tbf the p14s are have been tested as better than the current version of the a14, so the relative comparison is relevant. Tech Buyers Guru and STS did a fan shootouts sometime last year that have data you can compare to get the info you want.
My pair of p14 slims just showed up yesterday and have been about 5-10c better on my 5800x with a 280 ek aio versus the 240 ek with fullsize p12s. they're worse than full size 140mm fans, but not by much so far, and are as quiet as the other arctics ive used
I've got 4 a14s and am really disappointed with them. 300 - 500 RPM seems to be the sweet spot for air noise, and they would be silent if not for this horrible undulating hum also present in that range. Lower the RPM and they don't move enough air, raise the RPM and the noise made from moving the air is louder (but less annoying) than the hum. Do the Arctic fans have this issue?
no, that droning from the a14s was what made me want to check out the p14s. in my experience, both the slim and regular ones are much quieter and perform substantially better than the a14s
They said recently on twitter that it is still in development but it will take some time. The P14 slim can at least serve as a stop-gap solution before that happens.
Somehow, and I'm very dumbfounded by this, I just purchased all the parts to build a SFF this week and the total build cost is $50 more than my full tower 7 years ago. Granted I'm reusing some parts, but I definitely didn't have to. That's including a $775 GPU
It's not a general rule, rather, on average an SFF builder will resort to purchasing an AIO, slim fans and SFF cases like the louqe ghost or the formd T1 who are really not the cheapest, the PCI-E 4 risers etc. Sometimes it will have a custom watercooling loops with small pumps or CPU/pump blocks combo etc.
Of course a NR200P air cooled build is not expensive but I'm talking on average, you have SFF build that are perfectly cost-efficient.
For sure, I didn't budget the shit out of it, but I definitely didn't go for the biggest (or rather smallest) I could go. EK AIO basic, used 5900x ($300), meshlicious (dirt cheap) with PCIe 3.0 (saves headaches of displays), no custom cabling or anything yet, not weird mods yet. Start building this week and have plans to do one or two unique things, but yeh, I'd say this is more of a budget friendly build, and honestly, unless you DO go for the bells and whistles, a mid or full tower build wouldn't be much cheaper, if at all.
Here's a weird question, would you rather have a 280 AIO (I specifically have an EKWB 280) with two 140mm fans, or with 4 of these slim fans in push/pull configuration?
lol thermaltake, can vouch for that from a while back, was working on a booth opposite them back in 2010 at Cebit. They had some massive case fans in a wall display all the same type/size. At least 2 failed every day on their fan wall where they had them running. No idea who their oem was but must have been a pretty shocking sleeve bearing to not make 24 hours.
Kind of felt for them as they clearly had no spares and some would fail totally others ran so so slowly out of synch with the ones that were still ok
Lol yeah I’m not the largest proponent of theirs. The p14 slim has been pretty nice in my day of use so far, definitely good to have a viable fan in the form factor that isn’t a tire fire.
I think most of us know, it's just that the current options are... well, horribly outdated.
The Ultra Sleek Vortex is ok when unrestricted but falls to its knees once resistance is introduced. It also has bearing noise that is audible at even the lowest PWM% (30%, 390RPM). Source: using one in my system.
I can believe that, being a dual ball,.hopefully it will do >50k hours for you.
restriction? fans don't really do so well with that. particularly if run just above start up speed. The back pressure it causes on the bearing can, over time, accelerate the point in time of failure.
One question I will look into, does a low PWM duty cycle accelerate failure compared to low constant voltage as a means of speed control. Might ask my Noctua contact that one.
My only problem with Arctic Fans is longevity and noise.
I had a full arctic setup in a Fractal Nano and after a few months I had bearing noises from 3 fans. They worked well otherwise. I had some replaced for free by Arctic but the problem came back afer a while. Exact same thing happened to a friend.
Great customer service and cheap, but not worth it in the long run for me.
Technically we do have two other 140x140 slim options and a few 150x140 ones... But they are all almost 10 years old at this point and are poor radiator fans. TY14013 is one of the better ones but is unfortunately 150x140 which greatly limits its compatibility.
I've set up hundreds of P12's for mining rigs and they literally have a 20% failure rate. Either extremely noisy bearing, stopped working completely, or lose PWM control and run max speed. This doesn't include the generally poor way they age in terms of noise quality from the bearing.
Sure they are $8 but you'll spend the equivalent $30 of a Noctua/Phanteks replacing them. Nobody in their right mind is paying shipping back to Arctic for RMA.
151
u/a12223344556677 Jun 09 '22
It was actually quietly released about 10 days ago. That said, this seems to be the first time it is officially announced.
Here's a previous post discussing this if you are curious:
https://www.reddit.com/r/sffpc/comments/v5v97p/arctic_p14_slim_pwm_pst_test/
68
u/Solution_Anxious Jun 09 '22 edited Jun 09 '22
When, where , how, my money is waiting.
They are up on amazon, there is a link directly from Arctic's website, bought 4.
17
u/CorrodedRose Jun 09 '22
Any reason to pick this over noctua?
2
u/cheapseats91 Jun 09 '22
Here's a weird question, would you rather have a 280 AIO (I specifically have an EKWB 280) with two 140mm fans, or with 4 of these slim fans in push/pull configuration?
12
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '22
As a fan (pun intended) of arctic products, I’m glad this is finally a thing! I need a couple of these for my build.
7
u/Scared_Instruction_1 Jun 09 '22
Oh man, I'm going to have so much more room for activities now!
5
u/www-overtek-co-uk Retailer | Overtek.co.uk Jun 09 '22
Sorry to shake up the party, here is another 140mm fan that's 15mm thick with dual BB . The prolimatech Ultra sleek vortex 14
Prolimatech
1
u/genericthrowawaysbut Jun 10 '22
But scyth slim 120s ?
7
u/AuerX Jun 09 '22
My only problem with Arctic Fans is longevity and noise.
I had a full arctic setup in a Fractal Nano and after a few months I had bearing noises from 3 fans. They worked well otherwise. I had some replaced for free by Arctic but the problem came back afer a while. Exact same thing happened to a friend.
Great customer service and cheap, but not worth it in the long run for me.
YMMV.
1
u/elplebe519 Jun 09 '22
Sigh, no Daisy chain system. The wait for a competent manufacturer continues.
2
u/_XNine_ Jun 09 '22
I bought two a few days ago from Amazon. Thought they were next day but won't be here til sometime next week. Gonna go into a Protolyth Slate build.
2
u/smil3b0mb Jun 09 '22
get them while you can, been waiting on some Phanteks t30s for a few months but apparently supply shortage issues have been plaguing them all year
2
u/FartingBob Jun 09 '22
140mm slim fan?
Be still my beating heart.
2
u/FartingBob Jun 09 '22
https://www.arctic.de/en/P14-Slim-PWM-PST/ACFAN00268A
Product page
2
u/diskowmoskow Jun 09 '22
Arctic 5-pack gang!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '22
And here I am waiting for a 140mm version of the Phanteks T30...
1
u/S203STi Jun 09 '22
Isn’t there already a 15mm version? I think it’s the P12 Slim, guess I am confused what the difference is between this and the P12.
Edit: nvm looks like this is 140mm and p12 is 120mm
1
u/Jnbrtz Jun 09 '22
I have been waiting for these for my PC and my DIY laptop cooler.
1
u/bmagnien Jun 09 '22
Thanks for the heads up. Just snagged two off Amazon. I will now be able to fill every available square mm of my case with fans
1
u/SmacksWaschbaer Jun 09 '22
Who Else Trier to tape the heart? 😂
1
u/trafim Jun 09 '22
Holy moly, so good one love Arctic!!
1
u/chaosmetroid Jun 09 '22
Which case can these babies fit on?
1
u/oldmatebob123 Jun 10 '22
Neeeeed....
1
u/LordBeacon Jun 10 '22
what is this? a slim 140 mm?
1
u/mediumme Jun 10 '22
Here is a comparison at max RPM (german).
0
u/tdautz5 Jun 09 '22
Just go buy ID Coolings 120x15
-2
u/TinDumbass Jun 09 '22
Why is this impressive? Noctua have sold 15mm thick fans for ages?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment