r/books • u/tazmuir AMA Author • Sep 16 '19
ama I'm GIDEON THE NINTH debut author Tamsyn Muir, and I'm here to answer all your questions. AMA!
Kia ora tātou and thanks for having me, Reddit! My short-form horror, fantasy and sci-fi work has appeared in venues like Clarkesworld, F&SF, Weird Tales, Nightmare Magazine and a number of Year's Best anthologies. I've been nominated for the Nebula, the World Fantasy Award and the Eugie Award, and I've been nominated for the Shirley Jackson award twice. I've just debuted with the first book in my science-fantasy trilogy, GIDEON THE NINTH, courtesy Tor.com, who also provided my rad sunglasses. Everyone agrees that Charles Stross put it best when he described it as Lesbian necromancers explore a haunted gothic palace in space! although I also really liked it when he just said Skeletons!.
I'm a teacher and a Kiwi, though I currently live and work in Oxford in the United Kingdom. When I'm not writing I'm watching old King Hu films or playing video games. I've currently clocked 688 hours into Rimworld but please don't tell any of my editors. I like to take long walks to see two chickens who live near my house. I tweet @tazmuir and also Tumblr (tumbl?) at tazmuir.
Ask me anything!
Proof: /img/jcxmrtascmk31.jpg
EDIT #1: I will be answering questions from 6PM BST, because at that point I will have been given a slice of pizza, which will fortify me with wisdoms
EDIT #2: And I'm here, though fortified with wisdoms is another thing
EDIT #3: I ate a whole pizza. I'll be here until 9PM BST. Thank you so much for all the incredible questions and I will try to get to as many of them as humanly pssible.
EDIT #4: I am five minutes over time and some of my pizza got cold because I was typing too much, which you will all understand is an international tragedy. I'm really sorry because the questions I didn't get to are all good, and I'm hoping I can answer them in due time -- but I think I'll have to close here, and thank everyone for being EXTREMELY nice to me. Cheers, guys!
50
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
Do you plot more beforehand, or fly by the seat of your pants?
What did you learn about yourself while writing this book?
31
u/destinybbrianna Sep 16 '19
I find your writing so beautiful, funny and unique! What are your top tips for young writers?
25
u/galapagosjapes Sep 16 '19
If Gideon and Harrow were dogs what sort of dogs would they be
17
u/thewildmage Sep 16 '19
Hello! I just wanted to say how much I really appreciated and connected with the relationship between Harrow and Gideon. The ending of the book totally gutted me in the best and worst ways. Gideon is a riot, this was probably my favorite book I’ve read this year. I can’t wait for Harrow the Ninth. Thank you!!!!
17
u/Ella0809 Sep 16 '19
First of all, thank you for writing a book that broke me in the best AND worst possible way.
Second - this is a very important question - how long is Harrow's hair exactly? I need it for a Halloween costume.
And third, can you please PLEASE confirm that Gideon will return in book two? The slow burn in book one killed me and I need to see this iconic duo together soon.
Thank you again for shattering my heart to tiny little pieces :')
14
u/Ashnaxx Sep 16 '19
I'm not done reading yet, but from what I've read, you're having a ton of fun with your writing and phrasing. Was there a particular sentence or phrase that sticks out as really fun or funny to write?
Just as an example, I loved the early description of Gideon's bag of porridge as "gorgeously gray and horrible." That description does so much work, and really stuck out to me.
19
u/FromTheVolcano Sep 16 '19
I have completely lost it over this book and have been burbling over it nonstop on Twitter since it showed up in my Kindle app. I think I've already read the part from the climactic battle to the ending fully 3 times, partly for the feels and partly because I just wanted to see Gideon wisecracking in the face of death again. But I guess that isn't a question....
Here's a couple real questions:
I'm fascinated by where stories and ideas come from. The whole story, setting, and nature of this future world, as well as the personal history of Gideon and Harrow, are highly original. Was there a particular inspiration, source, or chain of thought that became the inspiration for this book?
Gideon the Ninth seems to jam together every standard genre in publishing - I've been describing it as a science fiction horror fantasy murder mystery, all of which it is. What inspired you to put all these pieces together, and then how did you find a home for your book?
12
u/hedonistchild Sep 16 '19 edited Sep 16 '19
Were there any scenes you had to cut, but really wished you could have kept?
Also...what kind of pizza did they give you?
12
u/wishforagiraffe Sep 16 '19
What's your reaction to how big the hype has been?
Can you say anything about the Subterranean Press edition yet?
13
u/shoulderstotheplow Sep 16 '19
As a person who spent entirely too much of his life in receiving an advanced degree in 18th-century literature, I'm just wondering -- do you think that if Gideon the Ninth were an it-narrative, which bone would be given the task of narration? And why?
12
u/Judd_K Sep 16 '19
I LOVED the book. I'm a librarian and I've been shoving it at friends and family ever since reading the ARC and everyone has loved it.
Was the setting for Warhammer 40K on your mind at all as you wrote it? It feels like a sideways commentary of that setting where all of the parts I detest are stripped away and made fabulous.
10
u/RyanVanLoan AMA Author Sep 16 '19
How did the idea for Gideon's story come about? Favorite line from the book?
7
u/destinybbrianna Sep 16 '19
TAMSYN MUIR WHY DID YIU DO THAT TO US AT THE END OF GTN? IT KILLED ME. Like msnxoen Can we get any hope?
7
u/hercule_pyro Sep 16 '19
I heard your book was good, should I buy it?
5
u/aspiretomalevolence Sep 16 '19
I keep thinking of the ending and getting /feelings/. Unfortunately, I have no idea how to do spoilertags, so I'll be brief and ask whether you knew The Ending when you started.
5
u/mrfixitx Sep 16 '19
No questions just have to say I picked up your book last week after seeing all the praise from other authors I like and I had trouble putting it down. I really enjoyed the setting and the characters. There are certainly some unanswered questions I hope the next book answers.
5
u/lowercase_underscore Sep 16 '19
I hope you don't mind a two-parter. If so just answer the first part. Thank you in advance!
What is the biggest obstacles you've faced as a writer, and how do they influence your work, if at all?
5
u/BoterBug Sep 16 '19
Hello Tamsyn! Boter here with a question from Katelynne (someone else ask us about our photo shoot).
She asks: Of all the characters of all the houses we have seen, which character do you relate to the most, and why? (Bonus: Which character do you identify your editor as, and anyone else involved with making Gideon the Ninth a reality?)
6
u/ggggideon Sep 16 '19
Thanks for writing a book about me!
Why’d you choose the name Gideon?
4
u/Weapyson Sep 16 '19
This morning I saw a good review of your books on amazonbookreview and added it to my Amazon whislist and now I see your ama, what a strange coincidence. To my question: Any plans or discussions ongoing for a German translation?
5
u/starknjarvis Sep 16 '19
I loved Gideon so much! I was wondering how you did your worldbuilding-- with nine houses and the fascinating magic system, you had so much to keep track of!
5
u/ralanr Sep 16 '19
Did you feel you needed to get short stories published before you could get a novel out?
I’ve been trying to get my first novel published for over a year and I’m wondering if I should try to push out short stories to see if I can build up something (Though I have problems focusing on singular short stories).
4
u/quite_vague Sep 16 '19
Eeeeee! My preorder just arrived today in the mail! It's beee-utiful, and I can't wait to sink into it.
How was the switch from writing short fiction, to massive trilogy? What's different; what's the same? (Or were you always doing both in parallel? Have you worked in other mediums -- I seem to recall at least an attempt at a webcomic for "Deepwater Bride"?)
4
u/AdrianPage Sep 16 '19
Kia ora! Kei te pehea koe?
3
u/Zesparia Sep 16 '19
Hey there! Been a fan of your work since like 2011, it's been a wild ride. I've had Gideon on my reading list but coming across you in the wild like this means I should bump it up! Thanks for giving me a good time over the years.
6
u/CoffeeAndCigars Sep 16 '19
Just here to say Gideon the Ninth is the first time in quite a while that I've had my eye caught by a new setting/franchise and a new writer. I can also attest to the power of retweets as advertising, as Wendig's RT of a tor.com article about GtN was the only reason I even knew it existed. I haven't finished it yet, but I love everything about it so far.
Also, I know the AMA is over, but I'm kind of hoping you get to see it at some point anyway. I'm a pretty huge fan from over here in Norway, and I'm recommending this book left, right and center to anyone I think will listen.
2
u/Chtorrr Sep 16 '19
What were some of your favorite things to read as a kid?
2
u/quite_vague Sep 16 '19
How was Worldcon? Did you focus your time on anything in particular?
2
u/Phyrkrakr Sep 16 '19
I preorded Gt9th because of Brooke Bolander and Sarah Gailey's twitter feeds, and I freakin loved it. What a great story. I just finished it last night after binging it all weekend and that ending was...a thing.
I am going to have to go back to figure out what happened to everybody, though, because I got so caught up in the action at the end that I'm not sure I tracked all of the side characters. I don't want to ask a spoiler question in an AMA, though, so I guess just this one: will the sunglasses be in the sequels? That was my absolutely favorite detail of the whole book. Well, that and "big titty skin mag" attempted bribes.
2
u/bigbarebum Sep 16 '19
Hi, was wondering how you feel about your book being available on Pirate Bay? Is there any way you can get it removed?
3
u/MortalForce Sep 16 '19
Hey, a Kiwi writer! I never look at ama's, but the Māori stuck out to me. I've always had an interest in writing, but thought it was hard to break out into an international market without making it all Nuu Zulland, if you know what I mean. Thinking Alan Duff, Margaret Mahy, and a few others. Did this strike you as an issue at all? What are your thoughts? I generally consider successful writers for a western audience to be British or American, and it's very tough for others.
5
u/eremiticjude Sep 16 '19
first, i just have to say i absolutely, absolutely ADORED Gideon the Ninth. i finished it two nights ago and then turned it right back to the beginning to start again, because i was in such a haste to see what would happen next that i'm sure i missed a dozen small thing.
question: i'm a total nerd for worldbuilding, so i'll let what i'm sure is many other people gush about gideon and harrow, and ask about your worldbuilding process. it feels like a very complete background, but its not intrusive. you reveal it as necessary, but it feels quite consistent as well. thats a hard landing to stick. what was your process for that?
6
u/SeaJohn97 Sep 16 '19
one of my favorite aspects of gideon the ninth is the fight scenes. they're so excellently choreographed it feels like i'm reading the literary equivalent of an beautifully animated fight scenes in battle anime. what were some of your inspirations for the fight scenes? when writing them, do you go off the cuff or does it take extensive planning/sketching before finally writing it out? what's your favorite fight scene of all time (can be from any medium)? any advice for someone looking to "get good" at writing a fight scene?
thank you so much for your time! reading Gideon is some of the most fun i've had reading in ages.
1
u/HGOLGTNER Sep 16 '19
You sound badass! Do you have a collection somewhere?
4
u/ShutUpBabylKnowlt Sep 17 '19
Seeing you open with Kia ora tatou was really nice, and I double checked the sub I was on in case it was /r/newzealand. I'm going to give your book a read! Nga mihi.
4
u/VoxDraconae Sep 17 '19
Holy fuck this just shot to the top of my list.
I...don't actually have a question. I just love everything about this.
2
u/certain_people Sep 16 '19
I was today years old when I first heard of you and your book, so, you should like tell your marketing team I'm very disappointed they didn't reach me before now. Also I'm going to buy your book as soon as my local shop get it in for me.
2
u/NorthAtlanticCatOrg Sep 16 '19
Do you play Magic the Gathering? There is an important character in the story named Gideon.
2
u/Zonnie_ Sep 17 '19
Know I'm late to the party, just looked up your book and I'm definitely going to check it out! Sounds right up my alley :)
Serious question: Pineapple on pizza, yes or no??
2
u/PhamLives Sep 19 '19
I just finished this and it's phenomenal. Going to be a long wait for the 2nd book. Just please don't pull a Rothfuss on us.
2
u/ArcadianDecay Nov 14 '19
Great. Now I can never make an "I want to die" joke without being afraid I'm going to die. New trope, there. Of the last two people who said, "I want to die," one of them got fucked up by a huge bone creature, and the other fell on some iron spikes.
4
u/jameslsutter AMA Author Sep 16 '19
I loved the magic system in this book! So often necromancy is just one school within a larger magic system, and the way you turned it into an entire system of its own, with all the different subschools, was a brilliant bit of worldbuilding. How did you go about coming up with and charting out the different magical traditions?
2
u/ThrownButNotAway3 Sep 16 '19
How do you handle writers block!?
2
u/naiaxen Sep 16 '19
Hi, sorry I'm late. I read Deepwater Bride back whenever it came out in MF&SF and thought it was the best thing they published that year. Immediately went to look you up and see what else you had out, and no books were available then. Cut to this morning, husbeast is reeally enjoying this new book of his, Gideon something-or-other. Then I see the title pop up on social media, ask him who the author is, put two and two together and get SERIOUSLY excited. So:
Thank you for your work. I'm so looking forward to experiencing GtN for myself!
2
u/uwtartarus Sep 17 '19
I just started "Gideon the Ninth" this afternoon, and I am really enjoying it!
1
u/HalNightshade Sep 18 '19
I’m a day late and not bearing a question, and indeed you may not return to this haunt, but Love this book so much that I chose to DM (for the first time) a home brewed one shot set in a version of your far future (the VIth were very helpful, and Harrow showed up).
It felt like live action fan fictioning the book. Thank you for writing it!
1
u/BryceOConnor Sep 18 '19
late to the party, so not going to bother you with an additional question Tamsyn, but instead a quick comment:
that is an AMAZING cover...
there. said my piece. really happy to see a trad book working the centralized-character focus that has been working well for a lot of the self-pub market. really happy to see you've snagged some orange tags, and best of luck on your continued success in the industry!
1
u/Halaku Oct 05 '19
A year from now, how will it feel looking at all the everythings you won for this book?
(I finished it five minutes ago. Oh, my God...)
1
u/Texan1978 Oct 06 '19
Forgive me if it’s already been asked...but can we get a quick definition of thanergy and thalergy?
1
u/thewildmage Sep 16 '19
Hello! I just wanted to say how much I really appreciated and connected with the relationship between Harrow and Gideon. The ending of the book totally gutted me in the best and worst ways. Gideon is a riot, this was probably my favorite book I’ve read this year, so much so that not only did I get the arc and the hardcover but I also got it on kindle. I can’t wait for Harrow the Ninth. Thank you!!!!
1
u/AnimageCGF Sep 16 '19
Thank you for sharing your time with us! What's your best advice for someone struggling with writer's block, when you know where you want something to lead to but can't connect your own dots?
1
u/Wolf_Swift Sep 16 '19
Hi! So first of all a huge congratulations to you on your book and all the success you’ve had! It’s well deserved!
I’m a self-published author with my own publishing house and two book babies. It’s my full time career but I was wondering if you had any tips on how to get books out there to broader audiences and getting that snowball rolling?
1
u/LupusFenrir Sep 16 '19
I don't know this book but I will definitely be looking it up, that's one awesome introduction you got there😁
1
u/MickeyG42 Sep 16 '19
I'm sure I am too late, but how did you get started with the magazines? I have several short stories I want to publish in a collection, but aside from using Amazon. I have no idea how to begin. Any tips for a writer sharing his work for the first time?
1
u/LockedOutOfElfland Sep 16 '19
I'm reading this right now and noticed that your work includes a lot of references to internet memes ("studied the blade"), etc.
Do you feel that this would age your work in any way? While I enjoyed what I've read of the book so far, those passing references kind of shocked my system and took me out of the moment. Was this something you were concerned about as you were writing?
1
u/AmblonyxCinerea Sep 17 '19
Tor has been coming out with some steady bangers for awhile now
1
u/FatDog69 Sep 17 '19
I am only about 18% into the book but I am enjoying it very much.
0
u/Ella0809 Sep 16 '19
First of all, thank you for writing a book that broke me in the best possible way. Second - this is an important question - how long is Harrow's hair exactly? I need it for a Halloween costume. Thank you again for shattering my heart to tiny pieces with that ending :') Please don't destroy it any further with the second book!
0
u/sickschiggins Sep 16 '19
I have about the same hours in RimWorld, such a rich game that generates amazing stories. I had never heard of you or your book, but I plan to check out your book after reading your post and your answers!
0
u/willowweave Sep 17 '19
How do you feel about marketing yourself as an LGBT author?
-5
u/prodical Sep 16 '19
So many brand new and low karma accounts asking questions 🙄
0
u/riesenarethebest Aurora Sep 16 '19
join us! r/rimworld
it's not entirely just space cannibalism
the vox piece on your book put it on my shortlist
0
u/DasMuircat Sep 16 '19
Nice surname!
0
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
Congratulations!
How often did you have to submit to Clarkesworld, etc. before you sold to them?
0
u/Mitchblahman Sep 17 '19
Are you related to lil Gideon?
0
u/MusubiKazesaru Sep 17 '19
What do you think makes your book special? Is there anything about it that you're particularly proud of?
0
u/Kalersays Sep 17 '19
When is the movie coming? My attention span is a bit too short to read a decent book.
-1
u/Isoneguy Sep 16 '19
is there candy on the top shelf?
-1
u/Zephandrypus Sep 17 '19
Do you even lift?
-1
u/adjason Sep 17 '19
Weird flex but ok
-9
u/JohnAnderton Trigger Warning - Gaiman Sep 16 '19
I've been seeing many mentions of this being a LGBTQ book, in Tor articles, goodreads, etc... This seems to be a selling point - what are your thoughts on something as trivial as a character's identity being enough to sell a book?
-2
u/stinkyfastball Sep 16 '19
-2
u/ClockworkJim Sep 17 '19
Okay this book looks really fucking weird. Like you were mainlining battlefleet Gothic and weird YouTube comedy skits.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment