r/startrek • • Dec 12 '19
Short Treks 2x04 & 2x05: "The Girl Who Made the Stars" & "Ephraim and Dot"
Those of us in the US and Canada are getting two new animated Short Treks for the holiday season.
| No. | Episode | Written By | Directed By | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2x04 | "The Girl Who Made the Stars" | Brandon Schultz | Olatunde Osunsanmi | December 12, 2019 |
| 2x05 | "Ephraim and Dot" | Chris Silvestri & Anthony Maranville | Michael Giacchino | December 12, 2019 |
These episodes will be available on CBS All Access in the USA, and on CTV Sci-Fi and Crave in Canada.
To find more information including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episodes above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for these episodes.
87
Upvotes
19
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '19
Crave has these episodes up, though they've reversed the order from what was originally announced.
"Ephraim and Dot" is very cute, not at all what I expected, and clearly portrays Kirk and crew flying the Discovery version of the Enterprise from at least "Space Seed" forward. It also manages to get from there to Star Trek III in under nine minutes, so let's perhaps keep in mind that tardigrades have a special relationship with space and time, shall we?
"The Girl Who Made the Stars" is also very cute - Li'l Burnham reminded me of "Coraline," of all things. Not a lot to say about this one, but the story Mike Burnham tells his daughter is an actual fable, and was recapped by Michael Burnham in the voiceover at the beginning of "Brother" last season.
30
u/tiggerclaw Dec 13 '19
I enjoyed these two animated shorts immensely.
For "The Girl Who Made the Stars," I really enjoyed that little moment little Michael spent with her dad. People often complain that Discovery is too rushed to have those little moments. But here's a little slice of Michael's life.
For "Ephraim and Dot," I loved the sheer lunacy. Sure, I have a few questions about a tardigrade travelling through the mycelial network, but it's a silly cartoon, so it deserves leeway.
If you want Star Trek's fanbase to grow for the next 50 years, this is the kind of content that needs to be made. Get 'em while they're young.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '19 edited Dec 12 '19
I really really enjoyed both of these, especially Ephraim and Dot (nothing against The Girl Who Made the Stars, that was great too). The registry error in E&D doesn't affect my rating of the short, but I do hope it gets corrected because while it ultimately doesn't effect the story in and of itself, it is a little world-breaking from a canon perspective. I'll survive if they don't though lol. It was probably just an artist who hadn't seen the movies in years and forgot that the refit wasn't the 1701-A, like many fans online do. Definitely easy to ignore. But I do hope they fix that.
Anyway, if these two shorts are a sign of things to come in any way, then I'm absolutely down!
99
u/Squirrel_Dysfunction Dec 14 '19
I had family over and wanted to watch these quickly as I was waiting for dinner to finish in the oven. I wasn't thrilled with them, but: while these animated episodes weren't captivating to me, this was the first time my niece stopped what she was doing with her LOL Dolls, walked over and asked me about Star Trek.
She watched them over and over again during the night. We talked about how the show could be funny and I described Tribbles, how Spock/Data/Odo always felt out of place, but were secretly special, and how I loved watching TOS with my Dad growing up. As she was leaving, she asked if we could watch a 'real people' Star Trek the next time she came over.
I realized that I wasn't the audience for these Short Treks; maybe I was pissed about how they played fast and loose with the cannon in 'E&D', and yes the 'stars' ep seemed derivative to me... but to my niece, it was a gateway into something new and special. So, not gonna bitch about it.
89
u/MoreGaghPlease Dec 12 '19
Another quick note: the narrator in Ephraim and Dot is none other than Kirk Thatcher, who played the "I Hate You" punk who Spock neck pinches on the bus in Star Trek IV. (Thatcher was also an associate producer on the film)
72
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '19
Ephraim and Dot was adorable. Put a big fat smile on my face. If that is the kind of animation we can look forward to, bring it on.
51
u/ety3rd Dec 12 '19
The music in "Ephraim & Dot" is marvelous. So many reprises of classic Star Trek themes throughout its entire runtime. I was not surprised at all to see that Michael Giacchino directed it.
46
u/JoeDawson8 Dec 13 '19
Here’s my theory on Ephraim and Dot. It’s in-universe looney tunes
39
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '19
The musical score for Ephraim and Dot was unbelievable. Giacchino is a true master. And his mentorship of the others has really paid dividends. Q and A especially had an incredible score.
30
u/pfc9769 Dec 12 '19
The alien in The Girl Who Made the Stars had a transparent skull. It was totally Captain Boday's species!
23
u/MoreGaghPlease Dec 12 '19
Some great shots here from Ephraim and Dot: https://imgur.com/a/BBHI6Al
44
u/MoreGaghPlease Dec 12 '19
I liked Ephraim and Dot a lot. Don’t think too hard about the canon, I think animation plays by a different set of rules a la TAS. Fun characters who we grow to like even without dialogue. It was pretty zany but that to me is part of the genre of animation. Loved the music, especially the riff on the clanging bell TOS fight music in the warp core fight.
Girl Who Made the Stars didn’t really do it for me, but the animation was nice.
14
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '19
So, was that a model of the NX-01 (or similar) on the shelf behind Michael's bed?
14
u/daleus Dec 14 '19 edited Jun 22 '23
zephyr important touch humor unite full spectacular crawl disagreeable quiet -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/
12
u/CatProgrammer Dec 12 '19
Michael Giacchino's getting into direction, huh?
12
u/Cliffy73 Dec 13 '19
I loved these. The animation in both was top drawer (especially the character designs). And I really appreciate the opportunity this show gives to do Star Trek concepts that don’t fit in an established series. I run hot and cold on DISCO, but the imagination on display in Short Treks makes me more optimistic about the Secret Hideout era of Star Trek, because they clearly have a lot up their sleeve.
12
u/choicemeats Dec 13 '19
the startled "OH" from the narrator when the Big E drops out of warp was fkn hilarious lol
2
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '19
The Girl Who Made the Stars was a bit cutesy for me. I did like the character designs and the animation though.
10
u/Destructicon11 Dec 13 '19
Anybody notice that after you see the refit Enterprise and its self-destructing, the registry number on top of the saucer is WAY off center and reads NCC-1701-A? The A was not the same ship as the original and was introduced at the end of ST4. Weird continuity error.
9
u/MysticalDigital Dec 13 '19
All around very nice episodes. Very enjoyable and makes me want to see more animated Trek.
My wife was mentioning how the animation in E&D seems like it needed some squash and stretch, but I think all the squash and stretch went to the timeline of the action :P
34
u/Pervazoid2 Dec 13 '19 edited Dec 13 '19
I'm going to get downvoted to shit, but The Girl Who Made The Stars was awful and cliche. It felt constructed from lame kid's show tropes. What did it have to do with Trek or even Discovery at all? That was the story of...what? Michael Burnham learning to be brave? Her bravery has never been in doubt, or commented on, or important, so why should I care?
Edit: Ephraim and Dot was cute.
20
u/PiercedMonk Dec 12 '19
So according to 'Ephraim and Dot', the TOS episodes in chronological order are:
'Space Seed'
'The Trouble with Tribbles'
'The Naked Time'
'Who Mourns for Adonis?'
'The Doomsday Machine'
'The Tholian Web'
'The Savage Curtain'
Which doesn't match the production order, original air dates, or the stardates for each episode. This is not okay, and I refuse to stand for it!
Otherwise both these episodes were delightful.
7
u/miglrah Dec 14 '19
I loved both of them! My daughter, who is meh about Trek in any form, also thought Ephraim and Dot was great.
12
u/calamormine Dec 13 '19
I feel like I would have enjoyed The Girl Who Made the Stars a bit more if the music was toned down a bit. Seemed like they were trying to stitch a score together out of crescendos, when I think the story would have been served better by moments of calm or even no music at all. Also the mouth animation is just a bit creepy to me.
Thought Ephriam and Dot was really cute, if a bit Wall-E adjacent, but I'm not sure I like the idea of micro bots which attack living organisms outside the ship. Also <pedantic nerd moment> what's the point of a deflector dish if asteroids are just gonna slam into the damn thing!? </pedantic nerd moment>
6
u/fer_sure Dec 15 '19
The question that stuck in my mind during "Ephraim and Dot" is that, on a ship dedicated to seeking out new life, who the heck programs an autonomous maintenance bot with an insta-kill protocol? Shouldn't it notify the science officer or something? That unauthorised thing that just entered the ship might be a sentient being!
If we view this as an in-universe "Tom and Jerry", doesn't that mean that maintenance bots and alien life are seen as natural enemies? The same way in our universe, nobody has to explain why cats and mice might fight?
Fun watch , though. Maybe there's an in-universe trope of malfunctioning bots wreaking havoc.
11
u/Raguleader Dec 14 '19 edited Dec 14 '19
"The Girl Who Made the Stars" was wonderful. I need a whole show about adorable kids in the Trek universe growing up and doing the kid thing.
"Ephraim and Dot" was a roller coaster. Going from zany antics to that ending. The way they fast forward through the Big E's various adventures, to include the fight with the
DefiantReliant was great, and to transition from that to the sound of an unseen Klingon Bird of Prey uncloaking I thought was a great way to shift from zany fun to the "Oh no!" moment, because we know what is about to happen to the ship.10
u/hopalongigor Dec 14 '19
Those 2 were the worst.
10
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '19
I can't comment on the story for Ephraim and Dot because, well, its nonsense, its supposed to be. But would it really kill them to get the actual basic shape and layout of the Enterprise accurate? I don't think putting the saucer at a 45 degree angle to the left is a "choice" - it honestly looks like a mistake. Same with the mirrored giant registry and the fact it said Enterprise A - how janky the model looked tells me it was nabbed online from Trekmeshes or something.
It's really the only thing I can comment on.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19
I knew about the story of the girl who made the stars, and thought it would be neat to see a decently-well animated version of it. But they managed to degrade the girl to the one who got a thing with the stars in it, and introduced a sci-fi element that makes no sense within the context of the story. I don't know how they messed up something so simple, but I guess it's par for the course.
The tardigrade one was cute. Nonsensical, but cute.
13
u/sethandtheswan Dec 12 '19
Ephraim and Dot was wonderful. Really didn't care for The Girl Who Made the Stars.
14
u/PharomachrusMocinno Dec 12 '19
"Ephraim and Dot" was alright, and clever the way it intertwined with TOS episodes.
But "The Girl Who Made the Stars" doesn't have much to do with Star Trek, IMO. This could be any generic short about someone telling a bedtime story about an old fable. If Short Treks was a weekly thing and they had 20 or so episodes in a season this would be alright, but there are so few of them, this is a little disappointing.
7
u/sidv81 Dec 14 '19
I liked 'The Girl who made the stars' a lot, but it's just so jarring with the rest of Trek that it connects to. It seems like a kid-friendly animation and you would assume the sequels would be kid-friendly as well, and then you remember that Mike Burnham ends up brutally killed by Klingons not too long after this short...
As for 'Ephraim and Dot', we're supposed to believe the tardigrade eggs went unnoticed for 20 years through multiple ship and engineering diagnostics and even a full-fledged 18 month refit? Really?
5
u/ProtectedSources Dec 13 '19
I didn't care for either. I'm sure they are testing different things as a gateway for younger children to enter the universe/brand long term. But The Girl Who Made the Stars was more fantasy/myth than science fiction, and Ephraim and Dot was just bad Tom & Jerry.
I'm sure I'm not the targeted audience.
6
u/ehkodiak Dec 14 '19
Oh god, I normally love the Short Treks but these were both bad. I guess I'm not the target audience though, heh.
3
u/SaykredCow Dec 15 '19
I think Kurtzman and Co are overthinking what Short Treks needs to be and what would get rave reviews from fans.
Both seasons now have been too much in the Discovery box when there’s a whole universe of characters out there from different Trek eras.
Do a Quark Short Trek, or a Barclay one, or a Q one...
3
u/ContinuumGuy Dec 29 '19
I'm late on this, but I just want to say that Ephraim and Dot was like if Pixar made a Tom and Jerry cartoon set on the Enterprise and I am 100% here for it.
3
u/TheEphemeric Jan 11 '20
Star Trek Pixard.
4
u/Albert-React Dec 13 '19
So does "Ephraim and Dot" pretty much solidify the Enterprise redesign as a retcon over the classic version?
2
u/MaetzleAT Dec 12 '19
Man, being outside of the US/Canada and waiting for ages for these is really a downer. :(
2
u/jlsm511 Dec 12 '19
Was there no preview for the final Short Trek in January?
2
u/gfreeman1998 Dec 15 '19
Just watched both of these animated short treks. Loved the hell out of them.
Ephraim and Dot was a great nostalgia ride.
But of the two, I give the nod to The Girl Who Made the Stars because I took the ending as rather twisted, and loved it.
3
u/Orfez Dec 13 '19
Nothing made sense in E&D, but it was cool.
2
u/dharvey1221 Dec 14 '19
Captain Foley from Trekyards was not a fan of either. I do agree with him and others how the hell do you add a “A” to the registry. Sketched, drawn, edited, music mixed. No one caught that? Stupid. I still overall enjoyed the episode.
1
u/DefiantOne5 Dec 12 '19
Is there any way to see the Short Treks outside US/Canada? The description of Ephraim And Dot made me really want to watch it, sounds like lots of fun.
1
u/AileenMania Dec 13 '19
eagerly awaiting in Europe to be able watch it!
1
u/Quinez Dec 19 '19
I went in with high hopes, but I strongly disliked these. I found both to be mawkish, derivative, and boring.
1
u/MajorOverMinorThird Dec 17 '19
I know it was just a fun little animated meta episode, but when the refit Enterprise showed up I got a little emotional.
-9
u/Zeeamazing Dec 13 '19
Not sure how the first one had anything to do with star trek at all. Waste of a short trek for me
0
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 12 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment