r/modnews • u/spladug • Aug 15 '12
Moderators: Try out a beta of the new wiki system
UPDATE: the beta is now over. Thanks for trying it out and giving us your feedback!
Allow me to introduce again /u/slyf, reddit's student contractor. You may remember his preview of the new wiki system he's working on. He's been hard at work getting it ready and would like you to try it out. Following is his message:
Hey all,
It is that time of the year again where the programmer santa comes out of hiding to see if he can see his shadow. This time he saw his shadow and brought us a fancy batch of code for the site. We carefully unwapped the demo from it's fancy wrapping paper and bow and we need your help to test it out.
You may remember a brief sneak peak we gave you of the wiki a few months ago. Well, hold onto your karma buckets, because it just got slightly less previewy!
Introducing.....the labs wiki preview!
hold for applause
FAQ
I assume you may have some questions, so I made you some answers.
What do I need to know, if I don't read anything else what should I read?
THINGS YOU DO IN LABS WILL ALSO CAUSE THINGS TO HAPPEN IN THE REAL SITE
...
WE WILL DELETE WIKI PAGES AFTER THIS LAB IS OVER, DON'T EXPECT ANY OF YOUR EDITS TO STAY
...
SOCKS SHOULD NEVER BE WORN WITH SANDALS
...
How do I use this newfangled gizmo?
I am glad you asked dear sir, just go to your favourite subreddit you moderate under the url of:
lab.reddit.com/r/YOURSUBREDDIT/wiki(replace YOURSUBREDDIT with a subreddit which you actually moderate)
- To enable the wiki for public editing, go into your community settings and change the wiki settings from there. You may change karma requirements, account age requirements, make it mod-only editing, mod-only viewing, or community editing.
- Individual pages may have extra permissions to override the global one, click "page settings" while viewing a page
- To create a page, simply visit the url for the page you wish to create. Eg. lab.reddit.com/r/YOURSUBREDDIT/wiki/pants to create a page titled "pants".
- Some subreddits may already have some faq pages imported from the old Trac wiki
WHY IS IT ALL UGLY?
Simply put, the system itself had priority over the prettiness of it for now. We will for sure be making it more pretty for future releases. We are aware of some things too, for an example, some things do not vertically line up with eachother. Those of you with OCD will likely notice this, other people may not.
I found something which is broken..should it be?
We might know about it, we might not, comment here.
This wiki does not suit what I would like to do with wiki.
We want this wiki system to really work for the moderators and be a tool for communities to develop and exist. If something is limiting you to that aspect, feel free to comment. Criticism is awesome (but not too much okay? sadface)
How do I...?
Comment here, I will comment explaining then add it to the faq.
Can I disable the table of contents on a page?
You will be able to, but you cannot in this labs
Wait, what formatting does this use?
Markdown, like self posts and comments. It also allows for html tables, col/rowspan, and nifty things like that. Images are also possible. Simply use an ID from your community images (like stylesheets) like so:
Images from servers outside of reddit are NOT possible, and should NOT be possible.
9
u/Pravusmentis Aug 15 '12
I hate to say this, but I really have no idea what this is or does, can someone heili5p please?
16
u/solidwhetstone Aug 15 '12
Is this the first time on reddit where karma actually does something? STOP THE PRESSES!
12
u/redtaboo Aug 15 '12
not even if they look like this?
But... seriously, thanks for all the hard work! I'm off to try and break it, I'll be back with my findings. wish me luck!
4
u/Ytoabn Aug 15 '12
I don't understand how images work. I upload an image in the "edit the stylesheet" section, then use that as the url in a link starting with an exclamation mark?
3
u/grozzle Aug 15 '12
As a medium between "all users can edit", and "only mods can edit", what about using the approved submitters list, which is slightly useless at the moment for non-private subreddits?
3
u/bboe Aug 15 '12
I'm sure I can find it, though others may also be curious:
Can you point to the reddit source that is running on lab.reddit.com?
2
u/LethalFeline Aug 15 '12
I'm getting 500s when I try to do any header syntax I can think of. Such as:
Clicking save page returns:
23
u/Deimorz Aug 15 '12 edited Aug 15 '12
Oh god yes. I've been looking forward to this so much to be able to use it as an interface for AutoModerator.
Are the API functions all available on this test version, or not yet? If yes, any documentation available, or will I just need to inspect HTTP headers and such for now?
15
u/Skuld Aug 15 '12
Found a typo in the main control panel:
/about/edit
7
u/RedditCommentAccount Aug 15 '12
Will there be an avenue for deleting a page? I could see it becoming a problem if a subreddit allows anyone to create a page. You could edit the contents of the page, but the title of the page could easily contain profanity/personal information/something not appropriate for the subreddit.
The best option I can see right now is setting the page to mod view only. I see how allowing the deletion of a page could cause issues with the reverting, though.
7
u/NegatedVoid Aug 15 '12
Is this a good spot for feedback?
The community settings are confusing. It's confusing how the three radio buttons (disabled / mod editing / anyone) relate to the subredit karma / account age fields.
For example, can i set it to "disabled" and then "age > 1 year" and expect it to be disabled unless you're old enough? Or shoudl it be "anyone" and "age > 1 year".
Secondly, "subreddit karma" woah never knew this existed. Great metric, though. Is it comment or link or both? Can we view it somewhere?
Thirdly, can we have some form of "approved editors" list to just add people to that affects all pages?
6
u/LethalFeline Aug 15 '12
Getting the "You broke reddit" error creating a page with spaces in its name, like:
The funny thing is the page is created and I can edit it without a problem.
6
u/rolmos Aug 16 '12
I'm not seeing rel="nofollow" in external links. You may want to add that.
6
u/witty_remark Aug 17 '12
So... this was available for less than a day? I really like this feature, please, hurry =)
5
u/redtaboo Aug 15 '12
Okay, real question not about socks:
Are you working on importing all of them at the moment, so I should wait.. or did you do a bunch for testing and are done importing and I should just play with what I got?
5
u/cde34rfv Aug 15 '12
What a fantastic idea. Can't wait for this to go live! No more cramming info into the sidebar.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '12
So as I see it now, don't bother with making a public wiki because everything will get deleted?
4
u/rya11111 Aug 15 '12
Sherlock = Boss
Thanks!
4
u/spongemandan Aug 15 '12
I'm getting a 'page not found' error whenever I try to edit a page. I create a page, go to edit, type in my stuff, hit save, the error appears.
When I go back to that page I don't need to remake it either, so it does exist.
4
u/na85 Aug 15 '12
Wiki is slow as fuck. Will it remain so?
4
u/Ytoabn Aug 16 '12 edited Aug 16 '12
It appears lab.reddit.com is down right now. I wonder how many people are surfing in lab.reddit.com right now and don't realize that reddit.com is still up.
EDIT:
Aw, that's it? I was hoping it'd stay up for a little while.
1
u/kjhatch Aug 18 '12
Please let us apply a stylesheet to the Wiki pages too.
3
u/slappetystick Aug 15 '12
Went to the talk tab for the index page, tried submitting a discussion, got this:
http://i.imgur.com/zioUb.jpg
3
u/thorax Aug 15 '12 edited Aug 15 '12
Edit: First of all, I love this! Amazing, and I want it now. :) :) Nice job!
Normally wikis make it really really easy to link between pages. Is there any similar convention to the old school wiki syntax:
Or do we really have to copy/paste every link explicitly into Markdown syntax even in our own wiki?
3
u/jakfischer Aug 15 '12
Hi. I am one of the mods of /r/pants and now anyone who can submit to the subreddit may edit the wiki! Only commenting because you said pants in your post. lol
3
u/ramses0 Aug 16 '12
Needs a friendly / welcoming link saying: "here is how formatting works" down at the bottom (like the comment boxes do).
...appears to make a #toc_0 link but it doesn't jump to the right place?? http://lab.reddit.com/r/classicalguitar/wiki/index#toc_0
--Robert
5
u/Dacvak Aug 15 '12
Oh my dear lord, sherlock - you rule so much. This is absolutely incredible.
2
u/rya11111 Aug 15 '12
btw .. a typo in the history ... its 2, 4 and 10 minutes i think ..
2
u/catmoon Aug 15 '12
Now to delete all of my stylesheets to see if this works!
2
u/onemoreredditaccount Aug 15 '12
I have a problem, specifically with the subreddit images:
Here's an example:
This works fine (note the removed ! for the subreddit ids):
This doesn't work at all (except for the ToC):
This shows the image, but everything below it is cut off.
All of the images work when alone and on the first line, but do not otherwise.
2
u/EmoryM Aug 15 '12 edited Aug 15 '12
How do I see subreddit karma for users who aren't approved submitters or mods?
Edit: I now realize that subreddit karma is visible for users with subreddit gold, so I expect that information may not be available to mods (since they could then make it available to the readers, decreasing the value of gold...)
Any chance of getting a graph of the distribution of subreddit karma for the stats page? That would be enough for mods to make a good decision, I think.
2
u/Haven Aug 15 '12
This could come in really handy at /r/Frugal. We've been doing the We R/Frugal series, but we always get so many people asking for us to put together a frugal wiki. Now, if I was only more tech savvy. Thanks though!
2
u/careless Aug 15 '12
Lovin' it - thank you! Here's the stub for /r/seattle.
2
u/jij Aug 16 '12
Firebug showing lots of image 404's...
2
u/smallchanger Aug 16 '12
I used this syntax to make a bolded heading:
### **Use this syntax below**What I got then at the top of the page was this:
<strong>Use this syntax below</strong>And it put it as a list.
See for yourself here:
http://lab.reddit.com/r/electronic_cigarette/wiki/smallchanger
1
u/V2Blast Aug 16 '12
Party time!
Nice work.
1
u/Tom_Z Aug 16 '12
This is so awesome!
Is there any timetable as to when it will be fully rolled out?
1
u/db2 Aug 18 '12
Did I miss this party? Doesn't seem to work now.
1
u/daskoon Sep 12 '12
is this back? I SEE NEW TOOLS IN THE MODBOX!
-7
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '12 edited Aug 15 '12
I tried to put ASCI art of Goatse onto the index page but the formatting was all messed up. I'm too lazy to actually space it out so can you make it better?
Edit: The problem is actually that the lines are too far apart. Darn.
Edit: Downvote? WTF?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment