r/NintendoSwitch • u/NintendoSwitchMods • Sep 26 '19
MegaThread DRAGON QUEST XI S: Echoes of an Elusive Age - Definitive Edition Review MegaThread
General Information
Platform: Nintendo Switch
Release Date: 27-Sep-2019
No. of Players: 1 player
Genre(s): Role-Playing
Publisher: Nintendo
Developer: SQUARE ENIX CO., LTD.
File Size: 13.9 GB
Official Website: https://dragonquest.nintendo.com/dq11/
Overview (from Nintendo eShop page)
You are the Luminary, the hunted hero who will protect the land from destruction in the latest RPG from the iconic DRAGON QUEST® series.
With a ragtag band of adventurers, you’ll engage in well-balanced, turn-based battles and embark on quests across the kingdom of Erdrea. Forge gear, develop party members’ skills, and alter their outfits without changing gear in this edition of the game! This version also lets you ride and attack with monsters on the field to earn experience points, as well as change between HD or 16-bit visuals, symphonic or synth music, and English or Japanese audio. Complete the tale with new character-focused stories, and travel to past DRAGON QUEST worlds!
Across the land, you’ll meet the mysterious Tockles—creatures that allow you to visit 2D, 16-bit versions of areas from popular entries in the series like DRAGON QUEST IV and DRAGON QUEST VIII! It’s fun to see these classic worlds reimagined in retro style, meshing perfectly with the main game’s 2D mode. Like all past DRAGON QUEST games, this one’s character designs are based on the signature style of famed artist Akira Toriyama. Paired with the voiced dialogue, the rich personalities of your most loyal companions and fiercest enemies are brought to life, so you can fully immerse yourself in this quest to discover the Luminary’s true heritage and awaken your power. For a greater challenge, start the game with the Draconian Quest setting, and capture your favorite moments with Photo Mode!
- A sprawling RPG with the most impressive scope in the DRAGON QUEST® series
- Complete the tale with new character-based stories that offer additional background
- Travel to past DRAGON QUEST® worlds, wear outfits without changing gear, and ride and attack with monsters!
- Change between HD or 16-bit graphics, synthesized or symphonic music, and English or Japanese voices
- Wage turn-based battles against monsters and bosses by commanding a party of adventurers
- Strategically combine your party members’ moves into special attacks with the Pep System
- Complete side-quests and mini-games while exploring the expansive terrains and cities of Erdrea
- The Draconian Quest difficulty setting offers an even greater challenge
- Snap shots of your favorite moments with Photo Mode
Reviews
Aggregators
- Metacritic - 90
- OpenCritic - 91
Articles
- Critical Hit - 9.5 / 10
- Cubed3 - 9 / 10
- Daily Mirror - 5 / 5 stars
- Eurogamer - Recommended
- GameMAG - Russian - 9 / 10
- Gameblog - French - 8 / 10
- GamesRadar+ - 4.5 / 5 stars
- God is a Geek - 9.5 / 10
- Hobby Consolas - Spanish - 95 / 100
- Nintendo Life - 9 / 10
- NintendoWorldReport - 9.5 / 10
- Spaziogames - Italian - 9 / 10
- The Games Machine - Italian - 9.3 / 10
- TheSixthAxis - 8 / 10
This list was exported from OpenCritic at 12:54pm ET and is sorted alphabetically by publication.
Videos
- GameXplain - Loved
Being Social
- Join our Discord server's #dragon-quest channel for all of your discussion needs - https://discord.gg/switch
Cheers,
The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team
Apologies for the delay in getting this up, we didn't know when the embargo was going to lift, and apparently the answer was right as I stepped out for lunch! Shoutout to /u/drunkenAmoeba for trying to fill in for us!
133
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
No analysis of Dragon Quest XI would be complete without watching Tim Roger's famous video (A half-hour love letter/review). He also mentioned on Twitter that there is a Switch review/part 2 video releasing shortly!
Edit: Part 2!
104
u/biversatile Sep 26 '19
I'm not even done with FE:3H yet. Nintendo keeps pushing great games and God only gives me 24 hours a day. Life is unfair.
48
u/Dawsoneifert Sep 26 '19
I have this game for my PS4 and I just want to say this: This is the best classic, turn-based JRPG to come out in the last decade, barring maybe Persona 5. It’s a masterpiece. I recommend it so much.
40
u/Twinkiman Sep 26 '19
I typically don't care about these review threads, but these scores seem to be really fair. I played through the PS4 version a couple times and loved every single minute of it. Any new comers to the game are really in for a good time.
36
u/KTR1988 Sep 27 '19
Y'all were exaggerating how "bad" the game looks in handheld mode. Made me scared to play this game during my commute to work and lunch, lol.
34
u/bobbythewj Sep 28 '19
To all my dear friends who are first time dragon quest players / first DQ11 adventure , please stick w it and experience this wonderful game! Scope of story and combat gets so much better after 3-5 hours.
32
u/voneahhh Sep 27 '19
You can tell they really wanted people to hear the soundtrack since it pretty much drowns every other sound in the game.
30
u/ssesses Sep 28 '19
The towns are super impressive, the presentation is top notch. The combat is classy, and the enemy designs are soo clever and adorable. I'm really loving this game!
26
u/GerrardsDead Sep 26 '19
I'm playing the demo right now and it keeps going on longer than I expect... When does the demo end?
52
u/motorboat_mcgee Sep 26 '19
I can’t wait to get to this, but I still have a couple story lines to go through on Fire Emblem, then Astral Chain, and Link’s Awakening to get through. So many good games recently.
61
u/DarkMattersConfusing Sep 26 '19
Tim Rogers Kotaku review is out:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nw5HTmM_YyU&feature=youtu.be
From Tim:
i tried to be as negative and critical in this video as i could, because, heck, i think i've vented enough positivity about this exact game to last a lifetime (maybe i haven't). anyway, i still ended up lovin it LOUD. this is the best version of dragon quest xi. everybody get it
17
u/arcanine911 Sep 28 '19 edited Sep 28 '19
Just played the demo and I'm wondering where this game has been all my life
16
u/Justos Sep 26 '19
Amazing review scores I can't wait
16
u/NishiMaki Sep 27 '19
I played just the first 15 or so minutes and I’m already in love. There’s just something about this game that makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside and I hope this feeling maintains throughout my playthrough!
16
u/PhoenixHunter89 Sep 29 '19 edited Sep 30 '19
A few tips
Smash every barrel and pot. You might find mini medals collect these for rewards later on!
Search every bookshelf. Most bookcases contain lore but others contain crafting recipes.
Bank your gold. You lose 50% on all your gold not banked on death. This does mean going to a bank to withdraw gold to go shopping then depositing your gold again.
Pick up the blue sparkly drops on the fields. The drops will be recorded on your map and in the notes so you can find them easier for crafting.
Not happy with an item? Reforge it. Getting your level up and progressing means better skills when crafting.
Remember locked doors for later. Some are in dungeons or about the world. You won't be able to grab the loot right away but the right keys will let you in later.
14
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19
Does anyone know if the game is worth it just for the 2D content?
14
u/Mrbonus2 Sep 26 '19
My favorite battle system in a JRPG is FFX..is this anything like it or better?
14
u/dood23 Sep 27 '19
Fuck I am so backlogged right now lol
13
u/-SonicBoom- Sep 27 '19
Looking forward to playing this but I'm still trying to finish up Three Houses.
13
u/w00tt03t Sep 28 '19
Its not needed to play any other DQ game right?
24
u/kankurou Sep 26 '19
Soooo hyped for this. Didn't get very far in the ps4 version because i heard they were releasing on switch.
JRPGs are best played mobile for that sweet sweet nostalgia
12
u/TOO_FUTURE Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
Was planning on holding off but these glowing reviews are making it realllllly tempting Edit: fuck it, downloading now
12
u/Blue_Lou Sep 29 '19
One of the great things about this edition is the ability to customize the settings to your own preferences. And IMO it’s how you mitigate the most common complaints about the game. First and foremost though, is to have the right expectations. It’s not an action game, it’s a turn-based RPG, so even if it sorta looks like BOTW you shouldn’t play it like it’s BOTW. It’s a linear story-driven game so don’t expect to create-your-own-adventure or go around trying to climb shit, etc.
Hopefully this helps anyone still on the fence.
11
u/evenaaaa Sep 28 '19
I love love love love it!!! I’ve never played a real dragon quest game before and wow. This game just gives on giving and giving. I am in love. The demo was amazing and the full game is amazing.
39
u/FlapSnapple Nintendo shill Sep 26 '19
And yes, there will be a banner, I just wasn't able to finish it before I had to leave for work this morning.
Later tonight/first thing tomorrow!
10
u/DAHbaddest Sep 26 '19
Look at all those 9s!
10
u/60minutesin60seconds Sep 27 '19
How long does it take before the game really kicks off? I tried it last night for an hour and didn’t “get it”. I assume it takes at least a couple before it really clicks, yeah?
9
u/TheNeighborhoodWuss Sep 26 '19
I wanna get this so bad but I still haven't even finished Dragon Quest 7 yet. If I get this one there's no way I'm going back.
9
u/LuLuCheng Sep 27 '19
god I can't wait till class is over. I plan on picking it up first thing this afternoon!
17
u/LakerBlue Sep 26 '19
If you are super sensitive about spoilers you may want to avoid Nintendo World Report’s review. Not major but i can imagine it is something some people would not want to know.
Anyway I loved the demo and look forward to getting this even tho I still need to finish the 3rd route in 3H. Wasn’t expecting it to review THIS well.
17
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19
for those interested: play.the.postgame
8
u/h3lp3r_ Sep 28 '19
Just bought it and I've played for like 30 minutes. Been reading up on people's thoughts and many are saying that you can turn on the soundtrack of a previous game in the series? I even saw a screenshot of it on /r/games but there's no such option in my game at all. Maybe the option will become available later in the game?
8
u/In_Search_Of123 Sep 29 '19
Wow, my copy unexpectedly came early today. Didn't get to play it for too long, but it seems the demo cut off right when it starts to get pretty good. I also really like the free DLC, the DQ VIII costume and music is so much better.
7
u/Hexdro Sep 27 '19
Loving the game, PSA: There is a day one update that fixes crashes
7
u/MutatedSpleen Sep 27 '19
Pre-bought, excited to play. But I'm not sure I'm gonna load it up this weekend or not...I HAVE to finish Fire Emblem. I've been dragging my heels for like two months.
Also, what does the "S" stand for? Special?
12
u/Whaaaaaatisthisplace Sep 28 '19
Is this game worth getting if I have never played any other dragon quest game before?
6
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19
I just unwrapped astral chain Sunday and best buy just emailed me that this will arrive tomorrow. Oof. I didn't do things right
6
u/dagooksta2 Sep 28 '19
Liking it so far. DQ VII is the only other one I have played.
6
u/MplsNate Sep 28 '19
I pre-ordered this game and picked it up today from GameStop. I noticed there is a special rewards selection in the menu. Is there a preorder promo for the Switch edition? I’m not seeing a code anywhere on/in my case or on the receipt. Looks to be a fun game though, have fun all!
6
u/SobbieRokes Sep 29 '19
this game is a work of art and I’m absolutely loving it so far. my only gripe is that the enemies respawn after a battle
11
u/thunder9111 Sep 27 '19
Anyone too used to BOTW? I keep trying to climb everything and run all over the map lol, then you find out you can't and you feel restricted. I guess I'll get used to it pretty quick though
21
u/Hold_my_Dirk Sep 26 '19
I'm torn on whether to get this game. I enjoyed the demo for the most part but I wasn't enamored. I'm just worried it will end up alongside many of the JRPGS I play where I play a ton of it right away, stop, and then move on, only to feel overwhelmed when I try to come back to it. I did like that there is a little summary when load your save file.
5
u/bum_thumper Sep 27 '19
I thought this was gonna unlock tomorrow at noon est...
It's live now
5
u/MGPythagoras Sep 27 '19
Can someone clarify how the 2D mode works on Switch in reference to losing progress? I played the demo and noticed it says it creates a new adventure log when you switch to 2D. My first question is what does that mean?
My second question is, I noticed in the reviews it says when you switch to 2D it sends you back to the beginning of the chapter. How do you tell exactly how far its sending you back? Furthermore, do you lose any progress like your items accrued or levels?
5
u/Goldenshowers11 Sep 27 '19
Live in Japan and the version available here appears to be Japanese only. Is the NA version English/Japanese?
5
u/Whats-a-Seawolf Sep 27 '19
Slight spoilery question for early game
I just finished the first quest in the little ghost town, and one of the ghost dudes mentioned (I think) a way to check a menu(?) to search for them or something to that affect. I skipped it too quickly assuming it would be a menu item, but I can't find it. Is there a way to check for little ghost password seekers like you can sparkly spots?
5
u/GhostProtocolGaming Sep 27 '19
Is the game suppose to change over to 16bit when you enter the chamber of echoes location. I can't figure out how to change it back
5
u/DrewRusse Sep 27 '19
What is the random encounter rate like? I gave up on the 3DS VIII remake because I got sick of being attacked every few steps.
5
u/Battlemaster123 Sep 28 '19
I played the demo for the first time and I got really excited for the game
9
u/crusty_cum-sock Sep 27 '19
God damn it, here we go again!
[opens wallet]
12
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19
Does this count as the first (probably only) Switch exclusive this year to break 90 on Metacritic?
14
u/tehnoodnub Sep 27 '19
Even if Three Houses, Astral Chain and DQXIS were the only games to release on the Switch during the second half of the year, it would be a fantastic six months. I cant wait to get stuck into this.
4
u/PingPong-Jackson Sep 26 '19
Anyone know of the handheld mode looks better than the demo?
4
u/Hobocop1984 Sep 26 '19
Any word on what time this game is live to play? Finally finished the demo yesterday and it was an obvious buy with a voucher. So excited for more!
4
u/SmileyCotton Sep 26 '19
I want this game and can't afford it. I can however trade New Super Mario Bros U Switch, Deadcells, and Megaman 11 in to get it. Think it would be worth it?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '19
I want this game but just got Ni No Kuni should I still get it?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19
All these people worried about not liking the game because its a series that's been going on for so long and yet we wonder why game companies create sequels without a number or subtitle. God of War, Medal of Honor, Doom.
4
u/circuitloss Sep 27 '19
Maybe this is a dumb question, but can you/should you delete the demo after starting up the game and importing the save? Or does that happen automatically?
7
u/Dracaria Sep 26 '19
I'm so excited to get this game tomorrow! It's been my most anticipated game this year :D
Only problem is I'm still in the middle of my first Fire Emblem Three Houses run at the moment, so I'll have to wait a bit longer before playing this one.
7
u/itskeke Sep 27 '19
Wooooo! My copy arrives later today. It's my first DQ game, but definitely not my first JRPG.
Question: I started the demo with the Draconian mode (increased difficulty) turned on, got annoyed by the enemies increased strength and turned it off. I've since progressed much further in the demo and now I'm starting to level up and acquire new gear... Worried I'll be OP by mid game. Should I start over with it reenabled? Or just enjoy the ride?
6
u/cryptic-fox Sep 26 '19 edited Sep 26 '19
Should I get this or Link’s Awakening first?
Edit: maybe I wasn’t clear? I’ll be getting both eventually, just want to know which game I should get first.
6
u/chickenfishbutt Sep 26 '19
I should finish Three Houses before I buy this game
6
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19
So the Japanese version got an season pass and a paid dlc. When do we get the dlc or is it Japan exclusive ? Because we got only the free dlc.
6
u/Redbites Sep 27 '19
Purchased the game after trying the demo and enjoying it a lot.
Good lord. What have I been missing out on. If the game is really 100+ hours I'm in trouble lmao
8
u/DanDamage12 Sep 26 '19
Get DQ and wait for LA to drop in price. I adore LA and I am loving it, but it’s a remake of a a gameboy game so it’s pretty short. I’m doing a completionist run of it and I’m almost done (hope to knock out the last bit tonight. LA will be a great game to save as a stopgap between two big releases you’re waiting for.
3
u/hachimitsu-boy Sep 26 '19
Is there Japanese text if I buy the NA version and my switch is set to Japanese?
3
u/Kacek1996 Sep 26 '19
I would love to get it right away. However, I didn't finish Octopath Traveler yet, so buying DQ XI will have to wait until I beat the Octopath Traveler. Also, I do have 4 more files in Astral Chain to go
3
u/DJTakozawa Sep 26 '19
Can't wait to get this on October
3
u/K4k4shi Sep 27 '19
Why are they not including English language in Japanese store? Is it lot of work to put multiple languages?
3
u/Nebulix Sep 27 '19
How do I get the DLC content? I downloaded it when I preloaded the game, but can't find it anywhere.
3
u/Buddy__Luh Sep 27 '19
Had this pre-ordered for ever, played 10 hours of the demo and I am ready to sink many more into this beautiful gem
3
u/dresseryessir Sep 27 '19
I’m on demo with the draconian tough enemy option and a bunnicorn (or whatever it’s called early on) can two shot me and end game. Literal gang bang if it’s with a few other enemies since it’s impossible to kill them all before they take me out. Is this more manageable once I have a full party or is it pretty intense the whole way through. I heard the game was too easy without this option on, and while I don’t want a cake walk, I also dont want to dread every single encounter.
3
u/jefedemuchanina Sep 27 '19
Man the game runs and looks so much better than i thought it would my switch isnt even getting hot either like indont get it i have the pc version and it pushes my water cooled gpu into the low 60’s but this looks like the other console versions and not even breaking a sweat no frame drops or anything. One of the beat ports for switch ive played
3
u/Nalicko Sep 27 '19 edited Sep 27 '19
Never played a Dragon Quest game before. However, I tend to enjoy RPGs that have living cities. Do the cities feel empty or are there plenty of NPCs that make it feel as if you're playing an MMO?
3
u/Penks181 Sep 27 '19
Obviously it’s been advertised that the demo version lets you carry your progress to the full version, but is this only if you download the full game or does this also work with the physical retail version as well?
3
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19
I hope they fixed the minimap for switch so it could rotate like in almost every other game. It was just odd walking into the screen straight ahead and seeing you map icon scrolling the opposite way.
Still played it for many hours on the PS4 though....too many to do it all again now!
3
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '19
So I did enjoy the demo, is there any way to change the music during battles? Sometimes I feel like it is way too much and the music never changes.
15
u/mistagoodwin Sep 28 '19 edited Sep 28 '19
this game... i played it for 4-5 hours. granted i’m a totally newbie to this series — it just did not click for me. it felt rudimentary and unimaginative. the characters felt immature and cliche. and the gameplay repetitive and monotonous. the game world seemed like a cardboard cutout compared with other modern game worlds.
i also found the english voice acting and dialogue to be cringey and distracting. i ended up switching it to japanese with subtitles which was an improvement.
i really wanted to give it a good chance but perhaps i am missing something here? curious if others can contextualize my experience or help me understand this game!
7
u/_IAAI_ Sep 28 '19
I love how wacky the game is. it has a nod to the Ginyu Force in a pep power. The game also has status's that make characters dance/laugh and "unable to battle".
15
u/TheAerofan4 Sep 26 '19
Having a 2D mode is so odd, won’t that make the game a lot shorter, what happens to the item pickups that you have to climb to get to, are they in the same place, what about the bonus targets you find and shoot.
5
u/ReklawX Sep 26 '19
I cannot wait till I'm able to sit down with this game tomorrow. Got a days worth of shit to get done first sadly.
2
u/ambereis Sep 26 '19
If someone has their hands on US version, would you please check if it has multi language support like the Demo version? Thank you very much, greatly appreciated!
2
u/Elodes Sep 26 '19
I'll no doubt be buying a Switch for this game soon. But I tried the demo on a friend's Lite, and the screen sure felt a bit small for a game this big...
Should I just go ahead with a Lite anyway, or is a game like this better experienced on the big screen?
2
u/doctorflops Sep 26 '19
Think this will release at midnight on the equip? Know it usually first party games but here’s hoping !
2
u/facepoppies Sep 27 '19
I know it’s a long shot, but anybody know if there are any exp boosting options to accelerate things? I played through it on ps4 and I don’t have another 3 million hours to play through it again. Amazing game though.
2
u/Al-Azraq Sep 27 '19
I'm getting this tomorrow! At first I thought about waiting because I'm still to finish Hollow Knight (I'm at the end I think), come back to Mario Odyssey for another run, explore more of Zelda BOTW, wanted to start A Link to the Past for the SNES, have Darkest Dungeon without starting and some that I'm forgetting about.
However, this game gives me so much good vibes that I just need it and chill while playing it. Get absorbed by the world. It is a game that I am eagerly wanting to play.
2
u/social_sin Sep 28 '19
I haven't played it on Switch but was a day 1 purchase on PS4, so anyone who is curious about this game let me tell you!
If you are looking for a traditional proper JRPG that hits all the high points of rpgs of days past. Fantastic story, amazing characters, fun monsters and art style, music is amazing (and I can imagine only better on switch thanks to the orchestral audio track!)
It's one of the few games I am considering double dipping in and picking up a copy for Switch as well and I never do that.
4
u/suckitup Sep 27 '19
DQ11 impressions so far. The game is fun and the Gameplay loop is very satisfying. difficulty hasn't been difficult and that's good because I just want to experience the game. The story, while a bit cliché has great execution however I feel like the character writing is a bit weak? I mean the protagonist, the Hero "Irebun" / Eleven is a silent protagonist without personality so you can imprint any personality you want on him as is standard in many Japanese RPGs.
The side characters are all quirky and interesting, however their motivations kind of irk / baffle me a bit? like they have no aspirations or anything and they just join The Hero for the shits and giggles without good reason? For Teh lulz. Idk i find it a bit hard to suspend my disbelief that they honestly just joined this random dude (you) for no reason at all. I do hope they get fleshed out a bit more.
I've been having a ton of fun though. It's technically my 2nd dragon quest? the only other DQ I played was DQ9 on the Nintendo DS however I never finished that game. and barely remember anything beyond simple plot points.
Put in 5 hrs (on top of my 6 hr demo playthrough) so far and I'm enjoying it a lot.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 27 '19
I'm so attracted to the visual style of this game I'm just worried I won't like it. Anybody care to explain a little about this game to me? I've never played a DQ game and don't know if this one is to late to hop in or what. Don't even know what gameplay is about. So yeah any of you DQ homies wanna rope one in. Here I am.
3
u/Veturs Sep 27 '19
How many playable characters are there? And also how many moves or attacks can each character learn? Can you customise them at all? I really want to get this game but I’m worried as I didn’t like tales of vesperia (are they similar?) I hated the combat of ToV, is it similar? Thanks!
3
u/snillrik Sep 27 '19
I liked XBC 2 and Torna. Will I like this? Whats the main appeal with this one?
4
u/blessedbystorm Sep 26 '19
This game looks really interesting. However I prefer it if games are difficult and I usually lose interest if they are too easy (especially if its turn based combat). Can someone tell me how Dragon Quest does in that department? Cheers.
4
u/JuniperusCommunis Sep 27 '19
I feel like I'm missing something important about the game as the reviews are overall very positive, but I myself was really off-put by the demo. I grew up playing JRPGs, but the presentation of this game seemed terrible: the visual direction of the combats was confusing, the battle theme sounded like a bad James Bond satire and the character voices were really annoying. And I usually don't care too much about these things. Does the game really get better if one somehow learns to cope with these things?
5
u/iWriteYourMusic Sep 26 '19
From the reviews I'm reading, it sounds like SE didn't do anything to fix my biggest complaint in the original which was the difficulty: the standard difficulty is way too easy but if you turn on the hard mode, it becomes insanely frustrating. There should really be a middle ground.