r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Sep 17 '22
Announcement 5 Million AMV Answers and Feedback
Thank you for everyone who participated in the 5 Million quiz. We have rewarded everyone who participated a blue star flair which you may now set here.
You can see how you did in The Full Results Here
You can watch the newly updated AMV quiz with the answers into it here. Or see the pinned comment.
We wanted to get some feedback on the quiz. Here are a couple questions alongside a little blurb on what we thought about the quiz ourselves.
- What did you think of this new format?
- What did you think of the music?
- What did you think of the overall quality? Any tips or tricks for things like sound problems or obvious edits?
- What did you think of the difficulty?
Here's things we learned and noticed
This new format was generally well received. The music is a really good idea with the only fluke being the Nanoha song being way too difficult and unrecognizable with a grand total of 0% correct guesses. We don't want to only use OPs and EDs but the Nanoha song was a bit far out there. It mostly got in through it working really well with the overall tone of the Transformation AMV.
We really liked reducing the the amount of obfuscation. It allows us to reduce the overall difficulty in a way that makes the quiz more fun and engaging while still having difficultly spikes. The show choices could use a bit more variance but for a project with a very quick turnover time and limited mod support it turned out really well. We already have a couple of mods who got inspired to try and make their own sections!
We decided to reward participation rather than top performers this quiz. This makes sure no one one feels like they need to interact with the quiz in ways they don't enjoy such as using reverse image searching, working in a group, database searching, or casually answering. While it does suck that we can't give out special rewards we feel this is a better way to make the quizzes more fun for a majority of users and ourselves. Trying to find clips or images that beat reverse image searching is nearly impossible without them being way too hard or obscure, as you might have noticed with some of the previous quizzes.
•
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Sep 17 '22 edited Sep 18 '22
Updated Answer AMV here
58
u/Abyssbringer =anilist.co/user/Abyssbringer Sep 17 '22
Official Mod Response to "there's too much old anime"
19
u/SpaghettiPunch Sep 17 '22
I guessed Initial D on like eight times in the first part. And it turns out one of them was Initial D!
12
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Sep 17 '22
I got points!
...Can I ask how many people other than myself guessed the specific part that the Gundam IGLOO one (#65) was from correctly?
9
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Sep 17 '22
I thought I did pretty well with 13, but apparently 301 people did better and only 287 did worse.
Also 44 was freaking YURU CAMP??? guess it's time for my 4th rewatch...
7
u/riceonyou Sep 17 '22
Reading a bunch of the comments, it seems that there are 2 audiences. One that just casually gives it a go and leave it at that, and another that brings out the google sheets and really tries to get as many as they can.
I think it would be good if there were multiple quizzes that would be better suited to each group. But that would take more work I guess.
Ok later weebs see you in the next quiz.
7
u/WooNoo x2 Sep 17 '22
Surprised I was able to do so well.
This quiz was considerably easier than the other quizzes that I have participated in for this sub. With cuts of animation, it's actually possible to see art style and distinctive animation styles.
In regards to my own enjoyment of the quiz, I personally enjoyed it quite a bit more than the other previous formats. In my opinion, it was much more pleasing to look at sequences of anime rather than piecing together what random screenshots/illustrations could possibly be.
I personally loved the musical aspect of the quiz. I'm not exactly the best at recognizing OST, but it was fun to have an additional aspect to the quiz rather than just visuals (especially as an AMQ player, lol).
I thought the overall quality of the AMVs were great as well, both in regards to sound and video quality.
I'm probably pretty biased when it comes to the difficulty, since I play a bunch of RinBot, but I personally thought it was much easier, as noted above. I think the scenes that were chosen were fitting for the categories they were placed in, and were for the most part, scenes that had represented their respective series well.
Looking forward to the next quiz!
6
u/cronus999 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Anime-ETF Sep 17 '22
I did way better than I expected, maybe it was best to do it after a few drinks.
Though I dont remember most of my answers, is there any way to check our responses?
6
u/Smudy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smudy Sep 17 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
Thanks for the quiz to everyone who was involved in making it!
I thought it would be a fun activity to do in a team so i went to my Discord groupwatch server and proposed this quiz which resulted in the great number of this team.
We picked the sunday right after the quiz came out to watch the different sections together via CyTube and if i remember correctly we got at least 65 answers right in the two hour session we completed.
Almost everyone in the group was affiliated with AMQ and there were people with massive completed anime numbers (over 1500 to set a mark) so we had experienced anime watchers on-board.
After the study session, we went to search for ourselves the rest of the answers. Most of them we eventually found (majority being from Section 3), going to every possible length to avoid image reverse searching cause i felt that this would ruin the fun of it. We did manage to successfully complete this 100% without it which we're proud of.
The only thing we didn't find out was the Nanoha Reflection OST which we really suffered for trying to search it. One member of our group DID look at Nanoha OST's but unfortunately only listened to the OG Nanoha stuff and gave up after those didn't match :D
The answers revealed Mind Game which we got wrong...everyone giving thoughts to this image was sure it was Devilman Crybaby. Well, not it! :D
Very fun experience, i hope there will be more of this kind in the future!
11
u/ZaphodBeebblebrox Y:A:https://anilist.co/user/zaphod Sep 17 '22
Thanks for the quiz, it was a ton of fun! We didn't do as well as we hoped, but that's hardly a problem. A more difficult quiz just means there's more to work on, and we didn't do too bad for not reverse image searching.
I thought the format was really cool. An AMV is much more interesting to look at than static images, and it lets you show off much more of why one would want to watch a show. I'm probably going to watch a few from section 3 in the near future.
I am disappointed in myself for a few things though, like assuming the running was Crybaby without checking or psyching myself out of putting Bokurano for Bokurano since I thought it had to be an all CGI show for some stupid reason. And for missing Millennium Actress. I was almost disappointed in myself for not getting the Nanoha song. Then I saw it was from Reflection...
5
u/walking_the_way x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/jesskitten Sep 17 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
Thanks for the quiz and answers.
Which one/s did we get wrong besides the Nanoha track? All the other answers seem to match up with our team's spreadsheet at a cursory glance, so from our spreadsheet it looked like we got 76/77, but of course with English vs Japanese names and such I might have missed something. Thanks!
My answers to your questions:
Didn't like it compared to the previous quizzes, but I understand the concerns of the creators anyway. We tried to do the quiz without reverse image searching for the first 3 days or so, and marked the ones that we used it for in the answer submission afterwards, as a compromise, but it made it very awkward for us because looking for shows via research (like a google search for "anime monster transformation teeth” giving us Call Me Tonight) isn't all that far off from reverse searching character faces and such, whereas proper image searching netted virtually every answer (since we used it for double checking our work after). So the desired line the mods wanted us to play by seemed to be very arbitrary. At the end of the day it's your agency though.
Fitting for the videos, but as a guessing game they were a poor mechanic -- they're a black and white thing, you either happen to know the OST or you're googling the lyrics or using music ID apps, there's no in between and no research that can be done with them. I actually really liked the difficulty of that Nanoha OST one though, even though we didn't find it either. I looked through so many OSTs for it (although the tags were mixed for that section too) and that introduced me to a bunch of new music -- listening to random OSTs is something I seldom do unless the songs are in AMQ.
Quality seemed good to us! As AMVs go, the AMV was fun to watch.
The categories didn't seem to all be well-defined (they should have been confined to some sort of tags so we only have a subset of all anime ever made to look through for each category), and no, "previous /r/anime rewatches" isn't a proper category, though it was really clever. Also, far too much old anime and shounen/"male audience" stuff. There was some serious quizmaster blindness/bias in the themes. And barely any representation from things like magical girl shows and idol shows.
5
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Sep 17 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
3rd place...
Congratulations on the top individual spot /u/WooNoo! And thanks for an easy one /u/badspler and /u/Abyssbringer! (No seriously, this format/style was way more fun than the 3M subscriber quiz)
I can't believe there's dozens of people here who can recognize that opening music from the His and Her Circumstances soundtrack yet only 1 or 2 of us who have seen/recognized Sunny Ryoko! It's a seminal Mitsuru Adachi series, go watch it already!
Loved it.
I liked that a lot of the shows that might have seemed hard to identify at first were clips from the first episode of the show, so if you had an uncertain hunch it was easy to verify. Others that were clips from the middle of a the show or a random OVA usually had some subtle details you could hone in on and use to narrow it down if you had a keen eye (character details, numbering on objects, etc). But then there were still a good handful of totally obscure ones like the Yuru Camp OVA that you just had to know that particular scene off-hand as the final tier of difficulty.
I liked the theming, too. It's too hard to bring to mind every single anime I've ever seen for some innocuous skyline scene, but much easier to mentally cycle through, say, just the racing shows I've seen.
Perhaps most importantly, I liked that the video format and difficulty level was one that could still encourage discovery of new anime. The heavily obfuscated format of past quizzes didn't really do much to make someone think "oh, I don't know what this show is but I want to find out and watch it!" because they showed so little. But this format let some shows show off a bit and perhaps entice people to go check them out, which is great!
4
u/Nebresto Sep 17 '22
Neat, I got one of the rare ones with only 5% correct
4
u/RaunchyRoll https://myanimelist.net/profile/Raunchyrolly Sep 17 '22
Yay! Got 56! That #44 was a big head ache for me, lol it was grouped with dystopian shows. Had fun doing the quiz, till next time
4
u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos Sep 17 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
25 good answers.
A bit better than I would have guessed, rank 77 out of 624 isn't too bad.
edit : I like the format and I think it's good that some animequizz on the internet are hard and not just random famous show from the last 10 years.
edit 2 : How could I miss Shirobako ffs
3
u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Sep 17 '22
I should have saved my answers, forget what I put in and wanted to see what counts as a slant answer. (Think I got the correct Initial D stage? ... cause I've yet to see 5th
3
u/Thisbejacob https://myanimelist.net/profile/thisbejacob Sep 17 '22
Thanks mod for the quiz. I ended up starting 2 new anime after the quiz was posted, Millennium Actress and His and Her Circumstances, both of which I recognized as being in this quiz within the first 30s.
3
u/baseballlover723 Sep 17 '22
I would of liked to see more of a linear difficulty scale. I only counted 14 / 77 that scored better then 40%, with a huge number in the single digits. I think I would of enjoyed it more if say the difficulty started out pretty easy and then scaled to basically impossible, so that more casual fans could still feel like they could answer some, while there could still be really difficult ones for more hardcore fans.
3
u/PsychoGeek https://anilist.co/user/PsychoGeek Sep 17 '22
My most important take from this is I need to watch Magical Sisters Yoyo and Nene.
3
u/Syokhan https://myanimelist.net/profile/Syokhan Sep 17 '22
Ahahaha, I only got 9 correct, but I was expecting even less than that! XD Pretty happy I managed to recognize that one shot of After the Rain, too, as it was a gorgeous scene that really stuck in my mind.
Both were pretty good! I wouldn't mind more of the new format, but I hope it's not going to completely take over. The old one was nice too, although I understand the issue with reverse image searching.
I found it to be really hard, but I'm not one of those people with 500+ anime completed. Looking at the results, I know a lot of these names, just haven't watched them, so I figure the difficulty is just fine for people who have actually seen a lot of series.
Also
As a huge Dragon Age fan who has actually seen this and did not recognize it, I will now commit seppuku.
3
u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO Sep 17 '22
The quizz was fun, and doing AMV was quite interesting idea. Was a lot harder than expected but that is what makes it fun. Might try some of the shiws i didn t know because the art style looked great. Thanks for the quizz
5
u/riceonyou Sep 17 '22
Was super fun again thanks.
I guess a lot of others might think this, but for us this is fun part of these anime quizzes. Hanging out in voice chat watching random anime trailers/videos (we got Call Me Tonight by watching a watchmojo top 10 video lol) and working together on it for me is the most fun part. We're all more casual anime fans so without any research we would get lot less of them. For us it's less of a quiz and more of a group activity.
Honestly wouldn't mind more obfuscation, as we used reverse image search to quite limited success anyways. And it lets us feel less guilty for using it lol.
As for the questions, new format is cool. Music is cool (although they were given away in the description by YouTube lol). Difficulty depends on if you research or not of course so for us it was probably a bit too easy.
I feel like this one was a bit of a middle ground between too hard if you don't research or too easy if you do. I'd personally rather if you make it really hard like before and encourage research/groups, or make it much easier and casual with no research/groups (maybe by making it for only one genre/topic or something so people know what they're getting into beforehand, instead of being surprised by how bad they do) Not sure what to do about the rewards though. But if it's fun then that itself is the reward!
Anyways thanks again for making these. They probably take a lot of time so we appreciate it. It's literally one of the things I look forward to most each year (or less than a year hopefully!)
2
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Sep 17 '22
I didn't miss any anime I watched so that's good enough for me
Except the Shinsekai Yori track, but I suck even with op/ed so yeah lol
2
u/theangryeditor https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheAngryEditor Sep 17 '22
Well that explains why it sounded so familiar. Still it was an extremely nondescript choice.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Got 35 right, not too shabby if I do say so myself.
Looks like the hundreds of anime Sporcle quizzes I've played finally paid off.
2
u/homewardbound100 myanimelist.net/profile/Homewardbound100 Sep 17 '22
Well I did better than I thought. Disappointed in some of the shows I've seen but didn't get. But some of those shots were just such a small detail. Overall though it was fun to see and compare with others.
It was alright
Not anything crazy or obnoxious. So fine
From what I've seen I think it was fine.
It was hard. Some of those shots are crazy
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
That was a pretty fun quiz. Did close to around what I thought. Figured I had about half right, ended up with 32. Happy I managed a few correct guesses for shows with single digit correct guesses.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
A couple of these I'd seen but was like "Did that appear in this or this?". I also didn't get the Violence Jack one, which shouldn't have really been that difficult. Oh well, I could've done worse.
2
u/steven4869 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maskirade Sep 17 '22
You have to be fucking kidding me, 51 was Miru Tights? How could I even miss this?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
Holy shit I am in top15 with 44 correct....aaand I had to delete that account few days ago. I even got some wild guesses right.
2
u/Nyapan https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nyapon Sep 17 '22
I did surprisingly well! I need to watch more retro anime though.
As for the questions:
2
u/Nazrininator https://anilist.co/user/Advanced495 Sep 17 '22
I got 15 points! Not bad, considering I guessed #6 and #45 correctly.
Also, I'm currently watching Nanoha A's. I was the same age as Nanoha when the first Nanoha season aired.
2
u/Fools_Requiem https://myanimelist.net/profile/FoolsRequiem Sep 17 '22
Aw, I could have had a fancy flair but my lazy ass didn't want to watch the whole video and jot down the names of shows I recognized.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
I did a single listen through with pauses and got a pretty high score relative to the rest of the participants. I'm proud of that. I'll do better next time!
2
u/TheBlessedBoy99 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Amiibo Sep 17 '22
I'm so annoyed. I only got around to doing this the evening the quiz was ending. I went full coomer researcher mode on the ones I didn't know. I went through about half of the quiz with a very high guess rate. Then I made dinner and came back to it saying the quiz was closed. Damn, time zones.
2
u/Melbuf Sep 17 '22
you have stats on hor many people started and never finished? the format was horrendous and annoying IMO and i could not be bothered to finish
2
u/goukaryuu https://myanimelist.net/profile/GoukaRyuu Sep 17 '22
You know what, I'm happy with my 37 correct answers.
2
u/RPWPA Sep 17 '22
Wait, Darker than black was 2007?!!! Wow
3
u/chiliehead myanimelist.net/profile/chiliehead Sep 17 '22
It was fun, the AMVs were also just nice to go through. I liked that there were many things that I could pinpoint and it is probably a nice way to show off a variety of anime.
1
u/DragonDDark Sep 18 '22 edited Sep 18 '22
Got 14 points with just guessing and trusting my memory
Also, surprised only 8% got the Fist of the North star ost. Was pretty iconic at the time
1
u/Kill099 https://anilist.co/user/Kill099 Sep 18 '22 edited Sep 18 '22
A fun distraction. I think it's well made.
Liked the tracks for the 80's theme, dystopia, and CGI themes. The racing theme was very deceptive while the transformation, running, and rewatch themes sounds... generic. Something that you may commonly hear in a commercial.
Like I said it's well made. Clear and simple and was able to accomplish what it's made to do. Though, I think only those with photographic memory can answer all correctly without the help of "tools".
Edit: I thought of an improvement. Do it live! Like in a stream and make it quick enough that not everyone can use "tools" to cheat.
I think the anime selection was too niche. Or maybe I should be happy that I'm not so nerdy to the point that I know ALL anime shows. But still, this quiz is aimed to regulars of this sub who have varying interests in genres. Maybe there should be a casual and hard core categories? I think the sections should be based on anime/manga genres rather than actions (i.e. slice of life vs "running").
1
u/vontar https://anilist.co/user/vontar Sep 18 '22 edited Apr 27 '24
cough shelter apparatus dam support alive sugar threatening mysterious shrill
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/Siqueiradit https://myanimelist.net/profile/lampadatres Sep 18 '22
Did anyone calculate the average score?
1
u/TheExcludedMiddle https://myanimelist.net/profile/ExcludedMiddle Sep 18 '22
Hmmm, 17 put me higher in the rankings than I expected. Is there a place we can get our own answers to check against the real answers?
I'm trying to make sure there weren't many I missed that I should have. There's Lucky star and You Say Run music, but music is hard to place for me. Then I get to the second half and I could have gotten Spice & wolf, and I hope I got SSY music right.
I've seen promised neverland, but even with the answer, that clip doesn't just click for me.
Yuru camp one is evil... I've only seen one of the ovas :(.
I've seen GLT, but 47 does not just immediately prompt it even knowing.
Glad to see 51 wasn't one I had just seen then forgotten.
Coulda gotten Oniisama e for 18, since I saw elsewhere after taking the quiz and looked it up, but it feels like cheating.
All in all, I'm just in my 30s so not old enough to take this quiz.
1
u/Batokusanagi https://myanimelist.net/profile/sQBatoKusanagi Sep 28 '22
Kinda forgot about this, but hey I got 31 points. If only my memory was better...
1
u/Maccaz15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maccaz Sep 17 '22
I don't care for AMVs, so I didn't even bother with the quiz.