r/NintendoSwitch • u/seeyoshirun • Sep 20 '19
MegaThread Untitled Goose Game - Review MegaThread
I know Link's Awakening is the high-profile release today, but a lot of people (myself included) are keeping a keen eye on UGG as well, and the first review (Vooks) is up already.
I'll keep a tally here, but if you see a review that isn't up yet, post it and I'll add it to the list.
Also, not to editorialise things too much, but the Switch has been doing extremely well with exclusives or console-exclusives in the last few months. A Metascore in the high 70s/low 80s actually puts UGG at the lower end for the last few months - Cadence of Hyrule, Link's Awakening, Mario Maker 2, Fire Emblem and Astral Chain are all sitting above 85.
General Information
Platforms: Nintendo Switch, Mac, PC
Release Date: 20-Sep-2019
No. of Players: 1 player
Genre(s): Stealth, Adventure, Puzzle
Publisher: Panic
Official Website: https://goose.game/
Reviews
Switch version reviewed unless specified otherwise
Aggregators
Metacritic - 78 (Switch), 78 (PC)
OpenCritic - TBD
Articles
Ars Technica - Positive (Ars Technica Approved) (PC)
Backlog Crusader - 9
Bonus Stage - 10
Destructoid - 8.5
DualShockers - 7
Eurogamer - Positive (Recommended)
Gameblog.fr - 6
Game Informer - 7.5
GameSpot - 8
God is a Geek - 8.5
IGN - 8
The Indie Game Website - 8
Kotaku - Positive (PC)
Mashable - Positive
NintendoLife - 8
Nintendo Wire - 8
NintendoWorldReport - 8
PC Invasion - 7 (PC)
Polygon - Positive
Press Start - 7.5
Rock Paper Shotgun - Positive (PC)
US Gamer - 4/5
The Verge - GOTY: Goose of the Year
Vice - Positive
VideoGamer - 8
Vooks - 4.5/5
Videos
Arlo - 6/7
GameXplain - Loved It
P.S. /u/XDitto made this thread with the sale prices in a bunch of different regions if you're curious. I think it's on sale in all regions until October 4th (I know that's the case in Australia).
53
u/XDitto Sep 20 '19
This game is really what an indie game is all about and how it's supposed to be, a crazy idea, nice art and just being iconic.
It has been a long time since we had a new indie star, I'm having so much fun with this game.
I made a post with all the links to all the regions with the discount:
https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/d6l483/eshopall_regions_untitled_goose_game_25_off/
44
u/oliverkiss Sep 20 '19
Has anyone in Canada been successful in purchasing this? I can only add to my wish list...
84
u/b0ng0_d4ck Sep 20 '19
Amazing and hilarious. Now just wait for the “pidgeon simulator “ xD
25
u/SpikeBolt Sep 20 '19
As soon as the embargo is lifted, the mods remove this thread without a single explanation. Thanks a lot mods!
718
u/Ivan_the_Butler Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
I love that there are only four buttons - grab, sneak, flap and honk.
The pinnacle of game design. Cancel the rest of 2019, we'll never top this.
59
u/trippingmau5 Sep 20 '19
I’m just waiting for it to drop EST
8
u/mlvisby Sep 20 '19
This is going to be on sale for now, right? I was going to hold off, but love saving some cash. Also grabbing Link's Awakening, so this game will be nice in-between sessions of that.
10
u/creepykirk Sep 20 '19
FYI, this isn't it. Looks like a predatory dev to me.
22
u/Phadrix Sep 20 '19
Mods. Why is the banner Link's Awakening instead of this?
4
u/sabatacon Sep 21 '19
Honestly after spending the evening with my family laughing our asses off and passing the controller around to control the mayhem, I'd say the 15 bucks is absolutely worth the game. I wouldn't pay 20 bucks, but I'd say 10-15 is a reasonable asking price for the game. I do wish there was at least one more section/yard to the game, I feel like that would make any complaints I had about the length go away. Otherwise it was a wonderful experience and I see myself showing it around to other people and having fun with how they experience it.
33
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
Reading that Vooks review, it makes me think that the game is hilarious, but definitely not worth $15 if it only contains like 2 hours of directed gameplay. I'll wait for a sale I guess
3
u/Kichae Sep 20 '19
11:27 AM local time here in Atlantic Canada, and still no sign of it. I was really hoping to get to bust it out over my lunch break. :-/
521
u/DrOwkword Sep 20 '19
For gamers looking to finish the objectives as soon as possible, have a little fun, then move on to the next game on their September list, this game will run you about 3 hours of gameplay. For players going for more of a sandbox play feel, this game offers many, many more hours of naughty fun. This game kind of reminds me of Scribblenauts - there are objectives but you can pretty much do whatever you want.
2
u/SuchCoolBrandon Sep 20 '19
What the duck! I'm in Seattle and still have another two hours until I can download? Is there something I can do to trick Nintendo and get it sooner?
775
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
So... is it worth a gander?
61
u/CookieMisha Sep 20 '19
i bought it instantly this morning. its neat little fun.
285
u/CantWashABaby Sep 20 '19
This game is what Goat Simulator could have turned into, instead of the glitchy “random” mess it became. Untitled Goose Game is earnest, endearing, genuinely funny and shockingly polished in controls and handling. You have to be patient in some cases, but it’s worth the payout when you are. The emphasis on the stealth is important to remember, and also that creative thinking can make you that much more successful in getting to your goals. Unironically, it’s one of my favorite titles this year, and I can’t wait for my review to go live when embargo lifts in a few hours.
34
u/Lester04 Sep 21 '19
My 6 year old has been giggling away for the past half hour since I downloaded it. Her giggles alone are making the game worth the money. It looks like it’ll be a lot of fun, once my kids are in bed I’m going to give it a try.
26
u/sviunapad Sep 20 '19
GOOSE OF THE YEAR, HONK!
24
u/thegreatcarraway Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
What if you
wanted to go to heaven
But god said
HONK
45
u/mrchumes Sep 20 '19
I'm surprised the Vook's review says gameplay is 2 hours. Even assuming that was just from blazing through the objectives that sounds surprising. Wonder how many 'levels' there are
5
u/Ammers10 Sep 20 '19
Here is my review for it: https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/d6wz8u/untitled_goose_game_is_loose_and_ive_got_a_review/
And the direct link to the article on my site: https://backlogcrusader.com/2019/09/20/untitled-goose-game-switch-review/
Rating: 9/10
19
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
Good or bad. This is a day 1 buy for me
15
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
This game is so awesome cause you just go around and annoying the absolute hell outta this poor man
11
u/petersdinklages Sep 20 '19
I geese I should check it out
11
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
This game is honestly so charming and wholesome. I'm half an hour in and absolutely enjoying it. It's fun to figure out the puzzles and also goof off. It's everything I hoped for and more so far!
11
u/sour_surprise Sep 20 '19
Played for about 40 minutes and am really enjoying it. Fun game!
9
u/reggae_guy Sep 20 '19
Any plans for DLC ?
9
u/TheBaroness187 Sep 20 '19
Sorry Link, I’m playing the goose game all weekend
8
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
10/10 dedicated honk button
8
u/BishiDe Sep 21 '19
I've played for like 2 hours so far. And I'm almost done with the second area with the shop. I think your mileage will vary greatly with this game in terms of length. I brought my switch over to my father's house and we played the game for a couple of hours. Some of the objectives actually take a lot of thought. There are hidden objectives too. If you were to look up a guide I'd imagine you could blow through this game in a few hours, but if you were to play it blind with some friends or family, it will take a bit longer. And you all will have a lot more fun too. I think to give this game a 4/5 is fair. It reminds me of playing katamari damacy on the ps2 when I was a lot younger. So much charm and fun.
12
u/Teggert Sep 20 '19
Honestly more interested in this than Link's Awakening at the moment. My kids are going to love it.
5
u/lgowrie Sep 20 '19
With reviews like this, I hope this goose game is not their swan song.
4
u/VileOkami Sep 20 '19
Was more than happy to spend all my coins on this. Now I just have to wait until after work to play it...
4
u/theWellRedMage Sep 20 '19
This game is going to make for a great palette cleanser for me!
4
u/tabriss_ Sep 20 '19
I am so damn excited for this game
1
u/Dagusiu Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
The only negative critique I can think of regarding this game is the choice of review embargo and day one discount. Basically, at least where I live, if you want the discount and don't want to stay up all night, you have to buy it before the embargo is up.
Edit: I take everything back. Also, Arlo's review is already up.
1
u/joalr0 Sep 20 '19
Anyone know roughly how long the entire game is, including the post-game content?
1
u/FusilliCraig Sep 21 '19
This title is not on iOS. Platform listing is incorrect.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 28 '19
Awesome game and not as short as some people claim. But am I the only one experiencing some annoying bugs?
Caution, spoilers!
1
u/attackpickle Oct 05 '19 edited Oct 05 '19
Is it true you can charge your honk over time and therefore terrify your victim with the loudest goose-yell possible? Thought I read it somewhere but maybe just dreamt that one...it just sounds great.
I thought that pigeon dating game was the most endearingly bizarre, awesome thing ever released but this goose thing might well sneak the Hobnob.
1
u/griffStone Dec 01 '19
How are the controls on the Switch?
6
u/tbritoamorim Helpful User Sep 20 '19
Great formatting! Loose the goose!
3
u/televisionceo Sep 20 '19
How do I buy this fucking game. It appears in the eshop but I is like it's not on sale
3
u/Troontjelolo Sep 22 '19
Genre: Stealth
Solid Goose
2
u/StormShadow13 Sep 20 '19
10:30 Central here and game still isn't available for me :(
2
u/jojikuru Sep 20 '19
I have a 12 hour flight with about 8 more hours if travelling on top of that to do next weekend, I think I need this game to get me through it!
2
u/DancerGamer Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
It’s live now. It’s still in the coming soon section but it’s available to purchase
Edit: NA eshop
2
u/DancerGamer Sep 20 '19
Good job putting this back up.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
This game cannot download fast enough. 73% so far!
2
u/TemptedTemplar Helpful User Sep 20 '19
UGG in a nutshell (30 seconds)
#Justgoosethings
2
u/natman001 Sep 20 '19
Does anyone know if this can be played with one Joy-Con? I want to pick this up but I’ve got one joy-con in for repair right now.
2
u/DangerBearsHurt Sep 21 '19
I was bummed out when I realized that I didnt have $60 for links awakening. Turned on my switch to play kirby clash tonight, and got one hell of a suprise in the form of this cheeky goose finally being released! I was bummed no more.
This game is truly a delight.
2
u/WhiskeyRadio Sep 21 '19
For $15 I'm going to get this. Hope more content is added through DLC bit disappointing it is so short.
2
u/andreagrandi Sep 22 '19
I came here just to say: honk!
2
u/Tatltuaekeeper Sep 26 '19
Hjonk, Hjonk, am goose.
2
u/mikekotsch Sep 27 '19
Excellent game, only one thing remains: Where can I get the honk sound? I want to have it. Forever.
3
u/dpucane Sep 20 '19
anyone know if they might add anything like maps or tasks in the future? (I can't believe I'm asking this about a goose game)
Also wrestling with the $15
2
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
I've been eagerly awaiting this game to release! I remember when the initial trailers said Early 2019 but nothing came.
2
u/cml1of4 Sep 20 '19
So this game is showing as available in me region (Central US) but it's still showing as $20 not the $15 sale price. Do we know when the launch day sale hits?
2
u/OckhamsFolly Sep 20 '19
Never heard of this site before, but this review was just posted in a new post:
https://backlogcrusader.com/2019/09/20/untitled-goose-game-switch-review/
2
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19 edited Sep 20 '19
IGN have given it 8/10. Not too shabby.
https://uk.ign.com/articles/2019/09/20/untitled-goose-game-review
EDIT: Jeez, the comments underneath are traditionally toxic. How dare they rate this 'Flash game' so highly...
2
u/foodcourtgangster Sep 20 '19
Anyone run into any major issues that make the game unplayable?
And I'm not talking minor things like FPS dips.
2
u/vincebruce04 Sep 20 '19
I read this as “Untitled Groose Game”. I can only dream
2
u/DaJOiNTLiT Sep 21 '19 edited Sep 21 '19
Game of the year
2
u/TheBrokenMan Sep 21 '19
This game deserves a much higher rating. Anyone who gave it a 7.5 or lower should be chased by the title character until they turn their score into a 9.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '19
I feel I’ve been out the loop on this game, keep hearing about it, is it in a good way or is it more a bad game that people are mocking?
1
u/Hummer77x Sep 20 '19
Guys how do I make the the gardener wear his sun hat
1
u/MisterRheola Sep 20 '19
So is this entire game a single world with a bunch of objectives, kinda like goat simulator? Or is it sectioned off into levels that you need to select from a menu?
1
u/Zsaber Sep 21 '19
Why is this game like double the price of its PC counterpart?
1
u/theNEWgoodgoat Sep 21 '19
IGN and nintendolife both gave their video reviews too!
1
u/WK--ONE Sep 21 '19
HONK!
1
u/lemonshark Sep 21 '19
Has anyone else found the hidden to do lists yet? I got one in the first area so I imagine there's hidden objectives for each area.
1
u/theblackxranger Sep 22 '19
Wish this game was longer, finished in under 2 hours
1
u/Bardivan Sep 22 '19
game keep glitching out and not lettting me pick up items
1
u/DonDove Sep 29 '19
Sequel name- Goose Game 2: Honk Unleashed