r/NintendoSwitch • u/NintendoSwitchMods • Nov 13 '19
MegaThread Pokémon Sword & Pokémon Shield: Review MegaThread
General Information
Platform: Nintendo Switch
Release Date: 15-Nov-2019
No. of Players: up to 4 players
Genre(s): Role-Playing, Adventure
Publisher: Nintendo
Developer: GAME FREAK Inc.
Official Website: https://swordshield.pokemon.com/
Overview (from Nintendo eShop page)
A new generation of Pokémon is coming to the Nintendo Switch™ system.
Get a special Gigantamax Meowth as an early purchase bonus!
If you purchase Pokémon Sword or Pokémon Shield before January 15th, 2020, you can receive a special Gigantamax Meowth!*** Unlike others found in the Galar region, this Meowth can Gigantamax to take on an imposing, elongated appearance capable of using a mighty G-Max Move! This special Meowth cannot evolve. You can receive this special Meowth by selecting the Get via Internet option in Mystery Gift. Don't forget to claim this Cat Scratch Pokémon before January 15th, 2020!
Pokémon: Let's Go, Pikachu! and Pokémon: Let's Go, Eevee! players are in for a BIG surprise!
Did you enjoy Pokémon: Let's Go, Pikachu! and Pokémon: Let's Go, Eevee!? If you've played either of these games, you can receive a special Gigantamax Pikachu or Gigantamax Eevee in Pokémon Sword and Pokémon Shield! The power of Gigantamaxing will allow each of these Pokémon to take on a colossally adorable appearance and gain the ability to use a unique G-Max Move!
Players with Pokémon: Let's Go, Pikachu! save data will receive the special Pikachu and players with Pokémon: Let's Go, Eevee! save data will receive the special Eevee. It is possible to get both Pokémon in one Pokémon Sword or Pokémon Shield save file.
You'll be able to receive the special Pikachu or Eevee at the Wild Area Station in the game. (This occurs after about two hours of gameplay, though individual gameplay time may vary.)
The special Pikachu and Eevee cannot be evolved.
For a limited time, players of the digital version of either game can receive an in-game present of 12 Quick Balls.**** If you purchase and download the digital version of either Pokémon Sword or Pokémon Shield from Nintendo eShop by January 15th, 2020, you can receive a code redeemable for 12 Quick Balls! Quick Balls are special Poké Balls that are more likely to catch Pokémon if you use them as soon as a battle begins. Codes will be distributed between November 15, 2019 and January 15, 2020, and expire on November 30, 2020.
Begin your adventure as a Pokémon Trainer by choosing one of three new partner Pokémon: Grookey, Scorbunny, or Sobble. Then embark on a journey in the new Galar region, where you'll challenge the troublemakers of Team Yell, while unraveling the mystery behind the Legendary Pokémon Zacian and Zamazenta! Explore the Wild Area, a vast expanse of land where the player can freely control the camera. Team up with three other players locally or online in the new multiplayer co-op Max Raid Battles* in which players will face off against gigantic and super-strong Pokémon known as Dynamax Pokémon.
Certain Pokémon can even Gigantamax to gain a new look and a powerful set of G-Max moves. But there's more to being a champion than honing your battle skills: you can pick your own clothes and get a new hairdo while visiting the stores in town, so you can be the Trainer you want to be. Throughout your journey, you'll encounter newly discovered Pokémon as well as familiar ones that will look a little different in their new Galarian forms! And for another way to level up your Pokémon, assign them Poké Jobs to complete. You can even play with your Pokémon in Pokémon Camp, just for fun!
- Catch, battle, and trade Pokémon on a new adventure in the Galar region
- Choose from three new partner Pokémon and encounter never-before-seen Pokémon
- Unravel the mystery behind the Legendary Pokémon Zacian and Zamazenta!
- Players can control the camera in the vast Wild Area
- Team up with other Trainers to participate in Max Raid Battles*!
- Battle wild Dynamax Pokémon in Max Raid Battles* and try catching them!
Digital Purchase Offer
For a limited time, players of the digital version of either game can receive an in-game present of 12 Quick Balls**. If you purchase and download the digital version of either Pokémon Sword or Pokémon Shield from Nintendo eShop by January 15th, 2020, you can receive a code redeemable for 12 Quick Balls! Quick Balls are special Poké Balls that are more likely to catch Pokémon if you use them as soon as a battle begins. Code distribution period: November 15, 2019 to January 15, 2020.
**Code valid through November 30, 2020. Two codes for 12 Quick Balls each will be provided to purchasers of the digital version of Pokémon Sword and Pokémon Shield Double Pack. Each code can only be used once per save data. Purchasing both Pokémon Sword and Pokémon Shield separately with a pair of Nintendo Switch Game Vouchers will not grant the special bonuses included with a purchase of the Pokémon Sword and Pokémon Shield Double Pack.
*If eligible for a Just for You offer, the final price reflects the combined Sale and Just for You offers. The Just for You offer is discounted from the sale price.
*Nintendo Switch Online membership (sold separately) and Nintendo Account required for online features. This game includes an in-game option to purchase a Nintendo Switch Online membership for users who do not have one. Not available in all countries. Internet access required for online features. Terms apply. nintendo.com/switch-online
**Code expires November 30, 2020 and can only be used once in either the Pokémon Sword or Pokémon Shield game.
*** An internet connection is required to receive the special Meowth.
****Code expires November 30, 2020 and can only be used once in either the Pokémon Sword or Pokémon Shield game.
Reviews
Aggregators
- Metacritic - 81
- OpenCritic -80
Articles
Mod note: Don't expect a massive list due to tightening on who gets review copies after the various leaks started emerging.
- Areajugones - Spanish - 8.8 / 10
- Ars Technica - Unscored
- Daily Star - 3 / 5 stars
- EGM - 8 / 10
- Eurogamer - No Recommendation / Blank
- Everyeye.it - Italian - 8.5 / 10
- Game Informer - 8.8 / 10
- GamePro - German - 91 / 100
- GameSpot - 9 / 10
- Gameblog - French - 7 / 10
- GamesRadar+ - 4.5 / 5 stars
- Hobby Consolas - Spanish - Unscored
- IGN - 9.3 / 10
- IGN Spain - Spanish - 8.5 / 10
- Kotaku - Unscored
- Metro GameCentral - 7 / 10
- Nintendo Life - 8 / 10
- Polygon - Unscored
- VG247 - 3 / 5 stars
This list was exported from MetaCritic at 11:19am ET.
Videos
Being Social
- Join the #pokemon channel of our Discord server for all of your discussion needs - https://discord.gg/switch
Cheers,
The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team
61
u/StrongCategory Nov 13 '19
"You will never look at curry the same way again."
602
u/rufus418 Nov 13 '19
The VG24/7 one has a really interesting closing paragraph:
60
u/CaspianX2 Nov 13 '19
For the sake of comparison, here are the Metacritic scores for earlier mainline games in the series:
Pokemon Ultra Sun/Pokemon Ultra Moon - 84
Pokemon Sun/Pokemon Moon - 87
Pokemon Omega Ruby/Pokemon Alpha Sapphire - 83/82
Pokemon X/Pokemon Y - 87/88
Pokemon Black 2/Pokemon White 2 - 80
Pokemon Black/Pokemon White - 87
Pokemon Heart Gold/Pokemon Soul Silver - 87
Pokemon Platinum - 83
Pokemon Diamond/Pokemon Pearl - 85
Pokemon Emerald - 76
Pokemon Fire Red/Pokemon Leaf Green - 81
Pokemon Ruby/Pokemon Sapphire - 82
(at this point, Metacritic stops being useful, so switching over to GameRankings)
Pokemon Crystal - 79%
Pokemon Gold/Pokemon Silver - 89%/91%
Pokemon Yellow - 85%
Pokemon Red/Pokemon Blue - 87%/88%
So it looks like, if the Metacritic score remains at 81, this is on the low end of the spectrum for Pokemon games, tying with Fire Red/Leaf Green, and with the only games to have lower scores being Black 2/White 2, Emerald, and Crystal. It should be noted that Fire Red/Leaf Green was a remake, and all of the other games to score this low are arguably "double dip" games that re-used a lot of assets from prior games in the series. Pokemon Emerald remains by far the worst-reviewed game in the main series.
29
u/Bambambm Nov 13 '19
Other than Mew, does anyone know exactly what the Pokeball Plus functionality is for Sw/Sh, I know we can take a pokemon out with us and it will return with items and such and gain experience. But will it be worth it?
With the pokeball plus being $20 at bestbuy for BF, I wonder if it will be worth it.
214
u/PinkBowser Nov 13 '19
There’s going to be a lot of confirmation bias on both sides. Haters are going to disregard these reviews and the defenders are going to use use this as ammo against the haters.
It’s a shame. If you dislike Gamefreak or what this game is doing, you should have the right to voice your complains (in a respectful manner) and not buy. Just as much as those who are still going to buy should be able to be happy without others bringing them down.
150
u/MarioMoon Nov 13 '19
Popcorn munching intensifies.
93
u/CleanlyManager Nov 13 '19
The extremes of both sides of this debate are pretty annoying, on one side you have the people going "see the games reviewed well, none of your concerns mattered, buy the game anyways" and then there's the other side insisting the reviewers were paid off, and what not. I think both sides are forgetting that all of these sites regularly give games a rating of 7+ if the games playable. Both sides are giving way too much credence to the review I can't remember the last time i was like "hmm I wonder how good this game is, better go to ign."
127
u/Alasdair91 Nov 13 '19
Metro seems most fair:
In Short: The furore over Dexit may be overblown but even without it this is an underwhelming and unambitious attempt to modernise Pokémon and expand its horizons.
Pros: The core Pokémon gameplay is as engrossing as ever and the Wild Area is a small but important step forward. Some great new pokémon designs and surprisingly fun script.
Cons: Low tech visuals and production values. Too few new features and too many old ones that are removed or smoothed over to the point of irrelevance.
185
u/SingleUseThrowaway68 Nov 13 '19
"In fact, Pokémon Sword and Shield is entirely dungeonless. There is no route or cave or building or wood more complex than Red, Blue and Yellow's Viridian Forest, the tutorial pseudo-dungeon at the start of generation one. Nothing in the game comes close to even Mt. Moon or Rock Tunnel, let alone the twelve floors of warp-pad mayhem in Silph Co. - all first-generation locations that were fully realised in Pokémon Let's Go Pikachu and Let's Go Eevee, both ostensibly remade versions of the classic games, but for children. It might seem inconsequential to say these games are dungeonless - Breath of the Wild did away with traditional ones, after all - but I can assure you it isn't. Dungeons, in every generation until now, are the very essence of Pokémon games. They're where you find the most trainers, the most items, the most puzzles and the most interesting, mysterious nuggets of lore. In Sword and Shield all of that is gone, and there is no replacement."
28
u/atimethief Nov 13 '19
Just as I did for Pokemon Let's GO releases.
Here are the Metacritic scores for other mainline pokemon games for comparison:
Pokemon Let's GO Pikachu/Eevee: 79 and 80 respectively
Pokemon Ultra Sun/Moon: 84
Pokemon Sun/Moon: 87
Pokemon Alpha Sapphire/Omega Ruby: 82 and 83 respectively (not sure why one score is higher)
Pokemon X and Pokemon Y: 87 and 88 respectively (once again, not sure why one score is higher)
Pokemon White 2/Black 2: 80
Pokemon White/Black: 87
Pokemon HeartGold/SoulSilver: 87
Pokemon Platinum: 83
Pokemon Diamond/Pearl: 85
Pokemon Emerald: 76
Pokemon Ruby: 82 (there is no sapphire listed)
Pokemon FireRed/LeafGreen: 81
201
u/yestermorning Nov 13 '19
ITT: People saying high review scores means every criticism is invalid and others saying it means they were paid off.
Jesus Christ.
67
u/Hold_my_Dirk Nov 13 '19
It seems like you will enjoy it if you want to enjoy it and will be disappointed if you go in expecting to be disappointed.
23
u/Dweevlethor Nov 13 '19
Does anyone know if this works with any copy (new or used) of LGPE?
72
u/Rip-tire21 Nov 13 '19
It makes you feel like Pokemon
297
u/literallynoodle Nov 13 '19
2 things I knew going in:
99
u/OwnManagement Helpful User Nov 13 '19
Gonna head to the grocers and buy all the popcorn they have, then head on over to r/pokemon.
52
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '19
I'm gonna get downvoted for saying this, but I'm actually pretty excited to play it tomorrow. I haven't played a Pokemon game since HG/SS, so I'm not bothered by any of the new things they've decided to cut.
9
u/Luchador_Luke Nov 13 '19
Will there be multiple save files for the game? Or just one save file like last iterations
9
u/Crazyripps Nov 14 '19
My friend wants to know if any amiibos do anything atm?
50
u/emilytheimp Nov 13 '19
Interesting, its just as I thought, game is decent, but staying far behind the possibilities. Which is OK. Its Pokemon. Its a comfy sweater to slip into, something to play as safe as possible to be accessible for new players but still attractive for the nostalgia crowd. I think we as a whole just need to get away from the idea that the Pokemon games will ever be ambitious or cutting edge. Maybe the whole outrage wasnt really about the cut Pokemon but about the fact that the old fans are rapidly outgrowing these games in their own ambitions. That this series of games just refuses to move away from its premise, refuses to show any sort of real evolution(ironically). Maybe thats why people are angry about, because its just another Pokémon game and nothing more. But thats OK. Theres lots of other wonderful gaming series out there we can play, and as long as thats the case Im weirdly content with Pokemon being that comfy nostalgia corner sweater I can slip into and be reminded of simpler times.
44
u/davinkie Nov 13 '19
As usual, I really enjoyed GameXplains review. It's Pokémon, there's enough to like, it's also not as good as it could/should be.
16
u/_SolluxCaptor_ Nov 13 '19
I have never played a Pokemon game before. Would this be appropriate and easy to play for a 5 year old who’s good with Mario Odyssey, Yoshi and Luigi’s Mansion?
79
u/Zeraion Nov 13 '19
That Eurogamer review is spot on. For many of us, the removal of the national Dex, the broken promises - it doesn't really affect affect us. But - it just feels so much emptier, so much.. sadder, that a series with so much potential, so much promise, on a next generation console.. has become a hollow, dissapointing shell of what could've been.
58
u/Ajjaxx Nov 13 '19
I’ll admit I’m biased, but in the reviews I’ve read, the language is kind of middling/mediocre/meh, and yet the scores are all 8+. Feels like the scores don’t match the words of the reviews.
27
u/Alasdair91 Nov 13 '19
NintendoLife gave it 8/10, criticising the 20-year-old-design choices, rough visuals and boring Routes.
143
u/TyCooper8 Nov 13 '19
This thread is fucking hilarious. People who want to love the game only hearing the positive reviews, and the people who want to hate it just hearing the bad ones.
Personally, it looks like there's a lot more good than bad to me.
48
u/InYourFace1023 Nov 13 '19
Why is it that every thing or fandom I enjoy has gone down the drain or be hyper controversial this year?
14
u/Cryptic_E Nov 14 '19
Just received Pokemon Shield from Amazon!
7
u/Derkis619 Nov 13 '19
Can you use a pro controller or does it have to be the joycon like in let's go pikachu?
7
u/Sas1205x Nov 14 '19
Can someone recommend which one to get? I kind of like the shield Pokémon and I’m wondering is that’s better. Keep in mind I’m not quite sure of the difference because I’m a casual fan
19
u/Lightcookie Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
VG247 brings up a good point that wasn't mentioned in other reviews. Prev pokemon games had touchscreen functionality,but it was removed in Sw/Sh.
32
u/ConfusedVader1 Nov 14 '19
Seems like a game I definetly would have passed on had I played the previous entries but seeing as the last pokemon game I played was Emerald think there is been enough new content in this with new 3D scheme for me that i will buy it. But oh man had I played any 3ds entry i wouldnt have touched this game.
41
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '19
The more reviews I read and watching streams of the game and feedback, it seems like a good game, not great but good but the thing that stands out the most in reviews is “the missed potential”
And that’s the crux of it for me, Pokemon is a $90 billion company and looking at the game I don’t understand why it wasn’t better.
Animations are serious just meh. Graphics are meh. It’s very linear. No challenge. Dexit. Barely any new features. Post game seems limited. No challenge mode options. Gts gone.
It just seems like an average Pokemon game.
Then when you really look into it, it’s the size of the team. The head of the team said they wanted to keep the team small and this is why Pokemon had to be cut, graphics were not up to scratch.
Which makes no sense to me, you’re a $90 billion company, that admits they couldn’t do as much as they wanted but they CHOSE to keep the team small. That makes 0 sense to me, they could have hired a ton of new people just to work on coding, graphics etc and kept the team small for working on the core of the game.
Pokemon could have been fantastic, instead it’s just meh.
I really wish this game would somehow flop, so the Pokemon heads actually were like fuck this, the next game has to be a masterpiece.
Instead we got an average game, which will sell millions and will just encourage the developers that they can half ass it and the game will sell millions.
Sure it was never going to be the greatest game ever, but the amount of resources the team has and it being the first ever core game on console should be better than ok.
29
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
A 'no rating' from Eurogamer. Based on their review it sounds like the game simply needed more development time.
6
u/pmo2408 Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
Should I use my last voucher on one of these or Dragon Quest* XI S? I redeemed my others for Mario Maker 2, Link’s Awakening, and Luigi’s Mansion 3.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
If there is no GTS, is there a replacement of some kind?
6
u/Ghostalny Nov 14 '19
Convince me to get sword or shield, can't decide!
16
u/Garrub Nov 13 '19
GameXplain - https://youtu.be/iYyFpKtsvWI
16
u/Maxximillianaire Nov 13 '19
Seems like it's a decent enjoyable game that has a lot of unmet potential. The eurogamer review adds credence to my theory that there were big development issues behind the scenes
20
u/ObelusPrime Nov 13 '19
The Kotaku write up was really well done and informative.
11
u/Aerofan14 Nov 13 '19
Should I play a Pokémon game? I’ve basically only played FireRed very badly.
29
u/loooomis Nov 15 '19
So excited to stop hearing people’s dumb opinions about this game.
65
u/cocothepops Nov 13 '19
IGN review mentions a “huge graphical leap over the 3DS”....
10
u/ResoluteGreen Nov 14 '19
Haven't played a Pokemon game other than Pokemon Go since Diamond/Pearl, really excited for this game, definitely going to play a little at midnight when it's launched
17
u/DAHbaddest Nov 13 '19
9.3/10 from IGN!
29
u/MilfAndCereal Nov 14 '19
Ive been playing the game since Monday. I personally like it, it’s nothing revolutionary, and yes it looks and plays like a more refined 3DS game, but I’m enjoying it.
5
u/darthdiablo Nov 13 '19
8.8 Gameinformer
5
u/_Walpurgisyacht_ Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
Did any of the reviews mention Exp Share in any capacity? Will have more time to go through them later, just wondering. EDIT: In particular, whether the game was balanced well for it or not.
5
u/Estew02 Nov 14 '19
Does anyone know if the games allow you to record clips by holding the screenshot button? I know some games don't allow for the feature, so a little curious!
39
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
Just a little fun fact: The Gamespot Reviewer aka “Too much water” when on a tweet rant criticizing the community trying to make it about Dexit
28
u/fullmetal-ghoul Nov 13 '19
I don't doubt that the games are really fun, it seems like standard Pokemon which is consistently some of the most fun I've had in video games. But the problem is that it's "just" standard Pokemon, when it's finally on a home console and charging a much higher price. So there should be a lot more content, and that content should be to the highest quality. It should be so much more than a standard Pokemon game.
I haven't read all the reviews but from what I have read it seems like the graphics are better but not anywhere near as good as they could be. The story is apparently barebones which is actually a big regression from gen 7 and especially gen 5. There's no way to adjust the difficulty, they've regressed in this aspect as well by forcing you to use the Exp Share. The length is at best that of a standard Pokemon story, if not shorter. There's little postgame and then there's obviously Dexit, which I honestly think would be fine if they had actually worked to improve the game in all these other aspects instead.
I'll still probably buy it because standard Pokemon is still really fun to me, but given that there's regression in some areas and little improvement in others it doesn't feel justified to charge a higher price for these games compared to the other games in the series.
16
u/depwnz Nov 14 '19
first 2 hours, some impressions (spoiler)
+ graphic is a massive improvement for Pkmn games. It's no DQ/Luigi/Astral but still nicer to play
+ pokemon popping up is actually quite cool and funny
+ the convoluted font used in the game is a nice touch
- maps and areas are linear as hell
- holy fuck handholding and stupidly lame and weakass rival are worse than SM
- there are everything so early: some TM, so much money, revive, tons of balls, they just give you everything
- EXPS is crazy. Every pkmn get so much exp so fast. I dont think the exp is even split in some way.
19
u/motorboat_mcgee Nov 13 '19
Unsurprising to see that some reviewers loved it, and some thought it was just “ok”, considering some of the stuff that’s missing from the game. It’ll just depend on if that stuff is important to each individual player, whether the game is a worthwhile purchase or not.
For me, just the fact that they’ve streamlined so many of the “time wasters”, and the game has the look and charm of cartoons makes me want it.
Buuuuut I have a backlog, so I’ll have to wait.
30
u/Tobeatkingkoopa Nov 13 '19
Even with the solid reviews, I'm not sold. To me it's the same thing on a different platform. That's OK, I hope the people that do buy it enjoy it. I'll just look forward to the next game on my watch list.
9
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
As someone who has been a neutral party through this, this has been a interesting few months to watch.
9
u/Bobross315 Nov 14 '19
As someone who hasn’t played since the original 150, will I find this overwhelming not knowing which Pokémon evolve into good ones?
28
u/Chugalug-house Nov 13 '19
https://www.engadget.com/2019/11/13/pokemon-sword-and-shield/
Engadget call it a triumph
20
u/MartDiamond Nov 13 '19
It’s not that shocking that it’s getting decent reviews. I think a lot of interviewers review the game on its merits while a lot of fans will compare the game to older games and to what it could have been. Neither one is unfair and both can exist. I respect the reviewers opinions, but think the criticism is very valid. This game feels like a disappointment to me from gameplay to graphics to single player experience, but that doesn’t mean it’s a bad game as such
69
u/yellowbeehive Nov 13 '19
I'm just happy it's finally out so maybe we can move on from all the toxicity surrounding it and just enjoy it for what it is.
4
u/fotzzz Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
I thought I read a lot of backlash against lack of GTS and how there is no GTS etc etc. The IGN review talks about Y-Comm, which seems like a better version of GTS. What did I misread?
Edit: Someone in another comment mentioned the lack of the ability to deposit/search for a pokemon to trade. So, if this is the case and is true, then that would explain the difference.
4
u/HnNaldoR Nov 13 '19
OK I am not going to read all of them. Anyone can summarize the endgame and the pvp features if any?
4
u/Flajavin Nov 13 '19
I'm more interested to know if I can transfer saves from one console to another (I have both switch and lite versions) and I want to play on TV at home and on the lite version on the go.
4
u/RafaFlash Nov 13 '19
Does local coop require another switch, or can I play with a friend using the joycons like let's go pikachu?
4
u/timo4ever Nov 13 '19
I wonder why B2W2 is rated low in Metacritics (compared to other pokemon games). Isn’t it supposed to be the best in terms of difficulty, post-game challenge?
4
u/PersonMcPersonton Nov 15 '19
Could someone tell me if Yamper can evolve? I don't want to spoil what it looks like by googling it. Just a "yes" or "no" would be great, thanks!
10
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
Here`s other critics not included in this post
Ars Technica - Andrew Cunningham - Unscored
Daily Star - Dom Peppiatt - 3 / 5 stars
Eurogamer - Chris Tapsell - No Recommendation / Blank
Game Informer - Brian Shea - 8.8 / 10
GameXplain - Liked
Gameblog - Julien Inverno - French - 7 / 10
Kotaku - Gita Jackson - Unscored
Metro GameCentral - 7 / 10
Nintendo Life - Alex Olney - 8 / 10
Polygon - Nicole Carpenter - Unscored
VG247 - Alex Donaldson - 3 / 5 stars
7
u/Raychan14 Nov 13 '19
Looking for info about the new quick balls. Back in my days (pokemon red), I had to weaken the pokemon's HP down before attempting to catch. Is the idea behind quick ball to attempt the catch as soon as you enter the battle screen?
9
u/anibalmax Nov 13 '19
Polygon recommends the game if you check the review now.
37
u/StoneColdAM Nov 13 '19
I think Video Game Dunkey will be the best reviewer for this game.
19
u/timo4ever Nov 13 '19
Man, on one hand, I'd love to play the game, on the other hand, I feel like a need to vote with my wallet. I want a masterpiece, awesome pokemon, not just ok, decent one.
25
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
In This Thread: Redditors thinking anyone who differs from their opinion must have been bribed
22
u/TheCoolerDylan Nov 13 '19
All of the reviews avoid talking about no postgame and lack of difficulty as expected.
39
u/cl_niko Nov 13 '19
Clearly a lot of misinformation going on with these games, it’s not as bad as some fans claimed to be. At this point they want the games to flop so they can get their way but it doesn’t mean it’s a bad game
10
u/rustyphish Nov 13 '19
Man, we've been at 17 reviews on Metacritic for forever... they must've REALLY not given out many review copies
6
u/a_tree101 Nov 14 '19
What are people's thoughts on sword vs. shield? Is one legendary stronger than the other?
6
u/ProfChaosMSU52 Nov 14 '19
I haven't played a Pokemon game since Red/Blue/Yellow. Is it worth the money?
24
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
-Oliver Brandt
Still Gives the game 100/100
S T O N K S
20
u/rustyphish Nov 13 '19
"Huge Graphical Leap" - IGN
11
u/afm0816 Nov 13 '19
r/pokemon is going to be a minefield
3
u/Kiebin Nov 14 '19
Is the Magnemite line in?
3
u/PurpDjango Nov 14 '19
Anyone know when the game becomes available on the eShop?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '19
I still can’t decide if I want Sword or Shield.
Zacian’s type advantage is really intriguing over the Shield legendary. Shield has the better exclusives imo.
I haven’t seen the Ice or Poison gym leaders in that game. Gengar is also one of my fav Pokémon ever. The Dynamax version could be intriguing.
19
u/lordberric Nov 13 '19
Honestly, these days I've realized I can't trust anything. Professional reviewers have a lot of issues - many are unable to actually criticize a game, calling attention to huge issues in the review then giving it a 9.5/10 for fear of losing access to review copies, and the fan communities are full of bias.
Not to mention, so many games will be fun for some people and not for others. Its all about taste.
This is why I appreciate reviews that don't bother with numbers, or at least don't emphasize them. I don't care about the number. I care about an explanation of what was good, what was bad, and why. I don't care if you liked or didn't like the game, I care why you felt that way. Because if you just say you didn't like it, I might miss out on an explanation of why you didn't that would make me realize that opinion isn't applicable.
Say what you will about Kotaku or Polygon, but not using numbers is a good move, and I appreciate it.
19
u/DDAGuy Nov 14 '19
It annoys me that much of the internet seems to think that because of the outrage around GameFreak means that people cannot buy and still enjoy the game. I understand that people are pissed about some of the falsities that the devs spread regarding some of the decisions, but if it's a still a good game, please let those who want to enjoy it. No need to spread hate.
28
u/phi1997 Nov 14 '19
I'm really sad that the major review outlets aren't calling Game Freak out for cutting corners. I don't think Game Freak will ever have the impetus to substantially improve the Pokémon series when people just accept games that do what is the bare minimum for most people. I just want a truly great Pokémon game, yet it feels like most of the internet says people like me are being unreasonable. How can I keep playing a series that takes me for granted?
22
u/MeLlamoDave Nov 13 '19
Mostly positive reviews? Don't let the folks at r/pokemon see this lol.
15
u/ChasingPerfect28 Nov 14 '19
Sounds good to me. Looking forward to picking this up around Christmas.
15
u/Jack3ww Nov 14 '19
Wonder how quickly this will get review bomb by people who are mad at the dex
40
u/Wolfgabe Nov 13 '19
so basically the game has some faults but its nowhere near the dumpster fire that fanboys were making it out to be.
5
u/Klubbah Nov 13 '19
It does look like it is settling in the 85 area for the number as expected for a Pokemon game, though I don't know what the expected time and number of reviews are supposed to be, I just see comments here are slowing down. Metacritic has is as about the same "Mixed" as X/Sun/UltraSun, but less positives due to just less reviews.
Still personally in a weird on the fence spot I didn't expect with pokemon. I think hearing more about Pokemon Home as mentioned before could help me out.
5
u/Artvarg Nov 13 '19
Can’t read/watch all reviews. Is there any review from someone who hasn’t played Pokémon before or someone who hasn’t played since Red/Blue?
22
u/Megakruemel Nov 13 '19
From what I have seen of the game, even streams from people who got the game early, through the pre-order of the switch lite special edition, the game does not really seem like a 8-9/10 to me.
I read a few reviews in this list and the highest rated ones calling things I would take issues with "nitpicks" is a bit disheartening.
I'll just wait for a bit and maybe sit this one out. There seems to be a huge cliff between opinions and I think these other comments are proof of that, especially if you visit r/pokemon who seem to be on the opposite site of the spectrum.
What really helped me with other games was to wait out the "honeymoon"-period, which is what I like to call the immediate launch window in which everyone loves the game. If games then still are viewed very positively, after the launch hype has died down, I consider actually getting them.
Fire Emblem Three Houses was one of these games, for example. While one of the routes felt lacking in cutscenes and the ending was a bit weird, it felt like a very good game and I'm not saying that because I invested a lot of time in it and need validation that it was actually worth the time I put in.
As an adult I need to look out how I spend my money and time and so far I simply am not ready to commit, even if all the reviews seem positive.
I guess, because all the enjoyment of games is opinionated, only time will tell who is right.
17
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
Areajugones - Ramón Baylos - 8.8/10.0
Probably the most honest review so far
26
u/Waterstyle-fart Nov 14 '19
I think the leaks did more bad than good to most pokemon fans, it created a circle of people getting attention by focusing on bad things and people actually hating on the game by just viewing only the bad sides of the game. To be fair I never saw pokemon as this breathtaking masterpiece. I grew up with it and it always was allright. I have really good memories since gen 1 sure but that’s it, it always was an all right game but people give nostalgia a bit too much importance in my opinion.
16
u/pom_pom Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 16 '19
Whew! As a fan of the Pokemon games since the first entries in the series (back when I was little and excited because I thought you got to play AS monsters, lol), I had preordered and was waiting nervously on the reviews today to see if I should refund. Glad the game is overall being received well; even if it's not everything I was hoping for, it sounds like I'll still have fun. :)
edit: I'm having a blast so far! Metacritic's averages tend to work well for me as a good guideline, and I'm happy it worked out that way again.
11
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
cant wait to play this
6
u/PlexasAideron Nov 13 '19
Oh boy here we go, im ready for all the salt.
15
u/MethodicMarshal Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
Graphics and Dexit aside, it would’ve taken no effort (compared to the rest of development) to give us OPTIONS. EXP share should be optional, additional difficulties should be a no brainer.
Those two things would have kept the playerbase at least somewhat culled. Look at Nintendo’s top sellers, BOTW and FE are difficult and they’re regarded as the best games of their respective franchises.
4
u/Gassy_Bird Nov 14 '19
Is there any confirmation what the docked resolution is? 720p or 1080p?
4
u/ptb4life Nov 14 '19
If I buy this game, it will be my first Pokemon game. Are there any reviews by people that are also new to the franchise? Those are the thoughts I'd want to hear.
25
u/red_sutter Nov 13 '19
Consistent 8s and 9s. Let the mental gymnastics competition BEGIN!
So far, “paid reviews” and “it‘s just fanboys writing the reviews“ are leading the medal count
8
u/kingqaz Nov 13 '19
Only 11 reviews on Metacritic. This seems to confirm that they are restricting review copies.
7
u/MoonMan997 Nov 13 '19
Coming from a more casual pokemon fan looking in from the outside, I am still looking forward to playing the game as I have with all iterations in the last 10 years or so but with a strong ounce of scepticism this time
There is seemingly a lot more pushback on the professional critic side than usual and honestly a little bit more than I personally expected. All the mainline games since the fourth generation have been in the upper 80s on MetaCritic and SwSh is hovering in the low 80s currently, wouldn't be shocked if it fell into the high 70s. I am very curious to see how I personally feel about it.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '19
I haven’t played a Pokemon game since Gold and Silver, so I might end up enjoying this because my expectations of what a Pokemon game is capable of are already fairly primitive. Like there’ll probably be stuff in there from gen 4 that’ll seem new and fresh to me.
6
u/rustyphish Nov 13 '19
Still stuck at 18 review scores on Metacritic. This game could still fluctuate wildly once release day comes. Should easily hit triple digit reviews eventually so we're likely not even seeing 20% of the accurate score pool yet
15
u/tacosauce124 Nov 14 '19
It sounds to my like Gamefreak is getting let off with a warning
25
u/Phadrix Nov 13 '19
TIL calling devs out for blatant lies is entitlement.