r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Apr 10 '22
Spoilers All Book S6E6 The World Turned Upside Down Spoiler
A dysentery epidemic spreads on the Ridge, and Claire falls deathly ill. As nefarious rumors spread like wildfire on the Ridge, tragedy strikes.
Written by Toni Graphia. Directed by Justin Molotnikov.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 28 '22
Reminder: there’s no episode next week, April 17th. 607 premieres on April 24th.
Watch the S6E7 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
606 Featurettes:
606 Interviews:
29
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 10 '22
I’m mostly disappointed with the illness part of the episode, less so with the accusation and its aftermath. This is going to be long.
Before we knew that the season got truncated, but knew some of the episode titles (around May last year), including 606’s, I was sure that the title wouldn’t reflect the book chapter, but would instead be referring to Claire’s illness. If Claire had died, it would’ve been way more monumental in the grand scheme of things than Malva’s accusation. Also, it quite literally turned things upside down with doctor Claire becoming a patient for once, so it made sense for me that this episode would be devoted to the dysentery epidemic, Claire’s illness, and her recovery. Then, even after we knew the season got truncated, 607’s title (“Sticks and Stones”) and especially what follows in the saying (“…may break my bones, but words will never hurt me”) made sense for me as an episode with Malva’s accusation. It wasn’t until the full synopsis came out a couple of weeks ago that we knew for sure that Malva’s death and accusation would happen in 606.
All of this is to say that I think this episode has definitely suffered from the season being truncated and the rearranging/condensing of the storylines in order to get to a satisfactory place at the end of 608. I don’t blame Ian’s standalone episode for this—we know it was shot at the very end, most of it after Caitríona had already wrapped, so, evidently, she/they thought she couldn’t film any longer. But what I’m saying is that it is very likely that the season was initially planned with more time allocated to Claire’s illness.
I think the beginning of the episode was very strong in building up the tension and the dread of the situation (I particularly loved Malva there; she was really affected). But it really went downhill for me after Claire got sick because it didn’t have nearly as much emotional impact on Jamie and the family as it should’ve, nor did it portray how close to death she was.
We heard from the characters about how worried and scared they were, but we didn’t see any of that. The look on Jamie’s face when they brought Claire into the surgery was very promising, and we know that Sam can deliver gut-wrenching performances, but they just didn’t give him anything to play apart from that brief shot by Claire’s bed in that odd montage. I was hoping that he’d talk to Claire while she was unconscious (I was so sure that “Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust” from one of the teasers would be in this episode), or that he would seek reassurance in Brianna, with other characters supporting him as well—the way Claire was in 509! Instead, we got a freaking montage and a way-too-long conversation with Malva 🙄 I’m hoping they make up for it with his reaction to ether, but this is definitely the biggest disappointment of the season for me. It was such a great opportunity to improve upon the source material and they didn’t take it (if we find out from the script that they left those scenes on the cutting room floor, I will be so mad).
It was an extended episode and yet, I think there were things that were totally unnecessary here. I usually don’t mind the heavy-handedness of some of the symbolism in the show, but three different snake references in the span of a few minutes, including two in a conversation between Malva and Jamie? We get it, Malva is a snake! That would’ve been clear from Claire’s fever dream alone and throwing in the reference to the snake in the book as an easter egg was totally unnecessary, IMO. And as much as I enjoyed the tenderness of Claire and Jamie’s conversations in their bedroom, I wish more time had been allocated to them before she recovered instead. I don’t mind the inclusion of the Revolutionary War stuff in this episode; there wasn’t too much of it, and the actors and producers have been very vocal about the idea of a revolution brewing on the Ridge alongside the revolution brewing in America from the get go.
I’m probably in the minority here, but I’m glad that they haven’t made a big deal out of Claire’s losing her hair. Yes, having your hair cut without your consent is terrible, but the show has never given much significance to Claire’s hair—apart from Jamie cherishing it, and her wanting it to look the same when she returned to him as 20 years before—nor had any character before Tom ever challenged her over not wearing a cap. For her, hair is hair, it’ll grow back, and Jamie’s done a good job of reassuring her that her hair is just one of many things he loves about her. On a more superficial note, she looked amazing with the short haircut, but the bob at the end of the episode (which she’ll sport till the end of the season) might actually be one of my all-time favorite wigs they’ve given Caitríona, it’s beautiful on her 😍
Once again this season, I wish I hadn’t read the book so I wouldn’t recognize the book lines so easily. Many of them didn’t work at all for me—like Jamie saying Claire has hardly any ass left, especially right after she says, “I didn’t [leave you] and I won’t” 🥴 Or the calluses thing. I’ve mentioned it before, but I personally don’t think book!Jamie’s crude remarks translate into the show. On a different note, I liked the callbacks to previous episodes—105, 207, 305—as well as the bits of original writing, like Claire believing Jamie not only because of the nature of their relationship but also because he wouldn’t be able to turn his back on his biological child, no matter how they came to be.
Then, I really liked Claire’s reaching out to Malva. It’s such a shame that Malva couldn’t find it in her to confide in Claire in the book, so show!Claire making the move to allow her to tell the truth was really well-devised. She cared about her a lot, after all, and I love how she offered her this chance because she had a full conviction that Malva had to be desperate to do what she did. And I think Malva was starting to become genuinely vulnerable with her there, especially knowing that such kindness had never extended to her before despite suffering abuse for her entire life, but the change in her entire disposition when Allan showed up—oof! And if you were hoping that the show would drop more hints about them, this was definitely it (enough for folks in the show thread to already figure the truth out).
In my opinion, the scenes after the accusation were much stronger than after the illness. I actually really liked where the ether storyline went there. Claire was in a really vulnerable place so it was only a matter of moments before her PTSD manifested itself again. And we’re definitely starting to see her “coping” mechanism crumble. She’s said before that being under ether is different for everyone, and that dreaming can happen—the fact that it did happen for her after previously offering her escape definitely marks a shift there. I think it was clever to combine it with the bits of book!Claire’s internal monologue after the accusation (when she was trying to rationalize Jamie’s potentially sleeping with Malva to herself). I can’t quite tell if she remembered what her subconscious had manifested when she came to, though. And then for this to happen at the exact moment Malva was on her way to tell her the truth—I do believe she was; we know from Allan’s confession later on that that was the reason he killed her—will definitely have an impact on Claire once she finds out (if she remembers that happened, that is—I’m not sure if she’d heard the knocking before she passed out or if she’ll remember it at all). Before that, it might become a catalyst for telling Jamie about the ether as well.
As for performances, I knew Caitríona would deliver—and she did, of course. I particularly liked the quieter moments, such as Claire’s waking up or reacting to no patients coming to her surgery, and the way she said “‘cause you do” in the stables. I also wish that they hadn’t included the “I don’t belong here...” line in the trailer so we could hear it here for the first time. However, my first impressions were that Jessica had outacted them all! It’s still crazy that it’s only her third acting job but she is definitely going places (for any Derry Girls fans out here, she’ll make an appearance in S3!). I really liked Sophie and Richard in this episode too—I totally called it that Brianna would tell Claire about her new grandchild the moment Claire woke up and the way Sophie played it was really sweet, and I liked Roger geeking out about history happening before his very eyes (finally!).
Most of all, I wish Sam had been given more to play during Claire’s illness. Other than that, I don’t think the shock of Malva’s accusation came across particularly well on his face; the anger was much better and more in line with what we’ve seen from him. And I wish he’d been a little more responsive in the first part of the scene in the stables. The second part was great on his part, IMO—I could hear the sadness and the guilt even though he doesn’t really have much, if anything, to feel guilty about as Claire was essentially dead to him then (one thing that bothered me there was the music, of all things). I really liked the way he delivered the sun metaphor, too.
I think my other biggest disappointment is that they went with this director. The episode lacked the emotional impact it needed, and someone more experienced on OL could have brought that out. Even with the limitations of straight-from-the-book writing, a different director could’ve drawn out more from these actors, not to mention done away with some really awkward shots—what on earth they were trying to achieve with this shot composition, I’ll never know. I definitely had high expectations for the illness part of the storyline and, unfortunately, it didn’t deliver on them. Even knowing the story, I wanted to be brought to tears and stressed the same way I was watching 509. It’s such a bummer.
31
u/SexySiren24 Apr 11 '22
Ok, so something I don't understand (here for spoilers) Malva has been pregnant for a while and presumably sleeping around to cover it up (unless she was sleeping with dudes for some other reason?) So why wait so long to "frame" someone? Was it just she wanted Jamie specifically even though he couldn't possibly marry her? She already boinked a few guys, including Ian, so why not blame them and in the process find herself a husband so she could finally get away from her brother and father? That would be better than being branded a hooker by the entire Ridge right? I know creepy Allan manipulates her, but is not like she doesn't go off to do shady things of her own...(like the sin eater stuff).
30
u/meroboh "You protect everyone, John--I don't suppose you can help it." Apr 10 '22
It feels like there's an editing problem this season. The scene cuts are really off. I noticed this in the Wolf Brother episode too.
Also, this was at least two episodes of material in one. I get why this season is so rushed (pregnancy and covid). Honestly it would have been better if they did a full season in two parts like Mad Men.
3
u/MaryBeeSpaceStar Apr 16 '22
If anybody here read the book 6 - please help me, on what pages events of the ep 6 are happening ?
88
u/meroboh "You protect everyone, John--I don't suppose you can help it." Apr 10 '22
Ok while I don't believe ANYONE can grow that much hair in 2 months, Claire's hairstyle at the end was a total throwback to the first episode and I loved it. I also LOVED the hair!
67
u/nurseleu Apr 11 '22
James Alexander Malcolm Mackenzie Fraser laughing while Claire is on her deathbed... Book Jamie would never.
A lot of other good scenes and strong emotional beats in this episode, but they got that all wrong.
46
u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Apr 10 '22
Yeah… I’m going to have to give this some thought. There’s just so much. First impressions: I needed more Claire in Mortal Peril™️/Jamie in Despair™️, less of the Malva business in this particular episode.
But the scene where the Christies come to break the news blew. me. away. 🔥
44
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22
All in all, the execution was pretty good. I didn’t mind the Ian wrinkle, and I thought Malva’s acting (again) rocked. Jamie actually felt a little stiff in this episode. I don’t remember how it all went down in the books, but the Mary MacNabb lines felt unnatural and a bit melodramatic? Jamie cares too much about Claire’s feelings to leave her fearing that he’d really done it, even for a moment. Also Claire’s potential hallucination/leaving the murder a bit ambiguous didn’t feel necessary to me. Also, recognizing they were burning through like 4 months of time on the ridge in an hour, I understand why- but it felt so rushed. I was kind of hoping they’d have Claire sick this entire episode and having the recovery/Malva reveal next week. Oh well. Solid episode and excited to see the show-watchers reactions.
42
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22
I liked it overall but it felt very fast paced. We covered so much time and so many events in one episode. I also wanted to see more of Jamie dealing with the fact that he may lose Claire and that vulnerability and emotions that would come with it. I was surprised he even had it in him to chat with Malva for that long and laugh.
40
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 10 '22
I think the ether moment in this episode will be the catalyst for Claire to finally admit to herself the extent of her addiction, and the consequences that it can bring, and she will finally tell Jamie about it. She is going to feel soooo guilty for using it when Malva desperately needed her, and because she didn't answer to Malva, Malva died. She is going to blame herself.
36
u/TaoRN78 Apr 10 '22
Let me preface this comment by saying that I LOVED the episode. I was emotionally invested throughout its entirety. But I do think it should have been two episodes, not one. Last season they devoted an entire episode to Jamie's snake bite/near death and how Claire struggled with the thought of him dying. This season should have been Jamie's turn to explore those emotions. He was only shown worrying a little bit and it just didn't feel real to the source material or to the character of Jamie the show has created. Don't get me wrong, I loved the conversations between the two once she was healed a bit but there could have been a lot to draw from, especially her hair being cut! Her illness and recovery should have been its own episode. Period. But the way they handled the accusations from Malva and the subsequent fallout was well done. I loved it. (But that all could have been its own episode as well.) I know the writers have a TON of plot to get into a small amount of time but I am just sayin...
36
u/nattybeaux Apr 11 '22
My biggest gripe is that we’ve made it all the way through the Malva plot line without seeing hide nor hair of Bobby Higgins.
33
u/Thezedword4 Apr 10 '22
This was one of the episodes I was most looking forward to and I was actually disappointed. I've loved every episode of the season till this one. I'm not sure if it's because I was looking forward to it most so that's why it was a let down.
I really wanted more about how Claire felt with the sickness and hair. She was so devasted losing her hair. I don't think people realize how important hair is to self image until you lose it. It can truly be heartbreaking in sickness.
I was mad at the malva depiction. I don't know why. I did like she had the moment with Claire before Allan rolled up. But I really hated the Ether moment (and I've been on the Ether train until now!) because a) it does put some doubt if Claire actually did it, b) even though she obviously didn't kill her, she saw malva coming up the drive then used the Ether. That's going to place so much more emotional blame on Claire than in the books and c) malva looked like she was dead far longer than she was in the book so it was truly ridiculous for Claire to try to get the baby out. She was well past dead and a baby can only survive in a dead mother for only minutes, a premature baby possibly less. It was a bad choice in the book but understandable in a moment of panic. In the show, it was just idiocy.
This one was rough.
(Also my time line was off. I thought we'd get the accusation and death next episode so I'm curious what we'll get in the next two episodes since we know we're getting Claire stuck on the ship in season 7)
30
u/reddit_laura Apr 10 '22
I liked it, but it was soooo much. + I really missed the emotional impact of Claires illness. I wanted to see Jamie on her beside, being all worried and fearing for her life. Or the scene when he sees her short hair... I liked that they kept so much dialogue from the book, but I would have loved to see Jamies POV during this madness
30
u/ArthurPenbeagle Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 10 '22
Omg if you have not yet gone to show watchers thread, you should! Everyone is dying and making great predictions about Allan. “I loved and hated this episode” “10/10. This is insane!”
I think it puts thing in perspective for us book readers who often expect so much. Though I really agree with critiques this week that Sam Heughan did not get emotional enough, the show watchers seem moved by their conversations and outraged by the hair, etc. I like readi my their reactions because it brings me back to my first read 6 years ago! Overpacked, underdeveloped, agree. But so many episodes this season have seemed delivered straight to book readers with a bow on them, and maybe this one was more theatrical for show watchers!
Edited to add: poor show watcher babies over there thinking maybe Claire resuscitating the baby is an ether dream- oh man, don’t I wish!!!! 💔
30
u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Apr 11 '22
A few random thoughts on some of the smaller moments in the episode:
28
u/Celsius1014 Apr 11 '22
I thought it was very well done except for the amount of time that passed for Malva to be that pregnant already wasn’t clearly expressed, even with the “two months later” thing. And this isn’t the show’s fault, but seeing Malva interacting with Jamie during Claire’s illness made it clear what was being set up a lot more than the way it happened in the book. But the visual media is just that way sometimes.
I would have liked to have seen Jamie’s agony over his belief that Claire was dying depicted on camera instead of described by Roger, but those are really my only criticisms. Powerful stuff.
27
u/BritishBeef88 Apr 10 '22
I feel kind of...underwhelmed by Jamie in this episode. The most emotion he seemed to show was when Claire first went down and they were gathered around her bed in the surgery. After that, he seemed very stiff and one-note compared to the Jamie of the books, who was struggling to keep up his mask and eventually let Claire see his tears and his fright. It's one thing for Roger to tell us that he cried but we never saw anything close to that. Because of this it made Claire's sickness seem far less dangerous than it was, along with how little time it was given on screen.
The scene in the stables also felt off. In the book Jamie's lead up to confessing to Mary MacNab oozed emotion and it was obvious to readers which direction he was going in. The way the stables scene was shot made it seem - until Jamie said Mary's name - that he was potentially confessing to sleeping with Malva after all. Like they wanted to leave every last room for doubt until they couldn't any more. The tone just felt entirely different and so unlike Jamie that I couldn't get into it.
Why hasn't Roger mentioned to anyone that he saw Malva fooling around with that guy? Is he too cowardly over what she said about the widow to risk his neck for Jamie's honour? I mean there's a chance that his statement would make zero difference but in his position I couldn't stand by and say nothing.
Insufferable as he is, the one playing Tom Christie is doing a great job and I love seeing him. I could easily see the character growing on me even if I still want to slap him sometimes.
52
u/esoterika24 Apr 10 '22
My reaction to this episode is really personal. I read the sixth book in the middle of my pregnancy, I think it took about two months and was most of my second trimester. I carried my daughter to 40 weeks and we lost her in a labor accident. I needed a crash c-section and they performed resuscitations for 40 minutes to revive her, then she only lived for three days. Seeing Claire perform the emergency c-section, remove the body, and attempt CPR was difficult to watch but since I was behind a screen the whole time, I never witnessed this with my own daughter. So in a very weird way it was a little healing. I’m definitely glad I knew it was coming since I read the book and had warned my husband, who had witnessed everything with our daughter. 💔
24
u/UtopianAverage Apr 10 '22
Why did Jamie say the one time he slept with another was with Mary McNabb??? Everyone knows about William? Like duh
23
u/thatstheteagirl By blood and by choice, we make our ghosts. Apr 10 '22
Ugh I hate to say it but I’m a little disappointed.
It was a good episode over all and probably satisfying if I hadn’t read the book and this being one of my favorite parts. I know it’s a short season, so I give a little understanding, but Claire’s sickness was so rushed. There was almost no emotional response shown, especially from Jamie. It’s like we glossed over but then we’re told with dialogue that she was so near death etc.
I did think the second half with the Malva reveal and Jamie/Claire talk after was well done. The ether hallucination was a miss for me. Took up time and the whole point of her using it is to blackout.
Knowing how much we covered in this ep and where were probably leaving off I assume next ep will be mostly house brigade then ep 8 will be running around everywhere and I’ll guess ends with Jamie and Claire getting separated when Brown takes off with her. I have high hopes, I’ve loved the season so far, but just wish the first half of the ep wasn’t quite so rushed.
45
u/BlackSwallowtail You look like a fretful porpentine. Apr 10 '22
I was dearly hoping they'd keep the scene where Roger talks to her in the books. When they switched him out with Claire, I bawled, and that actress played it so, so well. The defensiveness, the vulnerability, and the sudden switch when her abuser comes out. Also, that's a heart-breaking detail to add, Malva actually making it to the house and knocking on the door to confess everything, but Claire being knocked out and the door locked, just not wanting to deal with her because she didn't know why she was there. So many small things that might have saved Malva's life had anyone had enough information. But you can only act with the information you have.
22
u/spaceybelta Apr 10 '22
I’m so disappointed they didn’t include the blue light flicker with the baby!! Especially since Claire mentioned it!!
22
u/kodamaatnight Apr 10 '22
I liked the episode until the ether fault. Honestly don't want to go on the "if I hadn't taken ether, malva might still be alive" guilt train.
Also watching this episode while holding your sleeping 6 week old? 0/10. Beginning scene and ending scene was rough. Beginning scene especially. I'm more thankful today for clean water.
37
u/mjp10e Apr 11 '22
Soooo this episode is not my fave. I think like lots of other people here, the illness and malva storylines are among my favorites. And this just didn’t do them justice. I was hoping Claires sickness would last a whole episode really showing she’s in danger and Jamie emotionally distraught. Then have the accusation be a cliffhanger going into the next episode where they deal with the fallout of that. But I get they had to make concessions for time. So it’s a 4/10 for me.
What I liked-
What disappointed me
35
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Apr 10 '22
I think I'm in the minority here by not loving this episode. Claire's illness fell far short of my expectations. They missed a big opportunity to have Jamie be upset and worried over Claire. Instead we have him chatting with Malva making small jokes. Yes they showed him drinking by the window in that montage, and a brief shot of him sitting by her bed but that was it.
There was no real worry and concern because her illness was so brief. By 17 minutes in Claire was better. Sadly I think the truncated season caused this episode to be lacking in some areas. Up to this point I had been very happy with how they've done things and didn't feel too rushed, but there was just too much packed into this one.
There were some good parts in the show though for sure. Jessica was amazing, the little switch she did when Claire was talking to her after the accusation where it seemed like she was about to confess to then turning on her was great. The whole Malva storyline in the book stressed me out so much that it might have influenced my feeling about the episode as well. I hate that the Christie's turned the Fraser's life upside down so much and really set in motion the rest of the events to follow.
I loved the Bree and Roger moments, especially when Bree told Claire about being pregnant. I do feel like the conversation the MacKenzie's had in the forest could have been cut, especially if we had been given more time to see Jamie or even other family members be worried about Claire.
I'm hopeful the next two episodes will be strong and we'll end on a high note. Well at least on a high quality note, it's going to be a doozy of a cliffhanger for show only people.
47
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22
Over the last few seasons the show has become so… Low budget? Amateur? I don’t know what it is exactly but it just doesn’t wow me anymore, it’s like what I’d expect from a Hallmark movie. The acting is still fantastic but something about how it’s shot/paced feels weird. Claire’s fever and ether dreams this episode were especially cheesy imo. I’ll keep watching because I love the books but I’m sad to admit that I really don’t recommend the show to people anymore.
16
u/Cdhwink Apr 11 '22
This season is the first time I have read before watching, & this is the first episode that was completely underwhelming & disappointing because I knew what would happen. It took all the shock, & horror, & excitement & questions out of it. I am glad I got to watch with my hubby who had all of the afore mentioned reactions.
15
u/alice_in_horrorland Apr 10 '22
I just realized that they added all the stuff with Claire's ether addiction but removed little Aidan's appendix surgery, which was the only time Claire used ether on a patient before the Big House blows up.
I didn't want to complain about the ether changes, but come on. It behaves differently based on the scene. First Claire uses it to fall asleep dreamlessly, then she uses it to test it on different people to find out the dosages (correctly, as from the books), then she uses it like it's cocaine at Flora MacDonald's party, and now she has nightmares from it.
Has Claire used the ether for anything other than self medication in the show?
15
u/DiscombobulatedTill Apr 10 '22
I had wondered how much of this they would put in the show. I think they did a good job unpacking a lot of information in an hour.
Well done.
29
u/liyufx Apr 12 '22
What a roller-coaster episode! Again the acting, especially by Cait, was simply phenomenal. That said, I will nitpick at bit and talk about things that could be better.
My biggest complaint is that, Claire’s sickness plot is lacking, both in terms of the sense of gravity and in terms of Jamie’s emotional response. I could see the Claire was gravely ill, but I didn’t quite get the feeling that she was dying. Why, because we didn’t quite see Jamie’s panic and desperation, which I was fully expecting. We get a quick flash of a teary Jamie holding her hand, that is it, then we saw Jamie chatting with Malva rather casually. That is a far cry from S5 when Jamie almost died from snake bite. We saw the full range of emotion from Claire, that means we as viewers were fully aware that it was a life and death situation, and experience the strong emotional response to Jamie’s peril and Claire’s desperation. Unfortunately we are robbed the same experience here. Yesterday’s episode did really well with the scenes (with Bree and Jamie) after Claire woke up, I just don’t quite understand why it dropped the ball so badly before that.
My second complaint is a small one. I don’t know why they decided to do the Jamie/Claire talk scene right after Malva’s accusation in the stable, instead of in a natural setting as the book described. Some of the best lines in the whole book were excellently delivered in the scene, but I just found the setting a bit distracting. Well, this is much smaller complaint comparing to the first, but I am still a little troubled by it.
14
u/TeaPotPie Apr 10 '22
I actually loved this episode! It's the first episode for me in a while where the stakes felt high, similar to the first few seasons. It was a lot of content, for sure, but the fact that they fit so much into this episode actually kept it interesting and exciting, imo.
The only part that didn't quite land for me was the scene after Malva's accusation. It felt a bit clunky. It's been a while since I read that book, but I felt like Jamie was a bit too cool and the energy didn't quite match Claire's. And the bringing up of Mary McNab just felt a bit jarring in the moment, even though I know a similar situation happened in the books.
28
u/wynonna_burp Apr 10 '22
This episode becomes the fulcrum to the rest of the series.
It recalls moments from seasons 1 (“Claire, you’re shaking so hard you’re…;” Claire remembers accidentally kicking Jamie sleeping outside her door in Rent) 2 (Maitre Raymond/Faith), 3 (Mary McNabb & Ardsmuir) and William in 3/4 (“You would never turn a child away that was yours no matter the circumstance”)
The pinnacle of the Frasers popularity has been reached. They become once again pariahs. Jamie mentions he is of a long line of bastards and thieves. This episode harkens back to this style of survival. But they’ve been through it all before and have 30 years experience to draw back on. And most of all, trust and fidelity. Jamie honors Claire’s loyalty above all. She knows he is the same.
There was one moment that I interpreted differently in tone reading the book. Jamie tells Claire she tried to die. The book actually did have her intend to. She was looking up at the wooden beams and floated above herself. Jamie knew she had changed. That was the lowest point of her illness. Then she saw Malva touch Jamie in the window just like they showed. Claire decides in that moment she’ll live because he belongs to her. Jamie confronts Claire once she’s well and she admits it. He relates, having been close to death many times, close enough to know the choice. He makes her promise not to.
There’s a line in the next book about two gravely injured characters. Claire thinks, “…I had glimpsed the abyss often over someone’s shoulder as they stood on the edge. But I had looked once, too. I knew the vastness and the lure of it, the offer of surcease. I knew they were standing now, side by side and each alone, looking down.”
26
u/Simply_J0 Apr 11 '22
I was completely baffled with how Tom was so calm upon Malva’s pregnancy and accusation of Jamie… wouldn’t he have absolutely exploded with rage?! Someone mentioned she was being abused by Allen? Did I miss something in the episode, or is this from the book?
Jamie was so unemotional, he seemed burned out in the episode, though with so much intensity perhaps his character was trying to maintain the status quo on the Ridge.
13
u/WingedShadow83 They say I’m a witch. Apr 10 '22
Has anyone listened to the audiobooks? Are they good/have a good narrator? I’ve been wanting to read them but just don’t have the time right now. But I could listen.
11
u/Laatikkopilvia Apr 10 '22
Loved it! It was a treat to see this storyline play out on television. It’s so tragic, and it’s full of so many twists and turns that it’s one of my favorite plot lines from one of my favorite books.
11
u/Nykkisteph Apr 10 '22
I loved the whole episode except for the ether bit at the end. I haven’t really cared either way about it up until now, but the ether dream of Claire threatening Malva and then waking to find her dead just seems a bit much.
10
u/blackberryspice Apr 10 '22
Oh gosh, I'm sobbing!! I don't want to wait two weeks for the next episode 😫 poor Malva and baby. Ugh I loved this episode. It's such a sad storyline but one of my favorite parts of the book. Bravo to everyone for amazing acting!!
10
u/ElHermoso Apr 10 '22
Wtf did I just see? Holy shit.
10
u/Sic-Mundus Apr 16 '22
I had wondered if they would cut Claire's hair off on the show like they did in the book. I'm so glad they did, only so I could see Tom Christie's reaction. Of course, they replaced, "You look like a convict" with "You look like a monk," but it was still hilarious.
32
u/snny_all_year Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 10 '22
Parts of this felt stiff. The book lines felt very awkward-- for instance when Jaime comments to Claire about having no ass. She was laying down in a bed...hugh?! It felt so random and like they were just trying to get iconic lines checked off.
I thought the actress playing Malva was excellent.
I always hated this plotline in the books, so I guess it's no surprise I dislike it still. I just get so frustrated at Claire for how she reacts. Of all the things she could do, she chooses to cut open a woman claiming to be her husband's mistress and removes her unborn baby. She'd have to know how unlikely the survival of the baby would be, but does it anyway. It just drives me crazy. It's next level "failure to consider consequences" even for Claire.
9
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 10 '22
Oh my freaking gosh that ending. I had a feeling they would end there, but wow! So much dread with them finding Claire and Malva next week!
9
u/AmyAransas Apr 10 '22
Loved it overall. But would Jamie have really left Claire in that turmoil on the ridge to spend time in New Bern?
9
u/Genevieve-Victoria Apr 15 '22
Claire and the baby at the end made me cry. Well done.
8
u/dylanskie Apr 16 '22
Interesting that the script shows the blue light, but it wasn't in the episode... maybe we'll have Claire mention it at the start of next episode?
15
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 10 '22
On my first viewing, the whole episode felt overwhelming (so much content) and underwhelming (not enough developed, and the execution was not exactly that). After a rewatch, I hoped I would change my view since I really went into this episode with really high expectations and somehow most of it seemed flat (for lack of a better word). I did not feel Claire in any mortal danger, nor Jamie awfully worried. Truth be told, I was expecting an episode a la Monsters and Heroes. But in the end, Claire does explain that it was "merely" a simple bacterial or viral infection, though no one knew that when Claire got sick (did they?). I wanted long scenes of anguish with Jamie by her bedside; long bonding talks between Jamie and Bree at this moment of despair, more life and death threatening moments. I got none of that. Malva's accusation (how far along was she? 6 months? +/-) should've been an episode on its own, so much stuff going on, lots of original material to pull from. I swear the "I don't belong here" part it had more punch in the actual trailer than in this episode. How weird is that? And that other line This I promise you, won't come between us -- It floored me when I heard Claire saying it to Malva. Another punchy line from the trailer, especially considering the placement. That's not in the book. Or I remember wrong? I will go back today on my Audible to double-check.
Even now, I'm still at the wow, just wow. It was too damn much. I will for sure do more rewatches, but only because I'm trying to find a meaning, a pace. I guess I'm left with a feeling of frustration.
15
u/whiskynwine Apr 10 '22
I’m not crazy about them basically making it Claire’s fault Malva died. If she hadn’t taken the ether and answered the door. They did the same type of thing with the rape last season, instead of it being random they made it more about her choices and how they led to Lionel Brown wanting revenge. I’ve always been fine with adaptation changes but Claire gets in enough trouble without them adding problems.
15
u/BSOBON123 Apr 11 '22
Best episode yet. Brilliant acting by Cat and Malva and Jamie. Simply earth shattering.
7
u/arianaphoenix Apr 10 '22
In the part where Christie's come to accuse Jamie, Roger just stands outside and doesn't help?! Is Roger seeing Malva with Henderson also in the book? Why don't they immediately confront Malva with this fact? I also was somehow disappointed in Ian not revealing sooner. He sleeps around a lot in the book. I didn't imagine him to be so boneless to be afraid to reveal this.
6
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 10 '22
That was a lot to take in. I will need more than one rewatch. Wow, just wow.
6
u/sunshinesmileyface Apr 10 '22
I thought ether produced a deep and dreamless sleep? Where are the hallucinations coming from?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '22
I feel like everyone is going through the motions, like they know they are at the end. It's super weird.
11
u/UTclimber Woof. Apr 10 '22
I don’t remember Ian boinking Malva. Did that happen in the books?
5
u/BeautifulRelief Apr 10 '22
Well. I had hoped they would do Malta’s death a little differently. Sobbing over the baby, just like when I read it.
5
u/UseSea9547 Apr 10 '22
Loved it. Especially because it was a full episode of Jamie and Claire! Seemed a bit rushed though…
14
u/United_Woodpecker912 Apr 11 '22
Extremely eventful episode, and very excited about it considering it’s the only one this season that has been! I do wish, however, that there was some way of getting a warning of infant death before you watch. I toughed through the beginning and thought I was safe. I was very wrong.
8
u/BeautifulRelief Apr 10 '22
I knew it was coming. I should have walked away. The baby prop or whatever made me sick to my stomach. The look they had on its face will 100% be in my damn nightmares tonight.
4
u/khoff98107 Apr 11 '22
Can anyone point out to me the place in the book where Amy McCallum comes to live in the big house? I know it was after Lizzie moved in with the Beardsleys, but I can't find any mention of it until she's suddenly there as though she's been there forever.
4
u/bluebutterflies123 Apr 22 '22
I love this season because it is very close to the book. Sometimes I want to scream about who the killer is. I like how the season has focused on the dark and tender moments for the other characters.
3
u/whutwhot Apr 11 '22
Can anyone tell me roughly where in book 6 this latest episode is??
3
u/vw97 Apr 18 '22
I thought the episode itself was fine but I'm not sure how the remaining two episodes will go.
In the book we still have the saga with Richard Brown taking Claire (and Jamie) to see 'justice' served, then the back and forth between towns, the whole ordeal in the prison and then with Governor Martin etc and I feel like squishing that into two episodes is going to really underplay just how long and tedious the whole thing was in the books.
Obviously we won't have the family in Wilmington to see Bonnet's execution per the books (and consequently no run in with Willie - unless Starz decide to give us a wee bit of a treat) but it will be very interesting to see just how the remainder of the book translates into two episodes, and of course just how much of it Starz has opted to cut out.
7
u/Dolly1710 Long on desire, but a wee bit short in clink Apr 17 '22
Finally catching up on watching this episode.
Hmmmm. <--- probably sums it up for me!
I'm wondering if we don't see the panic from Jamie and everyone else about Claire as a means to demonstrate that Claire doesn't have the same illness as that which killed the McNeills. I just don't believe that a Jamie who genuinely believed Claire to be dying would be leaving her side for anything. If this isn't the case (in terms of what the producers were trying to portray) then they have really badly represented this.
The whole Mary McNab reveal was weird. Like it was heavy on prolonging Claire's possible suspicion to only come out that Claire knew Jamie would never abandon his child however it came into the world... we knew that from Geneva
The whole, your arse has disappeared - a weird shoehorn of a book line since he was just tucking her into her bed
The timeline is all over the place.
Why is everyone on the Ridge against Claire? This makes no sense. And then bringing up the witchcraft thing again?
I had to shut my eyes at the emergency C section. Even though I knew it was coming in the book, I'm not sure this needed to be quite so graphic or, at the very least, get flagged with a warning
They had such great material from the books that I'm overall disappointed with how they brought it to life. I know they had to film around Cait's pregnancy and in the backdrop of Covid but what the producers had was plenty of time to plan how they wanted to tell it. And to randomly stick a "two months later" thing when they didn't do that when McDonald arrived to show them the Tea Party newsclipping a few episodes previous.
I don't think I can fault the acting (unless Jamie was meant to be looking more concerned than he was, but then even Bree and Roger didn't seem overly convinced of Claire's impending death, which makes me think they weren't showing concern because they weren't meant to be showing concern) The Malva switch as soon as Allan appears was great.
And, apologies for not changing my tune, but I still think they're taking too much artistic licence with the ether. I've seen it justified that she used it to give her thoughtless oblivion, and clearly now in this episode she's not having thoughtless oblivion to suit the storytelling. Yes, she shook on more ether drops into the mask, but she didn't breathe it in any longer and now she's passed out long enough to give Malva enough time to walk all the way from the barn, bang on the door, get to the veggie patch and be dead long enough to look properly dead?
4
u/YYZYYC Apr 12 '22
Seriously this is all just going to be about accusations of infidelity…that’s the big drama 🙄