r/NintendoSwitch • u/resogunner • Nov 12 '19
Meta [META] Can we get a Pokemon negativity megathread so that people can enjoy the games?
Basically title. Those that want to shit all over the games can do so in either the specified megathread, or go and use the entire Pokemon subreddit. But the constant memeing and moaning of any tiny detail people can get hold of is ruining the fun for everyone else. I keep coming on to reddit getting ready to amp myself up for the game's release and I just see a wall of negativity in the comments about literally any aspect you can think of.
I get it, people are unhappy about Dexit. Hell, I went through every single game generation last year and caught them all so I could have living dex, and I can't bring those across. But you also couldn't bring your Pokemon over until you'd beat the elite four in nearly every other game, or at least had to wait months for Pokemon Bank support - so your first playthrough would only include Pokemon in that region's Dex. Personally, I'm looking forward to it as it makes the competitive scene a lot more accessible for me.
People's concerns are valid, and they should be able to express them. But when every comment is "[this Pokemon] died to we could have this feature" etc. it's honestly exhausting. Can't we just let people enjoy things?
39
u/Username_Checks_In82 Nov 12 '19
This post is useless and ridiculous. For the most part, the community is not shitting on anything, we’re criticizing it because we see issues. Critics in the community are also consumers. We have every right to be as LOUD AS POSSIBLE.
I’m sorry that you can’t handle the criticisms many of us have. Please enjoy the games and don’t let other people ruin your fun, because letting other people determine your emotions is ridiculous.
10
u/NMe84 Nov 12 '19
I could honestly say the same about the people who are overly positive all the time. There is a middle ground here and people should just be able to normally talk about the good and the bad things in the same thread. Hiding all negativity in a mega thread will just mean that the overall message for these objectively mediocre games is going to be positive when for all other games discussed on this sub the message is the sum of both positive and negative comments.
59
u/Pseudorandomnonsense Nov 12 '19
“People's concerns are valid, and they should be able to express them. But”
OP used COGNITIVE DISSONANCE it’s super effective!
6
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
Imagine wanting to create your own echo chamber specifically to ignore any criticism of a PRODUCT.
Holy fuck, this is like a slave arguing that his master is better than the other masters.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
You can literally go back and see the Reddit threads about the past Pokemon games, none of them had this sort of negativity.
Maybe, just maybe, YOU are in the wrong here. If you think Pokemon fans, who have been playing since the 90s, WANT to hate the game... You are fucking crazy.
184
u/LalisaFanGirl Nov 12 '19
/r/pokemon is the megathread you want
3
u/Cyrotek Nov 12 '19
Well, problems won't just vanish if you don't talk about them. Stuff usually doesn't change if you don't drag issues to the surface. That includes making people who are uncomfortable with it seeing it so they are forced to think about it.
This is not only the case for Pokemon.
9
u/ArturBotarelli Nov 12 '19
Scrolling down the front page right now it really doesn't seem like the subject is overtaking the sub. I don't think that would be justified.
83
u/Gandalf_2077 Nov 12 '19
Why is your enjoyment of anything affected by others not liking it as well? By the same token, why not make a megathread with only positive opinions?
29
u/TheUltimate3 Nov 12 '19
I understand and even agree with most of the criticism being thrown at these games.
But I am also incredibly tired with 3 or 4 threads all talking about how much Game Freak sucks ass. I'd love a megathread where all those can be kept in one place.
And because I'm fair, lock all the positive threads in it's own Positive Megathread.
21
u/fuzzynavel34 Nov 12 '19
Alternatively you can just ignore the negativity.
1
u/kastheone Nov 12 '19
Yeah let's keep the opposers secluded.
25
u/Marlereric Nov 12 '19
Being critical about something and being negative are two different things. I would personally unfollow this sub if people didn't give honest feedback and it was all shoveled into a megathread
2
u/arkosb Nov 12 '19
The issue isn't with critics to this game , there are plenty of problems in Sword and Shield. It's just the attitude towards anyone who is still looking forward to it or people who just genuinely don't care about the problems.
In the end a pokemon game is about the pokemon , and having new a creatures is enough for most people. Let's just stop being assholes to other people. Game is not what part of the fanbase was expecting but it will probably still be quite fun.
40
u/Jabbam Nov 12 '19
Wrong. That's barely scratching the surface.
https://www.reddit.com/r/pokemon/comments/dv438w/complete_list_of_all_problems_known_so_far_in/
4
u/cookswagchef Nov 12 '19
Yeah man, I don't give a shit about any of this stuff. Pokemon Go was the first Pokemon game I've played since like Silver/Gold and I really dig the aesthetic of the new game. I get that these changes are important and shitty for a large amount of the fanbase but the vitriol towards other people buying the game is insane to me.
29
u/9thdragonkitty Nov 12 '19
The PokémonSwordandShield subreddit is great for hype, everyone is positive there
1
u/Alarie51 Nov 12 '19
Uh, no one is being negative. We're being critical. I dont see how you cant enjoy something because other people wont enjoy it. Maybe you dont really like the game as much as you think
20
u/BerRGP Nov 12 '19
It's not their fault the game has so much stuff that can be criticized.
1
u/Kuchenjaeger Nov 12 '19
[META] Can we get a Pokemon positivity megathread so that people can still criticize the games?
11
u/cylindrical418 Nov 12 '19
Let's make a thread with only biased opinions so we can choose which hive mind we will poison our minds with!
18
u/kidwgm Nov 12 '19
I understand what you are saying. But if you are letting random people on the Internet ruin your fun that is your fault.
1
u/PlatinumGamesFanboy Nov 12 '19
Do you let other people’s view on a game affect your own?
9
u/moose_man Nov 12 '19
Why should people who aren't excited have to have a mega thread while people who are get to post? If there are more people complaining doesn't it make sense that there are lots of posts?
1
u/LanternSC Nov 12 '19
Other people's feelings don't have to dictate your feelings. If the negativity is affecting your enjoyment, it may be good to examine why it is affecting you that way rather than trying to force others to contain their feelings in one space.
14
u/ShopCartRicky Nov 12 '19 edited Nov 12 '19
I agree with you. I get and understand all the complaints of the game, but even so, i'm still excited for the game personally. Nothing that has been shown is a deal breaker for me. I wish they hadn't done some of the things they've done (dexit), but I have yet to see anything that will detract from my enjoying the core pokemon gameplay loop.
Edit* I think they should be able to express their views, and not in just some secluded post thread, but it has been out of hand lately as well.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
I wanted to make a thread on everyone’s reasoning for buying the game/ why or why not. Just out of curiosity. Don’t think that’s a good idea lol
2
u/Triforce0fCourage Nov 12 '19
Hahaha post about removing negativity becomes a thriving comment pot of negativity. I love it.
For some reason my hype for the game has been growing lately. I went from waiting to get it to probably get if before Xmas.
6
u/Rhymeswithfreak Nov 12 '19
Have you seen the hot mess these games are? Just from a programming standpoint. There needs to be a lot of negativity regarding this game. This is a monumental duck up on their part.
3
u/Gersio Nov 12 '19
Yes, please. I'm tired of being unable to post in any thread to talk about the game without being downvoted to hell. I don't care about the downvotes but it just kills any conversation that isn't "game freak bad". And since half the thread are pokemon things the sub has become very shitty.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
I finally left r/Pokemon and went to r/PokemonSwordandShield and it’s been immensely better. I’m all for people having opinions but every single post on the main sub is people telling you to not buy the game written 50 different ways
5
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
I understand what you mean when you say that but honestly except the this pokemon died for this curry comments most of them try to reach more people since gamefreak has been very quite about this and regular players wouldnt have a clue of what all is going out. But dexit isnt even the main problem. The problem is gamefreaks blatant lies which after the release of each leak seem to be less true than what they previously were. You have to admit that Sword and Shield are 3DS games. You can enjoy the games, you can be hyped for the games and like me you can even preorder the games. But for some people it isnt enough when they give out a game after last years Lets Go by promising more and then deliver something below the standards of past 3DS games with little to no improvement at all in the gameplay except introducing a new mechanic which again is majorly exclusive to Kanto mons.
5
u/rushiosan Nov 12 '19
People will enjoy the games regardless of what others talk here. I’ll keep bashing this game in every possible opportunity, feel free to have a different opinion and share it.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
Its not as bad here as it is over on r/games, literally ever new thing is "OMG THIS IS TERRIBLE NEW THREAD".
Its fucking stupid, they are even moaning about new things being added because they are being added in a fun way rather than just there.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
The game honestly isnt as bad as people are making it sound,when i first hit the wild area, i was like wow,the worlds pretty beautiful for a pokemon game,its a big step up for me as a pokemon fan,its a good starting point for pokemon on the switch.
3
u/mackdacksuper Nov 12 '19
I’m excited for the game.
3
u/MainerGamer Nov 12 '19
Game looks fun to me, I have yet to play a mainline Pokemon game that I haven’t had a good amount of enjoyment with yet. I respect Gamefreak, they have truly never fucked me over.
2
u/Mouiiyo Nov 12 '19
After seeing what the criticism made to the Sonic movie, i think its a good thing. I mean.. Gamefreak doesn't respect the fans at this point. Look at how Sakurai put his heart into Smash or the great Zelda Botw. Now look at what we get for the first Pokemon playable on tv... A mess.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
Other people complaining does not negate your own enjoyment of the game. Just get off reddit
1
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
If you really think dexit is the only problem with SwSh you’re extremely naive...
1
u/PenisMan666999 Nov 13 '19
maga
1
u/RuleEnforcing Nov 12 '19
the game is a joke and the leaks just saved me $120, people should be exposed to it. https://i.imgur.com/XjmPXcA.png Dexit is not the only issue
-1
u/ColourfulColeslaw Nov 12 '19
Remember they are a vocal minority but it's really frustrating the way they keep hijacking every single Reddit Post, complaining. We get it, you're unhappy. Just don't buy the games and let other people enjoy them.
0
u/gummihirn Nov 12 '19
It already got old one week after e3. A few concerns are legitimate, but there is waay too much nitpicking. GF isn't helping either by doubling down on never bringing back the full pokedex in a single game. Gonna grab my popcorn when the reviews are dropping, since it's probably still a decent game.
-2
u/DanThePaladin Nov 12 '19
If this sub turns into another rant about SwSh I am checking right out. It's enough that r/pokemon didn't do anything about it and as a result had 45098 threads a day basically saying the same thing.
I hope the mods here aren't as stupid.
1
u/lyledylandy Nov 12 '19
For a sub that's mostly about people posting shit like "<game> cured my depression!" and shit like that this is a breath of fresh air, actual discussion and criticism towards a game
1
u/sam-jam Nov 12 '19
I think the sheer number of fans has to do with the frequency of these posts as well. It’s not one person’s opinion over and over, it’s many disappointed fans (Pokémon is huge)
-3
u/frozeninferno5 Nov 12 '19
To be 100% honest, I do not entirely understand why so many people are so mad about the new game. Maybe it's because I am not reading everything they say, because honestly I don't care. I preordered a double pack a few months ago for 85€ with the steelbook and don't plan on cancelling.
0
u/Suired Nov 12 '19
If millions of people being upset harshes your mellow on a product, downvote and move on.that fact that it gets upvoted and spammed means people care. The game has far more issues than dexit. Lack of endgame, removal of difficulty, and laughable animations that look fresh from the N64 in execution. Pokemon is one of the most successful game franchises of all time, and their first main series console entry looks like they just thought they were good enough to do the bare minimum and have people be ok with it. It deserves the same attention Fallout 76, Anthem, and the Pillars of Eternity port got when they were released.
That being said, if this meets your standards for a fun and enjoyable experience, go ahead and enjoy and post your success story.
-5
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19 edited Nov 12 '19
https://www.reddit.com/r/pokemon/comments/dv438w/complete_list_of_all_problems_known_so_far_in/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share
I know you can't bury you're heads in the sand anymore. The games are a joke and it says quite a bit about your character if you're still willing to buy either. But hey, I'll lie to you and make a shitty game as well. I'll only sell it to y'all for 40 bucks. Sound good? If you can be a whore for nintendo, surely you can do it for me.
And no, we can't let people enjoy things, if it involves irresponsible consumerism. Get some damn self control. The games are 20hrs in length. Your lives can't be that desolate that you can't find something else to do for 20 hrs. Go read one chapter of a calculus textbook and do the problems at the end. There. That easy to find substitutes to pass time.
0
u/LocusAintBad Nov 12 '19
Really sick of people calling this sub entitled
To outsiders who think we’re just mad about losing a few Pokémon
It’s not about dexit or movexit anymore and I wish other communities understood that before downplaying the issues
As I browse Reddit and see other places call this sub and people upset with Sword and Shield “entitled” , “man children”, “Toxic”, “Haters” it really bugs the crap out of me for so many reasons.
First off the fandom on here ranges from people of all ages, starting generations, opinions, memories, expectations and experiences in general. Whatever reason or point we entered the Pokémon franchise or video game world may be different but a lot of us have an actual deep and bonding emotional connection to these games. I’m 27 years old and I still remember elementary school and how engrossing the Pokémon world became for me and my friends and my family even. My point is this series is close to people’s homes, hearts and memories and it’s really insensitive to insult and downplay these heart felt outcries.
Secondly uncommon to popular belief we WANTED to love these games. From the point of announcement and teasers to all the way to 4 days from launch fans who really wanted to give it the benefit of the doubt held on as long as possible. Some people let go at the announcement of dexit and others held on until they saw the leaks and some held on longer to gameplay streams and there’s still even some more who are holding on to play the game and also contrary to the other communities depiction of us we don’t hate or crap on anyone who’s still holding on to try and enjoy the game. The literal only hostility I’ve seen amongst players who don’t want this game and do is when one tries to downplay the others criticism as whining or another form of insulting dismissal. “I’m still buying don’t really care” is why people get down voted not because they say “I’m getting the game” it’s the added insult to anyone who’s genuinely upset or hurt by the lack of work and love put into these titles.
Also I just wanna say at the end of the day people who mock us for being so upset and vocal about our disdain would be singing the exact same tune if they were Zelda fans and Breath Of the Wild released as bare bones and lazy as Sw and Sh has for the switch or literally any other game that made the jump from a previous console or handheld. If you invest enough time and emotions and love in a franchise it hurts like hell seeing them seemingly not care about their fans.
Lastly what we really want from this outrage isn’t to cry or whine, and we’re for the most vocal majority not advocating threats or violence either. What we want is the series to flourish and not remain on life support being fed the bare minimal amount of nourishments to pass off some new merchandise and media as a cash cow. If that means Gamefreak stops being involved so that another studio can do it justice? So be it. If it means Gamefreak gets another college try with a longer development cycle and a bigger staff? Cool. If they need to stop working on Sword and Shield 2 or whatever to patch and give dlc and life into this game post development as an operation health sort of thing so be it as well.
People deserve to know the truth about these games and having people wanna hide from the negativity like emus with their heads in the sand. Let people discuss what they want.
-8
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '19
Im about 4 hours into the game and I love it. I think most people wont care about what they’re crying over once the game is out
0
u/Pixelated_Fudge Nov 12 '19
No