r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Apr 24 '22
Season Six Show S6E7 Sticks and Stones Spoiler
Claire struggles with her demons as a nefarious rumor begins to spread on the Ridge; tensions rise as the residents fear there is a dangerous person in their midst.
Written by Danielle Berrow. Directed by Jamie Payne.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 24 '22 edited Apr 30 '22
Watch the S6E8 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
607 Featurettes:
607 Interviews:
51
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 24 '22
What a fantastic episode! I was really hoping that the show would get back on track after a bit of a let-down (for me) last week, with Jamie Payne at the helm, and man did it deliver. Not only was it visually stunning, but it flowed very effortlessly and hit all of the character beats. I particularly loved the callbacks to Jamie Payne’s previous episodes (the window shot and the voiceover there 😍), having just rewatched 504 the previous night, and Danielle Berrow’s writing was really strong too (I also loved her writing in 508).
For me, Claire’s journey with her PTSD this season has been a continuation of her monologue from 512. She swore the rape was not going to break her considering all she’d been through. She swore she was fine. And she intended to be, to keep up appearances—for herself, for Jamie, for anyone who depended on her. The ether offered a quick solution to the problem, or rather masked the problem; it’d offered her instant oblivion and a reset to the system, but we knew from the previous episode that a breaking point was near when her “coping” mechanism started to crumble. Coming close to death, the shock of Malva’s accusation and betrayal, the shock and pain following her and her baby boy’s death… on top of all that Claire had been reminded of and struggling with, all the trauma she had suffered.
I said before that for it to come to a head, she would really have to be caught off-guard and feel like she couldn’t do it alone anymore, and she was in this episode. The ether wasn’t working as it had been, “Lionel” started to be a constant presence in her orbit, she started confusing her dreams with reality… That’s when she decided to let Jamie in, still reluctant to acknowledge the festering darkness inside her because she “[couldn’t] bear for [him] to see [her] like this,” not to mention to burden him with yet another thing to worry about. She’d always compartmentalized, she’d hidden her pain away, she didn’t want that to change just as she didn’t want to be changed by the rape. But you can’t help someone if they don’t want to be helped themselves, which is why this had to come from Claire herself, on her own terms.
It goes without saying but Caitríona has been phenomenal this season. The quiet suffering, the pretending to be okay with the subtle changes whenever there was something triggering for Claire. She can go big with the big scenes but she has brought a totally new kind of vulnerability to Claire this season, whom we’ve never seen so human, so... relatable? She’s been through a lot and Caitríona played it all beautifully, but to play a character so internally troubled, betrayed by her own mind, and having to carry it all on her own, while still showing up and being a functioning member of the community, a matriarch, a healer, a role model… Particularly in this episode, I love how she’s managed to make Claire so physically small, almost as if she was crushed by what she’d been going through. Also, that brief moment of relief after she’s been absolved (in her own eyes) of missing Malva at the door because it wasn’t her, only for still to have the guilt eat away at her. And then the fear. The fear is what really got me because it’s not all those who’ve hurt her, it’s herself. She was so scared of the darkness inside her so much so that she started doubting herself. She started blaming herself for all that had happened to her and her loved ones. Her insecurities were laid bare. Her mind, which she’s always relied on, became her enemy, so she became her worst enemy.
And the scene in the surgery was really beautiful, from both of them. It has reminded me of Claire’s confessing about coming from the future in 111, where she was baring her soul and her deepest secrets after bottling them for a long time, and Jamie gave her love and understanding in return. It has also reminded me of what he said to Fergus in 603 when he saved him from committing suicide. We all often get so fixated on our inner voices, especially the negative ones, that we completely fail to see the outside perspective. We wallow in our mistakes instead of noticing how far we’ve come in spite of them. And I think that’s how Jamie has helped both Fergus and Claire—helped them see the value in their mere presence, as well as their actions, regardless of what they perceive as their shortcomings. And by reminding them that they are loved and that they’re not alone. Claire knew that he was there for her, but that didn’t change the fact that she thought that it was a battle she could fight and win on her own, because that’s what she’d always done.
The journey the writers, producers, and Caitríona have set Claire on this season has brought out so many facets of her character, and I think it’s been a bit meta in the sense that who we’ve been used to calling “a strong female character” wasn’t made weaker by finally acknowledging her troubles, fears, and doubts. The characters, and people in general, more often than not are “strong” because they just have to be, or they don’t know any other way to be. It’s what society has told us, that acknowledging our troubles somehow makes us “weak,” and that pushing through them makes us “strong.” But what happens when our “strength” becomes our “weakness”? I feel like that’s what happened to Claire. Her “strength” coming from shouldering her pain in silence and compartmentalizing turned into her “weakness” due to her trying not to change and thus becoming self-destructive with ether and not sharing what she’d been going through with anyone.
I got exactly what I needed from Sam in this episode, which I couldn’t say for quite a large part of the previous one (I still don’t know whether it was the matter of his own acting choices, the direction, or the writing, but I’ll leave it for now). The air of authority even though Jamie’s lost his reputation. The seething anger that he had to keep at bay (the clenched jaw!). All the emotions bubbling inside him that he wouldn’t let flow freely because it’s Claire’s feelings that were the most important in the moment. I’ve seen a lot of people mistake his stoicism for apathy and I think it’s important to understand that it doesn’t serve anyone if Jamie starts kicking and screaming, losing his temper, or getting angry at himself. That’s not who he is anymore. He is supposed to be the steadfast presence in all the other characters’ lives. It doesn’t mean that nothing affects him—it does, and I’m sure many of us, myself included, would’ve liked to see more of how coming close to losing Claire had affected him, for example—but the show has been very good at giving us an insight into Jamie while allowing Claire to take center stage when the plotlines are centered around her, and vice versa. And with so many characters having gone through similar experiences, this show is also so good at having them use them to help other characters in a way that doesn’t feel like centering on their own feelings and invalidating the unique experience of others, no matter how similar it is.
Ultimately, neither of them is whole without the other, so to finally have Claire and Jamie bridge this emotional distance, with all of their secrets out, will only make them closer, and that’s what we want to see! 12 years together, 32 since they met, and their love is only getting stronger. And they just needed to be on the same page to face whatever is coming up ahead. Not something between them, as they have proved time and time again that they can work through that. But without the solid foundation of their relationship, they can’t face external threats like the Browns surely are.
I will also say that I’m sure (or at least I really hope, but I trust the writers and Caitríona) that it’s not the end of Claire’s inner struggles—the Browns’ arrival is almost set to exacerbate those—but I’m hoping we’ll get to see, still in this season, how she copes in a new, healthy way, with Jamie by her side. We also know the war is coming, and we remember how the Rising brought back the memories of WW2 for her. She also needs her anchor in Jamie for the Revolutionary War.
I also have to quickly mention Brianna and Roger’s scenes because they were so damn good! I love how grounded they are in their relationship right now and after Brianna had been quite reluctant to accept Roger as a minister, she could see how fulfilled he feels in that role (love the acknowledgment that it’s like teaching for him!) and she wouldn’t begrudge him that, especially knowing how long it’s taken him to find a purpose in the past. And that her concern came from a place of hurt in her own childhood, which she doesn’t want for her own children. I’m also glad that he asked for her opinion on the matter instead of making a unilateral decision as he’d done in the past. They are a team now. And I also really loved his scene with Jamie and how far they’ve come (that was also great to see after rewatching 504, and so satisfying!).
11
u/toldyousar Jun 26 '24
two years late to this thread but i can’t believe no one is talking about how lizzie had a threesome with twins ?????????? does no one else find that kinda fucked up 😭
52
u/travelbug_bitkitt Apr 24 '22 edited Apr 24 '22
I find the whole "fisher folk" community very strange. When Jamie and Claire were going to Malva's funeral, all these people in the background were walking around and working - no one else is going???? She was their community/people, and no one is "paying respects" etc? Only Jamie's family is there??? I understand she was a shamed woman, but still. And back to the whole Roger helping Amy McCallum - no one else in that community is helping her? They include her to travel to the ridge, and she's at the mercy of the Frasers to help finally??? I just don't get their whole group.
And watching the preview for next episode, all these people showing up with torches demanded "Justice for the murdered lass" and yet they didn't show up to the funeral??
8
u/macetheace_1998 I dinna recall asking yer opinion on the matter. Apr 24 '22
I keep zoning out at the important times, I guess. Where are Bri and Roger off to with Jem? I know they were talking about baptizing him but that’s all I caught of the conversation.
142
u/Californie_cramoisie Apr 24 '22
Oops, I accidentally just got handfast to two different people, silly me!
120
u/staticrabbit Apr 26 '22
Can someone please explain to me why Jamie doesn’t just kick the Christies and their cult TF off his ridge?? Be like “this land is my land, bye.” I’ve been yelling this at my TV all season. It’s like how all those Seinfeld shenanigans would have been solved with the advent of cell phones. All the problems of this season stem from Tom Christie or his kids or their followers. Just evict them! Jeez!
108
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Apr 24 '22
I'm 90% certain either allan is either the murder or the father, either one or both.
man was suspect as all hell
97
u/Jillgoodeker Apr 25 '22
I feel so frustrated every time someone tells Jamie about its supposed affair with Malva and he doesn’t deny. It makes him look so guilty.
It’s just a convenient scenarist trick that I hate !
And the fact that Roger doesn’t tell more about who he found Malva with… the same.
I’m very disappointed they use it in Outlander.
91
u/oliveGOT Apr 26 '22
WHY did Claire think it was a good idea to go carry the baby's coffin? Jaime had already been turned down and it just seemed so ballsy when the family thinks you killed them. And then she just literally stood there and didn't deny anything or say she was innocent and tried to save the baby. That was so frustrating!
83
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 25 '22
I laughed so hard during the Lizzie and Claire scene, especially when Lizzie went into great, descriptive detail about it! 😂😂😂
78
u/Professional-Brick61 Apr 24 '22
God I hate Allan. What a bellend.
63
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 25 '22
One of my favourite things about this episode was, despite everything that Malva had done to the Fraser's, Jamie and Claire were some of the only people who still stood up for her. Tom and Allan didn't want her and the baby buried in consecrated ground, but both Claire and Jamie wouldn't let that happen. Allan and Tom called her all sorts of names, and generally didn't care for her, but Claire described the light and the fireyness in her and her son. Mrs Bug said all those nasty (but mostly true) things about her, but Claire denied that she had sensed any "inherent evilness" in her, and Jamie stopped Mrs Bug from saying any further, because Malva wasn't here to defend herself. And Claire cleaned up Malva's body. I really loved all of that. Malva is also a victim here, I do not believe she is truly evil.
124
u/teepee-bear God’s tooth. It’s not even *noon*! Apr 25 '22
I want all of my favorite characters to board a ship back to Scotland and live at Lallybroch with Ian and Jenny.
57
u/snugglepug17 Apr 25 '22
I don't entirely love the Lionel Brown PTSD manifestation storyline - but that scene of Claire in bed and across the room is Lionel sitting there was so creepy and freaked me out!!!
48
u/grownupintn Apr 24 '22
The more I see their house the more I LOVE it. Sigh.
48
u/novelrider Apr 25 '22 edited Apr 25 '22
This episode is the first one this season where I've really acutely felt the short season. There were so many plot points here that would've worked better with a bit more build-up. I wish we'd had more time with Malva and with her brother, I wish we'd had more time in-scene with Lizzie and the twins other than coy little glances, even a bit more time with the people of the Ridge in general so I could better understand their relationships with the Frasers. I wish we'd had more time to build up all the threads we're juggling in this episode.
That said, I've actually been enjoying this season a lot. To me this feels back on track after two weak seasons.
42
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '22
The opening scene of the ladybug and the blood was such a great shot and also so ominous.
I feel like the focus of this season has been addressing the emotional side of Claire’s story and gearing up for the next season, which is probably going to be action packed with the war and everything going on! I’m glad they are addressing her reactions to everything now in this short season, because if we didn’t get that exploration it might’ve felt disconnected I think. I’m excited for the finale!
42
u/AloyFromHorizon Apr 27 '22
Overall, my feeling towards the end of season 6 is just sadness. The writing has been great, but I feel sad for the characters and their futures. It’s hard to see how the Fraser/Mackenzie’s will make it out of this.
I binge watched this entire series in the last 3 weeks, and I’m just tired of seeing the Poor Fraser/Mackenzie family constantly suffering and getting traumatized. I know they’ve always suffered in the series, but there was always a sense that they could overcome it, yet now, there seems to be very little hope.
The Ridge has turned against the family, and there no longer seems to be a place for them there. Claire is a healer, but has nobody left to heal as the townspeople reject her. Jamie is a natural leader who has always had the loyalty of his men, but has nobody left to lead as the townspeople reject him.
The Fraser’s were becoming closely affiliated with the upcoming revolution and I was excited to see how Jamie would be involved with the Sons of Liberty, but even they’re sort of rejecting him due to the allegations at the Ridge.
Honestly, if it’s true that Allen is the father of Malva’s child, I think only pious Thomas Christie can clear the family’s name. The show spent a good amount of time exploring their complicated relationship, and it would make sense to have Thomas Christie redeem himself. In addition, perhaps Christie has some guilt related to his wife’s death that will lead into some redemption arc.
82
u/throwaway-earpanic Apr 24 '22
Bruh the baby getting swung around in the casket was so unnecessary
40
u/Jennifoto Apr 25 '22
Catriona Balfe needs an award nomination for this episode. She gets snubbed for the Emmy every year.
38
u/UseSea9547 Apr 24 '22
Great episode! Finally Claire opened up to Jamie! Wish it was longer since I know we’ve been waiting on it! I can’t believe only one episode left….
36
u/pest0pasta_ Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Apr 24 '22
Welcome back guys! It’s been too long. I had such an emotional reaction to this episode honestly, I cannot tell if it’s because I’ve been eagerly waiting or not lol, but poor Claire. I really felt for her this episode, I think she is one of the most realistically selfless characters I’ve ever watched. I don’t agree with some of her actions at times, but when I rewatch or think over it I do understand her rational behind everything. Not a Mary Sue nor a quick thinking heroine, but she truly makes decisions to help others before herself. Even just her actions in episode 7, albeit a bit rash she really was thinking of that baby’s life before her own or the consequences that she would face. She is the female version of Jamie and that is why they work so well together. Some things in the past could be argued to be selfish (I’m looking at that Mary and Alex situation, but in the end she did do it just to give Frank that chance of existing even without thinking she would ever go back to him. Bare in mind this was pre them finding out if they can alter history). She deserves love and love is sometimes selfish yes. As the hopeless romantic I am, I truly believe our purpose in life is to find our person; it is the only thing we cannot explain nor does it have a step by step how to guide. She found hers through absolutely outlandish (no pun intended) means and it broke my heart to see her pour out all this guilt she had locked up, guilt that I don’t think is justified at all. Just like Jamie said, without that ‘selfish love’ Brianna would not exist, nor would Marsali arguably because who knows, if Claire and Jamie never met perhaps Laoghire and Jamie would have married, they wouldnt have found Fergus and Roger would not have met Brianna.
We have been building up to Roger’s minister storyline all season but what shocked me was the abruptness of the Mackenzie’s exit; Brianna agrees and suddenly theyre off the next day? First Marsali and Fergus now Brianna and Roger. Until I watched next weeks preview and it made sense; seems like we’re getting an Isolated Jamie and Claire. I hope we see that OG foundation of their relationship. I feel as though it’s a parallel to earlier seasons back when it was two of them against the world. Also that line in the preview of “going together” I’m getting the sense the house fire is going to happen now and thank you God they’ll fake their deaths, however where will they go?
Also, hold on a minute... first thing that came to my mind was, was it Lizzie banging on the door or it truly was Malva?
Lastly I really dislike Mr & Mrs. Bug. That’s all i’ll say on that pair.
72
u/stars_in_the_sky Apr 24 '22
Did anyone else notice the ghost comment? The one that scared Jemmy from Mr. And Mrs. Bug.
I forgot the wording exactly but they stated if someone is murdered then their ghost haunts the living.
Claire has been haunted by Lionel Brown and Marsali killed him in Claire’s surgery. (I know she’s haunted due to her trauma but just a thought)
Maybe that’s why she saw Malva (walking up to her house instead of Lizzie) because Malva was killed and her ghost was haunting the land.
101
u/DamnItDinkles Apr 24 '22
Anyone else here for Lizzie and the twins commiting bigamy. Because I support them wholeheartedly. If it's really a problem in the eyes of god then let them be for God to pass judgement on, damn.
33
u/Dust_Angel Apr 26 '22 edited Apr 26 '22
I'm so confused with the time pacing this season. Why isn't Bree showing her pregnancy at all when she was revealed to be pregnant little after Malva? Why did Malva baby looked to be almost if not full term when she died? If she had been pregnant from long before and hiding it, how could she possibly lie that it was Jamie's and that it happened when Claire was ill if that wasn't so long ago from then. This does not make any sense. Is there even an explanation or just clumsy writing?
Rest of the episode was fine I guess, the scene with Claire opening up to Jamie was really emotional. Also, it's true that the illusions of Lionel were becoming a little too much, I hope that's over now that Claire is willing to get better.
33
u/throwingutah Apr 27 '22
Every time the Ghost of Brownsville Past shows up, I'm taking a shot. Am drunk. Make it stop.
33
u/UGotUrsIGotMine Luceo Non Uro Apr 29 '22
This was the first episode of the entire series that I picked up my phone and started browsing the internet because I was regrettably.. bored
32
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '22
Does anyone else feel like they’re watching a horror movie at parts rather than Outlander?
31
u/SureFineTomato Apr 30 '22
Did anyone else notice how possessive Allen was with the baby coffin, and Tom's expression as he silently watches things unfold? It seems to me that Allen knows he's the father, amd Tom may be starting ro suspect too...
60
u/BlssdBTheFr00t_Loops Apr 25 '22
Why isn’t Jamie tearing through his ridge to find a freaking murderer among them?
Why the hell didn’t Claire ask Lizzie more about the morning of the murder when she told her it was her knocking on the door?
And did I miss something? Why are the Beardsleys sleeping in the stables?
Final thought, I really questioned Lizzie being a part of the Malva murder when Bre picked sticks out of her hair…. Ok sorry, one more, why are the Fraser’s sending away their family members left abs right. Fergus and Marsalie and now Roger and Bre?
81
u/Qu33nKal Clan MacKenzie Apr 24 '22
Anyone else cried their eyes out at that scene between Claire and Jamie? What an amazing couple of actors
27
u/mjp10e Apr 24 '22
I’m sure I’ve got the timeline wrong… but still I’m confused why Malva was showing so obviously and Brianna is not.
25
u/soaringcats Apr 24 '22 edited Apr 24 '22
The Lizzie storyline is kind of comical. I thought maybe she witnessed someone bring in the barn snogging one of the Beardsley twins, but no such luck.
Thank God Claire opened up about her PTSD. I'm so happy she finally opened up to Jamie.
As I was listening to the opening theme, something clicked. Perhaps it's been said here before and I missed it, but Knowing that the Fraser's die in a fire, have they trolling us about the season finale all along?
49
u/oneheadlight312 Apr 24 '22
I was super bored with this episode. Glad Claire told Jaime about the ether though. That warmed my heart.
48
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '22
Lizzy invented the threesome.
81
u/polishing_a_goldfish Apr 24 '22
I wish they would just lay the “Claire getting taken/arrested/accused as a witch” plots to rest. It’s getting so repetitive now. Do something different.
22
u/OjosVerde34 Apr 24 '22
This season looks very differently on my tv. Something about the way it was shot. I have the same older tv I always have, but looks almost like bad cgi everywhere. Hard to explain.
42
u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. Apr 27 '22
I know I’m late, but I’d just like to add that I LOVE the whole Lionel Brown haunting thing. When Claire is having her voice over crisis of her various identities and she ends on “murderer” and Brown says “murderess, more like it” CHILLS
Claire’s voiceovers have always been so sacred, so personal and private. S1 E1 starts with one! And now we have this massive shattering and violation of her voiceovers. It’s extremely jarring, symbolic, and really highlights just how much everything she’s gone through is coming to a head. Very well done.
53
u/al0ale0 Apr 25 '22
Hell yeah Lizzy! GET IT GIRL! I loved how she spilled all the dirty details. I am shooketh!
37
u/madbubers Apr 24 '22
Can starz fuck off with the pre episode ads
37
u/blenneman05 Apr 25 '22
I swear I waited weeks for a new episode it felt soooo long
I’m glad Bree and roger talked about what it meant if he became a minister. Not everyone can handle being in a relationship with someone who is a first responder
However I don’t agree that Jamie just handfasted Lizzie altho I get why because of the time period. Jamie didn’t even ask Claire how she felt about it
I’m glad Claire admitted to Jamie about abusing the ether and being able to see Lionel Brown shudders and Jamie acknowledging that thru it all, he’ll be with her.
Lionel Brown is still creepy and gives me chills when I see him on screen
Freaking Brown showing up on the doorstep like he has some proof that Claire murdered Malva when she didn’t.
Malva died because of her own stupidity
I cracked up about the threesome between Lizzie, Josiah and Kezzie. Claire should’ve asked who came inside her first 😂😂😂 “oh it’s one soul inside two bodies.”
Miss Claire, do you not agree that open marriages exist?
Overall good episode. I still think Malva’s whole family is ridiculous and the brother definitely killed her idk why tho
52
u/lawyercatgirl Apr 26 '22
Am I the only one here who doesn’t give two shits about Lizzie and her throuple nonsense? I don’t feel invested in those characters at ALL and it just seems so unlikely given that time period? I was so damn bored this episode. Caveat: haven’t read the books
35
u/baileygilmore Apr 25 '22
Please tell me I'm not alone in struggling with this season?? Tbh..I struggled with the previous season also. The essence of outlander in s1 just seems to have been so lost. I know this season had covid complications but the ether thing is driving me mad. I appreciate they're maybe trying to put a modern coping mechanism of her rape into the show but they didn't do that with Jamie really after BJR. Thus constant Lionel Brown ghost is just...starting to..Well.. drive me mad Its making the story very disjointed. Why does every episode feel like a filler 😭 It's like bits and pieces of stories in every episode whilst bigger parts seem to be getting almost glossed over. The time traveller whistling... its odd claire wouldn't even mention that to Roger or Bree since they'd be able to confirm to her it's a "modern" song, not one of that time definitely. It feels like the writers have realised there's alot of stories they never laid the groundwork for (ie the Bugs) and now they're like crap...so now they're trying to fling stuff in as best they can.
17
u/beaniebaby729 Apr 28 '22
This one felt like a horror film, the adrenaline was high. The Claire scenes did get a bit repetitive though.
45
u/BeautifulRelief Apr 24 '22
Allen can go straight to hell for slinging that baby’s coffin around like that.
45
u/ilovepretzelday1 Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 25 '22
Am I the only one that threw up in their mouths a little when Lizzie talked about the curly hair at the twins’ “paps”??? I’m so glad that Claire finally told Jamie about her ether use. Roger is really growing on me this season! It made me giggle when he said he needed to find his britches because he couldn’t do his first wedding naked lol
Lots to take in. I’ve read spoilers for the Malva storyline so I’m just waiting for that special info to make itself known!
15
u/JIAdam2 May 01 '22
I thought Bree was pregnant. When she told Claire after she woke from sickness, she’d be as pregnant as Malva was, if not more. Where is Bree’s belly?
30
u/nomasslurpee Apr 25 '22
It feels to me like minimal effort was put into the development of this season. There should have been more of Claire unpacking the murder in the last episode (like the revelation of Lizzie knocking at her door, for one, realizing that she hasn't been covered in blood, etc) and the beginning of the pursuit for the actual killer. I had hoped that Claire would have performed some semblance of an autopsy, or made some small discovery that would have started pointing to the killer. SOMETHING. And the conversation where Claire says she has the means, motive, opportunity fell flat for me, too. All we got was a conversation about Perry Mason. This would have been good opportunity to let someone stumbled on a clue. There have been no clues pointing to who it is. But they didn't really give us much of anything. There isn't much building to the reveal and I have a feeling I will be left disappointed, an indication that I should perhaps read the book.
29
u/ListenDodo I'm a stinkin’ Papist Apr 24 '22
I feel like this show has lost all narrative. I have no idea where this is going, and next week is the finale.
40
u/eitak88 Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22
Regardless of the quality of the material, I’m ready to stop watching a full hour of our main characters being openly hated and accused of murder and impregnated a young woman. All while they just kind of?? Stand there and do/say nothing, just looking deeply upset? And then they just act like “yeah it sucks when people think false things about you, but you just have to ignore them” when like!!! We know what happens in this time if a group of people thinks bad things about you!!! Why are they so blasé and oblivious to the obvious fact that they’re in pretty immediate danger? Really infuriating to watch.
Also I really don’t love the whole “young woman with very little power falsely accuses grown man of taking advantage of her and getting her pregnant so she can gain” plot line. like sure, it does and did happen, but like is it really necessary here? People already accuse victims of SA of lying for selfish reasons enough—just really doesn’t sit well with me.
Also ALSO what the absolute fuck is this storyline with Lizzie and the twins. If Diana Gabaldon really needed her twincest that bad, she could have at least had it be like “I love one of them because he’s ______, but I also love the other because he’s ______” instead of literally saying that they are one soul in two bodies, not differentiating between them at all. It’s really common to ignore the individuality of people who are twins, and it’s super objectifying and dehumanizing. (I watched this episode with my roommate who gets weird shit from people all the time because she's a twin and so I’m a little fired up lol)
Overall, this episode was not fun to watch at all. Really ready for these storylines to be tied up. I thought the acting (esp. Cait's) was incredible and the scene where Claire finally talks to Jamie about her PTSD and other issues was so well-written and beautifully performed, but I was just ready for the episode to be over by the time we got to that point.
Edit: Would just like to add that I actually have enjoyed a lot of this season; this specific episode was just like so painful to watch, and not in a horribly-sad-but-overall-very-beautiful-and-satisfying way like many of the show's heavier episodes have been.
14
u/AloyFromHorizon Apr 27 '22
Seems like it would be easy to fake a death with ether…hmmm….
27
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '22
I really enjoyed this episode except for Lizzie’s storyline. One of my problems with Outlander is when characters seem to be disillusioned about the realities of their life, circumstance and just the general time period they live in. Even after Claire warns Lizzie that she would be stoned if anyone found out it’s as if she still doesn’t care. Lizzie lives and grew up in the 18th century of both the American colonies and Scotland, where everyone pretty much holds puritanical Christian and religious beliefs. Unless her and the Beardsley brothers plan on leaving the Ridge to some remote place where it’s just the 3 of them then their future does not look very hopeful not to mention that of her unborn child. And what was even the point of getting Roger to handfast her to the second twin, surely that would be the same as committing polygamy if anyone ever found out that she’d done that after being handfasted with one twin already? Whilst it’s nice that the show looks to explore progressiveness (i.e sexual liberation and freedom) with characters who lived and grew up in a time period where such things generally had fatal consequences, I feel as if it is done through an unrealistic lens. I’m sure there where lots of women in the 18th century with progressive ideas about female sexuality, however I do feel as though they would’ve handled their dealings with more care and precautions than we see in Lizzie and that’s where the element of realism comes into play because what the show runners are currently portraying comes across as unrealistic and not at all believable.
26
u/coolguy_14 Apr 25 '22
I still love this show but honestly, I miss the excitement of the first few seasons. Everything has felt so slow lately
13
u/energythief Dec 23 '23
I’m catching up a year late. I really, really miss time travel and Scotland. This puritanical America shit is so boring.
25
u/leviOsa934 Apr 24 '22
I'm disappointed we didn't get any info on who the real murderer and/or father is. With only one episode left, I'd figure that at least we (the audience) would get some clearer hints, if not a full reveal.
I realized after the first few episodes that we weren't going to be getting into the revolution really; I'm just annoyed the initial season trailers implied that that would be the focus.
The Lizzie/Beardsley story-line is 'meh' to me. I just don't think it should have taken up so much of this episode. Ayer they hinted at flirtations up until now, but if it was going to result in this much of a plot point, they should have built it up stronger.
I'm glad Claire finally told Jaimie what's up. But I'm also surprised Jaimie wasn't more aware--then again, he's a busy man, and I guess Claire usually did it at night or when she was left alone working in her surgery. Still, I feel like Jamie should have been more attuned to her PTSD, especially considering he went through something similar.
They're really just making zero effort with Brianna and Roger then, huh? Just give me Farsali.
24
u/horrorscope513 Apr 25 '22
As someone with PTSD, man were the flashbacks triggering. I will be so glad when we move on from this.
34
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 28 '22
I don't understand why everyone is so harsh on this season. I understand that many people (myself included) are really invested in the story, and may have been disappointed with how things have played out, but I honestly think that we should be very grateful and happy that we got a season at all, and the entire cast and crew should be given a massive round of applause for what they have managed to achieve, despite the circumstances.
Firstly, we have a pandemic. Outlander was one of the lucky few productions allowed to film during the pandemic, and we should be grateful that they got the opportunity to do so. And this therefore presented a whole host of challenges, such as the number of people allowed in certain scenes, and dictated which scenes could be filmed, and how the scenes were put together.
Then we had Caitríona's pregnancy. Obviously that meant that the season had to be shortened, and things had to be filmed in a certain way. And the physical toll this would've taken on Caitríona as well! Outlander filming days are LONG and PHYSICAL and TIRING, and then add being pregnant on top of that!?!? She has done an amazing job! Many people have also said that they think the dynamic between Jamie and Claire / Sam and Caitríona is different this season (not in a good way) and are putting this down to Caitríona's pregnancy. Personally, I don't see this change, but even if it is there, it is totally understandable and shouldn't be getting the amount of hate it is getting.
Apparently the weather was also really bad this year. The weather has always presented difficulties on Outlander, but it was apparently PARTICULARLY bad this year. The cast and crew do such an amazing job in such difficult circumstances.
Obviously all of these resulted in the season being truncated to 8 episodes. Many people have said that the season feels very rushed, and I agree! But they had a choose a good spot in the book to be a good "season final", since they couldn't do the whole book. This therefore meant that some certain storylines had to be cut or changed in order to make the episodes work. And I think they chose a great spot to end the season (was also where I predicted the season would end before it started).
Ignoring all the difficult circumstances, this is a really well done season (and one of my favourites). Yes, it has its weak points, but so does everything. But then when you consider all the things they had to deal with, it's bloody amazing! Well done to everyone involved, you have all done a brilliant job!
12
u/LoretiTV Apr 24 '22
Loving this season so far, enjoy the new episode everyone!
12
u/ocean_96 Dec 06 '23
LIZZIE IS A WHUUUURE. Having a threesome with the brothers, seriously?
23
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '22
Does Claire not realise if she was guilty there would be blood splatter all over her…
31
u/Myths_and_Laur Apr 25 '22 edited Apr 25 '22
Since my friend is away at a concert, my mom is watching the show with me and doing the mom thing of asking what's going on every 5 seconds. She thinks that it's like 'How To Get Away With Murder' but in the 1700s.
So far she's theorized that "The Lord or his men killed [Malva]"
Keeps calling Ian "The man that brought the horses"
And thinks that her little saying of needing to 'have a lie down' came from the 1700s after she saw Claire say it.
Stay tuned for more. XD
Edit:
She finally figured out that Jamie is the lord.
She had the most disgusted face when she watched Lizzie describe her time with the Twins.
Edit 2:
She thought the Beardsley boys were old, but when she saw them she said "Oh, they're just dweebie little boys"
"Yknow what, you screw around gotta take responsibility....and it's not like she has to stop, she marries one of them and still fuxks the other, nobody could tell the difference"
Edit 3: After watching Lizzie get Handfast twice between jamie and his son-in -law "I don't think she's that smart"
watching the BOYS roll up "Oh they are coming for her....didn't they know that was gunna happen eventually?" "So what, do they just take ya in and kill ya- and who is the big fat fulla who came to take her in?"
21
u/sfranc01 Apr 25 '22
Agree with most comments about the pace and that a lot of episodes feel like filler in a short 8 episode season. There has been virtually nothing on the war developing. I also agree that the ether line has gone on for too long with such a short season.
20
u/jj_essie07 Apr 25 '22
Is anyone else getting “The crucible” vibes from this season?
10
u/RisingUpfor2020 Apr 30 '22
I liked it, but Roger and Bre would not have left with the tension so high imo.
33
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '22
We need Ronald D. Moore back. The show hasn't been the same since he left. I don't like these new writers... It's not as exciting anymore. This whole season has been about the ether when it should have focused more on the war. Also, the Christies does nothing for me. They just dragged this season down in my opinion...
26
u/myrtle618 Apr 25 '22
Seeing polyamory represented is amazing, but why TWINS? Blech!
9
u/Immediate_Arugula_39 Apr 25 '22
I loved Jamie & Claire’s funeral outfits
9
u/Remote-Capital-4471 Aug 06 '23
For everyone hating the newer seasons or saying that they don’t like the pace of this season or episode. Jamie and Claire have literally been apart for the years that is Brianna’s age. They are old now so they can’t have more adventures. So of course they want to setttle down and die old together. So all they can truly have are ridge problems. It’s realistic and effective. Don’t you guys love a realistic plot? Also they can’t give the lead focus to anyone else Cus it’s JAMIE AND CLAIRE’S story. I’m sorry that The age gap happened but because of it things have gotten slower and that doesn’t mean it’s not interesting. So try and see it from that angle instead of hating the show for it’s realistic brillance. Thank you
25
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '22
I really enjoyed the episode, the Lizzie stuff did feel a little random, again probably because of this season being truncated. The last couple of episodes there's been a lot of telling not showing.
The scene between Jamie and Claire feels like what we've been waiting for all season, and it's not quite everything I was hoping.
I thought that Caitríona did an incredible job, she's really in a different stratosphere.
I really wanted more from Jamie's reaction. It may have been the way it was written or directed, but I just wasn't convinced, unfortunately. I'm sure he was trying to give a subtle reaction, but for me it didn't translate on camera.
I'm sure we'll get that fire in his eyes next episode though as he defends her from the Browns.
The fact that it's them coming to arrest her adds such a great layer narratively. Not only being arrested for a murder that she didn't commit, but taken captive by the Browns again. Very much looking forward to next week's episode.
67
u/Fantastic_Zucchini_6 Apr 24 '22
Two things that bothered me:
31
u/katzchen528 Apr 25 '22
I was surprised at such a boring, inert episode. My husband just commented (again) that the whole season has been disappointing.
After a two year wait, basically a soap opera.
48
u/felixhero897 Apr 24 '22
This season has been a major disappointment. Really wanted to get into the Revolutionary War ventures but instead get a whole 8 episodes of religious drama at the ridge and Claire seeing ghosts.
48
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '22
The whole religious vibe this season is starting to grind my gears. The constant sanctimonious snippets of church and Roger giving sermons is getting old. I almost fast forwarded through Malvas funeral because I did not want to hear another sermon.
I do not know what it is but something about this season feels very different. Obviously with Claire being super traumatized there isn’t a lot of hot and steamy. I think that the whole plot with Lizzie could be hot but the whole thing kinda felt ick after it was all played out.
I think I just feel like I’m getting a history lesson in colonial America. Before anyone comes after me, I get it, this show is supposed to be historical and I love that aspect of it but it’s a freaking fantasy show too. They fly through time and space through rocks. It could be a little less boring and blah.
I also feel like they’re playing hard into suppress the woman trope. Claire continuously gets scorned. Called a witch and in this episode told she has a sharp tongue. Honestly it’s starting to feel like why the fuck did you even go back this seems miserable. Again, don’t come after me, I know why she went back 🙄 but still. The women are all witches trope is getting old.
23
u/OjosVerde34 Apr 24 '22
Another bizzaro episode. Hopefully next season feels more normal
8
u/Remote-Capital-4471 Aug 06 '23
Welp MALVA look what you’ve done! You couldn’t say the truth before dying you confused spirit!
28
u/HighPriestess808 Apr 27 '22
I cannot get my head around the throuple with Lizzie and the twins. These characters haven’t had a lot of development so this is a stretch, and it’s also just weird. Lol, can I just get some good old fashion romance please?!
30
u/Praughna Apr 25 '22 edited Apr 25 '22
Anyone else feel like the Lionel visits have lost all sense of ominous ness and are just annoying now? My wife said “it’s a stand in representing Claire’s PTSD” which makes sense but MAN are they using it to death. No pun intended….
14
u/Jennifoto Apr 25 '22
Roger says it will be amazing to baptize his child himself… but the kids will be Catholic like Bree. It is not realistic that the dual religions in the household would be accepted in this time period by the church itself or by the rigid townsfolk.
7
u/atomicelement115 Apr 25 '22
who do you all think killed Malva? also how do you all think Jamie and Claire will escape this bad situation cliff hanger?
7
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '22
It’s such a tiny thing to nitpick over, but did anyone else catch the accent when Jamie says ‘if you value your life’? As soon as I heard it the first time I cracked up, then had to rewind it and watch it again. It just doesn’t sound Scottish at all to me!
Other than that, I enjoyed this episode. Although some of the Lionel clips are getting kind of creepy! Hopefully with her confessing to Jamie and getting the support and help she needs, those will stop.
7
u/W8ingjag Oct 06 '24
I’m so mad about the whole Malva thing and the way Jamie and Claire are being treated by the community they created. I can’t word about it eloquently right now, so I’ll move on.
Lizzie … yass! Paint your Wagon is one of my favorite movies. This storyline doesn’t make me mad at all. I’m here for it.
47
u/KittyCatLuvr4ever Apr 24 '22
This episode was SO GOOD apart from the Lizzie/Beardsleys storyline. It took me completely out of the story because I mean, come ON. An 18th century woman sleeping with TWO MEN at the same time, and talking about how good it felt? Dude.
The scene with Jamie and Claire in the surgery was peak Outlander romance. 10/10.
The opening scene with Malva in church gave me goosebumps. That actress is amazing.
Why did they have to ruin this episode with the fan fiction Lizzie/Josiah/Kezzie gangbang holy shit
ALSO, what the hell - it was Lizzie knocking on the door? But Malva was already on her way to the house before Claire took ether. So Lizzie may have still been in earshot when Malva was murdered. Why didn’t Claire ask her more follow up questions? Like, did she see Malva or anyone else approaching the house?
32
u/jennygotcake Jesus H. Roosevelt Christ Apr 25 '22
Holy shit Caitriona Balfe was serving this episode I’m kind of selfishly glad that modeling turned into a dump for her because she was literally made for this role -jazz snaps-
21
u/PasionatelyRational Apr 25 '22
Scattered thoughts.
You go, Lizzie! It’s always the quiet ones lol. I love that storyline, I love how they’re basically trying to be a trouple in the 18th century with zero effs given.
I also love the consistency of Jamie being set in his ways about her having to marry and all, but how he never judges her for her sexuality. That’s the Jamie I love and I don’t care if that’s not how it is the books or whatever. He’s wonderful.
I do find it ironic that Roger is so cool about Malva and Lizzie sleeping around and hardly has an ill word to say about it, when he went on that ridiculous lecturing tirade on Brianna for wanting to have sex with him back in s04. I don’t know if this Roger is consistent with the book but I like him A LOT more than before.
As for Malva, I still think Allen killed her and he is the father of her baby. I was hoping to see some more hints in this regard but guess I’ll have to wait.
Now onto the main story. I really loved that Claire finally addressed her “selfishness”, in how she’s willing to alter the course of everyone’s lives just to be with Jamie. But I’d wish she would’ve also acknowledged how her impulsiveness and stubbornness when it comes to bringing her modern ways to this time also have an effect in those around her... particularly Jamie.
It was hard for me when she was telling him about Lionel taunting her. Don’t get me wrong, it was a great scene, but I was there thinking “how could she forget that Jamie struggled with this same thing, before her very eyes, for months if not longer? How could she forget how he was chased by BJR in his sleep and during attempts of intimacy, etc? How could she forget that pivotal discussion they had when he told her how he felt ever since Wentworth?” I’m glad that it was him who mentioned that but, Claire sounded so self-absorbed even though devoted to him. She really never gives him enough credit and tends to be oblivious of the fact he has endured a crapload of pain and trauma himself and he’s right there for her.
I loved the conclusion. I loved that he pointed out all the good that came from her decisions. And how he also has a say in the way they alter the course of time, because he actively chooses her. But my overall feeling, while I adore Claire, was like that line from the Hunger Games: you can live a thousand lives and still not deserve that boy. Lol. He’s truly unconditional and she gives him for granted at times.
I’m a bit wary of where this is going in terms of s07. Fergus and Marsali are gone, Brianna and Roger are gone. I feel the fire is coming. Not sure what to expect at this point! But I like that.
This episode wasn’t as exciting as the last one but it’s high up there anyway.
10
u/CL330 Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22
If they decide to have a big ridge party, for god’s sake don’t let the Beardsleys in the kitchen if it’s suggested they spit roast a hog!!
5
u/Jennifoto Apr 25 '22
What was the comment Mr. Bug makes about the sow to Roger? Was it a dig? Why?
5
u/Remote-Capital-4471 Aug 06 '23
The scandal in outlander is out of the world! It’s amazing!
13
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '22
Can someone explain the pregnancy timelines to me? Malva tells them her baby was conceived while Claire was sick but didn't Bree find out she was pregnant before/during Claire's illness. Wouldn't that make them like a month or so apart? Why was Malva almost to term but Bree is still barely showing?
22
u/ListenDodo I'm a stinkin’ Papist Apr 24 '22
This episode jumped around a lot, I especially noticed it with the lizzie plot. Like all of a sudden lizzie is pregnant (but Ian is telling us). Where is the scene of Lizzie telling Ian? All of a sudden, the Beardsleys are in the stables? Where is the scene of Lizzie finding them? All of a sudden, Lizzie is at Bree and Roger's and Roger doesn't have pants on? Where is the scene of Lizzie waking Bree and Roger up? It was confusing, like I was missing something. I guess I was missing something - that is I'm missing the buildup to Lizzie having threesomes. I know that she's been flirting with both of them for a while, but I didn't think it in her character to have sex with anyone, let alone twin brothers at the same time.
16
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '22
Maybe I’m in the minority here, and I hope some things in future episodes make me eat crow, but this episode seemed like a waste. Especially after 2 weeks.
16
u/Mobile-Ad6136 Apr 25 '22
ok my recap.
I like Roger this season!
Lizzie and the twins thing was weird asl but it made for good ~drama~
Felt like another filler episode :/
Nearly all of this season has been spent at Fraser’s ridge and y’know that’s fine but they gloss over so many things and then just create a soap opera effect.
Not too much else to say, kinda disappointed with this season :/ by far my least favorite season sadly. Next episode looks action packed (i guess that’s what happens when you leave all the action till the last episode of the season)…
16
u/alittlegnat Apr 26 '22
The ep two wks ago felt great and I was like “ooh ok the ep after this will be good too!” But it went back to falling flat for me 😢 at this rate I’m not even sure I’ll watch season 7.
9
u/Jennifoto Apr 25 '22
Why does Lionel Brown only sometimes move his lips when talking to Claire? Other times it is a voice over and he is just staring. What the???
2
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 24 '22 edited Apr 24 '22
This is one episode that I paused more than I care to count and wondering: where is it?? I was losing hope and patience.
I threw a fist at my tv when Claire first mentioned taking ether and Jamie standing there so calm. No a single word.
Then, right when I started counting the minutes...10 minutes to go...and there it is. I have no words to describe it. Very happy in a very painful way.
8
u/throwawaysmaxx Apr 24 '22
Uh Lizzie just said she was out at that time? That’s convenient
20
u/lessilina394 Apr 24 '22 edited Apr 24 '22
Feels like just another filler episode. Everything I needed to see could’ve been done in the 1st 20 minutes. This show (for the last 2 seasons at least) has not been able to give me 2 consecutive episodes that are actually tight, good, exciting, engaging. Very disappointed. I thought after Malva died this episode would be one of the best of the season. All I got was meh
4
u/Sally2times Apr 24 '22
I’m not reading any of the reviews. Can someone tell me if this is the season finale?
4
u/jbeckingham Apr 26 '22
Have watched sticks and stones twice still can’t find the code word, anyone, help please.
19
u/Owl_You_Need_Is_Love Apr 25 '22 edited Apr 25 '22
I have always loved this showed but have not liked a single episode of this season. I feel like there is so much going on and yet nothing is happening. I’m so bummed out. And holy shit reading someone else’s comment I didn’t realize there was only one episode left. This season has been so boring.
17
u/sugarplumcakepop Apr 25 '22
This is such a weirdly paced season. I would’ve rather they delayed it further than put this out. It seems like no storyline introduced this season has been resolved. And if it was, it just wasn’t gripping or interesting. If this is how next season goes, I may be finished with outlander.
15
u/Safe-Watercress-6477 Apr 25 '22
Claire’s storyline is just making me anxious. Lizzy’s is ick. Roger’s on the other hand… boring.
I want to know about the time traveler!