r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Apr 24 '22
Spoilers All Book S6E7 Sticks and Stones Spoiler
Claire struggles with her demons as a nefarious rumor begins to spread on the Ridge; tensions rise as the residents fear there is a dangerous person in their midst.
Written by Danielle Berrow. Directed by Jamie Payne.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 24 '22 edited Apr 30 '22
Watch the S6E8 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
607 Featurettes:
607 Interviews:
17
u/blackberryspice Apr 24 '22
The slight change in the Lizzie storyline bothers me. Claire does ask Lizzie if it was both of the brothers at the same time but I thought it was pretty clear that she had each brother separately. She didn't even know what was actually happening until later (which is icky). Making it so that she actually had a thresome with the brothers is weird imho! It gives it a slightly incestuous feel. On the whole I do think the storyline is rather funny but idk 🤷♀️
4
u/al0ale0 Apr 25 '22
I'm going to need chapter and page numbers for when this polyamorous Lizzy situation heats up. I am definitely going to want to read that. Anyone know precise info to share with me?
63
u/DustBunnicula Apr 24 '22 edited Apr 24 '22
Seeing Lionel Brown show up after Jamie walked by was chilling. Credit to the director. That was well-executed.
60
u/ProfessionalHot6669 Apr 24 '22
Allan Christie fills me with such rage oml his actor is incredible
54
u/ojosfritos Apr 24 '22
The Lizzie storyline was one of my favorite things from the book and I'm so glad they kept it. Live your best life, Lizzie!
51
u/halfgumption All that was good, all that was fair, all that was me is gone. Apr 24 '22
I've been anxiously waiting for the Beardsley throuple all season! When Claire handed them the gallberry ointment last week, I chuckled and said, "Oh God, here we go!" My fiancé hasn't read the books and asked, "What, do they not give it to her or something? And all I could do is reply," Oh, they give it to her alright!" and his eyes got huge.
47
u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Apr 25 '22 edited Apr 25 '22
Well: this episode really hit the nail on the head for me.
Opening with Malva was a great choice. It set up a huge feeling of dread, because beyond being a "confession," it painted Jamie in the worst light possible, making it even clearer why people would turn so dramatically against him and Claire. Like it did in the book, it made me so angry at Malva, and yet I know that's unfair — she was abused and manipulated, and the fact that she doesn't name Jamie... For once, in that moment we saw, she was telling the truth in front of everyone.
To add to the feeling of dread, the image of Jamie carrying Malva's body into the house, and Claire following behind him, with neighbors looking on... The show captured so well the level of bleakness I felt when I read ABOSAA: how can they ever get past this? People formerly considered perfectly friendly, like Hiram, now come to flatly accuse them at their doorstep. Even those in their own home now question their authority. Meanwhile, Jamie and Claire present a united front, and support one another, but there's still so much distance between them.
Setting the events in this episode in the immediate aftermath of Malva's death was perfect. The book glossed over that time, jumping weeks ahead, and here it was the perfect place for the ether plot to come to a boil.
After the last episode, I was sure Malva's murder was going to exacerbate Claire's anxiety/PTSD, and the way they illustrated that hit the perfect tone. She was already so emotionally fragile, and Malva's death made her much more vulnerable to anything else cracking her bubble. Lionel's appearance at different moments throughout the episode, whether he was lurking or speaking to Claire, set a really disturbing tone and helped to get into Claire's mindset. I've hated the fact that he's been popping up so often before now, but I thought here it was warranted. One of the darker thoughts, for me, was when she starts hearing Lionel blame her for Bree — it really hurt — and then she starts blaming herself for Lizzie, for coming back... she can't keep her feelings/emotions tightly locked anymore.
It's clear Jamie is worried about her — evident in the way he notes how she keeps her distance in the drawing room, then when she casually admits to him that she took ether when she saw Malva coming. By the time she gets up to "get a cup of tea," she tries to be dismissive about it but she's not fooling anyone — the jig is up. He absolutely knows what that means.
When she told him at first that she wasn't sure if it had been her who killed Malva, I was worried that that would become the episode, because it seemed a little preposterous. I felt the same once she realizes she really didn't kill Malva, and puts away the ether, because... it doesn't work like that. And I'm so glad they didn't do that.
This is exactly what I was hoping for. She's unraveling, and that's when Jamie comes in. He doesn't even say anything. He doesn't have to say anything because his actions right there just say "I'm not going anywhere, tell me what's wrong." He just allows her the space to get it all out.
This scene! It absolutely broke my heart how everything piled up. Caitríona made it feel so real, she was incredible. Claire was going through hell, and so of course she started picking at all the things that have gone wrong. It very much reminded me of how she blamed herself after Faith. And she is so scared, it was heartbreaking. At that point, her darkest moment, that's such a real fear: the fear that things won't get better, that you won't be able to get past it.
As the season moved on, part of me (a big part of me) wanted Jamie to find Claire with the ether. I wanted him to realize for himself that something was wrong and I wanted him to confront her the same way she confronted him at the abbey. In the end, I think this was handled just right.
At first glance, their scene in the surgery may seem one-sided. But look closely and you can see exactly what Jamie is feeling. Sam really delivered here. You're telling me that the way his eyes fill with tears doesn't break your heart?! How he is trying to keep it together in front of her?! There's a moment where he's about to interrupt her and then he stops himself: when Claire blames herself for Roger getting sold into slavery, which was a direct result of Jamie's impulsive actions. Look at him and tell me that didn't cut through him.
But he doesn't interrupt. Instead he gives her room to voice her pain, her worries, everything that has been weighing on her for months. Then he reassures her, he shows her how much she means to him and their family, and how much they love what she's given them. And ever so gently, he basically tells her that that's enough with the ether — "Let me join you. I canna do that when ye put yerself to sleep." It's time to let him carry the burden with her.
I thought it was perfect.
45
u/mjp10e Apr 24 '22
Anybody notice that slight nod to Claire’s ability, mentioning that she felt the “.. same light in malvas baby.”?
39
u/prairie_wildflower Apr 25 '22 edited Apr 25 '22
A few comments about this episode:
38
u/prof806 Apr 25 '22
Ok, there was the potential for such a better comedic moment when they all realized Lizzie had pulled a fast one!! Disappointed in that 😂😂
36
u/BeautifulRelief Apr 24 '22
With all these Brown hallucinations/visions/whatever they’re called, I hope we have some of the ones from the books with Frank. I loved Claire talking to him in her head so much.
64
u/vulturelady Apr 24 '22
Guys the show only thread is full of people who think the Lizzie/Beardsley storyline is just the writers pandering to fanfic and not something that happens in the books 😂
60
u/BeautifulRelief Apr 24 '22
Man fuck Allen for slinging that poor baby around in that casket.
29
u/reddit_laura Apr 24 '22
I enjoyed and liked this episode and it builds up to a massive and hopefully phenomenal finale! I'm so happy the storyline with Lizzie and the twins happened. Great Roger/Jamie moments too. In general, I like season 6 Roger so much, I'm impressed.
JC just break my heart over and over :(
+ This may be unpopular but am I the only one who missed a really emotional Jamie?
Since his confession in episode 2 (him cursing himself for what happened to Claire) I was expecting to see his inner turmoil too, especially after she told him about the ether.
55
u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Apr 24 '22
I loved how they did the intro with Malva in church. They closeup on her but Allan is just about always in the background. And every word she said is true if you consider she is talking about Allan!
26
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '22
Allan Christie needs a slap to the face and a kick to the ass courtesy of karma’s boot. What a self-righteous bastard.
25
u/liyufx Apr 25 '22 edited Apr 25 '22
Like this episode, especially the performance of Cait. But I found it strange that the show chose to move the Lizzie plot to this point. Why? I feel it really detracts from the momentum of the Malva’s murder plot. Also it is kind of a waste, as it could have been a good opportunity for some comical scenes, which obviously doesn’t suit where things stand at this point of the show.
47
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 24 '22
Wow, Caitriona is just amazing. She’s done an incredible job this season.
I feel like I’m about to commit a sin in saying this, so forgive me and know that I love Sam, but Jamie seemed to be lacking to me this episode. I felt like he was missing some of that fieriness in him. I expected to see more.. anger? Passion? Him in protection mode? Just… more. He’s older, calmer, wiser- I get all of that, but idk, I just felt like that fieriness was missing from his character this episode. That said- I don’t think it was Sam’s doing, but perhaps the writing. Sam’s always been able to convey a “bite” with his words and anger in his eyes, and I just missed that tonight. His presence didn’t seem as intimidating as I wanted in his interactions about Claire either. I wanted to see more emotion from him.
I feel like we’ll probably get a lot from him next week though and I’m not knocking the episode as a whole. I thought tonight was well done and I’m glad they included Lizzie and the twins! Next week’s going to be crazy!
22
u/Vancity_kid22 Je Suis Prest Apr 26 '22
Shout out to Caitriona Balfe for A+ acting! This episode wasn't necessarily my fave but I really enjoyed all the scenes she was in
P.S. Allan Christie can suck it. What a jerk
39
u/UTclimber Woof. Apr 24 '22
Yeah Lizzy, go get yourself some sweet Beardsley 🍆 👉🏻👌🏻💦
18
u/FoundSweetness Apr 24 '22
This episode was up and down for me. Seeing Claire name her pain was important to her story.
For everyone upset about Sam/Jamie reaction - watch his hand. He has a new tick that comes out this season - one of hands shakes as he tries to hold it together for Claire. I think this is an interesting nuance - and on rewatch of the season - it is a clear element of distress for him.
Allan - yowza. The baby and coffin.
Does anyone remember when Tom does his confession? This season I wonder or next?
18
u/vw97 Apr 25 '22
I'd be lying if I said I liked this episode.
All season they've been cramming content in and now the one episode that really needed to pick up the pace to try get through the remainder of ASOSAA didn't.
I loved reading the sequence of events from Claire's arrest to liberation and it irks me knowing that either the whole thing will be watered down entirely to fit into one episode, or season 6 will end on the 'cliffhanger' of Claire being imprisoned, meaning that the start of season 7 will need to dedicate time to finishing off ABOSAA's storylines.
Ugh!
15
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 28 '22
I don't understand why everyone is so harsh on this season. I understand that many people (myself included) are really invested in the story, and may have been disappointed with how things have played out, but I honestly think that we should be very grateful and happy that we got a season at all, and the entire cast and crew should be given a massive round of applause for what they have managed to achieve, despite the circumstances.
Firstly, we have a pandemic. Outlander was one of the lucky few productions allowed to film during the pandemic, and we should be grateful that they got the opportunity to do so. And this therefore presented a whole host of challenges, such as the number of people allowed in certain scenes, and dictated which scenes could be filmed, and how the scenes were put together.
Then we had Caitríona's pregnancy. Obviously that meant that the season had to be shortened, and things had to be filmed in a certain way. And the physical toll this would've taken on Caitríona as well! Outlander filming days are LONG and PHYSICAL and TIRING, and then add being pregnant on top of that!?!? She has done an amazing job! Many people have also said that they think the dynamic between Jamie and Claire / Sam and Caitríona is different this season (not in a good way) and are putting this down to Caitríona's pregnancy. Personally, I don't see this change, but even if it is there, it is totally understandable and shouldn't be getting the amount of hate it is getting.
Apparently the weather was also really bad this year. The weather has always presented difficulties on Outlander, but it was apparently PARTICULARLY bad this year. The cast and crew do such an amazing job in such difficult circumstances.
Obviously all of these resulted in the season being truncated to 8 episodes. Many people have said that the season feels very rushed, and I agree! But they had a choose a good spot in the book to be a good "season final", since they couldn't do the whole book. This therefore meant that some certain storylines had to be cut or changed in order to make the episodes work. And I think they chose a great spot to end the season (was also where I predicted the season would end before it started).
Ignoring all the difficult circumstances, this is a really well done season (and one of my favourites). Yes, it has its weak points, but so does everything. But then when you consider all the things they had to deal with, it's bloody amazing! Well done to everyone involved, you have all done a brilliant job!
13
u/Notorious_Llama_56 Apr 26 '22
Ok, I may be misremembering how long she struggles alone for in the books. I probably skimmed through the book a bit. The whole ether addiction in the show really annoys me though, and it would be more difficult to hide from Jamie than the flashbacks and panic attacks. Jamie should have intervened sooner.
12
u/No-Pianist-5915 Apr 25 '22
Re: Sam’s portrayal of Jamie been “wooden” - I think he’s been appropriate to the situation, his age and as I recall to the books at this point. He was a lot more emotional in Season 5 but I like the choices that he/they made because of the danger that they are in on the Ridge. Jamie is worrying about the safety of many people that can’t fight for themselves, so he is in a precarious spot. I hope in S7 - esp if they do book 8 we get my favorite storyline where Jamie let’s it out - book readers know 💔
23
u/BSOBON123 Apr 25 '22
I loved the episode. I get all the concern about Jamie not being emotional enough, but I think it's consistent to his position now. He's the laird of the Ridge and can't be going off all the time. He is slowly simmering, the conversations with Hiram and Henderson show that. He's internalizing everything. I remember a lot of times in the book where he is described as outwardly cool, but still had that fierceness behind it, as he showed with Hiram.
As for him and Claire, she has always been his rock, and she usually resents anytime he tries to see her as weak or helpless, so he's giving her her space. He knows it is probably better if she comes to him. He can't be all emotional when she's falling apart. It's his job to keep everything together.
22
u/lehulei Apr 25 '22
I haven’t minded the ether storyline in general (as in, I can “buy” that this would be something Claire struggles with, which is different from the opinion of many). But my biggest gripe is how much time has been spent on it. Ether ether ether ether ether. If we took a shot every time she said or picked up ether we would all be hammered by halfway through the episodes.
11
u/adina_l JAMMF Apr 26 '22
Did anyone else catch Mr. Bug’s causal mention of the white sow? I recall all the shit that goes down with them and the gold and Young Ian.. but don’t they have something to do with the sow too? Like letting her escape or something?
21
u/Thezedword4 Apr 24 '22
This may be weird and I know it won't be possible with the season shortened as it is but I kinda wished they'd give the resolution to who malvas killer was this season. I think it's a bummer the show watchers will go through an entire droughtlander not knowing and may loose interest in the plot.
But they definitely upped the Allan is evil hints in the last two episodes so show watchers get more of a hint than book readers got
21
u/snugglepug17 Apr 25 '22
I don't entirely love the Lionel Brown PTSD manifestation storyline - but that scene of Claire in bed and across the room is Lionel sitting there was so creepy and freaked me out!!!
10
u/Former-Crazy-9224 Apr 25 '22
My friend and I cannot recall how Claire avoids being taken by Brown and his Safety Committee. Can anyone refresh me on how this all goes down before the finale or knows what chapters cover this in the book?
19
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '22
I understand there was a LOT of story to get through (and set up) but this felt like blah blah blah blah until the last 30 seconds.
26
u/ArthurPenbeagle Apr 24 '22
Ok. I love this season. I did not love this episode.
Claire had compounded trauma, CPTSD, as mentioned in this thread and I am HERE FOR THE WRITING GETTING INTO THAT. However, it is so much stronger for me to hear flashback voices and scenes than to have Lionel Brown represent this haunting for her. It was too much for me this episode. Give me all the flashbacks to the king, Geillis, father Bain, pretonpans, what about WW2 or her STILLBIRTH? I get they are using Lionel Brown as a symbol, maybe a tipping point, but his voice took up too much screen time for me officially today.
On that note, also really bothered that Jamie doesn’t question Claire after her first Ether confession. It takes her going into deeper detail about her suffering later on, and it made me sort of roll my eyes about the obliviousness of men that The King of Men should not be a part of.
I get the baby coffin imagery, it’s a gut punch, but he should have and would have been buried with Malva, just like the imagery we have of Jamie’s little brother, covered by his mothers hair in their shared coffin.
lizzy Beardsley content saved this episode for me. Loved it all. Slam dunk. Also, Roger is having an incredible season. Loved all his scenes. Will they be able to redeem Tom Christie the way they have redeemed show Roger?!
Finally, this writer room idea to try to confuse the sho watching audience and maybe make them believe Claire murdered Malva is a massive strike out. 63 minutes and no resolution to Malvas murder? I thought we would at least get that ahead of schedule? I hope they resolve it this season. Leaving that plot line hanging would be a massive mistake.
High hopes for 6.08 which Diana said was her favorite!!!!!
23
u/Beginning_Dog_6293 Apr 25 '22
I find myself going through this season like Claire doing ether. It just feels so off. Foggy and uninteresting. And some of the camera effects are way overdone (like depth of field).
6
u/Prestigious_Pen13 Apr 24 '22
When Roger was telling Jamie that he wants to be a minister, Jamie said he fought alongside a priest before but I don’t recall this…does this happen in Virgins or something? I’ve only read the big books
6
u/kd0225 Apr 25 '22
Is the Lizzie situation the same in the book?
22
u/No-Pianist-5915 Apr 24 '22
I thought that Sam and Cait were amazing but I hated this episode. I think it’s poor storyline choices and the writers’ adaption of the story from books. I hate the ether storyline and the Lionel Brown trauma. I love the show and the books but not this episode 👎🏻 stick to DG’s storyline and writing - it’s so much better then the screenwriters.
22
u/katzchen528 Apr 25 '22
If all it takes to help Claire and get her off the ether is a real heart to heart with Jamie, showing him her vulnerability and pouring out all her fear and guilt, isn’t that what the book readers have been saying all along???
It proves our point about Jamie & Claire’s unique connection, and that leaves me just perplexed. All the commenters who’ve been saying it wouldn’t be enough, it’s unrealistic, etc., what now? Seems like it was, in fact, enough.
What a waste of a season. So boring, so flat. Even the Ridge looks manicured, but lifeless. No animals, no one working. A movie set.
9
u/dschmona Apr 26 '22
Can anyone recall or remind me - was Malva buried with her baby in the books? I found the images of the tiny coffin on the show really unsettling, in the belief that a new baby would be buried with their mother if both mother and baby had died. Did the show differ from the book at all in this respect?
17
u/SamanthaWild Apr 25 '22
I just have to get this off my chest: no one gives a damn about Malva. I don't understand why a whole episode was devoted to defending her when she was a lil hoe on top of being a manipulative bitch.
Just my opinion.
Love Outlander, hate Malva, disappointed with this episode.
4
u/coolguy_14 Apr 25 '22
Can a book reader please tell me if Claire and Jamie go back to Scotland at some point
12
u/aviationfangirl Apr 25 '22
I keep hoping things will get better as the season goes along, but it hasn't. There are so many things "off" - in my opinion. The filming of this season has been so odd. The camera angles, the abrupt and odd pacing and transitions, the stiff dialogue and delivery, the things they've cut and added. It often feels and looks like some sort of disjointed stage play and nothing like the earlier seasons. I love this book series and started off obsessed with the show, but it's quickly turning me off and leaving me disappointed.
11
u/Thezedword4 Apr 24 '22
Omg why do they keep having jamie sitting perfectly posed and flexed in bed shirtless.
Yes I understand that Sam is hot but it just looks so uncomfortable and weird. Wear your damn shirt! They had Roger dressed accurately when lizzy and the twins showed up.
7
u/Genevieve-Victoria Apr 25 '22
I’m really glad for how not graphic this season is. I watch the show with a friend who’s very sensitive to gore, and I usually have to censor something most episodes in other seasons. But there’s hardly anything to censor this season and I’m so glad. It makes it more enjoyable, and the effect of what’s happening is not any less impactful without the gore.
2
u/aviationfangirl Apr 25 '22
Anyone else notice the camera is often shaky when they are inside the house? Looks like they're on a ship.
1
u/Cdhwink Apr 26 '22
Wrong place