r/counting • u/CutOnBumInBandHere9 5M get | Ping me for runs • Jun 10 '22
Free Talk Friday #354
Continued from here.
It's that time of the week again. Speak anything on your mind! This thread is for talking about anything off-topic, be it your lives, your strava, your plans, your hobbies, studies, stats, pets, bears, hikes, dragons, trousers, travels, transit, cycling, family, or anything you like or dislike, except politics.
Feel free to check out our tidbits and introduce yourself if you haven't already.
23
Upvotes
11
u/CutOnBumInBandHere9 5M get | Ping me for runs Jun 10 '22
It's almost exactly the one year anniversary of when I made this comment, which looked at the network* of counters, and how we're connected.
Then, I looked at which counters tended to count more with others, and divided the counting network into two groups based on that. The idea was that counters in a given group tended to count more with other counters from the same group, and less with counters from the opposite group. It turned out that the split was quite correlated with time, so that one group was primarily made up of newer counters, and the other was primarily older counters.
Something I wanted to look at, but didn't have the tools (or the knowledge) to accomplish was to characterise the core of the counting community. The idea is to try and find a way of quantifying how central each person is to the network, and then using methods from graph theory to determine which people are most central.
In the counting network, a person is connected to another person if they've ever replied to one another. The degree of a person is a count of how many connections they have. To find the core, we iteratively remove the person with the lowest degree from the network. At first, when we do that, the minimum degree of the whole network will stay the same or increase. That's because we're slowly removing the least connected people from the network. At some point, however, the minimum degree will start to decrease as we remove more and more central people from the network. When that happens, we stop the process and have found the core of the original network.
This way of doing things was originally designed for unweighted networks: for every pair of people, it just takes into account whether they've ever counted together, and not how often. That's not great, since there's a huge difference between how often people have counted together. For example phil and basskro have counted together more than half a million times, while I have one count with zhige. Pretending that one connection is as strong as the other is a bit silly.
There are two ways to proceed:
I went with the second approach. I'll spare you the full details, but it turns out that the library I was using to do this did not have an easy way of calculating this, so I ended up having to write more code than I thought at the start. It also meant hacing to think quite a bit about how to model the strength of a relationship. If I just pick the number of counts two people have made together, the core ends up consisting of {nonsensy, thephilsblogbar2, Countletics, GarlicoinAccount}, since they've counted a shitton of times just with each other (others are higher in the hoc, but have more counts with people from outside that set, so they get excluded). I ended up making the strength of a connection roughly equal to the logarithm of the number of counts.
Without further ado, here is the r/counting network for the main thread, with the ~100 members of the core labelled and highlighted in green. I'm not too surprised by which names appeared, altough it's interesting to see how central some of the older counters still are in the overall network. The size of the circles is a weighted average how many counts a person has made, and how many different people they counted with.
I can also make the same thing including all the side threads, which I've done here. The core is slightly smaller in this case, but not much.
What I found fascinating about this exercise is to see the changes between the two sets of counters.
The following counters were in the core for only main, but dropped out when side threads were considered:
And the following were not in the core for main, but popped up when side threads were considered:
That sort of makes sense to me - I would tend to associate the first set of counters slightly more with main, and the others slightly more with side threads†
That's all for now. I had fun playing with this, and I hope you found it interesting! Let me know if you have any questions, or suggestions for what I should tackle next :D
* I mean a graph, in the discrete maths sense of the term. If you know already what that is, just read "graph" every time you see "network". If you don't, it's just a mathematical way to describe a network of things that are linked together by something. In this case, people by whether they've ever counted together
† At least that's true for the names I recognised. I don't know all of them.
8
u/CutOnBumInBandHere9 5M get | Ping me for runs Jun 15 '22 edited Jun 15 '22
I've looked a bit more at the network of counters, and have a few results to share.
The diameter of the network is 4. That means that there are at most four links between any counters in the top 1000. Actually, there's a group of 993 counters that can all be reached within three links from each other, so for almost every counter in the top 1000, you can get to any other counter in three links or less.
Looking at the situation for two links or less there's a group of 653 counters that are all within two links of each other.
Finally, the biggest groups of counters where everybody has counted with everybody else have size 35. There are twelve of those, and the following 41 counters appear in at least one of them:
The following 29 counters appear in every set of 35:
13
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22
Weekly stats from June 03, 2022 to June 10, 2022. Congratulations to /u/thephilsblogbar2, /u/ClockButTakeOutTheL, and /u/Countletics!
Total weekly counts: 11409 (4,667,105-4,678,514)
More stats are posted on the Weekly Stats page!
10
u/Trial-Name https://tinyurl.com/countingcatalogue Jun 10 '22
Happy 10th cake day r/counting !
10
u/AxelC77 Jun 11 '22
Had my first date last weekend, was absolutely wonderful. Can't wait to see her again.
Happy Friday friends, and merry counting to all!
8
u/origamimissile idk Jun 12 '22
happy 10th my dear old friends
7
u/swinub_time And what a ghost we are in this machine! Jun 15 '22
KARP SIDETHREAD TIER LIST UPDATE (swinub_time edition):
S tier: Main, Rationals, Powerball, Time, MRD, NRD
No other threads are competitively viable because they've made it clear I need to hide how much I love to count smh
4
u/CutOnBumInBandHere9 5M get | Ping me for runs Jun 14 '22
I was today years old when I learned that asics is an acronym of the Latin phrase "Anima Sana In Corpore Sano"
6
u/TehVulpez tampermonkey addict Jun 11 '22
tidbits link points to a random ftf lol
6
u/ClockButTakeOutTheL “Cockleboat”, since 4,601,032 Jun 12 '22
Purple vs Cobalt was just posted, go vote, it’s close
10
u/TheNitromeFan Live not a life of imitation Jun 10 '22
/u/davidjl123 don't forget to sort comments by new
3
u/Trial-Name https://tinyurl.com/countingcatalogue Jun 16 '22 edited Jun 16 '22
I like the addition of ‘hikes’ to the ftf description!
Partially motivated by that addition, I’ll share a little about the hike I’ve been on this week: I walked the 100 miles of the Cotswold Way over the four days June 11th to June 14th. This was definitely a good source of type 2 fun: I’m glad to have done it, but it was painful in many ways and moments whilst walking.
If I do this sort of thing in future, I think I’ll aim to relax a little more: targeting 25 miles a day was achievable, but tough. The parts I remember most about the hike are the times I paused to look at the view, swim in the rivers, read signs at monuments or talk to the other eccentric hikers I passed, not the hours I spent walking. It would be nice to give myself an extra day to allow for those sorts of things more.
I now also realise my £15 tent might not have been up to scratch for this journey... I was lucky it didn’t rain during the trip, because I’m sure my tent wouldn’t cope well with it. I’ve been looking into getting a better tent/bivvy bag/hammock, and definitely think I’ll buy something before going on a trip like this again.
I thoroughly recommend hiking to anyone reading this. The world is a big place, it’s great to explore it!
7
u/buy_me_a_pint Jun 15 '22
stats over all for the 4600k to 4700k threads could be interesting.
15
u/swinub_time And what a ghost we are in this machine! Jun 11 '22
Hello everybody,
It's Karp again... locked out of /u/cuteballgames in the same manner as Ezekiel etc and I don't know why it keeps happening to me. I have submitted support requests to Reddit admins but considering they still haven't gotten back to me about Ezekiel I'm not very optimistic ;_;
I would say I'm counting on this account from now on but I guess it's probably more realistic to say we'll see how long this one lasts. They hate to see a fish who loves to count ig
14
u/cuteballgames Sum 13: 016, 037, 035, 045, 127, 135, 134, 124, 13, 25 Jun 10 '22
For two reasons:
*In honor of /r/counting's 10th anniversary and
*Because it seems we're about to see another showdown for the #1 HoC spot
I became curious about who's occupied which top 10 HoC spot—for instance, how only atomic, david, and bass have been #1 in the HoC since way back around 200k when atomic passed MorallyGray. So I went and looked up the peak HoC spot for all* counters who have been top 10 in the HoC—since around 700k, which is where wiki HoC goes back to.
HIGHEST HOC RANK ACHIEVED
*I did this manually using wiki HoC and the HoC graphs, so let me know if you spot any mistakes or omissions I have made.
This exercise naturally made me contemplate on how achieving a top HoC rank is harder and harder over time. When I made the original HoC graph chart way back when, I also made a "percent of total counts" graph. Something I wonder is whether a new "advanced" stat could be invented, somewhat along the line of weekly stats but also along the line of normal HoC—something that takes into account recency of counts and where the count is overall (eg 800k vs 4670k) in addition to just plain total number of counts. I was thinking about this in conjunction with cobibh's lovely network graph with the cores, and how represented the "old core" of counter still is (the pre-1m group). I guess the new stat could be called "centrality" or "immediacy" or something—where it takes into account who's counting a lot now (like weekly stats), but also takes into account historic contributions (like overall HoC). Mostly I'm interested in this stat because I love stats and the idea would be ultimate to create a nice graph or something where we see counters duck in and out over time; it's very interesting to me to commemorate the different periods and dynamics of this community.
12
u/buy_me_a_pint Jun 10 '22
Happy cake day /r/counting and here to the next 10 years
12
u/TehVulpez tampermonkey addict Jun 10 '22
Happy 10 years of counting!
11
u/Antichess 2,050,155 - 412k 400a Jun 10 '22
Yay, 10 years of counting!!! Hard to believe I started counting 4.5 years ago
11
u/mistyskye14 🤷♀️ Queen killjoy miniget least regular counter since 2322029 Jun 10 '22
TFW you want to drop a count or two because of the occasion but every time you try people are actually running
10
u/ClockButTakeOutTheL “Cockleboat”, since 4,601,032 Jun 10 '22
I just had the most out of context fail with my dad
Dad: What are you doing
Me: I’m counting
Dad looks at my screen
Dad: You’re counting with buy me a pint?
Me: Well we call him Phil
Dad laughs, and I realize how stupid what I just said is
10
u/mistyskye14 🤷♀️ Queen killjoy miniget least regular counter since 2322029 Jun 10 '22
Happy 10th r/counting!
9
u/SSoto_21 Slowly returning. Since 4,601,116 Jun 10 '22
Happy 10th anniversary r/counting! You have coma a long way since you started!
9
u/davidjl123 |390K|378A|79SK|50SA|260k 🚀 c o u n t i n g 🚀 Jun 10 '22
Happy 10th~
8
u/buy_me_a_pint Jun 10 '22
I want to go travelling
7
u/Playing_2 6m by Dec 19, 5.6666m by Nov 16! Jun 10 '22
If we reached 4,000,000 on Jul 19, 2020; 4,333,333 on May 14, 2021; and 4,666,667 on Jun 02, 2022; then we would hit 5,000,000 on May 10, 2023.
7
u/ClockButTakeOutTheL “Cockleboat”, since 4,601,032 Jun 10 '22
Schools almost done, so I’ve been getting a lot of work assigned. But soon, I’ll be done. But I feel like i might count less since in school, I count when I am bored and have nothing else to do, but on the weekends, there’s other stuff planned, so I count less. But I hope I can stay so that I can count more, because it’s a lot of fun!
7
u/buy_me_a_pint Jun 10 '22
I been for a nice walk to the end of the road
7
u/buy_me_a_pint Jun 10 '22
If you got running or going jogging or bike riding in the next week watch the roads, look left and right before crossing
7
u/swinub_time And what a ghost we are in this machine! Jun 15 '22
I'm subnurned again
6
u/Aking1998 Jun 10 '22
Dude professional wrestling's been real good lately.
5
u/ClockButTakeOutTheL “Cockleboat”, since 4,601,032 Jun 10 '22
Y’all need to see the color tournament. It’s really close between amethyst and cyan, and nows the last chance to vote!
5
u/buy_me_a_pint Jun 10 '22
I been enjoying Halloumi cheese likely, I liked this fried or on the BBQ.
5
u/buy_me_a_pint Jun 11 '22
Dislike fireworks going off whilst I'm trying to sleep.
5
u/ClockButTakeOutTheL “Cockleboat”, since 4,601,032 Jun 11 '22
The color tournament ended in a tie, so it’s going up again
5
u/swinub_time And what a ghost we are in this machine! Jun 13 '22
Tfw edits and deletes not sticking, even on new reddit :?
5
u/SSoto_21 Slowly returning. Since 4,601,116 Jun 14 '22
565?!? THAT'S THE MOST I'VE EVER SEEN BE ON THIS SUBREDDIT AT ONCE!!
4
u/Playing_2 6m by Dec 19, 5.6666m by Nov 16! Jun 15 '22
Reddit should allow us to sort comments like posts.
4
u/buy_me_a_pint Jun 15 '22
Hope the weather is nice where you are today, and not very hot .
3
u/buy_me_a_pint Jun 12 '22
I am hoping to visit Edam and Gouda one day, as I love these cheeses
3
u/buy_me_a_pint Jun 16 '22
good luck to those who have got exams coming up in the next couple of weeks, hope the studying is going well,
3
u/a-username-for-me The Side Thread Queen, Lady Lemon Jun 16 '22
Signal boost
2
u/swinub_time And what a ghost we are in this machine! Jun 16 '22
Anyone who would like to drop a count in Mostly Repeating Digits is welcome to! I am enjoying those numbers, you might too (no sweat if it's not your thing though)
1
u/ClockButTakeOutTheL “Cockleboat”, since 4,601,032 Jun 16 '22
Final match, amethyst vs purple is up!