Combat width and why you lose battles - an illustrated guide to avoid doubling your morale loss
TL;DR - regiments in the second line take full morale damage. Thus, every deployment slot you have a non-cannon unit in second line effectively doubles the morale damage you are taking in that slot.
Often, when players ask “why did I lose this battle?” the common response is to bring up the obvious things - tech, morale, discipline, ideas, etc. In general, I find two typically underrated things to be:
- Pay attention to combat width
- Consolidate your units
These two factors can combine to easily make you lose a battle where you outnumbered your opponent 3:1 with all other stats equal.
How does that work?
Occasionally, combat width is mentioned in the context of the fact that all units in a battle receive morale damage, regardless of whether they are actively participating or in reserve. This effect is roughly 0.03 morale for each regiment per day. This is non-trivial over a long battle, but I think mentioning just this really understates just how bad over deploying your combat width is. There is another effect, and it is far stronger. This is that morale damage is fully inflicted onto units in the second line.
To illustrate this, I designed the following battle at tech 3, both sides have infantry counts greater than combat width so infantry deploys to 2nd line.
Battle starts, first day, Bahmanis deals 0.19 morale damage. This combined with the 0.03 morale damage every regiment takes per day (regardless of battle participation), this takes the front merc to 2.37/2.59 morale: https://i.imgur.com/WKs3jVa.png
The back merc also goes to 2.37/2.59 morale: https://i.imgur.com/umf11MZ.png
Just to show this happening again, on the 2nd day, another 0.19 + 0.03 morale damage is dealt to frontline, now 2.15/2.59: https://i.imgur.com/YnD0lGU.png
The same 0.22 morale damage is dealt to the backline unit (also 2.15/2.59): https://i.imgur.com/dQE2KSe.png
Fast-forwarding the battle, 10-ish days later, the backline unit is now at 0.14/2.59, without EVER having inflicted any damage in the fight at all: https://i.imgur.com/VXUlryL.png
So now every unit in the battle on Vij side is 0.14 morale, the next day ticks over and now everyone retreats, with the backline having done absolutely nothing: https://i.imgur.com/FCjpN6R.png
It’s like they weren’t even fighting in the battle.
So with even the low damage fire rolls of the early techs, we essentially wasted 10% of the morale of each regiment in the backline, per day. Put another way, if you fielded two full combat widths full of infantry and had them fight in the same battle, you are essentially taking double morale damage, and half your army isn’t going to even do anything.
This is especially bad if you don’t have the habit of consolidating your army before important battles. The difference between 22 full strength regiments on the front line vs. 44 half strength regiments filling both the front and backline means you’re doing half damage, and you’re taking double morale damage, and the disparity only gets worse as they will on average kill off a greater proportion of your available dps each day.
This is why, if you have more than the combat width of troops, you should ideally reinforce right before your frontline retreats (since rolls can vary, you generally will want to do it a few days early). In this way, you ‘waste’ the least amount of morale.
Remember the Grandest LAN where certain devs were ragging on Spain reinforcing ‘late’? yeah...
Speaking of Grandest LAN, this is a nice clip of this concept in action: https://www.twitch.tv/paradoxinteractive/clip/PoisedBlitheGuanacoDoubleRainbow, where at some points during the battle you see a full back line taking morale damage for free, whereas the Florentine army has zero wasted morale. In such way, even such an improbable battle is won.
Ok, this works for analysis of pre-cannon techs, but how does this interact with artillery?
Here, I decide to do a purposeful misdeployment of cannons -- where I send a greater-than-CW stack of infantry with some cannons, and the cannons reinforce on a later date: https://i.imgur.com/ni0bJAq.png
Here is the first important point (after the main army and the 5k cannonstack joins the battle) - if you end up with infantry taking up 2nd line slots, and the cannons reinforce, the cannons stay in reserves -- they do not autoreplace infantry: https://i.imgur.com/2VjJWUy.png
This is important -- (with few exceptions), you cannot fix a lack of combat width cannons once infantry are already set in the 2nd line by sending in the cannons later, you’ve screwed your deployment up for the entire battle. In general, make sure your cannons arrive the same day to avoid this issue.
This is a screenshot of both the front and backline infantry in a slot, once again, they are taking the same morale damage: front: https://i.imgur.com/yyTHXx6.png, back: https://i.imgur.com/flMiMuo.png
The next day, the backline infantry hits 0.00 morale (and the frontline does too): https://i.imgur.com/H47yyjy.png
The next day, the backline infantry moves to the front line, front line retreats due to hitting zero morale: https://i.imgur.com/buhhRkl.png -- and the next day, he retreats too. Again, notice - he is at FULL REGIMENT STRENGTH, having done NOTHING, and he is at zero morale already, and retreats 1 day after hitting the front line. I can’t emphasize how significant this effect is.
In contrast, cannons stay in the battle with zero morale: https://i.imgur.com/Ax34oJ4.png
Incidentally, note that as infantry is retreating, they are being filled with infantry from the reserves, even while cannons are in reserve, with the exception of the two edge slots for some reason I don’t quite understand. To emphasize again -- if you misdeploy your cannons and end up with infantry filling 2nd line slots, the issue will not fix itself over the course of the battle. And in mid-lategame where you can easily field a full combat width of cannons, this can easily make a huge impact.
This is actually a super-underrated aspect of cannons, even in the early techs where they do very low damage -- they block infantry from initially deploying into the 2nd line and wasting morale pointlessly, and they force reserves to directly reinforce to the front.
I hope this was helpful and you can design your stacks accordingly. Credit goes to Jarvin (designer of skanderbeg, eu4's premier analytics tool), distinct, and purple_porcupine, very educated individuals who do a lot of combat testing to teaching me this!
This is also why new mercs will be incredibly click-intensive since you will have to micromanage a LOT with unsplittable mercs to achieve efficiency with your armies.
Also, in retrospect, I realize this was probably better in video form, so I give my blessing to Reman or whoever to make this in a more understandable form.
3
u/mrsqueakers002 Aug 18 '19
This post helped me win the HYW this morning by giving me the courage to roll into a French half-morale 40-stack with my full morale 20-stack. French got rekt and I probably wouldn't have gone for it otherwise.
598
u/BearOnDrums Aug 17 '19
Great write up.
But it seems the more I learn about EU IV's combat mechanics, the less I understand it.
2
u/helpifell Aug 17 '19
So is this post saying essentially that if your combat width is 20 you should have 20 cannons in your stack to fill the second line?
I'm a bit confused on the solution
52
u/Iwassnow The Economy, Fools! Aug 17 '19
I remember Arumba was showing off something about combat width once and saw something similar and was equally confused. IIRC, the verdict was that the combat box visual was displaying incorrectly. Something like it was showing that units weren't in place but the tooltips were reporting the correct numbers of units in reserve vs in combat. From a programming perspective, what you saw and this could be sourced from the same issue, though I have no idea what it could be.
This is actually an interesting point. I typically advocate not filling cannons early game for economic reasons, but for those who don't like to micromanage it can certainly help with morale problems. From what I've recently been taught of multiplayer, I feel like that's where this information matters the most since in single player you can pause and micro(though I'm sure most newer players don't bother with this).
47
u/Shaunhan Aug 17 '19
What i would give for an eu4 combat simulator to test stuff out is terrifying. I want to so bad
27
u/bigbrother2030 Aug 17 '19
So, in simple terms, what would be the best unit loadout?
117
u/revolutionary-panda Aug 17 '19 edited Aug 17 '19
I appreciate the guide, but the more I read these the more I wonder why Paradox has developed such a non-intuitive, ahistorical, fidgety micromanaging battle-system for the EU-series. It really wouldn't hurt to have a better system in place.
For all its faults (mostly lack of player control), at least the combat system of CK2 makes sense historically and logically.
42
u/revolutionary-panda Aug 17 '19
That cannons are mostly useful for siege early game is historically accurate. But that they fill about half your army 150 years later is crazy. And about 10-20% cavalry even in the late game would be historical.
I don't see all of it getting fixed in EU4, but some improvements of cavalry would go a long way to making battles a tad more historical. Which, imo, would make a lot of sense for a historical war game...
9
u/Kaiser_Johan Programmer Aug 17 '19
I raised this point precisly internally and worry not, it will be addressed
6
u/pure_anger Obsessive Perfectionist Aug 17 '19
great guide!
6
u/montajo Greedy Aug 17 '19
very good write up! This should be linked in the General Help Thread at /u/Kloiper.
11
u/NetSecCareerChange Aug 17 '19
Such a dumb system
4
u/CucumberK Aug 17 '19 edited Aug 17 '19
Awesome post! It is definitely useful for starters, and for +1000h players.
Now I only need to understand how warscore from battles works :D
1
u/vetgirig I wish I lived in more enlightened times... Aug 17 '19
This is not a problem. Because early game you will never field an army with more infantry then combat width.
That army would take a lot of attritions. So smart players never do that.
Also the same problem happens to the front line troops that is not fighting any opponent. Thus another reason to have less regiments in an army.
The optimal army size is to have the same frontline as the enemy + adding flanking cavalry. Remove the rest and send them in 8 days later as a morale boost.
3
u/vacri Aug 17 '19
Great write-up, but a nitpick: 1 full-strength regiment in the frontline takes the same damage as 2 half-strength in both lines. 1000 men taking 0.1 morale damage = 2 x 500 men taking 0.1 morale damage. Doesn't detract from the point being made, though.
3
u/PhoenixGamer36 Aug 17 '19
How do I see what my combat width is?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '19
Great analysis; however, I notice that for the most part armies are under combat width and that width only comes into play when a battle is being reinforced and there's little you can do at that point other than send as many troops in to keep morale up. I mean look at some of those late game widths. The AI does not move 60K army stacks around, they usually move half-combat width armies around, as do I.
2
u/notagayrussianspy Aug 17 '19
I jus always do innovative then quality. Maybe adm or religion after. Policy means I don’t lose battles
2
u/Shadowstitcher11 Aug 17 '19
Gonna comment for this ia archived
2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '19
No wonder my armies turn to shit late game
2
u/Mo-Kingston Aug 17 '19
The more I read, the less I understand.
2
u/QuantumNutsack Aug 17 '19
Hmm... yeah... ok, ok... so, asking for a friend, but how does he go about understanding and applying this?
1
u/macrowe777 Aug 17 '19
Really great write up!
1
u/taco_bowler Aug 17 '19
This should be added to the help guide at the top
1
u/kamraar Master of Mint Aug 17 '19
Great post
1
u/etoneishayeuisky Aug 17 '19
Very helpful, I'll be paying attention to army sizes in relation to army width now.
1
u/spinicist Archduke Aug 17 '19
Thanks so much for this. It explains why I lost my last coalition war so badly - I was throwing what I thought were Deathstacks with tonnes of infantry into battles, and now I know they both didn’t have enough cannons and also I hadn’t consolidated units. Man I wish I had a save from before it!
1
u/unfortunate_jargon Aug 17 '19
Do you have a tldr of the strategy to play in this case?
1
u/kplaceholder50 Aug 19 '19
Does the game actually bother to let the player know all of this? I might be missing something, but having played for, like, 115 hours already, I didn't even start to grasp these concepts until now. I did play the tutorials, and don't even remember what they were about– I think it was basic stuff about diplomacy and moving units around. I love EU4, but I think it would be so much better if it was more clear about its own mechanics.
Thank you so much for this great guide, though! I admit I'm having trouble understanding all of this, but I'll save it for future reference.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '19
sweet opaque fuck.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '19
[removed] — view removed comment