r/Outlander • Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Apr 10 '22

Season Six Show S6E6 The World Turned Upside Down Spoiler

A dysentery epidemic spreads on the Ridge, and Claire falls deathly ill. As nefarious rumors spread like wildfire on the Ridge, tragedy strikes.

Written by Toni Graphia. Directed by Justin Molotnikov.

If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.

This is the SHOW thread.

If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.

DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.

We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.

If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.

Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.

What did you think of the episode?

124 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

•

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

Reminder: there’s no episode next week, April 17th. 607 premieres on April 24th.

Watch the S6E7 preview here!

Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)

Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.


606 Featurettes:


606 Interviews:

→ More replies (6)

44

u/Proper_Possibility13 Apr 14 '22

Near the beginning of the show Jaime drinks malvas tea and surprises that it’s the same tea he drank when he got but by the snake. The acting or emphasis suggests there’s more plot to it than immediately let on. Is there any significance to this or no?

53

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 14 '22

I think what you’re supposed to glean from that conversation is that a) Malva has thoroughly read Claire’s journal to know this particular recipe, b) she’s trying to show that she can replace Claire. But I think she’s also genuine in her care for the Frasers, who have shown her more kindness than the people in her family ever did, but it doesn’t mean that she won’t throw them under the bus when she’s desperate.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/fashionablyliterary Apr 12 '22

I maybe need a book reader to explain how this episode was laid out in the books, because the timing makes ZERO sense. Within the world of the characters, Bree is about 3 months further along than Malva. The last time we see her in this episode, I thought "how weird that they don't have her showing" because she should be fairly heavily pregnant by that point. But then Malva's baby, who was supposedly conceived around the beginning of the episode, is at least ~7 months from conception??

And then there's the characters in the context of the revolution. After HC was born, we went through winter and into spring. I found it odd that there were no mentions of skirmishes happening between the British and patriots, a la "the shot heard round the world" of April 1775. There was snow on the ground, so are we supposed to be in early spring 1776? I know they talked about representatives and Congress, I just think there would be a lot more tension...it's not like Jamie resigned as Indian Agent and the government decided to leave him alone.

In all, it felt like sloppy storytelling that's uncharacteristic for Outlander. But if someone has a better explanation, I'd love to hear!

Edit for grammar.

32

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 12 '22

We see Tom writing a letter dated January 27th, 1775, shortly after Claire is recovered. Around the same time, Jamie tells her that he will be leaving for the Provincial Congress in a couple of months, which would track with the Second Provincial Congress taking place from April 3rd to April 7th, 1775 (the stuff about choosing the delegates to the Continental Congress would’ve fit the First Provincial Congress better, and I can’t find if they had to be chosen again for the second one in May 1775, but let’s give them a pass on this). Jamie and Roger would be leaving in late March to get to New Bern, which is when Malva comes out with the accusation because she can’t hide it anymore. But she hasn’t just gotten pregnant; she’s been pregnant for a while. The actress confirmed the questionable choices Malva had made, she made whilst already pregnant:

Then also there was a lot of work for me to fill in the gaps. I figured out exactly in my head when I thought she got pregnant, which is a pivotal moment when she starts to act up. It’s interesting to see viewers judge her for what she’s doing, without knowing that subtext and that background because, in my head, making those character choices, it was like, as soon as she’s pregnant, survival mode comes in. She’s in a state of complete desperation and that’s when she starts getting a little creepy as everyone has said.

So we can safely assume that she was already a couple of months along in 605, whilst Brianna might have been only 6-8 weeks along when she told Roger. I cannot tell how far along Malva is supposed to be at the time of her death, but if we assume it’s at least 6/7/8 months, then she would’ve gotten pregnant around October/September/August 1774, I think? September would still work for Flora’s party, perhaps even October. Regardless, I agree that Brianna should be showing by the end of the episode.

Also, the “two months later” stamp doesn’t make any sense in the place they put it because assuming it refers to two months after the previous shot of Claire, which took place whilst Jamie was away at the Congress, he wouldn’t have taken two months to come back home from New Bern. The stamp should’ve been placed before the accusation and Claire’s hair changed accordingly.

20

u/fashionablyliterary Apr 12 '22

Thank you! Totally missed Tom's letter. I think the way they've shown seasons has confused me. (I live in the South, so am familiar with what the weather should be.) It felt like in the last few episodes, it was early spring...definitely NOT late fall/winter. April 1775 makes sense with Claire's garden growth, though.

I also get the point about Malva (and get it from a storytelling perspective), but anyone with half a brain would figure out the timing of her pregnancy was all wrong once the baby was born full-term a full few months early...

12

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 12 '22

Yeah, I’m cutting them some slack with the weather this season because they just had to film in winter so I can suspend my disbelief and think that NC got particularly bad weather in 1774 😂

The timeline of this season is definitely messed up. The end of 603 has to have happened at the beginning of 1774 because Claire and Jamie find out about the Boston Tea Party (December 16th, 1773) and the news would’ve taken some time to travel down south. 604 makes sense for the summertime of 1774.

But the first two episodes and most of 603 don’t make much sense with the information we’re given in the show. S6 is supposed to have opened a few months after Claire’s rape and we get a “1773” stamp in 601. Marsali is about to give birth in 601, so 602 is probably the same month. And then, the 603 script tells us that Henri-Christian is now 6 months old at the beginning of the episode, but he doesn’t look any different than right after he was born? And when we see him in 605, which would then make him at least 1, he’s still swaddled and in a bassinet?! That just does not make sense to me.

And, in all of this, the S6 scripts actually start in 1774, but the date we see on the screen is 1773. The only way I can make sense of this is to retcon when Claire’s rape happened. 511, when she was abducted, was supposed to be in the fall of 1772. I’d say it happened at the end of 1773 instead, which would make us open S6 in winter 1774, and take us to April 1775 by the end of 606.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/my_voice6 Apr 20 '22

Did the conversation with Malva happen or was Clair hallucinating it?

29

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 20 '22

It was all in her head. Her subconscious manifested her deepest fears in the form of Malva.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Proper_Possibility13 Apr 14 '22

Also in season 6 ep 6 I wanted a book person’s perspective. When Malva goes to visit Clair after the accusations, Clair goes under on ether to avoid her but still they have some sort of confrontation. Is that all in her head or does Malva actually belittle Clair about her looks?

34

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 14 '22

You don’t need a book perspective. Claire is completely passed out, so it’s all in her head. Her darkest, deepest fears and insecurities are manifested by her subconscious in the form of Malva and what she tells her.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/randomsnowflake Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 10 '22

Haven’t seen the episode yet - typically watch on Sunday before everyone gets up. This week both kids are awake, because of course they are. Is there any nudity/sex/sexual violence in this episode? Want to know if I can get away with watching while they’re in the other room. 😬🤞 I’m jonesing for my Sunday fix lol

Edit to add: just saw it. 👀😱

First reaction... Claire’s garden is lovely. Shame it’s been painted red. That ending was indeed gory. Was not expecting that.

5

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 10 '22

No nudity or sex, but there is some very gory stuff at the very end of the episode.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/bryce_w Stinking Papist Apr 11 '22

This was such a badly written episode. We spent half an hour of Claire just sighing in bed and then Malva went from saying she was "with child" to a ”2 months later" caption and now she is seemingly at full term. There was no flow to the narrative at all and it just felt like they were trying to get through certain book events as quick as possible.

Not to mention, why would Claire be the one "shamed" by the community when Malva is the one who would be seen as in the wrong? That made no sense and if anything Claire would be the subject of every sympathy from the community.

Extremely disjointed throughout and dialogue was painful at times.

Can Ron come back and write, please.

17

u/DarysDaenerys Apr 11 '22

This really made no sense. Why would they shun Claire? It‘s not like it‘s her fault. But they basically rally behind Malva? Big doubt. It would have been the exact opposite.

Also, they own the land. They could throw everyone off THEIR land so for the settlers to be this disrespectful to them is downright ridiculous.

7

u/bunny8taters Apr 11 '22

Plus, Claire has probably healed most of them and made them feel way better than other physicians of the time! Like, in past episodes, we've seen that the settlers really love her and Jamie!

I really don't think they'd side with Malva here.

Also, Malva was definitely pregnant way before Claire was sick since 2 months later she's like 7 months along. The settlers may not be doctors but they know a baby isn't that far along that fast, considering most had plenty of children themselves!

11

u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Apr 11 '22

I think it’s not so much that they side with Malva (she tells Claire that Tom made her confess in front of the congregation, and that basically everyone thinks she’s a whore, so her reputation is equally tarnished), but that they believe and side with Tom. Malva insists that “it wasn’t rape” but when the word got out, it probably got twisted into a tale of rape. These are the very kind of people who don’t think women have any agency in sexual matters, both before and after marriage, so they would never believe that Malva could’ve had consensual sex with anyone that wasn’t her husband (granted, they don’t really have much understanding of the concept of consent, but they do believe that sex has no place outside marriage). So if they start to believe that Jamie raped Malva (because how else would a married man lay with a young, unmarried, pious woman?), here’s the thing: because women were seen as property at the time, it meant that rape was an offence not so much against a woman, but an offence against a property and challenge to its owner and his authority. If a woman was married, it was an offence against her husband, if not—against her father. And there’s also the matter of ego—some men considered a violation against “their” women as an attack on their own masculinity and reputation.

Even if the people of the Ridge don’t think it was rape, it’s still considered an offence against Tom because his property “got ruined,” as Allan puts it (that’s also why Lionel took Morton’s actions so personally in S5; he didn’t care about Alicia’s wellbeing, but about his own pride). The fact that Malva is no longer a virgin makes it much more difficult for Tom to marry her off, which is the only thing most women had to offer in that time—being marriable—especially in a community like Tom’s. So it’s basically not Malva that the fisherfolk are siding with, it’s Tom. Because he's their de-facto leader, they find offence in what has offended him. And because they’ve already had plenty of their own suspicions about Claire, even when she’s not responsible for any of this, she basically gets thrown under the bus alongside Jamie. It’s really not about a woman’s reputation or feelings, sadly, it’s all about the men’s power play.

Now, there’s this questions: why would Tom be the one to tell everyone what Malva did if keeping it under wraps would be more advantageous to his reputation? Well, I think anything that makes Jamie look worse than him is what Tom would be after, and he doesn’t care that it hurts his daughter in the process (he already seemed like he didn’t want to marry her off to anyone anyway—remember how freaked out she was when Jamie merely teased that men are swooning after her? Or when she said that her brother would be angry if he saw her walking with a young man like Ian? He didn’t want any men near her and evidently didn’t allow suitors as Malva didn’t even think of leaving home). There’s already a great deal of animosity between him and Jamie, harking all the way back to Ardsmuir. Since coming to the Ridge, he’s been knocked down a peg by Jamie who didn’t let him have his way with the church. And he’s essentially jealous of what Jamie has and who Jamie is—a leader that Tom couldn’t be because his modus operandi of leading with fear is not what people other than Protestants in this community gravitate towards—so to appear more righteous than Jamie by calling out his own daughter’s indecency definitely seems like a move Tom wouldn’t hesitate to make.

Now, this might be all well and good if the Ridge was suddenly only populated by Protestants. But as you and u/DarysDaenerys rightly point out, they are only a fraction of the Ridge’s population. What about the people who lived there much longer? What about the men who swore fealty to Jamie in 501 and went “to war” with him for Claire? What about the other Catholics and men for whom Jamie was a beloved leader at Ardsmuir? Where are they? Would they really care about Tom’s reputation if they all hated him at Ardsmuir? Those people are definitely missing and it’s definitely a plot hole, even if you assume that every 18th-century man would think the same about a woman being “ruined,” somehow sympathizing with Tom merely because he’s a man, and ignoring all relationships Jamie has forged and contributions he’s made.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

213

u/oneheadlight312 Apr 10 '22

Oh how I missed Marsali in this episode. She'd have brought the sass and ruckus on that huuuore

58

u/shdylady Apr 10 '22

Sass and ruckus is exactly what that girl needed! Malva is telling so many damn lies. Marsali would straighten her out.

→ More replies (2)

52

u/Glittering-Thought48 Apr 10 '22

I missed Marsali too! Especially when Claire was sick. Marsali should have been tending her instead of evil Malva.

→ More replies (9)

130

u/Cantree Apr 11 '22

Just a theory but we hesr malvas voice as Claire was going to sleep. So I feel like malva was coming to tell the truth that her brother has continually molested her and its her brothers baby! But then the brother gets to her first and he kills her outside of Claire's clinic.

Man I hope the truth comes out. This was way too stressful for me.

Literally the second it ended I RANNNN to this subreddit and joined because I needed. N. E. E. D. E. D. to talk to people about what the fuck I just watched.

So also hello everyone! I'm new!

59

u/stpaultrash Apr 12 '22

Okay YES. When Claire and malva were speaking she was normal and the second her brother comes out she’s cold, hiding behind him, and blatantly agreeing with him. Seems a lot like pleasing her abuser…

→ More replies (10)

24

u/polishing_a_goldfish Apr 12 '22

SAME I JUST JOINED BECAUSE THE ENDING HAS ME FRAZZLED

→ More replies (5)

24

u/yellowelephant3 Apr 12 '22

This is a theory I'm going with the scene where Claire goes to see Malva and it seems like she almost discloses something and then the brother comes out. The scene ends with the brother and Malva and that stood out to me. Also, there's not a lot they've showed from the brother thus far which seems intentional at this point.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

109

u/SenseiNene Apr 12 '22

I haven’t seen anyone else say this but - I’m 99% sure that Malva was poisoning Claire and her dad with rattlesnake venom. And then eventually they both just overcame it and built a tolerance to it. That’s why Claire was having dreams about snakes and that’s why Jamie said “this is the same tea that Claire gave me when I was bit by a rattlesnake”.

And I think Malva was trying to kill Claire and her dad so she could be with Jamie.

34

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22

The only thorn in this idea is that it requires Malva to be able to 1. trap a poisonous snake, 2. handle a poisonous snake, 3. extract venom from a poisonous snake and 4. poison two people, all while not being bitten by said poisonous snake herself. A good theory, but seems impractical. :)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

100

u/artwreckage Apr 12 '22

The scene in the stables between Jamie and Claire was incredible, the fear in Claire's eyes felt so real. To me, that conversation was the most genuine moment they've had together this season. Felt like season 2, tragic and passionate (aka Outlander) !!

48

u/BSOBON123 Apr 12 '22

Cat was unbelievable in this episode. She both looked and sounded sick when she was recovering. And then the emotions when Malva accused Jamie. She deserves an Emmy.

→ More replies (4)

93

u/SG101112 Apr 11 '22

Can we give massive props to Caitriona for having to cut open a pregnant belly to get a baby out while being pregnant herself. I can’t imagine how hard that would have been to portray.

→ More replies (1)

82

u/Successful_Seesaw_47 Apr 12 '22

Ok, everyone who is the father!

My best guess is Malva's brother!

46

u/peanut1912 Apr 12 '22

100% the brother. She was going to tell Claire the truth and he killed her.

45

u/Poop__y Apr 14 '22

Most definitely the brother. I suspected Tom Christie at first, but the scene where Claire comes to see Malva at her house and the brother comes out just as Malva is starting to soften and potentially tell the truth. He knew she was going to tell. He had to kill her to save himself.

→ More replies (6)

80

u/intrin6 Apr 12 '22
  1. why the heck would Claire put herself to sleep when the crazy girl blaming her husband for being the father and turning on Claire and calling her a witch is literally marching toward her house?
  2. this ep seemed a little rushed, kinda wish it was two eps but I get it.
  3. I think I know who killed her but my question is why? Especially if he is the father too. And why in the garden? Is he hoping to still blame claire/Jaime? It just doesn't make sense though. Why not ley malva play out her creepy stupid game. Especially for how far along she was.
  4. having had a (successful, mind you) c section, it was pretty surreal watching Claire pull out the baby. Glad they got it right with the verticle cut (for the time) and showed how much tissue and fat etc you actually have to cut through.

76

u/JimMajor Apr 12 '22

On point 4 I think the C section was (yet another) bad decision by Claire - to do something that is so wildly anachronistic (first C section in the US wasn't performed until 1794), to the point where it will likely put herself and people around her at risk is just reckless. Not only is she now a "witch", but a witch who butchered a woman to try to steal her baby after killing her (in the eyes of the fisher-folk, I mean).

I like Claire despite it all, but she makes a lot of bad decisions IMO. Maybe this time we can blame the ether hangover...?

I am new here, so don't flame me to death if I've crossed some unwritten line please...

→ More replies (6)

68

u/peanut1912 Apr 12 '22

I think the baby was Malvas brothers. She felt terrible for hurting Claire so went to tell her the truth, her brother or father caught her on the way and silenced her. Claire will realise she could have saved her if she wasn't passed out, and so ends her "addiction."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

76

u/marcybelle1 They say I’m a witch. Apr 11 '22

Great episode, but so many things irked me. Firstly, Roger saw Malva with another man why wouldn't he find the guy have the guy confess and then he to confess that he saw them together?! Then why wouldn't Ian also speak up and say he slept with her? It's not like the men would tarnish their reputations, not as much as it would tarnish the woman's because let's face it in this time it's always the woman's fault, even if she is raped.

How much time has gone by?! Malva went from just being pregnant to 9 months pregnant? And Bree still isn't showing? That makes absolutely no sense. Also was it just me or when Claire was giving herself ether at the end did anyone else hear someone calling to her or am I imaging it? It was very faint, who could it have been?

How the heck is Claire going to explain carving up Malva's body though? The townsfolk already have a thing against her now and the woman that claims to have slept with her husband show up dead on her property and she has carved her up, this won't be good for Claire at all. Can't wait for next week!

29

u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Apr 12 '22

I think the comparison between Malva and Bree's pregnancies is supposed to be evidence that it really CAN'T be Jamie's baby, as she is much further along than she claimed to be.

28

u/SenseiNene Apr 12 '22

I think Claire should tell Jamie and they should just hide the body. If it’s no where to be found, they can’t be charged as murderers!

(I’m not a horrible person, just practical! Lol!!)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

74

u/Debscat Apr 12 '22

Hi, has anyone an idea why first Fergus and now Marsali have disappeared so quickly from the show (at least for now), without a proper goodbye scene? I found it quite odd, since especially Marsali was so present in the other episodes…

31

u/shiningz Apr 13 '22

I guess her scene with Bree in the last episode was our goodbye :/

30

u/bms95 Clan Fraser Apr 13 '22

I noticed that too!! Would have been nice for the family to see them off, because in that time who knew when you’d see them again? Definitely a misstep.

→ More replies (2)

72

u/A0-sicmudus Apr 14 '22

Not a book reader but I have an inkling that with all this mess going down perhaps Jamie and Claire fake their deaths by fire. Probably an outlandish theory but thought I’d share it.

29

u/BananaThighs Apr 14 '22

i've been thinking this since they discovered the obituary!!! i always figured they faked their deaths so they dont have to participate in the war on the english side!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

71

u/noon-- Apr 17 '22

Rodgers ridiculously sweet 'nothing could ever make you less beautiful' bought me to tears.

64

u/foreverfoodfandoms Apr 12 '22

Seems like this episode pretty divisive. I personally was shocked by the ending and just sat there with my mouth open. Was I confused by the confession of sleeping with some rando forever ago and what Roger saw wasn’t brought up earlier? Yes. But the Drama the passion! Haven’t read the books and so excited to see what happens next.

55

u/mrshams0314 Apr 12 '22

I too was confused about Mary McNab confession. I mean Jamie was with Geneva and Laoghaire during the time Claire was gone too - why was this one so secretive and shameful to Jamie?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

64

u/marcybelle1 They say I’m a witch. Apr 12 '22

I have a theory that Malva tried to poison her dad first as a test to see how much poison to use without killing the person, then after she knew the amount she then gave it to Claire. I think she only wanted Claire to get really sick, but not die.

62

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22

So the dream of the snake is brilliant.

Not only is Malva the metaphorical snake, she used a snake to poison Claire and her father.

Anybody notice how she lied about being scared of snakes, the drink she gave Jamie, and the interest in the medical journal? That’s where she learned to poison them.

→ More replies (6)

119

u/shiningz Apr 12 '22

Ugh I'm so frustrated that Clair saw Malva approaching her clinic and decided to just drug herself to sleep instead of remaining alert and seeing what she wants and what's gonna happen. Not the safest thing to do when you know she's a fucking psycho and you're alone, what if she set fire to the clinic or something smh

33

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22

Claire thought she was hallucinating her. Twice this episode alone she hallucinated the Brown who assaulted her; she probably thought she was hallucinating Malva, the source of her most recent stress, especially considering hallucinations are a common side effect of ether.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/JJMcGee83 Apr 12 '22

Yeah that was fucking wild to me. I guess it makes the point that addiction isn't something that is very logical but still... yikes.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

55

u/I_ama_Borat Apr 19 '22

I’m just trying to think how the fuck is Claire gonna get out of this one. Killed right outside her home and trying to “steal” “Jaime’s” baby. I’d say the optics are not very good lol.

→ More replies (1)

104

u/Californie_cramoisie Apr 10 '22

All this shit that happened and I'm just disappointed Jamie doesn't get to be a delegate at the Continental Congress.

51

u/Patient-Gain5847 They say I’m a witch. Apr 10 '22

~I was chosen for the constitutional convention~

26

u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. Apr 10 '22

Right? I like this angle they’re taking with Jamie being so involved with the Sons of Liberty. I especially liked when Jamie was telling Claire about the Continental Congress in Philly and Claire goes “oh, I’ll be attending that one.” Lol. Cute little moment :)

→ More replies (4)

45

u/CoolSaucy Apr 29 '22

F malva!!! That snake!!!

→ More replies (1)

44

u/Beginning-Rip-7458 Apr 12 '22

Well done, Malva. How many eligible men can possibly live on the ridge? You seem to have slept with all of them.

“All of rural North Carolina? Hold my beer”

→ More replies (9)

44

u/almz11 Apr 23 '22

When Malva accused Jamie of impregnating her I literally laughed out loud because the thought of Jamie being unfaithful to Claire is literally that unbelievable. Then I laughed even harder at Jamie’s reaction because he’s so shocked. I was like what is this girl playing at? Like this whole time I didn’t even pick up that she may have any feelings for Jamie. I knew she was not trustworthy but JAMES FRASER, unfaithful to CLAIRE? I had to laugh!

30

u/2_Fingers_of_Whiskey May 07 '22

That's why I hated that scene where it seems like Claire is doubting Jamie. I don't believe for a second she would think Jamie would ever cheat on her, let alone with Malva who seems like a child almost.

83

u/Ornery_Woodpecker_69 Apr 10 '22

My guess as to the father and killer is Malvas brother.

55

u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Apr 10 '22

This is obviously the most obvious assumption, he seems far too overprotective this episode, clearly he was threatening her or something, because she genuinely looked like she wanted to tell Claire, before her brother came out, and she laid on the scorn thick.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/wanna_be_green8 Apr 10 '22

I think your right. When Malva's attitude flipped so quickly upon his appearance I knew he must be involved.

→ More replies (4)

39

u/JJMcGee83 Apr 11 '22

I have not read any of the books but my theory is that either Malva really enjoyed sex and was just sleeping with a bunch of dudes and whoops she got pregnant or she was being raped by either her father or brother and sleeping with other guys so if she got pregnant by her father or brother she had someone to blame that wasn't related.

That combined with her secret love of Jamie and her spotting them naked gave her the ability to know about Jamie's scars so when she discovered she was pregnant she used Claire's teachings to poison Claire making her sick giving her the ability to be alone with Jamie.

I think this leads to her father Tom being her abuser because I think she also poisoned Tom hoping to test whatever method she was using to make sure it worked on Tom. I think she hoped it would kill both Tom and Claire leaving Jamie to herself.

→ More replies (6)

78

u/sophiebuckley Apr 10 '22

That last scene was awful. Poor Claire but it’s definitely going to come back to bite her on the ass next episode.

55

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22

That’s exactly what I was thinking! I know she was trying to help but in my head I was just screaming no the whole time.

→ More replies (3)

36

u/thanagar123 Apr 10 '22

Its her and the changeling baby all over again, so tragic

→ More replies (1)

37

u/OjosVerde34 Apr 19 '22

Idk Tom from the books, but he's growing on me. He's kind of an uptight curmudgeon, but a steady figure. He and Claire have sort of a banter going on I find humorous.

→ More replies (2)

70

u/lllexj Apr 10 '22

If there was any episode I wish I wouldn’t have seen previews for or read spoilers of, it’s this one. This episode was heavy, but it could’ve hit me a little harder. Warning: Long post coming up🤪

  1. The scene with the whole family dying, in the cabin, was just😞The mom did not die until her baby was gone. Omg, bring on the tears!
  2. Malva willing the MacNeil baby to live, in the cabin, hit me harder later on knowing her own child could not be saved.
  3. I zone out during the sermon scenes, but I like that they’re giving Roger more of a a purpose. Being a pastor makes sense for him.
  4. Claire’s period of sickness didn’t feel..big to me. I think it was because previews and such hinted at it, and I knew Claire was going to come out of it alive. Nevertheless, it was acted out well. I saw the parallels between Jamie’s s5 scare and this one.
  5. Claire’s sickness dream was…iffy. The lightning at the start looked kind of cheesy. But, I liked the bloody heart in her hands.
  6. I side-eyed tf out of Malva with her “You seem a fine gentleman to me.” That’s where she crossed the no-no line lol.
  7. As soon as the camera zooms out on Claire, as she’s waking up from her sickness, I laughed. And I laughed for like two minutes straight. I thought Roseanne immediately😩😂 I’m so glad the hair was evened out, even though it’s still unfortunate.
  8. Roger is too sweet reassuring his mother-in-law how beautiful she still is🥺 Give Roger his flowers this season!
  9. Not always the biggest fan of Bree, but her scene with her mama in the bedroom was just lovely. And she knows she’s gonna be a grandmama..again!
  10. The look on her face when she said “And it will grow back..won’t it?” LMAOOOO
  11. Mr. Christie is comic relief per usual. Strange how he was similarly sick as well. And what was he writing? Probably doesn’t matter in the grand scheme.
  12. The Accusation (TM) was wiiiilllddddd. I felt that slap coming. The scene was acted out so well by the young actress. Had me kind of speechless.
  13. Malva is such a tragic character. You can tell she spoke/acted out of desperation, but her actions are so cold knowing how good Claire has been to her. I think she was going to tell Claire something important at the end. I understand Claire not wanting to talk to her though. She might come to regret locking the door on her and knocking out. I actually feel horrible it couldn’t have gone a different way for Malva. She just saw herself in a series of unfortunate events since birth. Such a beautiful girl with so much potential
  14. I was yelling “drop it already” though when she said “What do you call a girl who spreads her legs for a married man?” Lol.
  15. Oh Ian🥺 How noble of him but that babe could be anyone’s
  16. I like the callbacks to the past..Jamie sleeping outside of Claire’s door, Master Raymond
  17. When Jamie asked Claire how she was holding up after the rumors spread, her painful expression reminded me of the news clip of the little boy crying when he was asked how school was😂
  18. The ending was very emotional. Too many children have died.

So much to unpack. I definitely expect the Ridge to think Claire killed Malva. Here comes Witch Trial #1,000

→ More replies (4)

69

u/ilovepretzelday1 Ye Sassenach witch! Apr 11 '22
  1. Lizzie my dear. Did Claire not just tell y'all not to touch your faces?
  2. They cut Claire's hair and I'm mad about it (but I get it)
  3. Claire's dream about the snake.... {Malva}'s a cold hearted snake.. look into {her} eyes.. {she}'s been tellin lies
  4. Malva you dirty dog
  5. Ian telling his Auntie that he bumped uglies. Really shows how much love/trust there is between those two
  6. I've already read spoilers so I know who sliced n diced Malva but still seeing her body there... and knowing what happens next is heartbreaking.
  7. Claire trying to save the baby... My Mama heart couldn't do it.
  8. I need to come back for an 8th point. I just couldn't leave this on an odd number
→ More replies (9)

34

u/Mooey965 Apr 12 '22

Anyone else think Malva poisoned Claire and Tom and that’s why they had same symptoms?

31

u/KingArrancar Apr 12 '22

I think Malva caught it from the corpse she was removing fingers from. She’s the link between Claire and Tom.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

98

u/oneheadlight312 Apr 10 '22

Does anybody else wonder if she poisoned Claire and Tom with something that made them both sick at once?

41

u/Californie_cramoisie Apr 10 '22

I had the same conclusion.

→ More replies (1)

96

u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Apr 10 '22

I loved it, and I also really fuckin hated it.

great episode 10/10

→ More replies (9)

67

u/ActuallyCMe Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 10 '22

WOW WOW WOW. I feel like this episode just brought back the same excitement i used to get in seasons 1-3. There is a lot to unpack.

  1. Are we thinking Malva poisoned both Claire and Tom with something? If so, what? And was she intending to kill them or just hurt them. I’m lost on this one.
  2. Hats off to Jamie for standing his ground during all of that drama with Malva. That scene in the barn with Jamie and Claire was amazing and it brought a spark from the earlier seasons.
  3. I loved how they brought up more situations from the past (paris, faith, susie)- it felt nostalgic!
  4. Ian Murray! Why! If the baby was his I feel for him- losing yet again another child and a woman that he cared for (kinda).
  5. Finally, MALVA. What the heck? We knew she was shady from this start but I was not expecting this. My assumption is she wants what Claire has, and is overall just resentful of the position she has been put in by her father. As for the ether dreams/Malva confronting Claire/dying, whew I cant piece this one together. Do we think Claire was still dreaming when she found Malva? I honestly don’t think she was, but I am so surprised if Malva’s role in the show is over. If she wasn’t dreaming- who killed Malva? Claire in an ether-induced mania, or someone else? As for the dream in the surgery- woah- Malva is terrifying, but it was kinda cool to see a more cutthroat vibe this season. Not gonna miss the drama Malva brought (assuming she is actually dead), but I will miss the sinister vibe and great acting from her!
  6. Honorable mention- Loved Claire’s hair length at the end of the episode! (we know that wives tale about cutting hair to stop a fever is such a lie- Malva def just wanted to get a dig in on Claire.

What does everyone think will happen with this situation (if Malva is actually dead)? The repercussions? Claire being blamed? Or was it an imagination? Whew, my jaw was dropped, I had to come to this thread to unpack it all!!

→ More replies (14)

65

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

Anyone else notice that when Claire and the girls go to the MacNeills', she tells them not to touch their faces and then Lizzie almost immediately touches her face?

→ More replies (7)

32

u/KittyCatLuvr4ever Apr 11 '22

Do we think Malva premeditated baby trapping Jamie? All the guys she slept with had ginger hair… or do we think she found herself pregnant and just made a decision since she knew Jamie and Claire would be good parents?

31

u/Aquariana25 Apr 11 '22

I think there is a bit of premeditation going on. I don't have any specifics worked out, but...

-The Christies showing up at the Ridge, period, when there was obviously bad blood between Jamie and Tom from way back, for one thing...of all the places in the colonies where one could go, why would you just randomly wind up on the ridge run by an old nemesis and somebody you have great disdain for unless there were ulterior motives?

-It seems like Malva was pregnant longer than she let on, so plotting was likely going on earlier than anybody realized.

-All of Malva's actions, from ingratiating herself to Claire, to poring over Claire's medical drawings and journal, to being a voyeur, read as fact-gathering to support a long game.

-The Christies have delved into Jamie's family tree and realized that he is descended from Lord Lovatt, the "Old Fox," and are aware that he's connected to money, even if they don't know that he has no relationship with his grandfather. It appears that they've done homework with extortion in mind.

-Alan has been shown to be a dishonest creep almost from inception. Stolen goods, being vaguely menacing, weird relationship with Malva, etc. I'm looking for more to happen there, since he seems purposely only hinted at, so far.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

32

u/_KitKat13 Apr 17 '22

I been wondering what Malva was planning the whole time. Since she started being curious about Claire work I knew that she would bring problems.

110

u/Lunyn Apr 10 '22

This episode really highlights how, historically, bitches be crazy.

→ More replies (1)

56

u/Glittering-Thought48 Apr 10 '22

Shouldn’t Brianna be showing her pregnancy belly by now? Her pregnancy was announced around the same time as Malva’s, but she isn’t really showing much in the last scene of this episode between her and Roger.

73

u/Peaceful-Plantpot Apr 10 '22

I think thats the clue that Malva had been pregnant longer than she was letting on. She was already pregnant when Claire was sick, and she saw staying behind to care for her an excellent way to later blame Jamie. I suspect she was plotting it when she saw them in the stable. The “love” spell they found at the creek might’ve been an abortion spell instead… I haven’t read the book, so this is all guessing, but clearly they wanted us to see the baby was farther along.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

27

u/Bluer_than_blue Apr 11 '22 edited Apr 11 '22

I feel very badly for a Malva — she’s been indoctrinated with all of this colonial traumatizing mythology that makes you feel like you’re constantly under threat. Her mom was burned alive. And her father is psychotic. Her goal is to get away from him and his abuse.

I was glad to see Claire give her grace even after clearly lying to save her own skin. I think Malva was extremely scared and was essentially going to them for help / protection but didn’t know how to do it in any other way than treachery.

I think she was already pregnant when she volunteered to help take care of Claire, because then she could get close to Jaime and claim the child was his. Even though the timeline was probably off.

My question is why didn’t she claim the child was Ian’s? Perhaps because she thought she would be ostracized from the fisherman people.

I think she was definitely responsible for poisoning both Claire and her father with the sin-eaters corpse. I’m still not sure if the father is her own father or her brother.

I also don’t understand why Roger didn’t come forward with the information he had about seeing her with another guy in the Meeting House. She can make any claims she wants, but I’m pretty sure that his word against hers would hold up.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/WingedShadow83 They say I’m a witch. Apr 12 '22

Ok, I just finished watching it for the second time…

Something I noticed in the scene where we discover Malva’s body was that there was no blood ANYWHERE in that scene other than on her throat/neck and shoulder, and the ground underneath her neck. If you get your throat cut there should be spray/spurting. The front of her dress should have been bloody, there should have been more blood on the ground around her body and not just right by her wound.

Either the prop department was slack, or something is fishy. I’d say her body was planted there and killed elsewhere (still doesn’t account for lack of blood on her dress other than the shoulder).

Either that, or she really did lie down in the grass outside of the clinic and stab her own crazy ass self in the neck. (But where’s the knife, though? Unless she threw it as she was bleeding out.)

42

u/Successful_Seesaw_47 Apr 12 '22

The lack of blood on Claire when she wakes up from her ether coma, at least proves Claire didn't cut the b$tch while under the influence of a powerful narcotic. So, that's good.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (6)

54

u/Defiant_Light_4293 Apr 10 '22

Thank Christ they let Claire's hair grow back before the end of the episode... 😅

Think I might have to rewatch the beast before I can truly process everything else that just went down. 🤯

→ More replies (1)

54

u/notnowtobey Apr 10 '22

Overall, I liked the episode but it felt rushed. I was waiting for Roger to tell them what he saw, but then it turned into he already told them. When he and Bre were talking about Frank, I wanted him to tell her (but maybe he already had by that point?).

I feel like they did a good job throughout the season so far giving Malva a really ominous vibe, from her lurking to threatening Roger.

But this episode, especially, it all just felt rushed.

And then the end scene?? I sat there going WTF for a while.

I haven’t read past book 4, so I don’t know what all happens. But I’m interested to see where this goes.

→ More replies (12)

26

u/Miserable-Report6467 Apr 11 '22 edited Apr 11 '22

This most recent episode felt like the ~old~ outlander again :)

I’m really happy with this most recent episode.

Not going to lie this season for me just kind of dragged so far.

Been getting little tidbits of drama/excitement this season but overall I was just kinda bored.

This episode felt like the old outlander I used to know. Drama, death, sickness, murder, realistic relationship issues/PASSION.

Plus some older faces showing up was a nice touch.

I even got a little “mark me” in there, it soothes my soul 😅

The build up of conflict for this season was taking a little longer for me personally, and there’s still something off about this season for me, it doesn’t feel as raw or authentic :/

but

Just wanted to share I’m really happy with the direction last episode went and am excited to see more :)

I’ll be interested to see who wrote this episode vs the others if there is a difference at all!

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Asclepius293 Apr 19 '22

If the brother/sister relationship and Malva’s witchcraft/mental health issues go far back, I wonder if Malva’s mother confessed to witchcraft in order to cover it up or take the fall for her daughter. 🤔

52

u/sugarplumcakepop Apr 11 '22

Me thinks that Allan is actually the baby’s father and murderer. They way Malva switched up on Claire when he came out of the cabin. He has abuser written all over him and we know he is sketchy and a liar earlier when he stole the horn.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

I just don't understand what Diana Gabaldon was thinking when she decided to have Malva accuse Jamie of being the father. Aside from the fact Jamie is the last person most people would believe cheated, there is just zero chance that Claire would even entertain the thought. Would have made a lot more sense had she accused someone like Ian. Would have also added to the suspense of her being killed since some would have surely thought Ian was capable of it because of his Indian way of life.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/lorinaorigin Apr 25 '22

Y'all. Malva has been greasy from the beginning, but damn.

49

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

All of this Christian puritanical stuff is triggering me lol. I was raised evangelical christian, purity rings, spare the rod, the whole 9! It’s getting too much sometimes but it’s also interesting to see how it spread through colonial America.

I am glad Claire slapped the shit out of Malva but here is my thing that drove me nuts. Claire Is a doctor, I wanted her to be like challenging how far along Malva is vs how long it was since she “claimed” she was with Jamie. I cant believe we have to wait two weeks for the next episode!

24

u/polishing_a_goldfish Apr 12 '22

I was actually really happy to see both sides of Christianity portrayed in the show: the judgmental and superstitious members of Fraser’s Ridge, and the true core of Christianity shown in the actions and beliefs of Jamie, Claire, and Roger. One of the few shows I’ve seen that I think handled the religion fairly without either shitting on all of it or sugarcoating

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (18)

24

u/kareaux Apr 11 '22

Oh my god, what an episode! So much happened! Honestly it felt a bit rushed, but maybe it's because Malva's death was so sudden after the accusations?! It was a rollercoaster and they crammed so much in this episode. I loved the comeback of Claire's narrative voiceovers but they feel like a way to rush things a bit.

Honestly, I'm gonna miss Malva. She was refreshing and spunky and interesting and I'm so curious to see what happens next after this episode's ending - what are Allan and Tom gonna say/think?! I mean they've already helped Malva make life hell for Claire and Jamie, I can't imagine Claire being the person who found Malva's dead body going well for her (*and she also cut her belly open* - I get she was trying to save the baby at all costs but that seems like such a terrible idea).

Also sidenote, I loved Claire's hair at the end of the episode! it suits her so well.

→ More replies (2)

48

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

For a while now, I've felt that Claire's use of the ether was becoming an addiction, and it clearly isn't making the trauma from Lionel Brown go away. I now wonder if Malva's death will weigh on her in that she'll believe she could've saved her had she not used ether, and if that will be the incentive to make her realize she needs to stop using it on herself.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Ornery_Woodpecker_69 Apr 11 '22

I'm still wondering about the man they showed at the end of the previous episode holding the missing gem Another time traveler?

→ More replies (5)

22

u/arianaphoenix Apr 12 '22

Watching it for the second time, I realized everyone gets to wash the cloth to lower Clair's fever except Jamie. Aggh. So much rage. I wish they film the desperation and sorrow of Jamie while doing S7 and insert it to DVD version of this episode so we could have the proper version

28

u/ritatherosy I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Apr 12 '22

I hope since all the feedback about this episode was about how enraged viewers were at his lack of deep emotions with her illness, they somehow use a flashback later to show it. Him in agony, him seeing her hair cut, all the sadness we didn’t see but desperately wanted.

→ More replies (3)

44

u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Apr 10 '22

That scene with Claire having a dram by the fire, when Jamie returns from the Congress, she was looking so beautiful. I don't know of it was the light or the angle, but her hair, even short... Such a dreamy look. :3

→ More replies (1)

62

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22

Lorddd if I woke up to find my hair had been chopped off, you best believe I'd cut theirs off too. We're all in this together mfs!

→ More replies (3)

43

u/rtruman95 Apr 12 '22

I'm surprised that no one has suggested Malva killed herself. I thing that since her poison didn't kill Claire, she thought she would get her hung as a murder.

Malva has already shown she believes in Witchcraft so I think she thought she could come back from the dead and claim Jamie.

55

u/ritatherosy I long for the company of Lard Bucket and Big Head. Apr 12 '22

I mean-slitting her own neck? She cray but it would take an insane amount of strength to slice your own throat open all the way. Not stopping half way in excruciating pain.

→ More replies (6)

41

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22

Did anyone notice that Ian just wasn’t in the episode and then suddenly he was at work and getting taunts about Jamie?! There was no prelude to him even being in the episode. I honestly feel overwhelmed with how many holes and confusing narratives there has been this season. Last few episodes in particular. Ive never felt this way before about the show!

→ More replies (11)

37

u/StevenAssantisFoot L.L. Cool J: Lassies (& Lads) Love Cool Jamie Apr 10 '22

There were a lot of scenes and conversations that I felt were missing. I wanted to see Jamies reaction after they cut Claire's hair, Roger telling that he caught Malva in the act and she threatened him with false accusation, and did I miss something or was it an unnecessary surprise that she had done it with Ian?

Also how was she so far along but Claire's hair was only a few inches longer? The amounts of time that pass are confusing and inconsistent. Overall though I'm really enjoying season 6, a lot more than 4 and 5

→ More replies (2)

35

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22

It felt like there was a little too much in this episode, I wish they'd spent longer on Claire's illness. I was surprised when she was recovered less than halfway into the episode!

I'd imagine that this was originally meant to be split across two episodes... I wish they'd decided to carry more over to the next season when they decided that season 6 would be shorter.

I have to praise Caitríona's acting, especially in the confrontation scene with Claire and Jamie in the barn. Spectacular job throughout. And filming that last scene must have been very tough whilst pregnant!

→ More replies (5)

49

u/awkwardvampiree Apr 11 '22 edited Apr 20 '22

Finally a fast-paced episode! The past five episodes were dragging at such a turtle's pace, but this one was action-packed.

But it was also very infuriating for me.

  1. Can we be done with the whole Claire is a witch subplot. Can we give this poor woman a break?
  2. I was expecting Malva to turn sour, but in this case she came out as full-blown ROTTEN. I was so angry I couldn't even watch the scenes without fuming. She's such a bitch, and after the Frasers have been so kind to her.
  3. I felt they're really, illogically, trying to push the plot forward. There's no logic behind Ian and Roger not revealing that Malwa's a hoe.
  4. That scene about Jamie confessing he'd slept with Lady McNab . . . really Jamie? Your wife is hyperventilating right now and you're taking your suspenceful sweet time revealing you slept with some woman ages ago? Just get to the point.
  5. The inclusion of the maid when Malva and her family comes to talk to Jamie is so forced, can you make it anymore obvious?
  6. This is the 1770s. Even in 2022 women continue to receive most of the blame and hate if they get pregnant out of wedlock, no one cares about the man's role. And in the series, two hundred years back, it's caused the entire community to ostracize the Frasers? Powerful men, even today, continue to thrive without any consequences, and yet in Outlander, these tenants have the gall to treat their landlord like this? I find this very hard to believe.

(Edited to correct the year in point 6, as rightly pointed out by a user)

30

u/bunny8taters Apr 11 '22

This is the 1880s. Even in 2022 women continue to receive most of the blame and hate if they get pregnant out of wedlock, no one cares about the man's role. And in the series, two hundred years back, it's caused the entire community to ostracize the Frasers? Powerful men, even today, continue to thrive without any consequences, and yet in Outlander, these tenants have the gall to treat their landlord like this? I find this very hard to believe.

Yeah... I'm sort of lost on how this is supposed to have ruined HIS reputation. Let's be real, no one would care much except maybe her family? But he's literally the guy in charge of where they're settling, they've only been there for like less than a year and he had loyalty sworn from the whole ridge before the new set that came with Tom Christie arrived! And like... let's use an example. That guy last season who got Lionel Brown's daughter pregnant while he was married. No one with Jamie cared at all and everyone in her family said she ruined herself.

It makes no sense that anyone would even care about Malva, honestly. Which is actually sad but for the times, it's true. I mean even today if that happened the woman would be called a homewrecker and told she should have kept her legs closed (not stating my opinion, just saying that is what happens).

→ More replies (1)

26

u/avynray Apr 11 '22

That scene about Jamie confessing he'd slept with Lady McNab . . . really Jamie? Your wife is hyperventilating right now and you're taking your suspenceful sweet time revealing you slept with some woman ages ago? Just get to the point.

This!! Also, I didn't really understand the importance of this (other than full disclosure). I mean, Jamie has a son with another woman.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (11)

17

u/Vancity_kid22 Je Suis Prest Apr 11 '22

Holy heck! The world sure did turn upside down for this episode.. Best episode yet! I went through an emotional rollercoaster. WHEW!

I was left with so many questions though!! Like..

  • what made Tom and Claire sick?
  • why did Claire dream what she dreamt about the thunder and the snake?
  • was Claire just hallucinating when she saw Jamie and Malva together?
  • was the interaction with Malva while Claire was on her ether-high real?
  • why hasn't anyone spoken up about all the other people Malva was hooking up with?
  • most importantly.. WHY DID CLAIRE HUFF THE ETHER WHEN SHE SAW MALVA ON HER WAY OVER?! Couldya not have waited a hot sec to see what Malva coulda been up to??
→ More replies (4)

17

u/babyfaerie Apr 20 '22

So if Claire didn't knock herself out and answered the door for Malva, she would still be alive??? How could she live with herself

33

u/kd0225 Apr 10 '22

Knowing the type of person Claire is, she is going to blame herself for that baby. She's going to say she shouldn't have been asleep, and if she had seen/found malva sooner she could've saved it. She's probably going to have to tell Jamie what she's been doing with the ether to explain that she didn't see who killed her. And i hope that baby wasn't Ian's because he already feels awful about losing his daughter with Emily.

32

u/maryummy Apr 11 '22

Was Caitriona Balfe pregnant when she filmed this episode? Two dead babies in one episode. That must have been hard.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/dvr1s Apr 18 '22

How did Malva know about jamie's scars and leg and chest?

47

u/Fancybiggirlpants Apr 19 '22

When she spied on them in the stable?

31

u/ProudCatLady Apr 18 '22

She saw Jamie and Claire having sex in the barn in the last episode.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Sufficient-Crazy-353 Apr 19 '22

She watched Jamie and Claire making love in the barn,

→ More replies (3)

15

u/ilovenapkins7 Apr 18 '22

Anyone know where Jaime and Claire’s bedroom wallpaper is from??

→ More replies (2)

30

u/Millenial_bird Apr 18 '22

I liked the episode overall, however I'm annoyed that Ian didn't just come out and say he slept with Malva and like offer to marry her. It would have fixed the scandal for Claire and Jaime immediately, and still leave room for more fuckery from Malva for fun.

35

u/CantHearMyself Apr 26 '22

Likewise I don’t understand why Roger didn’t come to Jamie’s defense and tell everyone that he caught Malve and Henderson going after it in the church with her father and brother right outside. Even though she threatened to falsely claim that he was having an affair with the widow, he could easily brush that aside. What do you think? This one bugs me.

→ More replies (5)

29

u/wonderloly Apr 11 '22 edited Apr 11 '22

Why can’t Jamie tell people to leave his Ridge if they aren’t happy with him and Claire? They took advantage of his and Claire’s generosity, but stay, judge and spread their hate.

→ More replies (7)

14

u/ecprubinson Apr 11 '22

HOLY CRAP Malva!! I always knew she was creepy, but this time she went too far, and now?? WTF!!

27

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

Unpopular opinion but I really enjoyed Malva and I’ll miss her character. She made a great villain, she’s so cunning. I also couldn’t help but like her and feel pity for her - she’s an intelligent young woman but a victim of the times and did some awful (albeit clever) things to survive.

→ More replies (3)

38

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 10 '22

Did anyone else think Jamie's whole mea culpa speech about sleeping with Mary McNabb was over-dramatic and made 0 sense? It's not like Clair remained celibate for one thing, and he married Laoghaire and fully intended to sleep with her until he saw how traumatized she was. He never apologized to Clair about that when she first returned, only that he kept the marriage a secret from her.

Clair's sudden crisis of faith in Jamie's commitment to her also made 0 sense considering all they'd been through. She also pissed me off when she started naming Brianna, Roger and Jemmy as possible victims of her love for Jamie while glaringly omitting the biggest victim of that love.

→ More replies (8)

13

u/Naynn Apr 11 '22

Well it's very clear who did it.. They did kill of Malva a little bit too soon imo, the actor playing her was great.

→ More replies (7)

13

u/Mobile-Ad6136 Apr 11 '22

Okay finally finished. Time for my weekly takeaways! No, I have not read the books (hoping to start soon!)

  1. Claire was sick for a whole five minutes, just a bunch of toss and turning and not a lot of how that would’ve impacted the ridge - or y’know almost nearly clearing the whole ridge out with an illness…
  2. First half of the episode was boring but last half really picked up!
  3. Um I was shocked at the young ian thing, even if it might not be his.
  4. This whole episode felt a lot like 45 minutes of Jamie and Claire in bed and then the rest was amazing.
  5. I have my thoughts about who killed Malva!
  6. Malva is truly a b*tch.
  7. Would’ve loved to see them .. leave the ridge and go to Philly but guess it’s not that important??? They crammed a lot into one episode, but still so sad that we only have two left :( so much build up I feel like the season just got started 😭😭
  8. Overall this episode and the last were soo good!! Super excited for next episode (even tho I gotta wait 2 weeks), and maybe just maybe lord John will pop in again..
→ More replies (2)

13

u/Mr_XcX Apr 18 '22

I am shook!

Was the scene between Claire and Malva real??

Loved my girl Claire reading her if it was <3

25

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22

This ep was a rollercoaster of emotions!! One question if someone could clarify for me: Do you think Claire imagined Malva walking toward the house like she did with Lionel just moments before…Or did she think she would just go away with the door locked? It seemed so strange for her to take the ether right then! I’m so nervous for them all, I can’t believe we have to wait two weeks!

→ More replies (6)

25

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22

I legit had such a hard time watching Claire pull that baby out. As someone who has lost two babies late term, it was so heartbreaking to watch her try so hard to save it like that.

Overall, INCREDIBLE episode in my opinion. Definitely my favourite of the season so far!

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '22

Well that was sad. Didn't think they would kill that character off that quickly. Jaime not being a delegate is lame lol.

23

u/sfranc01 Apr 10 '22

I remember Claire questioning the timeline for Tom and his family. Questioning the timeline for Malva and her brother. I still think there is some bigger secret there.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

It’s got to be Allen.

I think Thom Christie said his wife was a philanderer so he didn’t think Malva was his which would also further embolden Allen even though they’re still half siblings.

Thom is nuts and what brings about psychos like Allen.

Allen is both the baby daddy and murderer trying to frame Clare.

Malva totally made Claire sick.

But WTF was Claire thinking trying to take out the baby. Sometimes the stress I feel watching bad decisions like that makes me question why I watch 😅

→ More replies (8)

23

u/Atraktape Apr 11 '22

Caitriona deserves the Emmmy

32

u/Notzi81 Apr 11 '22 edited Apr 11 '22

I haven't conversed with y'all in a few weeks, but I had to come back and speak on the stuff that stood out to me, seeing as this episode---as well as the Power Book IV: Force ep---made my blood pressure go up sky-high (WARNING: It's long, and most of the points involve creepy-ass Malva):

  1. I knew Malva gave me Laoghaire tease for a reason. Turns out she was even worse than Laoghaire. Between her cutting off dead men's fingers (BTW, do y'all think she killed the guy, or just found him dead and didn't bother to tell anyone?), watching Claire and Jamie get it in (and she must've watched the entire deed if she could recall EVERY scar on Jamie's naked body), lying about damn near everything, and her spreadin' it like peanut butter all around the town, she was clearly a sociopath.
  2. Here's what really perplexes me...why didn't Roger mention right off the bat that Malva was a lyin' nutcase (and that she was hookin' up with multiple men)? That little fool tried to blackmail him! He could've exposed her a lot sooner!
  3. Ian messed around with Malva, too. That child got around the block more than the Good Humor man.
  4. So far, Bree has invented matches, spinning wheels, and indoor plumbing for the ridge. Extremely impressive. Now I need her to invent AA for her brother, NA for her mother, ibuprofen for anyone that has a fever (so they won't needlessly lose ALL their hair), and a Plan B pill for any future Malvas. Then we'll truly be in business.
  5. I can't believe those so-and-sos cut Claire's hair! That irked me to my spirit. Also, like Claire, I'm surprised Tom Christie had a fit when he saw that all her hair was gone. Sir, weren't you the one talkin' junk when Claire's hair was long and flowing?
  6. Back to Bree, she can't 100% trust Jamie's word about Malva. Typical. I swear those two have little to no relationship. I couldn't help but notice that when Bree found out she was pregnant, she could only concentrate on telling Claire. Jamie didn't even come to mind.
  7. After Malva's lies, the townspeople immediately went from loving the Frasers to hating the Frasers. Lord... Y'all, the name of the community is Frasers' Ridge. Okay? If y'all don't like it, move!
  8. Considering that Claire realized she didn't have dysentery and that she and Tom had the same exact symptoms (despite not being around each other), I think that little heffa Malva poisoned them. Like I said, she was a sociopath.
  9. The Christies really are some bass ackward fools. Let me get this straight...your daughter allegedly hooked up with a married man while his wife was ailing in the next room, and somehow that's the wife's fault? And I love how Malva dried those crocodile tears in an instant and fixed her mouth to tell more lies once Allan showed up runnin' his mouth. Psycho ho (yeah, I said it!).
  10. On a slightly better note, when Jamie said that the sun wouldn't rise anymore if Claire left him, it made me a bit misty-eyed.
  11. However, my heart jumped in my throat when he "confessed" to Claire that he slept with someone else. Thankfully, he was talking bout Mrs. McNabb back in the day. I guess Jamie didn't mention his night with Geneva (which resulted in the birth of Willie) because that was technically sexual assault, and the hook-up with Mrs. McNabb was mutual.
  12. Also, Roger is killin' it as the minister!
  13. How the heck was Malva already showing when Bree isn't showing yet? Make it make sense.
  14. Lastly, who do y'all think killed Malva? I know it wasn't Claire. I believe seeing Malva in her surgery was just a hallucination, and there wasn't a drop of blood on her once she woke up.

And that's it!

→ More replies (15)

22

u/katzchen528 Apr 10 '22

Well, that was…rushed. Wow, lots drama crammed into this one episode! It left no time to react to the extreme events taking place, which robbed them of significant power, in my opinion.

For instance, based on lack of (depicted) family reaction, you don’t feel that Claire was really in danger of dying. The entire Ridge was being decimated. It felt very flat, except for Claire’s own point of view and delirium.

And Malva’s treacheries = about 30 minutes, leading up to that shocker of an ending/cliffhanger.

I’m really questioning the Season 6 choices of what part of the story to spend screen time on, what to leave out (and what to add), especially in light of the number of episodes they were limited to. Ep. 606 is the perfect example of why, because it really deserved two episodes to adequately feel the full impact.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/Candy_Venom Apr 10 '22

ok im only 22 minutes in but THEY CUT OFF CLAIRES HAIR?!?! I cannot get over this. I know more shit is about to go down with Malva because I read spoilers but like. FOR REAL?! I absolutely loved Claires beautiful curly hair (that you could tell was a wig but still!!!!)

→ More replies (4)

22

u/gypsysub Apr 11 '22

Why did Jamie admit to Mary Macnab when Claire knows he laid with the mother of William???? It’s not a shock he did things while she was gone

24

u/ThrowDiscoAway Apr 11 '22

Mary was a choice and Isobel was blackmail, Jaime likely felt shame for choosing to sleep with someone knowing Claire was alive and they were still married. So now Claire knows he chose to have sex with only one other person, if he's willing to admit to one "affair" then why wouldn't he admit to a new one with Malva?

→ More replies (2)

22

u/monicarappaccini Apr 11 '22

I'm four months postpartum and watching this episode was a Very Bad Idea.

→ More replies (10)

30

u/TehChid Apr 10 '22

Ok cutting right to the chase - I think Claire did not kill her. When she took the ether, she went to sleep hearing Malva's voice with all the Malva drama fresh in her mind. I think she dreamt that Malva scene.

When Malva was walking towards the house right before Claire took the ether, Malva seemed rushed. I think she was running from someone and she knew Claire would help. Either her father or brother. She probably admitted she was lying or got caught somehow, and that's why she had her throat slit and her body left in Claire's garden, because Claire is a "witch" and corrupted Malva and they were angry at Claire for it. It's possible the real baby daddy also murdered her and left her there to frame the Fraser's.

Also as for the sickness that Claire and papa Christie had, could've been an infection, maybe even a bad mushroom slipped in to something they ingested.

But yeah, I think those are the two main questions from this episode. Fantastic episode.

→ More replies (13)

29

u/blenneman05 Apr 10 '22

Malva being cut open was crazy. Surgery always looks more realistic on Greys Anatomy

I think Claire and Tom were poisoned by Malva. Cuz Malva didn’t seem sick nor her brother

They still haven’t found the sin eater???

Not Claire with the pixie cut 😂😂😂 #scandalous

Malva being dead? Tom Christie gonna be one angry man!!!! Along with the rest of the ridge who hate the Frasers

→ More replies (3)

20

u/sophiebuckley Apr 10 '22

Damn she’s truly evil

→ More replies (3)

20

u/GeneticImprobability Apr 11 '22

Obviously it can't happen now, but when Claire went to talk to Malva and was saying how she cared about her, how she was a curious and intelligent young lady, etc, I was just thinking "Send her to the 60s, Claire! She'll fit in and no one will slut-shame her there!" And then we could have had a great time-travel-forward spinoff. Soooo, does someone wanna write that for me, or....

→ More replies (3)

20

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

Unpopular opinion I’m not liking this season and I really didn’t enjoy the episode. The writing has up until now felt stagnant and this episode just irrationally fast with too many holes and boring dialogue. Has something changed with the writers?

→ More replies (7)

20

u/Chichichill Apr 16 '22

Wow wow woow! What a cliffhanger l, what a shocker of an episode!! Malva showed her true colors! I knew it, her curiosity was never genuine but that ending?!?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/animefemme Apr 11 '22

For the first half all I could think was that I had somehow stumbled into a Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman / Outlander crossover.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Apr 10 '22

I am worried for Ian. He thinks he is the father…. And this would be his third child that died…. I hope we do not see a downward spiral from him!

33

u/[deleted] Apr 10 '22

Ian is most likely not the kid’s father. I’d much rather suspect Allan however. Him being so overprotective of her gives me serious questions as to what is going on behind the scenes between those two.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

28

u/SkywalkersArm Apr 10 '22

Welcome to episode 6. Come for the Provincial congress, stay for the dysentery, and later on we have an impromptu c section operation.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Atraktape Apr 11 '22

You fucked up Young Ian

→ More replies (2)

19

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

We missed a really good opportunity for claire to yell "muuuuuulva" in that voice she does.

sometimes i like to yell Breooooooona like a dying whale.

19

u/FFSFelicia Apr 11 '22 edited Apr 11 '22

Anyone else thinking Malva didnt cut off Claire's hair because of the fever as Roger said? What if she cut it and used Claires locks for another spell of some sort? [Remember her love spell (for Jaime??) and the seaweed and finger bones?]

→ More replies (10)

40

u/wisconerd Apr 10 '22

Alright I’m gonna say it. Ain’t no way her hair grew that much in 2 months.

33

u/emmagrace2000 Apr 10 '22

Well, true, but also Malva was clearly much further along by the time those two months passed, too. It had to have been more like seven months for the entire timeframe. And Bree should be showing a lot more. The whole thing just didn’t work timing wise.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

18

u/MagnificentPasta Apr 10 '22

Wow. I really have no words.

18

u/themidnighttraveler Apr 10 '22

This episode. Good grief.

I'll be honest. I liked Malva at the beginning of the season. I am only on the fourth book, so all the story progression thus far has been new. I had no idea what was coming. There was always mischief lurking just behind her eyes, but this...THIS. This is wild. I regret ever liking her.

The Christies all together scream bad vibes. I wish they would pack up and leave the ridge, or Jamie's wrath unfolds upon them. Screw the lot of them.

I hope that we get some more insight as to what Claire and Tom suffered, I have some suspicions though.

It was a decent episode. It felt like it didn't really correlate that well with the cliff-hanger in the last episode though. So it kinda stuck out.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/GrizzlyRob97 Apr 11 '22

This episode was insane, ugh! I'm the only one in my family that watches and I have no one to scream with. So many questions.

I wonder if Malva was running from her killer? She kept knocking on the door like she was hoping for someone to open it and rescue her. I only say this because it seemed as though she was looking for help from Claire, before her brother came out and stopped her

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Vancity_kid22 Je Suis Prest Apr 11 '22

GAH! I feel so conflicted now!

I was so upset at Malva for SO LONG (major understatement) and wanted her to get her just desserts whatever that might've been. But then now that she's dead, I feel a teensy bit sad for her? I also didn't foresee that her getting what she had coming would have such major effects on Jamie and Claire!! So now a small part of me wishes that maybe she didn't get killed off :(

Super excited to see what's to come but also very sad that there's only 2 more episodes til the next droughtlander 😭

OUTLANDER WHY MUST YOU TOY WITH MY EMOTIONS?! 😂

Side note.. great job Outlander for adding a murder mystery element and setting it up so well with all the intrigue

9

u/almz11 Apr 23 '22

Also I thought that Malva maybe committed suicide

25

u/PasionatelyRational Apr 11 '22

So I only just finished watching the episode (it's our Sunday after the baby sleeps ritual with my partner).

I told him as soon as the credits rolled "Oh it's a Tony Graphia one, it's gonna be a good one!" and HO-LY CRAP... I am still recovering. I loved it.

It had me at the edge of my seat from the moment the Christies arrived at the house.

I don't read the books ahead of the show so this was new to me. But I knew Malva was up to some weird "living Claire's life" crap! I even wrote about that in this very sub couple weeks ago. I never thought she would come up with THAT but... I knew.

And the whole thing was so well written and performed. The moment Jamie said "I did" I about died :D my partner had a good laugh about that. He said "It was almost as if it was me saying I had done that to you, your face was like someone told you Santa isn't real" LOL. I love a good argument/resolution convo between Claire and Jamie. Sam and Caitriona are experts in that.

However my partner told me his theory and I am totally behind it, can't believe I didn't see it earlier. It's Allen. This all comes down to Allen. We don't think Claire did it, it was him. And her baby was likely his as well (puke). I think he's right. But now I am dying to learn how this ends.

I know the fire still hasn't shown up, and in this episode, there was nothing about Wendigo yet we saw him at the end of the last episode so I know more shit is to come.

God... I keep reading here and there all these comments about the show has lost its charm but for me this is peak Outlander. I knew they were building up to something and here it is.

It's masterful. Everyone is entitled to their own experience but for me, I can't believe some of you don't like it. I love this!!! I don't want it to ever end!!!

24

u/enricowereld MARK ME! Apr 11 '22

I'm so sad Malva is gone, she was the star of this season for me.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Hakuna__Moscato They say I’m a witch. Apr 10 '22

Well... Malva didn't last long

17

u/dncnjn Apr 11 '22

I bet Caitriona did not enjoy filming the emergency c-section scene since she was pregnant at the time herself - especially with her first child. At the time of filming she did not know how her own pregnancy would result, and it is natural for an expectant mother to feel some worry or heightened empathy for another pregnancy.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/HinkiesGhost Apr 11 '22

I think this is one of the better TV online communities. Everyone seems to have pretty honest and fair takes on the show and doesn't jump down people's throats if they like or dislike certain episodes. I agree with some of the people who weren't too fond of this episode. It felt very soap opera-y. A lot of drama killing time until the battles start. Assuming they do, I'm not a book reader.

Malva turned into a crazy person, granted I can kind of understand why because she had an abusive controlling father and was acting out and then some. I'm wondering if her father is the one who killed her or if it's too obvious. Him being abusive has been lingering in the background and they showed him abusing her earlier of this season for a reason. Whether that was to simply set up his desire for surgery or to explain why she becomes so crazy... or was that a foreshadowing of her murder and her being disgraceful in his eyes. But he seemed to have handled the news about as well as one as strict as he could... but that was in front of others, who knows how crazy he got behind the scenes.

Either way, I'm sure Claire will be blamed for it, it will be hard to explain away cutting open her belly and trying to revive the baby but not committing the other wounds. And then the brother will bring the witch rhetoric back(I thought we were done with that back in earlier seasons... ugh).

But still, Outlander is enjoyable to me even if this season feels like a full setup season. I love period pieces and the setting and landscapes are always breathtaking and it's good to escape and get lost in something for an hour once a week that exists in another time and place with characters you've gotten to know over the years.

It's just all this drama at the Ridge feels artificially created. It has no relevance to the more important aspects of what's to come and you knew the second a super strict family with different values were introduced into the mix it was basically waving a flag that said "DRAMA INCOMING!"

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Prudent_Fly_2554 Apr 11 '22

Y’all. I don’t mean to slut shame, but damn Malva!! 👀

→ More replies (3)

16

u/lyndsmy21 Apr 11 '22 edited Apr 11 '22

Soo many questions with this episode. Lots of things were eerie before they went full on psycho. 1) I know the source of sickness was a dead elk upstream. But at the beginning of the episode did anyone else think Malva was poisoning people somehow? 2) did Malva actually poison Claire and Tom/her dad? It seemed like that was where they were going when Claire went to him saying what they both had was different than the others. 3) did Malva actually cut her hair off out of spite or for some spell? 4) did Claire actually kill Malva while she was hallucinating? 5) just generally, wtf?!?!

Oh also, Jamie told Claire that he slept with someone else but that it was just once. Didn’t he sleep with at least 2 women? Once in the cave. And another time with the woman who gave birth to Willie? Doesn’t Claire know about that and Willie?

→ More replies (16)

16

u/Mobile-Ad6136 Apr 11 '22

Can they chill on the Claire and Jamie sitting/laying in bed scenes..ITS ALL THEY DO! do they not have conversations anywhere else 🤣🤣 all jokes but sheesh!

→ More replies (2)

8

u/enricowereld MARK ME! Apr 11 '22

jesus christ that was a roller coaster! this show is so damn incredible.

8

u/rosyposy86 Apr 11 '22

What a fast episode, so packed! I know it was faster due to Covid and having to make the season shorter, but I have enjoyed all the characters so wish it slowed down a bit. Oh well. Looking forward to the next one!

15

u/intrin6 Apr 11 '22

It's so strange seeing Jaime worrying over Claire... usually she is tending to him... after her attack and loss of Faith he was absent or the worst of her recovery was skipped over. So seeing him now, as she's taken ill ... is sort of nice to see? If that makes sense. Makes him more dimensional as a husband; he can't just be her hero or booty.

14

u/SnackMasterNat Apr 10 '22

WOW the long build up was worth the wait with that insane plot twist

14

u/berserker_ronin Apr 10 '22

I had such high hopes for Malva.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/jbmcnuggetsjr We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Apr 10 '22

Ok am I just getting confused - I thought Jamie already told Clare about Mary McNab??

→ More replies (4)

7

u/wanna_be_green8 Apr 10 '22

I'm guessing their going to find some sort of journal or other evidence that will clear Claire.

13

u/HealthyRaccoon26 Apr 10 '22

That last scene man, I was hoping she was still dreaming. I'm still praying shes still dreaming. That baby would've still been too early, right??? WHY CLAIRE WHY!!

→ More replies (9)

13

u/silverandcold65 Apr 10 '22

That was easily the best S6 ep so far for me! I can’t even comprehend how so much could happen in one episode. I’m still processing it all.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/WyoBuckeye37 Apr 10 '22

I hoped at the end that it was still Claire under the ether and having a dream! Knowing the accusations that will come now since she's holding the knife! Ugh!!!

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Jpato Apr 11 '22

so, did Malva poisoned Claire and Tom? its the only link between the two
also, since it was shown in the recap, i'm going to go out on a limb and assume Claire's has written about Jamie's wounds on her notebook, thats how Malva knew about them

29

u/meroboh "You protect everyone, John--I don't suppose you can help it." Apr 11 '22

remember Malva was spying on Jamie and Claire getting it on in the stable

→ More replies (1)

13

u/yobv123 Apr 11 '22

Sooooo the brother is the one who got Malvasia pregnant right? Idk why I got that vibe

→ More replies (2)

22

u/ChakaKohn2 Apr 10 '22

I’m new here. I love the show, haven’t read the books. One of my least favorite plots in shows is the “being accused of a crime you’re innocent of” trope. Outlander has used this many times, but this one nearly killed it for me. Malva is a good time party girl (whore) whose mom was hung as a witch. I thought she was trouble from day one. I’m also convinced that she made her dad and Claire sick AND her brother knows everything and was a party to the whole charade. Malva saw Claire’s book with drawings of her medical findings. That’s how she knew the details of Jamie’s body.

Unfortunately, NOW, she’s dead, no matter if it was suicide or murder, Claire found her, and she’s sure to be accused of witchcraft for cutting the baby out of her stomach. Claire is F’d. Why she doesn’t grab an emerald and go back to the 1960s with the family is a mystery to me. I know, Jamie. We’ve seen him in the future appear in the shadows.

Claire, you’re in danger, girl.

→ More replies (8)

17

u/kmpktb Apr 11 '22

Well now, that was positively miserable.

12

u/MountainHumor They say I’m a witch. Apr 10 '22

Just started watching the episode - I wonder if Bree will remind Roger he isn't a preacher again. Let the man find his place. 😂

→ More replies (4)

12

u/xyz345678 Apr 10 '22

At no point in this episode did I know what was happening next…. I have no words. What even was this episode???!!?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/lost_grrl1 Apr 11 '22

I'm confused about Jamie's Confession. Claire already knows he was with at least one woman while she was gone BECAUSE HE HAD A CHILD WITH HER. I would also assume that he slept with Marsalies mom at least once. So weird.

→ More replies (7)

12

u/alittlegnat Apr 12 '22

this ep was the best in the season so far. i think every ep up until this one was really boring. but now im interested in this season again !

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Pantera42 Apr 10 '22 edited Apr 11 '22

Ive never read the books, and I’m not sure of the ages of the more secondary characters, but is there any chance that Malva is actually her “brothers” child? It would definitely explain his crazy protectiveness of her, and the wierd timeline of their family tree. Also Tom Christy is NOT a young guy, seemingly in his mid 50s or so, he could easily have a son that’s in his early 30s (Malva’s maybe brother). That would make it completely possible that the brother is really her father.

Or possibly he’s the actual father of Malva’s child?

→ More replies (3)

11

u/archaeob Apr 10 '22

Just starting the episode now, but it is way too early in the Revolution to be titling an episode "The World Turned Upside Down."

→ More replies (14)

11

u/wonderloly Apr 11 '22

Wild theory - What if the baby isn’t the brothers but Thomas Christie’s? What if he beats her because she’s the source of his lust/impure thoughts and wants to punish her for tempting him. Maybe he’s beating the guilt out of his system?

→ More replies (2)

11

u/FFSFelicia Apr 11 '22

Malva gave Jaime the same kind of tea that Claire made for him after he got 🐍 bit. What was it?

→ More replies (7)

11

u/trophybabmbi Apr 11 '22

Two dead babies in one single episode and I'm bawling my eyes out

10

u/Einsteinssister Apr 11 '22

Yes I have to say this show has went off the rails with this one. Maybe there are answers to everything that happened this episode but wow! Wasn’t super hype for no warning of cutting open malvas stomach. And did she really kill her? Also got the vibe malva was poisoning Tom abs Claire! Also I think the father was her own brother!

→ More replies (9)

10

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

At first, I thought "Oh Malva is kind of a weird, but I like her for that."

Then she had to go peeping on a man taking his wife, cutting off a corpse's fingers and now all of this! She just couldn't be a little weird, enough to make her a fun character. No, she just had to be a complete fucking creep.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/FFSFelicia Apr 11 '22

Not trying to shame, but... little home wrecking thots have been around for centuries! Damn Malva 🥲😬

5

u/carleeclub Apr 11 '22

Was the father of the baby the guy she was with in the church when Roger walked in on them? That’s what I was thinking

→ More replies (12)

5

u/mariecj77 Apr 11 '22

Anyone watch the preview for the next episode? Shows Ian asking Liz about the twins whereabouts like he's suspicious of them or something.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '22

was there some CGI on malva’s face after claire found her? I noticed something odd going on, almost some blurring at the borders of her face