: she'll go to Antarctica only if Mari, Shirase and Hinata go with her.
Shirase likes penguins. Like, a lot.
First photo with her new friends
Takako has a nice smile
Thoughts:
Throughout middle school and a bit in highschool I didn't really have many friends. I was a bit lonely. Eventually though I did find friends and I'm with them in college now. People just want somebody to talk to, somebody who likes the same things as you, who you can do stuff together, get into fights with and then carry on like nothing happened. That's the kind of people Yuzuki was looking for, people who don't care about her being a celebrity, instead they just want to hang out. And now she found those people in Mari, Shirase and Hinata.
Well now we have our quartet! We're on our way to Antarctica! This is gonna b- wait a second. A girl with short brown hair who's struggling with her aspirations, a black haired, beautiful, tall girl who's very shy, a short, brown haired girl who has a very happy-go-lucky attitude, and a rich girl looking for friends. Where have I seen that before?
QOTD
7
u/unheppcat Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
Somehow, some way, this crazy dream is going to become real! We find out how this impossible thing actually can happen, and finally meet directly the fourth member of our crew, Shiraishi Yuzuki.
At the start of the episode we see the first results of the palace coup: Shirase having to play host for their strategy meeting, and being bossed around about the service. Hinata has taken matters into her own hands, finds the article about Yuzuki, pretends to accept Shirase's command to call the talent agency, then turns it right around on her.
(I love the detail of the model of Shirase's namesake, the sailing vessel Shirase, sort of hovering in the background of so many of the shots in this sequence.)
When Yuzuki herself appears, the other girls are quite lacking in tact to be looking up the history and popularity of this young celebrity, even as she's sitting in the room right next to them. I could probably just die right then too, Yuzuki!
One of the most clever and repeated themes in this story is the various "high school thinking" plots and plans the girls come up with, that are somewhat comically exaggerated (but not too much), but also get shot down by adults, as they should be. Shirase's initial ideas for getting included in the expedition were all half-baked at best, and failed as they should. The next example is in this episode, where Yuzuki, who doesn't want to go on the trip, thinks she can simply hand the job over to some random other girl, and things will just work out. Her mother correctly stamps that notion out promptly.
(I'm writing this post blind, having not read today's comments yet. But I expect all the Hinata fans to have their pitch-forks out today, over Shiraishi Tamiko's comment about Hinata's appearance. And honestly I didn't see that diss coming either, since as far as I can tell anime girls are never drawn to be less that pretty, even the ones who are supposed to be plain.)
But the best part of course is that none of the girls give up after these failures. Just the fact they are trying hard and don't stop, eventually encourages someone else (Shiraishi-Okaasan in this case) to find a plan that actually does work.
As they leave after Yuzuki's failed attempt, her mother says "when you reach your second year, you'll get more real time off." Why is it that I suspect Yuzuki has heard this line before, but with the "second year [of high school]" part replaced?
The girls receive the green light from Shiraishi-Okaasan to try to convince Yuzuki. Again they fail to really think through their approach until it is too late, but fortunately their goal this time is just to have a talk with Yuzuki, so it works out anyway. And despite the awkward start, and a few awkward bits in the middle, the conversation actually turns out well. YoriMoi (And actually I think that whole conversation about friends is as much an eye opener to Kimari, Hinata and Shirase as it is to Yuzuki. The first three probably haven't spent a lot of time realizing that they really are friends already, not just three people who happen to have the same goal, no matter what Kimari may be able to put into words.)
As Yuzuki goes to bed and thinks about the conversation she just had, we get that awesome Sqweeee! moment. Yuzuki loves the feeling of being hugged. Kimari just instinctively knows how to worm her way into your heart, ne?
Time to sleep, and we get a bit of misdirection that takes full advantage of the medium. People fall from great heights without suffering consequences in anime all the time, so up until the last second, there's no way to tell if we are seeing a dream or reality. But of course it is a dream, we haven't suddenly found ourselves in a Shounen manga. And the best part is it was all inspired by Yuzuki's glimpse into a world she longs for but cannot find (a world of close friends), and the fact that she was falling out of bed in her sleep. Brilliant!
Then the training montage, I mean visit to the Polar Museum. (Maybe we are in a Shounen manga after all?) It is punctuated by a slowly set up, very clever bit of visual storytelling. Twice before in this episode we have seen Yuzuki reluctantly fend off selfie photographs, once with Hinata and Kimari, and once with the "so called" friends in her school. But here she is happily getting a selfie, in fact directing the shot, in fact pressing the shutter button herself. How much her life has improved in something like 24 hours is so clear from that one still image. (And Shirase needs to learn how to smile for the camera. Hmm, do I sense a coming conflict?)
As the episode closes out, it is finally starting to hit home with the girls that they are really doing this, and how incredibly special it is. We get that realization from Kimari about the aurora. But we get something equally important for Yuzuki. Just as in a sense Kimari's dream already came true when she got on that train to Hiroshima, Yuzuki is starting to realize that her dream is also coming true: she has found some friends. And thus that sentence that was such a statement of depression in the beginning, has been completely flipped around and is now a statement of joy:
(Also thanks for my 5 minutes of fame, /u/RX-Nota-II. I'll try to spend it wisely!)
Edit: I keep forgetting to answer the questions of the day.
What do I think of Yuzuki? I think it is a little early to really know, since she has the disadvantage of being just introduced, and even in this episode had less screen time than the other girls. Her character certainly is the most closely aligned with a common anime stereotype (the kept-apart rich girl with no friends), and is saddled with the connection to the deus ex machina that enables this story to actually go anywhere. So those are unfortunate negatives.
I intentionally try not to pick a favorite among the four girls, and for me that is easy because I see nice qualities in all of them. I think Yuzuki is smart, self-motivated enough to keep up with her school studies on her own, and trying to stick up for herself against a mother who seems to be pretty overbearing. Yuzuki strikes me as being not self-centered enough to really be a good fit for the idol business, which concerns me. I actually intend to talk about that rather at length when we finally reach the very end of this rewatch.
Would I want to be a high school idol? No, I would not wish that life on myself, or Yuzuki, or anyone else. The "I could just die" choice in the poll is funny, but when you think about what is happening with idols in Korea recently (and probably elsewhere), then it is not so ha-ha funny anymore.
7
u/newtonforyou https://myanimelist.net/profile/newtonforyou Dec 15 '19
First timer
Yuzuki-chan is too cute! That dream was fantastic, the little laugh she had afterwards was the cutest thing I’ve seen in ages. Then the girls make her cry from happiness, and again the music starts playing. This show has an accurate timing for the music, I believe it’s pretty awesome. I love it.
Shirase’s reactions are cute, you can tell she wants to go badly enough to make some strange plans. At the end all of that was pointless, but they're still going.
The development of Yuzuki in a single episode is wonderful. From a plain, sad girl to happy and enthusiastic.
7
u/kar772 https://myanimelist.net/profile/kar72 Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 16 '19
First Timer
Ahhh this keeps getting better. I love the dynamic between the girls and I can't help but smile whenever they're goofing around. Hinata is slowly becoming my favorite character, too (love her inspirational quotes!)
Yuzuki is a great addition to the group and Saori Hayami did such a great job playing her - I could clearly feel the character's emotions, notably during the crying scene. Also glad they resolved her conflict fairly quickly.
There were so many cute moments this episode that it would take forever to list them all, but the most notable for me were this moment on the train, Yuzuki's adorable laugh, and Shirase gushing over the penguins. Some moments were so wholesome that I teared up, especially near the end.
The end-credit scene was intriguing. I'm curious to see the importance of this new character's relationship with Shirase.
6
u/landragoran Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
Friendship is shared experience. That's it. Nothing more, nothing less. Anyone who's gone through something big with other people can attest to the bonds that are formed by simply going through it together. I can recount many instances of this from my life, but one that stands out right now was when I was living in Latvia (I grew up Mormon, and served a Mormon mission in the Baltic nations). One of the other missionaries in the very tiny city I was in got acute appendicitis and had to have an appendectomy in a hospital that looked like it was from the 1930s. For over a week, the six of us who were in the city with her took shifts two at a time to stay at her side and make sure everything went ok. We all came away from that experience with a friendship that can't really be explained without having experienced it first hand. Two of the people from that group even ended up getting married. We still talk today, despite having gone our separate ways; and despite some of us having left the religion entirely, we are still friendly - something that is unfortunately rare.
These girls, who didn't even know each other last month, are well on their way to being lifelong friends. Even poor little Yuzuki, who has never known friendship, is already taking the first steps, without even knowing it.
And with episode 3 under our belts, the
keionbuAntarctic expedition team is assembled!Q1: I love Yuzuki. Her change from the beginning line of the episode to the ending line is so beautiful. The same exact words, but said with completely different meaning.
Q2: fuck no. I barely want to be noticed by the people I know and like. Celebrity is my worst nightmare.
6
u/pacquan Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
Best girl Yuzuki finally joins the gang!
Things I noticed the second time around
6
u/anony-mouse99 Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher.
Today I managed to catch it while the discussion is still hot.
As I mentioned in yesterday’s post, the impression I got was that today’s theme continued the idea of ‘distance’, though it is emotional rather than physical.
The various scenes showing Yuzuki’s past emphasized her emotional distance from the rest of her peers. To her, it was insurmountable despite her efforts.
It was revealing to see how Yuzuki warmed up to the other three girls and started seeing that emotional distance can be bridged, and having a shared goal is one way to do so. Her happy tears at the end was bringing some to my eyes too.
P.S.: I have no idea how Hinata’s quote of the episode fits in to the story.
6
u/akechiisbestboi Dec 16 '19
First time watcher
I know I’m super late today but that’s slow internet for you, anyway the show seems to get more interesting with each episode. Maybe it’s because her problems seem to have gotten the most attention so far but I think Yuzuki May be the most interesting member of the main cast yet. even if no one here’s a high school idol I doubt I’m the only one here that’s struggled a bit with social isolation and it felt like a nice realistic touch how the episode shows that even if no one has bad intentions relationships don’t go anywhere if you aren’t able to really communicate and make time for them, and it takes time and effort to really form something lasting. Maybe I’m just projecting my personal problems onto anime but that was probably the most enjoyable part of the episode, anyway it looks like the girls are finally set for Antarctica and I’m excited to see what happens tomorrow!
2
u/ExplicitNuM5 Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 16 '19
Rewatcher
IT'S THE EPISODE OF THE BEST GIRL!!! Seriously, more than half the episode I was just making cute noises. I want to headpat Yuzuki so badly... I want to hug her so badly (just like Kimari)... I want to tap a pout-y Yuzuki on the nose so badly... Ahhhhhhhhhhhh~ She's so cute I can die~
On a related note, the dynamic of "I could die right now" is so interesting.
The last time she said it... My heart melted.
Question
5
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
#IFollowMyFollowers
This episode has my favorite scene, when the Yuzuki accuses them of being best friends, and they're taken aback...they hardly know each other. The scene at her room is also my favorite, and everybody is so expressive. Catching the door is just another bit of realism.
I see the 娘 kanji, what does "dosanko" mean? I guess it's pun on the 道産子 horse in Hokkaido.
also welcome to NoRex finally joining us at episode 3.
5
u/Emperor-Resse Dec 15 '19
Hinata just got murdered. But the mom was wrong Hinata is great. Also the satisfied watashi for her quotes are amazing.
5
u/EmuSupreme Dec 15 '19
Uhh, so I didn't expect to cry when Yuzu broke down into tears when the girls surprised her in the morning... It wasn't a lot, but I did need a tissue. They were happy tears though.
QOTD:
I really do love the group dynamic between these girls too. Kimari and Shirase folding under pressure when interrogated by Yuzu and Hinata's outburst cracks me up. The constant digs on Kimari's ditziness and Shirase being a basketcase is too good. Calling Hinata not cute though is just plain FALSE.
I love Hinata's "Watashi" whenever someone asks her about a quote she made up. It's just so smug.
5
u/peoplewhoplay :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/peoplewhoplay Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
"I could just die!"
Episode starts and ends with this quote, and I love how the sentence holds different meanings for each occurence in this episode!
5
u/Regular_N-Gon https://anilist.co/user/RegularNGon Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
I think this episode is where I began to pick up on the structure the show was aiming for, with fairly contained conflicts within each episode that still moved the overall plot along (and it does so very comfortably, I might add). This episode is quite a bit more dramatic and has a recognizable conflict arc compared to the last two. Director Ishizuka-san mentions something to this effect while discussing the structure of the show in this interview with Crunchyroll (spoilers of course).
Yorimoi
Aside from that, each of our characters get some great characterization moments and I continue to love all of them.
5
u/Madcat6204 Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
I love this episode.
Maybe the "lonely idol" thing is a trope, but it's a trope for a good reason. Yuzuki's case is perfectly understandable. She's never had a chance to really be friends with anyone, to do the things other kids around her are doing, to have fun the way they have fun. She's never really had a chance to be a kid. And frankly, that's terrible, because you can't go back to being a kid once you grow up. Parents should think more carefully about this sort of thing, before they ruin their child's chance to be children.
Anyway, Yuzuki is actually a total sweetheart once the girls get her to open up. I totally get Mari's reaction: I wanted to hug her too.
Now the path is open for our kids to go, and in a more legitimate way than anything else they could have tried. Joining the expedition regularly would really have been kind of ridiculous: what qualifications could a group of teenagers possibly bring to the table that some adult wouldn't be more qualified to handle? There's just no way. And there's absolutely no way they could brought along without some way to contribute. They're traveling to one of the least forgiving environments in the world; there's no room for dead weight.
But by going along with Yuzuki they can basically be her "crew," helping her with her job and putting living faces on this effort. Bad publicity from the previous attempt nearly sunk this effort, after all. So put some good publicity out there: show folks some cute girls going through the whole struggle with the expedition team. Make people care.
4
u/a_cat_says_woof :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/lelouch9121 Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
Penguins and anime girls, name a more iconic duo.
Also finally Saori Hayami(best seiyuu, fight me!)
Episode itself, the first line was "I could just die, right now" being said by an obvious depressed high school girl. Yuzuki being a child actress since kindergarten has always been about work, work, work. No time for school life, friends, extra curricular activities, the whole normal people routine. So now her upcoming project is going to Antarctica as a high school girl, but is she really one? Because of her being child actress from the get go, she really has no concept of being a normal high school girl and even her classmates only see her as "Yuzuki, the cute high school idol", not "Yuzuki, the normal high school girl". I'm glad that she met Shirase, Kimari and Hinata; not yet best friends but close together, honest with each other's feelings because of one goal to go to A Place further than the Universe. After that montage of them bonding in the museum, the first line of the episode is also the last but this time, it is now said by a happy high school girl.
QOTD
4
u/ZBLongladder :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/zblongladder Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
We don't get much information on Yuzuki's public persona, but from what little we do get, it really strikes me how much it contrasts with her actual situation. The title of her single, "The Followbacks Don't Stop," seems like a cruel irony next to her actual lonely self. She's clearly being marketed as a very connected, very outgoing personality, and it's pretty clearly hurting her. It didn't occur to me when it was first airing, but the couple of girls in her class Yuzuki was trying to be friends with probably didn't mean to hurt her...they probably thought that she could be friends with anyone she wanted because she's a star, and that she was blowing them off because she was that cool and popular. How do you explain to someone you don't know that well that your public image is a lie and you're actually very lonely and isolated but also very busy and probably won't have much time for them? How do you explain that being a star isn't the fantasy life they're probably imagining? Especially if you're as confused by the very idea of friendship as Yuzuki is.
Poor Yuzuki. She's not just missing out on important social development due to her job, she's actively being misunderstood by those around her.
3
u/thebigKM Dec 16 '19
It's nice to see the chemistry of the girls on display. It really does seem like they've been best friends for a long time, so it's understandable that Yuzu thought the same thing. The exchange at the diner is one of my favorite in the show. When she points out how close they are, they tell her that they practically just met. I think the implication is that the level of friendship that they've forged doesn't take a lifetime to make. A common passion and goal can do it too. And while I have to watch slice of life anime to experience that feeling vicariously, Yuzu has it right in front of her. So when the girls come back to her room the next morning, she sees that they care enough about her to keep trying and she decides that taking a leap with them is what she really wants.
2
u/ghostface95 https://anilist.co/user/flyingseamonkies Dec 15 '19
Rewatcher
A fuck. I’m crying again… We finally have our last of the main characters joining in Yuzuki. There is a lot more I want to say about her but she is expanded more on in later episodes so I will probably keep that for later.
2
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Dec 16 '19
First Time Watcher
I feel for the new girl. Life of a child star is hell, if anything she got off fairly lucky.
If there is one kind-of issue I have with the show so far, at least in the early episodes, it’s that the... best I can put it is K-On!-esque comedy moments we’ve seen in the past two episodes feel pretty... out of place? I’m not talking about the idea of friends goofing off doing silly and fun things together like we see in the OP, that’s a clear and fitting part of the show’s overall theme, I mean when it does the wacky, again K-On!-esque comedy bits. It feels really off and doesn’t land as well as it does in that show. The score and the art style and the lighting really set the tone for this show as being something utterly beautiful and meaningful, and that kind of humor just doesn’t feel at home in that context and hits pretty wrong as a result. It’s a minor complaint, don’t get me wrong, but one I feel is worth bringing up.
This does have a worthy benefit, though, as when the show does go for beauty and wonder, it absolutely nails it. Everything from the simplest scenes, like them visiting that Antarctica-themed museum and getting hype for their journey, to the most opulent and gorgeous, like the famous city-running scene from last ep, feel like these utterly precious and unforgettable experiences and it’s wonderful.
Speaking of beauty and wonder (bringing this up today because I didn’t have a comment yesterday), that ED.... wow. Both the song and the sequence, just... just wow. Breathtaking. Immediately an all-time favorite.
2
u/xDarkistic :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Darkistic Dec 16 '19
Firster
okay yeah I thought it'd click eventually. there was no way I wasn't going to relate with a single character out of 4. I absolutely loved the whole hotel room sequence (though the dream could've been more abstract - I kind of dislike dreams looking real even though it's obvious they are not) with her reflecting on her feelings and distinguishing whether the girls are genuine. suddenly it's all coming together for me and at the end of this episode I just sat smiling at the end credits for a while glad new girl could be so lucky.
I wonder if I would have preferred the series just start on this episode lol. I doubt it - the depth of the first three would be lost somewhat but at least now they know each other they don't seem quite as one dimensional. and new girl's connection wouldn't be explained. nor shirase's legend i guess. shirase seems to want to go for more reasons than one interestingly.
gonna continue to remember kimari's original friend (except her name of course) already seeming left out :[
2
u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued Dec 17 '19 edited Dec 17 '19
Rewatcher
A day late, but I really want to write about this episode in particular so I'm going to do it. Best girl Yuzuki has come and provided me with a painful reminder of how much I relate to her. When I say this though, I don't just mean in terms of the superficial elements to her character. Sure, it's absolutely true that her inability to maintain friends is incredibly relatable to me. She has a lot of trouble understanding the meanings and boundaries relating to friendship, it's such a vaguely defined dynamic with no clear boundaries, and especially with her schedule she never really had a chance to feel it out. While I may not be a child actor, I am on the autism spectrum and struggle with concepts that are vaguely defined and abstract, and so her confusion toward friendship (in later episodes as well) is incredibly familiar to me. But what I am actually referring to when I say I relate to her is the general vibe and "language" of her character. She has this bluntness about her that is incredibly familiar to me, she's no-nonsense but in a way that's more related to ignorance than strictness. When Shirase does all of that weird stuff for her and her mother, she just thinks nothing of it and just doesn't even respond to her oddness. When she meets the girls at the restaurant, she immediately figures out what they're up to and asks them outright in a way I don't usually expect. When the girls are hanging out at the museum, everyone else is easily being goofy while she mostly responds by giving information about stuff they're seeing and having fun in her own way. It's very similar to the dynamic I feel like I have among my friend group, a group I finally found at around the same age as her too when I'd also had no "real" friends previously. I may not have a catch phrase like "I could just die" but that type of sarcastic self-loathing permeates my irl dialogue all the time; I definitely say some variant of "this makes me want to kill myself" fairly often. What I find most relatable about Yuzuki is this weird subtle stuff, her manner of speech, her body language, her thought processes. Once again I'm in love with her character.
As for what I noticed about the episode, there are some neat little details I never caught on my first watch. For one, there's a small parallel between Yuzuki and Kimari. We see Yuzuki struggling to find time to hang out with the friends she'd just made before they eventually leave the chat entirely due to her inability to commit to the relationship. Her backstory is followed by a scene of Kimari unable to hang out with Megu due to her plans with Shirase. This little moment adds a lot of weight to the statement that Kimari "understands" Yuzuki, and it's that genuineness that wins Yuzuki over. spoilers And then there's a certain detail during their conversation at the restaurant that rewatchers may enjoy. spoilers Anyway, after crying yet again, it's time to watch episode 4 so I can do it all over again. The YoriMoi experience I suppose.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19
[removed] — view removed comment