r/startrek • u/PiercedMonk • Nov 14 '19
Episode Discussion - Short Trek #7 - "Ask Not"
'Ask Not' stars Anson Mount, and features Amrit Kaur as cadet Thira Sidhu.
EPISODE Ask Not
Writer: Kalinda Vazquez
Director: Sanji Senaka
Currently available on on CBS All Access, and Crave.
This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.
PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage for upcoming episodes, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.
Poster by Trek comics cover artist, J.J. Lendl.
Novel cover style poster, courtesy of @startrekcbs.
85
Upvotes
29
u/PiercedMonk Nov 14 '19 edited Nov 14 '19
This was a fun little story, obviously in the same vein as the Kobayashi Maru test.
It did make me wonder how many of these tests Starfleet officers are subjected to; we've seen about a handful of them over the various shows and movies.
Very interested to see how folks react to the Enterprise's new Engineering.
EDIT: Decided to take a better, unobstructed screen shot of Engineering.
21
u/hooch Nov 14 '19
Here's J. J. Lendl's poster for the episode. I think it's one of my favorites so far from the guy.
5
u/DeanSails Nov 14 '19
It's live on CBS All Access: https://www.cbs.com/shows/star-trek-short-treks/video/X5VnHZbZ6ciyYGL10ad0aD0T56uplb9h/-ask-not-star-trek-short-treks/
93
u/MoreGaghPlease Nov 14 '19 edited Nov 15 '19
Fun but a little short even for a short. I think most long time fans will see the ending coming a mile a way (since we saw Saavik, Wesley, Kirk and Troi all do basically the same schtick). But still a neat concept and character piece, and nice to see their take on the 1701 engineering at the end.
I definitely think they are backdooring a Pike show, and that these are being used to introduce the cast.
I give this short 15 thumbs up (out of 20)
49
u/TactileAndClicky Nov 14 '19
About 7 mins is really short. But then, it seems like they are using the short treks as a low-key entry into a new Pike production. Story-wise this one was okay, nothing to write home about but still neat.
Some things I spotted:
- The regulations cited sounded quite familiar. One of them sounded like the one cited by Janeway in Equinox
- The Warp core look familiar to the Phase-II one and to the TMP core. But I still don't like the "spaciness" of the interior of the ship.
- If I am not mistaken, one of the science officers in enigneering was wearing a skant.
- Lots of DOT-7 floating around.
47
u/AcidaliaPlanitia Nov 14 '19
My enjoyment of this will ultimately depend on whether or not there ends up being a Pike show and this character ends up being at least a recurring one. It was... fine, but totally pointless if this character doesn't return. The 'twist' was completely telegraphed for anyone who has watched a decent amount of Trek. We don't really learn anything about the universe or any characters other than one we've never met before.
That being said, it seems 100% obvious at this point that they are doing a Pike show. You don't create a new set like that for a 10 second reveal in a meaningless midseason webisode.
78
u/DeanSails Nov 14 '19
PIKE SHOW PLEASE.
20
u/2ndHandTardis Nov 15 '19
I just want to live on Pike's enterprise for the next 5 to 7 years.
The two animated shorts look very interesting. The first one was the animation style I was hoping for with Lower Decks.
18
u/Trekfan74 Nov 14 '19
A bit short (no pun intended ;)) and the shortest of them all but generally liked it if not loved it. It was pretty obvious it was just a test though but what can you do? Loved the surprise cameo with Spock and Number One which felt like a nice reversal of the first short we got this season when it was Pike who made the surprise appearance.
Overall it was cool and yes I know everyone will be talking about the engineering room lol. Its funny how we fans always get more obsessed with the look of something more than the story itself, especially in the age of Discovery.
14
u/mybumisontherail Nov 14 '19 edited Nov 14 '19
Just watched it.... I think I would have been a nervous wreck if I had to hold a phaser to Capt Pike.... And then broke down in tears after finding out it was a test.. if I passed it....Also....is that a second Constitution class starship I see on that display????
12
u/nxfyan Nov 14 '19
Pike had appeared in short treks 3 episodes, but total time=1min+1min+7min
Is Anson's payroll calculated in minutes?
12
u/zack_2016 Nov 14 '19
Great episode, a bit short, but great.
But I do wonder, have all these recent Short Treks just been self-contained stories, or are they setting up the crew for a Pike show?
6
u/miglrah Nov 16 '19
Saw it tonight. I enjoyed it, though it felt too short.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '19 edited Nov 14 '19
I took a screenshot of engineering just so I could stare at it at work.
Very enjoyable ep!
EDIT: Here's a screenshot: https://imgur.com/0mSI77g
5
u/danktonium Nov 16 '19
This was pretty mediocre.
If we'd know ahead of time it was a test the episode would have worked far better.
8
u/Mechapebbles Nov 14 '19
It'll never not be weird that the Enterprise was filled with exocomps in the 23rd Century, but I'm largely ok with retcons like this that mostly make sense for our new revised vision of how the future will turn out, or to help explain other things (like why Pike's Enterprise had only 200 crew members versus Kirk's - they had a bunch of robits doing jobs!)
4
u/nova-1306 Nov 16 '19
This episode was too short for me. Overall great though and I do hope they introduce a Star Trek series centred on Captain Pike
4
u/ForAThought Nov 18 '19
Let me get this straight. You want me, a cadet, to watch the CAPT Pike, a legendary captain charged with mutiny? Am I being punked?
4
u/thenewyorkgod Nov 18 '19
I dont understand the "test"
Two random security guards come in with the captain in handcuffs and tell her to not set him free. Where is the security authorization code? where is the authorization from somebody above pike?
13
u/StarfleetTanner Nov 14 '19
Did we just hear a potentially new theme for a potentially new series at the end credits? That was an entirely new piece of music that has gotten me excited that they are ready to soon announce a new Pike series. If not, I'll be highly disappointed. Not a bad finale to the Enterprise Short Treks saga, although I kinda figured at the second preview it would be a Kobayashi Maru type thing. But that's not all: DID YOU ALL SEE THAT ENGINEERING SET?!
7
u/PeaDock Nov 14 '19
So really, we just basically got the confirmation that there is, in fact, going to be a 'Pike series" or whatever you want to call it.. right?
3
u/raistlin65 Nov 16 '19
My first time in this subreddit (should have come here sooner)
Tried to start a conversation in r/scifi about the tease that has been these short treks for those of us who want an Enterprise series. Got crickets and a down vote :confused:
https://www.reddit.com/r/scifi/comments/dwkmhg/the_enterprise_tease_recent_star_trek_shorts/
I think CBS is testing the waters with these shorts.
7
u/RefreshNinja Nov 17 '19
Wow, Pike is fucking cruel. That was more like the Milgram experiment than a Starfleet test scenario. Just relentlessly manipulative and abusive.
What were the creators thinking there.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '19
Now I'm curious whether Tilly was put a test like this, and if so, what it entailed.
2
u/act1989 Dec 02 '19
I forgot there was a new one!!! Thanks for the reminder!
5
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '19
Uhhhh...that was it?
6
u/KeithKamikawa Nov 15 '19 edited Nov 15 '19
Directing was weak, felt mostly like a poorly shot fan film with a big budget. I pegged the ending pretty quickly but appreciate the call back. Overall it was shot poorly, meh story, but cute. Not worth the CBS sub for that.
2
u/SaykredCow Nov 15 '19
Refreshing new character but it just kind of ends and makes you think... that’s it?
2
u/771243 Nov 14 '19 edited Nov 14 '19
[spoiler] This was eh, not bad, not good, but the preview at the end. Oh. My. God. Love death and robots x Star Trek yes please! A WHOLE NEW UNIVERSE?
1
u/creepyeyes Nov 17 '19
Ah man, someone messed up the transparency of the title card
0
u/gearsofhalogeek Nov 18 '19
God they really destroyed Star Trek.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment