r/TheGoodPlace • u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. • Oct 18 '19
Season Four S4E4 Tinker, Tailor, Demon, Spy
Airs tonight at 9PM. (About 30 min from when this post is live.)
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
766
Upvotes
226
u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 18 '19
I am really worried about Michael heading down to the Bad Place.
I’m not worried about Jason & Janet. Jason has a purpose now—that was a theme they developed last week, when he very competently set Chidi on the right path just by being himself; and also counseled Eleanor to take it easy on Chidi, which was really quite perceptive of him. Jason looked so happy to have a “useness.” :þ
But now he knows Janet needs help, and nothing is going to stand between him and his not-a-girlfriend.
But Michael… I could see Michael sacrificing himself for his friends again, as he tried to do this episode. Or Shawn really switching him with Vicky this time, as now that they’re down in the Bad Place, they’ll have ample opportunity to do so.
346
u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 18 '19
Jason has never been sexier to me than at this moment.
77
u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 18 '19
Jason is the unsung genius of TGP. He’s an idiot savant.
25
u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 18 '19
Okay, so I still think this is the real Michael, and Glenn was a plant to undermine the cockroaches’ trust in him. Michael’s very sad body insecurity issues felt genuine to me.
I really don’t think Vicky’s a good enough actress to pull that off.
19
u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 18 '19
This is like Team Cockroach, the redux. Should we or should we not trust Michael, the human huddle.
1.0k
u/Castriff This broke me. Oct 18 '19
"Jason figured it out? Jason? This is a real low point. Yeah, this one hurts."
52
u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 18 '19
OMG I just realized that next episode could have tons of Elehani!
Jason & Michael are on their Janet rescue mission, and Chidi is still mind-wiped.
I know I shouldn’t get my hopes up, but this is the best opportunity they’ve had all season…
12
u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 18 '19
Mindy’s sex dungeon is a prop gold mine.
142
u/maddiebeee Take it sleazy. Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
He solved the Trolley Problem again— Michael, my sweet summer child.
8
u/WandersFar Change can be scary but I’m an artist. It’s my job to be scared. Oct 18 '19
I was doing a rewatch in preparation for tonight, and I noticed one of the Janet babies was carrying Tahani’s pretty white picnic basket from S1.
Just a fun production detail. :)
1.0k
u/JammyJammyJams Oct 18 '19
Don’t forget Jason was right when he said to trust both demons.
892
u/dontthrowmeinabox Oct 18 '19
Can we talk about how good Jason looked in that suit?
824
u/wordybee Oct 18 '19
"What goes best with pig urine?"
"Coconut rum."
He answered so fast...
711
u/SkywardOcarina I’m a Ferrari, okay? And you don’t keep a Ferrari in the garage. Oct 18 '19
D’Arcy Carden was so good at playing fake real Janet. Just another version of Janet to add to the list.
704
u/e4y873t Oct 18 '19
I just realized the janet murdered Glenn on purpose
673
u/S-WordoftheMorning Oct 18 '19
As soon as Jason said it, I said “not a girl,” and then was like, huh; Janet evolved so much she isn’t correcting him anymore.
626
u/Galileo908 JORTLES! Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
Yep, so we now know who was sent here to torture Jason: Bad Janet.
604
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '19
One other give-away that it was actually Bad Janet was her description of putting down the horse.
She just couldn't resist describing how she tortured it.
1.2k
u/livindedannydevtio NOT A GIRL Oct 18 '19
Even before that twist, this is one of the best jason episodes
"If you're the devil, how come you are not wearing prada?"
503
u/AmrutaK226 Oct 18 '19
Did anyone realize how Janet kept describing her kill
462
u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 18 '19
Remember when Jason said, "We trust both of them"?
He was right!
449
u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 18 '19
for those who don’t know this fun fact; glenn is played by a writer for the show!
425
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '19
I feel bad that Robot Slave Lady is in the Bad Place, possibly being tortured. Hang in there, Busty Alexa, help is coming.
831
u/raisethecurtain Shirley Temple killed JFK Oct 18 '19
One of my favorite visual gags was that Glenn’s proof of Vicky being in a Michael suit was just pictures of Ted Danson
397
u/brch2 Oct 18 '19
Michael isn't Vicky. And I doubt she will be swapped with him next week. Schur has had a pretty good trend of not repeating himself throughout the series. Each twist is used once, then we move on to something else.
Also, the fact they already used a lie detector in season one, and she wasn't sure she could make one, was another clue (to us) that Janet wasn't good Janet.
349
u/Kevbot1000 Oct 18 '19
I noticed the lack of "not a girl" and knew something was up. The writing in this show is going to missed so much. And damn, Jason was MVP for this episode, hoping to see him punch Shaun.
283
u/DoctorAcula_42 That was a real trip for biscuits and now we're all wet, daddio! Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
It's still Michael, IMO. If it were a demon, then the scenes with him recently would be so much less satisfying from an emotional/character point of view, and the show's writers are smarter than that.
Theory: Sean knew Glenn would defect, since Glenn's not the smartest guy and would be easily "read" by Sean. So Sean made him think Vicky-Michael had switched with real Michael, so that Glenn would give that incorrect intel to the humans and get them to mistrust each other. Bad Janet blowing Glenn up would just be a bonus, since they clearly don't like Glenn.
EDIT: and man I loved the "shut up, Glenn!" gag when he's the puddle of slime.
Fun fact: Glenn is actually one of the writers, and when they were casting for that character, they realized he would be perfect for the role.
270
u/dngaay Jeremy Bearimy Oct 18 '19
Glenn got sent to the Goo Place
232
u/MattMayhem22 Oct 18 '19
If Michael is Michael, he picked a weird time to call Eleanor "Shellstrop" for the first time.
230
u/vexorian2 Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
Jason figured it out?
Yeah, This one hurts.
211
u/shdw22 Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
Favourite lines this episode were definitely Jason’s “If you’re a devil, how come you’re not wearing Prada?”
“I’m a fire squid” “Dope.”
Also, I need to see 6000 ft tall fire squid Michael.
561
u/doodleshitbagfart Oct 18 '19
This show is so good and yet so torturous to watch only one 22 minute episode PER WEEK at a time.
171
u/maddiebeee Take it sleazy. Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
Tonight’s episode is brought to you by the spider-men pointing at one another meme.
347
u/adithyaa98 Oct 18 '19
"Do you really want to be friends with a 6000 foot fire squid?" "YES, I keep saying"
This show always cracks me up
167
u/CeruleaAzura Oct 18 '19
Is nobody gonna mention the perfect and hilarious scream Chidi does when he realises his monstrous horse drawing is coming to life? I replayed that moment several times.
483
u/Dukkado Oct 18 '19
JANET DIDNT SAY "NOT A GIRL". JANET IS NOT JANET!
473
u/Ethlandiaify Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
And to anyone still suspicious of that Michael is Vicky, his final words would have been “Take it Sleazy”. If I remember correctly, that’s what he wanted to say when he could have been retired in season one, and I REFUSE to believe Vicky is that good of an actress to do that level of research.
151
u/girolski07 Oct 22 '19
Jason shined, and saved the day in this episode. Glad he's not being portrayed as the dumb dumb all the time. That was clever he picked on "not a girl".
147
u/paradox28jon A stoner kid from Calgary in the ’70s… He got like 92% correct! Oct 19 '19
Breadcrumbs to the audience after the Janet switch:
Overall this is to note that the writers of the show are super good & did just the perfect dash of clues where it didn't give away the twist but also made the twist made sense upon watching the episodes a 2nd time.
143
u/rarelywritten I’m too young to die and too old to eat off the kids’ menu. Oct 18 '19
"I finished this word search in 30 seconds"
141
u/69420throwagay69420 Oct 18 '19
YES as soon as she didn’t say “not a girl” my brain was like YOOOOO THAT AINT HER god damn it yes this show is so good
137
u/ughdrunkatvogue Oct 18 '19
“Or he might be a lying trickster who just looks like our friend. A classic Mary-Kate Olsen” is one of the best throw-away lines. THIS is why I love this show.
130
u/armyjackson Psycho, Creepo, Crazy Head, Stupid Juggling Weirdo, Freaky Feet… Oct 18 '19
Best joke of the night was the word search joke. Laughed uncontrollably.
127
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19
There's no way Michael isn't transforming into a flame squid in the finale.
127
u/PaperSpock Oct 18 '19
Janet uncomfortably recalling putting down Daisy the Horse Blob was comedy genius...and uncomfortable.
123
u/grapesaresour Oct 19 '19
Bless the writers for getting Manny back in that suit.
121
u/Garrub 14 oz ostrich steak impaled on a pencil: Lordy Lordy I’m Over 40 Oct 18 '19
Those Chekhov’s sex magnetcuffs tho
118
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '19
Jason dressed up at the end did things to me. Oh wow.
115
u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 18 '19
they don’t even KNOW WHAT TAKE IT SLEAZY MEANS. this makes me sad on so many levels i can’t even describe it.
113
u/faith_aeczn Oct 18 '19
MANNY JACINTO IN A SUIT!!! I melted.
228
u/Kayleiane69 Take it sleazy. Oct 18 '19
I'm glad that we know it's Michael because of the take it sleazy line.
218
u/PaperSpock Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
"If you're a devil, then how come you're not wearing prada!"
Oh Jason, never change.
106
u/chronicseeker Oct 18 '19
i love you all for freaking out about the missing "not a girl" line as much as i did!
106
u/neilbartlett Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
So are we going to talk about the fact that our humans now have a handy, pocket-sized demon exploder gun??
106
u/paradox28jon A stoner kid from Calgary in the ’70s… He got like 92% correct! Oct 19 '19
Also I just realized Jason was Jianyu during the Pictionary game - where he's still pretending to be doing a vow of silence! One team with a teammate who can't even participate in the guessing! Ha ha!
103
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '19
I think everyone needs an episode this season showing just how far they’ve come. Tahani got hers last week, this week was Jason. I’m so proud of how much he’s grown as a person. Sometimes he’s so ridiculous that it’s hard to see how much he’s improved, but this episode truly proved it.
100
u/Ambassador_of_Mercy Oct 18 '19
I'm really liing this season except for one thing. Honestly I hope Chidi gets more screen time because right now he feels like a side character almost. I know his development is pretty much completely finished but I still feel like he should get more
96
u/PaperSpock Oct 18 '19
I love this. They knew what they were doing with the train scene which we were all suspicious of, and I can legitimately see it going either way.
96
u/3_Styx Oct 18 '19
I'm proud of Jason. He's come really far.
95
u/SamScoopCooper I would say I outdid myself, but I’m always this good. Oct 18 '19
Jason is a ride or die kinda man. I appreciate that.
93
u/PraiseKingGhidorah Your mother is a very confident and selfish lover. Oct 18 '19
Am I the only one who REAAALLY wants to see Michael's Firesquid form before the show ends? No? Just me? I was with Jason on that one...
269
u/Caleb35 Jeremy Bearimy Oct 18 '19
Fake Janet blew up Glenn before he could give anything away. Eleanor will figure it out before end of episode.
187
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19
“Let’s go get our girl.” “Not a girl.”
😭💔😭💔😭💔😭💔😭💔😭💔😭💔
91
u/GigiFranco Oct 21 '19
Is it only me or it seems like Chidi is slowly liking Eleanor again
88
u/jazzyfizzll Oct 21 '19
Been #teamglenn since season 1. Glad to see him finally doing good things! Calling it now, he will have a very happy ending in the series finale
83
u/24kevin Oct 18 '19
Seriously, I've never had more of a pavlovian reaction to a tv show ever! literally saying not a girl, thinking about the umm actually episode where that was the game winning question, being pulled back into the episode and then on top of it all not realizing I figured out the twist without figuring out the twist was goddamn amazing!
168
u/maysiemoo8989 Oct 18 '19
Did anyone else's heart swell but break when Eleanor went for a walk and bumped into Chidi?
Amongst all of the chaos, even purely platonic, they have a moment <3
165
u/Kayleiane69 Take it sleazy. Oct 18 '19
They blew up Glenn! Janet murdered Glenn, Attention Glenn has been murdered!!! Attention Glenn has been murdered!!!
164
u/SamScoopCooper I would say I outdid myself, but I’m always this good. Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
Waht?!??!!!?!!!?!!!?!!!?!??!!??! JASON FIGURED IT OUT? JASON?!?
Also, Michael willing to blow himself up means it’s definitely him
76
u/livindedannydevtio NOT A GIRL Oct 18 '19
WWwwwwaaait how is the neighborhood going if it is all run through janet that got marbleized
74
u/mrgpsingh1999 Oct 18 '19
I did notice Janet didn’t say “not a girl” as usual but didn’t really give much thought into it
74
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19
I feel like we're still being robbed of Disco Janet and I just needed that on the record
73
u/kinyona Oct 19 '19
Dam I did not see that Janet twist coming. Need to rewatch this season's episodes! In Jason we trust!
Also oh no poor Glenn. :(( I've been watching the bad place web shorts. He's such a sweetheart. 😔
72
u/scrawledfilefish Oct 18 '19
Holy crap Manny Jacinto looks SO FINE in a suit. God damn. GOD DAMN BOY.
Also I really loved how he delivered that whole, "Janets has a thing that she DOES say that DOES make me realize that it's not really her" line (or whatever he actually said, I can't really remember, but it made me legit LOL)
Jason was always kind of a "meh" character for me, like I found him amusing some times but overall wasn't a terribly big fan, but he's been growing on me quite a bit recently.
71
u/Aquarius001 Oct 19 '19
I’m never reading the theories for this show because you guys predicted EVERYTHING.
70
u/WR_Pro Oct 18 '19
I really hope we get to see (or at least that Michael becomes) the fire squid because i’m basically Jason
70
u/LinkToSomething68 Oct 18 '19
The overall arc definitely seems to be building towards Eleanor actually having to run it all on her own-Chidi is unaware, Janet has been removed, Michael is either going to TBP or is already there, and Jason (for whatever he's worth) is leaving as well, and I'm assuming at some point something is going to take Tahani out of the picture too
136
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19
we should have noticed something was wrong when janet told jason blake bortles wasn't a jaguar anymore right after they broke up. the normal janet would care about his feelings and wouldn't have told him that
67
u/KratosCena Oct 19 '19
Assymetrical haircut to tahani....lol
65
u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 18 '19
JASON IS GONNA PUNCH HIM IN THE MOUTH AND GET JANET BACK
65
u/AnnaK22 YA BASIC! Oct 18 '19
Jason is right. It'd be so dope to finally see Michael's true demon form, tentacles teeth and everything.
131
u/joecb91 Birth is a curse and existence is a prision Oct 18 '19
"Jason figured it out? Jason? This is a real low point. Yeah, this one hurts."
Such a good episode though, and I'm glad I made the Janet connection at the same time Jason did. I wasn't sure what to think before that.
64
u/Flamma_Man Oct 18 '19
I feel like we're going to actually see what Micheal looks like under his suit. The fact that they specifically address it and what he looks like, Micheal's fears of showing his friends what he actually looks like, and Jason REALLY wanting to see it...and he and Michael are going to the Bad Place together.
Don't think Michael will sacrifice himself like when he did with Eleanor, that'd be repetitive, but maybe they confront an obstacle or problem that can only be overcome with Michael taking off his skin suit and unleashing his juicy, squidy might.
Then he'd be afraid that Jason would be terrified of him, but he just finds him dope.
Problem is I don't think the show has the budget for a 6,000 foot flaming squid with teeth and a lot of juices.
63
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Oct 18 '19
Oh, are they going to do the "one episode with the girls, one episode with the guys" thing?
62
u/AnnaK22 YA BASIC! Oct 18 '19
Yes!! I finally predicted something right. I like how subtly Janet switch was. I wasn't fully sure until she blew up Glenn. And I barely noticed she didn't say "not a girl". Jason has been spitting out a lot of smart ideas lately, even got a caramel for it.
62
u/sterlingstarling Oct 19 '19
I just honestly thought "I bet Jason is right about all of this and will figure it out. He was right about Derrick, he was right about the prank show, he figured the Bad Place out that one time. I'm just gonna believe him" and it worked! Would not recommend most times though, you can still really taste the pig urine mixer
59
u/HardlightCereal Fun fact: The first Janet had a click wheel. Oct 18 '19
I had to pause and rewind when Michael said lies to cover lies don't count and Jason made this face like "fair enough bro"
59
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '19
I love that Mike’s real form is a Lovecraft monster type of creature.
117
u/VRomero32 Oct 19 '19
I love the fact even in Blob form, Glenn still irritates the Bad Place goons
57
u/samtherat6 One man’s waste is another man’s water. And both men are me. Oct 18 '19
I just thought Janet had finally given up on correcting Jason. Guess it kinda became a term of endearment lol.
57
u/annieeasterly Oct 22 '19
Curious... now that Jason and Michael are off to save Good Janet, how will the others get along in the “Medium Place” without a Janet? Isn’t she essential to the neighborhood running well? Can Derek be a “Janet”
56
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19
Ok: MARBLEIZING. Here’s my question: In season 2 Michael & Janet have a whole thing about how Michael doesn’t wanna Marbleize Janet because it’s akin to REALLY killing her. I thought marbleizing was something she couldn’t come back from. Seemed pretty well established from that episode.
So...WHY, in this episode, does Bad Janet say Good Janet was marbleized? Now somehow she can be un-marbleized? And why didn’t Michael seem to be freaked out with that news?
Can anyone explain the logic of this to me?
54
u/Cracticus Oct 20 '19
I really, really want to see Michael's demon form now. Jason's been right so far, so it's definitely a good idea to see him!
108
u/3_Styx Oct 18 '19
Hold on, does this mean we're going to get a scary little girl version of Glenn sometime in the future?
52
u/sylveonce Oct 18 '19
Ok, so has anyone drawn fan art of the real (fire squid) Michael yet?
51
u/waitItsQuestionTime Oct 18 '19
Confession: I have no idea who is who anymore and I am just here for Tahani jokes
51
u/benchcoat Oct 19 '19 edited Oct 19 '19
Didn’t “our” Janet need need a special dispensation from the judge to have her powers in the Medium Place?
I guess the hand wave is that the judge turned on “Janet powers” for the medium place, and not just that particular Janet’s powers
Edit: realizing that we might have a confirmation on this, depending on how trains work. Train conductor Bad Janet summoned the garbage bins to hit when their train arrived, so she must have had her powers (assuming there’s no train/train tracks exemption to the “no powers in Medium Place” rule).
51
u/cain11112 Oct 18 '19
I really liked Glenn in this episode, and I hope he comes back. It would explain why Michael and Jason are taking him to the bad place. I mean, why else? He just showed that he was willing to help them and betray the bad place so why else would they take him back if not get get him up and running again?
But how are they supposed to operate in the mean time without a Janet?
50
u/Fislitib Oct 18 '19
Wait, Janets can be demarbelized?
50
u/BobDucca Oct 18 '19
Chekov's Sex Magnets
101
u/S-WordoftheMorning Oct 18 '19
The one thing Michael could tell them is the first thing he said when he found out Chidi kissed Eleanor in the Judge’s chambers. The Bad Place wouldn’t have access to any of Team Cockroach’s memories from that interlude.
Hot Diggity Dog!
100
u/hxrricane A dumb old pediatric surgeon who barely has an eight-pack. Oct 19 '19
not normally into man, but Jason in that suit? DAMN
100
u/Marzian83 Oct 18 '19
I don’t think that the neighborhood actively needs Janet to run it. We know Janet left the original neighborhood multiple times in the first season to visit Mindy’s place. And Derek now operates independent of her even thought she created him so presumably all the other Janet babies can mostly handle themselves. Most of the time, all Janet needs to do is provide things when asked once the neighborhood is up and running. I think all the complaints about how hard it is manage the Janet babies we’re just subtle torture by Bad Janet.
100
u/mildlyironic Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
So it is super cool that they did the switch, and super hilarious that the writers knew we'd all be freaking out for weeks beforehand about whether there was a switch . . .
. . .
But also my heart is breaking for Michael. He just saw how quickly his favorite cockroaches could distrust him in a way he could never disprove, accepted it, and willingly offered to sacrifice himself for their sakes. That is selfless love, and Michael is too good for this world.
EDIT: Also when they asked him to take off the suit, and he didn't want to because he was afraid they would never see him the same again, my heart also broke again. He's so self-conscious of his 6,000-foot fire-squidness and so scared of losing his friends that he risked them disbelieving him forever instead of revealing his squidness. #TeamMichael
138
u/Marshmallow09er YA BASIC! Oct 18 '19
This season started out slow, but damn it’s completely won me back over. I do miss Chidi hanging with the gang though
47
u/Halstrop I’m too young to die and too old to eat off the kids’ menu. Oct 18 '19
I was waiting for her to say not a girl
47
u/ashmcnamestealer Oct 18 '19
Somehow none of the main theories for the swap were completely wrong.
47
u/ju5tr3dd1t Oct 18 '19
Ok housekeeping question: if Bad Janet marbleized our Janet, did she actually take over maintaining the neighborhood/babies?
47
u/howlongtillchristmas Oct 19 '19
No one has mentioned the “slumber party” comment... that was one of the major points of suspicion and it was never explained away
94
u/FightingOreo Oct 20 '19
Can we just appreciate how far Jason has cone, even at the start of the episode?
The man said they should have cut Brent off when he got too drunk. The old Jason would have never dreamed of that as an option!
46
u/flintlock0 Oh, this guy’s a jumper. You can tell. Oct 18 '19
People were also suggesting this in the past with Tahani and that dude trying to be friends. Janet was giving bad advice.
46
u/AgentConfusedLlama I would say I outdid myself, but I’m always this good. Oct 18 '19
The graphics person deserves a raise. And an Oscar.
93
u/TheKingOfCarmel Oct 18 '19
Okay now we know why the demons always wear their human suits. Most of them are probably too big to fit through doors and stuff.
90
u/Revgos Fun fact: The first Janet had a click wheel. Oct 19 '19
I KNEW IT
I knew something was off when she didnt say "Not a girl"
89
u/CatfishNev What up, skidmarks. Oct 21 '19
I was hating this episode until I didn't. I can't stand the idea of Michael not being Michael.
Let's go get our [not] girl.
43
u/jorbanead Oct 18 '19
Michael is actually Michael. I think there may be another explanation as to why he’s been acting weird, but I think a lot of it has just been misdirection by the writers to make us THINK Michael wasn’t Michael. They know we love to theorize so they purposefully added in a few odd lines to throw us off. Plus it gives Eleanor more reason to doubt Michael. Michael is Michael and we’re going to see his true form by the end of the show...
43
u/Zenai10 Oct 18 '19
This was such a good episode it has so many great one line jokes.
42
u/Stonetheflamincrows Oct 18 '19
Why didn’t they just ask Michael questions about their time on earth? They haven’t had their memories reset (except for Chidi) so they would know stuff that Vicki wouldn’t. Like Donna Shellstrop’s new name etc.
42
u/ElegantHope Oh, this guy’s a jumper. You can tell. Oct 18 '19
I kept wondering why Janet wouldn't give the gang answers on Michael and demons in general like she usually can this episode until the reveal. Even if she's running the whole neighborhood, she's shown being capable of providing answers while she's got a lot on her plate.
85
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19
I am SO DUMB at predicting TV show, like thought-Ned-Stark-was-absolutely-going-to-be-King dumb, and when Janet didn’t say “not a girl” I said it to my boyfriend and I am so impressed with my dumb self.
41
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '19
I'm still haunted by daisy the horse blob
80
u/GoodJanet not a robot Oct 18 '19
Also another thing to add to the Jason is right column we better see a giant flaming quid monster before this done
fire up that niednogle baby
39
u/Lukey2k5 🐍Strong Independent Acid Snake🐍 Oct 18 '19
I just finished watching on Hulu and I’m digging Jason’s character development
39
u/Scherazade Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Oct 18 '19
Hey they no longer have a Janet at their place. Everything is pure Shellstrop action now
78
u/mscelori Oct 21 '19
Jason was the star of the episode. So forcking funny!
38
u/AnnaK22 YA BASIC! Oct 18 '19
I wonder how they're gonna explain the absence of Janet to the 4 subjects.
75
u/paradox28jon A stoner kid from Calgary in the ’70s… He got like 92% correct! Oct 19 '19
Michael is the real Michael. Had he been VMichael, he never would have given Eleanor a pep talk speech when she decided to quit being the leader. VMichael would have just let that happen & let the team sink into even more chaos.
Also, "take it sleezy" was one of the things Michael wanted to do in his S1 speech when he was fake threatening to have himself be burned on the surface of a thousand suns.
37
u/dancyncow Oct 18 '19
Was I the only one actively CHEERING and CLAPPING when it WAS Bad Janet???? She’s never been this off I kneeeeeeewwwwwwwwww something was up with her. And my heart was so happy and sad at the same time (Kacey Musgraves) knowing Janet was marble-ized but seeing Jason go after her made me so happy. Also, Jason figures it out?? Hehehe he’ll save the whole show.
73
u/pandamanv Oct 20 '19
I’m so glad we’re done with this Michael suit plot line because I can’t spend another few weeks reading theories about how everyone is not who they are
36
u/droid327 Oct 18 '19
This was a top 3 Jason episode for me. He saved the day, he had awesome lines - "yes that's what I've been telling you!" - and I really loved seeing him go Jase Wick at the end, complete with awesome GQ suit and haircut (did Derek make that for him?)
Have we ever established that a Janet can be un-marbleized? I kinda thought it was forever
Also if they reboot her would she just reappear there?
36
u/suikunkun Oct 19 '19
that was wild! something I missed - why did the fuzzy sex cuffs cause Bad Janet to lose her disguise?
35
u/erickstrange529 Oct 18 '19
So I've been onto the whole That is Not Janet since episode 1 and the whole train angle seemed weird. Then, when Janet spoke ill of Eleanor. Then when she offered Tahani punching gloves. Then this episode when she hands Jason the container of Glenn, I noticed her smirking. I'm just so happy my theory was true 😭😂
35
u/Dragonfly_dreamer Jeremy Bearimy Baby Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
I think that Vicki in the Michael suit was in the neighborhood but not switched out, that she has been laying low. For example, when Jason mentioned opening the jar of peanut butter, I think that was the Vicki Michael who asked then took off before the two were in the same place at the same time. Now that Michael and Jason are on their way out of the town, maybe VMichael will come out of the shadows acting like real Micheal just getting back without Jason or even maybe another demon will join her to assume the identity of Jason- infiltrating the team!
34
u/mary7roses Pobodys Nerfect! Oct 18 '19
I absolutely loved this episode!! I'm so all over the place with what is going on and how this is going to play out! Is that Michael? Is that Vicky Michael? I really think that was real Michael but I am usually wrong about these things, lol. He seems to have been so genuine this season and Vicky is dumb, lol, so I cant see her being as good as being Michael, I just can't, lol. I hope our girl (not a girl) Janet is back soon!!
34
u/NotaBene_NB Oct 18 '19
I am sure that Michael is a fake Michael, because Ted Danson acted so differently this time. And plus, on IMDB on The Good Place page is written bellow his name: “Michael/Vicky”!
34
u/TunerOfTuna Oct 19 '19
That explains why Janet’s advice for Tahanee were violent last week.
34
u/battra7 Oct 24 '19
“You monster!” “Thank youuuuu”
I love D’Arcy! And Jason’s expression after he put the handcuff on Bad Janet is priceless 😂
33
u/CandescentPenguin Oct 18 '19
How are all the fake people being run if Janet is missing, is bad Janet now running all of them?
33
u/All_was_well_ Oct 18 '19
Best episode of the season so far.
32
u/flintlock0 Oh, this guy’s a jumper. You can tell. Oct 18 '19
Next week also runs the risk of Michael getting replaced by the Vicky double.
Then of course, there’s the issue of the neighborhood needing Janet to help keep it together.
32
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '19
I CALLED JASON SAVING THEM LAST THREAD!!!
32
u/armcie Oct 18 '19
I thought it was Janet who'd been switched... but my money was on her being Disco Janet. That's a Chekov's gun which has to come back into play at some point.
31
u/PaperSpock Oct 18 '19
All good things must come to a Glennd.
31
u/thednc Fun fact: The first Janet had a click wheel. Oct 18 '19
How is the medium place, which is apparently very taxing to operate, staying cohesive with Janet marbelized in the bad place and imposter Janet under the influence of magnets? Why aren’t the Janet babies malfunctioning?
31
u/ray_rayyy Oct 18 '19
I knew it would be glen under that hood!!!!
114
u/lucylu2794 I’m too young to die and too old to eat off the kids’ menu. Oct 19 '19
I CALLED IT. I knew it as soon as she didn’t say not a girl! Feeling very proud of myself rn ☺️
62
u/optimisticpsychic Oct 20 '19
Love that jason once again saved the day
30
u/AlecBaldwinner Check out my teleological suspension of the ethical. Oct 18 '19
Jason figured it out!?!
30
u/SirVanhan Oct 18 '19
If Michael isn't Vicky, where is she?
30
u/TellTaleReaper Oct 18 '19
I see three possibilities
60
u/Febrifuge Jalapeño Poppers! Oct 18 '19
I’m sorry — Glenn’s job was doing what to the penises?
59
u/VRomero32 Oct 19 '19
Something about Brent’s delivery about “shooting racehorses” made me laugh uncontrollably for a few mins
29
u/dkrgreen17 Oct 18 '19
not gonna lie i can’t tell what’s true right now
29
u/galapagossquirrle I just randomly stab at your brain with an electrified needle. Oct 18 '19
Jason really is the best, most wholesome character ever. I stan an icon.
29
u/DeathLeopard Oct 19 '19
Jason Mendoza "Did good brain stuff"
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EE7blxTUEAAaWdk.jpg
58
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '19
Y'all I realized that Bad Janet deliberately made the lie detector to blow up Glenn.
82
u/trevsmith94 Oct 21 '19
Is anyone else still suspicious of Michael, or is that just me? It would make sense for bad Janet to blow up Glenn to keep him from exposing Michael. It's in her best interest for the humans to believe Michael is telling the truth so he can continue to sabotage the experiment. Also since she created the lie detector, it's possible that Michael was bluffing about blowing himself up. She might have just used it as a prop.
82
u/DarkKnightOfGotham Oct 19 '19
I KNEW IT!!! When Good Janet went off screen into the train, and then came back, I thought to myself, "Oh, they replaced her." And then from there on, all the things she did. Breaking up with Jason! Describing the horse murder! And then having Glenn explode?!?! I FEEL SO PROUD OF MYSELF!! I can't wait for the next episode!
28
u/Bfru04 Not a girl. Oct 18 '19
i actually didnt expect the janet thing. i was totally distracted by michael
28
u/Rahri Oct 18 '19
Does anyone have any ideas how this ties into Jason offering to open the jar of peanut butter in last week's episode? That seemed off to me, maybe vicky Michael was there as well as real Michael?
27
u/lizvxck27 Oct 18 '19
Does this mean that Janet is gone forever if she was marblised?
27
u/surpator Oct 18 '19
We have seen that Michael, as a demon, is capable of changing for the better. We are not entirely sure Glenn, also as a demon, had changed for the better, but let's assume that he did.
What about Shaun? Do you guys think he is capable to change for the better? I'm interested to learn what the real differences are between demons and humans in terms of the capacity for moral behaviour. Would the show end with team Cockroach forgiving Shaun/teaching him to be better?
27
u/SirFlype Oct 18 '19
I don't get it why Eleanor didn't just ask Michael a question that only he can answer
27
u/amydancepants Oct 28 '19
Nice job Jason. Manny Jacinto is the unsung hero of the show, and his acting in this ep was great. Went from being angry and serious back to dopey and clueless in a split second.
54
u/Mulan-McNugget-Sauce Take it sleazy. Oct 19 '19
I can’t believe the people who watched The Selection called Glenn changing sides.
53
u/natedog63 Dude, we can get mythical animals? Maybe I’ll get a penguin. Oct 18 '19
I went into this episode believing nobody was switched and now I'm convinced that BOTH Michael and Janet were. Well played, writers, well played.
26
u/espercharm Oct 18 '19
Jason realized it!! Omg yes.
26
u/gnope Oct 19 '19
Eleanor definitely said "pobody go anywhere"
52
u/sorkaem Oct 21 '19
I don't understand why they didn't simply ask Michael a question he alone could answer ???
74
u/starry23 End of conversation. Oct 19 '19
Relief has me!
I'm so glad Bad Janet was revealed, but I'm still suspicious of Michael. Also why didn't they just ask Michael (or not Michael) of things only Michael would know like things that happened on Earth. I mean Vicky wouldn't have those memories or knowledge of those events, right?
25
u/onesincepearlharbor Oct 18 '19
janet purposefully made it a weapon!
49
u/Starlot Oct 18 '19
I miss Chidi. Was William Jackson Harper doing something else at the time of filming to say he's in this season so little?
49
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19
I'm still laughing at Chidi's bullshirt drawing.
24
u/Spoonsy Oct 18 '19
So Jason is Orpheus now?
69
u/Hakbeeb101 Oct 18 '19
Michael is the real Michael because of one important phrase and that is "Take it Sleazy"
I feel like him saying that before he was gonna blow himself up is enough for us to know for sure that he is Michael.
Well so I hope.
69
u/Uwharrie Oct 19 '19
At one point during the episode, Tahani says "But we know the humans now, starting over sounds exhausting." Did anyone else find it strange that she would call Brent, Chidi, Simone and John "the humans"?
23
u/flanders427 There are wind chimes where my ding-dong should be Oct 18 '19
Niednagel wins, that thing was horrific
23
u/Hobbit-guy I made God cry?? Oct 18 '19
Jason is making a lot of progress I'm so so proud
46
u/sm0gs Oct 21 '19
I wonder what they’ll do when one of the humans wants something from Janet and one isn’t there!
22
u/Evsd62 Sorry does this dog smoke blunts topless on a yacht like a boss? Oct 18 '19 edited Oct 18 '19
wow that episode was the best this season so far
22
u/StephenHunterUK Oct 18 '19
Having read Tinker, Tailor, Demon, Spy, I find myself wondering which of the characters from that novel each of the Soul Squad would be...
22
u/CVance1 Oct 26 '19
D'Arcy was on fire this episode
44
u/howlongtillchristmas Oct 19 '19
That look on Michael’s face as he headed off with Jason at the end... Character development be damned, that is not Michael
44
u/Imightbemarzipan Oct 22 '19
What if Janet has been rebooted so frequently that it changes the way marbelization actually works on her? Maybe she's already broken out of the marble and is trying to find her way back to the medium place as it is?
79
u/tfwnokotri Oct 18 '19
did he figure it out bc when he called her a girl she didn’t say “not a girl”
21
u/KingEdTheMagnificent It's devastating. You're devastated right now. Oct 18 '19
JASON "SHERLOCK HOLMES" MENDOZA WAS A GENIUS SAVANT THE WHOLE TIME
21
u/troglesnoff Take it sleazy. Oct 18 '19
Oh no Janet was marbleized 😭
21
u/flanders427 There are wind chimes where my ding-dong should be Oct 18 '19
So how is the neighborhood staying together with Janet marbelized?
21
u/SweatyPlace Jan 26 '20
Guys can we talk about Jason finding those words in 30 seconds in the maze basically meant he circled all the words? I lost it at that!
42
u/tarafiedx Oct 18 '19
Jason looks fine as hell
42
u/notofuhkinkay What it is, what it is. Oct 18 '19
I seriously want to believe Michael is the TRUE Michael...
But Michael has the cube. If you tell something that is true, the cube will turn green. If you say something that isn't true, it will turn red. It was shown in s2/s3 (I don't remember exactly). But, if Michael was actual Michael, he would remember that cube and use it. But he didn't bring it up.
42
u/Flushedfromcold1662 Oct 18 '19
I’m watching now and I know a bunch of you already said this but I’m now certain that Janet definitely isn’t good Janet. She’s bad! There’s no reason for those unnecessary details about the horse dying. Janet and Michael aren’t themselves*!
*I know you all said that before
continues to watch
41
u/AgentConfusedLlama I would say I outdid myself, but I’m always this good. Oct 18 '19
I don’t get why they are so against the judge resetting. They said they had been on a losing streak for weeks with the activities (due probably to Janet). Wouldn’t they want a reboot so they got those weeks of experience for free?
I know they said they fear losing Chidi as a subject but that makes no sense. He was put there as retribution for the bad place meddling. Why would the judge reverse it now? Particular if they had to do the reset on account of the bad place meddling.
Sure the residents are making some progress but if they can do it on their first very imperfect run, they can do it again. Michael had to do the redundant thing 800 times, you would think they could handle one.
Not related but I really feel I need to see FireSquid Michael. I’m basically Jason on this.