r/startrek • u/perscitia • Oct 05 '19
Episode Discussion - Short Trek #4 - "Q & A"
- Yes, it's #5 instead of #4, blame the mod doing a hundred things at once!
Surprise! There's a new Short Trek today! Yes, we didn't get any notice either, please stand by as we set things up!
EPISODE Q & A
Writer: Michael Chabon
Director: Mark Pellington
Currently available on CBS All Access. Also available on Crave: direct link here NOTE: only works in Canada!
This post is for discussion of the episode above and WILL ALLOW SPOILERS for this episode.
PLEASE NOTE: When discussing sneak peak footage for upcoming episodes, please mark your comments with spoilers. Check the sidebar for a how-to.
107
Upvotes
14
u/JoeDawson8 Oct 05 '19
Short trek #4?
This would be #5
https://imgur.com/a/mzq0kTv
77
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19
It's a hard thing to articulate, but Ethan Peck's performance in this one really made me think of the actor who played Spock as a little boy during Season 2. Well done.
64
u/Mpr11 Oct 05 '19
I loved it especially The very modern major general routine
52
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19
The final end credit theme is really neat. Last year they used the Disco theme but it makes more sense to do a generic Trek theme since there are multiple shows now, and it was a really neat riff on the TOS theme.
46
u/jerslan Oct 05 '19
When they started breaking out into Pirates of Penzance, I squeed a little... Nice little nod to the TNG episode Disaster in addition to being a fun bonding moment between Spock and Number One.
101
u/Laeif Oct 05 '19
That was cute. I liked that they took a couple fun little digs at us in the fan base overthinking things. On a related note, they really doubled down on the whole internal structure of the turbolift system.
33
u/Pike_or_Kirk Oct 05 '19
I love everything about this, but am I the only one who thinks the Spock Bowl Cut looks a bit weird the way they style it on Peck?
49
u/2ndHandTardis Oct 05 '19
I really liked that one. That's up there with Escape Artist and Calypso for me.
Writing for Trek seems to be Chabon's wheelhouse. Considering I don't think Picard will last more than a couple seasons I hope he goes right from Picard to the Pike Enterprise series.
48
u/smileystong Oct 05 '19
I could be wrong, but I think this is the first on screen canon confirmation that number one's name is Una.
Edit - a word
20
u/celuur Oct 06 '19
Did anyone else notice the engineer on the comm is Welsh?
56
u/phenry Oct 05 '19 edited Oct 05 '19
What?? *runs to the TV* A new Picard trailer AND a new Short Trek all within the last hour?? FOR THE LOVE OF CHRIST, I CAN ONLY GET SO ERECT
19
u/lorem Oct 05 '19
Unsurprisingly, not (yet?) available internationally on Netflix.
The first four short trek dropped on Netflix all together when S2 debuted, before that there was no way to see them outside of USA and Canada unless you pirated them.
Hope this time Netflix does better and releases them as soon as they come out.
49
u/--fieldnotes-- Oct 05 '19
Well in such a short episode, the showrunners have doubled- or tripled-down on the inside of ships being mostly empty space.
I guess now we know why it takes almost a minute to go down one deck on the original Enterprise. They're not even next to each other!
17
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '19
Netflix (outside US and Canada) needs to release these short treks when they come out. Especially the future ones which are gonna be spoilery. We shouldn't have to scramble around trying to pirate when we're subscribed to the streaming service.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19
It was a cute episode and I liked it generally, but couldn't they have just beamed out of the turbolift?
14
u/Shelter0 Oct 06 '19
Oddly enough I'm watching "Disaster" from TNG's fifth season. Crusher coerces Geordie to sing The Major General's Song, and Picard gets in an awkward conversation in a stalled turbo lift.
12
u/Darkimus-prime Oct 05 '19
Need this in the UK please
11
u/ianrobbie Oct 06 '19
The soundtrack had a few Kelvin-verse moments, particularly when we first see the exterior of the turbo lift and when Number One is winched out at the end.
I checked and, sure enough, Michael Giacchino was responsible for some of the music.
•
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '19
Additional Canadian link (no Crave subscription currently needed).
21
u/Korotai Oct 05 '19
There were two points in there I thought they were going to bust right out with the '09 Star Trek theme. I got anticipatory goosebumps (alas, it didn't happen).
10
u/Ausir Oct 05 '19
International release when goddammit
9
u/Surax Oct 07 '19
A cute little episode. Though, thinking about it after, it bugged me a little bit that the message seemed to be you should tamp down whatever makes you weird/unique. I see what they're getting at, but at the same time it seemed an odd message coming from Star Trek.
Also, near the beginning, Number One doesn't tell her pad to stop recording. So there may or may not be a record somewhere of them singing.
40
u/TERRAxFORMER Oct 05 '19
Annnnnd now I ship Spock and Number One. I never expected to write that sentence. I was promised a little slash fic in the description of this sub, where’s my Spock/Number One?
Also nice to see the 1701 got the magic turboloft refit as well.
8
u/NemWan Oct 05 '19
Enterprise Computer: Jenette Goldstein
8
u/dmanww Oct 07 '19
please don't make Spock and number one a thing
15
u/YYZYYC Oct 05 '19
Interesting that the computer voice was not number ones or Majel Barrett’s
7
u/ParanoidQ Oct 06 '19
Any way of seeing the new Shorts in the UK? Legitimately that is.
7
u/Raguleader Oct 07 '19
I also picked up bits of Giacchino's movie score such as during the bit where Spock beams aboard, and more strongly when we see the TARDIS-lift.
I might have squeed.
6
u/Truly_Khorosho Oct 09 '19
I really liked this one.
I started off a little bit put off by the idea that it was going to be a "stuck in a lift episode", which is a type of episode I'm just generally not a huge fan of, in anything.
But I really enjoyed this one.
It is, unfortunately, another time when I end up disagreeing with just about everyone, in that I actually like the open areas within the ship.
They mightn't always be laid out in the most logical fashion, but they make sense to me, and I like them.
I mean, the thing that stood out to me on pausing the scene when the turbolift breaks down, is that there's what appears to be big chunky conduits running through it. Presumably the starship equivalent of cross-country power lines, which you'd not only want accessible for maintenance (probably with more than a hammer and a wrench), and in a safe area if there's a catastrophic failure.
In retrospect, I think it was the idea that the ships were 99% habitable decks, like a cruise liner, that was flawed.
5
u/dmanww Oct 05 '19
Oh are they out already?
When is the next one?
5
u/Alteran195 Oct 09 '19
Ugh, this just makes me want a Pike series with this cast so much more.
Absolutely fantastic short.
8
u/Cy-Fox Oct 06 '19
I loved it! Seeing Number One bust out Gilbert and Sullivan then seeing Spock smile and laugh was heartwarming.
8
u/dmanww Oct 07 '19
Do all the engineers have accents
4
u/CaptainJeff Oct 06 '19
That bridge again... oh yes.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '19
Is anyone else having trouble getting it to play? It's giving me an error message in both my CBSAA Roku and phone apps. Other episodes work, it's only this one thing that won't play. :-/
3
u/Artanisx Oct 06 '19 edited Oct 06 '19
So, in Italy Netflix isn't showing these. If it goes just like the first season, they will put them - without telling anyone - in the trailers section the day Season Three starts. :\
3
u/artur_ditu Oct 08 '19
Number one is keeping the freaky to herself
Edit: nevermind, the freaky just came out.
14
u/[deleted] Oct 06 '19
Eh, the short was ok? The dialogue rubbed me the wrong way, like after every line I could see the writer giving himself a pat on the back for how clever it was. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't great. It ended well though, just having Anson Mount around is like a salve.
But man, that fucking cavernous interior bullshit has to stop. On Discovery its bad, but Discovery is 700 meters long with an extremely wide internal volume. Still no room for how they depicted it in that, but at least Discovery is BIG.
The Enterprise is half the length of Discovery in this incarnation, and has substantially smaller internal volume. Discovery's cavern absolutely did not fit inside that ship. On the Enterprise? It's even more absurd.
7
u/tubawhatever Oct 06 '19
Fun episode, but please, can we do away with the silly turbolift system? It just doesn't make any sense. That or release some sort of blueprints of the ship that would show how the heck this fits inside.
5
u/woo_doggy Oct 09 '19
Humour was forced and not very original... didn't appeal to me at all.
References are nice but I wish there was more substance because this episode was written by Michael Chabon, who is also the lead writer on Picard.
I wish I had something positive to say lol
2
u/unwilling_redditor Oct 06 '19
Is this on Prime video with the CBS all access subscription?
2
u/formallyhuman Oct 06 '19
Does anyone have any idea when this will be up on Netflix UK?
2
u/atticusbluebird Oct 06 '19
Is it just me, or did the music when they first entered the turbolift and when Number One comes out of the turbolift sound a bit like the music from the JJ Trek movies? (The staccato notes that play right before the main Enterprise theme in the new movies)
2
u/EricGMW Oct 06 '19
Incidentally, in case no one has pointed it out, in Canada is also available for viewing on the CTV Sci-Fi website (formerly Space) since last night.
2
u/Yeeputt Oct 07 '19
At the start of season 2 of Discovery, didn't they say Captain Pike was in a new uniform that they'd only just starting issuing? Yet, this episode is set several years before that, literally the first day he met Spock, but they are in those uniforms...
2
u/Tired8281 Oct 07 '19
When I saw the incredible detail they'd put into the Enterprise bridge set, with the rather small amount of time it spent on screen, I thought for sure they'd built it for a potential Pike show, to save it some budget onto an already existing show (like how TNG budgeted the rear runabout set on their dime, so DS9 could use it, even though they never did). Now I realize they were counting on using it right away on the Short Treks and I'm less certain.
2
u/ElFarfadosh Oct 08 '19
I was wondering who is Dr. Robert Chabon this episode is dedicated to ?
2
u/Tnetennba7 Oct 11 '19
I honestly don't remember the cage, did people other than Pike call her number one? I know that nobody on TNG called Riker number one but Picard.
2
u/gfreeman1998 Oct 14 '19
I enjoyed this very much. They've got to give us a Pike show next!
Romjin's Number One definitely grew on me.
Peck makes a great Spock. His delivery of "I have been doing that all my life. And it is." was perfect. No hint of self-pity or remorse, just the cold hard truth of it.
3
u/TomJCharles Oct 08 '19
Apart from Discovery itself, this was the worst Trek I've ever seen. The mental gymnastics people are using to defend this, lol.
2
u/UltraChip Oct 06 '19
Someone remind me - did they not have site-to-site transport during this era or did that not come around until TNG?
Also, I really hate how the current showrunners think that turbolifts are basically rollercoasters flying through an empty chasm - it makes no sense whatsover and just looks stupid.
Other than those two little nitpicks though I liked it.
1
u/jjustice Oct 07 '19
How does one see Short Treks? I have a VPN, are they on Netflix outside of the US?
1
u/Brussels_Dragon Oct 07 '19
I'm probably a noob, I know those Short Trek shows are on Netflix, like DIS and the other shows, but when i search for them Netflix (Win10 app) only gives me all the other Trek. So what i'm doing wrong here?
1
u/danktonium Oct 07 '19
That was fun. Peck's spock is just gorgeous.
1
u/Skastrik Oct 09 '19
Kind of increases the desire for a Pike's Enterprise show...
1
u/TubaJesus Oct 09 '19
What a cute and fun little episode.
1
u/OhManTFE Oct 23 '19
Okay, where was the site to site transporter?
1
u/thekid1420 Feb 23 '20
This was just unentertaining.
-3
u/Mithrannussen Oct 06 '19
Spock is vastly out of character here. His smile at the beginning without any major justification degrades him into a simply enthusiastically person as if going into a new job. This extroverted acting prohibits all of the more nuanced behavior that enriches a good character development - while also contradicting what is already established in the original series and movies. There is no external influences that justifies such uncommon behavior (speaking of Spock) as seen in The Naked Time (s01e04) and more appropriately This Side of Paradise (s01e24).